18 ms·
'It's like living in an igloo' People are turning off their heat as prices surge
- nnoitra 4y ago
- sokoloff 4y agoThe prospects of higher fuel prices and a $1600 rebate from our gas supplier (MA, USA) helped me to decide to replace our ancient boiler (1950s oil, later converted to single-stage 200MBTUH gas) with a modern modcon combination boiler. I haven’t compared degree-days of last year vs this year, but by the gas meter, through yesterday we’re using 40% of (60% less) on per-day basis as compared to last year. It was many thousands out of pocket, but if the 40% holds up, it will pay back in about five years. (Our old system was dark-comically inefficient though. For most 80-ish% cast iron boilers, it doesn’t make economic sense to replace with a [theoretical max] 95% mod-con if the old one is still reliable.)
- ricardobayes 4y agoI wish we could buy US-style furnaces and AC units. European combi boilers seem to give up the ghost after 10-ish years, regardless of manufacturer. You are very lucky to get 15 years out of any one without major issues. Planned obsolence maybe?
- bluedino 4y agoIt's easy to buy a junk furnace in the USA. Even the good brands have begun to make low-end units with only five year warranties and few serviceable parts.
- sokoloff 4y agoMine is a Bosch, assembled in South Korea. From my research, these seem more common in UK and EU than over here. It was also only $2550 for the boiler (much more for the trim, labor, pipes, pumps, etc., but the boiler itself was cheap). That was cheap enough that I considered buying an entire second one to just put on the shelf for the eventual need to replace it or replace major parts. I decided not to as the space required is probably more valuable than having a whole shelf in the utility room tied up for 10-15 years.
- flowerbreeze 4y agoIs it because less heat escapes from the boiler or the burning is more efficient?
- maxerickson 4y agoThe old burner likely achieved ~100% combustion (not sure what you mean by the burning being efficient). As to the other part, yes, less heat is sent up the chimney in modern designs. My boiler is getting pretty old but was sold as 80% efficient. As far as I can tell, the near drop in replacement would be 84 or 85%. Neither is a modern condensing boiler (which I'd have to figure out a new exhaust to switch and probably add active outside air exchange; tempting with the way the current one sucks all the humidity out of the house).
- sokoloff 4y agoThe overall burning cycle is more efficient. Even with tuning, my old boiler was putting out well over 200ppm CO (down from 2500/off-scale when they first tested it). That’s one source of inefficiency of getting BTUs of heat out of the gas and into the water. As a sibling mentioned, it was also sending 450+°F vapor-laden exhaust up the chimney and out the roof. New boiler vents through plastic pipe and extracts so much more of the heat that the exhaust is leaving the boiler at around 150°F with the water vapor largely condensed (at least this time of year) and giving up that latent heat of vaporization to the water incoming to the boiler. Additionally, it pulls combustion air from outside instead of the basement. (If you pull combustion air from the basement an equal amount of outside air must leak into the house to replace it.) New boiler also has a modulating gas valve and can burn in 5 steps between 25K BTU/hr and 149K BTU/hr (from memory, but close enough) to match the space heating demand. The old one was either 0 or 200K BTU/hr. I probably went from 60% to 95% now plus the effects of not pulling millions of cubic feet of outside air in per year. The computer controls on this one (and the ability of the boiler to not just tolerate but encourage condensation) mean I can heat my house at 32°F/0°C with 114°F/45°C supply water temps. Traditional boilers are harmed by acidic condensation so need return temps of 140°F which means supply temps of 160°F. That means hotter rads and pipes and more losses in the piping. As it gets colder, the boiler can compensate (via an outdoor sensor) and increase the flow temp so it’s just enough to heat the house. Based on 114°F flow (about 90-95°F return) being enough for 32°F, I'm virtually certain that I'll be operating in condensing mode (return under 120°F) even on the coldest nights we get here or if not, on all but one or two nights. I have pump controls that can run the pumps for a bit after the zone and burner shuts off to put that (much smaller amount) of trapped heat into the living space rather than leaving it trapped in a massive hunk of cast iron to leak to the boiler room. It’s a lot of small and medium effects.
- rightbyte 4y ago"With help from her son, Johnson just paid more than $1,000 to fill part of her oil tank, which she hopes will last her most of the winter." ... I see your problem right there. I see a common pattern where I live where senior neighbours refuse to buy heat pumps even though the payback is measured in years.
- tamaharbor 4y agoPerhaps older oil-fueled steam or hot water boiler systems cannot be easily retrofitted to use a heat pump? Just a thought.
