5 ms·
"Half as many ads" fascinates me deeply. Has a business ever publicly quantified how many ads you get? Does YouTube say, "we expose you to an average of x se
by Waterluvian 4y ago
"Half as many ads" fascinates me deeply.
Has a business ever publicly quantified how many ads you get? Does YouTube say, "we expose you to an average of x seconds of commercials and y pixels of static ads"?
How do I know what half should be? We've all been there: "it feels like YouTube has cranked the ads way up lately..." Will "half" just become "full" when "full" gets doubled next year?
- tshaddox 4y agoIt's pretty well-known for traditional television broadcasts, right? Shows are edited and even scripted specifically to provide the right amount of slots for ads.
- RobAtticus 4y agoIt's pretty much on a steady climb upwards though. So a show today probably has more ads per half hour than one 10 years ago, 20 years ago, etc.
- pram 4y agoThey’re also 300% louder than whatever you’re watching.
- mateo411 4y agoIt's much harder to measure television ad impressions than digital ad impressions. Publishers charge for digital ad impressions by the 1000. It's easy to measure because usually they receive an HTTP GET request indicating the ad has been served. For TV that uses traditional broadcasts you have to sample and scale. This is what Nielsen and other ACR companies do.
- weberer 4y agoYeah, that's why I don't watch TV any more.
- linuxftw 4y agoYou will be shown no ads from the hours of 8pm-8am, a bunch during your busiest times, or some such. In any case, how are people going to verify on their end they're getting what they paid for? Maybe in 10 years they'll have a class action resulting in everyone getting a dollar back.
- tedunangst 4y agoOh man, that's genius. Like a radio station that plays fifteen minutes uninterrupted at the top of each hour.
- praisewhitey 4y agoOn the instagram feed every fifth post is a sponsored post
- Waterluvian 4y ago(and on top of that, every third post isn't sponsored but is still selling something)
- TeMPOraL 4y ago(and on top of that, most of the organic content is now locked in time-limited stories, with a good chunk of them being reposts of TikTok influencers out there to definitely sell you something)
- james_pm 4y agoEvery other "Story" is an ad lately.
- ftio 4y agoI think he wanted to say "No Ads" but didn't have enough data to commit to that yet, so he's anchoring on "half as many." Let's see how it shakes out.
- TremendousJudge 4y agoWhy do you think that?
- ftio 4y agoFrom a user perspective it's messy and confusing. What does "half as many" even mean? The experience is only different in degree, not in kind. There's less value, both real and perceived, in such a position. It's hard to imagine that the conversation started from "half as many." My hunch is that it started as "no ads" and somehow backed down to "half" for one reason or another. A couple reasons I can imagine are: - They could've justified No Ads at the rumored $20 price point. Cut the price in half? Add half the ads back. - They want to make room for a $20 SKU later and need to reserve some features for it, which could include getting rid of all ads. - They want to anchor at "half" so that "No Ads" sounds even better if they change their minds down the line. Or some combination of all those.
- TremendousJudge 4y agoWhy do you have that hunch? Do you presume good will? My hunch says, what if the conversation started as "how do we make users believe there will be less ads"?
- Karrot_Kream 4y agoShould one presume bad faith here?
- freejazz 4y agoWhy would you presume good faith here?
- alligatorplum 4y agoOn the Android Twitter app, I get an ad every 4 tweets on my timeline. So "half as many ads" would make it an ad every 8 tweets.
- bombcar 4y agoI'd love for it to literally be "half ads" - whereas Twitter Plebeian gets a full add, Twitter Bluesbros only see the top half of the ad. Could result in amusing ads where the top half is aimed at the richies and the bottom half has "stick it to the man" discounts that only poors would see.
- Waterluvian 4y agoThat’s silly and hilarious and now I want to see it happen.
- eastbound 4y agoActually, user segmentation and giving discounts to poor people only on the same ad is absolutely brilliant, it’s elon-muskesque style of brilliance. It’s everything together: “Stick it to the man”, the rich can’t really complain, it’s correct i terms of user segmentation, and it’s a good joke too.
- CobrastanJorji 4y agoGoogle used to have that one thing that said "pay us and we will make some of the ads on the Internet go away." You paid Google, and then Google eliminated ads on their websites but also ads on any website that used Google to provide their ads, and Google paid those websites as if they had shown those ads. It was a really nice idea, but it had the downside of only affecting ads on a random (from the user's perspective) subset of the Internet. Also had the downside that if you're the sort of person willing to pay to make ads go away, you're probably also a happy ad block user.
- type-r 4y agoGoogle Contributor
- jjfoooo6 4y agoIn other words, it is that it's going to be very difficult for users to intuitively understand what "half ads" means and why they should pay for it. It's a completely nonsensical compromise. Musk's product ideas for Twitter seems to assume that what everyone wants is for Twitter to be more complex, with more knobs to fiddle with.
- Waterluvian 4y agoBecause every engineer knows that 99% of the customer base of their products are fellow engineers.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoThere's a simple way to make this legible to the user: instead of slashing ad frequency, eliminate half of ad surface. I.e. if there are N places on the page where ads are being served, turn off half of them for the paying users. This will be an obvious difference, and remain so even as the ad intensity/frequency increases.
- cycomanic 4y agoYes and be just as anoying. I'm not sure that anyone would see a value of just seeing half the amount of ads on a page.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoHalf of ads is strictly more valuable than all of them. Whether or not it's worth $8 is another question, but people still forget it's all a supplier-driven market: there is, and is not going to be, an option to pay $8 and get no ads. You choose out of what's being made available.
- Dylan16807 4y agoStrictly more valuable, sure. But if it's only 10% less annoying, there's very little incentive to buy. And adblock is an option sitting in the wings.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> Has a business ever publicly quantified how many ads you get? Does YouTube say, "we expose you to an average of x seconds of commercials and y pixels of static ads"? Broadcast television and radio have always done this. How could they do anything else?
- lupire 4y agoThey announce this is to users as part of the offering. But of course it's measurable.
- baby 4y agoIt's easy really. You start a counter, whenever it's above zero you stop displaying ads until the counter goes back to 0.
- james_pm 4y agoThought the same thing. How do you prove top me as the user that I'm seeing "half as many ads" now that I'm paying $8? No ads is easy. They are there or they aren't. I'd considering paying Twitter $8/month if it was no ads. Or, you know, I just keep using Tweetbot for $10/year and there's zero ads there and a straight reverse chronological timeline to boot.
- modeless 4y agoYeah the only way this could work is if the ads were replaced with a banner that says "thanks for paying", so you can actually see how many ads were removed. Which is a better experience than seeing an ad but worse than an ad blocker.
- dwaite 4y ago> Thought the same thing. How do you prove top me as the user that I'm seeing "half as many ads" now that I'm paying $8? No ads is easy. They are there or they aren't. They'll just double-up ads for non-paying users in the current ad slots on the feed.
- georgeecollins 4y agoBroadcast TV has had very specific rules for how many ads you can have and broadcast had less then basic cable.