6 ms·
> They're not particularly motivated to close this loophole either, for reasons which should be obvious. Agreed, but the ban on federal officials owning indivi
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
> They're not particularly motivated to close this loophole either, for reasons which should be obvious.
Agreed, but the ban on federal officials owning individual stocks is actually gaining momentum and I think has a good chance of passing, though what happens in November may change that.
- rootusrootus 4y agoIn this case, though, they were not buying & selling individual stocks. So we would need to ban them from owning any equities, even shares of S&P 500 index funds.
- insanitybit 4y agoI don't see why they should be banned from being a part of a double blind fund.
- elromulous 4y agoDouble blind? Consider e.g. knowledge the Fed is planning on raising interest rates before the public has it. That affects the market as a whole, so they could short sp500 and have a leg up on us regular folks. The solution is simple. Being in office (or working for the federal government, or any level government for that matter) is a privilege, not a right. If you want to exercise that privilege, then you should have to give up the right to directly trade any stock/fund. Your broker whom you can't divulge any info to then has the same footing as the rest of us.
- giantg2 4y ago"(or working for the federal government, or any level government for that matter)" I don't think this is right. My small town government isn't going to make any money on trading. Even if we contracted with a company big enough to be public, the contract would be too small to make any impact. Also, most in the military or civilian contractor positions have no real insight into the market moving deals. Nor do they generally have the capital to really take advantage. It's the high level officials and bureaucrats that need to be restricted, not the rank and file.
- foobarian 4y agoYou could argue the high level officials will find a way around any restrictions anyway, so all you will do is punish the rank and file no matter what.
- insanitybit 4y ago> Double blind? Consider e.g. knowledge the Fed is planning on raising interest rates before the public has it. That affects the market as a whole, so they could short sp500 and have a leg up on us regular folks. No, that's not how that would work. You'd treat it the same way that you do with executives owning stock but having insider knowledge. All of their transfers are done on a schedule and changes to the schedule have to be done in advance.
- karmelapple 4y agoAgreed. You become an official? Congrats, you no longer have direct control of your investments. Would that be such a downer for people looking to serve in government? Certain special limits seem reasonable to apply to government officials that have special knowledge or other authority.
- insane_dreamer 4y agoThat's a much harder case to make.
- nyc_data_geek1 4y agoCertainly hope it passes! Though with a high enough security clearance I'd imagine you could make a killing just going long/short on index funds, so I don't know how effective this would be at curbing the behavior. What we really need is all assets of elected officials held in blind trust, bar none, no exceptions, I think. Though I'm no hedge fund wizard and I'm sure there's a loophole to exploit there as well.
- SoftTalker 4y ago> What we really need is all assets of elected officials held in blind trust, bar none, no exceptions. Yes absolutely. I would also add: - Mandatory retirement from public office at age 65. We have minimum ages for elected office, nothing wrong with a maximum age. - Ban on lobbying for 10 years after leaving office.
- jrd259 4y agoWhy the age cap? Is there a evidence that elderly are statistically more likely to be corrupt than the young? Or perhaps you think we (I'm 66) have suffered significant cognitive decline?
- kodyo 4y agoOlder people are less likely to have to face the long term consequences of their corruption and depravity.
- soulofmischief 4y agoThis is a credible take and I would love see more discussion about this.
- robocat 4y agoDon’t target some bigoted stereotype. Target the problem of corruption. You can as easily argue the opposite: older people can be more conscientious because they have less to gain and less to lose. Who cares more about a payoff: someone who already has their gains and fewer years left, or the hungrier younger person? I suspect you have based your “fact” on sampling bias - we don’t get good visibility metrics on young corrupted politicians (not so many young politicians, not so much time for them to have been caught making egregious errors). Disclaimer: middle-aged engineer type.
- Traubenfuchs 4y agoWhat would keep them from telling their extended family or close friends the insider information?
