8 ms·
South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies
- gaterin 4y agoCultures that are self sustaining will exist into the future. If the Korean culture isn't one of them, so be it.
- oifjsidjf 4y agoSelf-culling of self-destructive cultures. There probably were many cultures like modern Korean throughout history. And since they collapsed they...well don't exist anymore obviously. Natural selection.
- idlehand 4y agoUnfortunately it seems that cultural aspects like accepting homosexuality, allowing women to run their own lives and valuing higher education and a scientific mindset are correlated with not prioritizing the reproduction of their culture to the next generation. I'd like the average human in a 100 years to be a bit more like me and a bit less like the average human today. But the rest of the Western world doesn't seem to see it that way.
- AlexandrB 4y ago> Unfortunately it seems that cultural aspects like accepting homosexuality... Are you aware of the research that correlates homosexual traits in men with higher fertility in women from the same genes[1]? These factors are not a strict net-negative. In addition, "culture" isn't transmitted genetically. You could spread a culture with below replacement reproductive rates if the culture was persuasive enough. There's not a "democracy" gene that suddenly emerged and spread from 17th century England. It was the ideas that spread. [1] https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn6519-survival-of-genetic-homosexual-traits-explained/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn6519-survival-of-gene...
- sanp 4y agoThis will not change unless housing is fixed.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoTechnically speaking, fewer people will fix housing, like it did in Japan.
- hgsgm 4y ago
- jorblumesea 4y agoS. Korea isn't just having housing problems, the root cause is complex.
- kitsunesoba 4y agoHousing is a factor yes, but I think it's just a symptom of the larger problem of cost of living outpacing compensation. Not only do parents need to pay for housing, but also for more food, more clothes, child care, sometimes school, and depending on the country extra wear and tear on a car or if it's a multi-child family, a larger vehicle like a minivan. And that's just the financial cost… good parenting also requires more time than can be alotted in modern industrialized society which require one's job to be their life. It's possible for many to just barely scrape by on their wages with kids in tow, but why would anybody subject themselves to that struggle if they don't have to? If one is serious about having kids it's better to wait until both parents-to-be have achieved higher salaries and saved up significant financial padding to help mitigate disaster. Problem is, many people will never make that kind of money, and thus will never have kids. Others who would find themselves facing fertility issues brought on by age by the time the means is available.
- danaris 4y ago> cost of living outpacing compensation Another way to word this is "the very wealthy increasingly consolidating all wealth to themselves."
- 4y ago
- nr2x 4y agoI really don't see this as a problem, humans are using resources at an unsustainable rate, we need fewer people, not more.
- threatripper 4y agoWe also need to maintain a balance in military power or else the country with more "firepower" will take over their geriatric neighboring country.
- hgsgm 4y ago
- f6v 4y agoYes, US-Mexican war was terrible.
- nradov 4y agoThe era of mass armies ended decades ago. Military power is now more a function of GDP than population size. For South Korea, the only significant neighboring countries they might need to worry about are North Korea, China, and Japan. All of those have similar demographic problems.
- bhouston 4y agoDon't be so sure. I could easily see a country that has a pretty horrid demographic decline being invaded by a verile neighbour filled with young people who want more space. They will likely view it as taking what is rightfully theirs from their decadent and declining neighbours. I suspect that will happen quite a bit in the next century. There is never an end to history, no matter how much we wish to believe that. It will just happen the next time around with a lot more remote killing machines and a lot of online multi-channel propaganda.
- ram4jesus 4y agoThis is a Malthusian attitude that does not really encourage problem solving and collaboration; it's antihumanist to the core. We should not retreat from our problems but solve them creatively - how do you do that? By solving's people's needs and enabling them to do what they want without worrying about poverty.
- trasz2 4y agoFertility isn’t a problem, insufficient immigration is.
- hombre_fatal 4y agoImmigration just delays the fertility problem, so it’s still a fertility problem.
- j245 4y ago> insufficient immigration I was told they were stealing our jobs.
- idlehand 4y agoImmigrants still revert to native sub-fertility after a generation, or two at most. Immigration may be a solution for countries in the Anglosphere, as there are countless educated English speakers who want to immigrate. Countries in the rest of Europe and in East Asia do not have the luxury of educated, native-language speakers in the millions wanting to immigrate. Those who do want to come to us instead of the Anglosphere, either lack marketable skills or lack the language skills necessary to be a part of society. This imposes considerable costs, and our pension systems are not equipped to handle people working here for 20-30 years and then living off a government pension for another 20.
- julianeon 4y agoTo me this is the clear downside of having a competitive, efficient society: it is so competitive, and so efficient, that people correctly calculate that by bypassing kids, they can save more & lose less time. That's where the the economic pressure (which societies seem to want, lest people become 'lazy') pushes the next generation. When that's what you incentivize, that's what you get - not just in Korea but all over the modern world.
