7 ms·
The US must not be a low-trust society. You should try to live in an actual low trust society (where people can't trust institutions and instead revert to their
by seydor 4y ago
The US must not be a low-trust society. You should try to live in an actual low trust society (where people can't trust institutions and instead revert to their family or clan). The US is not like that, people seem to trust other people they have never seen before because they trust things like justice or the US army or google or apple.
Other than that, it seems that things are progressing as normal. Since the times of the Enlightenment, there was this oxymoron of idealizing individual empowerment, while advocating that humans are social animals that must act collectively. Which is it? Well with today's technology and abundance people are drifting deliberately and decisively towards more individualism. Perhaps it is about ime to stop describing these things as 'problems' and realize that they are the new reality. Our politics worldwide is quite ancient , and not prepared for the next phase of individual empowerment. The places of the world that are stuck in collectivist mindsets are awfully deluded like Russia, or rigidly antiprogressive, like China.
- rayiner 4y agoEvery single highly individualistic society seems to be in population decline (more so if you factor out immigrants from “anti-progressive” Muslim or Catholic countries). Individualism seems to be a self-limiting feature of society: it’s unpleasant to raise children in highly individualistic societies, which makes such societies inherently transitory.[1] Is societal self-obsolescence how you define “progress?” How successful can your society really be if your people don’t seem to want to raise kids in it and perpetuate it? If you have to import people from collectivist societies just to take care of your elderly? [1] The inverse is not true—many collectivist societies are also facing population walls—but for quite different reasons.
- BlargMcLarg 4y agoBirth rates dropped to below replacement rate in the 70s near universally among developed countries, far before many of them became increasingly more individualistic. American culture and attitude seeping into most of those countries kicked into overdrive the 21st century, but birthrates were already low by then.
- CPLX 4y agoThe hidden variable here is the newly available innovation of birth control pills.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- klipt 4y agoIt's just nature's way of filtering out people who like sex but don't want kids. Prior to birth control, having a genetic predisposition toward liking sex was enough. In the future, most people will also have a genetic or cultural disposition towards wanting kids.
- CPLX 4y ago> It's just nature's way of filtering out people who like sex but don't want kids. More like: It's just nature's way of filtering out people who like sex but don't want [more] kids [right now]. That’s a lot of people, and thus, less kids.
- taneq 4y agoTaking it to its logical conclusion, it’s nature’s way of filtering out people who either (a) have good short term but poor long term planning, or (b) have good impulse control. Uhoh.
- trashtester 4y agoExactly this. A couple of centuries from now, people will laugh about that time people thought that the population will collapse. Most likely, there is an enormous selection pressure right now for any genes that predispose people (and in particular women) to want to have (many) kids. If those genes are as common as I believe, they should be dominant within about 10 generations (counting from approximately 1970).
- 4y ago
- seydor 4y ago> in population decline So? It's not the most populous groups that dominate, quite the contrary. The world had half the population just 50 years ago.
- godelski 4y agoYeah I find the conversations about population decline quite odd. We've seen the results of population explosion, and I don't think many agree that the results were great. But they also weren't that bad. I think people miss the point that (if you're a fellow Millennial) that when your parents were born there were less than half the number of people on the planet than there are today. I don't think rapid decline will be a good thing (just like rapid increase wasn't) but I don't think it is an existential crisis either. World population: (1804) 1 billion, (1927: 123yrs) 2 billion, (1960: 33 yrs) 3 billion, (1974: 14 yrs) 4 billion, (1987: 13 yrs) 5 billion, (1999: 12 yrs) 6 billion, (2011: 12yrs) 7 billion, (2023: 12 yrs) 8 billion.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoI think the reason for it is that those conversations tend to focus on local community as it relates to society's ability to support its existing retirement model. This conversation is then repeated across multiple countries with varying degrees of intensity, urgency and political backing. In the old country ( Poland ) for example, in 2016 ruling party introduced a stipend for each kid[1]. The official results don't seem to support the approach though[2]. I guess my point is that it may be existential crisis for some communities more than others. Naturally, it does not help that discussion of it almost invariably brings a question of overpopulation and all the baggage that brings. [1]https://ec.europa.eu/social/main.jsp?langId=en&catId=1246&newsId=9104&furtherNews=yes https://ec.europa.eu/social/main.jsp?langId=en&catId=1246&ne... [2]https://worldpopulationreview.com/countries/poland-population https://worldpopulationreview.com/countries/poland-populatio...
