14 ms·
Rent going up? One company’s algorithm could be why
- hammock 4y agoI lived in one or two of these Greystar, etc buildings that used this software. They are expensive buildings. You can negotiate if you find the right people though (99% won’t be able to do this), it is rare and difficult.
- matt3210 4y agoBefore I switched to better living arrangement, the property manager at my apartment complex had the goal of sending my account to collection with a 100% fee for collections paperwork. These people don't have empathy or compassion.
- shaburn 4y agoAll good until its not. Ask Zillow about betting on Real Estate algorithms, regardless of anti-competitive behavior.
- rebelos 4y agoRealPage seems to have recognized that multiple competing landlords in the same region who are independently setting rates and concerned about vacancy is a kind of prisoner's dilemma situation. Seems obvious they exploited that opportunity. Absolutely diabolical.
- leereeves 4y agoThis sounds like price fixing as a service, but I wonder if the law is prepared to handle it. The FTC guidance on price fixing[1] only discusses "agreement among competitors", and never mentions each party outsourcing pricing to the same service. If the competitors never meet or agree on anything, is it still illegal? 1: https://www.ftc.gov/advice-guidance/competition-guidance/guide-antitrust-laws/dealings-competitors/price-fixing https://www.ftc.gov/advice-guidance/competition-guidance/gui...
- paulryanrogers 4y agoCollusion by proxy is still collusion. My guess is their marketing will take care never to put in writing that effect, yet still communicating it with a wink and a nod.
- hammock 4y agoIt could be. There is something called tacit collusion, I am not immediately aware of case law involving a third party algorithm though. Here is a paper discussing the exact scenario: https://mdpi-res.com/d_attachment/sustainability/sustainability-13-00951/article_deploy/sustainability-13-00951-v2.pdf?version=1611207775 https://mdpi-res.com/d_attachment/sustainability/sustainabil...
- dasil003 4y ago> If the competitors never meet or agree on anything, is it still illegal? No idea how the laws were written, but the vast majority were conceived before modern big data systems were possible, and even today most regulators are unprepared for arguments like this (from the article): > Using software like YieldStar is “taking what we used to do manually on a yellow pad and calling people on the phone and putting it on a codified system where you take the errors out of the pricing,” he said. Modern big data and ML capabilities mean that not only is the human removed from the details of the process, but even understanding the mechanics and relative weight of different inputs becomes all but impossible. Large-scale human-based processes can still feel opaque and arbitrary from the outside, but at least there are entry points for human empathy and (more importantly) accountability. As we saw in the 2008 financial crisis, it's a very dangerous state of affairs when the risks and rewards of financial innovation are decoupled across different parties by means of opaque and unintelligible instruments. Computers are not the same as paper.
- treis 4y ago>Modern big data and ML capabilities But for the most part this stuff doesn't work. And I think in this specific case if there were really some secret sauce they'd make a lot more money as property flippers. Buy underperforming property for cheap, apply secret magic, and sell much better performing property for much more would make you way more money than selling a SAAS.
- whywhywhydude 4y agoWow, this is a brazen price collusion. No doubt about it. Using private data to fix prices and asking landlords to keep units vacant rather than decrease rents.
- boole1854 4y agoI'm not sure it's so clear. "Using private data" to set prices is hardly nefarious on its own, even if the result is higher prices. After all, "price stickiness" is a well known phenomena in the economics literature (and it can lead to sub-optimal allocation of resources). Maybe this is just a way to make prices less sticky. On the other hand, if the system recommends keeping units vacant, that does start to suggest that it is enabling landowners to take advantage of monopolistic pricing power. Yet higher vacancy rates could actually be socially optimal as well. A similar phenomena occurs in the movie theater business. Theater owners often price tickets such that the "vacancy" rates (empty seats) are quite high. However, a law that required pricing tickets low enough to fill all seats would reduce the return on equity in the industry so much that investment in the theater industry would plummet, vastly reducing the number of theater seats available available to fill consumer demand in the medium to long term.
