19 ms·
An elegy for GNU and RMS
- ssivark 4y agoI'll begin by quoting an excerpt from "A man for all seasons" Alice More: Arrest him! More: Why, what has he done? Margaret More: He's bad! More: There is no law against that. Will Roper: There is! God's law! More: Then God can arrest him. Alice: While you talk, he's gone! More: And go he should, if he was the Devil himself, until he broke the law! Roper: So now you'd give the Devil benefit of law! More: Yes. What would you do? Cut a great road through the law to get after the Devil? Roper: I'd cut down every law in England to do that! More: Oh? And when the last law was down, and the Devil turned 'round on you, where would you hide, Roper, the laws all being flat? This country's planted thick with laws from coast to coast– man's laws, not God's– and if you cut them down—and you're just the man to do it—do you really think you could stand upright in the winds that would blow then? Yes, I'd give the Devil benefit of law for my own safety's sake. ---- With every passing year, and the way modern web/cloud based SaaS is playing out, RMS seems increasingly prescient. His uncompromising and principled stance on software freedoms is crucial to maintaining the Overton window on the matter, allowing space for others to make compromises and find practical solutions.
- justinator 4y agoI'll begin by quoted this page, https://thenewstack.io/why-almost-everyone-wants-richard-stallman-cancelled/ https://thenewstack.io/why-almost-everyone-wants-richard-sta... And his public behavior has been equally worrisome. According to dozens of witnesses, Stallman actively sexually harassed women students and faculty at MIT, for 30 or more years. To the point that women have passed down RMS-specific avoidance tactics like he hates plants so faculty should fill their offices with them or “If RMS hits on you, just say ‘I’m a vi user’ even if it’s not true.” It had allegedly reached the point that he was asked so many times to stop asking out colleagues and students that he decided to create and hand out a business card to non-verbally harass. Georgia Lyle, who worked at FSF from 2015 to 2018, wrote a long Twitter thread about the exhaustive — and ultimately moot — efforts she and other FSF staff made trying to change Stallman’s toxic behavior and silence his “racist and sexist ‘hacker humor’.” I don't think I can improve upon that.
- teddyh 4y agoFrom what I can tell, every allegation you repeated is false: https://sterling-archermedes.github.io/ https://sterling-archermedes.github.io/
- cyber_kinetist 4y agoThis covers the Epstein comment drama, but what about the actual sexual harassment allegations?
- tptacek 4y agoThis doesn't rebut any of those allegations, and in fact adds new ones, like the time Stallman threatened to commit suicide if a woman refused to date him.
- teddyh 4y ago
- tptacek 4y agoNo, it was not in fact OK to coerce someone into a date with a threat of suicide in 1985. I was there. It's telling, about this whole Stallman debate, that anyone would even try to make this claim. Anyways, I didn't know anything about the suicide threat before seeing this link, and didn't know my contempt for Stallman could get any deeper. So thanks for that!
- 4y ago
- shadowgovt 4y agoIf anything, I think Stallman represents an increasingly-obsolete view of computer freedom. It is perhaps worth meditating on what happens to the protagonist of A Man For All Seasons. This article gives good reasons why modern financial incentives make it increasingly irrelevant if software is copylefted (the Corps interpret copyleft as damage and route around it; the free software community has not demonstrated enough organizational energy or proactive vision to outpace moneyed development with their copyleft solutions). Meanwhile, some of the Fundamental Freedoms are philosophically undercut in the Cloud era; why should you have the right to view the source code or modify what runs on someone else's computer? The best the GNU philosophy gave us is "don't use Cloud," which is head-in-sand ignorant of how modern developers value things. New approaches are needed, and the approach represented by GNU has run its course. The Overton Window moves regardless of RMS's opinion these days
- yjftsjthsd-h 4y ago> Meanwhile, some of the Fundamental Freedoms are philosophically undercut in the Cloud era; why should you have the right to view the source code or modify what runs on someone else's computer? Because the user should have that right regardless of where the program happens to execute. > The best the GNU philosophy gave us is "don't use Cloud," Er, no? They wrote the AGPL.
- shadowgovt 4y ago> Because the user should have that right regardless of where the program happens to execute. Sorry, that makes no sense. I have no right to the source code of the bank's ATM, and even less right to run any software I choose on that hardware.
- yjftsjthsd-h 4y agoYou're welcome to that opinion, but you're just arguing against Free Software in general; that's exactly the same argument as saying that the user has no right to inspect or control the software running on their own machine.
- flomo 4y agoPeople love Stallman as a moral figurehead. A lot of people who have 'worked for' him consider him to be a terrible boss. There has been many posts like this over the years, when a true believer figures out the leader is terrible at leading. You could even look at the history of FOSS organizing as setting up alternative organizations where RMS has no pull. Even Debian was about "laws, not men". I also do not believe Stallman 'got' SaaS or ever even really understood the basic economics of the software industry. Emacs was originally SaaS software if you weren't aware.
- dale_glass 4y agoI think it's clear RMS has some good principles, and an absolutely awful personality that doesn't make for a good leader. There's a solution to that: shove him off somewhere to the side, enshrined as a "spiritual leader" people consult with for nuggets of wisdom, and then 99% of the actual functioning of the organization is done by other people.
