13 ms·
Apple Music Sing
- passwordoops 4y agoThe real question is, which Karaoke app was recently rejected by app store reviewers for vague violations prior to this release?
- sudhirj 4y agoMy daughter is going to love this. Can anyone make out if songs like this are specially mastered with separate vocal channels? I’m guessing they’re not minus ones that someone else has arranged and played. If these are coming from the original artist it’ll be interesting to know if they’re being uploaded as separate vocal channels or if Apple is applying ML to do voice isolation. Do any audio file formats support separate tracks with level info?
- treis 4y agoThis is more or less just a Karaoke machine. Presumably Apple is getting the music from the same place they do.
- rockostrich 4y agoMy guess is that they're doing it through ML. The old "cancel out the left track with the inverted right track" trick is probably good enough, but I don't see why Apple wouldn't take it one step further. > Do any audio file formats support separate tracks with level info? I don't know what file format audio engineering software uses to store all the track info but my guess is that it's akin to a zip file containing a flac for each track.
- Wowfunhappy 4y ago> The old "cancel out the left track with the inverted right track" trick is probably good enough I've never had this produce good results. It removes major parts of the music, while also not fully removing the vocals.
- lostgame 4y agoI found out about this by having a poor headphone jack connection on a cassette walkman as a kid. I would actually take that and record out from that to another tape, so I could have 'instrumental' versions of the songs. And, no - it doesn't work very well at all; it sounds like a poor 64kbps MP3 with bizarre artifacts and; yes - many missing instruments.
- the_other 4y agoNative Instruments tried to popularise a four-track format for DJs but it didn’t spread far enough to take hold.
- lostgame 4y agoI was disappointed the .stem format never worked out. I actually had high hopes for that.
- peatmoss 4y agoI assume this comes along with “Mastered for iTunes” / “Apple Digital Masters” ah least in part. I think if it’s only available for limited tracks, we’ll know they went the full separate-the-vocal-track route. If it’s everything, then I bet they augmented with ML.
- copperx 4y agoWe know that artists submit lyrics, but if they enable syllable-by-syllable highlighting for every song, it's probably ML.
- MBCook 4y agoI’m curious to see how they do it too. Presumably if they have Don’t Stop Believing and a separate karaoke karaoke today, they could basically cross fade between them for the adjustment of original singer vocals. And it would work better than trying to remove vocals after the fact. But that would require both versions, synchronizing them, and KNOWING which two tracks went together. Is that easier or harder than getting the labels to just give you a special version with an extra channel for vocals? Hopefully someone digs in and finds out once this is released.
- lostgame 4y ago>> Is that easier or harder than getting the labels to just give you a special version with an extra channel for vocals? Depends on the label and the artist. Could be easier, could be much harder. Sometimes multi-stems just don't exist anymore; were lost, have additional licensing issues; labels are a nightmare to deal with.
- nkozyra 4y agoPlenty of file formats support this, but they're generally for DAWs and not for a final mix. In order to support volume the file would have to be packed with each individual track. Almost assuredly this is just ML-assisted frequency separation.
- colmmacc 4y agoAAC is already interleaved multi-channel. Two-channel L/R is obviously very common for music, but spatial audio and Dolby Atmos comes with more channels (up to 128, which can be arranged and binned into "beds"). 5.1 (6 channels) and 7.1 (8 channels) are also common for video. Having dedicated/isolated vocal tracks as a channel very trivial in the format. I'd expect this is how it's done, and not ML, because Apple have already been driving mixing and end to end workflow with studios for Spatial audio and mastered for iTunes.
- nkozyra 4y agoChannel and spatial/binaural tracks I'd expect, but separated tracks for instruments/vocals is a lot more time consuming and the kind of thing that studios/producers/masterers would bluster at enough that I wouldn't expect it to come close to giving Apple the volume they'd likely want. It absolutely could be done, I just think that Apple would want very good coverage and studios would be very slow to provide this format.
- colmmacc 4y agoApple need the labels either way. They can't just go creating new derived works without a license, and the artists and producers would far prefer to avoid the artifacts of something that is overly automated. It's already become pretty common for studios and labels to make stems available (stems are full multi-track files that can be used with a DAW) to industry insiders and even the public sometimes. There's a community of remixers, samplers, even a small cottage industry of YouTubers who work with these regularly. It wouldn't take them more than a few minutes per track to annotate which channel is vocals.
