6 ms·
It's bad news if you bought a home and the market falls. It's good news for people who want to buy a home and have been waiting for prices to fall. People wh
by paulpauper 4y ago
It's bad news if you bought a home and the market falls.
It's good news for people who want to buy a home and have been waiting for prices to fall.
People who read the Economist probably fall in the former category by demographics.
- bombcar 4y agoIt's bad news if you own a home and the market falls and you need to sell. Otherwise it's some opportunity cost (arguably) but you can continue paying your mortgage payments to stay in your house, and if you hold long enough it'll likely recover. This is different from the last major crash because that time house prices AND mortgage rates both dropped so you could easily feel "trapped" in your underwater house.
- enraged_camel 4y ago>> Otherwise it's some opportunity cost (arguably) but you can continue paying your mortgage payments to stay in your house, and if you hold long enough it'll likely recover. Most people cannot do this though, because the conditions that lead to housing market crashes also result in huge numbers of layoffs. What that means is that not only do people find themselves "underwater" but also unemployed, which means they either can no longer afford their mortgage payments, or sell at a (often huge) loss and start renting and/or relocate.
- neogodless 4y ago> It's bad news if you bought a home and the market falls. If you sell it (quickly). I happened to buy in 2007. House prices fell. But... I sold in 2020. Overall 38.5% price appreciation in 13 years. (Inflation over that time period was roughly 25%.)
- causi 4y agoI don't understand how high prices good news for anyone except people who own multiple houses. Your home is not a luxury. If you're selling it in an inflated market you're also buying in an inflated market, unless you want to throw your money away renting.
- 1123581321 4y agoIt’s good for people who want to sell and live in something smaller, since the market inflated the delta between differently valued houses on an absolute dollars basis. And in the age of increased nomadic living, emigration to low CoL countries and multi-generational households, there might not be much of a replacement to buy or begin to expense. Just explaining, not advocating for selling one’s home to retire.
- eweise 4y agoWell no. Its typical to sell in an inflated market and buy in a cheaper one. Market being a different location.
- syspec 4y agoBy definition that is NOT typical, otherwise the inflated market would have no buyers and the cheaper one would have no sellers
- lazide 4y agoNope - they’re talking about turnover between current ‘have’s’ and ‘have nots’, allowing the have’s to move to an area that someone who is poorer cannot afford to live due to lack of jobs or the like. There are more than enough actual houses in the US. We aren’t short on space. It’s location and current needs based on time in their life and available assets, etc.
- TuringNYC 4y agoIt is good if you want to change jobs and switch cities. If the market has fallen, you cannot sell w/o coughing up the difference in what you owe. (same in the case of owner death/divorce, where you need need to liquidate)
- ericmcer 4y agoGood news for people buying cash. For first time owners who need a loan the falling prices are more than offset by rising interest rates.
- TuringNYC 4y ago>> It's bad news if you bought a home and the market falls. >> It's good news for people who want to buy a home and have been waiting for prices to fall. It is bad news also if the market falls, you buy, and then it falls even more. The problem is the entire system where you are making a 30yr investment just so your family can get a good school district.
- nostrademons 4y agoIt's not that bad as long as you're planning to stay in your home and keep your job. Long-term owners are basically indifferent to housing prices, because they're not going to be making any transactions in the housing market. Same reason Warren Buffett is always marveling over why working-age people think news of stock market declines is bad. If you are a net saver, you want asset prices to be cheap and interest rates to be high, because you'll be a buyer of assets. Also, you're going to be investing in your children for a good 20 years, so it's not that irrational to make a 30yr investment in a house to get them into a good school district.
- jjav 4y ago> The problem is the entire system where you are making a 30yr investment just so your family can get a good school district. A good school district can be nice (if you'll have kids and if you'll send them to that public school) but the primary reason to have a home is have a place to live where the costs are predictable over the long term, unlike renting.
- bombcar 4y agoEven if you have no children, the people you sell your house to may, so a good school district is a thing to keep an eye on. It’s also shorthand for a bunch of other things that boil down to “things are being managed decently well”. If you know you’re buying the house they’ll carry you out of to the last 6 feet you’ll own, then you can be much more flexible.