8 ms·
I have heard this about various games (Risk and Settlers of Catan mostly). I don’t get it. The point of these games is to be a bastard. If everyone goes into it
by bee_rider 4y ago
I have heard this about various games (Risk and Settlers of Catan mostly). I don’t get it. The point of these games is to be a bastard. If everyone goes into it with the understanding that there will be double crosses, how could there be hurt feelings?
Monopoly is worse; it is just boring, I would dump my friends if they suggested monopoly not because I was hurt by their ruthless gameplay but for their terminally taste.
- tullianus 4y agoTwo features that make Diplomacy particularly bad: 1. Length. An in-person game can last easily 12 hours, and is mentally exhausting. Getting 10 hours in and THEN getting screwed by your friend feels worse than a game with less time investment. 2. Design. It's difficult to survive the opening few hours without alliances, but only one player can win, so everyone is incentivized to defect at exactly the moment they think they can make greater gains by defecting than by cooperating. Being betrayed, even if you survive, forces a total rethink of strategy and ruins the next hour or two of gameplay.
- legitster 4y ago> An in-person game can last easily 12 hours How are you playing it? We've never had a game run over 4 hours.
- tullianus 4y agoNew players and stretchable diplomacy period length :)
- legitster 4y ago> stretchable diplomacy period length Yuck. I can not stress enough how important a timer is to play Diplomacy in person.
- SamBam 4y agoI've generally heard of people playing over a weekend. So things like meals and sleeping sometimes happen during the negotiation turns.
- mikelevins 4y agoI was a member of an enthusiastic friends-and-family gaming group through the early and middle 1980s. We spent a good chunk of that time on Diplomacy, then moved to modified Diplomacy on custom maps (my first wife worked for USGS Map Sales, and so we had good maps to work with in creating our own Diplomacy maps), and from there we graduated to Nomic. If you think Diplomacy is long and exhausting, wait till you get a load of Nomic with a bunch of enthusiastic players.
- irq-1 4y agoThis? https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/14451/nomic https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/14451/nomic > In the words of Nomic's author, Peter Suber: "Nomic is a game in which changing the rules is a move. In that respect it differs from almost every other game. The primary activity of Nomic is proposing changes in the rules, debating the wisdom of changing them in that way, voting on the changes, deciding what can and cannot be done afterwards, and doing it. Even this core of the game, of course, can be changed."
- mikelevins 4y agoThat’s the one. An intelligent and enthusiastic group of players can extend it indefinitely. It’s all lawyering and deal making, even more than Diplomacy, it can continue for hours and hours, and you dare not leave the room for a second, lest all your carefully worked out dealmaking be washed away in an instant.
- jaylaal 4y agoMany people can't mentally context switch for game and aren't prepared for the behavior that is required of the game from those that can. It's an assault on their world view.
- elijaht 4y agoI would say Diplomacy specifically has features that make it cause hurt feelings almost intrinsically 1. It's a long game- after hours of play, getting doubled crossed unexpectedly sucks because of how much you have invested 2. The game almost purely relies on cooperation/other players. So double crossing someone really screws them- it almost certainly means I have no recource (luck, dice rolls, individual tactics). Getting double crossed feels like you got CRUSHED in such a complete way that I haven't felt in many other games I have played a few times with a few social groups. Most were aware of the point of the game and enthusiastic going in, but even with that, people's feelings got hurt quite a bit. I will say that Risk/Catan don't really cause the same feelings when we play. Diplomacy feels like a whole different level
- irq-1 4y agoUniquely there isn't anything in the game, or on the board, to negotiate other than cooperation. You're not trading corn, or loaning money, or anything. Even "positioning" of pieces doesn't matter because you need allies to do anything, and you'll lose any position without allies; you can't build a fort or get a bonus by holding Indonesia. It's just 'please trust me' and 'please be trustworthy'.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- LanceH 4y agoIn Risk, you're just fighting over limited resources. You largely wage these battles on your own. There is no real negotiation between players, other than an implicit, passing agreement when you don't provoke someone by attacking them. Diplomacy, however, you can't manage any attacks by yourself. You will either depend on someone helping you with an attack/defense, or you will have to trust that someone doesn't attack you as you overcommit. You don't just verbally agree to these things, either. Every turn, players commit to writing what they are doing and all the moves are resolved at once. So a player can go from imagined victory to catastrophic betrayal in the reading of a single order. This means that someone was just lying to their face for 15 minutes. Some people just can't handle that. Oddly, being branded as a backstabber just entices others to try to use that backstabber against what they see as a common enemy. Best game ever. (I only behave like this in game, I swear!)