- iicc 4y ago>Can anyone make out if songs like this are specially mastered with separate vocal channels ... or if Apple is applying ML to do voice isolation "Coupled with an ever-expanding catalog that features tens of millions of the world’s most singable songs" "The vocal slider adjusts vocal volume, but does not fully remove vocals" Based on the quantity and results it's ML like Spleeter (https://research.deezer.com/projects/spleeter.html https://research.deezer.com/projects/spleeter.html).
- MBCook 4y agoOh good catch on that last bit. I missed it when reading through.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- golergka 4y ago> Do any audio file formats support separate tracks with level info? There is a 4-track an audio format developed by Native Instruments that is mostly used by DJs, and only dance music gets released in that. However, now that I search their website, there's no mention of it anymore — guess it wasn't popular enough with the labels to get any traction.
- joegahona 4y agoIs this akin to karaoke? (The word never appears on the page.) > Apple today announced Apple Music Sing, an exciting new feature that allows users to sing along to their favorite songs with adjustable vocals1 and real-time lyrics. Users can already "sing along to their favorite songs" -- this feels like a wasted opportunity in the first sentence to explain the differentiator. It feels like they're misusing/misunderstanding what "sing along" means, and the real feature enhancement here is that users now have the ability to suppress vocals in songs. (Which is kinda cool.) I get that this is a press release, but "show don't tell" would go a long way in announcements like this, even (especially?) if it's not available yet.
- hamburglar 4y agoI agree with “show don’t tell” as a general rule for effectiveness in cases like this, but I find it really hard to believe anyone is going to read this and not immediately grasp what is meant by “with adjustable vocals and real-time lyrics”. Obviously you can already sing along, and the question about how this makes it better is answered within the same sentence.
- yunohn 4y agoWhat’s the reasoning behind leaving out the word “karaoke”?
- wingerlang 4y agoWhen I hear karaoke I think 90s looking machine with a tethered microphone, or equally old music videos with ugly subtitles. True or not, it is possible they just want to have full control of the image of their service. Another thing is that when you sing a foreign song, the karaoke also means to read the foreign subtitles in your own language. It's an extra meaning they might want to avoid, I assume this is not a feature they have.
- WXLCKNO 4y ago
- mark_l_watson 4y agoThis sounds cool. I was in glee club in Junior High, that would be almost 50 years ago, and haven’t really sang since. On the rare occasions when I have our house to myself, I sometimes partake in Apple Fitness+ dance exercises - I really don’t want anyone seeing that. Now I have the option to sing, in a non-embarrassing setting! This Music Sing service might also be really good at parties.
- pilsetnieks 4y ago> and can be enjoyed on iPhone, iPad, and the new Apple TV 4K But the old Apple TV 4K is not powerful enough for displaying text on a TV, even though any old iPhone is? I get that they want to push device and service adoption but they should pick a lane, either push users to upgrade devices, or push to sign up to paid services. Pushing for both at the same time is greedy.
- ricardojoaoreis 4y agoThat line stood out, powerful enough for 3D games but not for Karaoke…
- diebeforei485 4y ago3D games don't involve on-device ML. Using GPU's for ML is not very efficient on low-power devices. Having dedicated ML circuitry is the way to go.
- surewe 4y agoI'd imagine/hope that it's also supported on the previous generation, just that they'd rather advertise its usage on the new one. Edit: per the bottom of the page... > Apple Music Sing will be available on all compatible iPhone and iPad models as well as the new Apple TV 4K. :/ maybe they do ML to process stuff on-device, per other comments' speculation, that justifies requiring the newer model?
- pilsetnieks 4y agoiPhone 8 that is the oldest supported for iOS 16 has an A11 chip; the second gen 4K has A12. The first gen 4K has an A10X chip - maybe it needs the "Neural Engine" that first appeared in A11 but the 2nd gen does have it. In addition, the Apple TV is plugged in, it doesn't have to limit its power for battery reasons.
- MBCook 4y agoThe old Apple TV 4K can show lyrics today. I’d fully expect it to get this feature. Probably the HD as well. This seems like it might be Apple‘s standard thing of just promoting whatever their newest products are in all communications.
