11 ms·
Designed for Rural Living
- glasss 4y agoWas really hoping to see what the solution to the ferry problem was.
- drewcoo 4y agoJust don't put the goats on at the same time as the cabbages or the wolves. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wolf,_goat_and_cabbage_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wolf,_goat_and_cabbage_problem
- Veen 4y agoI imagine it’s a ferry that doesn’t need to be sent away for repair or a causeway or similar. But the solution to that problem isn’t important to the writer’s point. It’s in the article to exemplify the issues caused by not considering spacial and temporal factors when designing solutions.
- quickthrower2 4y agoMaybe a one way ticket off the island :-)
- eyelidlessness 4y agoI personally would steer the ferry away from killing ten people to save one person, but I’m also reasonably sure I’d be arrested by a rural philosophy professor.
- mrweasel 4y agoI'm really hoping it's something like progressive enhancement, but for ferries. It seems like a similar problem to web development. If you rely on JavaScript of even the most basic features, you risk having everything break, when you make a mistake in a tiny bit of JS somewhere. There may be limits to what you can do with a modern ferry, but it would be nice that if when everything else fails, it just revert back to being a "dumb ferry". So you'd be able to use it, but only in fair weather, or with more staff, something like that. Then you yank out the broken bit and install a replacement. While knowing very little about ferries, I suspect it's the integration of systems that makes repairs difficult.
- jeegsy 4y agoMy reading of the article suggests that they think the solution is better networking/internet!
- dredmorbius 4y agoThe CBC has a number of articles addressing the situation: <https://duckduckgo.com/?q=fogo+change+island+ferry+site%3A.cbc.ca+repairs https://duckduckgo.com/?q=fogo+change+island+ferry+site%3A.c...> Upshot / TL;DR: The new ferry, the MV Veteran, was built by a Dutch firm, and at least one set of repairs required it being returned across the Atlantic to Europe for an engine refit. Substitute service had been provided by, variously, a sister ship, the Galatea, the older ferry that Veteran and Galatea replaced, MV Earl W. Winsor, as well as a fourth ship, MV Legionnaire, fixed-wing and heliocoptor aircraft, the latter at standard sea-based ferry rates. This 2017 article discusses then-current issues as well as a five-year history of troubled reliability: <https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/mv-veteran-ice-damage-repairs-1.4172946 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/mv-vete...>
- friend_and_foe 4y agoIt's not just about rural living. This can be generalized to "different communities have different needs." It's why world government won't work, and why large states have to either leave a lot of leeway for self government or fragment entirely.
- dathos 4y agoI completely agree, although having a fair world where one community cannot ruin it for others seems far away
- tstrimple 4y agoLocal governing ignore externalities much easier. "Who cares if we dump our shit down the river. It's someone else's problem now!"
- lowbloodsugar 4y ago"Let's just dam the river, and damn the six other states that need it."
- Animats 4y agoGood subject, terrible article. No discussion of solutions. The problems mentioned come partly from having too many part numbers. That is, how much inventory do you need to be able to fix something? It's not the level of technology. It's the lack of standardization. Companies hate standardization. It allows customers to switch too easily. It makes repair too easy.
- mjevans 4y agoImagine an Industrial grade mini-computer board similar to a Raspberry Pi (whatever) but rated for operations even inside of a warm engine chamber (possibly with a different, standard fan). The physical dimensions and interface (available pins with functions) would be an ongoing standard (think similar to washer or screw sizes today). The CPU would probably have to be, or be capable of sufficiently emulating (hard realtime accurate) a target profile and speed. There are several likely candidates among existing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RISC-V#Implementations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RISC-V#Implementations (RISC-V implementations); for micron-controllers Berkeley's BOOM might be a bit much, but is more likely to be useful in MMI ((hu)Man Machine Interfaces) and user-facing systems, while there are at least 4 useful Microcontroller unit designs that look suitable for programmable controller card use. Oddly, though I mention cooling, heating might also be required for devices exposed to harsh winter conditions. It might be suitable for a design to be mounted adjacent to an external heating block. A team of experts in the field (rather than someone who years ago might have had such a future as a possible career path) would be better than I at picking the winner and initial profile targets. However those targets should probably have a wide range, possibly from some embarrassingly low Hz mode for 'sleep' / standby / simple toy use (E.G. the chips are reused in products rather than modules), to a low, moderate, reasonably fast, and high performance mod as possible options for industrial products with different demands. Thinking of potential higher order demands (vector graphics printers, CNC machines of various sorts, etc) the more fully featured Berkeley https://boom-core.org/ https://boom-core.org/ (64 bit, with IEEE fp) design might be a better fit; possibly enough to have two grades, with the higher end BOOM design able to emulate the responses of the initially power / space optimized designs. Though experts in the field might find that irrelevant compared to economies of scale from a single design (and the potential of binning to move partial failures to lower market segments).
