19 ms·
Estonia: Become an E-Resident
- izhak 4y ago…and pay 50%+ taxes the moment you withdraw your money
- bluelightning2k 4y agoLoophole as a service
- hypefi 4y agoE-residency is a scam, you basically have to pay taxes 'duties' without any major benefits 'rights' and protection as the citizens of that country have.
- Kretinsky 4y agoYou also now have to pay yourself a salary in the mean of your industry, otherwise the Estonian tax administration may come after you.
- happyjack 4y agoSucks for all the blue passports out there (USA). https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/foreign-earned-income-exclusion https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/fore...
- nerdyadventurer 4y agoMy question is: How is the outlook of Estonia in startup scene? (how the world perceive Estonian startups)
- trh0awayman 4y agoIs this as involved as it was a few years ago? I remember looking into this in 2017/2018 and the process of starting the business was relatively easy, but it was difficult to get a bank account.
- mhitza 4y agoNowadays you can setup a Wise account (formerly TransferWise), as your bank account for an Estonian company. Got my company setup in Estonia last year.
- yasinaydin 4y agoI think it's not related to (Estonia's) E-residency program, but requirements by the EU to physically verify non-EU citizen bank account owners. Similarly, (non-eu) expats who moved to Estonia with a D-visa but have not received their residency permits yet cannot get a bank account until they receive so.
- sintezcs 4y agoNo changes here. They are still heavily promoting this e-residency thing, but opening a bank account for your newly established Estonian company is still not possible remotely. You will need to travel to Estonia if you need a bank account in a “real” physical bank (not the fintech one). If you are not an EU citizen - you have even more problems. It’s a good chance to receive a refusal from both fintech and physical banks.
- kwhitefoot 4y agoWhat's a physical bank? And what is a fintech bank?
- saberdancer 4y agoI've heard that they no longer accept documents in English meaning you have to pay for translation of business documents/reports/etc. Is this accurate? The guy who talked about it was an angel investor and is not really impressed with Estonian e-residency anymore.
- sedeki 4y agoDo EU citizens have something to gain from an Estonian e-residence at all?
- siilats 4y ago
- mtgx 4y ago
- loehnsberg 4y agoIf you work for your e-company remotely as an e-resident from another EU country, you still need to get a trade license and VAT number to write invoices to your e-company and file income tax. If we leave liability aspects aside for a moment, you could then as well use your trade license and run the business as sole proprietor, which seems to be the much leaner setup.
- siilats 4y agoWith eresidency you can file the monthly vat reports in estonia online which basically means you don’t need to pay vat in eu after getting this residency. Vat is over 20% in most countries. I.e once you are eresident gas in gas station and electricity are 20% cheaper. For example you can export software development services to a USA customer which is vat free. That’s how you get money into your company account. Then you can spend that money on gas Or hotels.
- luckylion 4y ago> I.e once you are eresident gas in gas station and electricity are 20% cheaper. This isn't different from just being in the country you're in, companies usually don't pay vat on resources they use. And it only applies if you're using your car for business purposes only, otherwise it's 20% cheaper because you're committing tax fraud.
- nisegami 4y agoIncome tax for non-traditional employment is basically unheard of, so this would be effectively tax free for me.
- nulbyte 4y agoWhat is non-traditional employment, and where is this true?
- nisegami 4y agoAnything other than a 9-5 I guess? At some point if you run a business you may need to start taking laws and taxes seriously, but not everyone will get to that point. It's similar to the idea of paying a young server at a restaurant in cash to avoid taxes, except it's more common and less risky. Also, it's Trinidad and Tobago.
- Fervicus 4y agoSlightly off-topic. Anyone here moved to Estonia? How was the experience?
- Kretinsky 4y agoExpensive (25% inflation), people aren't nice here - it's not about foreigners, it's the Estonian society. People just don't really like to hang together, or make friends. If you're a bit different, you'll get "the stare". The country is divided between Russians and Estonians, and foreigners. Estonian politics revolve around picking on Russians. It's sometimes a bit comical: Estonian schools don't have enough teachers for Estonian speakers, because of lack of planning and funding, and now they want to ban russophone schools. Russophones are forced to "learn the language" (one of the most complex in the world) while being soft-excluded from the society. Anyway, Estonians don't really enjoy speaking with less-than-fluent Estonian speakers and will switch to english or try to make humiliating corrections, so picking the language is quite hard here. People won't hold the door if you have a kid in the arms, doctors won't be nice to you, there's absolutely no culture of service. You have systematically to send emails, calls, in-person visits to get things done, or get paid. It's not me being nice, every local will tell you the same thing we he stops pumping the "Estonia is nordic" meme (it's not, it's a post soviet society with 0 public services). Advice: don't go to Estonia. It's no wonder one fifth of the population already left.