- colmmacc 4y agoThis looks really cool, and it'll be interesting to see how artists and producers react. Presumably the tracks need to be mixed for the format with dedicated vocal track. Although it's possible to isolate vocals some of the time from mixes, using stereo separation (the vocals are often the only component that is 100% center mixed), filtering, and even AI techniques ... none are perfect. I wonder if this will have the real killer feature of professional karaoke ... the ability to transpose the song into a more convenient key for the singer. Apple have had this capability in Logic Pro's pitch shift and it's pretty good even on polyphonic music. Some Karaoke platforms use midi and midi-like formats and synthesize the instruments to do it, but I'd be surprised to see that here.
- batesy 4y agoSerato just released Stems, which allows DJs to isolate drums, bassline, vocals in the tracks they are playing live. The algos are getting pretty damn good. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v2Wy9szxU3A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v2Wy9szxU3A
- soylentcola 4y agoI remember seeing something like this in VirtualDJ the last time I fired it up and updated a few years ago. Only noticed because they'd remapped the high/mid/low EQ knobs on my old Numark controller to remove bass, drums, vox, etc. Wasn't what I was looking for initially but it was surprisingly good compared to the older "vocal remover" type plugins I remember having for Winamp et al back in the day. If I ever actually DJed anymore it would definitely be useful for mixing tracks.
- CrypticShift 4y agoAnd this is real-time (Like the apple sing). So it is a game changer for DJs (usability-wise)
- ghostpepper 4y agoWait, there are Karaoke machines that can transpose songs?
- JohnBooty 4y agoThis could really revolutionize amateur music. Having easy access to instrumental versions of millions of tracks will be huge for remixers, people recording vocal demos, etc. ...well, maybe. I'm sure you won't be able to export the vocal-less versions out to an audio file directly. But you should be able to turn off the vocals and capture the resulting audio by the usual means: loopback audio drivers, analog capture, etc. It's still a step, but it's going to be fairly easy and the resulting file should be quite clean. (It's also going to revolutionize the singing I do alone after a few glasses of wine but that's not super impactful to anybody but me)
- MBCook 4y agoIt’s not what this is for, but I’ve often thought it would be kind of nice to be able to just put Apple Music in a “instrumental“ mode. The easy way would be if it knew which tracks were instrumental or not and only play those. The GREAT way would be if it just played everything but knew how to remove the all vocals by playing just the backing track.
- paxys 4y agoExtracting vocal tracks from songs is something that is done trivially in all audio mixing software out there. This is hardly a "revolution", especially considering Apple isn't even going to let you export the results digitally.
- JohnBooty 4y agoIt's been a while since I played around with that, but I remember the results not being super clean. Is that still the case? I am assuming, perhaps incorrectly, that Apple has access to multitrack versions of some songs and that for these tracks it will be able to remove the vocals in a pristine way.
- yunwal 4y agoSounds like they're doing it with ML just like everyone else (hence not supporting devices with old chips).
- fuzzy2 4y agoGood, now maybe Spotify will up their lyrics game. It’s sometimes great but often mediocre at best. I also really miss the days when Singstar was a thing, or even UltraStar, the open source “clone”.
- jefft255 4y agoSo... Karaoke? Why do I have to read all of this to understand that they mean Karaoke?
- codazoda 4y agoWeird that this is new. I’ve seen it multiple times over the past few months. Maybe I got opted into a test group or something. I activated it by accident several times and ignored it because I primarily use Apple Music when I’m driving.
- MBCook 4y agoApple doesn’t tend to do that. They don’t unofficially beta test things with groups of users like Google or Facebook might. If you’ve had access, my guess is a mistake was made and you were not supposed to be on the magic list. Very cool.
- timmytokyo 4y agoYou may be referring to the lyrics feature, where lyrics are displayed as the music plays. Apple Music has had that for some time.
- codazoda 4y agoYeah, you’re right, I may have just seen regular lyrics and this adds some features (alternate singing positions and speed). So, it’s an enhancement to the existing lyrics feature.
