7 ms·
I'm certainly not a fan of how Musk has handled the Twitter takeover, but this sentiment, "New Twitter policy is freedom of speech, but not freedom of reach", s
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
I'm certainly not a fan of how Musk has handled the Twitter takeover, but this sentiment, "New Twitter policy is freedom of speech, but not freedom of reach", seems highly reasonable to me, no?
That is, what I find so awful about most social media (and places like YouTube) is how they focus on some of the most anger-inducing content for "engagement". That is, I think the problem is much more their algorithms than what people actually post.
That said, I think that, realistically, being at the bottom of the heap won't actually be much different from being banned - which I actually think is a good thing.
- seydor 4y agoI don't see a difference between censorship and demonetization/"deboosting". end up in the same situation via different means. No centralized medium can claim to do that seriously, it's a waste of resources and attention.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- elgenioso 4y agoThis is not a solvable problem. There is no algorithmic way to detect speech that needs to be boosted and deboosted on social media because there is no way to actually algorithmically detect what is truthful and what is just manipulative propaganda and marketing.
- drooby 4y agoQuick! Someone write an AI that classifies the likelihood of informal fallacies.
- brookst 4y ago100%
- achenatx 4y agoit isnt about truth or fiction, it is negative/hate tweets. I run a politics forum and the one rule is no insulting other people, groups, or positions. This makes for a very civil, but bland conversation. People engage with negative/hate tweets. I personally like talking politics without insults, but most people are incapable of it. It is easy to detect insults.
- tclancy 4y agoOk, now scale to a few hundred millions users in lots of languages.
- disgruntledphd2 4y agoNot even just language, but culture subculture too. This is a very difficult problem.
- tclancy 4y agoYou can’t sort sarcasm in all of the New Guinean languages? Amateur.
- qotgalaxy 4y ago
- lmarcos 4y agoI don't know about English, but in other languages you need to know the context to distinguish "hate" speech and insults. If I call someone "You, motherf*er!", without context you don't know if I'm insulting that person or just acknowledging my friend who just made a great joke.
- Shared404 4y agoDitto for English. Very common for that exact interaction in fact.
- 4y ago
- karmelapple 4y agoIt is a solvable problem: eliminate your algorithm. Facebook and Twitter both grew very popular without an algorithm. Then they chased the almighty engagement metrics.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- btbuildem 4y agoOne way to approach that problem could be to eliminate any attempts to boost / temper anyone's tweets altogether.
- paxys 4y agoPeople’s problem with Twitter was always that they would arbitrarily decide what is or isn’t acceptable speech, and Elon’s new solution does…exactly the same thing. The only thing that will change now is that liberal politicians and views will start being targeted rather than conservative/alt-right ones. Is anyone here really naïve enough to believe that this whole saga has been about “free speech”? It is simply a shift of power from the left to the right, financed by a handful of billionaires, Wall Street banks and Saudi/Qatari Princes.
- bb88 4y agoTrump and Elon have learned how to be controversial, which drives engagement. They literally are the result of the algorithms that have driven engagement.
- danans 4y ago> The only thing that will change now is that liberal politicians and views will start being targeted rather than conservative/alt-right ones. Conservative speech like "lower taxes are better", "extract more petroleum", and "prayer should be allowed in public school" were never targeted. The "conservative" speech banned were things like "LGBT people should have their human rights denied" and "Let's get together and attack the Capitol to stop the transfer of power". > It is simply a shift of power from the left to the right, financed by a handful of billionaires, Wall Street banks and Saudi/Qatari Princes. That raises the question of what are the "dividends" for those parties, regardless of the financial success of Twitter.
- oxfordmale 4y agoIt is unfortunately not how Twitter works. It is very hard to restrict freedom of reach. If you follow a person with extreme opinions, you will still see their posts. Even if Twitter managed to address that problem, there will be users that created curated list of Tweets of interest to their followers. ...and not to forget the mainstream media that love to refer to extremist tweets as it is an easy article to write.
