7 ms·
Musk's trial hasn't stopped, no matter what he told Twitter, says judge
- asdfasgasdgasdg 4y agoWhat!? How has nobody filed for a stay yet!? What do you supposed the legal teams are doing right now? Presumably there is some effort to make musk sign an even more iron clad deal before agreeing to a stay. Something like, "no condition that existed prior to October 5, 2022, material or not, shall be grounds for terminating the merger agreement." Perhaps they want him to remove the financing contingency given that if financing falls through Elon bears the majority of the blame for that. I guess from Twitter's perspective it's fine if things go to a trial since they are going to win anyway. And every day that passes increases the torque on Elon and X holdings. They have him over a barrel so why not demand concessions to ensure that no more shenanigans occur?
- helloworld97 4y ago
- dragontamer 4y ago> Presumably there is some effort to make musk sign an even more iron clad deal Why would anyone trust a piece of paper with Musk's signature on it after the months of tantrum he just pulled over this acquisition? The deal is already ironclad as it is. That didn't stop the tantrum. The only thing that's holding leeway over Musk right now is this court case.
- Nokinside 4y agoTwitter has no reason to stop the trial until the deal has closed (it can happen early next week). Why leave any room for Musk to delay or change his mind. Fool me once ...
- ceejayoz 4y ago> How has nobody filed for a stay yet!? Twitter doesn't want one, and would oppose a request for one. The judge in the case has been openly skeptical of Musk's delaying tactics and indicated the other day she thinks Musk let Signal conversations delete during discovery (https://www.theverge.com/2022/10/5/23389568/musk-twitter-signal-deleted-messages-judge-ruling https://www.theverge.com/2022/10/5/23389568/musk-twitter-sig...). He's out of good will here.
- cainxinth 4y agoExactly. He literally signed a contract that he tried to renege on. Now they are supposed to just take his word that everything is copacetic again?
- shadowgovt 4y agoIt should probably be signal boosted that when you are under a discovery documentation hold, the fact that services like Signal have auto-deletion as a feature do not protect those documents from Discovery and actively work against the user's best interests. "But your honor, I can't produce those documents because they were on a conveyor belt into a furnace" isn't a valid legal defense.
- deelowe 4y agoIt is if you don’t have access to the conveyor. Otherwise, you’d be liable for documents lost due to acts of God. He can still be in trouble if they can prove he used signal specifically to avoid disclosures during discovery.
- ceejayoz 4y agoSignal deletions aren't an act of God. Upon receipt of a preservation order, those Signal conversations should've been preserved. Give an intern the task of screenshotting them all. The same rules apply if, say, you delete email after 30 days; you have to pause that process once you've been required to retain evidence.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoIn this increasingly stretched metaphor he was the one that turned on the conveyor - disappearing texts is an option you have to turn on, not mandatory and not enabled by default.
- matt-attack 4y agoHow can they know or prove that he was even texting with Signal? How do they know those messages existed?
- Nokinside 4y agoMakes sense. Offer to close "pending the receipt" is not good enough. Musk has made so many quick reversals that there is no trust left. Twitter has no reason to ask for a stay until the deal is closed. It's better to just keep pushing and motivate Musk to close asap.
- belter 4y agoPDF: https://courts.delaware.gov/Opinions/Download.aspx?id=338770 https://courts.delaware.gov/Opinions/Download.aspx?id=338770
- Nokinside 4y agoMatt Levine: >What Musk apparently wants is to pause the trial while they can work this all out: He offered to “proceed to closing of the transaction,” but only “provided that the Delaware Chancery Court enter an immediate stay of the action ... and adjourn the trial.” What Twitter wants is sort of the opposite, to keep the pressure of a trial on Musk until he shows up with the money. This feels like a solvable problem — basically, you write some sort of agreement that says like “we’re going to work together to get the closing done this week, but if we don’t we’re gonna have an extra-super-bad trial,” and you get Chancellor McCormick to bless it — but they have to work together to solve it. They have to negotiate and draft an Agreement to Stick to the Agreement. If you’re writing that agreement, you have some trust issues.
- Zigurd 4y agoBloomberg is reporting Musk wants the deal to be contingent on debt financing. Twitter does not like that. So choices are: a) There is no new agreement. Litigation proceeds. b) Musk floats an actual walk-away settlement in an amount Twitter would agree to.
