21 ms·
School vs. Wikipedia
- atestu 4y agoThe workaround is to use Wikipedia and quote the sources you find on the article.
- algoatecorn 4y agoExactly. Wikipedia is a tool for finding sources. They're already cited at the bottom. Just click the footnote, navigate to the source, and fact check it.
- mrweasel 4y agoIsn't that exactly what Wikipedia wants you to do? You can put anything on Wikipedia without a source anyway. What I find obnoxious is that these are the same schools that will hand the kids a ChromeBook without being critical of Google incentive.
- ceedan 4y agoTo avoid the wikipedia issue (and also because research papers are a pony show) I wrote grade school research papers that were so obscure (at the time), that I used a geocities page as my source. Myotonic Fainting Goats... some dude who had a farm of them wrote up some web page about them.
- user3939382 4y agoThat's what TFA says
- teeray 4y agoI had teachers like this, some of them smugly defacing Wikipedia to try to prove their point. What they never realized is how quickly their vandalism was detected and removed. They never checked to see how persistent their edits were.
- kube-system 4y agoVandalism is easy to spot though. Wrong but plausible information is difficult to identify.
- akolbe 4y agoExactly. That's why the world thinks an "Alan MacMasters" invented the electric toaster. That particular hoax lasted ten years and spread far and wide: https://wikipediocracy.com/2022/08/11/wikipedias-credibility-is-toast/ https://wikipediocracy.com/2022/08/11/wikipedias-credibility... Example from the BBC: https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/articles/1D0xzxYf9ykH9gcYp9BnYW4/5-everyday-objects-with-curious-histories https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/articles/1D0xzxYf9ykH9gcYp9... Several books have the false info too. Wikipedia is useful, but it is never a good idea to rely on Wikipedia blindly.
- thrwyoilarticle 4y ago>Several books have the false info too Sounds like we shouldn't trust books blindly, either. Is there a source we can trust blindly?
- datadata 4y agoI think pedagogical goal is exactly to prevent the act of blindly trusting any source, regardless of source quality. Trust fails without verification, so the idea of a blindly trusted source is self defeating.
- thrwyoilarticle 4y agoThat's more optimistic than my impression. I view it as a mix of a few things: - What often happens when a person is surprised to learn something: they assume most other people don't know it and become eager to repeat it without further nuance or investigation. Like moon landing conspiracy theorists who learn that there are no stars in the photos. - The hazing, elitist attitude surrounding knowledge. I suffered, therefore you should suffer. From this perspective, it doesn't make sense for there to be a gargantuan, selfless compilation of knowledge more accessible than any library in history. It must be wrong. - People are lazy and will paraphrase the Wiki page that appears at the top of a web search for the topic. It's much easier to say Wikipedia can't be trusted than to instil upon pupils an understanding of epistemology, a distrust of what authority figures tell them, an appreciation of academic honesty, and the knowledge of how to construct a good bibliography.
- chatterhead 4y agoYou should be fighting this at the school. Wikipedia should not be used as a source for academic purposes; the sources being referenced on Wikipedia very well could be though and as such Wikipedia is an incredibly useful tool for surface level research and schools should absolutely be taking this approach to using it. They should not, under any circumstance, have children "Googling" the answer to questions. Most of these kids parents already use that phrase as a keystone of their parental pedagogy and they don't need that in school, too. Wikipedia is wonderful. They have more money then they will ever need so don't donate; but, they are great. Everyone should have a copy of Wikipedia locally updated yearly.
- jefftk 4y ago> Wikipedia should not be used as a source for academic purposes It's not a primary source, or a secondary source, but it's a great tertiary source for getting an overview of an area, and as a tertiary source (like other encyclopedias historically) it has a major role in academic work.
- ravenstine 4y agoThe nice thing about Wikipedia is that it is free of distraction, often very detailed, and has lots of citations that make it a great jumping-off point for finding other sources of information and verifying statements. Wikipedia, in my opinion, fails in that there is a bias with anything that remotely involves politics or health science. Students need to be taught that Wikipedia is NOT an objective source, and that basically no source of information is truly objective.
- coding123 4y agoThis is very true. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unidentified_flying_object https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unidentified_flying_object If you read that, you will walk away thinking aliens have not visited this planet. Probably definitively believe it. The reality is, we have no fing clue if they have or not. You can feel the skeptics just edit all day long denying anything. I'm sure by 2050 the article on god's existence will be less discussion on both sides and just say that people that believe are crazy. If anything remotely falls under "pseudoscience" even if there is science backing parts of it up, wikipedia just completely bombs the crap out of believers.
- kixxauth 4y agoAny new media has this problem. I know we think of digital media as being old and well understood at this point, but that's far from the truth. Media moves too quickly for most people to understand it. By the time you understand it, it changes again. That was true for newspapers, radio, television, digital media, and now ubiquitous computing. As people who build these media platforms (hackers) we need to do a better job designing the technology for humans and educating people to approach it with a more sophisticated mindset. Ex; social media has been a disaster. Remember, it was not that long ago that everyone got their information from the same places. This is going to be a long road.
- mikkergp 4y agoI actually think this is some not too minor part of the misinformation problem we have today. Sure some of it is willful, but simultaneously almost any common sense notion you have about how to do research these days has a big fucking asterix next to it, and may have been born of a time of different communication patterns.
- dfxm12 4y agoI wonder what the actual message is compared to what gets back to the parent. Are teachers really saying "Don't use wikipedia" full stop, then turning around and accepting any other webpage as a scholarly source? That seems really unlikely. At worst, wikipedia is a tertiary source. I'm surprised I had to deal with this in college, but the teacher in one of my classes, after we submitted our first papers, felt the need to break this down and explain how to use wikipedia and properly cite sources in this context. I'm sure some kids turned off their ears after the beginning of that lecture...
