12 ms·
SEC set to propose rules that would squeeze stock-market middlemen
- neonate 4y agohttps://archive.ph/sTbZ0 https://archive.ph/sTbZ0
- SamReidHughes 4y agoIf you look at Robinhood's 10-Q: https://d18rn0p25nwr6d.cloudfront.net/CIK-0001783879/afc62224-c731-412d-b698-ec897defa531.pdf https://d18rn0p25nwr6d.cloudfront.net/CIK-0001783879/afc6222... It has a revenue disaggregation on page 17. Just 15% of its transactional revenue last quarter comes from stock.
- largepeepee 4y agoHow about get rid of obfuscated monetary bullshit like darkpools first
- dahdum 4y agoDoesn’t that just increase volatility and hand profits to high frequency / predatory traders? How does it help retail or index investors?
- koolba 4y agoWhat’s wrong with dark pools? The name is meant to conjure up some evil mental image, but it’s just two or more parties that want to offload / onload some stock without impacting the market. It’s no different than telling your neighbor you’re willing to sell your house for $X without publicly listing it.
- tptacek 4y agoAlso: what's "monetary" about them?
- koolba 4y agoI have no idea what that’s supposed to mean as “monetary” would include everything from lunch money to interest rates.
- maxbond 4y agoSeems pretty clear from context they meant "financial" or perhaps "related to money", I don't think we have to put them on the spot for it. I imagine this is part of the meta-point you're making across the thread that people on HN talk out of their hat about finance (I plead guilty) but I feel like your comment about Money Stuff/"truth searching" was enough, and that asking people to defend their misuse of terminology is punching down.
- arc-in-space 4y agoI agree, but also, maybe some amount of punching down is deserved - there really does tend to be a lot of people speaking in an authoritative tone while being completely wrong in the finance-related hn threads EDIT: I suppose we can scratch the "finance-related" bit
- maxbond 4y agoI'm not saying that people shouldn't be challenged, but that you can do that without punching down. Indeed, without punching.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rocqua 4y agoDark pools mean that public market prices aren't as accurate. The story of financial markets being valuable to wider society is, among other things, price discovery. Dark pools don't serve that purpose. Moreover, the PFOF story depends on 'price improvement'. If public stock markets aren't accurate, then 'price improvement' is a meaningless concept, because it compares the price to the public stock market price. > It’s no different than telling your neighbor you’re willing to sell your house for $X without publicly listing it. The difference is that the most accurate price for 'my house' is not of significant public value. Whilst the most accurate price for stocks is quite valuable to the wider world.
- anonymoushn 4y ago'price improvement' compared to lit venues with no retail flow is already a meaningless concept.
- _5uxp 4y agoAll details and Fin. Engineering are just a more sophisticated scam to dump on public investors. There I said it. Sure someone can explain why not that in a long text but IMO that is not the truth.
- snowwrestler 4y agoIt’s worth pointing out that, in most U.S. localities at least, real estate transactions become public knowledge once they close. You can go look up, on a government website, how much a property sold for even if the transaction was conducted privately. So price discovery is still possible. I don’t think there is an equivalent public reporting mechanism for private “dark pool” transactions of financial instruments. Another way to say “without impacting the market” is “denying the market information it needs to set prices accurately.”
- cuteboy19 4y agoAssuming that you are interested in crypto, did you know that the vast majority of crypto trades happen in dark pools?
- vgatherps 4y agoAssuming you mean OTC desks, because there isn't much proper dark pool presence in crypto. OTC desks aren’t where majority of spot and delta one products trade although some of their advertising might have you think otherwise.
- cuteboy19 4y agoA dark pool is just a private transaction between two people. So every crypto txn not on an exchange is a dark pool onto itself
- manual89 4y agoWonder how Robinhood is going to survive a potential dilution of payments for orderflow if these proposals become reality.
- sircastor 4y agoI thought the real value of Robinhood was that it was a substantial source of information about retail traders for its parent company.