- theGnuMe 4y ago>Theater owners often price tickets such that the "vacancy" rates (empty seats) are quite high. However, a law that required pricing tickets low enough to fill all seats would reduce the return on equity in the industry so much that investment in the theater industry would plummet, vastly reducing the number of theater seats available available to fill consumer demand in the medium to long term. This sounds like a nonsensical economic argument. Do you have a mathematical model that supports this argument?
- maerF0x0 4y agoHigher vacancy == more choice where to live. The customer does get at least some benefit.
- jeffbee 4y agoIf the software allows them to take advantage of their supply monopoly, the software is not the problem. It's the lack of competition. Every housing discussion boils down to this: the black/grey stone/star/rock REITs are in this space because local governments have rigged the game to favor them. If the governments start rubber-stamping developer permits, the REITs will get their faces ripped off.
- ok_dad 4y agoAnyone involved with this type of business should be ashamed of themselves. This is a absolutely disgusting collusion of literal rent seekers. I can’t wait until “you’ll own nothing and like it” happens, so we can see a real revolution. People won’t stand for this, right?
- p4coder 4y agoRent increase has been one of the biggest contributor to core inflation [0]. That has caused fed to raised interest rate at a rapid clip and cause the market crash. So is an algorithm responsible for the blood on wall st? [0] https://www.corelogic.com/intelligence/the-role-of-rent-in-inflation-measurement/ https://www.corelogic.com/intelligence/the-role-of-rent-in-i...
- thunky 4y ago
- toiletfuneral 4y ago
- richbell 4y ago> Bottom line is that this service is not responsible for higher rents, the market is. This service is directly and indirectly responsible for landlord's increasing rent for their tenants. Blaming "the market" is a convenient way to cast blame away from people responsible onto a nebulous concept. Companies like Zillow use software based on "the market" to determine housing prices. But for all intents and purposes they are responsible for driving up housing prices based on actions informed by their software, because their actions directly influence "the market".
- defterGoose 4y agoThis is what so many "free market" hawks tend to misunderstand. The market is not an acyclic network, but is still strongly ordered in its power imbalance. 'The world is in greater peril from those who tolerate or encourage evil than from those who actually commit it.' -Albert Einstein
- anigbrowl 4y agoMost of them understand it just fine. They just don't care as long as it benefits them in the short term. Sure, you could talk about the long term unsustainability, but they quite reasonably figure that they'll be better positioned over the long term by virtue of having a lot more money.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- setgree 4y agoThis reminds me of management consulting. The consultants come in, recommend you fire 10% of your workforce, and when you pull the trigger you say, sorry McKinsey made me do it! Likewise, the recommendations made by the software are non-binding, but if pushed you say “well the algorithm said so…” In either case, it’s the c-suite/property manager making the call. But it seems that we like a measure of distance between ourselves and unpleasant decisions. The algorithm/well-groomed 20-somethings provide a kind of plausible deniability. The answer is, of course, a ton more housing.
- HideousKojima 4y ago
- richbell 4y agoWhile I don't know your intentions behind this comment, I'll add that high immigration is a core policy in places like Canada explicitly so they don't have to solve any problems around labour or financial policy. Skilled immigrants tend to have lots of money to spend and no debt; unskilled immigrants are exploited in schemes where they work below minimum wage at menial jobs (e.g., https://financialpost.com/news/retail-marketing/foreign-workers-sleeping-in-burger-king-basement-alberta-health-services https://financialpost.com/news/retail-marketing/foreign-work... or https://jacobin.com/2021/12/coffee-chain-fast-food-labor-pay-working-condition#:~:text=Tim%20Hortons%20has%20made%20extensive,by%20providing%20a%20dispensable%20workforce https://jacobin.com/2021/12/coffee-chain-fast-food-labor-pay...). I used to work for a government employment centre. It was depressing how many highly educated people emigrated to Canada for promises of a better life and ended up driving Ubers because they were mislead about earning potential or education equivalency.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tonyarkles 4y agoMan, even skilled labour… there was a gas station near my old house in Saskatoon. One night I was chatting with the guy that was working and we got to talking about work a bit. Turns out he actually has a Masters in Electrical Engineering, but the easiest way for him to come to Canada was to be sponsored by Petro-Can and work at the gas station for, I don’t recall exactly, 2-3 years. He was looking for volunteer work to do to try to stay sharp in the meantime. Crazy!
