6 ms·
Is there any large group representing App developers that could manage the large-scale negotiation and legal wrangling required to force Apple and Google to be
by dekhn 4y ago
Is there any large group representing App developers that could manage the large-scale negotiation and legal wrangling required to force Apple and Google to be more helpful when rejecting legitimate applications?
When I worked in Google (Ads, then later in Recommendations for Play and youtube) people often said this was intention to avoid teaching spammers how to get around the rules. But it's clear there are enough legitimate developers acting in good faith who are trying to change their applications without significant guidance that it seems entirely reasonable for a large-scale group negotiation.
- cwkoss 4y agoA union for customers of monolithic tech companies who provide negligent support could be cool.
- jehb 4y agoI've been chewing on this idea for a while now. I would love to join a software buyer's cooperative and pool my money with other like-minded individuals.
- johndhi 4y agoMe too! It's an interesting idea.
- 0xbadcafebee 4y agoSounds like in this case it needs to be a craft union or industrial union: a union made up of laborers of a craft or industry (in this case, mobile app developers). Get enough developers of high-profile apps on board, and now you have negotiating power. If they balk, make a union-controlled app store, threaten to sell apps only on the union store.
- sgjohnson 4y ago
- pclmulqdq 4y agoThis is more like a guild than a union. There is no discussion of leveling pay or anything similar. The doctors, lawyers, actors, musicians, and other professions have guilds like this. What makes them work is that there is a limited supply of available experts in the field, and a desire to raise their bargaining power.
- aussieshibe 4y agoI can't tell if you're joking. If you're seriously asking, how about that unions have consistently and successfully fought for better treatment and pay for workers all around the world. Many of the standards we expect today only exist because of union action over the last century or so. Developers are no different from any other worker in the sense that they have more power as a group than individually. That generally has translated to better conditions, better pay. As the gp comment suggests, it seems entirely plausible that this same effect would apply when applied to vendors. A union/guild/group of people is more able to exert influence over vendors than any one individual, and vendors have a bigger incentive to keep them happy and address any issues promptly. Individuals are, as the op demonstrates, completely at the mercy of megacorps.
- willnonya 4y agoSo, your rationale for joining a union is misinformation and propaganda might somehow work this time? Organizing wouldn't be a bad idea, a labor union would be.
- aussieshibe 4y agoWhat, in your view, is the difference between organised workers and a trade union? Trade unions are groups of workers organised around the common cause of improving worker pay and rights. You said the organised workers part isn't a bad idea, so I have to assume you're objecting to the only other defining feature of trade unions: collectively striving for better pay and conditions?
- philsnow 4y agoOne problem with this approach is that the customers of the app stores generally aren't individual developers, they're the companies that make the apps. It would be stronger to say Uber, King Games (candy crush), Roblox, and PUBG Mobile are dissatisfied with the way policies are unevenly enforced on the App Store / Play Store. Here are our demands, kindly address them or we will collectively deprive Apple / Google of the app revenue and band together to make our own. than Developers Alice, Bob, Carol, Dan, [...], and Zelie, who work at Uber, King Games, [etc] are dissatisfied with [...] ... Although, I can't say I would like to live in a world where the biggest revenue producers for the app stores get to dictate terms to the app store providers.
- solarkraft 4y agoThat's not a problem at all. Pretty sure the GP meant publishers, e.g. Uber, King Games, Roblox (...).
- bogwog 4y agoThat is a completely ridiculous solution to a very simple problem. How do we give bargaining power to developers? We break up the app store monopolies. That's it. Google/Apple giving you shit? Give them the finger and put your app on another store. There's no stronger bargaining chip than the free market.
- enumjorge 4y agoWhich other store? The only stores that matter as far as mobile goes are Google and Apple's.
- bogwog 4y agoThat’s a chicken and egg problem. Break up the monopoly, and the competitors will come. It’s not like the Google/Apple stores would be hard to compete with. They both have massive, longstanding problems that consumers and developers have been complaining about since forever. There’s a lot of opportunity to innovate in that space, if only it were actually possible to compete.
- mariojv 4y agoI'm not an Android user, but aren't third party app stores allowed on Android? https://www.androidauthority.com/best-app-stores-936652/ https://www.androidauthority.com/best-app-stores-936652/ They're probably not great places to try and grow your userbase based on the number of users compared to the Play Store, but they exist.