- nyokodo 4y agoThat’s the same problem as any other kind of insider trading.
- Arrath 4y agoWith the added bonus of possibly dipping into classified information.
- charlieyu1 4y agoInside trading is illegal to begin with. The problem is with prosecutions. That’s why I don’t think more bans will do anything.
- Supermancho 4y agoHaving the profits owned by another person adds risk from an insider trading scheme. Both risk in terms of information leaking and the "friend or family" simply having control of the money/goods. This is as good a start at curbing this behavior, as is practical right now.
- anigbrowl 4y agoStiff prison terms
- busterarm 4y agoThen we just need term limits and to kill civil asset forfeiture
- 23skidoo 4y agoLet's get rid of qualified immunity and add stronger protections against eminent domain while we're at it. Also, we need to address corrupt judges, we have very few legal mechanisms for that.
- busterarm 4y agoI would like to drastically claw it back but I think there are limited circumstances where that immunity should apply. At the very least, criminal immunity and being required to carry large insurance policies for civil damages. Paid for out of pocket and underwritten based on their job performance/complaints.
- 23skidoo 4y agoPolice are people and people make mistakes, this needs to be recognized on some level, but QI as it is now is positively un-American. We're supposed to have checks and balances and recourse for misdeeds. Nobody should be above the law. You literally need circumstances like those surrounding George Floyd to hold police accountable in this country. 2A was supposed to be insurance against nonsense like this.
- colinmhayes 4y agoand gerrymandering. And FPTP.
- yamtaddle 4y ago> Then we just need term limits The best argument I know against this is that it shifts power toward lobbyists and all those awful "deep state" people (you know, career civil servants) everyone suddenly started being worried about a few years ago, and away from elected officials.
- ren_engineer 4y agodoes it include spouses? Also doesn't prevent them from getting paid for information via other means. Or being promised cushy board positions once they are out of congress
- toss1 4y agoRather than banning officials from owning individual stocks, just make all trades transparent in real time along with actual beneficial ownership (e.g., if someone owns stocks through an LLC, Trust, etc.). This would nearly instantly eliminate most of the advantage of insider trading with far less regulatory overhead and the inevitable over- and under-prosecution of crimes. Elon Musk or Mark Cuban or some legislator starts buying batches of options? Everyone already knows and the market can move on it's own.
- insane_dreamer 4y agowon't pass if GOP controls house and/or senate post-Nov
- nosequel 4y agoPelosi and her husband are the worst offenders in all of the house, it won't pass if the GOP or the Dem's control the house, don't kid yourself.
- insane_dreamer 4y agoAgreed on Pelosi. But at least you have a pretty vocal contingent of House Dems pushing for it who might get their way; whereas on the GOP side nothing.
- pkt_nspktr 4y agoIn both the House and Senate, Republicans have proposed legislation to close this loophole. It's been Democrat-controlled committees that have prevented these from moving forward. Even Democratic bills have not made it out of committee, despite public pronouncements back in September. This seems like a issue that could get true bi-partisan support, but it will take Democratic leadership to move a bill out of committee at this point in time. House: H.R.6490 - Banning Insider Trading in Congress Act (https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/house-bill/6490 https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/house-bill/6490), Sponsor: Rep. Hartzler, Vicky [R-MO-4] Senate: S.3504 - Banning Insider Trading in Congress Act (https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/senate-bill/3504?r=33&s=1 https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/senate-bill/350...) Sponsor: Sen. Hawley, Josh [R-MO] Found this Democrat-sponsored bill: H.R.8990 - Combatting Financial Conflicts of Interest in Government Act (https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/house-bill/8990?r=1&s=4 https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/house-bill/8990...), Sponsor: Rep. Lofgren, Zoe [D-CA-19] EDIT: removed markdown formatting
- briffle 4y agoHonestly, I would be okay with allowing them to continue to own stocks, but all trading activity is published in real time. I honestly think that would be more telling than just making them not own them.