- pie_flavor 4y agoStallman is an ideologue, in every sense of the word; a crusader for free software. His worldview can sometimes be so small you can't fit your head inside it. That sometimes means he makes management decisions about Emacs optimizing for being a word processor, when nobody else in open source cares about word processors. That also sometimes means he makes management decisions about GTK optimizing for more accessibility, when nobody else in open source cares about accessibility. You can't have the good without the bad. If RMS were to be replaced, there would be no more high profile sillinesses, but at the same time, a huge number of things would slowly get worse because he's the only one who cares enough about them.
- mhh__ 4y agoBy high profile silliness do you mean arguably piloting free software into the ground? GCC is almost literally nonexistent as a place for new compiler research in large part thanks to previous stallmanist approaches to managing, this isn't just some cutesy hypothetical about principles and so on. The above also ignores stallman's manner around people.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- teddyh 4y ago> GCC is almost literally nonexistent I believe that you are referring to the old LLVM modularity? That is old news. GCC is now (reportedly¹) better in C++20 standard compliance, and this will probably not change, since, (reportedly²) both Google and Apple have moved away from LLVM involvement. 1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30653685 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30653685 2. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32924033 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32924033
- mhh__ 4y agoNot particularly. I don't really care about C++ compliance but rather fundamental new algorithms and optimizations in the backend. When I read papers on new compiler techniques it's never GCC getting the implementation, this saddens me but it's true.
- nimbius 4y agothis seems mostly like a well written argument for the politics and procedure as well as implementation of emacs, and its absolutely worth a read. I don't hope to see this comment beyond down vote oblivion. the author dances around a fire I want to throw myself into though. for the uninitiated, RMS as a potential sexist, and his unorthodox commentary on the age of consent in particular made him an unwanted figure. never meet your heroes, or so they say I suppose... my burning question is what is RMS now? repentant? reflective? changed? alloyed or convicted beyond his gnu?
- MBCook 4y agoEven if we ignore the horrible pile of allegations against him (and we shouldn’t), I always come back to the same fundamental question. He did some very important work at launching the idea of free software and starting important projects/groups. That’s very commendable. What has he done in the last 20 years to seriously benefit things? He had refused to budge on software being free, and that’s laudable. But what has he done tangibly? Because all I ever see reported is software-wise is him standing in the way of things or rejecting the idea of improvements. What has he done to improve things? I’m not aware of anything even semi-recent.
- wombatpm 4y agoMIT used to be place that coddled mavericks and misfits. Now they drive the Aaron Swartzes of the world to suicide if they stick to their principles too much. RMS’s time has passed. Problem is there is not a replacement.
- Volundr 4y agoIf nothing else, there needs to be a clear concession plan ASAP. One refrain I kept reading when he came back to the FSF was that we needed him back because no one else could lead this movement. Really? No one? In 36 years since the FSF was founded it hasn't managed to attract a single individual with the sufficient combination of motivation, morals, and skill to replace Stallman? If that's not the definition of failure I don't know what is. The man is 70 years old. Decent odds they'll be doing without him sooner than later.
- roenxi 4y agoI sympathise with the frustration here. However: - There isn't a big pool of people willing to devote time to Free Software. If we had a big pool of people who are better than Stallman and more willing to work on the cause then we'd talk about them. Stallman may not be unique, but he is rare in being simultaneously 1) principled, 2) motivated, 3) willing to work very hard for not a lot of money or prestige in the circles of power and 4) willing to put himself out there pushing a message. I can find any number of people who are 2/4 on that list. 3/4 is rare. A lot of people who want Stallman gone are going to trade off their principles when they realise that they can get invited to very expensive parties put on by the likes of Google, Microsoft and Amazon. Or plan on just fading in to the background. I think there is an interesting wound to be reopened in the Eich v. Mozilla topic on this point as well. - No related to this article, but people have completely unrealistic standards for volunteer leadership. The man is human and has flaws. Everyone has flaws. We can tolerate some flaws in people who are doing good work.
- joshuamorton 4y agoThe article quite clearly debunks 3, and all of the others are sort of redundant. Someone who is principled, motivated, and wrong to proselytize might better be described as "obstinate", and we don't generally like those people. (To be clear, re #3, there exist people who have done as much or more for free software as RMS, but people don't idolize most, except perhaps Linus, to the same degree)
- tooltower 4y agoI will dispute this notion that volume of technical work is related to how famous someone is. Today, there are lots of people in opensource doing backbreaking work that we rely on, but whose name we don't even know. Indeed, fame is often the result of them being outspoken.
- stormbrew 4y ago> We can tolerate some flaws in people who are doing good work. Sometimes people's flaws prevent them and the people they work with from doing good work. A lot of people I'd describe as "principled" don't want to be anywhere near Stallman for various reasons, often related to their principles. Maybe he's just cleared his orbit of anyone else who actually fits your 4 criteria, so only appears to be unique. This seems like a rather common failure mode of personality cults, tbh.
- georgeoliver 4y ago> I'm fine with using React for my personal projects, and I'd be fine with contributing to it, despite the fact that I think Facebook (the product, and the company formerly known as) has done orders of magnitude more harm to the world than even the worst possible accounting of the FSF. I guess that's the thing with humans, we like to go along with everything. I wonder what would happen if all the engineers were cats.
- tomcam 4y ago> I wonder what would happen if all the engineers were cats Do you think they aren’t? You’ve clearly never managed engineers ;)
- rgoulter 4y agoTo rephrase the statement more strongly: It's okay to use tools written by people who have done awful things. That seems entirely reasonable to me.