- throwaway0x7E6 4y ago>Licenses for fishing and for fish processing are distributed separately, Sengers explains. Authorities saw fishing as one form of employment and fish processing as another, and they wanted to distribute both forms of employment equitably among the communities of the province. As a consequence, however, fish caught near Change Islands can’t be processed there. the idiocy of nanny state lawmakers never ceases to amaze me
- bbojan 4y agoYeah, I understand why you would need licenses for fishing. It's a limited resource and you want to prevent overfishing. But why would you need s license for a fish processing plant? Why shouldn't anyone (whose facility fullfils hygiene criteria) be able to open one?
- 2rsf 4y agoYou said it yourself- hygiene and zoning are two big reasons, you don't want your next door neighbour opening a stinky fish processing factory.
- silon42 4y agoI assume fish processing includes fish farms, those are quite dirty...it's not just the stink.
- bluGill 4y agoI disagree with that. You can legislate how much smell the factory is allowed to emit. You can legislate some other environmental impacts. However let the factory builders figure out how to work with that. If the factory doesn't smell (or other adverse impacts) then let them build it.
- engineer_22 4y agoFish factories just smell. There's not much you can do about that.
- petewailes 4y agoRural person here. We've been having this argument in the UK for the last... Oh, 400 years at least. It basically boils down to, some muppet in Whitehall shouldn't be making laws about what to do with sheep/cattle/pasture/abattoirs/grain coatings... There's a lot of truth in it. You think there's bad regulation in tech? It's nothing compared to regulation on farming and ag generally. In terms of solutions, the only one I've ever seen proposed which I think could work would be to have governing bodies for rural areas (and this could apply more broadly to areas of society), where they are free to make laws as it pertains to the area of responsibility of the group, with a coordinating body overseeing the groups to design for efficiency and arbitrate where conflicts arise.
- Neil44 4y agoWithout getting bogged down in specifics there's definitely a sense sometimes that laws and policies are set by people who rarely set foot outside London.
- walthamstow 4y agoAs an 'only-half-joking' London nationalist I feel compelled to tell you that London too is governed by voters in the rest of the UK who know nothing about the city, its economy or its people. This isn't a disagreement, I'm just pointing out how great regionalism/federalism could be for the UK
- bowietrousers 4y agoLondon gets its own way, with its own affairs, a lot - it already has a mayor, an elected assembly, and its own transport governance.
- walthamstow 4y agoYou listed offices, but not powers. Those bodies do not really have any substantial powers. The GLA is not a legislative body at all. The mayor is responsible for transport and, uhh, that's about it.
- Roark66 4y agoFor clueless "decisionmakers" I 100% agree, but this? Seriously: “A lot of the engineers, researchers, and planners … have the best intentions, but they don’t always understand the reality of what it means to live in a rural community…” What other solution is there to a ferry, when a bridge/tunnel is out of a question? Relocation?
- nehal3m 4y agoThe point is that a technologically advanced ferry is more difficult to maintain in remote regions. I would speculate that 2 smaller diesel ferries would fit design requirements better. Maybe less stringent environmental requirements would be in order, to allow for simpler technology (the net benefit being you don't have to fly parts halfway across the planet every time the fancy ferry breaks down). Ultimately people who don't live in the environments things are being designed for might be predisposed to assume that advanced is better (or even the only option). The article argues that this is not always the case and we should take that into account.
