12 ms·
The great semiconductor drought may be about to break
- urthor 4y agoMay.
- j_walter 4y ago>Some chipmakers don't appear to have got the memo and are pushing ahead. Micron, for example, recently announced a $100 billion chip fab destined for New York state. Yeah, and Intel announced similar for Ohio...and how is that going. A lot different to announce an eventual fab than to actually invest that money next year (which is the TSMC portion of the story).
- bonestamp2 4y agoThe capacity might not be needed, but the political stability may be (or not).
- juve1996 4y agoPeople have short term vision because everything gets reduced to quarterly results now. Changes take time. Investing now makes sense - not for the next quarter or year - but for the next decade. Is anyone really going to bet the chip market won't be larger in 10 years?
- oytis 4y agoDepending on how technology progresses the market for chips manufactured with today's processes might or might not be larger.
- juve1996 4y agoIs that true now? My understanding is the chip shortage isn't just in high end new chips, but also older chips for use in things like cars and other embedded applications.
- bonestamp2 4y ago> everything gets reduced to quarterly results now Yes, it's interesting how we're so short sighted in the west compared to some parts of Asia and Europe. For example: my friend works for a Japanese company and their roadmap and outlook for success of a new product is 10 years. I was listening to a podcast and they were interviewing a guy from luxury conglomerate LVMH and they think about how today's products will affect their brand in 100 years. That's an extreme example of course, but it's still an interesting perspective to consider.
- willis936 4y agoMy mom excitedly told me about a large fab coming to NY recently and I told her it likely was not going to be built then pointed to examples where big tech companies have fucked over communities in the recent past.
- j_walter 4y agoI don't believe it's their intention to fuck the community over, but more to try to secure some of that CHIPS money. Intel, TSMC, TI and Samsung actively have fabs being built, but they are slowing them down right now. TSMC is the only one actively saying they are cutting CapEx next year while Intel has actively canceled orders for some of their new fab tools but have not admitted such.
- flyinglizard 4y agoI think these domestic fans are heavily subsidized and will go forward anyhow. It takes years to bring an advanced fab online so the state of the market in the next 2-3 years is immaterial.
- systemvoltage 4y agoCan confirm. Just bought 10k units of STM32L4R5ZI, shipping to the assembly house. We didn't procure it direclty, but through our ODM, message from our vendor is that there is a huge dump of semiconductors of all shapes and sizes in Asia. Actually, this is a batch that we bought as insurance due to long leadtimes. Now we will have excess inventory of assembled pcbs but xmas is coming and we could churn through inventory. The market is about to collapse and prices are going to plummet sharply in next 3 months. I suspect many companies have bought insurance and it is about to bite them in the ass with excess inventory.
- hef19898 4y agoThe Bullwhip Effect knows no mercy.
- yuvalr1 4y agoWill this collapse affect the price of popular brands like Mac, Pixel etc?
- mcv 4y agoI would certainly welcome a dramatic price drop. It's ridiculous how expensive some processors have been these past couple of years.
- e-_pusher 4y agoSounds like good news for companies trying to build right now!
- Gibbon1 4y agoWe got an unexpected drop of 20k units of NXP micro's after being cut off completely in September.
- joezydeco 4y agoThat may be true for ST but NXP is still quoting me 60+ weeks for LPC and Kinetis parts. Most of that is targeted to automotive but I don't see a flood of cars coming off the lines either. Where are these parts? STM32 also seems to be counterfeited more than other lines. Kind of glad I don't have to sift through that right now.
- idontwantthis 4y agoDoes this specify the kind of semiconductor needed most for electric cars?
- bombolo 4y agoRegular cars need semiconductors as well. Anyway for cars part of the problem originated when with covid they cancelled all orders and the assembly lines for their stuff got converted. Then their managers layoff workers and periodically go on the news, taking great care of never mentioning that it was partly their own fault.
- kristopolous 4y agoThe LEAN/Toyota production model had this catastrophic failure built in because it got rid of all slack. That meant that all buffers we're removed and any interruption caused cascading amplifying consequences. You get something like a pandemic and the consequences mean that interdependent feedback systems get broken. You read all these 1990s TPS books that are like "we switched to this system and there's no costs! Everything was better" This is the fundamental risk tradeoff coming back. It's always there, as reliable as a natural force. The classic works but like Womack always had that red flag. It's like 300 pages of skimpy on exacting procedural details and zero talk of downside. Everything works as long as 100% of your arbitrary selection of infinite supplies can magically appear on the loading dock perfectly on time (well usually it actually can, except when it can't)
- hef19898 4y agoSlack =|= buffer. Slack is, ironically, increasing the likelyhood of those things happeneing. Well managed buffers can mitigate them. Nothing prevents bad decisions from happening and no amount of inventory can save you from a pandemic induced disruption of global supply chains, because nobody has the money to fund those inventories. And even having those funds, it would be much wiser to use them in actively managing your suoply chains instead o just building slack... Fun fact: Toyota was among the least affected manufacturers, so much for TPS doesn't work. Second fun fact: When it comes to supply chains everybody not working in SCM seems to know better when somethung goes wrong ehile ignoring all the times stuff just "magically" shows up. This is true for all backbone domains so, from utilities over supply chains all the way to waste removal and the medical profession. The latter less so due to all those drama series.
