13 ms·
Texas state politics/law is completely f'd in so many ways, but one thing they do that I think is fantastic, and I wish all states did, was have a "Sunset Revie
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
Texas state politics/law is completely f'd in so many ways, but one thing they do that I think is fantastic, and I wish all states did, was have a "Sunset Review Commission", https://www.sunset.texas.gov/how-sunset-works https://www.sunset.texas.gov/how-sunset-works.
Basically, all agencies that are authorized by the legislature are set to automatically be abolished in (usually) 12 years. Once the expiration date is near, the Sunset Commission reviews the agency and recommends whether to reauthorize it, in which case the legislature must pass a law to reauthorize, but the "default" is that the agency expires.
This really helps fight the natural tendency of lots of these professional agencies to grow to protect their own power, regardless of their original purpose. And even if agencies are normally always renewed, the review process itself is really useful to, when necessary, smack these agencies upside the head to get them back to their original goal. One example I'm familiar with, a couple years ago the Sunset Commission basically tore the Texas Veterinary Board a new one after they decided to go after animal shelter vets for trying to save animals with extremely limited resources, https://www.mysanantonio.com/news/local/article/One-third-of-state-veterinary-board-resigns-10784396.php https://www.mysanantonio.com/news/local/article/One-third-of... - actual report at https://www.sunset.texas.gov/public/uploads/files/reports/State%20Board%20of%20Veterinary%20Medical%20Examiners%20Staff%20Report%20with%20Final%20Results_6-21-17.pdf https://www.sunset.texas.gov/public/uploads/files/reports/St...
- bsder 4y agoCounterexample: corrupt things like the Texas Railroad Commission or Public Utility Commission that get reauthorized every single time. All sunset laws do is turn state agencies into lobbying and patronage companies.
- jxramos 4y agoI guess out of sight out of mind would apply here. Even if rubber stamped repeatedly maybe it will present an opportunity to catch the eye of some inquisitive type to ask why?
- JamesianP 4y agocounterpoint: the good is not perfect therefore it is bad.
- bsder 4y agoCounter-counterpoint: Claims that something is better than the alternative need to be supported with some evidence. Sunset laws to do not magically improve the quality of the voting public or the quality of the elected representatives--and those are what ultimately decide the quality of the laws. Furthermore, if we cite Texas, the evidence seems to be a negative correlation rather than a positive one. (Side note: I'm actually in favor of laws having some form of trigger to cause them to disappear. Time, by itself, is generally insufficient, however. Laws should have a reason for going onto the books and when that reason is invalidated the law should be forced to be reauthorized with a different reason.)
- JamesBarney 4y agoWhy should those commissions be abolished? I've heard complaints about them, like I've heard complaints about every single regulating body in existence. but I haven't heard so many that it seems like they should be disbanded.
- modriano 4y agoAren't those commissions responsible for keeping the power on in Texas [0]? Didn't millions of Texans suffer significant cost, danger, and hardship and >100 Texans froze to death because of these commissions decisions to keep Texas' electrical grid isolated from the eastern and western power grids and to not address infrastructural issues discovered when the exact same problems were experienced in 2011? Weren't a lot of Texans each charged thousands of dollars for a month with very bad electrical service in the recent freeze? [0] https://www.texastribune.org/2022/02/15/texas-power-grid-winter-storm-2021/ https://www.texastribune.org/2022/02/15/texas-power-grid-win...
- PM_me_your_math 4y agoThe reality of that catastrophe has very little to do with politics. And those charged high rates agreed to variable pricing. The ultimate reason why Texas had a problem was because of a nasty ice storm took out infrastructure.
