8 ms·
How can you not be romantic about programming? (2020)
- npalli 4y agoGreat article, however the Roger Sterling character quote from Mad Men popped into my head "My father used to say this is the greatest job in the world except for one thing — the clients." or if you are internally focused and not directly dealing with clients - "My father used to say this is the greatest job in the world except for one thing — the Managers".
- jvm___ 4y agoWhat things in the room with you right now WEREN'T made by using code or programming of some sort. Vynil albums, the carpet in my 80's house. Not much else.
- daveguy 4y agoAnd you know vinyl made after about the 90s was also made using code. (90s is a WAG, but I'm guessing it's -/+ 1 decade)
- jvm___ 4y agoIt's my Dad's 60-70's record collection, probably early 80's at the latest.
- daveguy 4y agoOh, I bet that is a beautiful collection. What a prime time to be collecting vinyl. You're probably right about early 80s switch to digital. Although probably a mixed bag for at least a decade as old instrumentation hung around.
- Jalad 4y agoIn the same style as the article I want to praise the gods of computer programming, who walk amongst us mortals. People who were visionaries, and move the field forward when the rest of us futz around with CRUD apps. People like Linus Torvalds, Dennis Ritchie, Stroustrup, Donald Knuth, and hundreds more. By them, I am humbled and inspired. And we can't forget the wars of epic proportions: the Unix wars, and fights with Microsoft & Oracle, and the birth of the free software movement. All of these shaped the current software landscape. There's also so much to be said about the research labs where it all started... Indeed, how can you not be romantic about programming
- waltbosz 4y ago> when the rest of us futz around with CRUD apps Isn't this so demoralizing, to be working for some company writing boring business apps. I want to be a visionary. I have these Grace Hopper-esque ideas for how to advance developer experience. Some examples: 1. Reading code is so complicated. 1.a. It's been 20 years since I first experienced the joy of syntax highlighting, and it feels like nothing has changed since that leap forward in coder ergonomics. We just have different colors for different bits of code, but computers can easily draw so much more than colored text. Shapes, pictures. 1.b. There are so many different ways to write the same instructions. Different developers have different opinions of what constitutes correctly formatted code. I want tools to deconstruct and reformat code into more easily readable pieces. Really what I want is visual representations of code flow. 2. IDEs have coding auto-complete, but it's wonky. It feels like I'm in my kitchen and open a drawer to get a fork, and in the drawer is every kind of utensil ever invented by man spills out. I'm not convinced that AI assisted coding tools are the correct path forward. ... Perhaps this rant is just my ignorance of what tools are out there. I have to admit my experience is Visual Studio and VSCode and SSMS (don't get me started on SSMS). I haven't had much opportunity to explore what else is out there.
- wankle 4y agoI'm romantic about achieving things with programming more than programming for the sake of programming these days.
- oc_elder 4y agoGet old.
- thwayunion 4y agoIf you keep getting old eventually you might have a kid and then you get to re-experience the wonder of early life through your child's eyes :)
- _8j50 4y ago"This is our world now. The world of the electron and the switch; the beauty of the baud. We exist without nationality, skin color, or religious bias. You wage wars, murder, cheat, lie to us and try to make us believe it's for our own good, yet we're the criminals. Yes, I am a criminal. My crime is that of curiosity. I am a hacker, and this is my manifesto." Huh? Right? Manifesto? "You may stop me, but you can't stop us all." Yup, romantic.
- mindcrime 4y ago"That's cool" "That's not cool. That's commie bullshit"
- rg111 4y agoWhere is this from?
- pabs3 4y agohttps://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Hacker_Manifesto https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Hacker_Manifesto
- account42 4y agoThis exact quote (with the "Huh? Right? Manifesto?" bit) as well as mindcrime's reply is from the 1995 movie "Hackers" [0] which, while full of hollywood absurdity, has a touch of more "real" references like the quoted manifesto that give it a nice charm. "Yeah. RISC is good." [0] https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0113243/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0113243/
- zabzonk 4y ago> We don't call them instructions. Oh yes we do, or at least I do. And I can't find instructing an electronic shelf-stacker romantic
- Smaug123 4y agoBut it's a rock that we tricked into thinking! An electronic shelf-stacker is almost literally the starting premise of The Sorcerer's Apprentice!
