5 ms·
A ticking time bomb: healthcare under threat across western Europe
- nathias 4y agoIt is slowly decaying here, in a central european country with socialized healthcare. It isn't because of COVID or aging or anything like that, but rather because of a systemic 'privatization' where taxes collected via mandatory private insurance companies are used to fund an alternative privatized healthcare system that then offers higher pay to healthcare workers.
- vjulian 4y agoDoes it boil down to physicians and other care staff not being paid enough?
- nathias 4y agoit boils down on the competition always being able to pay more because of how it is financed (for the state its an expense, for private health its an investment)
- VWWHFSfQ 4y agoI think it's similar, but obviously not nearly as extreme, as doctors in Cuba being paid nothing and constantly trying to flee to the USA while there is a perception that Cuba has a good healthcare system. The practice and care itself may be good but if you can't take care of the workers then it will still fall apart. Cuban doctors are actually slaves though. European doctors just leave the public services.
- ghostDancer 4y agoIt's an organized dismantle coming from the right wing parties, they cut resources and spending creating waiting lists and the deviate people to private services. The promotion of private healthcare it's all over, super cheap prices for now, till the destroy the system and then I guess we will get a super expensive scamming healthcare like in the USA. In Spain several hospitals that turned private were returning to being public because the super efficient capitalist owners could not make it work.
- eitau_1 4y agoIn Poland we have waiting list for more than a decade and recently private sector pricing accelerated wildly while any complications are being sent back to public healthcare.
- wolongong942 4y agoRight wing parties haven't had much say in western Europe as of recent, unless you've re-defined right wing. We're having the same issues here in NZ and it accelerated with a left wing govt.
- timbit42 4y agoIt's not a matter of left-wing or right-wing. It's a matter of whether the ruling party is neo-liberal. In the US, both parties are neo-liberal. In Canada, both parties are neo-liberal. There is only a small difference in how neo-liberal these parties are. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neoliberalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neoliberalism
- nopenopenopeno 4y agoNZ has never had a left wing government. NZ's government is neoliberal, which is not left wing in any way. Neoliberalism is in all actuality right wing.
- ProjectArcturis 4y agoIf you're calling Jacinda Ahern a right-winger, the term has lost all meaning. Do you need the state to seize the means of production in order to call a government left-wing?
- nopenopenopeno 4y agoAt least a few explicit examples would be a good place to start. I look forward to it.
- 4y ago
- jleyank 4y agoIf governments can’t afford health care, how can individuals? Will medical care be limited to the wealthy? Or, as others here say, is it just a not terribly transparent effort to privatize and thus profit from the the problems of others?
- wolongong942 4y agoThe same thing is happening to NZ healthcare, i personally welcome means testing for elective surgeries. A lot of boomers needing healthcare here are sitting on significant gains from holding property, a boomer was recently complaining to me about his hip op being delayed twice through public, he owns a big $1m house, $2m in rentals and has $500k in a savings account, he could easily get it done this week with his own money.
- VWWHFSfQ 4y agoYou're saying that if you're in a high enough tax bracket then you should pay the most to support everyone else's healthcare but have no right to access it yourself.
- wolongong942 4y agoProperty has been a tax loophole in NZ for decades, so they haven't necessarily ever been in a high tax bracket.
- tuatoru 4y agoNo, gp is saying that if you have choices, you should be deprioritised in the queue for limited public resources. Edit: I took out a loan to have cataract surgery. I don't understand why someone would sit idle and crippled if they have the means to do something about it. You don't win by dying with all the money.
- virtual_void 4y agoHe’s clearly not saying that though. The statement was that a wealthy person was complaining about having to wait. Everyone else is also having to wait. They could speed things up by paying privately if they so wish. Also the wealthy should have a larger tax burden in absolute terms compared to the less well off. I say this as someone how is very fortunate - I don’t think we are taxed enough to make things sane and fair.
- dekken_ 4y agoFor profit health insurance is IMO not pro social.
- mathverse 4y agoAnd this is with then sucking eastern europe dry off almost all capable medical personnel. Lets face it Western European healthcare is a scam. They are barely existing with millions of qualified people from CEE and now they are eyeing countries like Philippines, Indonesia and such. It is all a ponzi
- albertopv 4y agoIt's not a Ponzi, reality is western europe is not really rich, not as much as it seems. Debt is over the roof, demography is a disaster, politicians worse and worse every year passing, corruption even inside EU parliament. China is now much richer as a whole.
