52 ms·
Helix: Post-Modern Text Editor
- behnamoh 4y agodupe https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33147270 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33147270
- hombre_fatal 4y agoThat is just "past discussion", not a dupe. A dupe suggests there's a competing conversation happening right now that may be splintering the discussion.
- pvg 4y agoIt's very much a dupe by HN's rules of dupery. It's just that saying 'dupe' went a somewhat out of style since it can come off a little aggro. 'Past discussion' is often just the polite way to point out a dupe.
- jeanlucas 4y agoAgreed, but on the other hand it's the 3rd time I'm seeing this posted and there's no new releases or anything.
- dang 4y agoOn HN "dupe" means "the story has had significant attention in the last year so. This is in the FAQ: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html. That doesn't mean it's a bad submission! it's a good submission, it just has also already happened recently.
- dang 4y agoThanks! Macroexpanded: Helix: A Neovim inspired editor, written in Rust - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33147270 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33147270 - Oct 2022 (306 comments) Helix: A post-modern text editor - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33039390 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33039390 - Sept 2022 (2 comments) Helix, Terminal Modal Editor - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30847041 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30847041 - March 2022 (2 comments) Helix: a post-modern modal text editor - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27358479 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27358479 - June 2021 (365 comments)
- Comevius 4y agoIt's a delight to use it, opens in a few milliseconds, has everything I need, you can't and don't need to configure it much. It just works. No distractions.
- godDLL 4y agoThanks. Now having installed it a couple of months back, I'll actually try to figure it out. That's the motivation I needed.
- d3ckard 4y agoRead the docs, I must say I like what I see. Seems focused, minimalistic and using existing technology well. Will give it a try!
- Entinel 4y agoI often wonder what a modern emacs would look like. This feel like a step in that direction.
- constantcrying 4y agoTo be fair it is far closer to a modern vim (modal and with a lot of similar mappings), which also gives it quite a bit of competition.
- User23 4y agoLook at Nicolas Rougier’s GitHub if you want to see what a “modern” Emacs looks like.
- kleiba 4y agoDefine "modern".
- justinhj 4y agoEmacs is under constant improvement and so are it’s many packages. Emacs looks like modern Emacs
- trenchgun 4y agoDoom Emacs looks like modern Emacs.
- masterof0 4y agoI'm a huge fan of Helix, use it everyday. LSP works out of the box(if you install it with a package manager, otherwise you need to do a bit of config) .My configuration file has 5 lines or so, great defaults. No need for overly complicated configuration, or installing dozens of plugins, etc.. Did I mentioned is crazy fast? Opens in ms, and everything feels very snappy. The only thing I noticed, when I use it with tmux, the colorscheme get reverted, dunno if that is a tmux issue or not. But in general, great editor, thanks to the authors.
- bobbyskelton41 4y agoYou need to enable true-color in your tmux config.
- whimsicalism 4y agoe: Huh, didn't even modify my tmux config and it worked on a restart of the terminal. Do you have any more information? Having a bit of difficulty figuring this out, found this for neovim [0] but doesn't seem to be working for me. [0]: https://jdhao.github.io/2018/10/19/tmux_nvim_true_color/ https://jdhao.github.io/2018/10/19/tmux_nvim_true_color/
- barefeg 4y agoI recently got into neovim (from vscode) and it took me 1.5 weeks to get it to have similar functionality. I really like the vim commands though. What’s your opinion on that compared to helix?
- onebot 4y agoHelix just has better out of the box experience. Will take you like 5 minutes to setup instead of 1.5 weeks. It is just so much easier to start a model editor if you havent used one before.
- bembo 4y agoI've switched to helix, from neovim and I can say that I like the commands much more. It feels like they took vim commands and made them much more consistent. Plus the UX is so good, lsp out of the box and all. In neovim I always feelt like my config was missing something but helix feels good without even touching the config. Much recommended.
- BossingAround 4y agoInteresting language support [1]. I might try it for some of my Python/Node projects (though it's hard to see a Python IDE that better than PyCharm). [1] https://docs.helix-editor.com/lang-support.html https://docs.helix-editor.com/lang-support.html
- rjh29 4y agoTree-sitter and LSP (language server protocol) are both global standards. If you support them then you automatically support any language that has a tree-sitter grammar or implements an LSP.