- JackFr 4y ago“The programmer, like the poet, works only slightly removed from pure thought-stuff. He builds his castles in the air, from air, creating by exertion of the imagination.” RIP Frederick Brooks
- kieckerjan 4y ago"Writing computer software is one of the purest creative activities in the history of the human race. Programmers aren't bound by practical limitations such as the laws of physics; we can create exciting virtual worlds with behaviors that could never exist in the real world. Programming doesn't require great physical skill or coordination, like ballet or basketball. All programming requires is a creative mind and the ability to organize your thoughts." John Ousterhout
- giraffe_lady 4y agoI'm more cap R Romantic I guess. I center myself on my relationships to nature, the universe, human connection. Computers and the code they run are as romantic as a pencil: I can focus on it and where it came from, what went into it, what it can do and I can feel awe at what we've achieved together and what we can accomplish with the products of that. But I don't feel any particular way about the pencil itself, nor more deeply connected to the things I really value for having contemplated it.
- 63 4y ago``I think that it's extraordinarily important that we in computer science keep fun in computing. When it started out, it was an awful lot of fun. Of course, the paying customers got shafted every now and then, and after a while we began to take their complaints seriously. We began to feel as if we really were responsible for the successful, error-free perfect use of these machines. I don't think we are. I think we're responsible for stretching them, setting them off in new directions, and keeping fun in the house. I hope the field of computer science never loses its sense of fun. Above all, I hope we don't become missionaries. Don't feel as if you're Bible salesmen. The world has too many of those already. What you know about computing other people will learn. Don't feel as if the key to successful computing is only in your hands. What's in your hands, I think and hope, is intelligence: the ability to see the machine as more than when you were first led up to it, that you can make it more.'' Alan J. Perlis (April 1, 1922-February 7, 1990) As quoted in the dedication of SICP, aka the wizard book[0]. [0] https://mitp-content-server.mit.edu/books/content/sectbyfn/books_pres_0/6515/sicp.zip/full-text/book/book-Z-H-3.html https://mitp-content-server.mit.edu/books/content/sectbyfn/b...
- zacmps 4y agoUnfortunately, I think this attitude is irresponsible. So many people's lives rely directly on software in one way or another that we shouldn't treat it so whimsically. That's not to say that the practise can't be fun, but just like building a bridge we need to make sure it works.
- kortilla 4y agoMost people aren’t building bridges though. Most people are building software that just assists some business process. That absolutely does not need the same rigor as building a bridge.
- zozbot234 4y agoThere was once a programmer who was attached to the court of the warlord of Wu. The warlord asked the programmer: "Which is easier to design: an accounting package or an operating system?" "An operating system," replied the programmer. The warlord uttered an exclamation of disbelief. "Surely an accounting package is trivial next to the complexity of an operating system," he said. "Not so," said the programmer, "When designing an accounting package, the programmer operates as a mediator between people having different ideas: how it must operate, how its reports must appear, and how it must conform to the tax laws. By contrast, an operating system is not limited by outside appearances. When designing an operating system, the programmer seeks the simplest harmony between machine and ideas. This is why an operating system is easier to design." The warlord of Wu nodded and smiled. "That is all good and well, but which is easier to debug?" The programmer made no reply.
- blueflow 4y agoBecause you gotta work with other people's code at some point or another. And much of it is unreliable, buggy and/or badly documented. I hate guessing parameters for a API call, i hate debugging the garbage that my coworker installed from Github, i hate learning into some software and having it obsoleted within two years and i hate fixing the CI/deployments. I love writing bare-metal code for the 8086 or AVR, because these platforms and their peripheral chips are well documented. I love platforms with formal standards and good documentation like C or shell script. But this isn't always useful these days.
- ofrzeta 4y ago> Because you gotta work with other people's code at some point or another. And much of it is unreliable, buggy and/or badly documented. Blaming others is fine but really sometimes that "other people" is yourself and often you barely remember that you wrote it.
