7 ms·
Even a global recession may not crush inflation
- _5uxp 4y agoI love how we still read about predictions from few people on such a complex thing. How often economist or experts were be able to predict future accurately? not often.
- datadata 4y agoI think inaccuracy is necessary for entertainment value. Ancient people for example made much around trying to predict astronomical phenomenon, before we were able to do that precisely. What is depressing about economics is that we don't really seem to be making progress towards accurate predictions like we have done with physical sciences.
- it_citizen 4y agoThe most valuable insights usually come from economists treating their discipline as history and not like some hard science with models that fail to capture the nuances of our reality.
- halpmeh 4y agoWhat’s the alternative? People enjoy reading predictions because it helps inform their opinion on a topic. An opinion on a topic as important as inflation is quite consequential. People use such opinions to decide whether or not to buy a house, change jobs, etc. If we stop reading the opinion of others, how can we build our own opinion on a topic?
- toomuchtodo 4y agohttps://archive.ph/5cMKH https://archive.ph/5cMKH
- NickC25 4y agoInteresting, but just seems the Fed and other key actors are in a damned-if-you-do-damned-if-you-don't phase and there's no way out. The Fed being afraid to do whats necessary (and the fact that Wall St. will cry and have a meltdown if the apple cart is flipped) doesn't help. The fact that wage growth has stagnated for like 30 years (at least in the US) and markets became used to outsized profits doesn't help either. This inflation issue is entirely a making of our own shortsightedness.
- sprash 4y ago> This inflation issue is entirely a making of our own shortsightedness. Yes, central banks printing money relentlessly for more than a decade has nothing to with it. We the people are to blame!
- generj 4y agoBroadly speaking we the people cheered for and demanded cheap money. Baby steps towards raising rates (during massive boom years) were decried by the markets, by politicians (an particular an ex-President) and by the populace generally who are not well informed on what central banks do. The central banks should have raised rates anyways - but let’s not pretend like everyone wouldn’t have hated them for causing a recession or even just a slow down in growth by doing so.
- prottog 4y ago> let’s not pretend like everyone wouldn’t have hated them The whole point of the nominal independence of the Fed from the political process is that they would be able to take unpopular decisions that may hurt in the short term but will further their dual mandate (maximum employment and price stability) in the medium and long term. Seeing as they cannot do that, and these days are venturing further away from their mandate by assuming the mantle of fighting climate change as well as racial inequity, we might as well do away with it entirely. It's not like the financial history of this country hasn't been replete with one crisis after another even after the advent of the Fed, and one dollar at the time of the creation of the Fed is worth about $30 now, so prices have only been stable for a strange definition of price stability. (For comparison, the Swiss franc inflated about 10x in a similar time period.)
- nine_zeros 4y agoThe real problem with this recession is that businesses are being asked to reduce prices by increasing supply - but paradoxically, the cost of increasing supply is higher because of interest rates. Just reducing demand with a recession doesn't reduce the price of goods automatically. For CPI to go down, someone on the supply side has to accept lower prices. Who is going to accept it? Only the most desperate of producers, and only if the owners of businesses want to continue that business. Paradoxically, if owners don't want a low margin business, they'll just shut them down causing even more shortage. One solution appears to be a deep recession that wipes everyone out and then another low interest rate cycle to start the business cycle again. But this will be very very painful and unpopular. Another solution appears to be for governments to incentivize increase in production. But this can't be a monetary incentive since that will cause even more inflation. A third solution is to export inflation to developing countries. Just import a lot more from other countries at lower prices so that CPI remains low. But without Chinese manufacturing, where is this going to go?
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoThe more amusing, although not completely unpredictable result of this based purely on human nature, is that all this excitement will likely increase demand in short term as people panic stock up on items before inflation increases prices out of their reach. You can apparently still see it in cars ( SUVs anecdotally for whatever reason ). We are in for a wild ride. One issue with economics is that it is based on a flawed model ( rationality is assumed ) and humans are way more emotional than the model allows for. I would like to hope that some marketing company has a real and closer model for predictions, but that is likely a closely guarded corporate secret.
- matwood 4y ago> The real problem with this recession is that businesses are being asked to reduce prices by increasing supply - but paradoxically, the cost of increasing supply is higher because of interest rates. You've nailed why the fed is in a pickle. Their only tool is a hammer, when they need a screwdriver. People moaning about energy companies not investing in more supply are missing that the fed is on the other side telling those same companies they are going to reduce demand and drive prices down. It doesn't make sense to invest in more supply when the fed is actively working against you.