- tptacek 4y agoRobinhood doesn't have a parent company?
- bmer 4y agoI think what was meant is "Robinhood the app's parent company, also named Robinhood"?
- dchftcs 4y agoGiven the tone I suspect the person meant "Citadel". Which is a view I don't endorse, but see often.
- conorcleary 4y agoWell you better go read some contemporary history then, because Ken Griffin has some luggage with Robinhood's name on it.
- vgatherps 4y agoRetail orders are valuable precisely because they don't contain much information
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 4y ago
- tptacek 4y agoThis is covered in great detail in today's Money Stuff, and you can usually skip a great deal of HN, um, truth-searching just by reading Levine first. https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-12-15/the-sec-wants-more-stock-auctions https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-12-15/the-se...
- texasbigdata 4y agoWhat does truth searching mean, that’s an interesting term.
- vgatherps 4y agoHN comments (laypeople in general) tend to make very confident and very wrong comments on market structure
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> comments (laypeople in general) tend to make very confident and very wrong comments on market structure Former equity derivatives trader here. The Levine article linked to is one of the denser accessible discussions on the topic I’ve seen. Also, as a current English speaker, the “truth searching” the comment you’re responding to cites refers to the general process of learning, and nothing specific to market structure.
- vgatherps 4y ago> The Levine article linked to is one of the denser accessible discussions on the topic I’ve seen That's the point, just read the Levine article instead of going through half-correct HN comments. Also, I'm a native english speaker (and lived in 2.5 english speaking countries) and have never heard the phrase truth searching
- gilbetron 4y agoThe original poster was using "truth searching" euphemistically. In other words, it was a more polite way of saying that many, or even nearly all, comments on such matters on HN are misguided.
- dahdum 4y agoMatt Levine wrote in some detail about this today. https://archive.vn/TJogY https://archive.vn/TJogY
- runeks 4y ago> Requiring such auctions would be a big change. The SEC says brokers send more than 90% of marketable orders to wholesalers. Unlike exchanges, which display price quotes publicly and allow a variety of market players to attempt to fill orders, wholesalers trade directly against the incoming retail flow, an arrangement that effectively prevents other market players such as institutional investors from interacting with individual investors’ orders. Sounds like a sensible change to me.
- tptacek 4y agoLevine points out that it's not clear that the change --- brief order-by-order auctions to beat the wholesaler price (which is in turn at least as good as the public market) --- will actually improve outcomes for retail investors; there's a paper: https://deliverypdf.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=285088095002029126087067070073097091033020039072045089028085123023100117077117084075049063097015112023016027073100009088092120111059011078059087095095007123122025015024093047094070090005010021110109107023088015081068091086118112120123117105126019096106&EXT=pdf&INDEX=TRUE https://deliverypdf.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=285088095002029...
- pclmulqdq 4y agoIf we look at the actual price improvement that retail order flow gets, I think we can be pretty confident that Robinhood and IBKR Pro users, who have the least price improvement today (one group because of greedy brokers and the other because they are usually professionals doing their personal trading), will do better. Users of Schwab and TD Ameritrade, who get the best price improvement, will probably do worse. Whether the total amount of price improvement in the market increases still does seem to be up for debate - I personally doubt that it will be much better for average retail investors than the old system.
- vgatherps 4y agoIt really depends on whether non wholesale players step up and participate in these auctions. While Citadel and Virtu are very large market makers, there are other equally large firms that don't jump through all the hoops to participate in wholesale, but would probably do on-exchange auctions. The SEC also talks about non market makers using this for execution, but I don't think that's going to happen immediately...
