5 ms·
If you are paying any bill for ads, make sure you only pay for conversions. Ie. unless the customer actually buys your product, then don't pay anything. Eg.
by londons_explore 4y ago
If you are paying any bill for ads, make sure you only pay for conversions. Ie. unless the customer actually buys your product, then don't pay anything. Eg. instead of paying $0.002 per view of your ad, or $0.10 per click of your ad, pay $6 per person who clicks your ad and then buys your product.
That way, ad fraud doesn't affect you. Plenty of ad providers allow such an option. Internally, they convert your payments per conversion into payments per click and then payments per impression, but importantly this shifts the incentive to get rid of bots to them, not you - you no longer care. The provider also has an incentive to send you customers who will actually buy your product, and to send the bots and web scrapers to their other clients.
- amelius 4y agoQuestion: how do they know if you're playing fairly and tell them of the conversion? Also, do they get the customer's personal data that is involved in the purchase?
- abofh 4y agoUsually there's a magic pixel that you embed on the checkout success page or a callback you invoke. I suppose people could cheat, but if your ad never converts, the network has no incentive to run it.
- Nextgrid 4y agoThis has major privacy and GDPR implications though.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- robertlagrant 4y agoSuch as?
- bigbillheck 4y agoI don't think ad companies care too much about that.
- Nextgrid 4y agoThose who implement the tools from the ad companies are responsible for their GDPR compliance - you don't get to offload the blame somewhere else.
- kritiko 4y agoThis is why all websites have big cookie consent modals that appear before you can view content now. Most people just accept all. (And even when doing that, things like Apple Tracking Transparency have broken fingerprinting for a lot of adtech.)
- Nextgrid 4y agoNone of those consent modals are compliant. GDPR compliance requires those modals to make it as easy to decline as it is to accept, and not skew the choice via a pre-ticked checkbox or making one option more prominent than the other. Which again reinforces my point that nobody is interested in seriously enforcing the GDPR.
- BeFlatXIII 4y agoAlso, how effectively can the GDPR be enforced on companies with zero European assets? They can say “stuff it” when the fines are levied. Will the EU force blocking at the ISP level?
- Nextgrid 4y agoRealistically it doesn't matter because: 1) the biggest offenders do have EU-based subsidiaries which can be fined. 2) nobody bothers sufficiently enforcing it even against EU-based offenders, so no point talking about outside-EU enforcement for now.
- ta8645 4y agoThey don't. But if you don't pay them enough, ad-companies will stop sending you any customers at all, and instead put their efforts into catering to other higher-paying clients. So you are incentivized to make a good ad campaign that generates a lot of sales.
- marcosdumay 4y agoThat would be the correct answer. The ad-companies are auction based, so they shouldn't have any problem with it. But somehow, people report differently. (Personally, I haven't looked for a while, so I don't know.)
- jeltz 4y agoThey generally just trust you.
- LatteLazy 4y agoAudit: They click 10 ads and buy themselves and then check you compensate them for all 10 sales.
- jamespo 4y agoThis has been around for a long time, but which major ad providers offer this?
- londons_explore 4y agoGoogle adwords does: https://support.google.com/google-ads/answer/6268632?hl=en-GB https://support.google.com/google-ads/answer/6268632?hl=en-G...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- somedude895 4y agoNoone, except scammy "affiliate" post view rackets. You can set max cpa bid strategies, but that's still paying cpms.
- titoCA321 4y agoEven before online, newspaper would "distribute" their papers to hotels and college dorms to "invisible" subscribers to increase the count of their subscriptions. And let's not even get into how radio and TV viewers are counted via Nelson.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dan-robertson 4y agoA problem is that deciding whether or not a customer was converted from an ad viewer is done by the people you pay for ads. Perhaps the conversion numbers are slightly inflated but in general it’s just really hard to tell. If you show a lot of ads to potential customers then chances are, most people who buy things from you saw your ads. Does that mean they came to you because of the ad? I think even if you had perfect information it would be hard to decide. There is some chance that you just have an added sales tax where you send $6 to each advertiser every time you make a sale. I don’t know how much (eg) google care about deciding whether conversion numbers are correct. But how do they even decide if the numbers are correct and what stops them from being biased towards reporting higher conversion rates?