- tpxl 4y ago> They're probably not great places to try and grow your userbase based on the number of users Cca 2012 there were thriving, competing stores then Google shut that shit down. They got sued and lost, but the competing stores were dead, never to recover.
- gambiting 4y agoI don't know if they are dead, on my Samsung Galaxy I usually download apps from the Samsung store not from the Playstore.
- benlivengood 4y agoAccording to https://play.google.com/about/developer-distribution-agreement.html https://play.google.com/about/developer-distribution-agreeme..., you can file suit in Santa Clara for a contract dispute. I think it will be pretty hard to fight a class-action legal battle with Google over a contract since every Android phone will happily install arbitrary APK files for users without the play store, but serving an APK from the play store in the first place requires agreeing to the above contract in full.
- dekhn 4y agoYou don't want this to be a lawsuit; you want it to be a friendly, bidirectional negotiation. That's backed by a severe economic impact for Google if they don't play nice.
- Zak 4y agoPart of the problem here might be conflating abuse prevention with policy compliance. Abuse prevention is adversarial, and it's risky to reveal details about why something was flagged as abusive. Policy compliance isn't, or shouldn't be. A building inspector wouldn't say "this building has a code violation in the kitchen area" and refuse to provide specifics about what would fix it. An app store needs both, and they need to operate differently.
- KennyBlanken 4y ago> A building inspector wouldn't say "this building has a code violation in the kitchen area" and refuse to provide specifics about what would fix it. Electrical inspections can be very much that way. "This isn't up to code, I'm not signing off on it." "How is it not up to code?" "Your electrician knows. Or you can look in the electrical code." Your electrician doesn't know; no other inspector has ever objected to the way they've done things. That electrical code is paywalled, despite being official government policy (written and published by a trade association, which regularly updates said code mostly to force people to keep re-buying their volumes.)
- Zak 4y agoThat's actually really problematic - both that the code is paywalled and that an inspector would be cagey about it.
- rurban 4y agoThat's an established existing cartel. app store regulation is a new forming cartel, without any formal body nor oversight.
- Zak 4y agoEven a cartel would be easier to deal with. Google could then say "your Play Store Certified Compliance Specialist can tell you what's wrong". It seems more likely that what's going on here is the issue was flagged by a bot which doesn't tell the human reviewer why it thinks there's a problem, and the reviewer believes they will be in more trouble if they make a mistake in overruling the bot than if they make a mistake in agreeing with it.
- dcdc123 4y agoSupport legislation requiring Apple and Google to allow third party app stores.
- thewebcount 4y agoBut this is already about Google and Google already allows third party app stores. (I mean even Epic, which is a pretty well-known, high-profit company couldn't get very many people to download their store for Android.) The solution is to support legislation requiring companies to give specific details of what the problem is rather than allowing them to play these games of "bring me a rock."[0] [0] https://jonathanbecher.com/2020/08/30/the-bring-me-a-rock-phenomenon/ https://jonathanbecher.com/2020/08/30/the-bring-me-a-rock-ph...
- darinf 4y ago^^^ this
- Brian_K_White 4y agoDoesn't Verizon lock down all their phones against sideloading? Doesn't do much good for google to allow something if everyone else is still allowed to do the same. The user needs to be able to download from the web like any windows/linux/mac app. Security and curation are no excuse for preventing it.
- charcircuit 4y agoNo, they don't.
- criddell 4y agoAnd Sony, Nintendo, and Microsoft! I’d love to write software to run on my PS5.
- bogwog 4y agoHomebrew development has been a thing for as long as video game consoles have been around. I don't think it'd be reasonable to require Sony/Nintendo/Microsoft to provide the development toolchains/SDKs/software they've developed for free. However, it would be good if they were required to allow third-party software installations with software written using third party toolchains (like the homebrew ones). Consoles like the PS5/Xbox really aren't all that different from PCs nowadays, even from the software library side. Most games are cross-platform, and even Sony has been bringing their exclusives to PC. So really, a PS5/Xbox/Switch is just a gaming PC with arbitrary anti-consumer, anti-competitive restrictions. Even if these restrictions actually subsidize the price of the hardware, it's still harmful to consumers since they end up spending a lot more money on software over the lifetime of the console. Plus, that hardware is extremely locked down, so it's not like consumers are really benefiting from those supposed subsidies. They're just paying slightly less up front for a machine designed to take a lot of money from them.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoIt's insane enough that we even allow corporations to own platforms and users. Software development should be free. They should not be able to reject anything. We should reject that notion entirely instead of playing the game they made up.