- matrix_overload 4y agoInflation takes years to build up and years to resolve. Last time it took over a decade to get it under control [0]. [0] https://www.federalreservehistory.org/essays/great-inflation https://www.federalreservehistory.org/essays/great-inflation
- skybrian 4y agoThey started fighting it rather late, though, and some of the underlying reasons are different. In the 70's the labor force was expanding due to baby boomers and women entering the workforce.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dmitriid 4y agoWhy is economic recession equated with reducing inflation? In the 90s Turkey had 100% YoY inflation despite a growing economy. After the fall of the Soviet Union many of the former Soviet republics had soaring inflation amidst crippling economic depression.
- tome 4y agoWho's equating? Recessions tend to cause deflationary pressure because people lose their jobs and stop spending as much. That's all, as far as I know.
- dmitriid 4y ago> Who's equating? The title of the article we're commenting on is literally "even global recession won't crush inflation"
- tome 4y agoInteresting, that doesn't read as "equating" to me.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- topspin 4y ago> Who's equating? Please don't gaslight. The entire premise of this Economist writing is that inducing recession by jacking up interest rates isn't the inflation cure-all The Great And The Good are group-thinking it is.
- tome 4y agoSure, a major recession would typically but not always be expected to reduce inflation. That's far from "equating" as I understand the definition of the word. It's surprising but not reality-defying that this one might not, which is why this article is interesting, rather than boring or impossible. And "gaslight"? What?
- SevenNation 4y ago> Everyone can agree on one thing about the past year. It has revealed quite how little economists understand inflation, including both what causes it and what causes it to persist. ... The larger problem is the lack of a common definition of the word "inflation". This article is an example. There are 27 instances of the word and no definition. The definitions used by most experts seem to fall into one of two categories: 1. a general increase in prices, as measured by the US Consumer Price Index or similar metric 2. a monetary phenomenon But these are not by themselves definitions, either. The CPI is split into core, non-core, and a dizzying variety of other metrics. When people talk about "monetary" inflation, the landscape is equally fragmented. The various money metrics have been discredited by some, flat out rejected by others, and revered with near religious fervor by others. If there's this much lack of consensus about what inflation is exactly, there can be little hope of predicting its future course, let alone controlling it.
- jmyeet 4y agoSo these are conclusions borne of accepting without question neoliberal foundations. The false premise here is that central bank action (Ie interest rates) is the only way to tackle inflation. This is false. Interest rates are indiscriminate. Whether you own a mortgage or are a failing business or a successful business, you are impacted to varying degrees. Increasing interest rates is a form of wealth redistribution to banks. The alternative to interest rates is taxation. Just enact an 80% corporate income tax rate and redistribute that wealth to the taxpayers most adversely affected by that. A lot of people like to demonize, for example, oil companies for "price gouging" when the price of oil is set by a global commodities market. If an oil company charged less, someone else would simply profit the difference between the charged price and the market price as a form of arbitrage. The history of price controls as effective long term strategy is not good. Others will also argue oil companies are engaging in price manipulation. That's a longer conversation with some (but honestly not a lot) of merit. But it actually doesn't matter. Why? Because the solution is to both of these problems is simply taxation. Opponents might argue that corporations will simply pass that cost on. Won't that simply generate more profits which generate more taxation? There is a fundamentally adversarial relationship between capital and labor here, which is why neoliberal publications like the Economist talk about depressing wages being a necessity. This is what's lead to almost no aggregate real wage growth in 40 years. Wealth redistribution to taxpayers essentially hedges the inflation problem but that borders on socialism, which is why it's not part of any serious conversation about inflation.
- britch 4y agoInflation today is largely due to higher energy costs due to the sanctions with Russia, as I understand it. Money is worth less because the cost to make and move things is more. It's not the case that workers have too much cash, which would make goods less valuable relative to currency. (In the US the fed has stated that they don't think the interest rate changes will make things less expensive) Inflation today is independent of employment. If it were the case that employees are paid too much, a recession would depress wages and stop inflation. But it's not. So us normal folks get it on both ends. Things cost more and we foot the bill by getting paid less