6 ms·
Crimean bridge: Who – or what – caused the explosion?
- aintmeit 4y ago
- pasiaj 4y agoThere are burnmarks high up on the pillars of the train bridge but not on the lower parts. This would suggest that the explosion happened on top of the bridge.
- taf2 4y agoI believe the burn marks you see on the train bridge would mostly be due to the fuel train cars that ignited shortly after the blast on the car bridge… that said I’m no expert just saw the cctv footage on youtube…
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoIt is amusing to see "trolling" casually used in the correct, modern sense in a BBC article. Doubly so given serious circumstances surrounding it use. Also I find it hard to believe Russia destroyed the mysterious drone boat that washed up. Seems like a colossal waste if true. Edit: I also wonder if it is some kind of response to nord stream getting blown up, like "Just look at that, some of your infrastructure out at sea can mysteriously blow up too with no one claiming responsibility, funny isn't it?"
- sixhobbits 4y agoInteresting that they mention trolling without quoting or mentioning the Tweet[0] [0] https://mobile.twitter.com/Ukraine/status/1578634825417650176 https://mobile.twitter.com/Ukraine/status/157863482541765017...
- svnpenn 4y ago> It is amusing to see "trolling" casually used in the correct, modern sense in a BBC article. The "correct" definition hasn't changed: > carefully and systematically search an area for something. Not sure how you came to the idea that internet slang is anything other than internet slang.
- selimthegrim 4y agoIsn’t that ‘trawling’?
- replygirl 4y agotrawling is a fishing technique
- daemoncoder 4y agoSo is trolling: one of the meanings is: fishing by trailing a baited line along behind a boat
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wsinks 4y ago"trolling" is another accepted spelling of trawling :)
- andrewflnr 4y agoEven when they're trying to use it as Internet slang, mainstream media tend to use "trolling" as a synonym for just saying mean things.
- Symbiote 4y ago> carefully and systematically search an area for something. That is trawling, not trolling. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/troll#Etymology_2 https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/troll#Etymology_2 https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/trawl#Verb https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/trawl#Verb
- bagels 4y agoIt seems like a completely valid military target regardless of nordstream. It'd certainly be in Ukraine's interest in blowing up the rest of the rail and road connections to Russia, I'm guessing trade relations will be pretty strained for some time.
- rgbrenner 4y agoThis bridge was completed in 2018, and has only carried freight trains since 2020. So Ukraine has never used this bridge.. it was only built to tie Crimea closer to Russia after its annexation.
- bagels 4y agoRight, I think regardless of who/when it was built, it is in Ukraine's interest to disrupt supplies and troop movements. Unfed troops are not going to really be motivated to defend territories.
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoIt absolutely is. I just find the timing interesting since it happened soon after. Its not like the bridge just became an available target, its been there the whole time. Still, those responsible may not have been able to pull it off until now so it's probably just a coincidence.
- n4r9 4y agoThe other interesting timing is the recent Russian conscription drive. This explosion disrupts one of the primary routes for getting troops and supplies across the border.
- sam_lowry_ 4y agoIt happened in the early morning after Putin's birthday. It was clearly a birthday present.
- HKH2 4y ago> Edit: I also wonder if it is some kind of response to nord stream getting blown up, like "Just look at that, some of your infrastructure out at sea can mysteriously blow up too with no one claiming responsibility, funny isn't it?" Do you seriously think Russia blew up a pipeline that it had complete control over? Why would Russia give up leverage like that?
- threatofrain 4y agoThe article ends with BBC saying they don't know and nobody claims credit.
- speedgoose 4y agoThe title was a clue. If they knew, they would very likely say who and what in the title.
- ummonk 4y agoNote that the Ukrainian postal service managed to unveil a stamp commemorating destruction of the bridge within hours of the explosion.
- iammjm 4y agoAre you suggesting the Ukrainian postal service pulled it off? This was months in the making; I bet they already have projects for the liberation of Crimea ready.