- simonw 4y agoI was just thinking the other day that what I really want is pretty much Duolingo for singing lessons. I'd love to get better at singing, but not quite enough to actually find, schedule and pay for singing lessons from a human teacher. But I'd happily do 15 minutes a day with a Duolingo-style app, especially if it could guide me through exercises to help me sing better.
- ssharp 4y agoThere are a lot of apps that having singing lessons. Yousician may be the most popular. I'd equate being able to speak a foreign language to singing in key. That's what the apps will be able to help with, at least from what I've seen. If that's what you're looking for, that's a good place to start. However, there is a lot of technique to make your voice sound pleasant and interesting beyond just singing on key. I'm not sure if that apps really help out there that much like an actual vocal coach could.
- simonw 4y agoRight, I'm not expecting anything that comes close to a vocal coach - but I'm not dedicated enough to seek one out. I want to spend 15 minutes a day and get incrementally better with some pretty generic tips.
- rsynnott 4y agoAn obvious name for such a product suggests itself.
- flappyeagle 4y agoThat's the sound of Apple completely taking over the East and SE Asian market
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nabaraz 4y agoAdd a camera and we have a TikTok?
- closetkantian 4y agoThis is so pointless that it made me start questioning reality and wondering if it was April Fool's Day.
- rsynnott 4y ago... I mean, karaoke's pretty popular. This might actually make me switch to Apple Music.
- gardenhedge 4y agoYeah.. I don't have loyalty to who streams me music so which app offers the most extras I will just get that one
- ffgh 4y agoEither I'm burnt out or jaded and cranky but I thought the same.
- romanovcode 4y agoThey should introduce "Discover Weekly", "Release Radar" and "Enhanced Playlists". Why are the recommendations lacking so much behind Spotify? That's the only reason I can't switch over and I would love to.
- timmytokyo 4y agoApple Music has custom play lists, which it updates every week. One of them is the "New Music Mix", which is sort of a combination of Spotify's "Release Radar" and "Discover Weekly" play lists. Apple also has other mix play lists, which are updated weekly: things like "Favorites Mix", "Chill Mix", and "Get Up! Mix". Finally Apple Music has custom "radio stations", which are endless playlists based on your listening history. (I believe Spotify also had stations, but I never used them much.) I switched from Spotify to Apple Music about a month ago, mostly because I wanted music in Dolby Atmos. (Not all songs are in Dolby Atmos, but many are, and they sound far superior on my AirPods to anything without it.) After transferring my Spotify playlists to Apple, I've found that the experiences are pretty similar. There are a few things I like better about Spotify (e.g., it has better support for non-Apple platforms like Linux and Windows), but I prefer Apple now. If you're curious, I'd recommend a free trial.
- micromacrofoot 4y agoI switched to Apple Music for a couple years and recently switched back to Spotify. Two main reasons: 1. The Apple Music desktop app is utter garbage. Other than performance issues and crashing, which happened to me almost daily, the UX is a decade behind. It's dead simple things... like the artist's name on the currently playing track isn't even a link. 2. Spotify's recommendation engine is outrageously better than Apple's. With Spotify I find new music that I actually like almost weekly, with zero effort at all. All Apple does is pigeonhole you with whatever you've listened to recently, I had a day where I listened to "lo-fi chill" music and that's all it recommended to me for weeks.
- yunwal 4y agoI find both Apple Music and Spotify's recommendation services pretty much awful after a few months of use. They both eventually end up pushing the same stuff and recommending me songs by the same artists I'm already listening to.
- rsynnott 4y agoDoes it have an option to enable blocky white-on-blue text, and some sort of incredibly fiddly and awkward UI, for that authentic karaoke experience?
- darknavi 4y agoAnything less than a bury, cheesy, bouncing ball that follows the current lyric is failure.
- ghostpepper 4y agoThe ball is so distracting, much easier to sing by reading each lyric completely and then feeling out the beat
- kitsunesoba 4y agoGotta have the completely unrelated 80s/90s stock video footage playing in the background too.
- felideon 4y agoThis will be a huge hit to Karafun’s subscriber base. I’ve paid for a couple of months before. Having this as part of my Apple Music or One subscription would give me no reason to ever subscribe to it again, assuming feature and library parity.
- gardenhedge 4y agoThis is awesome. I am sure my child will love it. I would have when I was a kid.
