8 ms·
Bill Gates: You’ll never solve climate change by asking people to consume less
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ryeights 4y agoImplement a carbon tax, and it will happen. The insistence from some that we can just innovate our way out of the climate crisis, when the Industrial Revolution and pursuit of technological expansion for the sake of profit at all costs is what got us into this situation in the first place, is what I find truly “quixotic.” There is no incentive for corporations to improve the climate situation in a meaningful way.
- seper8 4y agoAgree 100%. Tax generation of CO2 at the energy level and all else should follow. Then allow companies to get a tax reduction if they offset their output in some well researched and supported method. Tadaa...
- polski-g 4y agoIf you tax generate of CO2 and "all else follows", what "would follow" is that the party that instituted said tax would be voted out and it would be repealed.
- hedora 4y agoA dollar a gallon direct air capture carbon tax would make gasoline net carbon negative. Clearly, that would lead to mass hysteria and societal collapse. /s
- shakezula 4y agoYou got a source for this? I believe it’s probably roughly true but I haven’t read those figures and would absolutely love to see more.
- hedora 4y agoComputed it myself. Direct air carbon startups are advertising $50-$200/ton at scale. A ton is 2000 pounds. A gallon of gasoline emits 20lbs of co2 when burnt (most of the weight is in the o2, so the emissions are heavier than the gasoline). Divide the per ton prices by 100 to convert to per gallon of gas, and you get $0.50-$2.00. The existence of the tax would ensure they all had enough revenue to scale; fund them all initially, then let economics pick the winner.
- timst4 4y agoI agree full-heartedly as a dutiful member of Citizens Climate Lobby. However, if we can’t pass this legislation with a Democratic political stack in place, then when?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Schroedingersat 4y agoLook at how ignored political groups have traditionally made their voices heard. Like racial equality movements, unions, or womens' suffrage.
- nyokodo 4y agoNone of those movements required any degradation of the living standards of the majority of people but at most just the elites or a particular class and then not substantially. Climate is a very different fight.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoThere are countless ways to improve living conditions while reducing emissions. Free sustainable transport would stop the least privileged from having to fork over a third of their paycheck to auto and fossil fuel companies while freeing up billions spent on roads. Making landlords accountable for energy wasting housing design would reduce energy bills. Not invading countries for their gas and mineral reserves is pretty good for the people that live there. A direct carbon tarriff distributed evenly by population would lift living standards for the underprivileged and give them the resources to make a choice for lower emissions options. Right to repair, accountability for forced obsolescence or design faults and consumer rights decrease waste and benefit the poor immensely.
- scarface74 4y agoAnd statistically the Justice system still gives minorities harsher sentences for the same crime and are targeted more and union participation is down. Well I guess one out of three isn’t bad.
- Gibbon1 4y agoMy thinking about carbon taxes is they will just result in political blowback and a lot of the push comes from entities with an interest in the status quo.. Bill gates is right, trying to impoverish people in the developed world would both result in blowback and be a disaster if implemented. I think there is an 80/20 rule with consumption in developed countries. 20% consume 80% of the resources. Getting the 20% to reduce consumption is a won't fix politically. Yet degrowth people think somehow the 80% can reduce their consumption and not go under. Look at the amount of reduction in consumption that triggers a recession, it's 10X less than the shock degrowth people are demanding. The complicating factor is the upper classes are completely resistant to any sort collective action that benefits lower class people. And they are hellbent to make sure no one ever gets to see a successful example.
- Proven 4y ago[dead]
- xupybd 4y agoI don't see that working globally. It will be near impossible for it not to get distorted by political influence into something that does little to achieve the goals of reducing carbon emissions. I truly believe our only hope is to innovate our way out of this.
- abigail95 4y agocarbon tax is less popular than 4 degree climate change can't do it in a democracy
- grliga 4y agoSo consuming less will be actually effective but it's just that people won't listen/change. I agree with him
- ProjectArcturis 4y ago
- revolvingocelot 4y agoThanks CEO Nwabudike Morgan, very cool
- didgeoridoo 4y agoDownvotes from Morgan Industries haters… I was always a Zakharov man myself.
- ProjectArcturis 4y agoI guess quotes from a 25-year-old video game aren't very popular around here.
- hedora 4y ago"The present day significance of the impact depends on choice of a future discount factor." (American Petroleum Institute, in 1980, predicting CO2 emissions would "bring world economic growth to a halt in about 2025", unless minor action was immediately taken back then.) Source: https://insideclimatenews.org/documents/aq-9-task-force-meeting-1980/ https://insideclimatenews.org/documents/aq-9-task-force-meet...
- DLA 4y agoHey Bill and other elites - does this mean no more 20,000 square foot homes and private jets?
