12 ms·
This is a good case for why system bots/messages/etc. shouldn't be given regular names (and perhaps distinguished through other means too); if the error was ins
by userbinator 4y ago
This is a good case for why system bots/messages/etc. shouldn't be given regular names (and perhaps distinguished through other means too); if the error was instead "Username cannot contain 'discord'", it'd be more obvious.
- jameshart 4y agoThis of course rests on the assumption that there is such a thing as a 'regular name'. I'm obliged to link you to 'falsehoods programmers believe about names' now. I'm not happy about it, but those are the rules. https://www.kalzumeus.com/2010/06/17/falsehoods-programmers-believe-about-names/ https://www.kalzumeus.com/2010/06/17/falsehoods-programmers-...
- userbinator 4y agoThere are certainly far more Clydes than there are Discords (has anyone even been legally named Discord before?) I'm not happy about it, but those are the rules. ..."then change them", as someone might say. But that article seems to be mostly about the edge-cases. I don't think someone named Clyde is an edge-case, nor would someone named Bonnie, for that matter.
- jameshart 4y agoSo I perhaps should have been more clear. If your plan in choosing a name for your bot is to choose one that won't collide with a human, you are going to run into the fact that humans have a lot of very different names. Hence the link to the 'falsehoods' piece. The US Census of 1950, for example, has a lot of Descords, Descards, Dicords, Dioscords, and... in PA, a Rosa B Discord, in NYC, a Mr Discord. In general, all I'm saying is, it is far better if your intention is to allow people to choose their name, to not put any arbitrary restriction in place with the justification that 'it probably won't affect anyone'. If there's one thing people really care about it's their name. And no matter how unlikely you think it is that someone will run into your restriction... you're almost certainly wrong.
- Cyberdog 4y ago> (has anyone even been legally named Discord before?) In this post-Brony society, I’m sure of it. (Discord was the name of the villain on the show… I think. Never seen more than half an episode myself.)
- Izkata 4y ago> has anyone even been legally named Discord before? There was a Roman goddess named Discordia (where "discord" came from), and in the 90s Hercules and Xena TV series the Greek goddess used that Roman name instead of Eris, but simplified to just Discord. Those two series were pretty popular, so I can see it being more likely recently than in that 1950s census sibling comment found. On the flipside, that character is probably not something parents would want for their daughter.
- bcrosby95 4y agoThat's why I name my bots "A" and just ban any username with "a" in it. If you can't get it 100% right, fuck it, do whatever you want.
- saagarjha 4y ago:(
- giraffe_lady 4y agoThere's not exactly a list of canonical human names per se, but "bots can't use human names" would still be a very sensible rule for us to have. Put the cost and the burden on companies making bots, not on individual people who got unlucky. Also names are part of human culture, and Alexa for example has been in use for a very long time. There are valid reasons for names to die off in a single generation (eg adolf) but this is not a reason that our culture gains anything from imo.
- Dylan16807 4y agoWe can put bounds on it. Here's an easy lower bound, for the context of avoiding collisions: The name has to have been used by at least two different humans. Or to get closer to a reasonable bound, 100 humans.
- BlueTemplar 4y agoHow would you know how much it has been used ? We don't even have a database for all the humans alive today, much less one for the last 400 000 years...
- Dylan16807 4y agoYou can be pretty confident without a comprehensive database. If you're unsure about a name then don't pick that one. And people that are dead won't be inconvenienced, so you can ignore them.
- jodrellblank 4y agoPeople (and lawyers) might get annoyed if you called your bot Avici, even though he is dead and won’t personally be inconvenienced by it.
- Dylan16807 4y agoNaming something after a celebrity is a different issue entirely. It's actually a bigger problem if the celebrity has a non-regular name!
- slg 4y agoI feel bad for all the Alexas and the few Siris out there that have had their names hijacked my a couple of the biggest companies on the planet.
- eadler 4y agoreminds me of https://globalnews.ca/news/3311903/woman-named-alexa-seary-says-its-an-ironic-coincidence-she-has-same-names-as-amazon-apple-bots/ https://globalnews.ca/news/3311903/woman-named-alexa-seary-s...
- rabuse 4y agoI know an Alexa. She hates it.
- kokocute 4y agoThe only assistant not to be paired with another word as well.
- wlesieutre 4y agoApple is reportedly planning to remove "hey" from their wake word
- sohkamyung 4y ago"Seriously?" - sorry, but Siri does not understand the word "ously". [ "Siri - ously" ] Bad pun, I know. :-)
- isomorphic 4y agoI have a dreary theory of which Siri is leery. (I'm available for QA testing.)
- wincy 4y agoI hope not, my daughters name just happens to have syllables similar but not the same as “siri” in her name and calling her name sets it off ALL THE TIME.
- hn92726819 4y ago> This is a good case for why system bots/messages/etc. shouldn't be given regular names I disagree. The username can be clyde_discord/clyde_bot and the display name could just be "Clyde". Then the username Clyde wouldn't be taken, and the users would be able to still message the bot and not be confused. Though I personally really dislike simple human names for bots because it sounds cheesy and dumb.
- judge2020 4y agoIt's not about the username being taken, it's all about what people appear as in the client; bots and scammers might impersonate Clyde to steal credentials, social engineer, etc, so you cannot be "Clyde_help" nor "Clyde_Official" nor any variation that would make people think the bot/user is speaking on behalf of Discord.
- JauntyHatAngle 4y agoWhich is funny when you take into account that people are still using special characters to get a Clyde name that mostly resembles it. I question the effectiveness.
- saghm 4y agoWhy not just put a special logo or symbol or something on that profile to mark it as special/official, or have some sort of "user type" displayed that says "human" or "official bot" or "third party bot"? I feel like making it look like a regular username makes it _more_ likely people will be scammed by "other" regular users rather than less likely.
- kuschku 4y agoFor example, like a blue checkmark after the nick for users who are genuinely who they say they are?
- Martinussen 4y agoDiscord already does this - they just don't trust average users to be aware enough to check. (Based on my experience moderating some discords, they aren't wrong.)
- Thorrez 4y agoAmazon: Alexa Microsoft: Cortana Apple: Siri Discord: Clyde Google: Google Disclosure, I work at Google.
- boxed 4y agoWritten like that Google suddenly looks like geniuses.
- causi 4y agoAt least in the naming, sure. Everything else, not so much. I had to switch my whole house over to Echos because you can't change the wake word on Google Home. Every time I said, say, "Hey Google, turn the bedroom lamp off", the Home in the bedroom would say ok and turn the lamp off, both phones in the room would activate and complain that they didn't have a device named lamp listed, and every other Home in the house would start talking about how it couldn't hear me clearly. Then you yell "Hey Google, shut the fuck up!" and the blasted things start whining about how they "have feelings too" and I shouldn't be so rude. Few technological problems have made my fingers ache more for a sledgehammer.
- davidmurdoch 4y agoYou have to make sure the phones use the same Google (family) account as the Home.
- myself248 4y agoWere these devices given to you, or did you buy them?
- causi 4y agoA mix of both for the Google Home devices. The Echo dots I got on a black friday for like ten bucks a piece.
- bobsmooth 4y agoYou can't change the wake word because a separate, dedicated chip is listening for it and is not connected to the rest of the device except to wake up the main processor.
- blowski 4y agoGizmoduck back in the 80s had this worked out. His bot invocation was "Blathering Blathernsikes".
- fsniper 4y agoOh at first with my cafein lacking early morning brain, I mistakenly parsed it as "Developers should not be able to call their bots regular names". But it's nothing to the bot's name but how it's registered on the system right? So the suggestion is, the username should be discernible from platform users usernames.