9 ms·
Congress passes legislation to end US participation in global shark fin trade
- version_five 4y agoMy first though was "good", but then I started to wonder why it wasn't illegal and if there's some downside we don't see. For example if it's like foie gras that people don't like because they think it's cruel but has important culinary value, and isn't driving species extinction or anything. Seal fur is another example that comes to mind, opposition is based more on how cute the animal is than any actual environmental concerns. Eleven people voted against the bill, I wonder what their motivation was. Personally I have no idea, if this is the equivalent of an ivory ban, makes complete sense, if it's foie gras, not so much.
- helen___keller 4y agoMy understanding is that the shark fin trade is threatening extinction but I could be wrong
- waffleiron 4y agoI was actually thinking the opposite, which also might be wrong, that most sharks are dying because of overfishing in general and climate change. edit: not to say that this isn’t a good thing, we just need a lot more if we want to save the sharks
- kajecounterhack 4y agoIt's hard to specifically attribute why any fish population is decreasing, but it's not at all a stretch to say demand for shark fins contributes to overfishing of sharks. This isn't something anyone can quantify well because so much fishing is done illegally and shark finning especially being controversial isn't something folks advertise themselves as doing, but it seems very safe to assume there is an impact here caused by the trade. We also know that sharks take a long time to grow and as important apex predators, their declining numbers have bad knock-on effects for other species (threatening extinction may apply to not only the sharks themselves but the ecosystems they are part of). So banning finning feels unambiguously good?
- waffleiron 4y agoBanning finning is unambiguously good, and sharks are indeed and important keystone species. However if the majority of shark deaths occur as by-catch or due to global warming there isn’t a lot of change in outcome. This is like the whaling on Greenland, cruel and highly visible but also doesn’t impact you or me in any way. It’s easy to push these types of bans through, but it can also be a distraction of the actual harms that we are perpetuating.
- kajecounterhack 4y agoThe health of fisheries is often death by inaction because every special interest group blames each other -- recreational anglers blame commercial anglers blame climate change and nobody can point the finger hard enough to get anything done, exactly by way of arguing "this is just a distraction from the actual harm" We just can't know whether any action will move the needle, not for sure, unless we go do it.
- arcticbull 4y ago> they think it's cruel but has important culinary value You mean it's cruel but it tastes good, so shrug? I mean that's certainly a position to take. I'm pretty neutral on it but mostly because it is possible to get cruelty-free foie. [1] [1] https://nuvomagazine.com/daily-edit/guilt-free-foie-gras https://nuvomagazine.com/daily-edit/guilt-free-foie-gras
- waffleiron 4y agoAnd here I was thinking you linked to a vegan alternative. While less cruel, I wouldn’t call murdering an animal to satisfy your tastebuds cruelty-free.
- arcticbull 4y agoFair enough, I was alluding to the fact there's 100% less feeding funnel shoved down their throats daily. Here's a photograph of the production process from Wikipedia, but I'd probably avoid it if you're feeling hungry. [1] Personally I don't mind killing animals for food, I'd just prefer to avoid torturing them first. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foie_gras#/media/File:Mulard_duck_being_force_fed_corn_in_order_to_fatten_its_liver_for_foie_gras_production.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foie_gras#/media/File:Mulard_d...
- waffleiron 4y agoI agree with your point, these geese live way better lives than their force fed brethren. I just couldn’t agree with the cruelty-“free” part.
- defrost 4y agoIf we're playing ethics, how do you feel about murdering introduced animals to lessen their devestating impacting om pre existing ecologies? eg: Clean skin bull roundups in the Northern Territory and camel roundups in Central Australia? These are large coordinated musters to funnel feral animals into yards, to tracks, and to slaughter. There's a profit, sure, but the incentive for many is to stop them tearing up and destroying the land.
- shagymoe 4y ago>Eleven people voted against the bill, I wonder what their motivation was. The bill seems to be mostly about military funding: https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/house-bill/7776/text https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/house-bill/7776... The bit about shark fins is somewhere around page 4 thousand.
- jimmygrapes 4y agoProps for looking beyond the headline. I am only about 1/5 through and have 4 pages of notes so far (many of which are "things to expect context-free outrage bait headline/talkshow topics to focus on". We'll see how it goes.