- roywiggins 4y agoIt seems entirely apiece with how a rule begins ("Don't cite tertiary sources like encyclopedias, Wikipedia is an encyclopedia, so don't cite Wikipedia") and then gets simplified to the point of uselessness ("Don't cite Wikipedia", then finally "Don't use Wikipedia") and then generates its own inverse rule ("If it's not Wikipedia, you can use it"). At each stage the why gets shaved off and then people come up with their own reverse-engineered explanations ("Don't use Wikipedia because it's edited all the time by randos, so it's less reliable than the other stuff you'll find online"). You can see this with, eg, p-values- people learn the rule "A p-value measures the probability of obtaining the observed results, assuming that the null hypothesis is true." which becomes "a low p-value means we should reject the null hypothesis" becomes "a p-value is the probability the null hypothesis is true" (the inverse).
- d4rti 4y agoWhat's code red mean in this context?
- dfxm12 4y agoLikely, an active shooter drill
- yellsatclouds 4y agoah, so training to trigger people's fears from a young age... you know, for safety.
- davegauer 4y agoThis is correct.
- kube-system 4y agoThis is probably a relic of what these teachers learned 20+ years ago when the internet had an higher ratio of academically spirited content, and wasn’t yet entirely full of people trying to make a buck with pages that merely look like content to googlebot. Do schools still have subscriptions to things like LexisNexis? I feel like it would be eye opening to many students to see just how different an academic search engine is compared to public search engines.
- NegativeLatency 4y agoMost (all?) of my schools did have a subscription (early 2000's), but it was only accessible at school on the school computers, so I basically never used it, because I did my homework/research at home.
- kjkjadksj 4y agoMost schools have off campus proxies you can use now
- NegativeLatency 4y agoHigh schools?
- mellosouls 4y agoWikipedia is a terrific resource for an overview - and sometimes in-depth - coverage of a subject. Where it might fail is - like a calculator (and obviously Google) - make research too easy; I can see that being an argument to at least change the focus of study methods in some cases. Another way it might fail as a resource is where the "expertise" of the editors contributing is biased (and therefore so is the content) towards the demographics of Wikipedia editors, eg leftist/white/male/middle class, which carries it's own significant risks of misinformation in some areas of knowledge where those biases are potentially harmful. Complacency towards this last point, which is breezily dismissed by the author with "No agenda (or damn near no agenda, I mean, come on - show me a more neutral source for this information)" severely undermines his argument.
- mountainb 4y agoThis parent is wrong, and the teacher is also wrong. There is no reason for children to use a source like Wikipedia for anything. Children also should not be permitted to use services like Google, which is bad for similar reasons, amply recited by the link author. Schools usually have access to excellent library databases. It's never too early to teach children useful research skills. Wikipedia is anti-useful. Searching Wikipedia is an anti-skill that actively misinforms users, training both children and adults into believing that they can do "research" by punching strings into a text box to retrieve often highly inaccurate articles which are also un-citeable for any serious purpose. When the web was young and fresh, Wikipedia was better than many alternatives. In the current era, with so many digitized books and journal articles, there is no reason whatsoever to use Wikipedia for anything but the most casual browsing. >Instead, they’re bad-mouthing Wikipedia specifically, and then having them do a fucking Google search and using whatever pops up as an authoritative source! >Are you kidding me? Google is worse, so it's not like the teacher is offering a better alternative. The teacher instead should be directing the children to print or digitized encyclopedias and towards appropriate databases. The teacher would also be better off directing the children to sources like Archive.org to seek out higher quality primary and secondary sources responsive to whatever questions are being posed.
- tablespoon 4y ago> This parent is wrong, and the teacher is also wrong. There is no reason for children to use a source like Wikipedia for anything. Exactly. To oversimplify, the correct advice has two parts: 1) don't use Wikipedia, 2) use these better sources instead. The teacher is wrong because they're apparently forgetting the second part, but the parent is also wrong because missing that doesn't make Wikipedia a good source. IMHO, a pretty good lesson for schoolchildren is: quality information usually takes some effort to access, and information that's easily accessible is probably bad. That's because quality is usually expensive, so free very often takes shortcuts on quality or injects an agenda.
- mountainb 4y agoCorrect. If the children are going to get any value from the many, many hours spent in a school, why not use the library resources that the school pays vast fees to maintain access to (public, private, AND parochial all pay for these things), which require actual skills to be developed to use effectively? Why should the teacher earn a salary for telling children to type into a text box? A computer could do the job of telling kids to "search Wikipedia" for less money, but a teacher can be more helpful to train students in the core academic skillset that is formal research. Why do we look at the state of affairs in which undergraduates even at "elite" schools arrive to universities completely unprepared to use any academic-caliber library research tools and consider that acceptable?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ziml77 4y agoThis is something new? When I was in high school back in 2004, we were already told to not use Wikipedia as a source. What most of us would do instead was use the references section to find resources. (Or if we were being lazy, we'd just go by what Wikipedia said and then copy its relevant citations)
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> in high school back in 2004, we were already told to not use Wikipedia as a source I think we all assumed the situation had evolved.
- guywithahat 4y agoWhy would it? Encyclopedias were not regarded as good sources before Wikipedia, and Wikipedia is demonstrably less accurate than encyclopedias and more biased towards their sponsors
- bananarchist 4y ago[citation needed]
- greiskul 4y agoWhich sponsors does Wikipedia have?