- drooopy 4y agoDo they really have to give a name to every new hardware and software feature they come up with? Especially when the feature in question is just karaoke.
- bfung 4y agoIf you have 3 year olds, get ready for more baby shark and let it go.
- imwillofficial 4y agoIt’s not that Apple services lack polish, they are usually great. It’s that they feel incongruent.
- CharlesW 4y agoApple services sometimes seem incongruent because they are. Other times they're experiments (which can and do fail), or windows into far larger projects. For example, QuickTime for Windows 3.0 was a product of porting significant chunks of pre-NeXT MacOS to x86¹, which was eventually leveraged for Carbon². ¹ http://preserve.mactech.com/articles/mactech/Vol.17/17.01/2001ASpaceOdyssey/index.html http://preserve.mactech.com/articles/mactech/Vol.17/17.01/20... ² https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_(API) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_(API)
- CrypticShift 4y agoI'm kind of disappointed at the priorities of these streaming services. I guess I'm not in the mainstream, music-consumption-wise. After all, it makes sense. If you want to engage subscribers to your service, what else would you do? How most people engage with recorded music? Well, they just… sing along… I'm also curious (like some on this thread) how they are technically separating the vocals. Is this yet another proprietary music format that artists have to mix/master to? (Like spatial audio)
- kevincox 4y agoI'm honestly more surprised the other way. I can't believe it took this long for them to offer even a basic karaoke experience. I thought this would be an obvious feature.
- notpushkin 4y agoPeople will definitely rip no-vocal versions out of there (if they are good quality, that is). I see some pretty neat implications: - Young artists can (illegally) use beats by popular producers. Young producers can listen to various tracks and better understand some techniques that were shadowed by vocals before. - More bootleg remixes of popular tracks. Things that weren't possible by just slicing and sampling the track would suddenly be possible, too. - Better music stemming / demixing ML models. I believe right now the baseline is Spleeter by Deezer [1], which is pretty good but leaves so much room for improvement. [1]: https://github.com/deezer/spleeter https://github.com/deezer/spleeter
- hunter2_ 4y agoBack in the day, we just took a channel differential (L minus R) with one channel high passed so the difference didn't have all the bass eliminated. Tons of reasons it sucked: stereo reverb on vocals wouldn't cancel out, other instruments panned dead center (or at least highly correlated) would cancel out along with the vocal, and early MP3 encoders often sounded better in "joint stereo" or "intensity stereo" mode (assuming low/mid bitrates) which very reasonably gave more bits to the center and fewer bits to the sides, so the differential sounded like hot garbage. Exciting to see that this technique has been replaced with ML.
- diebeforei485 4y agoPerhaps that is why it's not available on Mac. Of course people can still rip it off an iPhone/iPad through the "analog hole" via the Lightning to 3.5mm adapter
- notpushkin 4y agoOr just using a jailbreak? (unless Apple Music uses some hardware DRM)
- hrrsn 4y agodjay Pro AI has had this feature for a while now - https://www.algoriddim.com/neural-mix https://www.algoriddim.com/neural-mix It works pretty well on Mac
- Not15CharsLong 4y agoInteresting yet very anti-competitive move by Apple. There are lots and lots of existing providers of karaoke tracks: these invest (depending on quality) between several dollars and several hundreds of dollars to record "soundalike" tracks Sales of such tracks do not generate royalties for the original performer, but do pay out to the composer (per track sale and for things like public performance). Apple is now garroting these middlemen using technology, and most likely using this capability as leverage in negotiating with recording artists ("hey, give us a 14-day exclusive on iMusicOrWhateverWeCallItThisWeek, and we'll kick back an additional point on residuals"). This is bad news for the existing providers, and barely good news for anyone else.
- NaturalPhallacy 4y agoIt seems like just regular old competition to me. Like lightbulb manufacturers pushing out big candle or automobiles pushing horse breeders out of business. Who Moved My Cheese comes to mind.
- JohnBooty 4y agoThere are lots and lots of existing providers of karaoke tracks: these invest (depending on quality) between several dollars and several hundreds of dollars to record "soundalike" tracks Commercial karaoke establishments will still need to pay for the licensed versions if they want to be legal. That doesn't change. People who don't want to do that already had tons of options - Adobe Audition and tons of other software can remove/reduce vocals. So I don't feel like this changes the commercial picture too much? I feel like this will mainly affect at-home singalongs.