- Strom 4y ago> now they want to ban russophone schools There is nothing about banning Russian language schools. It's about shifting state funding from Russian language to Estonian language. Privately funded Russian schools can keep operating. It's also not out of the blue, this has been talked about for over 30 years now. The latest developments are also still just more talk, no actual action has happened. As for the culture of coldness, that is true. That also means though that if someone is nice to you, it's genuine. I personally much prefer this truthfulness to the USA style of fake niceness.
- Kretinsky 4y ago
- StevenHarlow 4y agoI've never entirely been sure what the benefit of this is. If I'm a resident of Spain (citizen of the USA) is there a benefit for me to get an E-residency through Estonia instead of starting my business here in Spain instead (or in the USA)?
- worldsayshi 4y agoTax and simplified admin I assume?
- arlort 4y agoThere might be a tax benefit (for the business, income tax would still be paid where you live) But as far as I understand the main value proposition might be for non-EU citizens to be able to open a business in the EU remotely with access to the EU market, banking system etc
- Xylakant 4y agoI’d be very careful about the business taxes - it used to be a common model that Germans would form a UK ltd to do mostly business in germany - and they were generally liable for corporate taxes in germany. (1) So depending on your local tax laws and where you perform work/where your customers are located, you might still be liable for taxes. (1) see the section about “inbound Tätigkeit” here https://www.dittmann-hartmann.de/Fachgebiete/Gesellschaftsrecht/uk-ltd-vs-gmbh https://www.dittmann-hartmann.de/Fachgebiete/Gesellschaftsre...
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoIndeed. Many EU countries expect to pay the corporate tax levels of where you live, not where your company is registered. Like say you have a company tax rate in your country of residence of 40%, but you open a company in a country where you'll pay just 5%, then your country of residence will expect you to pay the difference to the local 40%, minus the 5% tax you paid in the country where your company is registered so you save nothing in the end while also making life more difficult for you in attorneys and accountants fees. I knew people doing this without reporting their foreign company income to their local tax authorities, but if they catch you you're looking at severe fines and possibly jail time. I knew a British guy living in Sweden making money from his UK company without fully paying Swedish taxes on his gain from the UK. He later got slapped with a equivalent ~80k Euros fine by the Swedish tax authorities. Turns out, governments don't like you cheating your tax dues. Legally avoiding taxes in the EU is pretty difficult for the average person without completely relocating to a tax heaven. So be careful and hire dedicated tax attorneys with experience in international/EU tax laws before you think you're clever and dream of dodging taxes like you're Amazon all on your own.
- nonameking2026 4y agoWhat is the privacy like ? Can other governments query your status in Estonia and about your Estonian company ?
- appplemac 4y agoThere is an open company registry, it’s possible to see the companies a person owns in Estonia, and how much revenue those companies have generated in the past quarter through rik.ee. Doesn’t require registration to search.
- kimi 4y agoI guess so. In any case you have to declare revenue and ownership, or commit tax fraud. Consider that in some countries (eg Italy) running a foreign legal entity but being based in the country means that said legal entity must pay taxes in the country. So I have frankly never understood what eResidency is for, as you will still have all liabilities for the country you are in.
- yewenjie 4y agoDoes this mean if I am resident of a country that has higher income taxes than Estonia and register a freelancing contractor business there, I will have to pay taxes on Estonia only?
- tomschwiha 4y agoFrom my knowledge it depends on your common location. But better consult a tax lawyer.
- iLoveOncall 4y agoNo. Your freelancing contractor business may pay less taxes but when you pay yourself a wage you will pay income taxes for your actual residency.
- kimi 4y agoAnd tax authorities may wonder whether setting up a foreign company was for tax reasons only, and decide that you still owe taxes on everything and that you are a tax dodger. So talk to a specialized tax accountant who know their stuff (and that won't be cheap).