- Merciernmon 4y agoYes, it's the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) passed once per year to fund the U.S. military. Because the NDAA is considered a "must pass" bill, it's used as a vehicle to pass a bunch of other legislation (all bundled into the same bill). There's only limited opportunity to debate or offer amendments. The NAY votes likely had nothing to do with the shark fins.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoA bloated and excessive NDAA gets bloated further still. And Congress wonders why so many have so little faith in Uncle Sam. But hey. The sharks are safe.
- paxys 4y agoMembers of both chambers of Congress have a near 100% reelection rate. The only time a politician is replaced is if they decide to retire or their own party doesn't support them in the primaries. Even if Americans really have "so little faith in Uncle Sam" they definitely don't show it in the voting booth.
- pessimizer 4y ago
- hanniabu 4y ago> but has important culinary value Let's devastate the earth for our taste buds
- numpad0 4y agoI’m not sure foie gras have sustainability implications, it scales up and down well. Basically the only principle involved is to insert a pipe into a bird’s throat, and force feed it to the point vision will be lost from complications. The bird is then slaughtered and liver harvested. Resultant specimen is butter-like but rich in flavor and pleasantly elastic. Gods forbid foie gras enjoyer entering heavens, but the sin of it isn’t in environmental division.
- sheusndudn 4y ago
- MisterTea 4y ago> For example if it's like foie gras Its not. Imagine that an unknown being hauls you out of your environment, chops your legs off with no anesthetic, then casts you back into the world crippled and bleeding. That's what shark fin hunting is like. They don.t kill the animal. They mutilate it and let it die a slow death.
- kashunstva 4y ago> Its not. But only because we have differing set-points for defining animal cruelty. Force-feeding an animal so vigorously that it develops hepatic steatosis, only to kill it and consume its liver sounds equally cruel to me. Don’t get me wrong; I’m delighted the U.S. Congress saw fit to ban this practice. Now go ban the thousand other forms of cruelty visited on non-human animal species.
- MisterTea 4y agoI get your point. But does hepatic steatosis cause the animal to suffer? The end result for the animals in both cases is death. How quick you make that death is is the difference between humane and inhumane.
- gigatexal 4y agoWe as a people shouldn’t be killing sharks for their fins just as we shouldn’t be killing Elephant’s for their tusks or rhinos for their horns. It’s pointless and just because there’s a market for something … damnit makes me so mad
- waffleiron 4y agoIt’s pointless like a lot of other animals we eat, they don’t have to die but we only kill them for our pleasure. Picking elephants removes the fact that finning is done for culinary reasons. Sure it’s a delicacy but so are many other animals that are being eaten.
- numpad0 4y ago> they don’t have to die but we only kill them for our pleasure. Debatable, cheap foods seem to straight up allow me lesser cognitive abilities than “better” ones. Personally I think we should seek to maximize positive effect of life including those of animals eaten, rather than chasing calories and counting skulls.
- yesbut 4y agoTook long enough.
- ancapsfascists 4y agoI do not understand how a human can participate in finning. Amputation of the fins from a living, awake animal then tossing it into ocean while it thrashes around in pain. There's no excuse for that level of inhumanity.
- xyzelement 4y agoDon't be sharks do that to people (replace fins with arms/legs) all the time? edit: I was kidding. Sorry shark lovers who took it seriously, I get it...
- joshmarinacci 4y agoNo. Shark attacks are incredibly rare. You’re more likely to be hit by lightning.
- thaumasiotes 4y agoSure, but lightning frequently strikes on land, whereas no shark attack has ever taken place on land.
- lostlogin 4y agoShark attacks do occur on land. Sharks snap when out the water, so they’ll bite someone for sure. I did a brief Google and found this account. 2015/01/27, 3:30 am Maui, Pali scenic lookout Fishing Water Depth: onshore Victim: M. Pollard Description: Lacerations to left calf. Considered a provoked incident due to activity. Shark: Requiem shark, length 4 feet. https://dlnr.hawaii.gov/sharks/shark-incidents/incidents-list/ https://dlnr.hawaii.gov/sharks/shark-incidents/incidents-lis...