- Not15CharsLong 4y agoCommercial karaoke establishments are, outside Japan and Korea, not very relevant. The at-home market in the UK, on the other hand, is pretty significant. None of these households know how to operate Adobe Audition or something similar: they just want to sing along with whatever is on the telly*. There are lots of companies catering to that market. In fact: in the past, Apple was more than happy to allow them on their platform, to fill in the gaps left by Apple's inability to negotiate certain agreements. In the past year or so, Apple has gotten more and more restrictive with regards to "soundalike" content. And we now know why... Is this inevitable? Possibly. Is it fair? Maybe. Is it yet another cottage industry that Apple strangulates? Definitely. *And yes, this is a very simplistic caricature by choice. Of course UK consumers are more sophisticated, but...
- whistl034 4y agoIt's a cool feature, even if you're just reading along. Our Amazon Echo Show started doing this recently when listening to songs on Amazon's own Music service. I noticed it, thought it was interesting, commented once to the wife, then went back to just listening.
- JohnBooty 4y agoDoes it highlight the current word in the lyrics, or just the current line? The new Apple one looks like it's doing it word by word. As a user/listener I don't really care. But the engineer in me is curious.
- quenix 4y agoIt's done the line for two years now. Now it looks like the current syllable in the word.
- causality0 4y agoIs there a reason they're not calling it karaoke other than mind-boggling pretentiousness?
- gw67 4y agoIs this powered by MusicXmatch or is a competitor?
- deskamess 4y agoAmazon Music has this, right?
- TuringNYC 4y agoI feel bad for Smule, which is a pretty awesome app. This features seems to offer much of that capability natively (minus the community.)
- mensetmanusman 4y agoApple should put 3 M2-ultras in the next Apple TV and see what happens as it turns into a game platform.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoThe free version is using YouTube like we do in our family. The downside during voting season is that Disney songs are interrupted by rape allegations that 6 year olds ask about.
- Wowfunhappy 4y agoI love karaoke, but I wish we could switch to a system with better visual cues. For example, anyone remember those Disney sing-a-longs with the bouncy mickey mouse icon? IMO, the icon really helps communicate timing information; you can tell what's coming by the speed and arc of the icon. I'd love to have that system with a wider variety of music. There's also RockBand's approach, which displays scrolling syllables to be sung when they cross a white line. It's a bit harder to read, but I'd take it over traditional karaoke.
- caconym_ 4y agoI wish that before working on this they had fixed the long-standing bug where Apple Music playback on the Apple TV 4K (and possibly other versions) disables the screensaver, making it impossible to use on any OLED TV without risking burn-in.
- madelyn-goodman 4y agoI"m curious if artists can opt out of their songs being included in those that have these capabilities. This seems like another way that a streaming service is exploiting artists to me. It's cool technology definitely, but there are some problematic implications for sure.
- Rallen89 4y agoI'm sure the contracts they signed were long and covered every contingency
- therusskiy 4y agoSpotify released this feature to some users this summer: https://sea.mashable.com/entertainment/20715/spotifys-new-karaoke-mode-lets-you-sing-along https://sea.mashable.com/entertainment/20715/spotifys-new-ka... Though I have no idea how to get into this beta test. This is a killer feature for me as I am trying to learn to sing. There are some services online that use AI to split tracks into instruments and vocals that do hell of a job, but trying to combine them with written lyrics again is a pretty painful experience.
- alkonaut 4y agoStill no trace of that feature for me either. Is it officially launched?
- manv1 4y agoThis is going to be another new way for people to generate content for TikTok. Great idea, actually. How does the mic situation work? Will you need a USB mic? Can you use a BT headset?
- insane_dreamer 4y agoI would assume it uses the phone's built-in mic but you can switch to a BT mic at the OS level (as with any app)
- ddoolin 4y agoWhat I really want is lyrics on CarPlay. I'm sure there would be a ton of huffing in here about distracted driving, but...well, I don't care! I'd really just use it for confirmation of a word or phrase on a small handful of songs myself. It would be great for passengers, though.