- octoberfranklin 4y agoHaving this rant on the front page makes HN look childish.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pfraze 4y agoSo it goes. RMS represents his time: a great observation of the vital importance of software in the interplay of freedom and authority. I’m of the mind that nothing should be respected beyond its meaning, and so if RMS is no longer a great conveyor of the mission then it’s best to respect him for what he provided in his time and move on. But if he still has a role — which is the debate here — let him play it. It’s not so hard. We can operate without him without disrespecting him.
- mgraczyk 4y agoI read through the linked email thread discussing the need for a C++ AST in emacs, and I have to say I was stunned by the arrogance, rudeness, and completely ignorance of RMS. When faced with clear, specific evidence that he was out of his depth and confused, he doubled down and literally said he would no longer discuss the issue because the other parties were "trying to pressure him instead of convince him". This is IMO embarrassing and unprofessional behavior for an adult. Most engineering managers or architects in most jobs would be reprimanded or fired for behaving that way. I would never consider interacting with GNU in a professional capacity after reading those emails, so I agree with the conclusion that RMS should step down.
- layer8 4y agoIt’s also a perplexing display of ignorance for a compiler writer, as clearly and obviously static analysis typically requires the whole AST, and there’s almost no limit to the static analyses that are useful to have in a code editor.
- mhh__ 4y agoStallman is probably a good example of how people practice based on principles end up like how you describe when the principles drive them away from the real practice of their users (or just reality in general). "skin in the game" as taleb would say, only a little bit more subtle.
- assttoasstmgr 4y ago> I was stunned by the arrogance, rudeness, and completely ignorance of RMS Why were you stunned? The guy signs his emails "Dr. Richard Stallman" whilst only having an honorary doctorate. Clearly there are issues. It's as insane as signing emails "Dr. Bill Gates", "Dr. Clint Eastwood" and "Dr. Billy Joel" (all having honorary degrees).
- LukeShu 4y agoWithout saying I agree with him on this, here's his defense of it: https://stallman.org/articles/dr-stallman.html https://stallman.org/articles/dr-stallman.html
- userbinator 4y ago
- lettergram 4y agoWhile I agree in part, I think you can’t have a “flawed” but effective advocate for free software. We kind of already have that in “open source”. What Stallman was advocating for was the far-left pulling everyone further with him. That said, I think what actually failed him was his poor management and discipline. He couldn’t build an organization. He could inspire and advocate. What’s troubling to me, is that no other organization or project really pushed free software in the same way. Out of the tens of thousands of people working in tech. How many were principled enough to do what Stallman advocates. Very very few, if any. And none are as effective.
- asveikau 4y agoHaven't finished reading, but they say using emacs since 2010 makes you an emacs old timer? Hardly...
- yjftsjthsd-h 4y agoOver a decade? That's a long time in software!
- asveikau 4y agoNot for emacs.
- kdtsh 4y agoThe number of people who have been using and contributing to Emacs continuously since the 80s probably numbers in the dozens if not less. The maintainer of Doom Emacs has been an Emacs user for about 10 years; the lead maintainer of Magic has been an Emacs user for, well I’m not entirely sure, but I’m not aware of his contributions prior to Magit which started just shy of 10 years ago; the maintainer of Projectile has been an Emacs user for about 20 years, and their major contributions started around 10 years ago. If you’ve been using Emacs for 10 years, you’ve probably seen a lot, especially if you contribute to the project. 10 years is a long time in software, whether the project has been around for 15 years or 40 years.
- Volundr 4y agoThey didn't say they were an old timer. They just used it to establish that they weren't some junior dev whose been using it for all of 4 months but now has opinions we should definitely all listen to. 10 years may not be an old-timer in Emacs terms, but it's well past the clueless newbie phase.
- adamrezich 4y ago> I have never used C++. say what you will about RMS but this is pure unadulterated gigachad.jpg
- void-star 4y agoRMS has been right about so much and continues to be proven right again and again. And he has written and maintained so much software that is the bedrock of the modern internet. I’m bewildered by the prevalent anti-RMS sentiment I see so frequently on “hacker” news. Is he opinionated? Definitely. Vocal and perhaps even forceful about asserting his opinions? Yep! But guess what, this is _his_ software and FSF vision we collectively decided to build so much on top of over the last several decades. He gets to call the shots until he really does step down and until then, we’ll, that’s just the way the cookie crumbles. Lets stop talking about him like he’s an infirm wingnut who’s past his expiration date now. His message and position has stayed the same since day one and frankly I think more of the people that depend on his work should revere and respect that a bit more instead of the relentless attitude of entitlement he seems to meet so often. There’s a crowd that has complained and continues to do so wrt Linus and it’s just as bad of a look imo.
- selestify 4y agoWhat bad things do people say about Linus?
- kentrado 4y agoI think it is mostly resentment of the rabble. They use morality to strike against powerful men and in turn feel a snippet of power themselves. No need to contribute to free software to the same degree as him to prove him wrong, that's too much trouble. Their contribution shall be retribution. A destructive action, instead of a more commited creative one. "but there is genius in their hatred there is enough genius in their hatred to kill you to kill anybody not wanting solitude not understanding solitude they will attempt to destroy anything that differs from their own not being able to create art they will not understand art they will consider their failure as creators only as a failure of the world not being able to love fully they will believe your love incomplete and then they will hate you and their hatred will be perfect like a shining diamond like a knife like a mountain like a tiger like hemlock their finest art"- Charles Bukowski
- yeowMeng 4y agoI may have seen RMS talk once. I arrived early. After witnessing an interaction with a younger woman, it was weird…
- csande17 4y agoI've seen a few articles lately that suggest that the FSF needs to get with the times and stop being so militant about free software. But if you're looking for an organization whose philosophy is "free software is a good idea, but social issues in the tech community are more important, and who cares about 'microcode' or 'blobs'", there are already a lot of organizations that can offer that for you. That's Mozilla, that's the GNOME Foundation, to a first approximation that's every other open-source-related organization. Why does the FSF need to change to become the same as everyone else? (If you're looking for a text editor developed under that philosophy, I can recommend Visual Studio Code.)