- EdwardDiego 4y agoNeither snow nor rain nor heat nor trained attack dolphins stay these couriers from the swift completion of their secret bridge demolitions? We'll know it was the Ukrainian postal service when someone asks Putin to sign to confirm delivery of a whole parcel of humiliation.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoI think the suggestion was that this was a planned Ukrainian covert operation, and the postal service was told in advance as a propaganda play. Zelensky is a former actor who clearly understands PR, so it is not unlikely that he would plan something of that sort.
- awb 4y agoWhy would they risk a leak that threatened the operation just to promote a stamp? It doesn’t seem like it would take hours to grab a screenshot off of a TV broadcast and photoshop it onto a stamp, without advanced knowledge.
- Symbiote 4y agoThe stamp shows fires on the high part of the bridge: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/oct/08/putin-dealt-bitter-blow-as-blast-cripples-key-bridge-to-crimea https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/oct/08/putin-dealt-bi... I expect the Ukranian post office has many similar stamps designed and ready. They make good material to promote Ukraine.
- irrational 4y ago> Russian President Vladimir Putin accused Ukraine of attacking the bridge in an "act of terrorism". When 2 countries are at war, with active combat going on, is an act of terrorism possible? Isn’t it just a normal thing in war to destroy infrastructure?
- ummonk 4y agoThe bridge is certainly a legitimate military target. However, if indeed a bomb in a civilian-marked truck were used as Russia alleges (I have my doubts based on the footage and pattern of destruction), then it would be an act of terrorism that violates the rules of war (and such an act would be doubly egregious due to the civilians killed as collateral damage in Thai attack).
- pydry 4y agoWhether a truck was used or not 3 civilians were still killed.
- shawabawa3 4y agoCollateral damage isn't against any international laws of war as far as I know
- ummonk 4y agoYes, but if you violate the laws of war in an attack (e.g. if we stipulate that Ukraine did use a truck bomb, either with or without the knowledge of the truck driver), then the entire attack is unjustified and the collateral damage becomes murder.
- atoav 4y agoForgive the cynical response, but: more civilians have been killed for far less. Surgical precision drone strikes at weddings for example, where it turns out nobody there was a terrorist.
- TillE 4y agoThe unmanned boat theory is pretty compelling, though I'm not sure what the final step would be. Firing a missile up towards the bridge?
- warinukraine 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dopeboy 4y agoThere's speculation on r/combatfootage that a wave preceded the explosion suggesting a delivery by sea.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoThat's what Mike Martin and The Warzone speculate as well. https://nitter.net/ThreshedThought/status/1578646915545432066 https://nitter.net/ThreshedThought/status/157864691554543206... https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/explosion-rocks-russias-prized-kerch-strait-bridge-leading-to-crimea https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/explosion-rocks-russia...
- amelius 4y agoHow many kg of explosives would one need to cause something like this?
- EdwardDiego 4y agoI've been amusing myself with mental scenarios of the trained Russian attack-dolphins detecting Ukrainian frogmen and deciding that they're not getting decent enough fish for this bollocks and swimming away looking casual.
- jcranmer 4y agoThe images of the damage seem to thoroughly rule out the boat theory. There's clear evidence of lateral shockwaves on the upper-side of the deck (the guardrails are basically completely blown off), and the underside doesn't have the same lateral damage--the catwalks are mostly intact, for example. I'm also skeptical of missile theory--if you're targeting this with a missile, and you have the precision of such, the place to blow up the bridge wouldn't be where it was hit, but on the high portion of the bridge, where replacing damaged sections would be hard. The truck bomb does seem the most likely option to me.
- selimthegrim 4y agoIf the truck was headed to Crimea from Russia, why is the Russia bound deck sunk?
- jcranmer 4y agoThe alleged truck was traveling from Russia to Crimea, on the westbound side of the bridge. It was this side of the bridge that was sunk.
- selimthegrim 4y agoOk, the rails are on the south side, I understand now.
- idlewords 4y agoLike the article points out, CCTV footage of the explosion shows that it did not originate from the truck; there is a bright light above and to the right of it the instant before the explosion.