- CalRobert 4y agoI have a limited company in Ireland. I am the only employee. I pay myself a wage from that company. One thought I had was that I could live modestly, pay myself a fraction of what the company takes in, let my company take advantage of Ireland's famously low corporate tax rates and invest accordingly, and then cash out, perhaps after moving somewhere without 52% taxes on all income over (70-90k depending on spouse, kids, etc.) Alas, I am not the first person to think of this. The Close Company Surcharge effectively means I have to pay out on a given timeline and as such incur an income tax liability.
- luckylion 4y ago> after moving somewhere without 52% taxes on all income over Does Ireland not have some form of expatriation tax? In Germany, this doesn't work, because they'll tax you "as if" you've sold your company at the time of emigration.
- zerr 4y agoIt is useless unless they put tax-haven-like conditions on the table. Why should I pay regular taxes to Estonia instead of my country?
- willeh 4y agoAnd that's exactly what they have, specifically they have a unique form of corporate taxation that means that only dividends are taxed at the end of the FY.
- pilsetnieks 4y agoNothing particularly unique about that. For example, Latvia has that too, although they did that at least in part because of the Estonian example.
- qwytw 4y agoYes, Latvia and Estonia are the only two countries in Europe which allow this. That seems pretty unique to me. Also corporate tax rates are veery low there compared to most other European countries (this this is the case in most of Eastern Europe)
- xrayarx 4y agoIt is not entirely true that everything can be done online. The e-residency kit is physical and needs to be picked up, which depending on your location could be cumbersome. A major problem may be the various cross border tax regulations.
- OJFord 4y agoBut in-country at least (I thought from your comment 'oh you have to go to Estonia?') - they've even re-opened the location in Kyiv: https://www.e-resident.gov.ee/pick-up-locations/ https://www.e-resident.gov.ee/pick-up-locations/
- cestith 4y agoThe US is a pretty big counter example. It's two major cities on the Atlantic and Pacific coasts. That's a round-trip flight at least for people in most of the country.
- OJFord 4y agoThat's not a counter example? That's still 'in-country' and not Estonia.
- cestith 4y agoOh, sorry. I read your post originally as in-country meaning not cumbersome, as opposed to potentially cumbersome but less so than having to go to Estonia in person. Yes, New York and San Francisco are domestic for US folks obviously.
- throwaway4good 4y agoAnyone here actually have this form of residency? If so why?
- mhitza 4y agoI do. I live in Romania, and the bureaucracy level here is almost Kafkaesque. With digital services there's no paper pushing, the financial regulation in Estonia has been very stable, whereas in my home country it changes drastically almost every election cycle. Mind you, I still have to deal with my state's institutions for reporting taxes (and what have you), but at least I don't have to manage a company here. It can involve a lot of running around and being present, whereas with an Estonian company I could move at any point to another EU country without having to think of ever having to come back and deal with company related stuff (sure, I could officially delegate someone to do that on my behalf, but those are just complications for complications sake).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- amelius 4y agoSounds nice but there might be a catch, e g. you might have to serve in their army.
- tambre 4y agoThat's only possible if you have national defence obligation, i.e. you completed the compulsory draft or have applied so otherwise. In both cases you need to have citizenship, basic education, of good health, not in jail, no criminal proceedings and a few other minor things. See §81 of the Military Service Act [0]. [0] https://www.riigiteataja.ee/en/eli/513072022006/consolide#para81 https://www.riigiteataja.ee/en/eli/513072022006/consolide#pa...
- maeln 4y agoNo resident will ever be drafted / asked to serve in the army of their residency. It would make no sense. This e-resident is mostly a way for Estonia to lower the barrier in creating a company in Estonia (and therefor having access to the E.U common market). This is a clever move because it attract start-up and smaller companies (who tend to be more afraid of paperwork) in Estonia rather than another E.U country, which means they will pay taxes to Estonia instead of Germany, France, ...
- gasull 4y ago"Do you tell applicants to Estonia’s E Residency program that if their country has CFC laws (most do), they’re risking getting double taxed and fined in their home countries for being the majority owner in a foreign corporation?" https://twitter.com/levelsio/status/999189334401073152 https://twitter.com/levelsio/status/999189334401073152
- jFriedensreich 4y agoi normally love levels io but this is a bit misleading and overly negative, this applies only for countries with cfc laws but no double taxation treaties, and this is often communicated as far as i remember the onboarding experience.