- donedealomg 4y ago
- Animats 4y ago"Semiconductor lead times were down four days on average last month. ... On average, lead times still measure in the half-a-year range, at 26.3 weeks." Not sure that means much. That 2% improvement is down near the noise threshold. There are a large number of new fabs under construction, but few come onstream before next year. We'll probably have a semiconductor glut by 2024, if China doesn't attack Taiwan.
- jhoechtl 4y agoMany of theses newcomers will default in 2024 when prices plummet due to oversupply. We had it all in 1999/2000/2001 when the dot com burst brought retail internet fees drastically down. I think it is comparable.
- crote 4y agoAnd that's even assuming the new fabs will produce the chips currently out of stock. The current exceptional shortages are mostly in legacy nodes, whereas newly constructed fabs will mainly be producing on cutting-edge nodes. Building new fabs for legacy nodes simply isn't economically viable.
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoWouldn't that mean the old fabs or their equipment will go down the line to make older chips? I figured that's how it goes with these things.
- magicalhippo 4y agoThe way I've understood it, the expensive part of producing a chip is making the mask set, and the mask set is intimately related to the process producing the chip. That is, you typically can't take a mask set used at one foundry and start producing at another foundry without further ado. In some cases one can do it[1], but I imagine it requires a fair bit of money to port the mask sets and qualify the new parts. A specific process at a foundry might be sufficiently unique that there's few if any alternative foundries, I believe this was the case for AKM's factory which burned down[2]. If an old part still sells it's often high-volume "jelly bean" stuff, in which case it makes economic sense to let the old machines run as long as they can as they're written off entirely, but not to invest a lot in upgrades. If it's low-volume niche stuff, the price per unit is high, but that means any upgrade cost would drive up prices a lot due to low volume. Thus any customers still hanging on to some old design requiring that part might consider such a price hike a good time to redesign their circuit instead. [1]: https://www.latticesemi.com/-/media/LatticeSemi/Documents/ProductChangeNotification/PCN12/PCN01A12NotificationofIntenttoUtilizeanAlternateQualifiedMaskSetandFoundryfortheispPACPOWRPowerManagerIIProducts.ashx?document_id=44281 https://www.latticesemi.com/-/media/LatticeSemi/Documents/Pr... [2]: https://www.diyaudio.com/community/threads/akm-factory-fire-will-have-a-terrible-impact-on-the-audio-indusrty.362358/#post-6395374 https://www.diyaudio.com/community/threads/akm-factory-fire-...
- beebeepka 4y agoBoom and bust. The industry had a phenomenal last few years and now it's time for adjustment. Some sectors,like HDD and memory, rely on the annual floods (hehe) to keep stuff from getting cheaper, but not all of them. I have the money but also tons of patience. No, 2000+ euro for a video card is not a good deal. Even half that is too much. Sadly, I know a good amount of people who fall for the hype and actually do buy overpriced stuff because it's cheaper than a few months ago
- stavros 4y agoI just bought a used 3060 for $250, definitely nowhere near $2000.
- Roark66 4y agoThis is pretty cool. I hope the 30x0 cards come even more down in price once new AMD cards show up. In other news, did no one noticed USD is now worth more than one EUR? For us in EU this sucks because adding our ~20% vat on top of prices (plus whatever local sellers feel they can get away with) the prices still feel too high for many people. I worry the trend mentioned in the article doesn't reflect better supply, but lower demand due to incoming recession.
- beebeepka 4y agoThis is exactly what I am talking about. I paid 400 euro for a brand new 1070FE back in 2016 and here you are refuting my statement with a line that you have bought a used 3060 for 250 dollars how many years after release? I am glad you are happy with your purchase and yet I wouldn't pay that for a new 3060, even if I wanted one
- stavros 4y agoYour statement was about 2000 or 1000 EUR for a card. How much do you think is a fair price for new 3060s? 50 EUR?
- 4y ago
- gw99 4y agoI suspect it’ll go down the toilet again the moment China kicks off at Taiwan properly. Not because TSMC but sanctions and supply chain issues.
- frippertronics 4y agoThe latest Electronic Design to Delivery Index (EDDI) report for September (available here [1], but behind a free subscription) indicates this as well, with a general increase in component supply. IC's are still low, but have been increasing since the seemingly largest recent dip in supply in May 2021. It's going to be interesting to see the report for October to see if the trend is continued. [1]: https://nexar.com/spectra/eddi https://nexar.com/spectra/eddi
- bell-cot 4y agoOn top of the usual supply/demand dynamic, my impression was that a lot of [clever|greedy|evil] speculators bought up large quantities of many SKU's. If true, and those speculators feel a sudden need to to unwind their positions - things might get interesting++.