- theptip 4y agoIs LSP support for Python better than PyCharm's? My assumption has been JetBrains' implementations are better for languages that they support deeply since they have so many more man-hours of polish, but e.g. Rust is going to be better with LSP than JetBrains' plugin implementation.
- rjh29 4y agoI have not used the LSP directly, but Python's LSP uses Jedi under the hood, the same code as VS Code's official Python extension - it is very good. JetBrains put in lots of effort but they are just one company - the power of LSP is that the whole community (including companies like Microsoft) are building a single tool that all IDEs and editors can use. Granted I hit a couple of bugs as it is under heavy development but I think they'll win out in the long term.
- whimsicalism 4y agoThat may be true but at least for JVM languages, intellij is better than LSP.
- dead10ck 4y agoNot quite, it gets you about 90% there. Even with a grammar to use off the shelf, you still need to write queries to make use of it for highlighting, text object selection, auto indenting, etc. These have so far been particular to the editor.
- michelledepeil 4y agoI gave this a couple of tries but my vim muscle memory is actively hurting me the longer I try... I would love if this had a - at least somewhat closer to - vim-mode, because all the rest, LSP, startup speed, etc, is excellent.
- _joel 4y agoI think there is a config that maps more to vim, try this https://github.com/LGUG2Z/helix-vim/raw/master/config.toml https://github.com/LGUG2Z/helix-vim/raw/master/config.toml
- stvnbn 4y agoWhy is it not the default?
- vulcan01 4y agoHelix primarily follows the Kakoune model instead of Vim's. It can be confusing to switch from Vim, but Helix's model tends to be more intuitive if one does not already have Vim muscle memory.
- xypage 4y agoBecause it's not the same as vim, they've made some fundamentally different choices and their default binds reflect that. I genuinely think helix stands to be better, it lacks the community and thus the extensions of vim/neovim as well as decades of experience, so it's hard to replace it, but for me it's managed to nevertheless.
- weakfish 4y agoI love helix. It’s my daily driver at work (python) with occasional hops over to VS Code for a graphical debugger. Would love if anyone has tips for getting the python DAP working in Helix, though.
- constantcrying 4y agoOne thing I really liked about it was the UI experience where as soon as you typed the first character of some sequence it started showing you all the other option starting with the same character. (Try pressing space or Ctr-w in Normal mode) It made the whole thing far more explorable and I really thought it was a good experience although clearly not yet on par with something as fully mature as vim (but also with far less technical baggage). The first thing I did on my vim setup was installing an extension which gave me very similar command completions.
- behnamoh 4y ago> The first thing I did on my vim setup was installing an extension which gave me very similar command completions. How did you do that? Were you also able to replicate the small popups that open when you press `m`, `g`, etc.?
- constantcrying 4y agoJust an extension. It is https://github.com/liuchengxu/vim-which-key https://github.com/liuchengxu/vim-which-key if you are interested. >Were you also able to replicate the small popups that open when you press `m`, `g`, etc.? Yes, although 'm' has a totally different meaning in vim (placing a mark), so there is no popup for that. But it works where there are actually sensible choices, even for marks it works and shows you every available one, which is pretty cool
- Graziano_M 4y agoIf you're using Neovim you want this one: https://github.com/folke/which-key.nvim https://github.com/folke/which-key.nvim New nvim api lets mappings add a desc which will get picked up automatically with this plugin.
- RabidDartGunman 4y agoHelix is really great. If only it had a VIM (or VIM-like) mode available. I find the Kanoune shortcuts really limiting, as they fail to use the relative line numbers for anything except moving the cursor. Bidirectional selection, deletion, commenting, etc. is super useful when coding.
- riwsky 4y agoCould you give an example of an edit you couldn’t express?
