10 ms·
Context to Twitter's 2023 advertisers issues
- rolenthedeep 4y ago
- makeitrain 4y agoThanks.
- CharlesW 4y agoI opened the post link in an incognito window and it looked fine. The main difference was a footer asking me to log in or sign up. Maybe all the stuff you remember was removed?
- MSM 4y agoI have to be very careful how far I scroll down when reading threads. If I scroll a little beyond the last reply, I get a "See what's happening" full splash screen. Extremely frustrating when you have these X/? Posts and have no idea when the actual end is without checking for existence of the next.
- Xylakant 4y agoTry scrolling down. Once you barely touch the bottom of the thread you’ll see an overlay that you can’t get rid of. Or at least I did.
- stevewatson301 4y agoYou could add a user script that redirects from twitter.com to nitter.net or any of the alternative Twitter frontends.
- spoils19 4y agoAgreed, I find it irking that GP is attempting to force others to follow his own standards. So much for free speech.
- nullc 4y agoAsking, encouraging, and highlightning the negatives of not doing his way isn't forcing in any way at all.
- spoils19 4y agoWhat evidence is there of dark patterns or antagonizm?
- tom_ 4y agoJust visit twitter.com on iOS Safari in private browsing mode without logging in, and see how you far you get. The twitter experience for those without an account is fucking awful.
- nullc 4y agoMaybe you're always logged in there or have ad blocking that knows how to remove it but if you view twitter not logged in and scroll down a bit you'll get hit with an undismissable prompt forcing you to create an account to continue reading. (certainly not the only one, but what is irritating people in this sub-discussion).
- Wowfunhappy 4y ago> Why do people still link to Twitter instead of of nitter? Because Twitter is the original source. When people start publishing on nitter instead, we can start linking there.
- pmoriarty 4y agoI always link to nitter's mirror of the twitter thread in question, just because it doesn't require javascript to view.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pvg 4y agoPlease don't complain about tangential annoyances—things like article or website formats, name collisions, or back-button breakage. They're too common to be interesting. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- John23832 4y agoI agree with you, but you’re doing the same thing that the rule you’re quoting tells you not to do.
- pvg 4y agoI'm making a note of both of these things, thanks.
- johnny_b_g 4y ago
- Veen 4y ago.
- pvg 4y agoWhere on earth are you melvins getting this stuff? I work at NSA with tptacek. Edit: this is a reply to a comment that got sneak edited. It said: Yes, but he's also a co-founder of Y Combinator and the creator of Hacker News, so you're unlikely to make much headway arguing with him.
- shkkmo 4y agoIt isn't a tangential annoyance when a site blocks you from reading the thread without logging in.
- pvg 4y agoComplaining about tweets being on twitter is among the most known-tangential of tangential annoyance complaints. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=author%3Adang%20tangential%20twit&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- wdb 4y agoIs Nitter scraping Twitter?
- Imnimo 4y ago>Media buyers did ask those questions. Twitter had zero answers or assurances, the presentation imploded and ended shockingly early. I'm very curious what sort of questions these were.
- CharlesW 4y agoHere's some good background: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/11/01/opinion/elon-musk-twitter-advertisers.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/11/01/opinion/elon-musk-twitter... (archive: https://archive.ph/IZp4P https://archive.ph/IZp4P) Elon himself said that Twitter "cannot become a free-for-all hellscape", and so advertisers want to understand exactly what the plan is to avoid that given that (for example) Elon laid off 75% of the moderation team. Pre-Elon, leadership spent lots of cycles building trust and confidence with advertisers, involving them in policy discussions, etc. That is not only no longer happening, but it appears that Elon is blocking people who are asking tough questions. https://twitter.com/loupas/status/1588599808587345921 https://twitter.com/loupas/status/1588599808587345921 For anyone confused about motivations, this isn't about "wokeism" but is straight capitalism. In the same way that airlines don't want their ads to be placed next to coverage of an air disaster, advertisers and agencies need assurances that Twitter isn't on the road to becoming a cesspool, and that their brand/ads won't appear near harmful content.
- LudwigNagasena 4y agoThis is so vague it literally clarifies nothing.
- imustbeevil 4y agoThey pre-sell ads every year. They fucked it up for next year. It was a very easy read.
- LudwigNagasena 4y agoYeah, that was already obvious from the Elon’s tweet. That piece adds nothing except for some trivia about a special event for advertisers.
- watwut 4y agoIt was not obvious from Elon tweet that the lack of sales already happened back in May. And apparently many other people thought he is raging over events of last week only. Twitter issues are larger then that and started sooner. Firing of account managers or blocking ad buyers on Twitter were just last step in issues. The special industry event where many companies sell and buy ads a year in advance at discount is the context I did not had and many people did not had.