- cycrutchfield 4y agoRolling shutter effect
- 4y ago
- DeWilde 4y agoOccam's razor leads me to the conclusion that it was most likely done by the Ukrainian intelligence agencies and that the truck was loaded with explosives. Question is did the driver know or was he unavare.
- EdwardDiego 4y agoHow did it lead to the truck being the source of the explosives though? How did they time the explosion to the train's crossing so well? Feels to me like attacking from the ocean would have a higher probability of success than trying to sneak a truck packed with explosives onto a bridge that (one assumes) the Russians are very watchful over.
- DeWilde 4y agoBy being packed with explosives. The video of the inspection of the truck before it crossed the bridge shows a not very thorough inspection and it was not X-rayed. Also the underside of the bridge is untact as far as burn mark go.
- crazygringo 4y agoAnd in terms of timing, even if the driver was unaware (i.e. wasn't a voluntary suicide mission), all it would take is a radio detonator and someone watching from afar with a telescope, if not a drone.
- EdwardDiego 4y agoAh true, I had assumed that the inspection would be a lot more thorough given the propaganda significance of the bridge.
- simion314 4y agoFor me this is weird because the truck was coming from Russia and there are checkpoints too, so Ukrainians would need to have somehow access to explosives inside Russia. In theory you would find more Ukrainian sympathy in Crimea and not in Russia, but I do not know that area of the world so maybe the level of incompetence in Russia is even larger then I thought. It could be that truck, but it could be the Putin "clever" tactics to claim Ukrainians are terrorists(for some reason Russians started to use the terrorist word when a military target is bombed but when they bomb civilian apartments and malls it is just the old soviet incompetence excuse)
- pclmulqdq 4y agoThe number of anti-russian-infrastructure sabotage attacks happening in recent days is getting troubling. First Nordstream and now this. It seems unlikely that this was a missile strike or a boat attack from the analyses I have seen. A car bomb or a big explosive placed on the top of the bridge seems like the most likely possibility. This attack is certainly something that a Ukrainian special forces unit would be capable of doing. It is certainly possible that these are Russia's doing to get their population interested in the war and cut off Europe from gas, but a false flag would not be my first guess. Edit: I am not trying to say that these attacks are "anti-Russia" or that they were not done by the Russians. I am only saying that a lot of people have been destroying strategically important infrastructure operated by the Russians. Who is doing it is anyone's guess. To think we know who actually did any of these attacks without a thorough investigation is silly.
- birdyrooster 4y agoI agree the few number of attacks is concerning, hopefully this is the start of a more substantive campaign to degrade the Russians capability to wage war.
- redwood 4y agoI find it concerning that you seem to be feeding into the Russian trollfarm narrative that the Nordstream sabotage was "anti-Russian" as opposed to Russian led
- pclmulqdq 4y agoI am not saying that it was anti-Russian, just that it was an attack on Russian infrastructure ("anti-russian-infrastructure" isn't the cleanest wording, sorry). However, we don't know who did it. It could have been the Russians. It could have been the Americans. It could have been the Germans. It could have been an extremist climate activism group. We have no idea.
- chasil 4y agoWho would have a motivation to disrupt Nordstream, and why? There are many, many scenarios that could result in everything that we have seen.
- Simon_O_Rourke 4y agoEveryone knows it was the fault of the Rand Corporation, in conjunction with the saucer people and under the supervision of the reverse vampires. In all seriousness though, who knows, the job is done and that's all that matters.