- KMag 4y agoThat reminds me of a time I went camping on a beach with a group of about 6 people. We found out one of the guys was afraid of sharks. We were walking after dark, about 20 meters from the water and a friend of a friend make a joke about "land shark", and the galeophobe jumped, turned, and asked "where?"
- MBCook 4y agoHonestly I’m surprised to learn it wasn’t already.
- kornhole 4y agoSharks kill about 5-10 humans per year while humans kill about 100 million sharks every year.
- LAC-Tech 4y agoI was invited to a wedding in Taiwan once and kind of felt like a dick for not eating the shark fin, because the poor server was confused and didn't know what to do. I guess I didn't accomplish much...
- yieldcrv 4y agoDid any Senator know they were banning this? What else is in this years NDAA? The 83-11 vote suggests nobody really knows, since anything's that's not related to keeping the government open and financing the military gets a 51-49 vote along party lines, which is not enough to pass in the Senate as you need 60 votes.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoIt would have been 83-12 but Rand was running late that morning.
- from 4y agoThey tried to force the ENABLERS Act in which would basically turn lawyers into informants but fortunately that was shut down. They'll have this debate every year until someone eventually sneaks it in.
- LinkLink 4y agoThere really does need to be a limit on bill length https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/house-bill/7776/text https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/house-bill/7776... For anyone who was riding their high horse on this, the bill is a majority a defense spending bill which includes appropriations of sea territory and military operations. About 3000 pages of spending, and oh but dont kill sharks.
- feet 4y agoIt would be cool if there were other ways to actually get things passed
- KMag 4y agoTo expand a bit more on this, one consequence of increased transparency is fewer back-room deals. This means that instead of one backroom deal getting support for bill A in exchange for support for bill B, and another backroom deal getting support for bill A in exchange for bill C, they now need to comingle bills A, B, and C in order to get them passed in a single transaction. The short attention span of the electorate and the sound-byte focus of most media means that politicians have a very tough time explaining that they only supported bills B and C because it was a necessary compromise to get A passed. Transparency is a net positive, but it seems spaghettification of bills in an unforeseen consequence.
- cormacrelf 4y agoThis happens to some extent everywhere there is actual democracy going on. Different people care about different stuff, and sometimes they don’t trust each other to hold up each side of the bargain if there’s no legal process binding the deal together. Private people have contracts. Politicians had a need for a similar formal arrangement to make sure the legislation they’re offering isn’t passed without what they’re seeking. They came up with one. Americans love their omnibus bills but everyone else just passes them all on the last day of the session. Or has the two bills sitting hostage, one in each chamber (when the chambers aren’t controlled by the same party) while a compromise is formed. Etc. No real difference in transparency or outcome or anything else. Just that in the US there are really quite a lot of people involved and a lot of interest groups in what amounts to a very large democracy. It is always clunky to have that many people represented. You can still give a name to a sub-bill and talk about it individually. I don’t really see a problem with it except for the offices that have to deal with it. Also, seeing as you cannot stop them from agreeing to vote a certain way in private, the omnibus bill is something of a transparency measure itself, in that at least we know in an omnibus bill which things were on the trading table and agreed upon at the same time. When there isn’t one, all you can lob is kinda evidence-scarce accusations that your party gave up something you care about and they have some plausible deniability.
- pabs3 4y ago> as part of the National Defense Authorization Act What do shark fins have to do with the military?
- Moto7451 4y agoThat’s how Congress works. Omnibus bills get additions for special interest (like shark fin law). Which Congress person has enough money from Big Shark Fin to derail the military budget? None of them! This is an easy win for the proponents of the legislation. I’m not claiming this is a good system, it’s just how this happens sometimes.
- totalhack 4y agoBout time. This stuff, and the demonization of sharks in general, is super sad. I've been fortunate enough to go diving and see sharks and can only imagine how different things looked 50+ years ago before major population declines started.
- wilg 4y agoShoot, this is terrible news for my FinTech startup.
- todd8 4y agoWhat the heck! We were participating in it before? I had heard of the terrible practice and had no idea that the US was doing it too.