- oneoff786 4y agoWhen the population is growing quickly the ratio of young:old people is high. When the population is shrinking, the ratio becomes very small. A society with many old people and few young people will suck
- Der_Einzige 4y agoThe collectivist societies, like South Korea and Japan, are experiencing stronger and worse populations declines than highly individualistic societies.
- hotpotamus 4y agoWhich societies are even still growing? I thought that even developing countries were falling off in birthrates. I assume the world in 2100 will be mostly Amish people and Israelis at this rate (and the oceans will be a couple meters higher too).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- luckylion 4y agoAre they, if you factor out immigration? As far as I know, in Europe, the recent-ish immigrants are propping up birth rates, but they adapt to the average in two or three generations.
- Barrin92 4y agoThey're not collectivist societies. South Korea in particular is effectively more American than America. From shopping-mall centric kpop to double eyelid surgery, no country has so thoroughly absorbed Western standards as SK has, and then some. Japan slightly less so, but not by much. Even China today is ruggedly individualistic with much less social trust than you'd find in Europe or the US. If anything funnily enough as some people have pointed out, countries like Britain now look like Japan did 20 years ago, they've if anything leapfrogged us at our own game. I've traveled a lot, in particular Asia and I would struggle to name one country that actually deserves to be called collectivist.
- jkhdigital 4y agoI think the real issue is that "collectivist" and "individualist" are very crude terms that attempt to summarize a whole litany of cultural nuances. My son just started 2nd grade here in Japan after being born and raised in the US (spouse is Japanese). It's really clear that here, children are socialized to think of the group to which they belong before themselves when contemplating their actions. Stated differently, people are socialized to identify strongly with the groups to which they belong. Does this mean the society is "collectivist"? I don't really know. I do observe that many of the social activities involved in group cohesion here are viewed as somewhat burdensome obligations. I believe it was de Tocqueville who first observed the seemingly novel and unique way in which Americans viewed social association: "When citizens can associate only in certain cases, they regard association as a rare and singular process, and they hardly think of it. When you allow them to associate freely in everything, they end up seeing in association the universal and, so to speak, unique means that men can use to attain the various ends that they propose. Each new need immediately awakens the idea of association. The art of association then becomes, as I said above, the mother science; everyone studies it and applies it." https://oll.libertyfund.org/quote/tocqueville-on-the-spirit-of-association-1835 https://oll.libertyfund.org/quote/tocqueville-on-the-spirit-...
- godelski 4y agoBut many collective societies are also facing similar issues of loneliness and isolation. This isn't just a western problem. We also see this same problem all across Asia: India, Japan, China, Korea. Some of these countries even had a rise in isolation before the US. I don't think it is a individualism vs collectivism issue, though I'm not going to dismiss it from the equation. I think it is that humans have just gotten comfortable as our lives have all tremendously benefited. We have little day to day problems. The problems we face now are much more abstract and existential than before, which tend to not be as motivating for adopting risky behavior.
- rayiner 4y agoAs I noted, the inverse is not true--some collectivist societies are also declining. But the reasons are different. Some Asian societies really socialized an anti-natal mindset in the mid-20th century as a means of population control. China's one-child policy was the most brutal manifestation of that mentality. In the short run this was helpful to development. But unless they can break out of that cultural trap, in the long run it will destroy those societies.