- blueflow 4y ago> often you barely remember that you wrote it Yes, exactly. My memory is extraordinarily crappy, another reason for me to invest time into writing documentation.
- Digit-Al 4y ago“Always code as if the guy who ends up maintaining your code will be a violent psychopath who knows where you live” - John Woods I have a terrible memory. Sometimes I'll look at code I wrote ages ago and think "Wow! I really did a good job here.". Other times I'll think "Wow! What the hell was I thinking?" lol
- vsareto 4y agoSome people can maintain the complex code they write but might be viewed as spaghetti to someone else. You can't trust always trust someone's call when they say code is unmaintainable.
- dkarl 4y ago
- layer8 4y ago> Instructions are “like a sorcerer’s spells”. We should replace all use of “invocation” by “incantation”. It somehow feels right,
- CoolestBeans 4y agoTo use another sports example, I watched "The Last Dance" recently. There's footage of Dennis Rodman working out and he says to the camera, "Its not just basketball we have to deal with on this team... Its the pressure of the bullshit. I'll play the game for free. You get paid for the bullshit after. Basketball is a simple game, but when you leave this confined zone. Its hard."[1] That's why people get disenchanted with programming (and with a lot of other things)! We love to do the actual core activity. We love it so much we do it for free. You get paid for having to deal with the pressure to succeed. And you get paid for having to do all the other stuff that comes along with it. Its the other stuff that grates on you until you hate it. [1] https://youtu.be/-Ythtg8ZVbY?t=166 https://youtu.be/-Ythtg8ZVbY?t=166
- jason-phillips 4y ago> We love it so much we do it for free. Absolutely. I would have worked for SpaceX if they let me sleep in a hanger, they wouldn't have to pay me. I would work for free for a company making widgets for which people paid cash money if they let me work on interesting problems, interfacing with my customers, so as to see the fruits of my labor pay off. Happiness isn't always derived from that which our society says it should be.
- amelius 4y agoPeople forget that even without salary an employee still costs quite a lot of money.
- nicbou 4y agoDefinitely. I got to experience programming before and after doing it professionally. My passion for it left, then returned as quickly as it left. I always loved programming, but doing it professionally just wasn't the same.
- Maphistow 4y agoWhat did you do after coding?
- ge96 4y agoI love being part of it. My fear is losing it but I suppose even in a not well off place, there will be a computer somewhere I can use and work on. I just like tinkering, making things. Seeing it go.
- Chinjut 4y agoThere's writing code that you want to write, code you find interesting to do something you care about. And then there's writing code that somebody else tells you to write, that you have to do for a job. Those are different things. I'd imagine most of us started off spending lots of time on the former, and now instead spend most of our time on the latter.
- zwkrt 4y agoI read the article and I still can’t help mis-parsing the headline. The author meant “programming is a romantic activity”. I read “how can we overcome romanticizing programming?” Maybe it’s just my perspective. I used to be in love with programming. But doing something I loved as a job left me open to burnout and vulnerable to being used. Now I’m not “in love” with programming. Partially because it doesn’t intrigue and surprise me like a new lover does. We have a comfortable relationship, we’ve settled down. I’m married to programming and it’s work but it’s worth it. There’s still fun and fulfillment, but I’m not infatuated like I used to be.
- chasil 4y agoI have written some beautiful code. I am dwarfed by what was written before 1970 in moving products through our plant. They knew assembler, hard and were before everything we now know. I am in awe of them, my predecessors, who are long past.
- jsrcout 4y agoThe following text, alleged to come from either one of the Zork games or possibly the original Adventure, brings me back to the original romance of programming I felt years ago. Reminds me of all-nighters with my classmates in college, death march projects back at my first job, and so much more. I wanted to be one of the Implementers. *Not one of the headless ones... Tomb of the Unknown Implementer This is the Tomb of the Unknown Implementer. A hollow voice says: "That's not a bug, it's a feature!" In the north wall of the room is the Crypt of the Implementers. It is made of the finest marble, and apparently large enough for four headless corpses. The crypt is closed. There are four heads here, mounted securely on poles. There is a large pile of empty Coke bottles here, evidently produced by the implementers during their long struggle to win totality. There is a gigantic pile of line-printer output here. Although the paper once contained useful information, almost nothing can be distinguished now.