- modriano 4y ago> The reality of that catastrophe has very little to do with politics. "Politics" means "the activities associated with making decisions in groups." Anything that impacts the lives of groups of people where people made decisions (like the decision to have an isolated electrical grid [0]) is politics. I live in Chicago. We have far worse ice storms than Texas but we also see over weeks 100F in the summers. We realized that A) power is a critical utility that people need to literally live, and B) it's technologically unnecessary and economically irrational to let inadequate infrastructure cause mass casualty events and cost us $195 BILLION [1] in damage, contamination, and lost economic opportunity, so we made the decision to engineer a resilient power grid and we don't experience the kinds of massive, protracted failures that Texas keeps having, despite the Public Utilities Commission of Texas and the Texas Railroad Commission investigating the failures when Texas' grid went down for the same reasons back in 2011 [2]. By definition, that's politics. > And those charged high rates agreed to variable pricing. My power bill each month ranges from $100 to $150 and I just pay for what I consume. People in Texas were getting automatically charged rates as high as $11,000 in a month where they received terrible service. [3] It's just bullshit to say anyone agreed to that. > The ultimate reason why Texas had a problem was because of a nasty ice storm took out infrastructure. Failure here was and remains a choice. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_Interconnection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_Interconnection [1] https://www.austintexas.gov/sites/default/files/files/HSEM/2021-Winter-Storm-Uri-AAR-Findings-Report.pdf https://www.austintexas.gov/sites/default/files/files/HSEM/2... [2] https://www.ferc.gov/sites/default/files/2020-04/08-16-11-report.pdf https://www.ferc.gov/sites/default/files/2020-04/08-16-11-re... [3] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-weather-texas-bills/texas-freeze-raises-concerns-about-ridiculous-variable-rate-bills-idUSKBN2AN0EQ https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-weather-texas-bills/t...
- IgorPartola 4y agoI wonder what would happen if we did this with laws. There are so many laws that get passed that are literally no longer applicable (funding to build a bridge in the US is done as a law), but also I wonder if this would engage everyone a bit more in how the country runs.
- Waterluvian 4y agoThat might be a good idea. But I’m not sure your example is a good one. Repealing a budget law only adds paperwork and cost and complexity. It’s not like these kinds laws have an ongoing cost. I wonder if one issue is just perception: people often see laws as “ongoing rules” when they can often just be, “on this date congress agreed to these terms and conditions for some thing.”
- yieldcrv 4y agoMany laws are like that Even various key provisions of the Patriot Act usually they are unceremoniously reauthorized by Congress because its just too much to think about sometimes Congress forgets (or the related lobbyist forgot/couldnt get a lunch date with the co-sponsor) but this isn't a perfect system its just more case load in practice that no individual person is aware of I personally cant think of any debate that occurred on an upcoming sunset provision where people consciously said “yeah that has no more applicability let it expire” or “we have to reauthorize this or itll be a disaster” its just nobody has time to think about it so they rubber stamp it in the annual budget reconciliation bill to keep the government open
- mLuby 4y ago
- duxup 4y agoDo you really need a sunset commission to do these things? Sounds like bureaucracy for bureaucracy…
- rudolph9 4y agoI think the point was the auto-expiration.
- duxup 4y agoWhat is the bureaucracy for them? Sounds like another bureaucracy that would end up just like the folks they’re policing. Another system gamed, influence peddling and etc .
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoThey Sunset Commission themselves are also reviewed [1]. FWIW, the reality is that of course while the system is not perfect, pretty much everything is out in the open and reviewed on a scheduled basis. That really does go a long way to prevent the type of "slow power creep" of a lot of these professional licensing boards. 1. https://www.sunset.texas.gov/about-us/frequently-asked-questions#9 https://www.sunset.texas.gov/about-us/frequently-asked-quest...
- duxup 4y agoThat just sounds like Dr Seuss bee watcher situation where the solution is more of the same.
- aaronbrethorst 4y agoSocial Security, Medicare, and Medicaid would no longer exist. Nor would the Clean Water Act or the Clean Air Act. The ACA would have expired two years ago, too. I think this is a scam in the same way that pushes for term limits for politicians are a total scam: https://www.vox.com/polyarchy/2016/10/18/13323842/trump-term-limits https://www.vox.com/polyarchy/2016/10/18/13323842/trump-term... (and I say this as someone who is appalled by the fact that the average age of a US Senator is essentially at the retirement age.)