- godelski 4y agoI disagree. The issues Japan is facing look very similar to what the west is facing: loneliness. Here's a 12 year old article stating the same thing about Japanese men having no friends[0]. We see similar trends in Korea and even China. Yes, there are other contributions to the population declines. The parameters have different values, but I'm arguing that the same parameters exist. That the models are actually quite similar. In China we are seeing the Lay Flat movement as a response to 996[1]. One could argue that the loneliness is forced upon these people because of their working hours, but I don't think that as different as you make it out to be. There definitely is a linkage to higher work hours and lower number of friends. [0] https://japantoday.com/category/features/kuchikomi/growing-number-of-men-have-no-close-friends https://japantoday.com/category/features/kuchikomi/growing-n... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/996_working_hour_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/996_working_hour_system
- donw 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ulfw 4y ago
- peanut_merchant 4y agoThis argument feels like an oversimplification to me. These are only two examples of "collectivist" societies. The idea that you are either strongly individualist or China/Russia seems like a false dichotomy. Some of the happiest societies in the world employee a model that is neither rigidly collectivist or individualist (e.g. the Nordic model). My intuition is that the solution like probably in the middle ground at a political level, while adapting to our new digital reality. The argument that our society must embrace full individualism or fail, feels a bit like the red-scare lite.
- woooooo 4y agoIt's deeply American to call Russia "collectivist". It's more similar to 1800s America, economically, than it is to the USSR. Oligarchs owning resource extraction for sale into capital markets. Generally when people say "collectivist", they mean "bad guys in black hats and also I liked Ayn Rand"
- hackerlight 4y agoRussia is collectivist not because of their economic system but because of their nationalism. National rejuvenation is prioritized above the prosperity and freedom of the individual.
- badpun 4y agoThat's just a narrative the ruling thugs use to explain to people while their lives continue to be shitty while the rest of the world keeps improving. Most people in Russia are brainwashed into believing that, even though they're not well off by any means on a personal level, Russia is a global superpower that can rival the US. BTW I wonder if the current absolute embarrasment of Russian Army in Ukraine will be able to speak some sense into Russian people - but, judging by what I see in the Internet, the official propaganda has already convinced Russians that their army is fighting against entire NATO forces and not just Ukrainian army (because obviously, just the Ukrainian army would be defeated in under a month).
- 4y ago
- Supermancho 4y ago> The US is not like that, people seem to trust other people they have never seen before because they trust things like justice or the US army or google or apple. I'm not sure what you mean by "trust", beyond small interactions like say...taking a photo with a phone for them or helping them with the door. I can say, confidently, the vast majority of American's do not trust strangers. FUD permeates every news outlet and as economics get more desperate (most live in economic long tail) opportunists are rightly feared and seen everywhere. Litigation is unusually high in the US. US society has even begun to socially monetize the predictable nature of humanity with baited porch pirate prizes and hazard-trapped bike theft, etc.
- e9 4y agoThose ‘small’ interactions maybe benign for you but where I grew up there was non 0% chance they’d take the phone and run away if I asked them to take photo. I don’t think you truly appreciate how much trust your country has.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Supermancho 4y agoSome families have been trained to choose not to ask someone for any reason. There is also the common experience that someone will say no or ignore your request for photo-taking in the US (as well as there being a nonzero chance they run with it). The underlying issue is it's more about trust in risk management. Who wants to get a possible $1000 ticket and probation for a 200$ phone? There are much easier ways to snag a phone (bars, resorts, pickpocketing, etc). A thief certainly isn't going to do it at somewhere like Disneyland or Mount Rushmore, where there's a zero chance that you'll get away if there's an incident. Is it really about trust in the people? Not in the way the article describes.
- gernb 4y agoJust curious, what makes Disneyland or Mount Rushmore different than say the Eiffel Tower https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-32844573 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-32844573 https://metro.co.uk/2016/02/19/gang-of-disneyland-child-pickpockets-who-wore-mickey-mouse-ears-raked-in-6k-5706022/ https://metro.co.uk/2016/02/19/gang-of-disneyland-child-pick...
- hotpotamus 4y agoThe US having the highest rate of private gun ownership in the world doesn't really make it seem like a high trust society though, does it?
- Test0129 4y agoI'm not sure you have the correct definition of a low trust society. If the US was a low trust society due to it's gun ownership Mad Max would be more than a movie. In fact, Mad Max is a perfect example of a low trust society. All but the most degenerate Americans believe murder is wrong... so I'm not sure what kind of point you're making about guns. That alone is a shared ethical value. An important one, too! America is very high trust. It still has something that resembles a democracy, private property rights, businesses, etc. All of this signal that Americans can have shared ethical values - a fundamental point of high(er) trust societies. None of these would be possible if people fundamentally didn't trust each other. Despite what the media portrays Americans as almost none of it is true.