- WesolyKubeczek 4y agoBy being so tired that I can be barely romantic about anything at all, it appears. By software products being so invariably lousy that I can’t help but feel that this was a papercut #999. By „platforms”, „ecosystems”, „communities” pulling the user experience each their own way, destroying it into shreds in the process. I want to be romantic about programming, I’m just too jaded, tired, and numb.
- TurboHaskal 4y agoLove programming. Never let your boss see you smile while at it.
- nonrandomstring 4y agoI think there is a lot of romanticism in computing because there is a lot of irrationality. We don't like to admit that. We pretend to be "scientists". Irrationality is as much the engine of progress as reason. Both can be directed toward good or evil ends. Ada Lovelace saw one romantic side of computing as the possibility of machines writing poetry, music and song. Today as much fear, horror and loathing as joy surrounds that idea - but that is also romantic in Mary Shelley's sense. Big-R Romantic features are in both; possibility, drama, tragedy, and rejection of reason according to a counter-enlightenment embrace of emotivism. Ours is the age of impossibility - the hopeless inevitability of the status-quo, the lack of vision for alternative systems, amidst a grinding project to render all human affairs predictable, legible, identifiable, and controlled. Today "computer love" (the romance in computing) derives from the struggle to overcome the ignorant, cowering bureaucracy to which lesser men put machines in pursuit of mediocrity and dull power.
- Maphistow 4y agoNicely put
- avg_dev 4y agoi could not disagree more. simply put: code is language. language in textual form is writing. writing is art. code is art. that is all
- nonrandomstring 4y ago> i could not disagree more. I'd have liked it if you had tried.
- nikanj 4y agoHow? Because I spent 12 hours yesterday wrestling with ESM loader issues and trying to get some basic Typescript running. Programming sound romantic in theory, but in practice it's a messy, nasty business that breaks people. Kinda like parenthood, actually.
- Tade0 4y agoTo be fair the transition to ESM has been quite the trainwreck. Sometimes I wonder if it was really worth it. Parenthood didn't brake me for one. Actually, I found strength I didn't know I had and my priorities went into sharp focus.
- dvh 4y agoJust a correction. The fat guy wasn't from his team, he was from some other team. And he didn't fall, he jumped down onto the first base because that's what he was only barely able to do, he knew that in the best case scenario he only have like 50% chance for the first base because he run so slow. So basically his tactic was: if I run as fast as I can I have 40% to reach first base. If I run as fast as I can and jump I have 50% to reach first base. He didn't even consider going to second base, ever. Moneyball is great movie, go watch it.
- cortesoft 4y agoAnother correction: it would be “game winning runs”, not “game winning points”
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- osrec 4y agoStrangely, I just finished watching Moneyball about a minute ago, open HN, and see this quote from the film! That was an unbelievable coincidence!
- amelius 4y agoBecause it is not a performance art.
- afr0ck 4y ago> Others are the golden threads of this world, holding it together at the seams with no more than a dozen people knowing about it This is literally __alloc_pages() in the Linux kernel.
- avg_dev 4y agoplease go on... would enjoy hearing more.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- afr0ck 4y agoThat function is the heart of the page allocator inside the Linux kernel [1]. The fundamental building block for every memory allocation on any system (running on Linux). Whether you call malloc() in a C program, kmalloc() inside a kernel driver, the new operator in C++, load a file in python, or almost any other operation, it will ultimately end up in __alloc_pages() (for small objects, multiple units will share a single __alloc_pages(), then there is a fine grain object manager on top of that such as Slab/Slub, jcmalloc, tcmalloc, mimalloc, etc. but you got the point). [1] https://github.com/torvalds/linux/blob/c3eb11fbb826879be773c137f281569efce67aa8/mm/page_alloc.c#L5519 https://github.com/torvalds/linux/blob/c3eb11fbb826879be773c...