- CSSer 4y agoThe first thing I did was open the article and search for PFOF (Payment for Order Flow). > This proposal would address a controversial practice called payment for order flow, in which some brokers collect rebates for sending customers’ orders to wholesalers. Mr. Gensler has called the practice a conflict of interest and, in past statements, left open the possibility of banning it. The SEC’s best-execution proposal doesn’t go that far. But it imposes additional obligations on brokers that engage in payment for order flow to help ensure that customers are getting a good deal. Shame. They’re skimming money straight off the top. Perhaps I should withhold judgment but I suspect they’re banking on the idea that Joe Schmoe, who downloaded an app to gamble with his future, isn’t going to seek out this financial disclosure data. I have a friend who can rattle off everything there is to know about option spreads and general technical analysis drivel. He initially didn’t believe me when I told him about PFOF.
- tptacek 4y agoWho's skimming off money where now?
- CSSer 4y agoInstitutional investors. I can’t explain it better than Matt Levine’s article. It’s well worth the read, and it links directly to the SEC proposal if you’d like to read deeper from there. After reading the article, my take is less harsh. It is really bizarre to me why instead of outright banning it, they just want to make it a really bad deal to do so. But if it works, great! We’ll see.
- tptacek 4y agoLevine doesn't believe PFOF involves people skimming money from retail investors, if that's what you're implying. Levine's story boils down to: retail order flow is cheaper to make markets for, wholesalers and brokers can split the savings three ways (between retail investors, the broker [via PFOF], and the wholesaler). That's not skimming; that's, like, the operating principle of Walmart.
- rjchint 4y agoThe proposal needs to go further and expand the scope of the rules to stock options as well, which is where most of citadels revenue comes from, being the contraparty to options trades of robinhood yolos. If someone can add that as a comment to the rules to the SEC that would be fantastic.
- vgatherps 4y agoOptions already have to go through an on exchange auction process
- ngoilapites 4y agoAll money has to go up in the great divide (a fancy term for today's growing inequality).
- TOR_USER_01 4y ago> Robinhood to pay $65 mln fine to settle SEC charges of misleading customers > The SEC charged the company with failing to inform customers about payments it received from trading firms to route customer orders through them, a move that resulted in customers paying higher prices to execute trades. > Robinhood customers' orders were executed at prices that were inferior to other brokers' prices," the SEC found. https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/robinhood-pay-65-mln-fine-settle-sec-charges-misleading-customers-2020-12-17/ https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/robinhood-pay-65-ml...
- svggrfgovgf 4y agoFrom Levine: "Payment for order flow sort of created the zero-commission retail-brokerage model, but it’s not really necessary anymore. You can run a profitable retail brokerage on net interest margin, without charging for trades at all." So what everyone should be complaining about is not PFOF, but "net interest margin". In other words everyone should be complaining about the brokers not paying enough interest on the cash balances in the brokerage accounts.
- LatteLazy 4y agoThis confused me at least: do people keep cash in their brokerage accounts? Is this an American thing (limey Brit here). I transfer cash in once I've decided to trade and the brokerage usually holds it for a max of a day or two until the trade actually executes (say I am buying an index fund where orders today are executed tomorrow). The only time there has been cash for longer than that was when I know I needed it (a week or two before buying my first place) so I didn't want to risk a stock market crash etc.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> do people keep cash in their brokerage accounts? Some people use a brokerage account as a checking account. Most don’t. Interest can also be earned on lent securities.
- tacostakohashi 4y agoIn the US, settlement is T+2, so if you are buying, the broker doesn't pay the cash/receive the shares until two days later, but they won't let you buy without cash in your account first, so cash for unsettled trades is a bunch of float.
- IMSAI8080 4y agoI am keeping some cash in my Vanguard account because it's offering a better interest rate than my cash ISA.