- seydor 4y agoSo people are optimizing. Why should they optimize for maximum population?
- simlevesque 4y agoWell, demographic crunches are not really enjoyable.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoThe planet is telling us that ever increasing population isn't enjoyable, either, and perhaps even less so.
- eastbound 4y agoThis. I’m super annoyed that countries consider depopulating as a catastrophe. Instead of immediately encouraging repopulation AND trying to deal with the climate catastrophe, why don’t we accept depopulation as a benefit and put much less pressure on the climate? In 1990, CO2 emissions equated CO2 absorption by trees. All the goals about CO2 are about coming back to 1990 levels (minus the surplus). So 1990 levels of population is what we should aim for. If a country depopulates, let’s not increase births.
- seydor 4y agoIf we accept this, (contrary to the hitherto used economic models of growth) then we 'll need to change priorities in economies, fund more automation, deflate all the useless real estate bubbles etc, take down excess infrastructure, switch to robust nuclear energy etc. There aren't going to be enough ppl in the future to maintain this infrastructure.
- cercatrova 4y agoSo will every country eventually. Usually countries solve this with immigration but Asian countries (as opposed to Western ones) are quite xenophobic based on personal experience and those of talking with others. As such, they don't let in many people and those that do find a hard time becoming a citizen (Japan's resident foreigner population is 2.29% according to Wikipedia). There is also not a huge reason to have children, I think many are finding. The societal pressure from decades or centuries past is simply not there much anymore. They already have jobs, are making money, so why spend it on raising a child which can be very expensive? Or they're not making enough money to raise them (see rising rent prices and stagnating wages), so again, why spend all that money they don't have on raising a child?
- steele 4y agoSouth Korea is not xenophobic
- decafninja 4y agoI wouldn't describe SK as xenophobic, but it's definitely far, far, closer to being a homogenous society than a melting pot. Those not of Korean ancestry are treated as outsiders. This doesn't necessarily mean disrespectfully, though in some cases it does.
- teej 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racism_in_South_Korea https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racism_in_South_Korea
- cercatrova 4y agoWhen I went to South Korea earlier this year, I was denied entry to a business while my ethnically Korean friends were allowed. I was astonished that this kind of thing happened in this day and age.
- steele 4y ago
- hunglee2 4y agoInterestingly, DRPK, at 1.86 births per woman, has a significantly higher birthrate than ROK at 0.84. Should these trends continue, we might see the two halves of Korea diverge into rich, old, low population south vs poor, young, high population north.
- codekansas 4y ago1.86 births per woman is still shrinking, just not as quickly
- bhouston 4y agoI think that the commonality in places that are having falling birth rates are: - expensive housing - very expensive to raise kids, e.g. day care. - women expected to remain in the workforce, or they need to remain in the workforce because of the cost of living. This makes kids seem incredibly inconvenient and also it isn't clear your kids will have a better life than yours. Kids are not a joy, but a burden. I think we need to let the primary caregivers of children, women or man, not have to have a stressful a full-time job while raising kids. Also we need affordable housing and affordable child care. Big cities are not setup for this - the bigger the city the more expensive and inconvenient raising kids are. Thus the remote work trend may be part of the solution to this. I also think that living in rural areas is pro-fertility (for these same reasons) and given that this tends to trend Republican, there is likely a Republican pro-fertility advantage over the long term, at least in North America. BTW any notice that Elon Musk says we need more kids while at the same time has cut parental benefits and also killed work at home at his companies? Also he pushes "hard core" hours that would annoying any parents. That guy doesn't make sense to me.
- seydor 4y agoPeople keep saying economic factors dont matter, but having a comfortable home is key. It was the norm for most of human history; you could simply build one by yourself. It is probably still true in dirt-poor places with high-fertility rates. Family is conceptually proportional to a person's property and the tiny or temporary 21th century spaces just don't leave a lot of space for "let's have a kid" (I think that 's the reason why the US has higher fertility that europe: bigger homes)
- bhouston 4y agoLarge houses also feel empty, and then you want to fill it. Also a large house lets you get away from the kids when you or they need it, which leads to happiness. And having a yard or a street where they can play with friends is also amazing. I'd be so paranoid about my kids safety if I lived in a crowded downtown core.
- idlehand 4y ago
- seydor 4y agoJust a bit ahead of the rest of the world
- rayiner 4y agoCulture is a powerful thing. My dad spent his career in public health, exporting to Asian countries contraception and the idea that children are a burden to economic and social development. And it was amazingly effective. In our home country of Bangladesh, the total fertility rate has dropped from 5.7 kids per woman the year I was born to under 2 in 2020. But the new cultural attitudes towards having kids seem entrenched now, and it seems like we will overshoot the targets and go well below replacement levels all across Asia. The economic consequences of that aren’t going to be pretty. Japan and Korea face many economic headwinds, but among them is the fact that there will be fewer consumers in 50 years. Immigration isn’t a solution to that either. The culture you can create with a homogenous population where everyone is socialized in the same norms from birth just can’t be replicated in an immigrant nation. London and Toronto are fine, but Tokyo and Kyoto are remarkable and different and I doubt they can be maintained in that state by non-Japanese.