- rfreiberger 4y agoI'm not sure if this is the same as the DJ apps that remove vocals and other instruments but there seems to be a surge of apps that have this feature. It's impressive how well some of these work and I believe they are mostly based on an open source project (I can't recall the name).
- twosdai 4y agoThere's a neat trick you can do with songs that don't have much reverb. If you load a track. Clone the channel into a second one and then just "flip" the wave form it will remove all the vocals. Not perfect but it's pretty damn good.
- deluarseo 4y ago
- bluedino 4y agoI want to see how well this does with Yellow Ledbetter
- vlunkr 4y agoHere's a question, is it copyright infringement to serve modified versions of a song? We know that attempts to censor movies have not held up in court, how is this different? Did all the publishers agree to this in their contract with Apple?
- bobthepanda 4y agoIANAL, but Apple Music already pays people per stream, and this type of modification wouldn't result in additional people needing to get paid, so that at least eliminates a whole class of issues.
- lilyball 4y agoThey're not serving modified versions of the song.
- vlunkr 4y agoRemoving or lowing the volume of the song is definitely a modification.
- insane_dreamer 4y agoNice way to make karaoke dead easy for those with iPhones
- danjc 4y agoDiscovered moises.ai recently which uses ML to separate songs into separate tracks for vocal, bass, drums, guitar. I was skeptical but it works surprisingly well.
- brap 4y agoTo anyone wondering how this will work, since the post didn’t say: > The feature won’t see users switching over to music tracks that already have the vocals removed, however. Instead, it’s relying on an on-device machine learning algorithm that processes the music in real time, Apple says. The algorithm isolates the vocals from the rest of the song, allowing users to adjust their volume accordingly using a new slider button in the Apple Music app. (TechCrunch) I wonder how well this will work. Especially when some songs apply all sorts of wacky effects on vocals. Sometimes it’s not even clear to a human what should be considered vocals and what’s part of the instrumental. The context matters too. Maybe they’re using the lyrics as a signal?
- copperx 4y agoIf this becomes popular, Apple will ask artists to optionally submit instrumentals along with their tracks.
- jbverschoor 4y agoSounds a lot like vocalremover.org
- jguimont 4y ago> Apple Music Sing will be available on all compatible iPhone and iPad models as well as the new Apple TV 4K. Does this means that only the newest version of the Apple TV 4K can run this? I have a old 4K, what does it mean for it?
- heydenberk 4y agoThis is The Onion's "we're thinking printers", but for karaoke machines. What a world.
- widowlark 4y agoIn my opinion, Apple should be more focused on improving their streaming sound quality and wireless spec. support. This does nothing for me.
- bcrescimanno 4y agoI'm excited for this feature. My brother purchased a small karaoke machine for my daughter for her birthday this year. It connects to her iPad via Bluetooth; but, so far, she's only been able to use her regular iTunes library for music. This is because the "karaoke music service" pushed in the box for the and available on the app store was a subscription for $19.99 PER WEEK. I don't care if their audio processing to drop the volume of the lyrics isn't perfect. It will give my daughter the whole Apple Music catalog to sing along with and without the side of price-gouging.
- wiseleo 4y agoShe'll love Smule. :)
- jagged-chisel 4y ago> “Apple Music’s lyrics experience is consistently one of the most popular features on our service,” I do this ... but because I have no idea what that phrase was, not because I'm singing along.
- throwaway743 4y agoThere's gotta be a way to do this with youtube captions and audio
- amelius 4y agoMicrosoft had this awesome research project called MySong. This reminded me of that. https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/project/mysong-automatic-accompaniment-vocal-melodies/ https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/project/mysong-auto...
- musicale 4y agoImpressive that they seem to have worked out the licensing, which is usually much more expensive for karaoke (presumably some sort of "public performance" license) than for personal listening/streaming. So when can we get an Apple Arcade Rock Band/Guitar Hero type game that includes vocals, guitar, bass, keyboard and drums and works with any song on Apple Music? And how about an automatic Dance Dance Revolution/Just Dance/etc. with the entire Apple Music catalog?
- gofreddygo 4y agoConfused Apple "sing" with iTunes "ping". To think its coming back... Silly me. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ITunes_Ping https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ITunes_Ping