- RabidDartGunman 4y agoSay I am at the last line of a part of a function, that I would like to delete - maybe some debug output. In VIM, I will look at the relative line numbers and immediately see that I would like to delete up to the number 8. Then I simply write d8<up> or d8h, and I am done. As far as I can tell - I may be wrong - in Helix, I would have to first do 8<up> and then 9xd. Note the number 9 in there. This is due to the fact that in Helix, I have to count the number of lines I want to delete, rather than just being able to look at the relative line numbers.
- bo0O0od 4y agoIn Helix you'd have to x downward or use v to enter visual mode. But you initially said that you "found kakoune bindings limiting". In kakoune you can 8Kxd, or 8K<a-x>d on less recent versions. The vim approach is usually superior for simple commands like "delete N lines", the kakoune approach is superior when you want to compose commands, e.g. `%sif<ret>f(<a-i>(sand<ret>cor` is "select all `if`, find `(`, select inside `(`, select all `and`, change to `or`"
- gnuvince 4y agoIn Helix, you can use `maf` to mark the outer function and then press `d` to delete it.
- 4y ago
- aldanor 4y agoFor anyone who's used to fd/jk/kj/jj/jf or the like in Vim as an alias to ESC to exit insert mode, it looks like Helix is not too usable as of today: https://github.com/helix-editor/helix/issues/2612 https://github.com/helix-editor/helix/issues/2612 I would've considered exploring Helix myself if it wasn't for this.
- vitiral 4y agoRemap capslock to CTRL when held and ESC when tapped. Good idea for vim too
- samatman 4y agoThe classic mapping is Alt/Meta to send escape when tapped, because terminals send Alt-q as `ESC q`. I have no strong opinions about how people lay out their keyboards, other than that people should try a split key if they haven't. My layout sends ESC when Alt is tapped, capslock is for backspace.
- Shared404 4y agoWhat about holding spacebar to overheat the computer and exit emacs?
- qu4z-2 4y agoWhat about it?
- mike-the-mikado 4y agoSee https://xkcd.com/1172/ https://xkcd.com/1172/
- qu4z-2 4y agoI know the xkcd, I just don't understand your point.
- dm319 4y agoI'm a long time user of vim/nvim and have learnt so many great techniques from "practical vim". Helix looks good, and the speed is impressive. It does seem very code-centric though, movements seem based with this in mind. I also find it inconsistent that some movements cannot be combined with actions but others can. Having said that, there are certainly some ways that vim could be reimagined. I find beginning and end of line movements awkwardly placed by default, as is moving up and down by half and whole pages. I have a feeling that movement-action paradigm as opposed to action-movement paradigm of vim will have some tradeoffs with visualisation being a plus, and more advanced repetitions bring a negative, but I haven't totally thought this through.
- tomphoolery 4y agoIn my experience, as another longtime user of vim and now using helix as my daily driver, it does take a bit of getting used to. But once you grok the whole idea of "selection first, then action", it becomes a bit easier to deal with. Honestly I think Helix is a better editor for those who are looking for the features of Vim but don't want to learn its esoteric syntax. I had to learn Vi/Vim in order to work with FreeBSD machines back in the day, and I had a whole book to reference its commands, so for me it's kinda second-nature. But for new users, I can imagine Vim not being the easiest thing to figure out. I chose to take the plunge and start using Helix most of the time because: 1. It's like Vim/NeoVim enough that I didn't constantly get stuck. Most of the modal commands are similar to Vim, and you can always fall back to mouse-based selection and using normal commands like Ctrl/Cmd+V and Ctrl/Cmd+C if you don't want to get into the registers just yet. 2. Built-in support for the stuff I actually care about. LSP, fuzzy file picking, inline docs, IDE-like features like "go to definition", it's all included. And unlike NeoVim, it doesn't crash half the time when I'm working on TypeScript files (thanks Rust!). Haven't needed CTags at all since I started using Helix. 3. It's fast. Like, way faster than NeoVim or Vim unless you don't use any plugins. And without plugins, it looks great. Tons of themes to choose from, easy to switch them in the config, etc. > I have a feeling that movement-action paradigm as opposed to action-movement paradigm of vim will have some tradeoffs with visualisation being a plus, and more advanced repetitions bring a negative, but I haven't totally thought this through. I think the "advanced repetition" side of this is just going to look different, more like Emacs or Sublime Text in its functionality IMO. For example, the "Migrating from Vim" guide mentions global replace (https://github.com/helix-editor/helix/wiki/Migrating-from-Vim https://github.com/helix-editor/helix/wiki/Migrating-from-Vi...). This doesn't really go into how it looks, but what happens looks a lot more like NeoVim than Vim. It's still just as fast as Vim to write these commands, albeit a different syntax that you have to get used to, but the benefit is being able to see what is happening to your file while it's happening, rather than after the fact or having to jump through every instance and "confirm" it (which is problematic on large files). In other words, I think this will be/is possible to do in Helix, but it will just look a little different than in Vim.