- fl0id 4y agoGenerally I think with the cheaper ones, you just use the heatpump instead. Without the old pipes.
- jleyank 4y agoA house built in 1987 in Massachusetts didn’t have air ducts as oil heating didn’t require it. Messy as all get out trying to get a heat pump installed. All of those kinds of places (“where a/c wasn’t needed”) suggest the need for replacement housing which is blindingly expensive.
- 0x53 4y agoI think we will probably see a lot of minisplit type heat pumps being installed in the coming years. In addition to being easy to retrofit, they have really high efficiency ratings (20+ seer).
- rightbyte 4y agoYou get a better heat pump setup with old water pipe radiators really than electric radiators. A water-water heat pump with a drilled hole. But it is more expansive than air to air heat pumps.
- bad_alloc 4y agoCommon issues you face when getting a heat pump: * Few suitable places to install it * Lack of qualified workers to install it * Limited availiability of heatpumps * Conventional heaters do not work well with heat pumps. Floor heating is preferred and also not easy or cheap to do * Not enouch capital to finance it, despite it making economic sense. I got one, it's great and they should replace oil and gas heating for sure. But these problems can keep people away from them.
- isoprophlex 4y agoThe article opens with a +18% increase in heating prices, and talks about the problems people have with paying their heating bills. Meanwhile, in the Netherlands, gas prices went from 0.70-0.80 eur/m3 to 3.50-4.00 eur/m3 I spoke to someone at the collections department of a utility company. They expect total carnage as people start to skip on paying their bills. Government support notwithstanding, the coming winter will be hell. People on or below the median income will be hurt by the coming 300-400€ increase in monthly costs.
- ricardobayes 4y agoAt that point it almost makes financial sense to fly to a warmer country in the winter months.
- HlessClaudesman 4y agoThe bird strat. If only we (most of us) didn't have a raft of responsibilities keeping us in place.
- isoprophlex 4y agoYeah, drastic measures are suddenly not so crazy sounding anymore. I wish I was being hyperbolic but the situation is very bad indeed... I think government support is the only way ~25% of the country can get through. A friend, with a very conventional house, is suddenly looking at a yearly bill of over €6000. Up from €1500 last year. Many people simply don't have that kind of money, especially in a period with crazy inflation.
- wcoenen 4y agoAs a fellow European, my reaction was the same. Energy prices still seem very low in the US compared to here. I could afford to pay the extra 400 euro/month. But it feels like a perverse luxury now that there are many people who can't afford it. And it's basically throwing money in the gas furnace, which I'd prefer to invest into something useful. So instead I'm sitting in a room at 16 to 17 degrees C, wearing extra layers (including thermal underwear), under a blanket, sipping a hot beverage.
- H8crilA 4y agoAll in all it's good to see the market react by cutting consumption. You may hate this post but the reality is that it's the only way forward, subsides will only increase the price without doing anything about the problem. Also, not many people realize this, but the problem isn't caused by the war. If you don't believe me then open an inflation chart of your country of choice and try to spot any change to the shape of the curve around Feb 2022.
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- DoctorOW 4y agoIt sucks because there's ultimately far more efficient ways to heat a home and the only reason they're not implemented is to try to force greater consumption.
- sokoloff 4y agoIt’s not the only reason. I’m literally a mechanical engineer (by degree, not trade) and tried to get an air-to-water heat pump to replace my aging gas boiler. Only one firm in the area could even quote me on one, tried to talk me out of it at every step, and gave me a quote that reinforced their sales pitch. It was literally never going to payback over a combi, which dozens of companies would be happy to install and service. So, a fresh combi boiler sits on my wall (which is a good improvement over the old), but it also means that I don’t entertain the question again for another 15 years. I was among the top 0.1% aware, educated, and motivated potential customers of a heat pump and it couldn’t happen.
- Brigand 4y agoWhich region of the world do you live in? Also air-air and air-ground were not an option? These are more readily available.
- 4y ago
- WallyFunk 4y ago'Heat or eat' is a real dilemma. I don't mind being cold though. I would choose to be well fed rather than living in a warm room, if given that choice.
- mihaic 4y agoRarerely in these articles do I read anything about the profit margins that the distributors are making, and if there's oversight there. Subsidies are some of the worst solutions when the service providers are an unsupervized oligopoly.
- popotamonga 4y agoI took thermal isolation to an extreme (expensive) but i barely need to turn heating on at all. tshirt at home while cold outside. On my old house i had total of 8kwh heaters, had to be near them and 5 minutes after turning them off it was freezing again. crazy
- ljlolel 4y agoHow do you get fresh air?