- ElemenoPicuares 4y agoAre you arguing that FSF should deliberately disregard social issues to be different? Do social issues waste valuable care that could be spent caring free software? Or is there another reason to be frustrated by people caring about the social impact of their organization?
- csande17 4y agoI don't think the FSF should do anything just to be different. But I think it's a good idea for different organizations to work to improve the world in different ways. The FSF should focus on its core mission, and they should leave space for other organizations to focus on other issues.
- xbar 4y agoAgreed. It seems to me that ensuring the freedom of free software addresses a fundamental social issue that without RMS never would have been met and could have been lost several times along the way. I see a lot of references to getting with the times and modernity in the complaints against RMS. I don't see much in the way of complaint that GNU is insufficiently free-as-in-freedom, which is the only thing I really want out of GNU.
- bheadmaster 4y agoFree Software Foundation deals with the issue of software freedom. Not diabetes, not the poor children in Africa, not child slavery in China, not social justice - just software freedom. If they start caring about other issues unrelated to software freedom, they would have to divert their resources from the issues of software freedom to something else. Demanding they care about other issues is demanding they care less about software freedom, as their resources are limited, naturally.
- fetteredflag 4y ago
- dleslie 4y agoI met him once. He used the urinal beside mine, despite there being three available and myself not being in the centre. He was wearing socks, no shoes or sandals, in the public bathroom. Later we argued over whether digital artistic content should be made freely available, and he took the side of unequivocal defense of a user's right to resell, regardless of there being any derivative effort, and with no obligation to compensate the creator. He had no clear concept of how to compensate the original artist aside from an initial work for hire model. In his desired reality, wealthy persons would provide patronage to artists and artists would have no other source of income, because redistribution would be free. It's positively medieval.
- ekianjo 4y ago> In his to desired reality, wealthy persons would provide patronage to artists and artists would have no other source of income. It's positively medieval. Do you prefer copyright where someone can make one thing in their 20s and live until the end of their lives doing nothing else but reaping the money from what they did once? Or dead authors still being paid for their creations? Its positively nonsensical.
- dleslie 4y agoI prefer copyright in its original intent, that struck a fair balance between public good and creator need. RMS simply did not care, explicitly so, about compensating creators and supporting their efforts. Vigorously, clearly, did not care.
- CyberDildonics 4y agoWhy is that nonsensical?
- ekianjo 4y agoBecause dead authors can't write new books.
- 4y ago
- zzo38computer 4y ago> RMS insisted that people lay out every possible use case so he could figure out the minimal set of information that would need to be exposed. I think that is impossible.
- olliej 4y agoI read through the thread (which was a grind, I don't recommend it - there were many good arguments made, and many cases of RMS telling people that they were pressuring him, insulting him, or did not understand the point of free software) and I was sorely disappointed that no one just bought up constexpr. constexpr is to a first approximation a C++ equivalent to rust's macros. Being C++ it is exciting, and basically requires a correct C++ compiler to include a correct C++ interpreter.
- killjoywashere 4y agoTo all people complaining about what this that or the other organization is or isn't doing: lead, follow, or get out of the way. Stop clickety-clacking on HN and go make the world you want.
- b3morales 4y agoYou don't have to be the sole capo di capo to lead; nor does following mean you don't get to speak or think for yourself. Everyone involved in a group has a leadership role to take by acting in, and advocating for, ways to make the group achieve its goals.
- xbar 4y ago
- panny 4y agoEveryone who thinks they know how to improve what RMS does has failed to improve what RMS does themselves. If you are a more compelling free software movement leader than RMS, people will follow you. That just hasn't been done. No long winded articles will ever change that.
- DonHopkins 4y agoTon Roosendaal is a vastly better free software movement leader than RMS, many people follow him, many corporations contribute to and support his foundation, and Blender is one of the most successful open source projects on the planet.
- LtWorf 4y ago> many corporations contribute to and support his foundation But corporations would never ever fund the FSF. Google is rewriting a whole OS to avoid having to give device drivers for android. Companies prefer to spend millions of $ to avoid the GPL. They only like MIT-like licensed open source. They hate anything that can be used to give freedom to users. Google has forbidden the use of AGPL software completely. This means that having support from companies is incompatible with making libre software.