- stovenctl 4y agoI really like helix. So much that I've switched from jetbrains to neovim. I think hx is way more "discoverable" than vim with it's "whichkey" by default functionality and it's motion-first structure is way more attractive to me. As someone used to an IDE, I just really want git integration and other things. As soon as they land on a plugin system, maybe it will be viable.
- ar_lan 4y ago> I really like helix. So much that I’ve switched from jetbrains to neovim. This is a very confusing statement. Helix caused you to drop JetBrains IDEs for another editor (that is not Helix) entirely?
- elefanten 4y agoNeovim is closer to Helix but satisfies the needs in the second paragraph?
- Queue29 4y agoStarted using helix as my $EDITOR a few weeks ago and so far I love it. Especially 'hx --health' and its built-in ability to use many language LSP's. My helix config file is literally 3 lines long, and with that I get full language support. theme = "autumn" [editor] rulers = [80, 120]
- deagle50 4y agoI liked autumn so much I copied it in IntelliJ and VS Code.
- tomphoolery 4y agoLong-time Vim/NeoVim user here...about 20 or so years with it being my daily driver for the last 8. As soon as I found Helix, I was unsure whether it would become my new editor, but I've been using it every day for a few months and haven't really looked back. The only thing I still use Vim for is `vimdiff` with Git, but I don't think I need to, just been lazy about configuring Helix to do the same thing. Helix does everything I need, nothing I don't, and I don't have to learn a bunch of esoteric syntax. It's a great editor for people new to the world of shell editing, and I highly suggest trying it out.
- doix 4y agoI used vim as my daily driver probably for the same amount of time as you and couldn't make the switch . The lack of tabs and folding destroyed my workflow. I like to set my splits up a certain way when I'm working on something specific and then make a new tab when I change context. Then I just change tabs to context-switch quickly. I also immediately fold all when I open a file to get an "overview" and then slowly dig in deeper. Both currently impossible in helix (at least last time I checked). A lot of my muscle memory also doesn't work, specifically with shift+v and selecting/moving sections around quickly. I got used to the different order of things fairly quickly, but I'm not convinced it's actually more efficient. I also found the random pop-ups with hints really annoying and distracting. I'm guessing there's probably a config to disable them but I haven't looked into it.
- ar_lan 4y agoIs lua considered an esoteric language?
- WirelessGigabit 4y agoYes. It uses 1 as the start of an array.
- pascalkuthe 4y agoI am contributor to helix that is working on bringing diff functionality to helix. You can check the current progress on the first related PR on github (https://github.com/helix-editor/helix/pull/3890 https://github.com/helix-editor/helix/pull/3890). The PR is pretty far along. A new gitoxide release is happening today and once that is out we will only be waiting for an upstream library to merge my fixes. The machinery developed in that PR contains most of the heavy lifting for implementing a vimdiff tool. The only thing that is missing is support in the rendering system to display them. I will be collaborating with one of the maintainers to make that happen as well so we will get a diff mode in helix sooner rather then later.
- nathias 4y agothe true post-modern text editor is copilot (death of the author etc. etc.)
- marsven_422 4y ago
- stag 4y agoI've recently started using helix as my daily editor, and would really like to see: 1. Git gutter. 2. Commands similar to * and # in vim.
- yellowapple 4y agoHaving to switch between "normal" and "insert" modes all the time is one of the things that turns me off from vi and its family tree, and is consequently something that turns me off of Helix, too. There are a lot of neat ideas here, though, and I wonder how many could be hacked into other editors like Emacs.