- sieabahlpark 4y ago
- mschuster91 4y ago> I think this is a scam in the same way that pushes for term limits for politicians are a total scam: https://www.vox.com/polyarchy/2016/10/18/13323842/trump-term https://www.vox.com/polyarchy/2016/10/18/13323842/trump-term... There are problems with term limits, indeed... but is the alternative really to keep the status quo and have essentially a generation of wealthy gerontocrats in power who are completely disconnected from the reality of life for many of their constituents, not to mention who are fucking over the planet? Politics needs continuous supply of fresh blood, people who grew up with computers and no fossils unable to read e-mails that aren't printed out by aides for them. And of young people who have realized that it is no longer possible to join a company at 16 for an apprenticeship and leave it for pension at 65, or that a single earner can no longer afford a comfortable home. And while we are at it: We need not just term limits, we especially need age caps for politicians and corporate officials. Reach pension age and you're irrevocably out. Here in Germany, old buffoons at the helm of companies who refuse to use computers are the single worst issue for the German Mittelstand. Companies that can't adapt because the owner is stuck in 1960 mentally will wither and die eventually - and while I don't care about ignorant owners, I do care about the employees and the loss of economic contributions.
- chrismcb 4y agoAre you saying they wouldn't exist because they wouldn't get reapproved? Because that is what you are implying. And term limits are definitely not a scam
- dane-pgp 4y agoThe more civilised way of doing this is to have an independent commission whose job it is to regularly review the state of the laws on the books and put forward lists of them to be repealed by the legislature. This works quite well in the UK, for example, where Statute Law (Repeals) Acts have been passed[0] every few years since 1969, with the most recent[1] repealing the whole of 817 Acts of Parliament, and portions of more than 50 others. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statute_Law_%28Repeals%29_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statute_Law_%28Repeals%29_Act [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statute_Law_%28Repeals%29_Act_2013 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statute_Law_%28Repeals%29_Act_...
- m463 4y agoI think that's a good system and it is nice it exists, but I sense that expiring something might be a better way. There's a lot to be said to having people step up to defend something instead of having people attack something bad, or even overlook it out of ignorance. I also remember one thing trump did I thought was interesting was that adding a new regulation required eliminating 2 existing regulations.
- bovinegambler 4y agoHey, just by the way, it seems your characterization of the outcome with regards to vets at animal shelters is not correct. It's kind of the opposite. It starts on page 41 of the PDF (second link). The problem was: "Recent court decisions prevent the State Board of Veterinary Medical Examiners from regulating shelter veterinarians or veterinary medicine practiced in animal shelters." "Strictly interpreted, the statutory exemption means anyone who practices veterinary medicine in the context of animal shelters and rescue groups is exempt from the Veterinary Licensing Act, including standard of care measures and use of controlled substances. The impact of the decisions is already having an effect on the oversight and regulation of veterinary medicine in Texas, as the agency has begun to close all complaints against shelter veterinarians, declaring them non-jurisdictional based on the decisions. Taken to the extreme and assuming the Act does not apply in the context of shelter medicine, animal shelters and rescue groups would not need to hire licensed veterinarians. If the Act does not apply to the care of these animals, any person regardless of training, education, or qualification, and regardless of their criminal or disciplinary history, would legally be able to practice veterinary medicine on shelter and rescue animals." The recommendation from the Sunset Commission was therefore for the legislature to change the law to make sure veterinary medicine at rescue clinics WAS regulated.
- IG_Semmelweiss 4y agoI only read the quoted text not the source link, but I dont see a reasonable basis for the recommendation inference you are making. The commission is just stating the facts. I don't think they are advocating any change in law. (again from the quoted text). The fact remains that state veterinarian boards were going after shelter practitioners, the court then gtanted shelters relief - on the basis of the Act - then the Commission generated the post-mortem on the Act. There seems to be no recommendation from the quoted text?
- bovinegambler 4y agoWell, open up that PDF :) The whole thing is just three and a half pages, starting on page 41. On page 43: "Recommendations 5.1 Request the Senate Committee on Agriculture, Water, and Rural Affairs and the House Committee on Agriculture and Livestock to take action to clearly define the scope and limits of the statutory owner exemption in the Veterinary Licensing Act." It goes on...
- Eumenes 4y agoWe need this for the federal government