- sosodev 4y agoIt clarifies that advertisers aren't being persuaded by crazy activists like Elon is claiming..
- wodenokoto 4y agoI find the most surprising thing in this thread that there apparently is an event that sells billions of dollars advertisement space each year. I thought all this happened on online auctions. I wanna know more about New Fronts.
- CharlesW 4y agoIf you've heard of TV "upfronts"¹, NewFronts² are the same thing with a focus on digital content. They're marketplaces that bring together brands, creators, advertisers, marketers, and distributors. ¹ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Upfront_(advertising) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Upfront_(advertising) ² https://www.digitas.com/en-hk/services/newfront https://www.digitas.com/en-hk/services/newfront
- lumost 4y agoIf you wanted to buy 10 billion of twitter, you wouldn’t use robinhood. Same deal for advertisers. The premium buys and the big space goes through heavy negotiations (but might be rtb’d for execution as needed)
- pyuser583 4y agoTwitter isn’t publicly traded.
- dan-robertson 4y agoI think that analogy doesn’t make much sense. If you’re trying to buy a lot of stock it’s basically going to depend on how good you are at execution whether you do it yourself in tiny bits or as a big block trade with someone who is good at execution. If you want a significant % and you’re not eg black rock, you’ll often need to negotiate with the board.
- jtthe13 4y agoAn easier analogy is the ad industry term « inventory ». When you want to commit to buying very large quantities of inventory you might want more guarantees, discounts and other specific terms that wouldn’t be feasible or reasonable in small quantities. It happens for goods, and it’s roughly the same B2B negotiations for ad space. That’s also why most big advertisers never pay the actual rate card price of an ad slot. In TV or print, I’ve seen many discounts of over 50% on the official price for large ad buy commitments.
- peoplefromibiza 4y agobut, honestly, does it really surprise anybody? I'm quite sure Musk was expecting this outcome, despite the PR said otherwise. It's like complaining that Trump failed to make America great again, like that was really his plan. Or that, in my Country, Berlusconi did not deliver the "liberal revolution" he promised. They are not there to make anything great, their great plan is to boost their ego, fix their problems, skip jail, and nothing else.
- jokethrowaway 4y agoOh, so many different issues. Big businesses have an interest in stability (business as usual is predictable) and in being left leaning (pretend to care about people, lobby politicians to lobby for policies that entrench you in a position of power), it's to be expected they won't like change and that they won't like Elon. I don't think Elon cares too much tbh, he's obviously going to pivot Twitter into something like Line in China which does everything. I'm half expecting payments with crypto soonish. Trump biggest mistake was not to decrease public spending. You can't really scream at big government while doing exactly what your opponents are doing. He was decent policy wise and was positive for the economy. Overall he did much better than I expected out of a reality show contestant. Berlusconi did some good things policy wise but ended up facing a system that doesn't want to change. Italy doesn't have any hopes of redemption. The government is designed so that radical change is impossible (it's different in the US). Italy will keep on piling on debt until the government completely chokes the entire population and the country collapses. Trump and Berlusconi share a lot. Elon is crazy in his own way and pretty different.
- enragedcacti 4y ago> Trump biggest mistake was not to decrease public spending. You can't really scream at big government while doing exactly what your opponents are doing. Of course you can, it has been the republican modus operandi for 40+ years now: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jude_Wanniski#The_Two_Santa_Claus_Theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jude_Wanniski#The_Two_Santa_Cl... https://www.commondreams.org/views/2009/01/26/two-santa-clauses-or-how-republican-party-has-conned-america-thirty-years https://www.commondreams.org/views/2009/01/26/two-santa-clau...
- fxtentacle 4y agoWow, isn't this a material adverse event that would allow Musk to renegotiate the price?
- mmastrac 4y agoI'm pretty sure it's too late for that.
- watwut 4y agoNo. But, it probably cemented twitter decision to insist on selling it. Advertisers being unsure and afraid in between time was know risk (based on what I read about it).
- blitzar 4y agoThis happened after the musk bid. This happened after musk claimed that twitter was defrauding advertisers.
- fxtentacle 4y agoI see
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- stalfosknight 4y agoI look forward to the demise of the twin sewers of disinformation and privacy destruction Meta and Twitter. I think people forget the internet got along just fine before these companies existed.
- singingfish 4y agoI liked facebook in the early days of popular adoption as it got the normal people I know using the internet more like I had been for a long time. But it went wrong after that and it's an platform that's lost a great deal of its value.