- nomel 4y ago> If you follow a person with extreme opinions, you will still see their posts. Even if Twitter managed to address that problem The purpose of following a person is to see their tweets. How is this a "problem"?
- oxfordmale 4y agoElon Musk is talking about restricting freedom of reach. That works for Google, however, not for Twitter. The entire point of Twitter is to be able to follow people you are interested in.
- nomel 4y agoI don’t understand your answer to my question, or maybe I don’t understand your original statement. Were you saying it’s a problem that you can see extreme tweets of people you follow?
- oxfordmale 4y agoMy original point was directed on Elon's Musk belief he can solve hate issues on Twitter by limiting the reach of negative or hateful tweets. It is an approach that works for Google, as they can filter such results. As you point as well, Twitter is about networks and if you are interested in a controversial person, you will follow them. That is good from an individual perspective, as you should have this freedom, however, it can be negative for the society as a whole. A good example is fake news.
- attentive 4y agoFreedom to "yell into the void" isn't really a freedom of speech. They might as well post-it on the bathroom walls.
- oska 4y agoYour 'yelling into the void' here is every yell being recorded and kept, every person who has a link to a recording being able to hear it, every person who follows a chronological playback of your yells being able to hear them all, etc, i.e. there is no 'void'.
- somat 4y agoYelling into the void is the central mechanism of twitter and platforms like twitter. I is why when I joined a mastodon server the whole thing felt so weird to me, I was expecting irc. Whom am I talking to? No one and every one. You yell into the void and hope someone is listening. Note that the same could be said for any mass publishing platform, posting a web page is also yelling into the void. or publishing a book or writing a newspaper article.
- root_axis 4y agoYeah, it's very reasonable but it's also the status quo prior to Elon buying twitter. Elon openly attacked twitter for its moderation policies and made a public spectacle about big tech censorship and styled himself as "free speech absolutist" in his own words. Now that Elon's own money is on the line he's completely done a 180 and is using the exact same reasoning to defend his moderation policies as did his detractors when he was on the other side trashing twitter. Elon is, as usual, totally full of shit, people have a natural disdain for flippant dishonesty.
- nomel 4y ago> but it's also the status quo prior to Elon buying twitter. Wasn't the status quo to ban accounts completely, due to individual tweets, rather than hide individual tweets? This seems much much more permissive.
- root_axis 4y agoTwitter has historically utilized a wide range of moderation strategies including deranking, post removals, fact checking blurbs, temporary bans, permanent bans and more.
- nomel 4y agoIt appears that three of these that you listed, which are the most silencing, will no longer be used (assuming legal content): post removals, temporary bans, permanent bans. I don't understand how the new policy is "status quo", if this is true. That's a very significant change of policy.
- heavyset_go 4y ago> It appears that three of these that you listed, which are the most silencing, will no longer be used (assuming legal content): post removals, temporary bans, permanent bans. This is not the case given that Twitter has removed posts[1] and banned accounts that were critical of Musk[2]. [1] https://external-preview.redd.it/LvQhCbGd3mXlAjyj0GktvQaAJ_3IDOLje2eCXdbgn1g.jpg?width=506&auto=webp&s=25b4e598a5c37d1c339d0af050af72804c640bb4 https://external-preview.redd.it/LvQhCbGd3mXlAjyj0GktvQaAJ_3... [2] https://i.redd.it/5hgt89c599y91.jpg https://i.redd.it/5hgt89c599y91.jpg
- fhood 4y agoI'm actually really pleased with how well youtube avoids serving you rage bait once you have made it clear to the algorithm you aren't interested.
- watwut 4y agoIt is literally shadowbaning. It is literally what he was originallt supposed to stop per his fans.
- PartiallyTyped 4y agoIf a tree falls in a forest and nobody heard it, did it fall? If a person wrote obscenities on twitter and nobody saw them or can discover them, did they write anything? If they did, how do you know when you haven't seen it. If they didn't, how is it different from never writing it in the first place?