- jerf 4y ago"Sponsor" may not be the right word, but Wikipedia by its nature ends up privileging the most motivated. Sadly, "the most motivated" are not always the most reliable. Sometimes they are! Lots o' love to the That Guy who is obsessed with the 14th century French poetry, and writes an entry that the most detail-oriented academic could hardly hope for. But in general... it's not a good bet.
- bawolff 4y ago
- shp0ngle 4y agoI am not sure at which level his kids are. It’s more than fine for elementary school, not fine for university… and there is spectrum in between.
- appenz 4y agoWrong school? Our local schools (Silicon Valley, CA) encourage kids to use Wikipedia. Your school may just be a little behind the times. The discussion now has moved to NLP models. GPT-3 models at this point can generate extremely high quality answers to complex questions. Is there still a point in asking a student to write a few paragraph on the definition and effect of acid rain if you can get that from OpenAI within seconds?
- Cyberdog 4y agoThe point isn't to have the kid write the essay about acid rain. The point is to teach the kid about acid rain and have them demonstrate an understanding of it. If the kid just turns in an AI-written essay that they may not have even read, they have learned nothing.
- PebblesRox 4y agoAn interesting exercise would be to have students generate the paragraph and then fact-check and edit it.
- robotnikman 4y agoSomewhat related: (Most of what you read on the internet is written by insane people) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32897812 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32897812
- the_third_wave 4y agoSmart teachers, be glad that they're still around. It is not the fact that "anyone can edit Wikipedia" which is the problem - as noted elsewhere vandalism is usually quickly dealt with - but more that in many subject areas "only certain edits are allowed to stand". Any topic which is even slightly politically contentious is soon taken over by a bunch of self-proclaimed keepers of The Truth™ who make sure that only their narrative is allowed to be followed. Given this phenomenon those parts of Wikipedia have more in common with political propaganda than encyclopedic articles. Even just using the references is fraught with error since those references are often just as biased as the articles in which they are referred. The only parts of Wikipedia which can still give some semblance of what is really going on are the edit history and talk pages, the latter in combination with its own edit history. It is there you can see how the narrative is being controlled, especially on the edit history pages.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- janmarsal 4y agoA teacher who calls wikipedia a bad source is usually a bad teacher. They think their job is to weed out the bad students from the good, and they hate how wikipedia makes this job harder for them, so they forbid the use of wikipedia. Only a bad and lazy teacher would do something like that.
- js8 4y agoTo me this misses what age group of kids are we talking about. If you're 12 and writing an essay on something as an exercise, go use Wikipedia. You will likely not be able to understand the primary sources, and secondary sources might be mixed bag. If you're in college, that's a different story. You should prefer primary sources, but Wikipedia is still a great starting point. I would say the primary problem is that libraries as a public good suck nowadays, but that is caused by copyright, a neoliberal version of enclosures. If you really have to tell kids not to use Wikipedia, point them to a real alternative - SciHub and LibGen. ;-P
- anon400232 4y agoAs valued as SciHub and LibGen may be, they are repositories of mostly disjoint materials. They are not seamlessly interconnected. As a very basic bar to strive for, I don't think either offer full text search over their contents. Any recommendedation for third party tools that might help?
- Avicebron 4y agoWhat do you mean by full text search over their contents? I just found a full published article? Do you mean that there's a competing article on libgen? If so, that's fairly normal with science, it changes year to year or month to month, those articles can both be valid in some sense because they are time dependent.
- Kim_Bruning 4y agoMany! In biology and medicine, pubmed is the most common ( https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/ ) . For general purpose you can use google scholar ( https://scholar.google.com/ https://scholar.google.com/ ). When you find an interesting article, both these tools will allow you to both seach backwards for articles that it cites, and search forwards for articles that cite it in turn. Repeated application can quickly help you expand the pool of potentially relevant articles (especially once you surface review articles in the citation chain, which can help tie things together and/or let you jump across to associated topics) . Finally, both of these tools yield you a DOI which you can plug into scihub. You can also install the extension "Sci-Hub X Now!" to do this last bit for you. ( https://github.com/gchenfc/sci-hub-now https://github.com/gchenfc/sci-hub-now )
- jjackson21 4y agogoogle search with site:edu
- user3939382 4y agoWikipedia's editorial policies result in the amplification and ossification of (political, academic, medical, etc.) establishment narratives and standards, which are often corrupt for a wide variety of reasons. I'm not suggesting I have a silver bullet solution to this problem, but as a result I tend to disagree that Wikipedia is this holy grail of knowledge. That's only true for uncontroversial topics. For everything else, you have to find all the silenced users on the talk pages to learn about the real scope of a topic.
- rendall 4y ago> you have to find all the silenced users on the talk pages to learn about the real scope of a topic... You definitely need to read the talk page.
- jimmar 4y agoSome teachers like to play god in the classroom. Source: I'm a teacher. I try not to play god and impose non-sensical rules, but I could if I wanted to and nobody could do anything about it. Parents could complain, my department head could try to talk sense into me, but if I impose a rule saying that citations must be written in Comic Sans size 11 font with every third word italicized, then I'm within my rights to take points off for deviations from the assignment instructions. Society places a lot of trust in teachers, and there are few checks against bad teachers.
- freedomben 4y agoAs someone who suffered under teachers who like to play god, and thrived under teachers like you, thank you. > citations must be written in Comic Sans size 11 font with every third word italicized you would become a legend if you did this :-D
- bombcar 4y agoI could see it as a easy example of the "brown M&Ms" theory: https://www.npr.org/sections/therecord/2012/02/14/146880432/the-truth-about-van-halen-and-those-brown-m-ms https://www.npr.org/sections/therecord/2012/02/14/146880432/...