- FractalHQ 4y agoI’m the same way- my MacBook trackpad is closer to my fingers than the escape key! Not to mention, in VSCode I can do anything with the command palette with cmd+P without the need for separate modes and without the need to memorize a million shortcuts. If I know the first letter or two of the command, then it’s only 3 keystrokes away. For example, “Evaluate Math Expression” is “cmd+shift+p”+”ev”+”enter”. The command palette also provides great additional explorability with the fuzzy searchable menu + descriptions. This is a far superior workflow because I have access to every possible command in the editor / installed extensions (very easily mapped to my own shortcuts of I want) without the need to memorize anything. I can even reverse-search commands by typing the shortcut and it will tell me the commands bound to that shortcut. I could be missing something, but Vim and family feels like a huge step backwards in workflow for me.
- yellowapple 4y ago> If I know the first letter or two of the command, then it’s only 3 keystrokes away. For example, “Evaluate Math Expression” is “cmd+shift+p”+”ev”+”enter”. The command palette also provides great additional explorability with the fuzzy searchable menu + descriptions. Similar deal for me in Emacs, especially with things like ivy or helm. Pretty much anything more complex than an existing keystroke is a simple M(eta)-x and a couple letters (and spaces for wildcards). My setup even extends that to search results, opening files, you name it. Something like Vim or Helix could probably get most of the way there by defaulting to "insert" mode and having some keystroke like Esc or M-x to temporarily switch into a "command" mode.
- pprotas 4y agoIt is really great that your workflow works for you, and you enjoy working that way! It seems like you've spent time getting used to this workflow, and now get to reap the benefits. Be careful though, just because you are used to doing something in a specific way, doesn't mean that your way of doing it is superior!
- dathanb82 4y agoEvery time I see a "X: a [new/better/best/modern/postmodern/blazingly fast] Y" post on HN, I just know it's going to be written in Rust
- euos 4y agoAtwood law ran its course. Now we need a same law, except for Rust.
- archseer 4y agoDoes it matter? I used Rust to write it but I don't claim it's "blazingly fast". The post-modern tagline is a joke. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33158035 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33158035
- nvader 4y agoYou don't mean to argue that because there are potentially an infinite number of possible editor configurations, that they must all be equally valid, and that there is no objectivity in editor design? ;)
- cosmojg 4y agoIf Helix added some kind of compatibility layer for Vim/Neovim plugins (much like Neovim's support for VimScript or the existence of things like Torch.jl in Julia), I'd switch in a heartbeat. As it stands, I simply rely on too much of the Vim/Neovim ecosystem to make the jump.
- gnuvince 4y agoI'm a long-time user of Emacs, and although I don't see myself switching to Helix, one thing that I really liked when I looked at Helix was how good the out-of-the-box experience was. As I get older, I am annoyed at the amount of customization that I have for different programs, and I wish I had fewer dotfiles that to maintain and carry around. I recently started trying some of my daily drivers (alacritty, fish, tmux, git) without my configurations and though they're a bit less comfortable, they're pretty good nonetheless. I would probably put Helix in that category: I would probably be fine just using the thing without any customization, because the defaults are so well chosen and polished.
- johnnypangs 4y agoWaiting on this PR to get through: https://github.com/helix-editor/helix/pull/2507 https://github.com/helix-editor/helix/pull/2507 I write mostly in typescript, and being able to run eslint and tsserver is pretty important for my workflow. (I could just use this branch and build it from source though…)
- zahllos 4y agoI'm using alacritty all the time, and I'm thinking of switching to starship from powerline because powerline has noticeable startup time (I think it is python-based). Unfortunately neovim+plugins does too, probably as a result of plugins more than neovim. I tried this and it is much nippier than my current neovim+plugins setup. I'll have to plug in a bunch more language servers to fully compare. In a way I'm almost hoping they don't add a plugin system. There's something to be said for this all-rust future my terminal suddenly seems to have found itself in: it is quick!
- mastax 4y agoEvery text editor should support multiple cursors. In fact, every text field should support it. I often copy paste things into vs code just so I can use multiple cursors to edit something. Also block indents. If you're going to require four spaces for a quote or a code block, don't make me copy paste between an editor just so I don't have to indent each line individually.