- jbverschoor 4y agoSeems like another trick to postpone / lower the price to me.. > on the terms and subject to the conditions set forth therein and pending receipt of the proceeds of the debt financing contemplated thereby So if the financing terms cannot be met, the deal is off. Perhaps some terms are about revenue, users, value of the collateral (TSLA perhaps?). Heck, maybe Elon found one of his Billy friends to short TSLA termporarily, which would cause the collateral to be not enough. Tricks I tell you
- dragontamer 4y agoThe discussion I've seen is that this is such a strongly written contract, that the only out is Elon Musk declaring bankruptcy. At which point, the court will seize all of Elons TSLA shares and use it to pay for TWTR as best they can. Either that, or Morgan Stanley (Bank in charge of $13 billion) needs to start talking about bots and mDAU Given how well that went for Elon, I don't think Morgan Stanley will do that. It's better for them to take the billions they lost on this deal already and just write it off. (Maybe $1 or $2 billion loss so far given how much credit markets have moved between April and today)
- hef19898 4y agoSince Musk signed a very one sided contract with Twitter to buy the company, I have zero reason to assume the contracts with his financing partners are any different. So, a wild guess I know, as long as Musk's Tesla shares are enough to pay the 54.20 per share for Twitter, why would banks object to the deal? They will get enough collateral, one way or the other. For Musk so, it doesn't look too good.
- jbverschoor 4y agoBanks can give any reason why they won't finance, and MS will do so for EM as long as the risk-reward ratio of EM as a client is high enough. Reasons could be - TSLA is volatile. The stock would fall if EM doesn't own enough share anymore, because of the risk of him leaving as CEO. Market conditions. "For reasons of their own"
- robertwt7 4y agoIt should be a win for twitter, although Elon has done some great stuff, a person like him shouldn't be allowed to just tweet random stuff like that then cancel. isn't that manipulating the market as well? I feel bad for the twitter employee and stakeholder at the same time tbh. One day out of nowhere a billionaire just talk some random stuff about buying twitter, plunging the stocks, then cancels, then drama..
- dragontamer 4y agoThis is all very terrible for Twitter. Forcing someone to be the owner of a company they don't want is just bad. But this is very good for Twitter shareholders. Forcing the deal is important for US Contract law in general. When people sign documents, they must be solid with the courts enforcing the contract. We can't just let one person give up deals after the fact.
- bena 4y agoIt's also bad for Musk. He's being forced to own a company he doesn't want. And probably can't offload for anywhere he paid for it. He can either try and make it work or just eat billions in loss.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- maccard 4y agoNobody forced musk to sign a contract binding him to buy twitter. He did that of his own volition. Let's not pretend that he is caught in some red tape here
- bena 4y agoI'm not saying "Woe is Musk", I'm saying this is a deal where everyone is going to lose. I don't even know what the worst/best case scenarios would be here. If he's right about Twitter, now he has essentially a toxic asset and everyone knows it. But he made a bad deal in the worst way. No one is buying it from him. And people are going to be more hesitant to deal with him in the future. Because he's obviously not doing due diligence. If he's wrong, it's not a good look for him either and while someone may eventually buy Twitter off of him, he'll likely have trouble with other deals still. Because of the diligence issue, and his conduct through this ordeal. Like, who is coming out of this deal happy?
- rc_mob 4y agoTwitter is going to become a bed of lies under his rule.
- salawat 4y agoAs if it wasn't already?
- cainxinth 4y agoJust because something is bad doesn't mean it can't get any worse.
- shadowgovt 4y agoIt'll only get that bad if we're lucky. Something has to be done to convince the average user that Twitter is not their friend, is not a reliable source of information, and is not a good place to share your intimate thoughts because they're sitting out on a public forum for everyone to see. Maybe Musk turning it into his private hell playground will do the trick finally.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Bakary 4y agoTwitter users don't want reliable information but attention
- cainxinth 4y agoWe all want things. I, for example, want the U.S. government to regulate all these social networks much more aggressively given the provable and significant impact they have on elections. I know the free speech absolutists like Elon find that idea unpalatable, but I think the Wild West era of social media needs to come to a close.
- 4y ago
- mrcwinn 4y agoFor what it's worth, deposition has been postponed while parties work out a settlement: https://www.reuters.com/markets/us/elon-musk-twitter-agree-postpone-musks-thursday-deposition-2022-10-06/ https://www.reuters.com/markets/us/elon-musk-twitter-agree-p...