- influx 4y agoSimilarly to police unions, teacher unions prevent many of those checks. Public servants do not serve society by having unions.
- thebooktocome 4y agoIn my locality, the union is the last line of defense for teachers who don’t want to teach creationism, abstinence, and the like. Local politicians are far easier for a vocal minority to bully.
- bobkazamakis 4y agoPolice and teacher unions are terrible not because they are public servants but because our capitalist system provides them with no way to extract additional value. Teachers don't have qualified immunity or get the privilege of shooting your dog, making it a pretty poor comparison.
- Aspos 4y agoSo a wrapper with a random legitimate-lloking URL, a custom CSS styling which would serve wikipedia content with some random wacky headers and footers would do as a source in your kid's school?
- aidenn0 4y agoI was in primary school before the web, and we were either discouraged or forbidden from citing encyclopedias. Tertiary sources, in general, have been discouraged for papers for a long time.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoGoogle books should be free to peruse for school students. That would be a good use of government money. If people are against Google books, then the governments should scan and share all of human knowledge.
- tbt 4y agoSchool rarely helps with learning and almost always harms learning. If you're still sending your kids to school, be mindful that you're doing that for reasons other than to help them learn.
- JediWing 4y agoThat is a bold claim. In my experience school gave me exposure to subjects I would not have thought or been interested to explore on my own, and put structure around dedicated learning time. I have kids. I send them to school. They are learning! You might have a leg to stand on if your argument weren't so incredibly absolutist. I could certainly concede that American schools may be a less than optimal way to learn with some outmoded practices. There are certainly variances in educational quality. But school rarely helps with learning? School almost always harms learning? I reject those claims as false on their face.
- tbt 4y agoIt rarely helps with learning vs. natural counterfactuals. It harms by socializing kids to not believe that their own curiosity is hopeworthy. See John Taylor Gatto's work. Instead of inefficient spending for large, programmed classes, you should have daycare/day supervision with lots of resources (books, internet, age-appropriate tinker equipment like electronics and tools and so on, microscopes, telescopes, a few adults on hand who are experts in whatever topic to help kids get traction / navigate), more free-rangness, less authoritarianness, more mastery learning, more apprenticeship.
- shadowgovt 4y agoThe flaw in the policy isn't don't use Wikipedia. It's don't use Wikipedia but then do use Google and trust whatever comes up as top search result. That's bad policy. Policy when I was in high school was don't quote Wikipedia, but feel free to chase sources cited by it, read those, and analyze and quote those. This still has the potential for bias, of course (the editors on Wikipedia will have pruned the set of sources cited by the article), but the meta-goal was to teach students how to search primary sources (read: "Actually get up and go to a library and open a book,") so it achieved that goal even if the books were biased.
- flerchin 4y agoIs this guy me? He could be me. Literally had this same conversation with my kids this week.
- aimor 4y agoEvery now and then I like to read through Wikipedia pages for things I know more than the average person on. It keeps me skeptical of the things I read on there. For people unfamiliar with a subject (students) I think Wikipedia pages are misleading, poorly organized, and sometimes wrong. That doesn't make Wikipedia useless, but the author's best advice is to use Wikipedia as a map to other sources of information. I don't think Wikipedia has a path forwards for fixing the quality of its articles. In my opinion it requires every page being rewritten by an expert with a single voice, as a traditional encyclopedia would have, which is the exact opposite of Wikipedia's core. Though I did check, and they have more than enough cash to write a traditional encyclopedia.
- akolbe 4y ago"The apparent accuracy of a Wikipedia article is inversely proportional to the depth of the reader's knowledge of the topic." – Kozierok's First Law
- encylopinion 4y agoI stopped using Wikipedia a while ago. Its math and science content is too nonsensical to be useful. I occasionally read a history article, maybe once every 6 months. But history from things happening hundreds to thousands of years ago, predating modern media... sorry historians, it might as well be fiction. I'm sure someone has thought long and hard about why the content is losing quality.
- hutzlibu 4y ago"Its math and science content is too nonsensical to be useful." Can you name a example? I found them to be generally of higher quality than controversial topics. So maybe not always with the best didactic approach, but usually a good start. And then I follow the links, if I want to dive in deep. Wikipedia is useful for me, for quickly checking something. Not scientifically dive into a deep topic.
- thebooktocome 4y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partial_differential_equation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partial_differential_equatio... Repetitive content, written at several levels simultaneously, weird fixations on tangential topics.
- twobitshifter 4y agoIf we’re thinking about sources: Teacher primary source on policy Student secondary source on citation policy This blog post is third in line It could be that the teacher is explaining to students, don’t copy and paste from Wikipedia, go to the source, and use Google Scholar to find your sources. If they’re using Scholar, are they still Googling? Maybe to a child.
- fonix232 4y agoWikipedia needs some further systems implemented to ensure that the information they host is valid and correct. For starters it would be nice if established articles had a level of protection by default - e.g. don't immediately publish changes, but await for consensus and/or a known reputable contributor accepting those changes. This would both help avoiding vandalism, and maintaining the quality level of the wiki pages altogether. Then another thing I'd like to see is recently changed sections being highlighted - e.g. an added sentence/word/reference, a deleted section, etc., would all be useful to see. Combine this highlighting with the previous idea of withheld contributions (i.e. show the new contribution, but mark it with a warning that it's not yet confirmed legitimacy, and even offer the user to vote if it's a legit edit or not). Basically, Wikipedia needs to transition from a 'raw information first' approach to something that also addresses edit history in an immediately visible way.
