15 ms·
Hyundai investigating child labor in its U.S. supply chain
- kache_ 4y agothe world is a rough place there's all kinds of abuse going on, even without the child labour, in labour intensive jobs. man this sucked to read
- jorblumesea 4y ago>A Reuters investigative report in July documented children, including a 12-year-old, working at a Hyundai-controlled metal stamping plant in rural Luverne, Alabama, called SMART Alabama, LLC. > In a statement on Wednesday, SL Alabama said it had taken "aggressive steps to remedy the situation" as soon it learned a subcontractor had provided underage workers. It's hard to believe no one noticed 12 year olds working in manufacturing. It would be one thing if they were 17 and this were some legal technicality. Willful violation of the law and a "oops weird" cover up. The fine will likely be a fraction of the money they saved.
- jeffbee 4y ago
- _jal 4y agoAnd modernized slavery in Florida (2002 article): https://www.tampabay.com/archive/2002/07/03/slavery-alive-in-florida-agriculture-industry/ https://www.tampabay.com/archive/2002/07/03/slavery-alive-in...
- healthandsafety 4y ago
- moron4hire 4y agoIncidentally, I was just two days ago in Montgomery, Alabama at the Equal Justice Initiative's museum documenting and memorializing the plight of enslaved people in the Americas. While not uniquely exploitative amongst all US states during the 2 century era of the legal slave trade, the post century of near complete lack of enforcement against the illegal slave trade, and the post half-century of transforming the slave trade into the prisoner-slave trade, this is true. Alabama--along with the other deep-South states--has been really bad about forced labor. I'd say it's more like 400 years of custom, with the first 150 years pre-dating the founding of the US, and the last 50 just being ignored because it's "only prisoners", with no introspection on just how those people became prisoners, or why what they did (or didn't even do) was considered a crime.
- dwater 4y agoPeople in other parts of the US joke about how the deep south is backwards and give facts like the lack of quality education as examples, but fail to realize this is intentional. The working class in the deep south may be "backwards", but it's not by choice or culture. The people in power in those states intentionally create conditions that result in a permanent underclass who have no opportunity besides selling their manual labor and well-being for whatever pittance the capitalists deem. Slavery was outlawed but exploitation wasn't.
- orangepurple 4y agoSlavery was never outlawed in the United States of America. Its government can still fully legally actually enslave prisoners.
- bombcar 4y agoIs there an example of a government that has outlawed slavery without some sort of exception for prisons, etc?
- orangepurple 4y agoSlavery is even legal in the EU according to European Convention on Human Rights Article 4 Paragraph 3. I love subparagraph (d) which is a wonderful catch-all in case a legal pressure relief valve is needed in the future to justify god knows what. Article 4 – Prohibition of slavery and forced labour 1 No one shall be held in slavery or servitude. 2 No one shall be required to perform forced or compulsory labour. 3 For the purpose of this article the term "forced or compulsory labour" shall not include: a any work required to be done in the ordinary course of detention imposed according to the provisions of Article 5 of this Convention or during conditional release from such detention; b any service of a military character or, in case of conscientious objectors in countries where they are recognised, service exacted instead of compulsory military service; c any service exacted in case of an emergency or calamity threatening the life or wellbeing of the community; d any work or service which forms part of normal civic obligations.
- willnonya 4y agoYou should try visiting reality occasionally. It's not so bad, you just have to leave your delusions behind at the border.
- dang 4y agoPlease don't break the site guidelines yourself, regardless of how bad another comment was or you feel it was. It only makes things worse. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- dang 4y agoPlease stop posting flamewar comments to HN. It's not what this site is for, and it destroys what it is for, and you've unfortunately been doing it repeatedly (e.g. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33253658 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33253658 - swipes like that are totally not ok). If you'd please review the site guidelines and start following them, we'd appreciate it. Note this one: "Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- maxfurman 4y agoThis article exists because Hyundai noticed, no?
- delusional 4y agoReuters investigating and publishing an article isn't what I'd normally describe as "noticing". That's closer to being told.