- sircastor 4y agoIt may be hard to believe, but free software development stacks are a relatively new thing. When I was growing up, you had to buy the compiler, and the documentation for how to use the tools, and the language. (Though I think most 70s and 80s era computers came with BASIC) While I sympathize with the idea that this should be open and free and easy, there are too many bad actors out there, so we can’t have nice things. And for every “free” platform and language and toolset there is either a developer who’s being funded by some other source or not being paid at all.
- jfoster 4y agoBut there might be alternate approaches that allow for more freedom. For instance, what if Google assessed the risk level of each app and presented that to users, rather than blocking publishing entirely? They could add all sorts of scary warnings in-between a user and a suspicious looking app, but eventually still allow both users & app developers to proceed if they have sufficiently high intent. They could even monetize it by getting developers to pay per update if they want a "detailed assessment" which was able to result in a "very low risk" rating, if passed.
- theamk 4y agoThat already happens -- google already allows both users & app developers to proceed if they have sufficiently high intent. Here is one example: https://www.expressvpn.com/support/vpn-setup/enable-apk-installs-android/ https://www.expressvpn.com/support/vpn-setup/enable-apk-inst...
- tpxl 4y ago> They could add all sorts of scary warnings in-between a user and a suspicious looking app That's a nice looking app, would be a shame if it had a big scary warning on it. If they did that, they would rightfully be accused of running a racket.
- ocdtrekkie 4y agoThe Coalition for App Fairness, which of course, is currently involved in major litigation against both Google and Apple. It's open to new members! It looks like the author of this post is already a member. https://appfairness.org/members/ https://appfairness.org/members/
- dekhn 4y agoThanks for pointing this out- I either failed to recall it existed, or didn't know it existed, but it more or less is what I was describing above.
- pannSun 4y ago> Is there any large group representing App developers Why would enlightened individualists band together? It reeks of unions, or worse, tribalism! /s
- hugh-avherald 4y agoNational governments.
- Joeri 4y agoIANAL, but isn’t that group called “the court system”? This person is stuck in google’s kangaroo court, but they should just switch venues as soon as the apps are removed and sue google for damages. They can demonstrate google materially impacts their business and is acting in bad faith. Going through google’s legal department is probably going to quickly get the result they want.
- arvindamirtaa 4y agoDidn't work very well for Epic (v Apple). While the law might force their hand, it may just end up in a lose-lose situation (the most likely outcome).
- Nemo_bis 4y agoThe Digital Services Act is supposed to provide some legal recourse, at least in the European Union. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Services_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Services_Act https://verfassungsblog.de/dsa-fails/ https://verfassungsblog.de/dsa-fails/ However, ask the politicians at the European Commission, and they will boast that it is about this: > By summer 2023, the first very concrete effects of the #DSA will be visible for all users. This includes: Accessible "button" to easily flag illegal content https://nitter.it/ThierryBreton/status/1592856203935510528#m https://nitter.it/ThierryBreton/status/1592856203935510528#m Which just happens to be what the reviewer was complaining about (ways to report "objectionable content").
- solarkraft 4y agoThe EU is in a weird place. They seem to be genuinely motivated by "individual rights", but with more of a focus on harassment rather than freedom of expression, so they usually err on the side of over-enforcement (of censoring rules, etc), since they're so used to the under-enforcement of the past.
- kristopolous 4y agoThis is what trade guilds were for. Antique webs of trust with documentation purporting legitimacy. That's still, in real terms, how college degrees are done. The play store could have tiers so beginners can still access it. "Untrusted app" versus "trusted app". Then if you had satisfied the trust for say the itunes store you can bring the documentation over to fast track it on the play store. It shouldn't be an incremental one off pain in the ass every time. Do the passport paperwork once and be done with it