- londons_explore 4y agoMost online businesses have multiple ways to track conversions... It will become pretty obvious if Google says you sold 130 widgets but your warehouse guys only delivered 60.... Likewise, lots of businesses have a different landing page for people coming from an ad vs people from organic search and people coming from referral links/shared URL's. The business counts how many people visited each of those. They'll know if the ad providers stats are lying...
- blfr 4y agoThe issue is not that you sold 60 widgets but Google tells you it was 130. The issue is that you sold 60 widgets with ads but you would have sold 59 widgets without ads: are you making sales because of ads or are you showing ads to your would-be customers.
- heatmiser 4y agoIf I understand the premise, it should be simple enough to disaggregate my organic vs. paid-for conversions. For brand lift campaigns though, without enough historical sales numbers, I can see how it’s harder to tell if your ad money is being well spent.
- Dave3of5 4y ago> If you are paying any bill for ads, make sure you only pay for conversions Others have already pointed out that this is actually impossible. The big ad platforms charge on impressions you can setup any targeting you want but they charge on impressions that's it.
- disgruntledphd2 4y agoSo Facebook charge based on impressions, but they rank based on conversions which tends to reduce the impression billing problem.
- bluGill 4y agoConversion isn't the best metric though for many ads. The big advertisers don't care about conversion because they are not trying for customers today, they are trying for mind share so when someone thinks about buying they are on the list. Conversion is a lot easier to measure than "buys your car sometime in the next 3 years", and is worth measuring. However it is often only a proxy for the real metric.
- danielmorozoff 4y agoCan you share which services allow to pay for conversions?
- omgomgomgomg 4y agoWould be curious to here, too, as far ad networks go. There are many affiliates for online casinos, crypto exchanges etc, they usually have a cpa + revshare deal. They scrap the non converting audience, its vastly more expensive, but I imagine converting an impression from an add somewhere on an app or such to a paying depositor with life time values north of 200usd is just not going to be economically viable. So far, all I have spoken to ended up a cpm model slightly shuffled.
- aasasd 4y agoYeah, I long thought that these kinds of fraud are ultimately filtered by measuring the return. Paid to Zonama web shop to show your wares, but all visits are from people comparing prices with the in-house brand? Well drop the shop. Bought an ad campaign, see zero conversion? Why would anyone continue buying it.
- jonnat 4y agoEven if it would be easy only pay per conversion, you would create a different type of perverse incentive in which ad platforms would exclusively want to target consumers their models attach a high preexisting (before exposure to ads) probability of conversion. That is OK for lower funnel tactics but it would severely reduce your ability to put your brand in front of a new audience.
- beardedetim 4y agoMaybe there's two sets of ads being discussed here: exposure/top of tunnel and conversion/bottom of funnnel?
- remram 4y agoConversion is not even sufficient. Conversions tell you how many people went through your ad and successfully bought something, but the value of ads is *how many people who weren't already going to buy something bought something through the ad*. E.g. people might be seeing an ad for Target after typing "target" in Google. The number of conversions through that doesn't matter and should be discounted. People might be seeing an ad or hitting an affiliate link for a website they already use regularly, if they go there hours later it doesn't mean your ad is effective.
- omgomgomgomg 4y agoAfter speaking to many sales reps for ad networks I have decided to to so,however, these Cpa deals have negative value, say if you provide a service that will or with not have better customer life time value than the cost for the cpa, what would be a useful idea about that?
- jklinger410 4y ago> ...make sure you only pay for conversions...Plenty of ad providers allow such an option This is untrue.