- jeffbee 4y agoNo, Hyundai noticed after Reuters broke the story based on police sources four months ago.
- tyingq 4y agoThey noticed because of escalating local news coverage, probably: "Reuters first reported on July 22 that allegations surfaced about SMART’s labor practices after a Guatemalan girl reportedly working at the Hyundai-owned auto supplier went missing from her family’s Alabama home." https://www.fox6now.com/news/hyundai-subsidiary-allegedly-uses-child-labor-report https://www.fox6now.com/news/hyundai-subsidiary-allegedly-us...
- citizenpaul 4y ago>aggressive steps to remedy the situation Who wants to bet those aggressive steps will be. When our contract with the child labor ends we will put out a search for a replacement contract company. This time when we say "CHEAP CHEAP CHEAP Labor on the bid we will specify we don't mean "Child labor cheap" just regular old undocumented slave labor cheap.
- bombcar 4y agoYou might be able to clock 13 year olds from around you, but are you sure you can do it reliably for the entire world?
- moralestapia 4y agoI work on ESG consulting and part of the speech we give is "... ESG is not only environmental, there's other important areas to improve like making sure there's no kids working on your company, blah blah" kind of like a joke and it then triggers more jokes from the other side like "Oh you got us, time to change our plans" etc ... and then we never talk about the subject again because who is going to actually do that, right? Right?! Well, color me amazed, TIL there's child labor happening in the US.
- vasco 4y agoESG is a complete farce in implementation, or at least that's what I gathered once I learned that a tobacco company like Altria can have a 79/100 ESG score. If there's enough "other stuff" that can bring a company who's existence causes death and disease as its main impact on society to 79/100, I don't really care about the scoring system.
- reaperducer 4y agoTIL there's child labor happening in the US. It is extremely unusual for this kind of labor abuse to be carried out by American companies. As the articles note, these are Korean-owned and Korean-operated companies. FTA: "Korean-operated SL Alabama, finding children as young as age 13." There are hundreds of foreign owned and operated factories in America that are run like independent kingdoms, staffed with people from other countries with their own restaurants and dorms so the workers are never exposed to the outside world, so that the company can put the all important "Made in USA" label on the product. There's at least one all-Chinese factory outside of Las Vegas. There was a Chinese-run industrial marijuana farming operation shut down in Arizona last year. And this is not unique to the United States. There are similar operations in Italy, Germany, and elsewhere. There are multiple Chinese factories in Italy churning out "Made in Italy" leather good for the luxury market. Lots of newspaper articles about it over the last ten years or so.
- Ekaros 4y agoDisgusting that we are trading with country that uses child labour... We really should sanction them until provably they have solved this and slavery issue.
- such12 4y agoThe companies using child labor were Korean owned and operated, and this issue was detected and investigated by US media and authorities.
- serf 4y agoI don't really even get who that joke is poking at -- not the US presumably; there is plenty of record of U.S. companies being indifferent to poor labor conditions without a sanctioning reaction.
- eunos 4y agoBut US Government seems hellbent to sanction all of them.
- jrochkind1 4y agoYou realize that country is the USA? I'm not sure if you were being sarcastic or what.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pagade 4y agoReminds me of this: https://twitter.com/chaitex/status/1583118970089263104 https://twitter.com/chaitex/status/1583118970089263104
- such12 4y ago@dang - the title in editorialized and misleading. The actual title is: "Korean auto giant Hyundai investigating child labor in its U.S. supply chain" The article only mentions Korean owned suppliers operating in the US, some directly controlled by Hyundai, which were investigated by Alabama's state Department of Labor, in coordination with federal agencies.
- Noumenon72 4y agoI think this is a relevant observation, given that it changes the emotive thrust of the headline from "foreign country has better standards than our country!" to "our country has good standards that ensure foreign investors don't end up employing child labor".