- mattkrause 4y ago'Such agents sometimes hesitated to push rents higher. Roper said they were often peers of the people they were renting to. “We said there’s way too much empathy going on here,” he said. “This is one of the reasons we wanted to get pricing off-site.”' Yikes!
- IAmGraydon 4y ago[flagged]
- armatav 4y agoIt’s a system where relentless money printing cripples it by forcing that perspective. You need to gamble in order to keep your shirt, or you need to raise prices. Simple solution is not to print money. Capitalism is not the problem.
- carlivar 4y agoI agree. As an exercise, consider who has more impact over your life: Joseph Biden or Jay Powell?
- svnpenn 4y agoI totally agree. Apple makes $300 billion in revenue a year, they are barely keeping their shirt!
- armatav 4y agoApple’s not a single dude working for $40 an hour into his broken savings account last time I checked. Downvote it all you want, money printing is the issue - not “capitalism”. Sound money eliminates this problem.
- svnpenn 4y agoYou are totally right. Companies would never do stuff like using handouts on stock buybacks instead of workers right? Right?
- jareklupinski 4y agoA few days ago, someone posted an article about Work Number and how it lets basically any corp pull your current salary. At the time, I didn't see the harm in allowing it, since I didn't see a situation where this could be used against me. After reading this article, I froze my data. I believe landlords should price rentals based on the value of their property, not the value of its tenants.
- UweSchmidt 4y agoAs usual, systems allow for the few people who really care to opt-out, preventing backlash but not impeding the system's function.
- dorchadas 4y agoCan you give a link to how to freeze it?
- jareklupinski 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33210775 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33210775 this thread has a bunch of details, I went the email route https://employees.theworknumber.com/employee-data-freeze/ https://employees.theworknumber.com/employee-data-freeze/
- q7xvh97o2pDhNrh 4y agoYeah, I've seen "The Work Number" popping up more and more — usually buried deep inside the company's HR documentation. I've personally opted out entirely, instead of just going for the freeze. (In their terminology, a "freeze" lets them keep all your data and continue harvesting new data, whereas an "opt out" instructs them to delete all your data entirely.) Another important detail: At my company (and presumably many others), it's not just your base salary that's sent over to The Work Number. It's also full details about your equity comp. I've grudgingly disclosed my base salary as needed (leasing applications, etc), and it's easy enough to do without involving The Work Number because most employers are fine with generating an employment-verification letter. But I don't see any reason why the average landlord would need to know about my equity package, so I found that bit especially unsettling.
- zdragnar 4y agoLocal metro put in a light rail line years ago through an area with the expectation that it would re-invigorate those neighborhoods and cause more housing to be built. For years, there was very little movement; existing rents and land values along the line were too low for anyone to bother building additional dense housing. This failure, among others, became a talking point among those who have tried to stall building additional lines. Now, with the metro in an acute housing crunch, rents have gone up enough that investors are finally building more housing along the light rail line. What are they building? Small, chic apartments geared towards young people. It's not really the sort of thing that fosters strong communities, as anyone who wants to start a family is unlikely to stay there long term. There's really only two outcomes I see: housing prices stabilize at marginally affordable at best, or the "character" they are trying to go for disappears not long after the housing bubble pops, and the area becomes blighted. All of this is to say that there are market-driven price floors on housing that aren't easy to shift. The "just build housing" mantra might be over-estimating the extent to which people are willing to accept prices going down. There's better ways to make money elsewhere for the people you expect to do the building and management after a certain point.