- nunodonato 4y agocontrolled ventilation. (not OP, just speaking in generic terms)
- popotamonga 4y agoDIY ventilation with co2 monitor, some motors to control the incoming air. The amount of air needed to recycle the air is so small it doesn't make a dent on the temperature.
- 0x53 4y agoThe typical solution is to use a heat recovery ventilator (HRV) or a energy recover ventilator (ERV). They exhaust old air outside and bring fresh air in, but they also attempt to transfer the heat of the outgoing air to the incoming air.
- nunodonato 4y agoInsulation is the best way forward. High cost upfront, but low cost in the long term. Passive houses are the future, not active heaters.
- nradov 4y agoThere are some health risks to living in a cold home which can't be fully prevented just by dressing warmer. In particular being a little cold all the time tends to cause higher blood pressure due to vasoconstriction in the limbs. For young, healthy people this isn't a serious problem but prolonged low temperatures tend to cause a significant increase in elderly death rates. https://doi.org/10.1007%2Fs11356-016-6235-y https://doi.org/10.1007%2Fs11356-016-6235-y
- benj111 4y agoThat only kicks in around 18c though. So you could still lower your thermostat significantly. Plus dressing warmer could prevent this?!?
- nradov 4y agoDressing warmer helps but doesn't fully prevent the reduction in peripheral blood flow.
- benj111 4y agoI disagree. If your sat in a room at say 10c with thermal underwear, thick socks, long Johns, hat, 3 jumpers, coat and thick hat and gloves. Then you'll probably be sweating, blood will be flowing inorder to get rid of heat. Extra clothing lowers the temp at which blood flow to the extremities reduces. There isn't some arbitrary line at which no amount of extra clothing will make no difference, else you could say the same thing about house insulation. Is blood flow going to reduce just because it's 10c outside, regardless of the inside temp?
- coding123 4y agoSo now you have someone that's constantly adjusting their clothes to get the temp right and might just toss up hands and live a bit colder.
- 4y ago
- HlessClaudesman 4y agoCan anyone tell why global energy prices have skyrocketed in the last 6 months?
- justoreply 4y agowar in Ukraine?
- foepys 4y agoOn reason is that the EU (except Hungary) largely stopped importing gas and oil from Russia. One of the world's largest exporters of both. Pipelines into other countries do not have the capacity that the EU pipelines have. The EU then buying from other sources contributed to a shortage and rising prices.
- ksidudwbw 4y agoStupid corrupt leaders in Germany shutting down nuclear plants and relying on putin for basic needs
- aaron695 4y ago
- jlquant 4y agoCutting consumption is great. Still, we should do the rational thing and deplete our current enemy of its natural resources rather than buying gas at four times the price from the U.S. And stop buying Russian LNG via China, which through shipping pollutes so much that it will probably offset the energy saved by cutting consumption. Probably we should also stop hundreds of private jets flying to climate conferences.
- AlexErrant 4y agoI have my thermostat set to 50f (10c)... only because any colder and I worry about pipes freezing. I'm on the computer all day, so I sit in a sleeping bag and have an electric hotpad on my hands. It works fine for me, I can still get in "the (programming) zone", even while I'm on day 4 for a water only fast, which typically drops my metabolism and therefore my perception of body temperature. (I'm a pretty extreme person...) I typically do this every winter, but especially this one because fuck the war.
- zwkrt 4y agoI appreciate your intentions but the overall description sounds like you’re attempting to mummify yourself!
- odessacubbage 4y agoi'd really love to be able to fast like that but my productivity falls through the floor whenever i've tried
- AlexErrant 4y agoFor me, day 2 is by far the hardest. Significant energy swings on days 1 and 2. After I hit day 3, it's mostly smooth coasting - I can do 7 days no prob. If anything, days 3 and after, I'm more productive. I find it somewhat easier to focus, and there's zero eating/foodprep/cooking/toilet distractions (I also pee less despite drinking quite a bit of water.) I say this with the advantage of having done this for years - you may need to build your way up to it.
- twobitshifter 4y agoIf anyone is in this situation, we can look at solutions people used when they heated with wood in old homes. In japan, people ate at tables with a thick quilt built in to cover your legs. European sitting chairs were designed with “hoods” to trap as much heat as possible. Everyone wore long johns every day in the winter. A thick wool sweater was a requirement for life and you had blankets all over. Only the critical parts of the house with people in them were heated. When you went to your bed, which was likely away from the fire, you would boil water and put in a bottle that you kept underneath your blankets all night.
- uwagar 4y agoshouldnt have sanctioned russia so hard.