- herbst 4y agoI've read the article. And honestly the thing I've read is that it's possible for a company to do child labor in the US. And that this actually happens. No comparing, no who is better, just the blunt reality of child labor in the US
- such12 4y ago> And honestly the thing I've read is that it's possible for a company to do child labor in the US. And that this actually happens. You are missing the part where the foreign owned company is caught by the police and investigated by the authorities, and then the crime is reported by the media. This is exactly what you'd expect in a country where child labor is not accepted. It's not honest to omit this part. Indeed it's a deliberate deception.
- phnofive 4y agoPlease contact hn@ycombinator.com for Dan and co. As far as I can tell, they haven't even suspended these suppliers yet.
- Pigalowda 4y agoFrom article As Reuters reported, migrant children from Guatemala found working at SMART Alabama, LLC and SL Alabama had been hired by recruiting or staffing firms in the region. In a statement to Reuters this week, Hyundai said it had already stopped relying on at least one labor recruiting firm that had been hiring for SMART
- la64710 4y agoI hope the right agencies step in to help these kids … brutal as it may be it just might be possible that the kids did not receive any assistance so this (working) was probably their only way of surviving.
- Jolter 4y agoSince they were reported missing to the police, I would assume that you’re right and these kids were trying to survive on their own for one reason or another.
- snake_doc 4y ago
- Jolter 4y agoIt’s possible to be upset by both of these problems, and act to abolish both.
- colejohnson66 4y agoNot to mention that people here have complained about prison labor. It’s just not brought up every day, but when it is, there’s comments complaining.
- LtWorf 4y agoAll the free market lovers never mention how this is literally against the free market.
- WalterSear 4y agoOn the contrary: this is free market end game. A market that is not for sale is not a free market.
- timellis-smith 4y agoIs it? I think true free marketers are about fair competition, and few would argue that legislation is necessary. Allowing one company to benefit by illegal behaviour distorts the market and thus goes against the principles of free markets.
- pbhjpbhj 4y agoReally? "Fair" is not at all a free market concept.
- Dylan16807 4y ago
- jmull 4y agoHere's a link from the article to more information on the child labor violations: https://www.reuters.com/world/us/hyundai-kia-auto-parts-supplier-alabama-fined-child-labor-violations-2022-10-11/ https://www.reuters.com/world/us/hyundai-kia-auto-parts-supp... (This links to more info.) Wow. I think the thing that shocks me the most is that the punishment from the Department of Labor is a very mild slap-on-the-wrist. A small fine and a promise not to do it any more. This should basically be the end of that company entirely. Instead they just have to point the finger at some low-level managers, fire them, and keep on rolling. I would think criminal charges are warranted for importing 12 and 13 year-olds for labor. The children can't consent. That's essentially child slave labor. If Hyundai/Kia drops them, that would at least be a much bigger penalty than the DOL imposed.
- irusensei 4y agoWelcome to current year. Its all good as long as the children been exploited are not the children of the people who vote for you. Its all green as long as the coal or oil burning is being done away from your borders.
- danans 4y ago> Welcome to current year. Its all good as long as the children been exploited are not the children of the people who vote for you. That's been happening forever, not just the current year. Child labor sweatshops were a major source of industrial productivity for centuries the world over until relatively recently. Charles Dickens' novels turned it into an adjective in English bearing his name that described (among other things) the indifference of those in power to child labor.
- greggeter 4y ago
- Yoofie 4y agoThe thing that gets me is the pathetic "punishments" that these companies get. $30k fine + some "training programs". Seriously? There need to be a minimum 5+ zeroes on top of the fine + jail time, or nothing will change.
- coinbasetwwa 4y ago
- dev_tty01 4y ago>The locals out in Alabama are all drugged out. Geez. One visit and you are an expert. Totally off base. California is ranked 29th in drug use and Alabama is 41st out of 50 states. https://wallethub.com/edu/drug-use-by-state/35150 https://wallethub.com/edu/drug-use-by-state/35150
- tptacek 4y agoWorth noting that one of these suppliers appears to have been majority-owned by Hyundai itself. The Hyundai subsidiary apparently targeted the families of recent immigrants.
- legitster 4y agoI'd really like to know more about the "oppressive" part. Were these 12 year olds lying about their age to get a summer job? Or were these children getting pimped by a staffing firm? I think there should be a huge divergence of punishment options based on the actual details.