- Jasper_ 4y agoIt seems absurd to me that they'd judge the success of public transit as when the property values go up, rather than whether people are riding it and using it. We should build public transit because it's an improvement on quality of life for the community, not because people who don't live there will see a return on investment. Housing prices will always be a bubble, as long as they're so detached and distant from the communities they're trying to build.
- zdragnar 4y agoThe people who ride the lines were already getting from point A to point B using other means (cars, busses, taxis), so ridership isn't really a useful metric. Pretty much all of the lines that are being built are being sold as ways to improve the economy along the line, as people are pulled out of cars and off the freeway (i.e. greater visibility of local stores and housing options to commuters).
- ineedasername 4y agoSeems like it’s real easy for them to assert something very like monopoly or cartel-like price manipulations on behalf of landlords without even doing so deliberately. Once enough people use your product it’s easy to make a claim like “raises average rent by X%” and have it be a self-fulfilling prophecy simply by virtue of tweaking the algorithm to favor increases regardless of market fundamentals and competition.
- codekansas 4y agoFor the past few months I've been in a somewhat unusual housing situation. My wife is a medical resident in NYC, and the hospital system she works for is quite large and owns a lot of NYC property. They offer their employees subsidized housing at greatly reduced rates (meaning, an 1100 sq. ft. Manhattan apartment for $2300 a month). It has a "company town" feel, but it has been great for us, and the incentives seem like they're aligned in this case - employers have an incentive against being extractive because it reduces their employees' effective compensation. The residency program is 7 years which means we're stuck here anyway, and we don't have to worry too much about about her being fired or wanting to find a new job. In a competitive labor market like tech / finance / medicine it seems like employer-subsidized housing isn't a terrible idea, and is an alternative to just relocating corporate offices to a lower CoL area.
- cced 4y ago> it seems like employer-subsidized housing isn't a terrible idea, and is an alternative to just relocating corporate offices to a lower CoL area. Would this be in a way similar to how we've tied health care to employer-based insurance? If so, I'm not sure I'd want to be in a position where my employer subsidizing my housing makes it difficult to leave said employer for better opportunities or, god forbid, you lose your job and then home subsidy.
- toast0 4y agoI think it makes sense in some cases and hospital residency is one. It's a temporary position (even if temporary is 7 years), often where the employee has limited influence on the location. They're likely to have lived somewhere else before taking the position, and will live somewhere else after the position. There are existing strong incentives to not move jobs during residency, so an additional one won't hurt too much.
- ghufran_syed 4y agoThis whole discussion seems to miss the point that sellers always want to sell for as much as they can, and buyers always want to pay as little as they can. If the price goes too high, buyer's won't buy. You could get the same effect by having an auction every month for all the units that would be available in the next month - the price would still rise, but then you could blame the other buyers for "overbidding" The optimal price for a seller is always "whatever the market will bear" - which we don't like the sound of it's a big "evil" corporation. But if any of us as individuals were selling a car for example, and some software would help us maximize the sale price, we would gladly use it - I don't see how the seller has a moral duty to take less money, same as the buyer has no moral duty to pay more
- anigbrowl 4y ago> sellers always want to sell for as much as they can, and buyers always want to pay as little as they can Not actually true. Lots of people discount or donate $ or labor or commodities by choice, as cash flow is only one of many things different people want to maximize. You've made the mistake of assuming one kind of economic behavior is the default for everyone. It isn't. There are 4 predominant patterns of economic behavior that emerge in simple economic games: https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.1600451 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.1600451
- mtgx 4y ago
- malikNF 4y agoThing is, we are talking about housing here. A basic necessity for everyone. I can live without a car, I can live without that expensive new_shiny_toy_of_the_month but housing is something that's vital, it has the ability to impact so many aspects of my life. So the whole debate here, as far as I understand is, how ethical is all this. Is it ethical to squeeze every last cent out of a person looking to house themselves and their family?