- ghaff 4y ago>There is no real negotiation between players, other than an implicit, passing agreement when you don't provoke someone by attacking them. It depends how you play. I've seen people make treaties for all sorts of things for various durations, e.g. don't attack from Country X into Country Y and I won't attack across that border either.
- munk-a 4y agoBinding or non-binding treaties? Because in diplomacy everyone is always making non-binding treaties, promises and threats - and that's where the betrayal comes in. I have heard of some people using binding treaties in diplomacy (i.e. three turn ceasefire between France and Prussia) but that has always struck me as a terrible idea because you're shifting moves into the open and things get boring and cliquish.
- ghaff 4y agoI think I've played both ways (or at least played in a group where people didn't break treaties even if they could) but it's been years.
- jgalt212 4y ago> The point of these games is to be a bastard. I guess you never play poker because you don't like to bluff. Or you've never faked a pass in basketball before taking a shot. Or you and the catcher like to announce when you're going to throw a curveball.
- bee_rider 4y agoI’m not sure why you’d guess that, stringing somebody along for hours in Risk and then backstabbing them at the crucial moment seems to at least match your suggestions in terms of duplicity, and is the height of glorious bastarddom.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoIMHO, Risk is one of the few board games worth playing specifically because it's so engaging. Most of my friends who are "into boardgames" tell me that Risk is a terrible game because it starts fights. But the games they want to play bore me to tears. (I can't even read the manual for Settlers of Catan without dying of boredom, but from what you say maybe I should give it another try.)
- spencerflem 4y agoI'm definitely one of those "into boardgames" people so take this all with a grain of salt :p - Risk is definitely a great game and imo people who are into games and don't want to play are saying that because it's 1. long & 2. they've already played it enough to have mostly figured out the strategy Diplomacy is very good and like risk it has very simple rules, grand stakes of world domination, and actual direct conflict. Unlike risk, there's small numbers of units, no luck, and you need an ally, ideally multiple allies, to accomplish anything. If you're looking to get into it I can reccomend text-based turn-a-day style play with strangers on webdiplomacy.com I can only stomach a game of it every year or two because it's legitimately heartbreaking when someone you've spent two months working with every single day stabs you in the back causing you to not lose the game outright but be a crippled angry husk for the next month, and then lose. Tried it with friends once and it was just too much, even with anonymous strangers it hurts. Anyways sorry for the ramble :) go risk, and go diplomacy <3
- fshbbdssbbgdd 4y ago>be a crippled angry husk for the next month, and then lose. Do people resign in diplomacy? Or do you stick around to try to punish the player who backstabbed you?
- thevinter 4y agoIt depends on the players, but for how the game is structured you still have a good chance of "winning" (finishing alive with in a draw) even if you're way underpowered, as long as you're friendly and provide some value
- Someone 4y agoI think the main factors are - Unlike with Risk, Catan or Monopoly, if you lose a game of Diplomacy you can’t blame bad luck, as there is zero luck involved. The only ones you can blame are the other players and yourself. - because it’s multi-player, you can easily get beaten by players that, in your opinion, played weaker than you (“I was doing great until they decided to all go against me”) - There’s no way to really play the game without investing serious attention.
- jgalt212 4y ago> there is zero luck involved I consider decision making under uncertainty well within the purview of luck. There's no luck in tennis, but do I scramble back to the middle of the court, or do I bet my opponent will wrong foot me?
- vintermann 4y agoThis is true, there is emergent chance from being a simultaneous moves game, and from being a game with more than 2 players. You can totally win or lose from luck in Diplomacy.