- disabled 4y agoGates’ main house is actually 66,000 square feet. He apparently has 6 total houses. See: https://www.velvetropes.com/backstage/bill-gates-house https://www.velvetropes.com/backstage/bill-gates-house Anyways, Gates is always preaching about “policy” (The Gates Foundation is about power and getting governments to fund their objectives, ultimately) but never actually sets a good individual example of how to live, like normal citizens. I mean, it is not coincidental that he is preaching about global warming right after the Nord Stream pipeline was blown, which released an unprecedented amount of methane in to the atmosphere.
- notriddle 4y ago> You’ll never solve climate change by asking people to consume less The headline says 'no.'
- disabled 4y agoThe above poster is just suggesting that Bill Gates not be a hypocrite with respect to consuming less. He consumes way way way more than the average citizen. I don’t even know why people listen to him. Shouldn’t we be listening to actual climate scientists in the US government? And not some software CEO who has conflicts of interest? Why are we even platforming this dude and giving him any legitimacy?
- sattoshi 4y agoHe spends a lot of money to be heard. Nobody was listening to him until he started throwing millions around to organizations to platform him.
- presentation 4y agoIf I were Bill Gates it would probably be miserable to take normal flights, can't walk two steps before someone gawks. If anything just reinforces that being famous sucks.
- ps901 4y ago[flagged]
- yucky 4y ago>The only thing left is to ditch capitalism entirely How exactly does that work?
- wincy 4y agoJust enslave the entire world and make them do your bidding. It’s simple.
- abdullahkhalids 4y agoListen to the anarcho-syndacalists like Chomsky, which demand that companies be owned by workers in that company. There are many proposals for this, but here is an off the cuff one I just came up with: Every company with more than 100 workers, must have 80% of its ownership by those same workers. The difference between the ownership stake of the top worker and the bottom worker must be no more than a 5x.
- rank0 4y agoNothing is preventing any group from forming that exact governance structure. The cold hard truth is that nobody wants to do that. You’ll always lose to your competitors. Nobody actually wants to manage the entity that employs them.
- abdullahkhalids 4y agoYou misunderstand. Anarcho-syndacalists like Chomsky demand, that by law, all companies must follow this worker-owned structure. It's a complete restructuring of the economic system. In the new system there won't be any capitalist-owned enterprises that will burn capital in the short-term, and exploit their own workers to to kill their more ethical competitors. Also, all workers don't have to manage their company, only some of them. Workers at large just need to be able to kick out any management that decides to exploit their labor. In our current system it is the shareholders decide how much exploitation should be done, and their opinion is "as much as will keep profits high".
- chiefalchemist 4y agoAsking? Of course not. There's no incentive to just stop, and 100x more signals to consume. Instead, apply of concept of capital gains being taxed less than income to consumption and carbon footprint. It works for the behavior of the rich. I'm sure Bill would agree. It can work for the rest of us in the context of climate change. p.s. Funny how Bill (and then wife) built a massively excessive home. I guess he asked himself and that didn't work. So now he speaks from experience?
- presentation 4y agoI think these mega billionaires do that as a way to park their money, financial advisors telling them to diversify into real estate lol. Just wish they'd do it in a more socially productive way...
- ericmcer 4y agoYeah no duh we don’t have any power, and even if I convinced 100,000 people to walk everywhere and never drive, we would only lower gas prices by a fraction of a cent which would result in other people driving more.
- TenJack 4y agoI agree with this. We may end up having to filter the carbon out using nuclear energy.
- anemoiac 4y agoDecreasing consumption doesn't necessarily imply a decrease in quality of life. In the West, at least, we generally work too much, have too little social engagement, and spend lots of money and resources on things that don't really improve our lives. Many things that could actually make us happier don't require much consumption, but they're essentially luxury goods because of the modern lifestyle's high demands. I'm thinking of things like relaxing with friends and/or family, volunteering/contributing to your local community, exercising, eating healthily... even getting enough sleep on a regular basis!
- jshzglr 4y agoMost of this is pretty obvious and yet people act differently. That’s the whole point. It’s not a realistic solution.
- smabie 4y agoI mean you can go to do? People have made their choices (including me).
- rufus_foreman 4y ago>> we generally work too much I decide if I work too much. You don't get to decide if I work too much. >> have too little social engagement I get to decide my level of social engagement. You don't get to decide my level of social engagement. >> spend lots of money and resources on things that don't really improve our lives I get to decide how to spend my money. You don't get to decide how to spend my money.