- colinmhayes 4y ago
- ghufran_syed 4y agoHaving thought about it a little more, I think we don't like the idea of it because "shelter" is a basic human necessity, not an optional purchase. But a lot of the problem of unaffordable housing has been created by our own policies in the US, this article is a good summary of the issue: '"Zoning is not a good institution gone bad. … On the contrary, zoning is a mechanism of exclusion designed to inflate property values, slow the pace of new development, segregate cities by race and class, and enshrine the detached single‐ family house as the exclusive urban ideal.” So writes M. Nolan Gray in Arbitrary Lines: How Zoning Broke the American City and How to Fix It.' https://www.cato.org/regulation/fall-2022/case-abolishing-zoning https://www.cato.org/regulation/fall-2022/case-abolishing-zo...
- conductr 4y agoEven if you exclude zoning from the equation entirely and look at the raw material and labor costs associated with building it’s usually exceeding most definitions of “affordable”. Density is often lauded as a solution, but building vertically is more expensive than horizontally. It only helps spread land costs across more square footage. The costs of going vertical usually outpaces the savings of diluted land cost. So there’s really no solution that’s sustainable. The result being all affordable housing is a shell game of subsidies. Some of this is our own doing as well as we continue to up the requirements of building standards/codes. Some make more sense than others, but in general we don’t design building codes with costs in mind and I feel that’s a pretty large recipe for disaster.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoThis is mostly not true, excluding skyscrapers, which yes are costly. You’ve forgotten roads, sewers, utilities, sidewalk maintenance etc. Missing-middle housing is much more efficient than suburbs. Washington DC is a good example, for those unable to visit Europe.
- pixl97 4y agoEh, infrastructure costs of growing horizontally are underestimated in the sense you demand everyone has cars, massive interstates, thousands of miles of water and sewer piping, pollution problems brought on by car culture, etc.
- danielfoster 4y agoPeople really need to be asking themselves, “Why isn’t new housing being built?” and focus on removing the barriers to building new housing. Pricing algorithms wouldn’t be such an issue if it were easy to add new supply.
- anigbrowl 4y agoPeople also need to be asking themselves 'who opposes new builds, and where do their political donations go.' Property owners as an economic bloc are not passive political price takers, they lobby for their own interests and tend to be much more organized than tenants.
- Plasmoid 4y agoLargely it's because the existing residents don't want people moving in. They liked how the neighborhood was before and they want it to remain static. To this end, you get zoning rules, ever tightening building codes, impact fees, taxes, public hearings, and just straight up prohibitions on building.
- anm89 4y agoBecause we have an overabundance of housing for one. Massive portions of our housing supply are sucked up as STRs and and second and third houses due to a decade of free money. On top of that we have all time record numbers of houses set to be completed over the next few months which are still being snapped up by investors. We have a shortage of available housing. Not a shortage of housing (there are individual markets where this isn't true and there are actually shortages of physical units). Fortunately, this is to some degree in the process of correcting itself but I doubt the place we get to is going to be a solution that very many people are happy with either.
- Plasmoid 4y ago> Because we have an overabundance of housing for one. I've seen this canard so many times it physically hurts me. I don't know where you found this so it's hard to provide specific debunking so I'll just go over all of them. 1) The houses aren't where people actually want to live. There is a lot of vacant housing in dying rural towns, mining sites, or the middle of nowhere. So unless you have a plan to get people to move to Buffalo-Butte then available housing there may as well not exist. 2) The most of the "vacant" homes aren't actually vacant. Depending on how badly the stats are gathered they will include a lot of garbage. Let's look at the list of things that considered vacant: - Houses on the market for rent/sale - Houses that have been rented/sold but not yet moved into - Houses that unfit for human habitation - Houses undergoing significant renovations - Houses that are used seasonally That's right, if your house burns down the still-smouldering rubble is considered vacant. There is just not enough housing where people want to live. Objections like this only get brought up when someone is about a half-step away from proposition house rationing. Not for them though, other people should have their housing rationed.
- scotty79 4y agoThat's basically price fixing by a third party.