- devteambravo 4y agoIt's all part of the scam. What are we gonna do about it? Legitimately asking.. Have a 7yo and I'm afraid for their future.
- nailer 4y agoThis is Wikipedia's fault. - Wikipedia know people mistakenly cite Wikipedia itself - Wikipedia agree that people should not do this - Wikipedia had the opportunity to educate Wikipedia's audience not to do this. - Wikipedia has not educated Wikipedia's audience not to cite Wikipedia itself. What they should have done: > We hope you find Wikipedia useful. Remember to never cite Wikipedia itself! Instead cite the websites and research papers Wikipedia cites. If information isn't cited by Wikipedia, don't use it! It can be added by anyone and can even be removed from Wikipedia at any time! That's all they needed to do.
- akolbe 4y agoTo be fair, they did and do. Every page contains a link at the bottom to a "Disclaimer", the first two paragraphs of which read as follows: "Wikipedia is an online open-content collaborative encyclopedia; that is, a voluntary association of individuals and groups working to develop a common resource of human knowledge. The structure of the project allows anyone with an Internet connection to alter its content. Please be advised that nothing found here has necessarily been reviewed by people with the expertise required to provide you with complete, accurate or reliable information. "That is not to say that you will not find valuable and accurate information in Wikipedia; much of the time you will. However, Wikipedia cannot guarantee the validity of the information found here. The content of any given article may recently have been changed, vandalized, or altered by someone whose opinion does not correspond with the state of knowledge in the relevant fields. Note that most other encyclopedias and reference works also have disclaimers." Moreover, see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Wikipedia_is_not_a_reliable_source https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Wikipedia_is_not_a_r... It's just that people don't take any notice.
- nailer 4y agoI’ve think people aren’t seeing the disclaimer, rather than ignoring it. An on screen notification that appears for first time users or when text is selected are possible user interfaces that would ensure people understand.
- 4y ago
- reducesuffering 4y agoI learned 10x the world history from Wikipedia than I ever did from history classes writing up non-wiki citations in the proper format.
- mherdeg 4y agoI'm actually really glad that schools are sending the message "don't use Wikipedia as a trusted source". Students and parents naturally being contrarians will ... use Wikipedia, or learn to read primary sources and re-cite them, which is a step towards primary source research and a step in the direction of critical media consumption. If students and teachers happen to notice that the Wikipedia consensus is close to reality … that's a great side effect. Teaching them that the raw consensus of most Internet users is generally trustworthy is a pro-social exercise (even if you do it in a sneaky way by triggering students' rebellious instincts). And teaching them that their teachers are misguided in the way they talk about Wikipedia is, arguably, also a good critical-thinking exercise. An alternate exercise that schools or parents could do is to have their kid try to introduce a false fact into Wikipedia and see how long it lasts or whether it can enter reality via citogenesis. It's better that kids are not introduced to this concept. I'm glad that it's not done.
- Cyberdog 4y agoBut what about when the Wikipedia consensus is quite far from reality? If your only source for most or all of your information is Wikipedia, you will never know.
- JediWing 4y agoMy understanding of "don't cite Wikipedia" is the same for "don't cite the Encyclopedia". By failing to use a primary source, you're subjecting yourself to the interpretation and biases of someone who has already ingested the source material and formed an opinion. It's a great place to orient yourself on a piece of subject matter, though! And I certainly agree that the dreck that makes up 95% of Google results should certainly not be cited academically.
- lxe 4y agoInteresting how this mentality haven't changed in many decades now. We weren't "allowed" to cite/use wikipedia as any type of source in high school back in 2006. The easy solution is simply to cite the primary sources directly from the wikipedia's citation.
- MrTortoise 4y agoI would expect wikipedias to be more accurate than teachers. I am a software engineer who spends his life showing people the origional sources of information to help them unpick collective repeated misunderstandings. That takes me, with more experience that my team combined to do that. teachers have experience of teaching - not possessing knowledge or the practises of sifting, applying and validating their hypothesis aroudn the veracity of information. Most curriculums are out of date in ways that don't matter all that much. But i still rekon wikipedia is still more up to date than them.
- graypegg 4y agoOne of the most useful parts of a wikipedia article are the table of references on every article, glad the author mentioned that. Maybe they've dealt with some uninterested teachers, but I only remember mine telling me to not CITE wikipedia, not that it was untouchable. For any topic, you have a starter kit of references to go and check out, with a light synopsis of why it's relevant so you can filter out the junk ones, that's a pretty valuable tool on it's own!
- strangattractor 4y agoWow - these comments are wackier than anything I have ever read in Wikipedia. 1. Using XKCD as a source for academic malfeasance. 2. Thinking that encyclopedias should be/are written by a single individual. 3. Wikipedia's editorial policies result in the amplification and ossification of (political, academic, medical, etc.) establishment narratives and standards, which are often corrupt for a wide variety of reasons. 4. Wikipedia is anti-useful. I'll add my own. Wikipedia causes halitosis and ED. Before Wikipedia people did not have to evaluate their sources. Wikipedia is causing the culture wars in the US. Kids should be looking things up in the card catalog because it teaches patience and persistence. Wikipedia articles don't cover the topics in depth......
- davidjfelix 4y agoThis is the kind of FACT based analysis I look for when complaining about computers on a computer forum. Could you possibly assign a "truth score" to this for me so that I can ask a scholarly journal (which has never been accused of publishing falsified data) to publish it!? Sorry for the sarcasm. I've been rolling my eyes at the comments too. Where do these lunatics come from?