- marcusbuffett 4y agoThis project looks awesome and as someone who’s used vim/neovim my whole career, I’m very excited for a modern modal editor. If it had an easy motion/sneak/leap/hop sort of thing (there’s an open PR), I’d switch right away. I keep checking on it every few weeks. Can’t wait for that and the plug-in functionality.
- wanghq 4y agoAnyone else read the title as "post-mortem text editor"?
- adenozine 4y agoOther than Kakoune, is there anything else in this vein? Preferably not written in Rust?
- kristiandupont 4y ago"Not written in Rust"? Is Rust at that level on the hype-curve by now? :-D
- adenozine 4y agoIt's just notably bad for beginners, and getting worse all the time. I've been in software for over three decades and I haven't seen the obsession this bad since Java, which has apparently come a long way towards UX, and also didn't ever put out new BS every six weeks that I can recall. Rust on the other hand, is an absolute nightmare for beginners. I've spent a lot of time throughout my career working with non-programming-inclined math and *-int people, and I've already seen one outfit crash and burn from trying to deal with it's complexity rather than just using Python/R/Matlab, because "safety" or because "performance" or whatever else somebody lied and told them. This shouldn't become a Rust-bashing thread, I'm just genuinely curious if there's lesser-known "post-modern" text editors. It's crazy to think how many thousands of days I've accumulated in gedit... For how much we spend our time in editors, it still feels so primitive just typing things in a few bytes at a time and compiling, etc etc. Back in the early 2000s, I thought we were getting close to just Star-Trekking it, but alas. I have to read about whatever the shit a devcontainer is... to edit text...
- the_mitsuhiko 4y agoI’m curious though how as a user of the editor the programming language even matters (beyond how complex it is to compile). And if you do want to contribute I’m reasonably certain that helix by virtue of how it’s programmed is the easiest to contribute to I have come across.
- adenozine 4y ago
- ilrwbwrkhv 4y agoHelix is cool if you want a terminal editor. For a GUI editor, I am very interested in https://lapce.dev/ https://lapce.dev/ It is perhaps the only editor which for me seems as snappy as Sublime Text.
- archseer 4y agoWe're planning to support multiple frontend too. The terminal one is just the main client.
- b3morales 4y agoOh, this is good to know! May I suggest putting that in the FAQ? I looked for this information but didn't see it browsing the docs (perhaps I missed it though).
- LoganDark 4y agoUnder "Features", in the readme: > It's a terminal-based editor first, but I'd like to explore a custom renderer (similar to Emacs) in wgpu or skulpin. You're right though, it's nowhere to be found in the FAQ.
- bobbyskelton41 4y agoIn addition, the developer of Neovide proposed collaboration a while back: https://github.com/helix-editor/helix/issues/39 https://github.com/helix-editor/helix/issues/39
- bembo 4y agoThis looks really cool, but I hope they go for the kakoune style commands like helix.
- ColonelPhantom 4y agoLite XL (lite-xl.com) is also extremely fast. Also, because a lot of it is written in Lua, you can very easily extend it yourself; you can just monkey-patch many functions and do what you want! It's kind of immature in some ways, for example, the current release version has some limitations in the native plugin interface (which you need for loading C libraries for Lua, as Lite may use a statically linked version), and there is a conflict between the linewrapping and projectsearch plugins where opening a file from it is bugged if you have linewrapping enabled by default. Lapce does seem more advanced in some ways, but IMO the enormous hackability of Lite is also a nice advantage.
- the_mitsuhiko 4y agoI quite like it. I use my own fork of it that introduces a few things that make it more familiar for vim users. It’s definitely different but a lot of it is better. It’s the first editor I’m seriously giving a try as a hardcore, many years vim user. If you want a more vim like behavior you can play with my patches: https://github.com/helix-editor/helix/pulls/mitsuhiko https://github.com/helix-editor/helix/pulls/mitsuhiko
- xarthna 4y agoYou can pull vim from my cold, dead hands.
- lytedev 4y agoNobody is gonna try! Use what you like!