- belter 4y agoIt's Musk you are talking about... "Musk declined to attend in-person Twitter deposition, citing COVID exposure risk" - https://news.yahoo.com/musk-declined-attend-person-twitter-200254654.html https://news.yahoo.com/musk-declined-attend-person-twitter-2... Note the link above refers to a previous scheduled date, not the one that should start today. :-)
- outside1234 4y agoThis from the guy that wanted his employees to work in close spaces during the height of the pandemic without be vaccinated? What a BS artist this guy is
- 4ggr0 4y ago> citing COVID exposure risk Is this the same Musk who wanted to keep his factories running and downplaying COVID? - https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/13/business/Elon-Musk-tesla-factory-coronavirus.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/13/business/Elon-Musk-tesla-... Ironic that he's complaining about "fascist" COVID guidelines and wants to keep his lemmings working at all costs, but as soon as his own health is on the line, it's suddenly dangerous. (of course it's not ironic at all and just what I expect of him, but, you know...)
- Zigurd 4y agoIIRC the original deal deadline is October 24. This leads me to believe that Musk is under some time pressure to propose something like this. He is hoping Twitter agrees to this proposal and subsequently Musk would be able to blame financing falling apart for the failure to complete the deal. Twitter is right to suspect this is a ruse. Musk's tweets that he thinks Twitter would be an "accelerant" for some vague idea of a super-app is just more smoke to obscure a cynical move. He has no clue of how to make one. There is good reason to think the whole idea of a "super app" is specific to some Asian markets. Now Twitter must be counting all the losses Musk will take if Musk is forced to pay $54.20 per share. The settlement will be a few dollars less. There is potential for collateral damage: If Musk is forced to sell a lot of $TSLA, it could be the tipping point where investors wonder what a realistic valuation is for a car maker that is about the same size as BMW, but is currently valued 3.5X the market cap of Toyota.
- FabHK 4y agoJohn Gruber (from Daring Fireball) summarises Musk's move nicely: > Basically, Twitter is taking Musk to court to make him go through with his legally-binding offer from April. Musk today is proposing that if Twitter drops the suit, he will ... go through with his offer from April. https://daringfireball.net/linked/2022/10/04/bloomberg-musk-twitter https://daringfireball.net/linked/2022/10/04/bloomberg-musk-...
- falcolas 4y agoI can't see how it would benefit Twitter to drop the suit, since Musk could easily just go back to his previous tactics of delaying and fighting in the court of public opinion, as opposed to the court of law.
- datavirtue 4y agoMusk reminds of Trump more with each passing day.
- helf 4y agoRight? But, really, it isn't Trump he is reminding you of, it's every spoiled rich manchild who has surrounded themselves with yes men and willing fanbois and now believes their own shit. Not to mention he is getting to the age where your brain really starts turning to mush if you aren't proactively trying to prevent it. Watching a lot of Gen Xers become Boomer Lite is fascinating and infuriating.
- 93po 4y agoHow long till we start seeing the comments comparing Elon to Hitler? If we're doing Trump comparisons it can't be far behind.
- newphonecartel 4y agoIt's astounding how fast stuff falls off front page these days.
- irthomasthomas 4y agoMusk stories are downranked on HN. Dang has confirmed this. They don't want to expose Musk to the type of analysis and criticism that a forum of real engineers might engage in.
- 93po 4y agoStories that drive a lot of comments quickly get downranked. Unless you post the specific dang comment I seriously doubt that there's an Elon specific filter.
- nurettin 4y agoIt's funny, if twitter price keeps rocketing, he will actually get a good deal.
- TheCoelacanth 4y agoNo, the price is converging towards the acquisition price because people are starting to feel more confident that the deal will go through. No one would think Twitter is worth that much if there wasn't a pending acquisition at that price.
- nurettin 4y agoIt is my understanding that if price goes above 54, he will get a good deal buying at 54. Why do you say no?
- JamesSwift 4y agoThe "rocketing" is due to the deal being back on, because when it closes each of your shares is worth $54. Theres no incentive to pay over that price.
- pwinnski 4y agoIndeed, if the price goes above 54 and remains above 54, he will get a good deal. It will do neither of those things. It's only even getting near 54 because of the impending deal. People buying now know that when the deal closes, the shares will be worth 54, so if they can buy for less than that, then buy, buy, buy. Once the deal closes, it's profit-taking time, so sell, sell, sell--and the stock price plummets.