- DonHopkins 4y agoBlender is GPL. Yet corporations fund it. Go figure. https://www.blender.org/about/license/ https://www.blender.org/about/license/ The Software Blender is released under the GNU General Public License (GPL, or “free software”). This license grants people a number of freedoms: You are free to use Blender, for any purpose You are free to distribute Blender You can study how Blender works and change it You can distribute changed versions of Blender The GPL strictly aims at protecting these freedoms, requiring everyone to share their modifications when they also share the software in public. That aspect is commonly referred to as Copyleft. The Blender Foundation and its projects on blender.org are committed to preserving Blender as free software. https://fund.blender.org/ https://fund.blender.org/ Unity. AWS. Meta. nVidia. Decentraland. NetEase Games. Epic. egirl. Intel. AMD. Blender Kit. Ubisoft. Blender Market. Phala Network. Adobe. Microsoft. Google. Steam Workshop. Reallusion. Activision. Op Games. CoreWeave. CGCookie. Q Orihect Studio. Wube Studio. Oracle. Kista. Looking Glass Factory. WebsiteSetup. Numfum. StringKing. Cube. CGSLab. BlenderMagic. PolygonIQ. [...] >This means that having support from companies is incompatible with making libre software. Bullshit. Cygnus Support's motto was "We Make Free Software Affordable". Big companies support free software, and free software supports big companies. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cygnus_Solutions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cygnus_Solutions https://web.archive.org/web/20220228142052/http://www.toad.com/gnu/cygnus/ https://web.archive.org/web/20220228142052/http://www.toad.c... >Marketing Cygnus Support -- Free Software history [...] >We had the grandiose idea that major computer companies like Sun, SGI, and DEC would fire their compiler departments and use our free compilers and debuggers instead, paying us a million dollars a year for support and development. That wasn't quite right, but before we starved, we stumbled into the embedded systems market, doing jobs for Intel (the i960, a now-forgotten RISC chip), AMD (their now-forgotten but nice 29000 RISC), and various companies like 3Com and Adobe who had to port major pieces of code to these chips. In that market, once we fixed the tools to support cross-compiling, we had major advantages over the existing competitors, and we swarmed right through the market for 32-bit embedded system programming tools. And ultimately, we did get million-dollar contracts, such as one from Sony for building Playstation compilers and emulators. This allowed game developers to start working a year before the Playstation hardware was available. This enabled the Playstation to come to market sooner, with more and better games. [...] >Later, after hiring more experienced executives, we discovered that our pricing was "leaving money on the table". We still needed to estimate our own costs and overheads and profits -- but we also needed to estimate how much money our work would SAVE our customer, or MAKE FOR our customer. When there was a big discrepancy in those two numbers, we could raise our price significantly, and the customer would still be happy. For example, the Sony PlayStation contract enabled Sony to ship the PlayStation months earlier (with working third party game software). Even a single month earlier of shipments would result in hundreds of millions of dollars of income for Sony. Similarly, big networking vendors like Cisco had tens or hundreds of millions of dollars riding on the introduction dates of their new products. We were selling them "insurance": if any big problems came up in the development software as they worked on the product, we'd fix them rapidly so their engineers would be able to deliver the product on time. Chip vendors, for whom we built many compilers, were betting big money on getting at least one large customer for their latest chip. Early availability of our tools allowed their customers to reliably prototype large, complex products with the chip. Our pricing gradually grew to include a percentage of the value that our work was creating out in the world, for our customers. [...] Gumby, one of the founders of Cygnus, was just discussing gdb development on Hacker News a couple days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33030088 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33030088
- vmoore 4y ago> RMS is nothing if not a man of principle. He really, truly believes in his ideas of software freedom in a way that I really do think very few people believe in anything these days The thing is, RMS is also a free software extremist in ways. He uses free software exclusively. Hard to imagine living that way. At some point you will have to interact with Windows in our modern world, or interact with other proprietary software. That said, I use Trisquel[0] as my daily driver and have no issues, but I also own a workstation with Windows 11 installed for programming and general computing. The software available for Windows is fantastic and many vendors target Windows and treat Linux as a second class citizen, so I'm forced to use Windows just to interact with our modern world. So in a sense I'm enjoying the best of both worlds and not letting the free software ideology rule me. [0] https://trisquel.info/ https://trisquel.info/
- saagarjha 4y agoOne of my disappointments is that Richard Stallman fails to see the big picture of people should care about free software. He’s a hacker so he feels like the best way to sell his position is “ok you can have the source and edit it”. But to the vast majority of humanity this is basically irrelevant! They can’t code, the don’t want to code, having access to the code is “basically useless”. The things people actually want: accessibility, data portability, privacy, agency-they’re all as relevant and universal as ever. But the GNU and RMS remain dead set on “oh we’ve got to push everyone to adopt the GPL”, which I respect but fundamentally ends up being an ineffective use of resources. When you train a pubic to care about free software and understands why they need it, that’s how you get true freedom. Leaning into the fringe appearance, and definitely continuing to remain socially inept if not entirely inappropriate, is just shooting yourself in the foot.
- rgoulter 4y agoWith Chromium and VSCode, there are 'pro-privacy' forks which which remove the telemetry from the codebase. With Windows, there isn't an equivalent ad-free option. I think "freedom to manipulate the source code" may not be a popular point, but it seems foundational in that it restricts what the software can otherwise get away with. e.g. I don't like the idea of buying 'smart' TVs which come bundled with adware.
- Tiberium 4y ago> With Windows, there isn't an equivalent ad-free option. You're right, the closest we have is ReactOS which doesn't have enough interest (although understandably so).
- bheadmaster 4y ago> But to the vast majority of humanity this is basically irrelevant! Oh, it's very, very relevant. For example, I can't think of a person who wouldn't ask a programmer friend, or hire a freelancer, to remove ads from their devices, if they had the option to do so. People want to control their software, even if they're not programmers, because people like being in control of their lives - it's natural. I don't see how could anyone argue against human desire to control their own machines.