- vkou 4y agoSettlers of Catan is in many respects not a very good game, because many of its mechanics are zero or negative-sum, with a heavy helping of RNG. This creates a lot of opportunities for kingmaking and spiteful plays from people who are not able to win, but are able to make sure that you lose. And the worst part is that you're often forced into these situations through no fault of your own. Diplomacy allows for all of the same plays, but as the player, you have way more agency about both getting into, and getting out of them. It makes the adversarial alliance-and-dealmaking part first and foremost.
- bee_rider 4y agoI didn’t generally experience that. From what I saw, generally everyone gangs up on the person in the lead, if they are getting close to victory (this seems like a fair and obvious thing to do). So, part of the game is hiding how close you are until nobody can stop you. Hiding your strength is part of pretty much every strategy game with more than 2 players… Is it a perfect game? No. But it is pretty good. And let’s not give Risk and Catan the Seinfeld treatment — sure there are better games… made in response to their perceived deficiencies!
- mattnewton 4y agoDiplomacy is quite a bit different because you 100% win by being the nicest asshole. Past a small mechanical threshold, there really is no way to make it up in strategy or luck, it is only the interpersonal relationships and convincing that wins games. That, coupled with the fact that the game takes a long time and encourages a lot of communication, means the recipe to get invested and blur the boundary between game actions and lies people told you to your face and got you to trust them, can be very unlike risk. Finding out your friends can lie and manipulate you can be like finding out Santa clause isn't real.
- CallMeJim 4y agoWhat!? Santa Clause isn't real?
- mattnewton 4y agoWhoops haha. It is the best Tim Allen movie though.
- yamtaddle 4y agoYou may be surprised that some people play board games assuming some kind of "fair play" or "play with fun in mind" rule is implicit. They may get very pissed off if you "ruin" a game by taking every single advantage you can according to the rules. [EDIT] Risk and Catan also have what are sometimes regarded as straight-up design flaws that can cause "zombie players" who stick around for most/all of the game but, very early on, no longer have any chance of winning. In both cases pretty much the only entertaining thing left to do is to be a prick to other players and try to play "kingmaker" by causing the second-place player to overtake the first-place one. Often, in Catan, if you're that badly screwed you don't really even have a way to do that much. This leaves the zombie player having a pretty bad time just about no matter what, and can leave other players upset if the zombie player stopped playing to win and started playing just to mess with other players. Risk, especially played in the (really, really not great, as much as I liked it when I was 10 years old) world-conquest mode, also has a problem with very long games and early player elimination, in addition to sometimes generating hopelessly-screwed-but-not-technically-out-yet players.
- squeaky-clean 4y agoI've had the inverse happen to me, not playing optimally upsetting someone. Playing the DC superhero deck-building game at a card shop with some friends and a stranger asked to join, he already knew how to play. Well I didn't stop another player from getting one of the final Power Ring cards and he flipped the F!&%$ out. "How could you not block her! She's guaranteed to win on her next turn now! You suck at this game!" Bro, I'm just trying to power up my batman. It's not a very competitive game. Needless to say we asked him not to join in our next round, "that's fine, I don't want to play with a bunch of noobs."
