7 ms·
The Tesla Cyberquad for kids has been recalled for not meeting safety standards
- 1123581321 4y agoHas anyone tried one and found it to be unexpectedly dangerous (or safe?)
- bombcar 4y ago> According to the CPSC, it failed to meet federal standards for mechanical suspension and maximum tire pressure on ATVs for kids and doesn’t have a “CPSC-approved ATV action plan” meant to dictate things like “rider training, dissemination of safety information, age recommendations, and other safety measures.” Not sure what the "federal standards for mechanical suspension" would be, but I bet the maximum tire pressure thing is a release valve if you overfill it (kids might not know how dangerous an exploding tire could be) - and the last one means they didn't write enough manuals that everyone ignores anyway.
- zardo 4y agoI would bet in both the suspension and tire non-compliances are labeling. That's mostly what federal vehicle regulations deal with. I would say it's a massive failure of the Tesla compliance team to miss that, but I suspect Elon likes to leave that role unfilled.
- thatguy0900 4y agoArticle says all tesla did was consult on the appearance, everything else was done by a toy company. Would be funny if Elon told them to take the labels off
- epicide 4y agoI'm not sure how anecdotal evidence for something failing (or not) changes this. Even if 1 in every 1000 of a model of car (0.1%) is expected to experience a flaw, that could be more than enough to issue a recall. But that means that you and your closest 100 friends aren't likely to have experienced it.
- 1123581321 4y agoStill, some of the engineers here might be able to provide additional insight into the design.
- LanceH 4y agoWhat he's asking is some sense of whether these are merely statutory violations or whether they are so far off the statutes they are dangerous. Sometimes straying from the statutes results in something considerably safer, or perhaps just better without being more dangerous. You see this sometimes with medical devices that don't qualify legally to be medical devices, but are far more popular. Think wheelchairs or hearing aids in particular. The article is brief and only mentions them being out of spec and under documented. It doesn't say anything about failures.
- bombcar 4y agoIf I had to guess I'd suspect that "mechanical suspension" means there's a pinch-point (or it hasn't been properly proven there isn't), the tire thing means you could overinflated the tire and it could pop/blow up, and the "not enough documentation of the hazards" thing is just the silly paper and stickers everyone ignores anyway. The first two I'd probably grant; I'm surprised that Radio Flyer didn't just modify an existing design that already had those (or they did and exposed something that wasn't exposed before).
- brookst 4y agoFailing to follow regulations IS a failure. Regulations serve two purposes: 1) ensure compliance with best practices, and 2) demonstrate attention to detail. Failing a labeling requirement is like failing the classic Van Halen brown M&M test: it's not dangerous in itself, but it indicates a lack of diligence that people should assume is pervasive in the product.
- LanceH 4y ago> Failing to follow regulations IS a failure. It's not a mechanical failure, which is clearly what was being talked about. This is why the above poster was asking if anyone had anyone with experience with the actual atv. That it is out of spec is not something anyone here is disputing.
- drcongo 4y agoWhen this thread inevitably fills up with Tesla fans, I have a serious question: Is it particularly difficult to turn off the high beam in Tesla cars? I keep wondering why so many Teslas keep blinding me on dark roads.
- dariusj18 4y agoFrom my limited experience, I imagine there is a touch screen interface to do so. =p
- filoleg 4y agoYou dont have to use touch screen for that, you can switch between automatic and manual modes for headlights using just one of the stalks on the sides of the steering wheel.
- billfor 4y agoFSD beta requires auto-highbeam to be enabled otherwise it will not engage.
- dawnerd 4y agoNot even just FSD anymore. Latest updates are forcing anyone using autopilot. You can override by turning high beams off but you have to do it every time you reengage autopilot - at least until they fix that loophole.
- chroma 4y agoAuto-brights are enabled by default when you engage FSD, but you can manually set it to only use regular headlights by flicking the left stalk.
- itsautomatisch 4y agoI think a lot of people just use auto high-beams on their Teslas, but it seems to be very hit-or-miss if it actually works properly or not.
- InvaderFizz 4y ago> According to the CPSC, it failed to meet federal standards for mechanical suspension and maximum tire pressure on ATVs for kids and doesn’t have a “CPSC-approved ATV action plan” meant to dictate things like “rider training, dissemination of safety information, age recommendations, and other safety measures.” > The good news is that there aren’t any known instances of someone being seriously injured while using the Cyberquad for kids, though Radio Flyer did apparently receive one report of it tipping over when an adult and child were riding it at the same time, resulting in a bruised shoulder. So it didn't have the required level of suspension stiffness and tire pressure (too hard or too soft, who knows), and it wasn't half covered in those yellow warning stickers. I had no idea this existed, but seems like a fun product. 10mph does seem quite fast, which is probably the main cause of the problems. I doubt this would have been an issue had it been limited to 6mph like the other ones Radio Flyer makes
- 1970-01-01 4y ago>Radio Flyer has received one report of an incident where the single-rider Cyberquad tipped over when driven by an eight-year-old child and a 36-year-old adult female, resulting in a bruised left shoulder to the adult female. Sometimes you really need to stop and think if your best interests are being considered. So far, it's as dangerous as a bicycle and probably 2x the fun.
- nlowell 4y agoIf you're selling a motorized vehicle to children, you should probably follow all the laws even if they don't seem that critical to your bottom line
- JustSomeNobody 4y agoElmo is so rich, he doesn't care. This recall doesn't matter to him one iota.
- bogota 4y agoAre we calling him elmo now or is that just a typo? Pretty funny typo if nothing else. I hope it sticks
- core-utility 4y agoDid you even read the article? This was a Radio Flyer product that Tesla effectively licensed its brand out to.
- JustSomeNobody 4y agoDon't assume people have not read the article.