- rgoulter 4y agoWhat free or open source projects have had good governance? The motivation for neovim being forked was a frustration with having a vim PR rejected over fear that something would break. The last few years neovim and vim have competed. 'BDFL' I'd most associate with Python, where Guido van Rossum recently stepped down from the role IIRC.
- jillesvangurp 4y agoThere are quite a few healthy and longing projects; decades in some cases. You can't do that without good governance. Of course sometimes that governance comes in the form of a benevolent dictator workaholic running the whole show. Nothing wrong with that as long as it works. E.g. Linus Torvalds might not be the nicest person to deal with, but he sure gets a lot of people to contribute very meaningful changes to Linux continuously. I'd say he's an extremely effective manager of what is arguably one of the fastest evolving bits of software on this planet with a sustained modification rate of many tens of thousands of lines of code every month for decades. So, I would call that good governance. Other projects do less well because of governance issues and inter personal issues. Not going to name names here; we all know examples of such projects. My observation is that ideology, dogmatism can get in the way of good governance. There's a lot of OSS software that gets written and sponsored by corporations. You tend to see a lot more pragmatic attitude in projects like that. People working on those projects are getting paid to do so and are expected to do so competently, solve technical problems, and generally do things that have business value. Conflicts can happen in any project but when the conflicts are of an ideological nature, there isn't a pragmatic way of resolving those issues. Pragmatism and ideology simply don't mix. At best you can agree to disagree, which is the pragmatic thing to do.
- adultSwim 4y agoDebian has been a great example of open transparent governance over technical infrastructure
- kazinator 4y agoHere is where RMS went astray with this GCC AST thing. He's insisting that technical barriers be erected to protect something, when that is the job of licensing. We would never take some GPL-ed shared library, say, and cripple the API with inconveniences so that proprietary applications can't take advantage of it. That will cripple the free applications too. Of course you make the API technically excellent and complete, and then protect that with the license; it's a GPL violation to link it and call it from a GPL-incompatibly-licensed program. Same with GCC: expose the full AST so that people are unblocked in doing whatever analysis they want, and protect that with licensing, if you must. By favoring technical barriers, Stallman is being exactly like the jealous company that didn't give him the information to fix the printer, without signing an NDA. "You can view a printed version of a partial AST, in a pitch dark room, using a tiny spotlight, and take only handwritten notes, provided you sign this agreement ..." Come on ...
- LtWorf 4y agoI like the idea but the problem is that gcc isn't a library, so the AST was going to be "output", so not covered by a license. They should have moved gcc into being GPL licensed libraries to achieve this.
- kazinator 4y agoBut then it sounded like he wanted multiple functions in such a library so that the AST is never revealed in its entirety. (As if someone clever couldn't find a way to use them all and piece the AST together?) The underlying problem is this elephant in the room: no matter how you set up the access to the AST, it will be legal for someone to make a GPL-ed utility program which uses that API, and dumps the data to standard output. That utility can then be used in a proprietary development ecosystem, the same way that GNU Bash, Make, CoreUtils, Awk and everything else can be used in a proprietary ecosystem. The subtext behind RMS's arguments is to make it difficult to write such a utility such that it pieces together the entire AST. That's probably why he was vehement on the techincal solution. I'm amazed Stallman just doesn't come to the conclusion "so what?" like everyone else. If someone user finds value in GCC just as a parser, maybe that's better than them not finding any value in it at all. Say someone uses an IDE, whereby GCC is used to help with completion, refactoring and all that. But the actual product that is built for the target uses some proprietary toolchain (e.g. licensed ARM stuff, run on Windows). The back-end parts of GCC aren't used at all. Well, "so what?" That's like saying it's a crime someone proprietary app only used malloc and strcmp from glibc, but rolled its own printf. What if GCC was used to compile the code, but only to obtain diagnostics and maybe run some unit tests? That happens, and I suspect it really bugs Stallman.
- ordu 4y ago> You, as a contributor, can advocate a certain decision, which means you present arguments why I should approve it. I don't need to advocate a decision in that sense. A long long time ago I was a moderator at a (mostly) teenagers' forum. And back then my personality morphed into a state that may talk like that. I'm not proud of it. It lasted for a half a year or so, before I recognized that I became a jerk. I still feel the shame. I hope though that it was a good for me to see how power corrupts. I hope I'm immune to it now. But it is sad to see it in RMS.
- rejectfinite 4y ago
- olliej 4y agowhy? It's someone's personal blog not a corporate mouthpiece.
- ljw1004 4y agoMy job over the past several years has been to work on IDE integrations for a language (Hack, Flow). Prior to that I worked on C#/VB "Roslyn" system at Microsoft, which is entirely about exposing the internals of the compiler to plugins. Autocomplete isn't really helped by the AST. Here instead is how it works: (1) Query the backend "at the specified line+col in the file, what context are we in?" (2) The context might be a qualified identifier, e.g. "foo.|" or "foo.ba|" or "MyFoo::|", in which case the context will have to tell you the type of the thing to the left of the qualifier. You then make a second request to the backend to ask for a list of members of that type. (This requires you have some common language with the backend for referring to types). (3) Or, the context might be an unqualified identifier, e.g. "|" or "fo|". In this case you have to assemble a list of all possible identifiers in this position. (You might also want to assemble keywords here, but it's hardly necessary). This list will include all local variables; for this, you can use the AST so long as the semantics of your language aren't too tricky about what variables are in scope, or you might query the backend for them. The list will also include every single top-level symbol in your entire project. (Even in languages which require import or #include statements, you still want to list top-level identifiers that haven't yet been imported, because that's what a nice IDE experience is -- you help the user type this and then help them auto-insert the import). This fact means that autocomplete has to be powered by the build system, has to know about all files in the project. Also, for large projects, there might be countless top-level identifiers across the project, maybe in the tens of thousands, so autocomplete needs some serious pre-compute assistance. So how would one achieve any part of the above with an AST? The AST solely helps with part of the first step, allowing you to identify which AST node you're in. Then you still have to query the backend using the exact same API as above to learn the type of the qualifier to the left of the current AST node. Then you still have to query the backend to find all members of that type. And you still have to query the backend for its build-system knowledge of every type in the file. In other words, the AST has barely helped you at all in your quest to implement autocomplete.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pieter_mj 4y agoHe's not only a man of principle, very prescient, but also 100% incorruptable. In other words, there's nobody to replace him.