- EGreg 4y agoThe global media is very fragmented, and people don't get information from other countries very easily. Russians have already launched an ongoing investigation, and are reporting it locally as follows... I'll use Google Translate from one of the Telegram channels carrying the news: The case of the explosion on the Crimean bridge was brought under the article "terrorism". During the investigation of the terrorist act on the Crimean bridge, many witnesses and eyewitnesses were interrogated, special expert studies were started and largely completed — Bastrykin As the head of the Investigative Committee noted at a meeting with the President of the Russian Federation, explosive, genetic and forensic examinations were carried out. He also said that relevant instructions had been given to the FSB and the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia to conduct operational-search activities. Later that day: In preparing the terrorist attack on the Crimean bridge, the Ukrainian special services resorted to the services of a fly-by-night company - it was through it that they ordered the ill-fated truck According to media reports, the driver Mahir Yusubov was transporting cargo on the order of the TEK-34 company, which ordered him to transport the film from Armavir to Simferopol on October 6. As Readovka already wrote, the driver could have been on the Crimean bridge on October 7, Vladimir Putin's birthday, but stopped nearby for the night. As Readovka found out, the head of TEK-34 is Oleg Aleksandrovich Antipov, and the company is registered in Ulyanovsk. Antipov has been in charge since November 13, 2020. Previously, the company was registered in the Volgograd region, but at the end of March 2022, the legal address was changed to Ulyanovsk. For 2021, according to our data, the company's revenue was equal to zero, and the company itself is listed as unreliable, since it has not paid taxes for at least the last three years. On the forums of carriers, comments were written on behalf of the TEK-34 company in the period from 2018 to 2020 - on behalf of a certain Olga. All this points to the work of the Ukrainian special services, whose involvement in the terrorist attack is no longer in doubt after publications in major Western publications. To implement their plan, they resorted to the use of a fly-by-night company, of which, unfortunately, there are a considerable number in Russia. And today: According to information from KP military correspondent Alexander Kots, the cargo, ordered by a citizen of Ukraine, arrived by sea from Bulgaria in the form of 22 pallets of film to Georgian Poti. After that, it was loaded onto a truck and sent to Armenia, where it was cleared according to the rules of the Customs Union. As a result, the truck again entered Georgia, and then crossed the border with the Russian Federation through the Upper Lars checkpoint and went to Armavir, where the cargo was transferred to another truck, which drove onto the Crimean bridge. Most likely, the explosives were planted in rolls of film to avoid detection through x-rays. This happened in Bulgaria, which indicates the participation of foreign intelligence services in organizing the attack.
- michaelwww 4y agoFrom the size of it, I'd say it's about the size of Timothy McVeigh's Oklahoma city bomb, which was a 16 ton truck filled with fertilizer. All trucks over this bridge were supposedly inspected, so I think it would have to be a more compact explosive. Perhaps the secret services have classified explosives the could produce this kind of explosive punch just from a car trunk load?
- nyokodo 4y ago> All trucks over this bridge were supposedly inspected The operative word is “supposedly.” I suspect the same corruption that is everywhere in the Russian sphere exists in their infrastructure security apparatus.
- hirundo 4y agoWhen I moved from California to New Mexico I hauled a cargo trailer crammed full of my possessions across Hoover Dam. A cop pulled me over at the entrance and had me open it up. When he saw how full it was, he poked around it a bit, and told me he really shouldn't let me through, but go ahead, and don't do that again. It would have been several more hours to drive down to Needles and cross there. Now I know what he was afraid of.
- copperx 4y ago> Now I know what he was afraid of. Are you implying cops are on heightened alert for bridge detonations in the US? If so, why?
- hirundo 4y agoThis was in 2004, and 9/11 didn't feel like old news.
- Symbiote 4y agoIn the EU at borders lorries and freight trains are x-rayed. I've only crossed the external EU border by land a couple of times, but lorries had to drive at a constant speed (without stopping!) through a metal archway, which presumably was the x-ray machine. I haven't seen a similar system near vulnerable infrastructure, but it might exist. It may be overkill for a lightly trafficked road. Art exhibition of x-rays of lorries: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2yk0Rb8XNyM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2yk0Rb8XNyM A few seconds showing an inspector looking in detail at an x-ray of a train: https://youtu.be/LQdtJ9skyuY?t=219 https://youtu.be/LQdtJ9skyuY?t=219 In fact, this looks very similar, in California. I haven't see this car-sized version in the EU: https://www.cnet.com/news/privacy/dhs-x-ray-scanners-could-be-cancer-risk-to-border-crossers/ https://www.cnet.com/news/privacy/dhs-x-ray-scanners-could-b...