- siliconc0w 4y agoIt's illegal for competitors to get together and agree to a price floor but it's apparently not illegal to do so through a middleman. I guess housing is so inelastic that you can turn the screws and even let units stand empty to keep artificially high prices.
- deviantbit 4y ago“The beauty of YieldStar is that it pushes you to go places that you wouldn’t have gone if you weren’t using it,” said Kortney Balas, director of revenue management at JVM Realty" What she really means, is she would have never imagined sucking every penny out of you, until she got a hold of their software. They get filthy rich, while you need a place to live, and they generate excess profits on false supply and demand models. Where I live, we have 60% occupancy, but the area is priced beyond anything reasonable. $2500 a month for a studio is nuts. Now we're getting a renters tax from the city. Joy.
- andrepd 4y agoHonestly Georgism looks like a perfect fit here. "Market" rent going through the roof like you say, while occupancy stays low? Enjoy paying 1000$+ every month on a vacant flat you're making no money off. I.e.: double-dip pressure for prices to fall and/or occupancy to rise.
- deviantbit 4y agoSo, lower your rent, and fill the unit. Make $1000 a month to cover the cost is better than losing money on it.
- maximilianroos 4y agoThis is mostly a distraction from the underlying issue. The algorithm helps sellers to maximize prices given the supply & demand so, yes, this probably is responsible for a few percentage points of increase in price, in the same way that price comparison websites are responsible for a small decrease in the price of car rentals. But the underlying problem here is the supply & demand! Rentals are competitive, an algorithm can't force people to pay more than an comparable rental property is charging. It's the lack of housing supply in areas like SF is responsible for rents being a multiple of what they could be. Developers want to build apartments, but are prevented from doing so by local regulations. So we need to change those regulations or, as is increasingly happening in the last couple of California's legislative sessions, take control away from local authorities (e.g. SF Board of Supervisors).
- midislack 4y agoWe could also just not live in San Francisco. That's a better option for many.
- tjr225 4y agoAnd yet people love it and want to call it home, and are willing to make sacrifices to do so. I know I have here in the Seattle area. Mind ya own business!
- nkrisc 4y agoI think what they’re really saying is that maybe not every person who wants to live in SF, for example, can. There’s some upper limit on how many people can live there and if more people want to live there than can prices will go up. So maybe not everyone who wants to live there gets to.
- bombcar 4y agoIn the past this would cause other places to become “more San Francisco-like” (arguably Seattle itself has changed since the 80s and perhaps in this direction). Why that doesn’t occur could be interesting for discussion.
- ok123456 4y ago
- raincom 4y agoThis has been the case for the last 7 years or so. In the bay area, apartment managers, who run REI-owned properties, blame the software for yearly rental raises, and that they have no say in how much they should charge rent. Mom'n'pop apartments or individual condos managed by third parties are reasonable in terms of negotiation, as they are not bound by any software. Yes, the software used by these properties is another way to engage in cartel-like behavior--price fixing.
- anm89 4y agoDefinitely not a decade and a half of virtually free money and endless liquidity that encouraged people to chases returns outside of stocks and bonds. No, it's those blasted algorithms.
- richbell 4y ago> Definitely not a decade and a half of virtually free money and endless liquidity that encouraged people to chases returns outside of stocks and bonds. >No, it's those blasted algorithms. You're spot-on about free money encouraging people to overspend. In Canada it's common knowledge that people would borrow against their house to put down payments into other houses, which they would borrow against to put down payments on other houses, etc. But an effect can have more than one causes, and algorithms driving up the prices is another cause. E.g., the op, https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-11-08/zillow-z-home-flipping-experiment-doomed-by-tech-algorithms https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-11-08/zillow-z-...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- GoodJokes 4y ago
- ROTMetro 4y agoPeople that don't think price collusion/illegal carterls hidden as software taking advantage of the fact people don't want to be homeless, please report this to the FTC. https://reportfraud.ftc.gov/#/assistant https://reportfraud.ftc.gov/#/assistant Report as 'something else'.