- pmoriarty 4y agoUnfortunately, in the unlikely event of these two companies completely disappearing, there'll be plenty of others as bad or worse to take their place.
- freewizard 4y agoThis is quite basic 101 for ad/media. It'll be surprising if no one ever texted Elon Musk about it since May.
- darkteflon 4y agoHuh, it’s almost like he has no fucking idea what he’s doing.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- qull 4y agoIs this considered a constructive comment on HN?
- tom_ 4y agoThere's an upvote/downvote mechanism that you can use to provide feedback. HN does sometimes position itself in opposition to Reddit. Nothing wrong with Reddit, of course, just that Reddit does thing sone way and HN does things another. And snarky low-value comments are one of the things that Reddit does and HN does not. But: because HN doesn't generally do them, you can sometimes get away with the odd one, if it's timed right. Personally, I upvoted this one.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- arrow7000 4y agoMore than yours is
- systemvoltage 4y agoDang needs to step in and put a warning at top in each of these threads (I think he did it once in one of the main threads). Those tend to be really helpful. The discourse aroung Elon Musk on HN is seething with irrational hate and not a whole lot of sensibility. I feel like I should hit the 10k karma point and bail out of here. I definitely do not fit here ideologically, politically and intellectually anymore.
- gausswho 4y agoIs there some kind of benefit at 10k karma?
- cavisne 4y agoI think this will all work out fine in the end, the unique thing with twitter is the exact people who lead these boycott campaigns... are all completely obsessed with using twitter. The author of this thread is a prime example. And the ads are placed on the feed not on a piece of content (like the issues youtube was having). Elon should just deploy a "woke bubble" option where your ad is sandwiched between posts from two liberal elites. The audience would still be broad as just as many people follow these people to laugh at them as to support them.
- klyrs 4y ago> Elon should just deploy a "woke bubble" option where your ad is sandwiched between posts from two liberal elites. The reality distortion field behind opinions like this is truly bizarre. Trans makeup artists got demonetized on youtube by the same advertising industry. The vast majority of advertisers don't want their ads shown next to anything remotely controversial. They don't want a "woke bubble" they want a "broadly palatable platform." If your feed is mostly QAnon and you like that, advertisers aren't going to "reach" you in a woke bubble. If twitter becomes an unmoderated cesspool, that's the userbase, and it won't attract the "general audience" that advertisers are after. Even if free speech means twitter must host all user-generated content, it still doesn't mean you can force normies to read it.
- iLoveOncall 4y agoIs it that big of a deal? Apparently it represents only 10-15% of the ads for a year, so just a bit more than a month. Not only that but the fact that it isn't pre-sold due to uncertainty does not mean that it won't be sold later, during the year, when (if) advertisers see that Musk's Twitter isn't that awful after all. I also imagine that the budget of advertisers that doesn't go to Twitter doesn't necessarily or fully go to other platforms. Advertisers that wanted to reach Twitter users in 2022 most likely still want to reach Twitter users in 2023, so I'm not convinced that they won't end up giving that money to Twitter anyway during the year. I wouldn't invest a single dollar in Twitter at the moment (we can't anymore anyway), but this honestly doesn't seem to me like something apocalyptic for them.
- noahtallen 4y agoI think part of why it feels like a big deal is because Elon is making it a big deal. (E.g. he has been tweeting and making a big deal about advertisers pulling out)
- pvg 4y agoIt's 15% to 20% of revenue that you get to lock up in advance. It's a big deal.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- iLoveOncall 4y agoHum, no, it's 10-15%. And it doesn't mean that it's lost if you don't lock it up as I've said. On top of that, Ads aren't 100% of Twitter's revenue, it's 89%. And that's without the new blue checkmark.
- pvg 4y agoYou can check the business news and market reactions when a company misses its revenue targets and external estimates by far smaller amounts than that for a better sense of what constitutes a big deal.
- russellbeattie 4y agoIf the ads produce results, then the advertisers will be back as soon as the dust settles. This isn't even a question. Businesses follow the money. If Coke doesn't advertise, Pepsi will happily pick up the slack, etc. It's only a question of short term losses until Musk learns to shut his mouth. If it turns out ad money is just being flushed down the drain because most of the views are in fact bots, as I suspect, then Twitter has a whole other challenge.