- Minor49er 4y agoI hope a student finds this blog post on Google and shows it to the teacher
- impalallama 4y agoEveryone knows that you just use wikipedia's own sources instead.
- throwawaygal7 4y agoWikipedia is most young peoples go to source for knowledge. The way important entries frame a subject is considered to be a neutral observers take, but they're often anything but when it comes to politics, history and philosophy. Often these important entries are the personal fife of one or more admin who structured things according to personal preference. An easy way to see this is to look at a topic that is split in the academy along geographical lines - the entry in wiki will often favour whatever region the original cabal sided with and give the other short thrift. Meeting a wikipedia admin in real life is often eye opening and explains some of these choices. The old encyclopedias were more transparent; siding with their own cultures scholars in a way that was generally more uniform. Wiki masquerades as the final objective authority but has the same old issues burried and obscured. Even an undergrad intro course on a given historical subject will often come into violent conflict with a given entry. The best entries are scientific topics, like botany or physics - and this impression of mine is probbaly based on ignorance.
- jmchuster 4y agoWhen i was in school, the rule was also "you can't use the encyclopedia as a source". So it feels more like trying to get students to learn to find and use primary sources. Wikipedia actually makes this incredibly simple now, since everything has a citation link.
- rendall 4y ago> learn to find and use primary sources... Except that Wikipedia policy is only to use secondary sources, otherwise it is considered original research.
- karaterobot 4y agoSeems like the purpose of these research papers in school got lost somewhere. They are an opportunity to develop skills and judgment, not to do important scholarly work. By saying "don't use Wikipedia" they are missing an opportunity to teach kids how to find and vet resources. Wikipedia does have a ton of issues: as do, evidently, some of the top peer-reviewed journals in the world. So, the provenance of a citation is not enough, and focusing on it is beside the point. The skill schools should be teaching is how to sift the wheat from the chaff, since that will be more valuable later on.
- rvba 4y agoI dont understand thr current trend on Wikipedia to add long quotes by various people to the articles. This makes fhr articles less concise. It also feels like reading material for 5th grade. I tried deleting those few times but often this led to edit wars. It feels as if in some cases some D tier people want to be quoted on wikipedia for stuff, so they add own quotes and "guard" them from taking them down.
- SevenNation 4y ago> If I thought it would be even remotely worth doing, I would fight this shit at the school. Sadly, I do not. This statement (and the general sense of the author's emotional state) makes me wonder whether the author has actually spoken with teachers or is getting his information from his kids. Kids are just as capable of spinning facts for effect as adults. Or ignoring nuance. Or straight up misinterpretation. Before "fighting" the school, the first step should be to understand the school's position. Then the teacher's position. Only after the actual facts are on the table should a decision about action be taken. The author appears to be doing the same thing he rails against the school for doing: treating a single source as the beginning and end of the story.
- jshandling 4y agoHere here!
- verisimilitudes 4y agoThey could learn about SNES emulator Near (RIP) or, say, the Scots language.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jrm4 4y agoThat's funny, I literally have this discussion at the beginning of every semester of my college "Technology for Information Professionals" class. It's such a good icebreaker. Always starts with a timid "Oh, I can see reasons for both" and ends with "What were my teachers thinking? Anyway we would just cite the articles that Wikipedia cited to lol"
- yamtaddle 4y agoThis is a good thing to point out (guess what: books are still way better than both, yes, physical books, I know they shouldn't be in this The Year of Our Lord 2022 but they are, the whole "information superhighway" and "making all the world's information accessible at your fingertips" hasn't worked out as well as we thought it would) but I was really hoping this post would be a showdown between lies taught in school and the more-correct versions on characterized-by-teachers-as-unreliable Wikipedia. That would have been funny.
- brnaftr361 4y agoTextbooks are obscenely limited. Interactive feedback is gone, animation is gone. I mean trigonometry is so much easier to understand if you have moving visualizations of what everything means. And because of the obscene costs of textbooks, and the various moats that publishers have, including book-specific curricula, and the very low effort options they have for homework assigning and grading student get tied into a shitty ecosystem at great cost with zero optionality. And how many students have spent how many hours of their lives reinventing the wheel to build mental models to do shit that was done decades ago? As opposed to the internet, where you can find a variety of options using different modalities and have direct feedback visually, numerically or otherwise through parametric models that can give you instantaneous feedback. Shit even Desmos alone can give you a huge deal of insight by tossing variables in and instantly seeing the results as opposed to taking 3 minutes every time you change a var with the TI-84 CE bullshit academia forces onto students. Oh and it's all free of cost. Shit there are even open source textbooks now, but nobody uses them.
- yamtaddle 4y agoI would agree that the Internet has delivered spectacularly well in a few kinds of instruction. But if you're looking for raw, across-all-disciplines knowledge, books still win and it's not even particularly close. They shouldn't, but somehow they do. Library Genesis is probably the best free part of the Web by a country mile, as far as raw disseminating-human-knowledge goes, and it's supposed to be illegal. And its utility is based on... giving you free access to books, periodicals, and papers.
- betwixthewires 4y agoTeachers are overpaid and mostly pretty stupid. School boards are bureaucracies that prioritize student learning somewhere near the bottom of the list. What do you expect?
- chris_wot 4y agoWhere can I get a job as an overpaid high school teacher?
- betwixthewires 4y agoGo apply I'm sure they're hiring seeing as they'll hire anyone.
- chris_wot 4y agoDear god, they’ll overpay just anyone?