- hackeraccount 4y agoTokyo and Kyoto are remarkable and different but not like they were 50 years ago or 100. The U.S. is remarkable and different in way that's not like it was before a 100 years of immigrants came here. There's a thru line though - a path dependence in the U.S. that takes immigrants and changes them as much or even more then it's changed by them. There's a world culture homogenization which is unfortunate in some ways but immigration is only part of the story. I don't think it's even a big part of it.
- rayiner 4y ago> There's a thru line though - a path dependence in the U.S. that takes immigrants and changes them as much or even more then it's changed by them. Apparently not as much as we think: https://www.sup.org/books/title/?id=35594 https://www.sup.org/books/title/?id=35594 (“Full assimilation in a generation or two, Jones reports, is a myth. And the cultural traits migrants bring to their new homes have enduring effects upon a nation's economic potential.”) Cultural homogenization due to mass media and the internet is of course unavoidable. But Tokyo is the product of more durable attitudes. There is an orderliness to it that comes from it being populated by Japanese people who were raised by Japanese parents who were raised by Japanese grandparents—even if they watch American movies. As you acknowledge, immigration changed America, destroying the republic as originally conceived and making it something different. Italians and Irish didn’t come to America and assimilate into the small government Anglo-Americanism. They retained their statist orientation and voted in FDR (who would have won without them), whose judicial appointments rewrote the Constitution. Whether you think it’s better or worse, it’s hard to deny it’s different. And it’s quite reasonable for people in any country to want to resist such changes that immigration can cause.
- colechristensen 4y agoThe political issue for 2040 is going to be countries in demographic crises pretty much everywhere trying to drastically change housing, employment, and childcare to try to get their populations to reproduce. The rent seeking which has made so much of people’s lifetime income dedicated to housing which is getting progressively smaller makes investing or just affording children unreasonable to very many people. Society will need to reorganize itself so that people can have children younger and afford the space to raise them in comfortably which means working parents who can hire childcare so that they can have lives outside of only raising children. This doesn’t happen with high density city property development which is about the only thing people advocate for. We need zoning in cities that forces the presence of big spaces for people that actually want them including parking for vehicles and significant tax penalties for vacancy. Housing needs to be a bad investment. Facebook ads seem to think I’ma real estate investor and one of the ads I’m seeing a lot is bragging about sixty percent returns on property development projects. That is not adding value and charging appropriately for it, it’s just theft.
- burlesona 4y agoI think you're very confused about how development in cities works. It's the parking requirements, large lot requirements, large size requirements etc., plus the general absurd difficulty of getting any kind of permit to build anything anywhere, that makes housing so expensive in the first place. If we took a pro-development attitude and made it easy to build everything by relaxing requirements, the market would respond with a much broader variety of housing options, including some large family-oriented spaces but also a lot of small single-person oriented spaces. As you say "housing should be a bad investment," I think that's true to a degree, but the best way to make that happen is to relax the rules and make it an extremely competitive market with abundant supply. Then the price of housing would be mostly determined by the cost of construction, which would be much cheaper than the current market where prices are driven by scarcity to societally damaging heights.
- idlehand 4y agoAbsolutely right. Unfortunately, this won't come to pass. Housing is the one point of leverage my parents generation have over my generation. It will be the leverage of my generation over my children's generation. By keeping homes scarce, we create an asset class that old people naturally have more of, since they bought in earlier. And we will need all the leverage we can get when every working age person has to support one or more retired people.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoWe've just passed the 8 billion mark and that is unsustainable. So what's happening in Korea, and also in other countries, needs to happen everywhere for a while. Then, humanity will be able to enjoy life in a sustainable way without worrying about the impact of every action, food choice, travel.
- polski-g 4y agoCountries trying to raise birth rates are like fat people trying to lose weight: "we've tried nothing and it didn't work!"
- davesque 4y agoI think all these modern societies are finding out that you need to make civil life about more than just extracting the maximum effort from people for the least possible compensation. If that's the way things are set up, then it's only a matter of time before the machinery of the economy leaves no space for everyday life to occur.
- alienalp 4y agoThere are obviously not enough healthy marriages in culturally corrupted (in a bad or good way depends on how you see it) countries. Obviously marriage is not likely in a big swinger party.
- locutous 4y agoAt this rate there won't be a South Korea before too long. The future belongs to the fertile.