- willyt 4y agoMaybe the organisation that bought the ferry should enforce the contract they have with the ferry supplier so that the ferry works properly? Maybe the contract should have included a service plan? It’s a four hour drive to a city of 100k people in a province full of ferries so not that hard to have a maintenance agreement, surely? Sounds like a one-off procurement screw-up. Not an endemic problem.
- willyt 4y agoScotland, Norway, Finland and Sweden the Faroe Isles all seem to manage it. Norway has replaced most of thier short haul ro-ro ferries with battery electric ones based on brand new technology and many of them will be further away from a city than this. If you look at the size of the slipways on satellite and the length and exposure of the crossing you can see that it’s not a problem that can be solved by a pontoon with an outboard on it. It is a what would be a 10 car ferry with a crew of 4 people in Scotland one of whom would be a mechanic. If the engine goes wrong, the EMS displays a code and the service tech from Cummins or Caterpillar or MTE comes and fixes it, not the local car mechanic. You can’t buy a new 1600hp engine that can be serviced like this anymore, they cost more than £100k and the local guy is only trusted to do oil and filter changes. Maybe that’s bad but then you need to change the course of diesel engine design philosophy at a global sized company to solve this problem. Not going to happen.
- eyelidlessness 4y agoRural living is simultaneously overly accommodated (as in we go out of our way to encourage policy, promote social mores, and expand technology which supports choosing to live in rural areas) and woefully abandoned (the problems discussed in this article, but I’d emphasize lack of access to things humans depend on generally like health care). I honestly think most of the solution is to stop over-accommodating. The vast majority of rural-living people don’t need to live so remotely from the resources they deserve, and they could live slightly closer together without any meaningful harm to their lives or preferences. To the extent people do need to live in rural areas, we should recognize they’re critical members of society and do all the things we already do to expedite movement of resources in more urban areas. Per the article’s main theme: we should eliminate the time and place problem by mostly not living in remote locales where we don’t need to, and do whatever we can to minimize the impact of distance for those who have to.
- blamestross 4y agoWelcome to the old centralization decentralization cycle. The article talks about a lot of real issues with rural QoL. High QoL is more efficient when centralized but if you tolerate a lower QoL then the perspective shifts. Rural living is decentralized infrastructure and an important thing to preserve as a hedge against cataclysm. We really do need our whole last mile of 3rd world country not to get eaten by corporatism.
- alt227 4y agoThis becomes more complicated as QoL is subjective. For some people living in an urban environment, no matter how many resources are available, will always be a lower QoL than living in a rural area.
- specialist 4y agoYup. Left Behind vs Stay Behind. When the Stay Behind cohort has the power to veto, accommodation becomes extortion. Worse, Stay Behind often thwart efforts to help Left Behind. Every budget cycle, my state argues about funding public education. It'd be easy to write off the Left Behind, especially since the Stay Behind work to end public education, especially since rural areas are subsidized (accommodated). But the wiser, calmer nannies in the capital fight to keep the rural schools funded, as best able. Can't abandon people just because they were born in the wrong zip code. Then the Stay Behind always extracts some concessions to allow the nannies to help the Left Behind. Aka extortion. And Stay Behind despises the nannies for the effort.
- pard68 4y agoI live very rurally. Thanks to a state government with very little "nannying" our tiny county government can make infrastructure decisions that fit our needs, financials, and abilities. Almost every road in my county is dirt/gravel. When you have very minimal use, this is a vastly superior road medium. No specialty equipment is needed to maintain the roads, just a dump truck and (ideally) a grader or plow. Nearly every farm out here has both, so road maintenance is a community affair. Likewise, we have nearly no bridges, the roads just go through the creeks and you are expected to have the ability to judge whether or not you and your vehicle can cross. We have a bridge in need of repair, it's been closed for four years with no sign of fixing soon. We do not have the money (as a county) to fix it. The water crossings are closed after storms, for a few hours, this is vastly superior, for my rural community. It's the same as it is in tech. Your tech choice are partially informed by the size and capability of your org.
- nonethewiser 4y agoKinda seems like a scenario where you can save 80% of cost by ignoring 20% of the problems. Not good enough for many, but it's a very strong value proposition none the less. How do you manage work and remoteness? Long commute? I imagine internet isnt good at home.