- guywithahat 4y agoYeah I wonder if the Dad was a manager so he put his son to work or something. They said these were "documented" citizens which I assume means they're not illegal child immigrants. The only other thing we know is that most of these factories were set up by Koreans companies, so they're probably not super small mom and pop shops. The fact they didn't go more in depth into their situation makes me wonder if it's because it goes contrary to the narrative, I know Reuters has a habit of doing that
- refurb 4y agoPretty much this. I remember having a paper route when I was 10 years old. Yeah, not the same thing as a factory line job, but I wanted the job for extra money. If these kids were forced to work, that's horrible, fine the company, punish them hard. But if these were kids working a few 4 hour shifts a week because their parents worked there, then that's entirely different. Not legal, but not the same as exploiting some youngster against their will.
- abeppu 4y agoThis really awful, but maybe it's also an indicator of the flattening effects of globalization? Not so long ago, the unthinkable thing wouldn't have been child labor in the supply chain of a big company, but we all would have expected it to be an American company with Asian manufacturing. Actually relatively recently, I had an executive from an American company express to me earnestly that child sweatshop labor helps grow local economies, and therefore it was misguided to condemn the practice. But it seemed implicit, in a condescending way, that that was justifiable for other people in other places.
- nonrandomstring 4y agoI don't think it's "whataboutism" to point out that we're comfortable buying goods made with child labour so long as they're from another country - and that sets a moral bar for when it's done closer to home. Surely people remember those girls manufacturing Amazon and Apple products at Foxconn, about 14 years old, who tried to kill themselves by jumping off the roof, but Foxconn just installed nets to catch them and bounce them back onto the production line. EDIT: I found the entity investigaing the matter [1]. And also another story indicating that it may have been an internal whsitleblower who began the trail. [1] https://borgenproject.org/labor-exploitation-at-foxconn-china/ https://borgenproject.org/labor-exploitation-at-foxconn-chin... [2] https://www.cnet.com/tech/tech-industry/undercover-reporter-details-work-at-foxconns-iphone-plant/ https://www.cnet.com/tech/tech-industry/undercover-reporter-...
- WastingMyTime89 4y ago> I don't think it's "whataboutism" to point out that we're comfortable buying goods made with child labour so long as they're from another country We very much are not. Both the USA and especially the EU have stringent laws against importing goods produced using child labour. Companies put some serious efforts auditing their suppliers to ensure no child labour is used and every time they fail it becomes a major scandal (see Nike as an exemple). Actually the reason you know Foxconn employed 14 years old is because it was a major violation of child labour law and was widely reported as such. The Chinese state wasn’t happy about that at all. I can assure they didn’t go back to the production lines.
- nonrandomstring 4y agoIf you're trying to paint a picture of justice and the rule of law working all according to plan, I don't buy it. IIRC it was an undercover documentary I watched. Not sure who the team who made it were, and cannot find it on YouTube etc now. But I do not recall it being a labour audit team from Apple or Amazon. Both of whom I remember initially denied the claims, and then distanced themselves from Foxconn (while the story blew-over) before eventually admitting it much later [1] Of course we all know how such inconveniences are spun: it was an "isolated" incident. A few bad apples. Mistakes were made. The (scapegoat) managers have been fired. Lessons learned... etc. > I can assure they didn’t go back to the production lines. On what basis do you make such "assurances"? Because I'm pretty sure you are wrong. For me, a most stomach churning aspect of that whole story was the "soft torture" of the poor kids who were not even able to end their ordeal by suicide. The anti-suicide nets were the company's response instead of changing the awful working conditions. Quite beyond belief. They were designed to catch the workers, who could then be given "counselling" (presumably advice on what would happen to their families if they tried that again) and then returned to work as soon as possible. [1] https://www.industryweek.com/talent/labor-employment-policy/article/21958624/foxconn-admits-that-it-employed-14yearolds-at-a-plant-in-china https://www.industryweek.com/talent/labor-employment-policy/...