- wkdneidbwf 4y agouse what you like /shrug
- ElCapitanMarkla 4y agoMaybe I’m looking in the wrong place but whenever this is posted I’m always surprised there’s no deb package.
- jarbus 4y agoI want to love helix, but the transition from vim is too great with very few resources that explain how something that would be done in vim could be done in helix.
- givemeethekeys 4y agoI use vim a lot. Here are my first impressions about Helix: - It loads noticeably slower than vim on my old laptop. (Vim being immediate, Helix taking about 3 seconds). - The default theme is purple, which I'm not a fan of. - It's more "put together" than vim out of the box. I wish vim had a bunch of plugins installed out of the box. - I get some vim shortcuts but not all, which I immediately miss. I guess I'll have to read the docs.
- teo_zero 4y agoHelix supporters often cite the object-action paradigm as preferable to vi's action-object. I find this argument moot: you can work in object-action fashion in vi as well if you remember to begin your sequence with 'v' (possibly at the small cost of an additional keypress in some cases).
- sys_64738 4y agoHow do you list buffer like :ls in Vim? I might have missed this someplace.
- teabee89 4y ago"brew install helix" gives me: > Warning: No available formula with the name "helix". Did you mean healpix, helib or helm?
- archseer 4y agoMaybe you need to update your homebrew cache? https://formulae.brew.sh/formula/helix https://formulae.brew.sh/formula/helix
- teabee89 4y agoYes! I waited out the long `brew update` and now it works :)
- b33j0r 4y agoSame thing happened to me when this was posted last month. Then I spent 15 minutes imagining my new editing bliss while it failed to compile from source. I thought I solved it, but nope. I like it, but make it work before I get that excited?
- friend_and_foe 4y agoI see a lot of vim-to-helix comments, but I have been a helix user for a little while and decided to try neovim seriously for the first time. I've used it, but I never got into it. I like the extensibility and customizability of neovim. I do not like the action-subject (verb-noun as some put it) model flow, but that could be just muscle memory and bias. I'm going to keep at it and see if I like it better, it might turn out to be more powerful. I don't like a lot of the default binds, helix's binds just seem to be more sensible, again could be bias since I used helix first, and I can always change them.
- teo_zero 4y agoEven in neovim you can select a region first (via 'v') and act on it later. E.g. to change till the end of the word: 'vec' (where idiomatic vi would be 'ce'), to delete the content of a block: 'vibd' (idiomatic: 'dib'), etc.
- tristanbvk 4y agoI could give this a try. My current VSCode setup offers me nothing really. Just nice syntax highlighting.
- ShredKazoo 4y agoIt's interesting to me, reading comments in this thread, that this editor mostly seems to appeal to current vim/emacs users. It's like the first choice everyone makes when selecting an editor is deciding whether they want something that runs in the terminal, something that calls itself as an "IDE", or something in between. Am I the only one who cares a lot more about functionality than branding or user interface? The 80/20 rule means 20% of an editor's features are going to provide 80% of the value. Instead of focusing on an editor's presentation, why not try to identify an editor which has an unusual feature you consider valuable?
- b3morales 4y agoI use Emacs. I love seeing people working on new editors, too. NeoVim looks awesome, Helix is cool, I wish Kakoune was still active. BUT I don't understand why we're still writing new full-featured editors like this that only run inside terminal emulators.* We've had GUIs for 40 years! They're good, actually! It's okay to have an interface based on pixels instead of grids of characters! Yes, of course sometimes doing a bit of in-terminal editing is the best way to get something done, but that should be quick, basic, and exceptional, not something where you need an LSP client and project management. * EDIT: I see now another thread where someone from the Helix project says they're planning other frontends, which is great! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33497529 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33497529
- godDLL 4y agoif there were indeed hundreds of thousands of text editors, then yes, the way your thinking flows would be warranted but in reality there are less then a hundred alltogether for all time each is a project of passion, and all are resultant in a peculiar, particular and special kind of thing to do a special kind of thing you can't select a thing the VIM way and then do something to it the Emacs way you can't eat Catholic while working Maori or you can, but then it is just another special thing that you made up text isn't a thing code is a thing (many ways, depending on the approach), prose is a thing (many ways), poetry is a thing, legal writing is a thing text is not a problem that can be solutioned, it is not a question that has an answer
- dalanmiller 4y agoHuge thank you to the helix team and contributors. Running `hx` for the first time is one of those experiences where you go simply go, "woah". I've since never looked back and it's slowly defeating how often I open up even larger things in VS Code. The thing that always held me back from learning `[n]vim` was the huge amount of configuration variability between all the variants and the lack of instruction on just doing something out of default. Neovim is basically the best experience out of the box but even sometimes there you want to have extra functionality. It's really hard to beat the amazing defaults in `hx` and even better `hx -g fetch||build`. The one thing I'm still missing is ease of running singular test cases or test groups in larger codebases. This still feels hard on Helix.