- floppydisc 4y agoJust out of curiosity; has anyone here contributed to Wikipedia?
- Cyberdog 4y agoYes, back before I lost faith in the project. I actually initiated some somewhat-notable articles such as those on Tank Man (the Tiananmen Square protester) and traditional ("hand-drawn") animation. Most of my more recent contributions have been fixing typos/grammar or removing obvious spam, but I've given up on doing even that little as of late.
- floppydisc 4y agoWhy have you given up? Is there too much spam-bashing?
- chris_wot 4y agoI did. I invented the [citation needed] template. I have written countless articles and done more maintenance work than most. I was recently banned indefinitely by a mob.
- floppydisc 4y agoWhat was the cause of the ban?
- mcguire 4y agoWhen I was in school, long before Wikipedia, encyclopedias weren't accepted as references. That's why you had to go to the library. I don't have a problem with that part. On the other hand, if I were a teacher, citations of random internet stuff would result in a bit of a lecture and points off the second time.
- IceHegel 4y agoWikipedia is the closest thing the west has to Regime media. It’s usually correct about factual matters, but has high levels of embedded bias towards establishment ideas.
- bArray 4y agoWikipedia certainly has its biases, but I think for school children it is perfectly fine as a source. It's not as if they will read research papers instead, let alone understand the quality of their source.
- rtanks 4y agoI've always used Wikipedia as a starting point to lead me to other sources.
- sagondis 4y agoI had a fight with my 9th grade daughter on the exact same topic. She was arguing anything other than wikipedia is more accurate !
- THENATHE 4y agoWikipedia is the single greatest tool mankind has ever developed for the internet. Where else can you get a mostly correct and accurate understanding of essentially any topic known to man for free, and then have resources for further research if desired. Even if Wikipedia isn’t 100% correct on everything, I can’t think of any resource that is (that is also free).
- j7f3 4y agoyeah that's rather correct when it comes to the English language Wikipedia but the Polish language Wikipedia has been hijacked by the right wing nut jobs it's public knowledge by now not to trust Wikipedia in Poland unless you're one of them also Polish politicians use Wikipedia to boost their profiles, they treat is as a free self aggrandizement platform everyone knows they edit their own profiles and wipe out any unflattering info Polish Wikipedia is a poster child for what could go wrong when you leave editing to the common people
- jccalhoun 4y agoI teach college and I still get college students straight out of high school who think that a web site is credible if it is a .org.
- cjohnson318 4y agoArguing about the relative strengths of Wikipedia versus Brittanica highlights the core issue that very few things are irrefutable fact that can be proven and expressed concisely with natural language, and that most things are beliefs, and interpretations of biased or limited observations. Both sources are "mostly accurate", it's just that some teachers think that using the internet for research is too easy; "carrying books back and forth across the library builds character".
- raydiatian 4y agoWhat is most interesting about this article is that this doctrine seems not to have changed for 20 years. I was told the exact same thing back in the early 00's: "Wikipedia is the devil". It's a well known fact to anybody that has passed through them that public schools are a fucking joke. It's not the teachers fault, it's the budget's fault. Another point with regard to this article is that the notion of single-source citation is absolutely stupid. At CERN, do you think scientists see a single event that confirms the existence of the Higgs boson, and then declare victory? Absolutely not. So why would you rely on one article saying that "X" is true. Use Wikipedia, and Google, and synthesize an averaged perspective, or at least a perspective that takes into account incongruencies between sources if nothing less. The irony then of me assuming that public schools are still peddling "Wikipedia=bad" based on a single article is not lost on me.
- trevcanhuman 4y agowhy would it be the budget's fault ? I disagree. The private high school were I attended also said this about wikipedia. Yet it recommended using Google search and Google scholar for getting the primary sources. But you know what I've found ? It's hard to read primary sources. I tried reading up on e.g. the cell. The parts of a cell. But I've barely found any primary sources for it. Everything is in ad-filled webpages or cool academic webpages with images but no references! Also, I think recommending Google search is bad because it tries to guess what you're searching for based on the profile they have about you! That's just so bad for getting objective information.
- raydiatian 4y ago> But you know what I’ve found ? That you can stick a space between the last word and the question mark to annoying effect, I suppose. > The rest of what you said Is mostly disheveled in its organization to the point where I can’t really respond effectively. Glad to know private schools are failing people as well, I guess. Nevertheless > I disagree. Seriously, with what. From context it seems to be that you disagree with using online searches other than Wikipedia (or maybe Jstor) for research purposes but you put “I disagree” right in the vicinity of (a) question about budget relation to public school being a shitshow (b) the fact that you went to private school and (c) that your private school lamented the use of Wikipedia, something I also disagreed with. Based on all I’ve said and what you’ve said, what you disagree with remains unclear, and vaguely discernible from contextual clues. > Why is it the budget’s fault (that public school is bad) Have you watched the news lately, there’s like a weekly or monthly school shooting. Have you ever had free lunch? How many teachers do you know in the public school system that retire financially secure? What is the national average for college attendance out of public schools, then compared to that of other nation’s numbers? How effectively do public schools campaign for and encourage students to pursue higher education? Public school budgets could benefit from federal spending increases (as one option but literally any source would make a difference) to increase mental health resources, acquiring better teachers, encouraging better educators to work in public schools, improving resources available for education, I mean do I really have to exhaust this laundry list? > But you know what I’ve found? It’s hard to read primary sources. Respectfully what does that have to do with anything. This sounds like a reading disability, not a condemnation of… what, online articles? Are you a bot? I swear you must be a bot. This makes no sense. > Ad-filled webpages Get an ad-blocker? Scroll past Google’s search suggestions? > Google search is bad because it tries to guess… Then use DuckDuckGo, or alternative du jour. “Googling” is a widely-accepted synonym for “web search”.
