14 ms·
Google pays $18 million to shutter Apture, CloudFlare clones it in 12 hours
- aresant 15y agoApture had great distribution thanks to a very simple pitch to publishers: "When somebody is reading an article and wants more info on a word / topic you lose them to Google - with Apture keep them on your site!" As a result they received huge support from major destination sites like NYT, Time Magazine, etc. Funny that Google wound up buying them and negating the major value they delivered to publishers. I wonder if they do a rev-share on the advertising it generates when it becomes a Chrome feature, probably not.
- jacquesm 15y agoLikely google thought they would make up the expense in increased adsense revenues from the publishers that use Apture post shut-down, but 12 hours is a terribly short window for a shut-down to be effective. I wonder how often they'll be able to buy the 'next Apture' until they figure out that they're going to have to live with it, after all if it only takes 12 hours to clone then this seems like a winning business model with a guaranteed exit.
- tikhonj 15y agoI think they didn't so much shut it down because they wanted it to die--they probably shut it down because they didn't want to support it and moved the team over to working on the Chrome feature alluded to in the article.
- pbhjpbhj 15y agoPerhaps there is an IPR issue here too? C&D just around the corner?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- jerrya 15y agoApture provided a horrible mechanism that breaks browsers and violates common "web ui standards" and created gross privacy leaks. At one point, as implemented on the NYTimes site, I showed that every single time a user selected a portion of the text at an NYTimes, apture enabled post, the contents of the selection were sent to apture servers. I was more than happy to see them go. It's a shame that CloudFlare promises to bring them back, I am hopeful they will do this in a manner that is not so outrageous or harsh on the user.
- cdata 15y agoHi, I'm one of the engineers working on the Apture replacement (Highlight). Care to be more specific about the biggest gripes you had with Apture's original implementation? As far as the general UI and UX is concerned, I'm not sure what we would really change, but generally I'd be happy to do what I can to ensure that bad practices aren't carried over (especially those related to user privacy).
- chunkyslink 15y agoPersonally I hate the whole implementation. I've never found anything in those annoying boxes of any use at all. I just don't want a box popping up when I mouse over links. Its just a bad idea. Could you implement a 'permanently disable this feature' option ?
- cdata 15y agoThat's a good idea. It's difficult to communicate the purpose of a "permanently opt out of this feature" button from the little widget that pops up, but it's definitely something we could integrate into the main window that expands. Would that be a satisfactory experience for you? Feel welcome to suggest alternative UI ideas for adding a feature like that, if you have any.
- jerrya 15y agoI do like redthroway's suggestion of putting it on it's own subdomain. That makes it easy for noscript or adblock to get rid of that and only that and leave actually useful scripts and content served.
- shasta 15y ago90% in 20 hours - amazing! Maybe someone good at math can eatimate how many months it will take them to do the other 10%...
- whatusername 15y agoThey'll probably get 90% of the remaining done pretty quickly.
- lifeformed 15y agoand Zeno can handle the rest.
- w-ll 15y agoI would but the proof is rather long for a HN comment, simplistically the limit goes to infinity.
- pluies_public 15y agoAccording to the ninety-ninety rule, about 20 more hours. :-) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ninety-ninety_rule http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ninety-ninety_rule
- yanw 15y agoIt is worth mentioning that Apture was an annoying product and I for one am glad that they "shuttered" it. As for the acquisition it was probably for talent or IP or both.
- powertower 15y agoI love CloudFlare and their story. IMO they are one of two (or three) recent startups that I consider to be genuine, and have a real product/service that adds actual value. The rest not so much ... just fluff and social.
- cdata 15y agoCloudFlare engineer here. Just wanted to say thanks for the positive assessment :) having so many awesome users keeps us feeling really positive about the stuff we do.
- drivingmenuts 15y agoAre you a user (site-owner) or a browser (a user of the site)?
- j_baker 15y agoI'm a former Apture developer/current Google employee (but I don't necessarily speak for either one). It's worth noting that Apture won't actually be shuttered until likely sometime in January (probably around the 10th). We had originally planned on Dec 20th, but we weren't confident that we had gotten the word out to everyone who uses our product (most notably people who use our plugin).
- libraryatnight 15y agoNot relevant to the story completely: What does it mean that Google is rolling this into Chrome? Does it mean that now Chrome will by default pop up with tons of annoying bubbles whenever I highlight text?
- jrockway 15y agoI'm guessing it will be integrated in a similar way as Search and Translate are.
- stickfigure 15y agoAs someone considering CloudFlare's SSL and CDN services, this worries me. The bottom line is that this misfeature is an annoyance for 99.9% of internet users. Of those, maybe 1% understand how to get rid of it - probably by installing browser plugins that block the origin servers to some degree. I have no intention to use this (obnoxious) feature... so if there's any risk that part of my customer base will receive a degraded experience on my website, this is a compelling reason to use a competitor.
- xxdesmus 15y agoIt'll be opt-in. I have no idea how this would degrade your customer's experience in any way.
- stickfigure 15y agoThe internet has a way of "fixing" what it interprets as damage. For example, if I'm in a pool of shared IP addresses that gets used by spammers, I might find my legitimate outgoing emails blocked as spam. Likewise, if end-users find that cloudflare provides irritating features on websites, they may very well develop browser plugins that block cloudflare services - even the 'good' services (deliberately or not). Maybe this is far fetched, but the bottom line is that anytime you associate yourself with unsavory activities, you risk getting hit by the blowback - even if you don't "opt-in" yourself. Taking the long-term view, this cannot possibly be good for CDN customers who don't want to annoy their users.
- stickfigure 15y agoThe internet has a way of "fixing" what it interprets as damage. For example, if I'm in a pool of shared IP addresses that gets used by spammers, I might find my legitimate outgoing emails blocked as spam. Likewise, if end-users find that cloudflare provides irritating features on websites, they may very well develop browser plugins that block cloudflare services - even the 'good' services (deliberately or not). Maybe this is far fetched, but the bottom line is that anytime you associate yourself with unsavory activities, you risk getting hit by the blowback - even if you don't "opt-in" yourself. Taking the long-term view, this cannot possibly be good for CDN customers who don't want to annoy their users.
- nchuhoai 15y agoI don't know what people feel like, but I really miss Apture being gone. For some of you, it might have been an annoyance, but for me, it is simply an amazing service. Apture's capabilities (which go beyond mere search) have helped me explorer so many topics right from within the site. For the college student who doesn't understand all the keywords of the text, Apture was a blessing. I really hope, the guys will integrate it in Google at least half as good
- nchuhoai 15y agoreally, people downvote me because I find a web service helpful?
- goodweeds 15y agoApture was incredibly obnoxious. Moreso then when you copy from sfgate or the new york times and they add extra text and adds into your copied text.
- jrockway 15y agoThis article was so jam-packed full of meaningless drivel that I think I'm going to be sick. Why does every argument have to be framed as noble startup versus evil corporation, when all you did was write twenty lines of Javascript? If I issued a press release every time I wrote a simple computer program, I'd have my own Library of Congress by now. (I clicked through to another article on that site raving about CloudFlare saving the Internet. Apparently by providing managed Apache hosting, they are un-breaking the broken Internet. Wow, amazing! Next week on The Tech Wankosphere and Hacker News: "jrock.us CEO runs apt-get upgrade; picks up a few bugfixes". That's right folks, I'm saving the Internet!)
- Terretta 15y agoYou are saving the Internet, one patched bug at a time. No, really.