- iLemming 4y ago> there's nobody to replace him I think we should look at the statements like that through the prism of skepticism. Whenever something like that gets said about a person alive. In the same manner, people talked about Hitler, Putin and Trump. No living person is irreplaceable in the context of societal progress. Sometimes, after they die, we may acknowledge their role, their remarkable achievements, and their legacy. Can we please stop idolizing RMS? I think, doing that today brings nothing but harm to the people who promote ideas of free software, Emacs aficionados, et al. I'm not claiming your statement is wrong, you may be 100% right, and who knows, long after he leaves us, we may come to believe that he was indeed worthy of adulation. But while he's still alive, let's not make it weirder than it already is. I don't want to be called a cultist because I use Emacs.
- meribold 4y agoI wish the response to RMS returning to the FSF board in March 2021 would've been more like this article instead of the self-righteous outrage we actually got. Secondly, it seems Vim was forked for less disagreeableness from Bram than what RMS has displayed. Is there a popular fork of GNU Emacs? More people channeling their unhappiness with RMS into something constructive by exercising the freedoms FOSS gives them and less time spent demanding the organization RMS founded become more like the OSI, EFF, GNOME Foundation, or Linux Foundation seems like it would be more productive.
- Lammy 4y ago> Emacs is not an independent project, and it isn't governed by its contributors. I'm the head of the GNU Project, and that includes Emacs. Honestly adore this attitude and wish more devs had the self-assuredness to run their projects this way. Assured not only in the their vision but in their ability to have a vision. When that’s missing it becomes really easy to write software that creates tedium instead of freeing us from it. There’s even a word for when a project’s vision is to avoid vision. The one word in a readme that fills me with more dread than any other — “unopinionated”. Translation: “Here, you make all the decisions, because the only way I know to avoid having any Wrong Opinions at this scale is to have none”. If the concept of “unopinionated software” had a favorite color it would be “What’s yours?”
- staticassertion 4y ago"Unopinionated" is not about leadership at all, it's generally about providing a library versus a framework, and the "less opinionated" it is the more "library-like" the code is. The vast majority of open source software is effectively maintained by people who don't give a shit about users/contributors, obviously, as they're unmaintained github projects. It's fine for the majority of projects because no one uses them. What's weird is that anyone uses emacs when it's led by a fairly incompetent developer and a radically incompetent leader.
- Lammy 4y agoI honestly think the word itself is great example of a meme in the Dawkins sense, an actual non-biological living thing that keeps living by influencing humans to become its hosts by tickling all of our senses at once: It’s visually pleasing to see written out and to scan over, at least in my sans-serif browser font — unopinionated. - Check our how it has a completely uninterrupted horizontal sight line! - The unbroken visual falls along the midline for a nice balance between the above and the below. The eye can’t stray into words on adjacent lines like it could if we were focusing along the word’s baseline or at cap height. - The properties of the leading ‘u’ glyph welcomes the eye to start reading the word left-to-right. The ‘u’ has nothing below baseline or above midline to be a visual obstacle blocking any angle of entry to the word. If our focus enters the ‘u’ anywhere below x-height the first thing we see is its happy smiling bowl with nothing sharp telling us to look away. If our focus enters it at or above x-height, the two sharp stems would look unwelcoming, but the adjacent ‘n’ is ‘u’s perfect opposite and makes that entry angle into something unique, a yin/yang sort of thing, pulling our eye’s motion into at the very least a diagonal. Without the ‘n’ our gaze could enter the word straight down and just sit in the bowl of the ‘u’ instead of continuing to scan right. - The tittles on the ‘i’s prevent the above-sight-line negative space from overwhelming, breaking it into two wide and one thin segment. - The ‘n’ shoulder connects the two tittles into something like a paperclip that feels as though it pins our line of sight tightly to the tops of the lowercase glyphs. - The ‘ini’ group has its own line of vertical symmetry, like a cute li’l’ sans-serif Solomon’s Temple, and the location of that group provides a nice thick natural visual center point in the word as a whole. It sits a little bit left of actual center, but that gets balanced by the two ascenders on the right side. - The ‘t’ ascender would break our sight line, but its cross-stroke falls right along the line of sight, ensuring it will always be the first part of the ‘t’ we see, so it will never fail to grab and hold our gaze until our focus is safely on the other side having dodged the ascender completely. - The ‘p’ descender balances the ‘t’ ascender both in horizontal distance from the word’s visual center and with its opposite orientation. Those qualities combine with the ‘n’s shoulder to imply possible rotational motion of the entire word around that origin. - The ‘d’ ascender would break the sight line of it weren’t the last glyph, but instead it provides a nice satisfying perpendicular terminus, stopping our left-to-right scan at the best possible place where we’ve seen the entire word but get made to linger and take it in for just a moment longer. Its syllables form a naturally musical staccato rhythm, and the necessary mouth movements feel physically pleasant to say — unopinionated It’s a perfectly-sized dose: six syllables is long enough to be satisfying, and any longer than a single word would be too much. It’s the same feeling as picking the ideal number of Skittles® in a single handful: - Three is too few and just feels like the remains of a previous mouthful as soon as you start chewing. - Four is like the minimum that won’t make you think “I should have taken one more”. - More than seven and the whole wad turns into a brick around the back of your teeth so you can’t even chew properly to break it down. - But six? Perfect sweet spot. The word as a whole has a smooth rising and falling sound when spoken. Say it over and over and you can feel it like a sine wave — unoPINIONatedunoPINIONatedunoPINIONated Emotionally, saying the word has that ‘90s-cool-guy vibe, like I’m smart enough to be able to care about things if I, like, wanted to, man. Stop, like, harshing my buzz. This comment is not a joke in any way. I still hate the word’s meaning but admit it has an impressive form :) Ok, one joke: I just spent like 15 minutes trying to think of things I like about this word because I thought it would be funny to be opinionated about ‘unopinionated’.