- hotpotamus 4y agoDo people in low trust societies see murder as acceptable? That seems unlikely to me. I suppose one problem even with the discussion is that killing another human is sometimes acceptable; murder is by definition the unlawful killing of a person as defined by that society. Nevertheless, doesn't the US have the highest murder rate in the developed world? Again, it does not sound like something I'd associate with high trust. A couple questions occur to me as well - how does gun ownership correlate with high and low trust society (by your definition). And I'm sure this exists on a spectrum and societies will change over time, so which way would you think the US is trending?
- cb504 4y agoHow you treat the "other" is the measure of a low trust society. Murder is wrong and not tolerated within the clan, but violence towards the "other" is ignored and in some cases encouraged. Yes, there are hate crimes in America but they make the news and promoted to the FBI. This helps build trust.
- brnaftr361 4y agoI don't know that it follows that it's a deliberate shift towards individualism, or if society is effectively pidgeonholing people into these behaviors.
- hahdhdkdbdjs 4y ago> > presented with numbers about declining trust > proceeds to distrust the numbers thanks.
- seydor 4y agodeclining trust does not mean "Low trust". And I m not sure about declining trust either (despite what people say). people are much less likely to solve interpersonal differences face-to-face rather than through a public impersonal institution , it's just that institutions change , now we have large private-sector agents running our lives , and too many of them are in the tech sector https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_trust_and_low_trust_societies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_trust_and_low_trust_socie...
- paulpauper 4y agoYou should try to live in an actual low trust society (where people can't trust institutions and instead revert to their family or clan) This is the definition of trust unless I am missing something. Trusting your family or clan is social trust.
- BigRedDog1669 4y agoLow trust society means low trust between people publicly (in society). Family trust is private and isn't what is being talked about with this label.
- seydor 4y agotrust in public things. or as it says here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_trust_and_low_trust_societies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_trust_and_low_trust_socie... "the ability of various peoples to organize effectively for commercial purposes without relying on blood ties or government intervention"
- Ozzie_osman 4y ago> You should try to live in an actual low trust society (where people can't trust institutions and instead revert to their family or clan). I live in the US but grew up in a society closer to low trust. Lots of pros and cons to both, but I think one thing you are overlooking is that there are things a family/clan provide that are not replaceable by institutions or other things. No institution will provide the same moral support when a loved one passes away that family/clan does. No institution will blindly stand up for you, no questions asked. There are downsides to these types of societies, but there is a lot of value to these types of bonds/relationships. Less about trust, more about care. You are never emotionally isolated (even if you really want to be). You're always interconnected.
- rabuse 4y agoI believe this is why the U.S. has such a large gang culture in ubran areas. Everybody wants to feel like they belong to something, and if they don't get that through family, then they turn to their local street for that.
- badpun 4y agoIn Europe, it's the football hooligans. They're quite large groups (thousands of people in every major city) that spend time together and fight together (against police and other hooligan groups). It's like US gangs, but without making money aspect and luckily mostly without guns.
- chii 4y ago> No institution will blindly stand up for you, no questions asked. which i think is good - blindly standing up for someone, and unfettered loyalty, is not a sign of a good, rational democracy. Families do that, but even then, only to an extend. Your position should be defensible by a fair institution, but only if your position is _actually_ something defensible as agreed to by society at large.
- britch 4y agoI think it's framed as a "problem" because it is associated with high rates of depression, substance abuse, and suicide. It doesn't seem like people like how things are going all that much
- nathias 4y agoThis is not what an oxymoron is (that would be something like individualist community). There is no direct contradiction between individualism and our social aspect, we have always been social and we invented societies and institutions to make space for individual freedom. When these institutions and societies collapse the individual swallowed by larger structures. People have these kinds of simplistic notions and then argue against pulic spaces, but those are required for individualism to be possible in the first place and once they are privatized and accepted there will be no individuals just googlers/metaers/amazoners people subsumed into a larger hierarchical community (neofeudalism).