- KingMob 4y agoI used to like him too, until I signed up for Nomad List, discovered the mods were rampant anti-vaxxers, and he hasn't done anything about it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- psychphysic 4y agoWhat's the cost of application? This is useless for me but I imagine huge for those who need a pied a terre in EU.
- pilsetnieks 4y agoAn electronic pied-à-terre, if you will. This will not get you an actual residence permit, tax residency (for you as a person), a Schengen visa, or any of that pesky physical stuff.
- nulbyte 4y agoThe application fee is 100€, according to the video, then another 190€ fee to file for creating the business.
- andsoitis 4y agoThis caused me read up on Estonia on Wikipedia, and this struck me: “ Estonia has pursued the development of the e-government, with 99 percent of the public services being available on the web 24 hours a day.[198] In 2005 Estonia became the first country in the world to introduce nationwide binding Internet voting in local elections of 2005.[199] In 2019 parliamentary elections 44% of the total votes were cast over the internet.”
- fsh 4y agoI find it extremely concerning that they mix e-government and electronic voting. The former is obviously a good idea, while the latter is an existential threat to democracy. Estonian citizens can now no longer audit the validity of their elections in the way that paper ballots have allowed.
- SuoDuanDao 4y agoTo the Cryptoskeptics of HN, does this seem like a legitimate use case of Blockchain to you?
- francislavoie 4y agoNo. https://www.usvotefoundation.org/blockchain-voting-is-not-a-security-strategy https://www.usvotefoundation.org/blockchain-voting-is-not-a-...
- rpigab 4y agoIt's a typical case of a problem that we really think could be fixed by technology, but you're only adding or changing technology layers and the end result doesn't change, because it's not a technological problem, but a human one. People can be confident in paper votes because they can understand how to audit the result, and who does it. The best e-voting software in the world can provide that level of trust only to some engineers who know the code, and only if they can audit all the systems where the software is deployed. It's like passwords, it can't work if part of the population has no clue why it's needed or how it works. It's even worse with blockchain, because you can't put everything on the blockchain, it needs to interact with the real world, and that's where you can cheat the system (like stealing the keys of people in retirement homes because they don't know what they are for - sure it happens with paper but it's harder to do and easier to catch them in the act).
- aliswe 4y agoI heard Estonia still requires local sponsors and a significant portion of the company needs to be owned by a citizen, is that true? or was that just rumors?
- Strom 4y agoDefinitely not true. Would cut down on a lot of scams, but alas. The e-residency is popular among various online scammers, because it gives them access to the EU banking system.
- yasinaydin 4y agoAFAIK the only 2 local requirements to find a company in Estonia are: - Address in Estonia - A contact person from Estonia (resident or citizen) Both of these services could be rented separately or together by various service provides. Accreditated ones are listed at E-residency's website.
- krn 4y agoMy conclusion about the Estonian E-Residency program is that it is essentially useless, unless you want to become an Estonian tax resident by physically relocating to Estonia. And there is a good reason why you would like to do that[1]: > For the ninth year in a row, Estonia has the best tax code in the OECD. For instance, if you live in Estonia, you can use an Estonian limited liability company to manage all your investments without paying any taxes at all, as long as you don't withdraw any money from it. [1] https://taxfoundation.org/publications/international-tax-competitiveness-index/ https://taxfoundation.org/publications/international-tax-com...
- davidguetta 4y agoIts good for creating a estonian compagny with tax benefits no ?
- Archelaos 4y ago> For instance, if you live in Estonia, you can use an Estonian limited liability company to manage all your investments without paying any taxes at all, as long as you don't withdraw any money from it. How much is the tax, when I withdraw the money?
- krn 4y ago20% flat rate.
- bsndev 4y ago
- bitL 4y agoWhy not get Dubai Golden Visa for 5-10 years instead, get 0% taxes and the ability to live wherever you want (Dubai doesn't enforce residency duration limits to Golden Visa holders)?
- tokai 4y agoBcs Estonia is a small democratic state and UAE is a disgusting dictatorship?