- oneplane 4y agoIt ignores all sorts of externalities and world-wide interactions. The concept of living in an isolated rural bubble forever is an illusion. Air and water for example, they don't just stick around in one place. So if you pollute something, that pollution happily goes elsewhere making it everyone's problem. Same with disease, or cancer. Say you need to go out to the hospital for radiation treatment every day, and you can't do it without assistance from an ambulance, that gravel road and the no-bridge concept is suddenly a really bad idea. I think it's ignoring more than just 20% of the problems, it's ignoring looking (and planning) ahead, and understanding that not all factors are known, especially not in lower-populated areas. And then there is the power imbalance a supplier will have over a small rural town, as it is unlikely that there is much to choose from, and no real power to influence a large company anyway. So now you're stuck with undrinkable water, bad internet, and barely any healthcare.
- whywhywhywhy 4y agoSounds more of a governmental issue where they really just don’t want remote places to self govern. Could have asked them what boat they needed and bought it. Could have let them run whatever fish industry they wanted but nah have to step in a nanny you. Cos you know, you might start to ask why are you paying them.
- neilv 4y ago> A large part of the problem stems from a tendency on the part of technology designers to assume that properties of time and place don’t matter, I've seen a few family farmers, for example, and they seem very well aware of the importance of equipment that they can maintain themselves, and they also DIY a large number of pragmatic necessities. But look around at our own field's technology design right now, and it's often: * By people who don't understand the application domain, and apparently don't care to understand it. * By people focused -- not on the interests of the users -- but on the interests of some other party. (For example, any time you see what we currently recognize as UX dark patterns, and then the other engineering effort against users' interests, for which we might not yet have terms.) * By people who'll make technology choices for individual gain, not even gain of their company. (For example, to add a marketable new stack keyword to resume, even when it's clearly inappropriate for theis project and the company right now. Or to do an unwarranted new project, so that it can be credited to them.) * By people strutting around and posturing about their skills/impact/status. (Contrast with your stereotypical small family farmer, where boastfulness is frowned upon.) Maybe it'd help us to think of those stereotypical farmers, to remind ourselves of humility and user-driven design.
- systems_glitch 4y agoWe all had to learn this at some point, everyone tries to get their parents running Linux so they don't have to fix Windows viruses.
- lowbloodsugar 4y agoI think you're joking? My mom has a mac so she can go chat with the nice young people at the nearby Apple Store when she needs something fixed, which she inevitably does. We also learned not to buy her a desktop, like an iMac, because then she can't take it into the Apple Store for them to undo whatever damage she has wrought. So macbook for her, and peace of mind for me.
- systems_glitch 4y agoThat is exactly my point! The article talks about the wrong-fit but well intentioned tech solution resulting in the end user not being able to use the thing for a higher percentage of the time than the old, broken thing it replaced. I also eventually made the same choice, and switched my parents from Linux to Mac after I realized that Linux was definitely not the Right Thing for them. Still had to learn the lesson, though :P
- VLM 4y agoInterestingly, there's nothing "rural" about bad engineering solutions. For example I live in a big city where they built an interstate spur that was essentially unneeded in the 60s because nobody expected the cities to start decaying in the late 60s, so they demolished the unused spur a couple decades later when it was apparent the city was permanently blighted and would never grow in that direction. Insert a zillion "bridge to nowhere" stories here for a similar transportation infrastructure fail. Another big city story: A local hotel/condo development wanted the entire city to pay for a light rail system for bragging purposes. They got it. It connects to very little and very few people ride it, but paying off the politicians to get it was less expense than the marketing bragging increased the sales price. Admittedly this is a corruption story not a civ-eng transpo engineering failure. I mean, yeah, its sad whenever a "solution" makes things worse, but it's not specifically a rural problem. Reformers usually make money off making things worse, its a very old human story.
- LatteLazy 4y agoRural life is expensive, low productivity/pay, has poor social and health outcomes, and produces a lot of pollution. As much as possible, we need to phase it out as much as possible, and stop idealising it or enabling it.