- anemoiac 4y agoA little aggressive, no? No one's "deciding" anything for anyone in my comment. You don't get to decide how much work/social engagement/widget purchasing makes you content any more than you can "decide" how many drinks it takes for you to get drunk. All I'm saying is that many people could both reduce their consumption and improve their quality of lives by optimizing for factors unrelated to material consumption.
- 4y ago
- refurb 4y agoI agree 100% with Bill. You need to incentivize more efficient consumption. Whether through technological advances or through policy that “nudges” people to consume more efficiently (e.g. carbon taxes). But the challenges remains. Severs governments were cutting taxes and handing out cash when gas prices jumped. That’s the exact opposite of what you want to do.
- janef0421 4y agoI think people are quite open to many practices that involve reduced consumption, they just don't like the vague idea of reducing consumption because it suggests austerity.
- klhutchins 4y agoLocalize manufacturing? With those huge cargo ships producing lots of CO2, wouldn't the best impact be to reduce the use of those ships? Try not to ship parts to get assembled into another part, to get shipped again and again back to the origin, and then final assembly and packaging and shipped to the store? I know it's naive to think we can build manufacturing plants at the source of raw materials, and near consumers, but there should be a better balance?
- shadowfox 4y ago> to think we can build manufacturing plants at the source of raw materials, and near consumers The source of raw materials and consumers may be quite far apart (certainly in the modern world). While it can be argued that maybe they shouldn't be, that is likely to require a significant change in consumer (human?) behavior. And then there is the question of how local is "local" - are you advocating for each city/state to be self-sufficient in terms of agriculture and manufacturing or are you considering a whole massive country like the US as "local".
- 3qz 4y agoBill Gates in his climate book: “geoengineering is the only known way that we could hope to lower the earth’s temperature within years or even decades without crippling the economy.” Pretty soon we’re going to start seeing authoritarian solutions to climate change. Rich and powerful people aren’t just going to sit around and watch the planet die. I think they’ll do whatever it takes no matter how many people are hurt.
- pcthrowaway 4y agoUnsurprising that one of the world's most successful capitalists is advocating for innovation to drive consumerism rather than anti-consumerism. I'm not saying he's wrong; it's hard to get people to reflect on, and change, their lifestyles. But it sends a harmful message; it's like saying it's pointless to teach people to swim safely, because staffing better lifeguards would be more likely than changing peoples' behaviour. Then people count on other people to bail them out from their poor decisions and end up drowning (an actually possible scenario with rising sea levels)
- bergenty 4y agoCompletely agree. Science has to save us here, as it will govern enough time and stability. We need an age of sustainable abundance, not sustainability through frugality.
- prng2021 4y agoI see many comments here, in various media, and hear in real world conversations blaming corporations and billionaires. They're not faultless but we should be way more critical of ourselves as average citizens. Every year we want bigger and bigger cars, particularly in the West, but it's a global long term trend. If you compare pretty much any 2022 vs 2002 model vehicle, say the Honda Accord, you're going to be shocked by the increase in physical dimensions. How is that not incredibly hypocritical to want ever larger cars (mostly SUVs and trucks now) and yet point fingers at the companies we work for for their poor ESG funding and goals? We aren't even willing to accept cars that remain the same dimensions. They literally have to be bigger. That's despite average family sizes gradually declining for many decades. Climate change matters.. but not enough to give up the chance for a larger car next time. Bigger vehicles means more materials (plastics, metals, etc), weight that could have been shaved, worse fuel/battery efficiency, and it wouldn't surprise me if it requires signifantly more asphalt and road repairs over time to accommodate the vehicles. I could keep going about how obsessed we are with more and more horsepower and with lower 0-60 mph times, all of which are extremely excessive wants in the face of climate change.
- Gigachad 4y agoBill calls for greater innovation, but as soon as we get more efficient things, we just consume more. We have constantly gotten better and better tech, and yet our consumption of resources only goes up. It seems that resource usage has nothing to do with how efficient or advanced our tech is, but simply the maximum amount of human labor we can allocate to resource extracting. So climate change can only really be solved by a lower population.
- The_Amp_Walrus 4y ago> as soon as we get more efficient things, we just consume more That doesn't seem to be true in terms of C02 output https://www.google.com/search?q=us+carbon+emissions+per+capita https://www.google.com/search?q=us+carbon+emissions+per+capi...
- 4y ago
- belfalas 4y ago100% bullshit and such a typically American way of looking at it (I am an American). Look how fast the world changed when Covid hit. Achieve a change in values and the whole world will turn on its axis.
- t0bia_s 4y agoDuring covid, climate wasn't issue. People, like Gates, promotes mask, vaccines, antibacterial gels, tests... Which produces millions of tons of plastic waste. And also great income for his business. But who cares, now we need innovations because he loves our planet a people, right?