- avg_dev 4y agovery cool. i recall in one of my classes at unversity (i did a compsci degree) we used nachos (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_Another_Completely_Heuristic_Operating_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_Another_Completely_Heurist...) and i have vague memories of implementing some kind of virtual memory system with a page table. i also did a microkernel message-passing rtos for the i386 in another class but if i recall correctly, that particular os didn't have to support dynamic allocation (or maybe i have forgotten - it was a long time ago). i am not sure how useful such a limited system would be in practice. thanks for the information. i am a high level programmer by trade these days, but given enough free time, i think that it would be fun to learn about the internals of the linux kernel in some depth. frankly, it intimidates me a bit (perhaps it should, im not sure).
- einpoklum 4y ago> How can you not be romantic about programming? 1. Read the code I have to work on at the office. 2. Sit through a meeting with my boss. Guaranteed to leave your spirit romance-free.
- draw_down 4y ago
- gumby 4y agoI love this. Programming is so much fun. Even when my work means I don't program for work any more (which inevitably happens) I continue to do so recreationally. I'm really sad for people who chose the field just for the money and are miserable about programming. I hope it works out for them, but that's no way to live.
- the_only_law 4y agoI didn’t enter this field for money, but it’s the only thing keeping me in it
- gumby 4y agoI'm sorry to hear that. Good luck.
- the_only_law 4y agoBecause I’m not deluded enough anymore.
- TheCapn 4y agoThe final two paragraphs once again remind me of the Programming Sucks[1] Blog entry I've reread several times. It's almost mood dependent whether I look upon on the systems we've created or in fondness or in anxious peril. I still love this career, but with some recent burnout occurring I often find myself quipping "Technology was a mistake". There's absolute beauty in code. There's also absolute despair at times. I wonder if things will ever become more rote or structured in my lifetime, or will we be constantly pushing the envelope, hardly looking back and just barrelling ahead, pitfalls and all [1] https://www.stilldrinking.org/programming-sucks
- 2-718-281-828 4y agoI am romantic about it - all the classics I read - the first program in C, in Assembler, in JavaScript, PHP, Perl, Python - Charles Petzold, Stroustroup, Larry Wall - discovering procedural, declarative, object oriented, functional for the first time - setting up vim, working from the command line - gets me almost sentimental - and yet, I lost the passion, lost the drive, feeling burned out after years in the industry. I really hope I'll manage to reignite that fire. After all it's the only thing I'm moderately good at and I need to earn money to pay my bills after all. Working in the industry was only rarely living up to the sentimental romanticism you dream up as a youngster fiddling away in your past time after school. I'm working on it to stay positive - meditation is my personal defragmentation tool (those days when you could look windows - wasn't using Linux back then - over the shoulders organizing those colorful tiles - those were the days - when PC magazines came with CDs and funny programs on it). I'm not old yet really. I will have my come back. I'll show all of you. I know, I'm more than just a code monkey.
- waltbosz 4y agoI've been burnt out from work. I lost interest in coding because I spent so much time coding for a job that made me so unhappy. I've been able to rekindle my passion for coding by finding personal projects to work on. I like to build utility apps, or screensaver-like art experiments. It's fun to learn something new. I once wrote a art project using CSS transitions, then rewrote it using a Canvas element. It was interesting to see the way coding was different in each situation. I never realized how much heavy lifting the web browser's CSS engine does until I tried to crossfade a colored square in a Canvas. Also: Are you old enough to remember magazines with printed source code that you would have to type in manually? I remember finding them in my parent's basement among their science fiction literature magazines.
- 2-718-281-828 4y agoAs a matter of fact I wrote articles like that myself for a German computer magazine. Mostly Perl and ... oh, such fond memories ... VRML.
- uni_rule 4y agoIt is romantic to pursue a hobby for the sake of it. That said, work is not romantic. All you did is fuck up a good hobby, look at it, it's got deadlines. Is that worth it? Probably, it makes a decent living, but work ain't romantic.