- jonstewart 4y agoIt’s been obvious for decades that RMS has his flaws as a software architect and product manager. Make him more perfect, address all the issues raised by the TFA about C++ AST access in emacs, and it wouldn’t change anything about whether he should be shunned: the man is a sexist, harassing creep. There’s a lot of talk here about him being a man of principle — let’s stipulate that’s true — the conclusion is, he has no sense that the most important principle is to treat others well.
- zasdffaa 4y ago> I'm saying the FSF is ineffective at achieving those goals So what's your solution that would prevent commercial interests screwing it over?
- oblak 4y ago
- oblak 4y ago
- morelisp 4y agoThe FSF and GNU project have always been a weird mix of things: - (Especially FSF) A political organization to advance the ideals of free software, or more generally present a more equitable vision of how software can fit into society. Here RMS is effective, but for years now as a writer and thinker and not as an organizer or administrator. Here lots of others are qualified for those roles, but RMS has spent decades driving many of them off. - (Especially GNU) A particular technical vision - probably best summarized as "a free user-programmable Unix". Here, RMS is fairly effective, but it's not clear this technical vision is good anymore. Qualitative advancement often happened via long-term, sometimes acrimonious forks (GCC, Emacs) or in parallel (Linux). A small steering committee would likely be a better approach to avoid RMS's personal technical biases and blindspots. And here again, RMS's approach has made a lot of people who could significantly contribute here uninterested in returning to try to fix this. - A particular style of project/team management. This should have been dead, or at least not so dominant, as soon as Linux took off. But RMS has a style of working which is wildly out of sync with even his own contemporaries, let alone the current generation of programmers. And the development and administration end up bound to that, discouraging and occasionally completely forbidding anyone else. - RMS's attempt to rebuild a social environment he had and lost at MIT. Especially for "core projects" - Emacs, GCC, Hurd - you had to be RMS's friend, or at least RMS would come to think you were his friend. This means technical disagreements would tend to get interpreted as personal betrayals, which is unproductive at best. As long as RMS demands the organizations fulfill all of these (and especially the last) role, the good parts will never succeed dragging the bad parts along.
- worik 4y agoI have been using Emacs as long as it. I have no complaints about how it has developed I was particularly surprised when it complains about the GC discussion without noting the words of wisdom RMS was offering: Put the maximum effort into user visible changes. It was not that he (RMS) wanted a word processor and GC was not getting there. It was because GC improvements do not improve (in this case) user experience. It (ash) seems to think this is a sign of malevolent, not benevolent, dictatorship.
- Andrew_nenakhov 4y agoSo many words about how ineffective rms leadership is. Well, free software movement is not something exclusively belonging to FSF and Stallman. One can always start his own organization and lead the fight for free software with it, instead of complaining about the FSF fighting the previous war of the 1980s or so. Just lead the way, be the change, etc.
- ThinkBeat 4y agoEmacs is his baby in a way. It is his privilege to develop it in a way that he believes is best. Much like how Linus has a decent say in what happens to Linux. Why should RMS change how he does something because some big corporation can write a propriety editor, and a proprietary compiler? This is nothing new. There were plenty of proprietary compilers at the time the project started and that was one of the primary reasons to write it. Instead of bitching about leadership on a free software project and feeling entitled to have it changed to yours and others liking If you feel strongly that Emcas or GCC is heading down the wrong path, you are 100% free to fork it and within the limits of the license write whatever features you want, Perhaps if it is hugely successful or the features do turn out to be killer additions GNU may decide to add some to Emacs. In so far as fighting the good fight for Libre software it is the same fight he has fought for decades and the way the world has developed lately I would say most of these predictions have come true. RMS is extremely smart and extremely dedicated, and he has made a lot of sacrifices due to his principles. Yes, he is stubborn (So is Linus) and eccentric. So what? How the F can people claim to be fighting for an "inclusive society" if you can't let a guy, be a bit eccentric. If anything, we need more eccentric people in a society that is turning ever more and more homogenic. And please consider that Linux would not exist today if it was not for the GNU compiler, and a lot of the GNU free tools. Today they can be replaced but back then it was available for free. Compilers used to cost a lot of money way back when and a lot still do.