- VLM 4y agoIf "everyone knows" via the media that there's going to be a toilet paper run on chips and your business depends on shipping product, you'd be a fool not to stock up while there was still stock, instead of going out of business until the nonsense blows over. So I know a small time Ham Radio kit mfgr (its like a one man shop) who STILL has about three years sales volume of Arduino-alike chips in his closet. Sucks locking up that much money in inventory AND contributing to a toilet-paper run, but for him it beats unemployment, and for me, I can buy and build his kits which is better than not being able to... In a greater economic policy way, its an inflation-reducer. He has a huge pile of money locked up in his closet in the form of unprogrammed Arduino chips, instead of hyperinflating stuff he could have bought like a better spectrum analyzer or real estate or whatever else.
- sokoloff 4y agoI bought about five years of my small-scale production back in Dec 2019 (what amounted to full reels of most parts, not because I wanted five years specifically). That was driven initially by MLCC cap supply “weirdness”, but while I was buying, it was dirt cheap (well under $2000) to just buy all the components. It’s come in handier than I expected for the MCU shortages, but it’s also been really nice to not have to even look at stock/lead times when considering/prototyping new products. I wouldn't be surprised if keeping 180 days of high-running, common parts on hand becomes the norm for high-margin products.
- phlipski 4y agoYou're probably on to something there. JITD may morph to JITD+B (+B = plus buffer).
- 4y ago
- zeristor 4y agoTo paraphrase Oprah Winfrey: "You get a Raspberry Pi, and you get a Raspberry Pi, and you get a Raspberry Pi, ..." I am tracking the strike price on eBay, with greater supply the price should edge down towards the market price, looking to see at what point the price will drop down. Although price is one value, it would be handy to have an idea of the depth of the market at that price, it isn't as though there are thousands listed.
- squarefoot 4y agoIt is possible that scalpers will delay the prices return to normality for a while, by buying large lots where possible, therefore prolonging the scarcity. However, they'll have to sell them earlier than say those bought a couple years ago. Fingers crossed.
- hhjinks 4y agoI ordered 4 4GB Pi 4s at $90 a pop in January. They were meant to arrive a few weeks later, but I was a few hours too late to get units from that batch. The next batch would've arrived later this month, but I canceled the order a couple weeks ago. Really hoping I can pick some up for cheaper soon.
- zgniatacz 4y agohttps://shop.pimoroni.com/products/raspberry-pi-4-essentials-kit?variant=40110476165203 https://shop.pimoroni.com/products/raspberry-pi-4-essentials...
- sokoloff 4y agoWhat you’re tracking is market price. You’re hoping it falls towards an MSRP or other price.
- Vt71fcAqt7 4y agoGood point.
- zeristor 4y ago
- cutler 4y agoExcept for Russia guffaw, guffaw.
- bullen 4y agoWe're going from semiconductor shortage to assembly shortage. The real shortage is energy, and that is why the US HAS the strangle the dollar liquidity. FIAT money is only worth something if it's backed by scarcity and violence. It's downhill from here for eternity, I suspect you wont be able to buy anything off the shelf in a couple of months/years. Which is why you should buy last generations quality hardware now at peak architecture/lithography (14nm Atom, 14nm Xeon 4-core (larger has memory contention and is too power hungry), 28nm Raspberry 4). This generation and the next is/will be less open/repairable and have higher max TDP which is a problem with unreliable power.
- yrgulation 4y agoIdk know how to phrase this in a polite and calm manner. What the heck are our politicians in the eu, us and aligned countries. This pandemic and the war revealed that we are extremely vulnerable both in terms of resources and electronics. Why is there no serious change in how we source both. At least for electronics why arent there plans for massive investments? I understand east europe is orders of magnitude more expensive than asia but if cost is a factor the area is still cheaper than western europe or the us. Or why not invest in semiconductor manufacturing in the us and west eu using modern robotics and processes? Do we enjoy being held for ransom?
- bayindirh 4y agoFrom Isaac Asimov's Gods Themselves: “PRACTICAL POLITICS”—AND THE DEATH OF A WORLD “Let me give you a lesson in practical politics.” Senator Burt looked at his wristwatch, leaned back and smiled. “It is a mistake,” he said, “to suppose that the public wants the environment protected or their lives saved and that they will be grateful to any idealist who will fight for such ends. What the public wants is their own individual comfort. “Now then, young man, don’t ask me to stop the Pumping. The economy and comfort of the entire planet depend on it. Tell me, instead, how to keep the Pumping from exploding the Sun.” Lamont said, “There is no way, Senator. We are dealing with something here that is so basic, we can’t play with it. We must stop it.” “Ah, and you can suggest only that we go back to matters as they were before Pumping.” “We must.” “In that case, you will need hard and fast proof that you are right.” “The best proof,” Lamont said stiffly, “is to have the Sun explode.”
- mastax 4y agoDid you miss the CHIPS act, and the other US and EU actions I can't remember the names of?
- b4je7d7wb 4y agoI think our politicians are busy thinking how we will not freeze and starve. Building a fab in close proximity of russia or other unstable areas is probably not a priority right now.
- 4y ago