- bpodgursky 4y agoIt's usually a safe assumption.
- core-utility 4y agoI didn't assume, I asked if he'd read it.
- gear54rus 4y agoDon't know if it's an autocorrect or the new nickname for the guy haha
- Shared404 4y agoSide note, anyone who likes Gen Z humor should take a read through the CPSC's twitter account. For example: https://nitter.1d4.us/USCPSC/status/1585307603558486034#m https://nitter.1d4.us/USCPSC/status/1585307603558486034#m (random nitter instance because the main one has an SSL error).
- tomjakubowski 4y agoUSCPSC's social media is run by a millennial https://www.linkedin.com/in/josephgalbo/ https://www.linkedin.com/in/josephgalbo/
- lm28469 4y agoMove fast and break kids
- alden5 4y agoit's interesting that that they only want the controller, it'd be sweet to find a "broken' one for cheep that could be fitted with a new esc, but knowing this thing's target audience i doubt many will get the recall
- londons_explore 4y agoThis seems to be "recalled for not having the right safety paperwork and certifications" rather than "recalled for being actually unsafe". One can never write laws and regulations that both keep everything safe, while at the same time not banning things that aren't dangerous. A good compromise is to instead publish 'guidelines' for manufacturers. If a manufacturer followed the relevant guidelines, and the product still injured someone, then any damages payable by the company would be much reduced. Conversely, if a manufacturer decides to have the suspension so soft that it violates the guidelines and injures someone, then any damages claim is dramatically increased. That approach lets companies stray outside the guidelines when they have a lot of confidence that their design is safe.
- atonse 4y agoAs a business owner, I understand the spirit of this, but as a parent/customer, does this mean I'd have to rely on my own research to find out that toys have certain safety standards? Then that's a no – I'd rather put the onus on the business because that's the cost of doing business. And just to clarify, even though I'm a business owner, I firmly believe that all the headaches absolutely should be the burden of the businesses and not the customers.
- londons_explore 4y agoIf the system works as intended, you might even want to buy products that don't meet the guidelines. That means the business owner has got a design that they believe is substantially safer than the guidelines allow - hence why they made the business decision to not stick to the guidelines and use their own design instead. Obviously this falls down when the business owner believes they'll never have to pay out (eg. overseas amazon sellers, or businesses that plan to claim bankruptcy as soon as the first claim comes in). I think required liability insurance should cover those cases - where the 'excess' of the policy is the total value of the company. The insurance company will likely insist the guidelines are followed too, since they don't want to take on an unknown risk...
- 4y ago
- londons_explore 4y agoThese cars are worth more than $1,900 on the 2nd hand market... Anyone who sends theirs back for a full refund is losing out. And the company might be banking on that fact, knowing that they're going to get very few returns...
- klyrs 4y agoActually, they're paying a full refund for sending in the motor controller. I've half a mind to buy one; replacing the motor controller sounds like a fun afternoon. Replacing the body panels sounds considerably less fun, but the thing is fugly as a cybertruck, which is a reason that I'm not getting one.
- jollyllama 4y agoATVs are pretty dangerous to start with, especially for kids.
- dontbenebby 4y ago[flagged]
- hardnose 4y ago>Why would you introduce your children to anything associated with Elon Musk? He makes good stuff, and doesn't frequently go on weird aimless rants motivated by clearly disguised personal animosity. So there's that.
- nomel 4y agoA more accurate title would be: Radio Flyer's Tesla Cyberquad for kids has been recalled.... It wasn't designed or made by Tesla. This would be like saying "Chevy Jeep for kids recalled" instead of "Power wheel's Chevy Jeep model recalled".
- hardnose 4y agoThe goal here of flagging Tesla up front seems entirely obvious, and to be expected of vindictive modern media in a panic over the loss of their monopolistic control over media discourse.
- seattle_spring 4y agoPublicly traded company with a board is "monopolistic," but "owned by one rich guy with an agenda and possible mental instability" is better?
- brookst 4y ago* FCA Jeep, or Chrysler Jeep if you must.
- AdamJacobMuller 4y agoWhile I agree the headline is poor and could be better (your alternative is better) this was made at the request of Tesla and sold on teslamotors.com, it's not disingenuous to call it Tesla's.
- arminsergiony 4y agoWhy would you subject your children to anything that is even remotely related with Elon Musk?
- terminatornet 4y agoelon is absolutely addicted to hurting people with his products!
- liminalsunset 4y agoLooks like the motor is a standard "500W" (of course it's not, it's being overdriven) brushed DC motor and this has a 288Wh Li-Ion battery. Given that this is being recalled for documentation and regulation issues and not some inherent mechanical defect..... They give you a 1900$ refund and 50$ to "dispose" of it and send back the old motor controller. Spend $15 of that 50$ on a "brushed dc motor controller" on AliExpress. Well of course anyone doing it is going to actually spend $25 instead to upgrade it to 1kW riight??? Heh. Sounds like a good... nope I mean great deal to me. Anyone who goes to the lengths to obtain a replacement motor controller (likely of higher wattage) probably has a clue and will have good fun doing it. Too bad there's no field weakening on a brushed DC motor, but you can also get a 1.8kW dc-dc converter for 20 bucks....
- alden5 4y agoI can’t believe a $1,800 atv uses a dc motor, a replacement brushless motor and foc controller would make a great upgrade
- liminalsunset 4y agoTo be fair, this was built by a toy company, who also makes things to the likes of Power Wheels toys or whatnot. It was never intended to go particularly fast or be particularly powerful, and most of the cost was probably from the fact that Tesla had input on the design. I cannot be sure what kind of motor is actually used in it but the "crappy brushed escooter from 2000s with lead acid batteries" style of motor is far too obvious to ignore in the videos I've seen of this.