- mrep 4y agoSounds like you should use a better brokerage. Vanguard defaults to putting all my money in Vanguard Federal Money Market Fund (Settlement fund) with a current 7-day SEC yield of 3.8%. They do charge me a 0.11% fee though.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoWe already see a LOT of auctions running in the options markets, and trading these auctions it is one of the profit centers of market makers. It turns out that speed is still a factor in a stock market auction, and you can still have designated market makers that are guaranteed to get a cut of each auction. I'm not sold that this move will actually result in much better prices for customers on average, but it will certainly "spread the wealth around" by allowing all brokerages to take advantage of a uniform price-improvement structure rather than negotiating individually with Citadel/Virtu. I have been an IBKR customer for a while, and I'll be happy because I don't get a lot of price improvement under the current system. Schwab customers, who get a lot of price improvement, may be less happy. In options, there is the suspicion that the presence of a lot of auctions probably results in wider spreads, which we could see as auctions make it to the stock market, too. If all retail order flow goes into the market through special channels, the only trading remaining in the "normal" system will be from sophisticated traders, who you don't really want to trade against. Of course, the SEC may then say "the experiment was a great success, retail traders are getting HUGE price improvement," ignoring that retail traders may be getting worse prices than the old NBBO from the widening of the spread.
- vgatherps 4y ago> We already see a LOT of auctions running in the options markets, and trading these auctions it is one of the profit centers of market makers. It turns out that speed is still a factor in a stock market auction, and you can still have designated market makers that are guaranteed to get a cut of each auction. The complexity and fragmentation as well - you can preferentially do auctions at venues you have an advantage on, and bully the venues away from fixing whatever you exploit by threatening to take away flow. > In options, there is the suspicion that the presence of a lot of auctions probably results in wider spreads, which we could see as auctions make it to the stock market, too. If all retail order flow goes into the market through special channels, the only trading remaining in the "normal" system will be from sophisticated traders, who you don't really want to trade against. Effectively all retail flow already goes through even more cutoff special channels? But I agree with the point, this seems like adding a tremendously complex game instead of just shrinking tick sizes. At least in options, you tend to have much wider spreads. But the fact that plenty of stocks trade at min tick is a sign the spreads could naturally be tighter.
- seanhunter 4y agoAs someone who used to work in execution brokerage, this rule change seems on net to be good news for retail investors and bad only for folks like citadel and robinhood.[1] In the wake of flash crash there was a fair amount of research suggesting that rolling auctions (rather than continuous order matching) are net positive for almost everyone except HFTs who exploit market microstructure. In my view they should also get rid of reg NMS, which entrenches HfT arbs and gives a permanent advantage to people who pay to colocate at the exchanges. Europe has shown that reg NMS is not needed and doesn’t benefit investors. [1] noone should be crying for robinhood. Their entire business model is about disadvantaging small investors to benefit themselves and Ken Griffin.
- hitpointdrew 4y agoIMO the whole system needs to be overhauled. With today's tech there is no reason that trades can't be immediate, the fact that it takes 3 days to "settle" a trade is absolutely beyond ridiculous. That and let's also get rid of any special treatment for the investment industry that retail traders don't have (for example as a retail trader, I can trade in the pre or post market but if I do my trades aren't guaranteed to happen in any timely manner like they are during normal trading hours. This lets big investment firms, who can trade in real-time in pre and post market, do things like respond real-time during earnings calls that retail investors are unable to do).
- liotier 4y agoCould rules such as order matching within coarse-grained time increments level the playing field ? What would the drawbacks be ?
- carterschonwald 4y agoThere’s actually 1-2 venues that have launched in the past year that do something like that.
- chollida1 4y ago
- yalogin 4y agoI had no idea that, until the recent round of “innovation”, the retail investor traded only with other investors in the brokerage consumer list. I always thought the brokerage is just facilitating access to the actual trading desk where the trade is put up for anyone to pick up. Am I right in understanding that Robinhood took this and abused it by turning itself and its customers as the source for high frequency traders?
- passwordoops 4y agoPretty much. "Robinhood makes money in a number of ways, notably through a system known as payment for order flow. That is, Robinhood routes its users' orders through a market maker who actually makes the trades and compensates Robinhood for the business at a rate of a fraction of a cent per share." [0] The market maker is usually a big player like Citadel. And with this information, they can front-run the market. [0] https://www.investopedia.com/articles/active-trading/020515/how-robinhood-makes-money.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/active-trading/020515/...