- yamtaddle 4y ago> Well I didn't stop another player from getting one of the final Power Ring cards and he flipped the F!&%$ out. "How could you not block her! She's guaranteed to win on her next turn now! You suck at this game!" Bro, I'm just trying to power up my batman. It's not a very competitive game. Ohhhhh yeah, there's "expert" players who hate when others don't play "correctly". You even see it in poker with pros getting really mad when someone wins with an "incorrect" play (among actual pros this can be a sign of cheating, but some of them still get mad when non-pros do it). Some of these like to try to "puppet" other players into doing the right thing, and my god, just... please don't. A helpful pointer or three after a play or after the game is great. The odd "uh oh, if so-and-so gets X on their next turn, it's all over!" said to no one in particular can be OK in many games. Telling people what to do while they're playing, more than very occasionally, is awful though. I do kinda get it, it can be frustrating when you play with someone who gives the game to another player who shouldn't have won on that turn if the other'd made the obviously-correct play, but that's just part of playing a game with a mixed-skill set of players and you gotta roll with it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- squeaky-clean 4y agoDifferent players have different mental "lines that shouldn't be crossed". I play Civ 6 cloud games with friends from college who now live around the world. (No turn timer, you get a Steam notification when it's your turn). Sometimes someone will spend literal weeks on a turn trying to make agreements for war declarations or for world-congress votes. The time that crossed the line: Poland wanted to declare war on Greece, no one else wanted to get involved on either side, and it was a pretty even match between them. A friend not involved in this game was visiting family in the same city as the Greece-player, so we knew he'd be dropping by to visit him too. Poland-player told the "neutral" friend: if Greece-player shows you his civ game, take a picture of the screen when he's not looking and message it to Poland-player. Well he did it, Poland declared war, and his knowledge of the position of troops lead to him winning the war. "How did you know I didn't have any troops in my southern cities?" And Poland told him how he knew. It didn't end the friendship but there was about a month of not talking to any of us. When he cooled down there was a long meeting over whether that was cheating or "All is fair in Love and Civ". We could never come to a real agreement, 3 in favor of cheating, 3 in favor of dastardly but legal. But we now have an explicit rule of no screen sharing of any kind.
- bee_rider 4y agoI mean that’s clearly cheating, not worth blowing up a relationship over but still annoying.
- petemir 4y agoClearly cheating? I would call it classic espionage
- smeej 4y agoWe played a live-action version of Diplomacy in my high school mock UN club. Each person was part of a team and had a role. I was the Chancellor of Germany. If an assassin from another team was able to get alone with me, without any of my countrymen, and show me a card saying she was an assassin, the Chancellor of Germany would be killed during the weekly meeting and, not having a Chancellor, not get to make any moves on the board for that week's turn. They would instead be distracted by determining the new Chancellor. If the assassin had been caught, her country's treachery would be revealed, cementing any of their opponents in alliance. It was an awfully fun thing to be doing on the side, between classes and during free periods, but it'd be wildly impractical in an environment with less proximity! Our mock UN group was weirder than I realized at the time. Our faculty advisor requires that we each speak in one of the 6 languages of the UN likely to be spoken by whatever country we were representing, and he'd simultranslate into English. Somehow it didn't occur to me at the time to ask why a suburban physics teacher was fluent in those six languages.
- whartung 4y agoYea, it's one thing to drop a SORRY card on your wife. It's another to lie to her for 2 solid hours and then stab her in the back in the end, expected or not.
- permalac 4y agoI'm with bee_rider, the point of the games is what you just said, so why so surprised?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- georgeecollins 4y agoTo be good you really have to build someone's trust and then break it. That's the thing-- people think well if we all go in not trusting each other, who is going to be mad? To be good at that game is to be able to get a friend or a stranger to really trust you.
- joe_the_user 4y agoI agree with the gp and the other responders that however much other games might seem like they involve "being a bastard", Diplomacy is entirely another level. Describing exactly how is the challenge. Let me try: The games' mechanic mean that everyone is just fighting for territory, those who intelligently cooperate will defeat others. So in this situation, the most effective strategy is cooperating intelligently early in the game and betraying your allies mid-game. The insidious thing about the situation is that if you're playing among friends, the natural way to cooperate to leverage the trust you already have with your friends. And so what any winner does is be themselves, use the rapport they have with their to get cooperation but be just a little less trustworthy than their friends expect. That is where the tendency to break friendships appears.
- vintermann 4y agoI don't play those games much, because they tend to spill out into the next game/real world. It's not that someone will feel betrayed and have hurt feelings, it's that it's a perfectly sensible strategy to have the next game in mind, or to involve existing real-world relationships. I prefer games that are over when they're over. That said, when I have played such games, because my group wanted to play them, I've had a policy of just not lying or making promises. I may say things like "that doesn't seem like it would benefit me does it, because then B will surely just toss me out of the lifeboat next turn", and of course NOT speak up when someone makes a wrong assumption to my benefit. It feels like I've won more than my fair share of those games still.