- CivBase 4y agoWhen I was in high school a little over a decade ago, my school told us to use an academic search engine that they payed for access to. It was actually pretty neat. I'm surprised that hasn't become more ubiquitous.
- BashiBazouk 4y agoI would think just taking everything at face value on the main wikipedia article might not be a good idea but if after reading the article, doing some verification by following the citation links or using the article and citation links as a jumping off point for further research would work as well as anything from the card catalog library days of my education.
- pogform 4y ago> And holy hell, don’t get me started on how they teach math or English, or this new "Code Red" shit. I'm really interested in this off-handed remark from the author. Not having children of my own, and being many years removed from the US public school system, what exactly are they getting at here? I'm assuming it's related to common core?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- davegauer 4y agoSchool shooting drills.
- linuxhansl 4y agoControversial pages on Wikipedia (contemporary politics, etc) are typically hard to edit. Others are easy to edit. Vandalism is rare and temporary, and nobody is going fight earnestly over topics such as how a light bulb or an electric engine works, or when a certain building was build or most historical events, etc. Wikipedia does not absolve you from checking references or the credibility of the text, but it does a damn good job collecting and pre-checking a lot of the content. You still need to be able to recognize hot-button topics and take those with a grain of salt. And as I said usually those pages cannot be edited by everyone. The school does not seem to understand how Wikipedia works. At all.
- Proziam 4y agoMany controversial pages on Wikipedia have a clearly identifiable bias which becomes impossible to edit because, as you mentioned, they are somewhat 'protected.' For such instances it is always advisable to go directly to genuine source materials, e.g., case records or legal documents. Were I a teacher I would not accept any compiled source as a citation because the skill of digging deep enough to find the closest thing to the truth is too valuable to do otherwise.
- franciscop 4y agoThree years? I was a highschool student 10+ years ago and back then they already didn't allow us to use Wikipedia, luckily at least we were explained that we could read thing in Wikipedia and then use the sources as our own sources. I remember spending waay too many hours reading bout "exotic" physic topics there and then asking my teacher, who was luckily not annoyed! (or at least didn't show so)
- inawarminister 4y agoI used to read a LOT of random Wikipedia articles in English when I was in late primary school and middle school. Might be the main activity I did that allowed me to start learning proper, academic English. I've been doing the same now in Japanese and Interlingua (or Latin directly). And while I don't know if the truth is there, at least for daily level comprehension it's a very useful method.
- chx 4y agoIn a lot of things historical, Wikipedia is overrun by, let's not mince words, neonazis. If you want to be more polite, people with a very strong yearning of their nations past to be really great, science be damned. The thing is, everything needs to be sourced but the veracity of the source, especially if it is not in English is not verified. That's because of the "no credentials are recognized" policy of Wikipedia which makes every historian stay far away from this cesspool of trolls. And since it's a clique, it's impossible to fix anything, edits will be reverted and there's nowhere to turn. I gave up, too, long ago. I was adding the proper spelling of an ancient Persian vizier and scholar and my edit was reverted with "The other names in the lead are not supposed to have custom alphabets or whatever they're called". It's a Persian article and you refuse "custom alphabets or whatever they're called"?? I am out of here.
- chris_wot 4y agoI don't know why this is being downvoted. This is happening in lots of ways, small and large. To be successful on Wikipedia, you need to know how to game the system.
- c7b 4y agoIn my experience the wikipedia articles themselves are good, but the references unfortunately less so. Way too many newspaper-style sources, the academic papers range from 'the actual original paper on the topic' to 'obscure'. I wish articles had a section similar to the literature review in academic papers, that could raise the quality a lot. I think it'd need some nudging/template to get that somewhat consistent (like the boxes they have on many articles that are connected via a common theme, those are great).
- LunicLynx 4y agoProbably the most simple fact is, that Wikipedia destroyed an industry. While this industry came down they sowed the seed of not trusting a source where everybody could do what they did. For free. I’m with the OP on this. There are probably mistakes. Especially on highly contentious articles (politics). But in general it is the best collection of factual information out there.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoI am very pro-wikipedia. If there's a problem with Wikipedia or even just the way that people use Wikipedia then I think it should be discussed, because that improves Wikipedia, and Wikipedia is an amazing human achievement. I'll repeat my comment the last time this came up, that if you want a basic summary (probably more suitable for school) then the simple English Wikipedia exists. It is slightly less likely to have a long rambling article. I personally like the long rambling articles, because the point of a wiki should be to be easily updated, to harness the most intellectual input, and I feel it often better reflects reality than a polished summary. But there is a place for polished summaries. Probably won't be long before they are done by AI (introducing more fascinating philosophical questions) but for now simple human written pages are available. There seems to be some concerted movement to not fund Wikipedia, I'd encourage people to both donate money and time. The easiest way to get that money spent is by having lots of people using and improving Wikipedia and its sister projects.
- fhchl 4y agoI feel it is important to teach kids not only to be critical of online content but also give them recommendations/hints/alternatives on where to find good sources of information. Finding content online is surely a good skill but supplying a catalogue of good sources via a mentor / teacher kick-starts people to understand what actual reliable content is. For example, I recommend anyone interested in math subjects to (also) check the Princeton companions to (applied) math. https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691150390/the-princeton-companion-to-applied-mathematics https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691150390/th... https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691118802/the-princeton-companion-to-mathematics https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691118802/th...