- jeffreyrogers 4y agoThey have to execute at or better than the national best bid and offer so you are getting at or better than the price you'd get if you posted a marketable order to an exchange. I don't see how they are front-running.
- mring33621 4y agoOh yes, the old "They have to execute..." I'm sure these nice American businesses are complying 100% with this rule. OTOH, I'm not sure that it's easy/possible to really know what the 'NBBO' is, at any given 'moment'.
- drivebycomment 4y agoFINRA requires retail brokers to make a report on price improvements based on a retroactive analysis vs NBBO. So, yes, they do know what NBBO was, and whether they were truly price improvements or not, and that's being monitored and tracked, and the brokers get yelled at if they violate that. Pretty much all conspiratorial, "motivational" analysis of PFOF critics on HN are simply wrong. As Matt Levine explains it clearly, from the utilitarian perspective, PFOF is not a bad thing at all for retail investors. Whether it can be even better is a different question and clearly SEC is trying to find that with the new proposal, but as is always the case with a complex system with differently motivated actors, what exactly the new balance point for the new system will be is uncertain.
- abritrum 4y agoDon't want to hijack topic but my post on FINRA got flagged. I am interested in your read of the trading halt of MMTLP two days before the ticker was supposed to be deleted. Previously trading was supposed to go on until the 12th, investors could sell. But after FINRA halted the trading, investors were left with the shares to be converted to a new company shares at some future date. https://investorplace.com/2022/12/investors-petition-for-finra-to-reinstate-mmtlp-stock-trading-after-halt/ https://investorplace.com/2022/12/investors-petition-for-fin...
- jgalt212 4y agoEven if PFOF (pay for order flow) were provably optimal, I don't like from an investor perspective because the fees are hidden. Gensler makes a similar argument.
- rr888 4y agoPeople care way too much. Brokers used to take huge commissions, now the HFT market makers really aren't as exploitative as people's imaginations believe. Virtu is a good example, its a $3B market cap, less than half the size of Twilio.
- sesuximo 4y agoKind of an interesting comparison. According to Wikipedia, virtu is about 1/8 the size. But other than headcount and apparently market cap they seem fairly close by the numbers.
- rufus_foreman 4y ago>> People care way too much I agree with this, as an individual investor, from my perspective the most likely thing that happens is that the SEC screws things up. I started out paying what in today's money would be $50 a trade to buy or sell a stock. So for a $2000 trade, that's going to mean starting out down 5% on trading costs ($50 buy + $50 sell). Now I pay nothing. Does it matter if I pay $50.01 or $50.005 per share on a trade? No, it does not. Leave it alone and let the brokerages compete, they're not monopolies. I much prefer the current system to even a small risk of having to go back to commissions.
- thedangler 4y agohttps://i.redd.it/hjz53s6up96a1.png https://i.redd.it/hjz53s6up96a1.png
- fakeslimshady5 4y ago
- theyknowitsxmas 4y agoHow to shoot yourself in the foot and lose money to Dubai.
- rekttrader 4y agoPFOF is what gets you rekt. Just ask the humans who trade with alpaca and robinhood. Robinhood had citadel. Alpaca has the Japanese counterparty... where it’s legal to front run.
- SpeedilyDamage 4y agoHaving only whatever partial understanding Levine (I do love how many people here mention him, he makes us all feel smarter for sure) has imparted on me, I really don't get the obsession with these brokers. OF all the seemingly shady things going on with finance, this doesn't really seem that bad...
- mikewarot 4y agoIf it were up to me, I'd make the market a series of batch executions, every 30 seconds... 20 seconds of open for orders, 5 seconds to actually compute the transactions, and 5 seconds to send out the results, and then repeat. Completely eliminate the idea of high frequency frontrunning.