- theCrowing 4y agoYou are projecting the views of riches in China on the very few factors you are allowed to see go further than 100 miles from a big city and you are basically in the 1900s.
- albertopv 4y agoCome to Italy, there's people from the hills sellings eggs from their cars. Btw, China has a space station all alone, only country in the world. How so?
- theCrowing 4y agoSee they have cars... everyone else knows that it's not a good investment?
- albertopv 4y agoI have a 16yo car and I'm a sw engineer with a decent salary, italian avg is 12yo, which is a lot. And I live in a comparatively rich northern region, southern Italy is much, much poorer. Less and less people can afford to buy a new car, let alone a BEV. We are back to 1970s cars selling numbers.
- karencarits 4y agoBefore, being a doctor or a nurse was probably more of a vocation or calling. As that attitude had been destroyed, healthcare professionals expect proper/normal work times and conditions, which is extremely costly. I think secularism plays a part in this, and Christian organizations still provide a lot of care which the government is not capable of giving
- nopenopenopeno 4y agoUtter nonsense. If nurses didn't previously expect decent work conditions, what on Earth motivated them to unionize? Your comment is just total garbage all the way through.
- fithisux 4y agoMalice aforethought
- virtual_void 4y agoServices, such as healthcare, public infrastructure, public transport, energy etc should be run by the state. There is always a conflict of interest when companies run these things because they care about profit / shareholder return more than they care about the people. Now, the fact that the state is often corrupt is another problem that should also be fixed but i just don’t buy the argument that companies should run public services because they’re more efficient. The UK is suffering badly with this. I’m old enough to remember how badly some state run things were but i still believe that it was then due to underinvestment as it is with healthcare now.
- nopenopenopeno 4y agoFalse binary. Under capitalism, the state is always beholden to the interests of capital, i.e. "private" capital.
- throw6383878 4y agoState has conflict of interest as well. It is entity that is trying to save and extract money, just like big corporation. Lets not pretend it is somehow more moral!
- ethanbond 4y agoBut in democratic states the people also hold the reins on the other end via elections. You don’t get to vote for CEOs or their boards or their boards largest shareholders for $0. So yeah they’re characteristically different.
- chongli 4y agoThe problem with state-run healthcare (as well as education) is that costs (especially salaries) can become a political issue. In parts of Canada we’re experiencing severe shortages of healthcare workers (such as nurses) because governments have frozen their pay for political reasons.
- 4y ago
- PaulKeeble 4y agoCovid isn't helping. There is a constant stream of infected patients in A&E and intensive care, vast growing numbers of disabled Long Covid patients and a lot of healthcare staff have been impacted. Its a big increase in the needs for healthcare and will be for the foreseeable future. Healthcare staff have been heavily impacted by Long Covid and since there is no treatment let alone cure they are being lost at a faster rate than in most other industries.
- brainchild-adam 4y agoI, for the life of me, cannot understand how something as essential as healthcare does not take priority over comparatively less essential things. It must be an unintended result of our complex societal setup with each stakeholder pursuing their own limited gain with no regard for the bigger picture, because it just makes no sense. Same is true for other essentials such as firefighting, basic infrastructure, etc. Why would I rather have 5G/Fibre/stadiums/TV shows/[any other less essential contrasting example] than proper healthcare? If I cannot pay for both, let's have the more important one. I know I'm oversimplifying. I believe my core point still stands.
- negamax 4y agoHealthcare is expensive and have massive fines built in for good reasons. Government jobs are for life with little to no repercussions. Also they might not align people correctly with incentives. We need government run programs with private sector like efficiency.
- naasking 4y ago> Government jobs are for life with little to no repercussions. This is one of the main problems: without some kind of feedback mechanism, this means bureaucracy can only monotonically grow which means inefficiency can only increase. At some point that inefficiency starts making private healthcare look competitive.
- negamax 4y agoThat's pretty much it. Government jobs are lower paid because money comes from taxing private sector. Career growth there is all about how big of a team in numbers someone has reporting to them.
- wilde 4y agoWe’re paying a ton of money in America and have worse results.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- boxed 4y ago> In Germany, which spends more on healthcare than almost any other country in the world Really? This graph: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_health_expenditure_per_capita#/media/File:Health_care_cost_rise.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_hea... ...seems to say what you expect: there is only one outlier and it's the US. This graph: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_health_expenditure_per_capita#/media/File:Life_expectancy_vs_healthcare_spending.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_hea... ...is even more damning. Maybe it's just the US who has a problem?