- robenkleene 4y agoI just wrote an in-depth comment about why I don't think Helix needs an extension system (despite the historical precedence from other text editors) that I think folks interested in Helix might find interesting: https://github.com/helix-editor/helix/discussions/3806#discussioncomment-4070879 https://github.com/helix-editor/helix/discussions/3806#discu...
- epolanski 4y agoAm I the only one that doesn't have any strong preference for some editor? I am always super impressed by all the comments stating how much of a night/day difference editors make to them. I have to say that I have tried many (VSC, neovim, Emacs and Spacemacs mostly) in the last five years but at the end of the day I feel like none makes such a difference to me so I just default to whatever my colleagues use to make collaboration (fixing ide issuesm, exchanging configs and tips) easier.
- shepherdjerred 4y agoI think the real power is in learning keybindings, either emacs or vim. You'll be able to use those shortcuts everywhere -- your IDE, shell, web browser.
- dead10ck 4y agoThis is surely just the bias of those willing to make a comment one way or the other. If you are so-so about it, you probably don't make the effort to make a comment.
- jpeeler 4y agoDo you have strong opinions about what operating system you use? Makes me wonder what the most common area of the stack people's choices are for where their choice is strongly preferred in their computing experience. Also, I imagine that team size and existing diversity of choice plays a role as well.
- godDLL 4y agoYou're stuck using things like that. For work, you're stuck choosing from what's available, because the work is to be done now, not later. If choosing I'd go with Mac for work. They have hardware that is reliable, and software that is approachable. Unless it's 3-4 levels deep into MS tech, I'd be confident the Mac can handle it. If I was starting a new project for myself, like a game or a SaaS thing, then I'd go with some Debian or Arch peppered with a RoFi search/command thing, and a window manager akin to i3. A development machine, entirely geared towards looking at and making of code. But if time wasn't an issue I would not jump on any of the things available to me. They are all largely misguided with relation to my goals. None of them are particularly enabling. All of them are better than center-aligned Comic Sans in a Word.app document, but none of them integrate my prior knowledge, or even the projects I previously did. Every new project is entirely new anyways. Computers kinda went the sellout route circa 2012, the PC makers do what they understand will sell well, and there aren't any projects that are different enough to warrant an interest. The commercial offering is geared towards the common journeyman programmer, in it's entirety. There are no niche computing devices, I'd expect to see thousands of those, but still there are a handful at best. There is like one model of a 3-year old Thinkpad that I'd buy, but it doesn't get me excited enough to actually do that. I'd put some Linux on it, with flare. I have strong opinions. I have the 20+ years of experience to have formed them. If I were to take a job or a gig in coding ever again, I'd ask the employer for a machine and figure it out from there. I don't care what it is. As my employer, you make these decisions and suffer their consequences. I'm just here to figure it out, clock out and go home, where you will never, ever call or message me. You got your 8 hours, and they are as you made them come out. Get screwed.
- betaby 4y agoNo deb packages unfortunately ( or generic x86-64 tarball)
- shrimp_emoji 4y ago>Modal editing >Not using an ADM-3A terminal To pick more than one of these is nonsense.
- kruxigt 4y ago
- SuperSandro2000 4y agoI get shiny new stuff syndrome vibes everytime there is a new editor that claims to be perfect and magically solve all problems.