- summerlight 4y agoTwitter is known to be a weak digital ads platform. By its nature, its format is not very suitable for ads that directly end up to conversions but it's more of brand ads. Brand ads are hard to accurately measure its immediate effectiveness so it's important to get advertiser trusts first. I think the previous leadership was able to convince advertisers to allocate an experimental level of budget with bunch of initiatives on brand safety over several years. But Elon simply blew up the foundation they've built just within a week and now he's blaming "activists" for "advertiser boycotting". But in the reality, it is just a really good justification to pull off advertising budgets from Twitter since it's been largely "experimental" and ad agencies don't want to be blamed for any uncertainties from this leadership change. And you know, everyone want to be as frugal as possible these days and digital ads is a kind of soft budget...
- jefftk 4y agoI think this is mostly not true. The missing ads here are high-end (as advertising goes) brand ads. This isn't the blender you just looked at on Amazon following you around or weird tricks to remove belly fat. These brand advertisers are not just looking for lots of people to see their ads, there are lots of places they could buy that more cheaply, they are looking for prestige, trust, respectability, etc. This is why you see these ads on the NYT but not on gun forums. Ad space on Twitter is worth far more if the advertisers have guarantees about what their ads might be shown next to (and if Twitter has a good reputation).
- kristianbrigman 4y agoOn the other hand... it seems that Elon's long-term plan is to try to create a social media platform where the users are the customers instead of the product... that seems like it would have to rely less on advertising revenue to do that. I am not sure how that will play out but I wish him well (as someone who is not a major user of most social media)...
- heartbreak 4y agoHow many $8/mo users does he need to pay the billion per year in interest he saddled Twitter with?
- warkdarrior 4y agoTwitter apparently has 166 million "monetizable daily active users", which seems enough to bring in $1B in revenue per month.
- phillipcarter 4y agoDo you have a source, and does that source define "monetizable" as "willing to pay at least $8 a month?
- summerlight 4y agoBringing "monetizable" to "monetized" is a completely different story. YT premium has only 50 million premium+music subscribers with much stronger contents and a more suitable format for monetization. And they only could bring roughly only 2% of YT users with very aggressive marketing. I would say the conversion rate would be closer to 0.2% for Twitter assuming the best scenario since it doesn't really have a content model and there's no incentive for good publishers to participate. This will give Elon precious ~$30M ARR at the cost of pissing advertisers off. Oh and don't forget that Elon still has to pay $1B just for annual interests. Perhaps they could turn @elonmusk to a protected account and offer paid $8 subscription per month for "super follow" or whatever. Maybe it's a better monetization model given Elon's significant influence to the crypto market... :sigh:
- 4y ago
- tonetheman 4y agoHe should have bought parler. They are his people.
- pyuser583 4y agoTwitter used to be a bastion of free speech. At one point ISIS/Daesh was announcing executions on Twitter - which was when Twitter started enforcing their already existing rules (eg no conspiring to murder people). Somehow it’s got stricter and stricter to the point where satire articles get flagged. I’m pretty sure Twitter has room to maneuver without advertisers caring. The problem is advertisers demanding assurances when the company literally had a takeover last week. There are no assurances ik a situation like this, which lets activists manufacture doubt.
- jtthe13 4y ago> The problem is advertisers demanding assurances when the company literally had a takeover last week. Advertisers have the right to demand all the assurances they want. There are other places to spend ad budget. In this economic context there is extra pressure to make every dollar count. Advertisers care about brand equity and RoI. They don’t owe Twitter one dollar. It’s not the advertisers’ fault the takeover is so messy. It’s 100% of Musk’s doing. It’s not the activists’ fault Twitter had no good answers, irrespective of where the questions originated. And lastly, it’s not the first media M&A deal in history. Seeking assurances post-acquisition is boringly standard practice.
- watwut 4y agoI don't think ISIS organizing on Twitter and other genocides worldwide is something good. But also, Twitter was moderating long before ISIS issues - except it focused on English speaking world (meaning Americans were moderated much more). More importantly, the events this talk about were in May. That was when advertisers asked questions about future leadership and got no answers. Except what was on Elon Musk tweet feed. And Elon Musk vision as shown on his feed does not add confidence. There thing are apparently bought a year in advance, so they think a year in advance. Twitter used to spend a lot of effort in order to ensure advertisers year after year. Musk thought it is unnecessary, so he did not. So now they are doubting because communication toward them changed. Then, as Musk was firing ad accounts managers from Twitter, he had group call with ads who felt not being listened to. Combine it with being unsure who even to talk to, they did not bought again.
- rolenthedeep 4y ago
- pyuser583 4y agoTwitter really is good if you put effort into who you follow, like, and block. Especially block.
- crunchyfrog 4y agoThis could actually help explain why Musk suddenly decided to go forward with the Twitter deal. Losing all these advertising commitments are real damages Twitter could point to in court and make Musk pay on top of the $1B break up fee even if the court decided not to force the sale.