- eunos 4y agoWaiting for the sanctions...
- Waterluvian 4y agoFor capitalism to work in the modern era, we need to make an example out of misbehaving companies every so often. Like… destroy the company and throw the officers in prison. I want shareholders so petrified of their stock suddenly being worth nothing that they keep the board in check who makes heads roll when this kind of bullshit is tried. Everything less is a tacit acceptance that child labour is fine as long as you factor the cost into doing business.
- Vt71fcAqt7 4y agoThen manufacturing suddenly moves to a country that doesn't care... as it already has.
- Waterluvian 4y ago“Someone is gonna enslave those children. It might as well be us.”
- Vt71fcAqt7 4y agoThe word "those" is masking your logical fallacy here.
- knaekhoved 4y ago99% of "child labor" cases in the first world are actually completely reasonable. I'm glad I was able to break child labor laws as a kid - it was very helpful for my actual and perceived level of independence, was a great learning experience, and let me overcome meager material conditions. I think a lot of people here had soft lives as kids and extrapolate from that experience that kids are too fragile to handle working or something.
- herbst 4y agoDid you work a 8 hour job in a factory? I think that's a huge different to slightly breaking the child labor laws.
- patientplatypus 4y ago
- jmclnx 4y agoWell if this is true, seems to be another indicator of the US Race to the bottom. 40/50 years ago ,this would have been a big scandal in the US. Since a certain US president in the early 80s, seems the US has been slowly slipping into third world country territory. And the massive "defense" spending another indicator if this.
- dirtyid 4y agoWere they at least paid?
- mlindner 4y agoI'm not sure why people are believing this. This is just China making up fake charges to offset what they're doing in Xianjing.
- lofatdairy 4y agoIs this a troll comment? > Following the Reuters report, Alabama's state Department of Labor, in coordination with federal agencies, began investigating SMART Alabama. Authorities subsequently launched a child labor probe at another of Hyundai's regional supplier plants, Korean-operated SL Alabama, finding children as young as age 13. I can't tell if you're being serious, but you have two comments both casting doubt on this article so maybe you are. The article is reporting on investigations conducted by US authorities, so I suppose you imagine that the US is acting in the interest of China to weaken its own charges against China?
- Animats 4y agoEmployee comments about jobs in that stamping plant.[1] Some of the comments are totally generic and probably fake. The ones that say twelve hour days for five to seven days a week are probably real. [1] https://www.indeed.com/cmp/Smart-Alabama,-LLC/reviews https://www.indeed.com/cmp/Smart-Alabama,-LLC/reviews
- CyanLite4 4y agoSlight problem… you’re firing the whistleblowers at that supplier who reported the problem in the first place. This is going to discourage future whistleblowing for unethical practices.
- 1-6 4y ago“Regulators did not accuse Hyundai and Kia of wrongdoing in the case.” Of course, because they were the ones wrongfully letting this happen without knowing.
- 1-6 4y agoI don’t condone child labor but it made me think: What if I were a 13 year old with good grades and I consented with parents and got a proper work permit. If the money I made went into good investments, that would be a whole lot of compounded money for later in life. I would do it!
- tomcam 4y agoSame. In a heartbeat.
- zulban 4y agoHeh. Good grades? The more kids have to work during school, the worse their grades and educational outcomes are. Work permit? Do you think the factory is following proper work hour restrictions for a kid? Safety... Can a 13 year old be properly trained to be safe in a factory? Consent? Kids cannot consent because they aren't mature enough to consider everything I mentioned. Finally you're assuming the money might be invested, whereas maybe they can't even open a bank account without help. I hope the money becomes theirs. Do you think it will? This is not the American dream, it's the American nightmare. Kids need to be kids. Learning and developing is a very difficult full time job.
- maerF0x0 4y agoI had a friend who had a really bad home life. His mom was abusive and mentally unstable. He moved out at 15, and "child labor" was why he could rent and eat. Nonetheless it should by far, exceedingly, not be the norm. I myself had a job in my school at ~15 myself, it was nbd and I was happy for some spending money that my mom couldn't provide.