6 ms·
In my opinion, the biggest problem Sundar has is that he is too much of a chicken to shake things up, and his underlings know it. They do something dumb, he ge
by pclmulqdq 4y ago
In my opinion, the biggest problem Sundar has is that he is too much of a chicken to shake things up, and his underlings know it. They do something dumb, he gets questioned about it, he says the word "thoughtful," everyone at G gets a little bit angry, and then the whole thing blows over. That does not incentivize responsibility among the managers underneath him. Sundar tries to keep peace between managers and departments, but in doing so, he loses control.
There was an "exit only doors" fiasco a year ago, and the man couldn't say either:
* "yes, VPs get special permissions to access the buildings" or
* "that is a security risk and everyone needs to go in through the same lobbies"
He just said "thoughtful" and the VPs lost their exit-only door access for a while until it blew over.
This was such a small, petty thing that I pretty much lost all respect for Sundar over the fact that he couldn't take a stand on it. He absolutely refuses to provide an opinion about anything to the wider group of Googlers. His underlings know that, and they know they can do stupid shit and work against each other without accountability.
- cosmotron 4y agoWhy would VPs be interested in using different building entrances?
- pclmulqdq 4y agoThe lobbies get very crowded around 9 and 5, and so do the elevators near them.
- datavirtue 4y agoCan't have the executives possibly smelling the rabble.
- galaxyLogic 4y agoAll executives exit effectively immediately!
- stoltzmann 4y agoAt some offices, the exit only doors are in significantly more convenient locations.
- ikiris 4y agoThe buildings were designed for much more open access prior to security policy changes that made most of the useful paths exit only.
- jrockway 4y agoOh man, is that something that changed in the last few years? One thing I always liked about the Mountain View campus is that every door, no matter how minor, had a badge reader on it, so you could always take the most direct path between two possible points. At the same time, there were a lot of stories on the internal social network about people walking in behind them, so I kind of get why the policy might have been changed. I would have been one of the people mad about it! (I posted one of these following-me-in stories once; I unlocked the door and someone pushed me out of the way to go into the office ahead of me, and I didn't see their badge. I tracked down security, they reviewed the tapes, and it turned out to be a legitimate coworker. I shared the story with the angle "this is what you should do if someone follows you in", but I got panned for not doing enough to protect my coworkers. I probably didn't post this, but my takeaway was "if your security depends on me being able to beat someone up that is larger than me, you're already dead". One of the few times the internal social media hive mind turned against me, and it was really really weird.)
- LexGray 4y agoSounds like they need to make reporting dead simple. Put an alarm button on every badge reader. Hit the button. Pre-recorded “intruder who did not badge present. Everyone present please wait for security.” Then locks second internal door. Or even better just automate counting bodies vs badging on every entrance/exit. Lots of nfc/face recognition type technology to tell who is who.
- bsimpson 4y agoI think it was a kneejerk to the YouTube shooter. There are also now rules about how many badge readers need to be between public and private areas. This turns into a mess in historic buildings that have technically-public stairwells littered throughout. (The Munich campus is particularly bad for this.)
- birdyrooster 4y agoI remember when Sundar became CEO the first thing he did was hole himself up in 2000 Amphitheatre Pkwy and block access to all Google staff not in that building. The next thing he did was get bullied by the board and their CFO, but I digress.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoIn all seriousness, it did seem like Ruth Porat (the CFO) was the real brains of the operation. Sundar is the fall guy.
- scarface74 4y agoNo manager who leads in demand software engineers will ever be able to change anything unless their reports believe in the vision. The minute things don’t go their way, we can just get another job, It’s really hard for a CEO who had nothing to do with the current success of the company to have any type of credibility with employees. Let’s look at the CEOs of the other BigTech companies. - Apple: Tim Cook had as much to do with the current success of Apple as Jobs did. He worked for Apple from the time it was broke until today. - Amazon: Jassy (my skip*10 manager) led the AWS division from its “real” founding until he became CEO. - Facebook - still founder led - Microsoft - the CEO came in from Azure and had a vision for what the “new MS” should look like - completely different than “Windows Everywhere”
- tektekX 4y agoThere's some bizarre PR campaign going on to try and brand Sundar as the next Steve Jobs: lots of the photos of him looking thoughtful with steepled hands overlaid with anodyne quotes about technology or AI. It's unclear to me if he's much more than a tech billionaire by luck. No kind of strategy is ever communicated to employees, just defensive + responsive TGIF responses. Truly bizarre.
- oogetyboogety 4y agoThat's funny. Yes, for me this bizarre PR campaign shows up as promoted content when I scroll through my Google news feed.
- notatoad 4y ago>believe in the vision Which means there has to actually be a vision. As far as I can tell, the vision at google is just to keep making boatloads of money off AdWords, and not really care about anything else.
- solardev 4y ago> making boatloads of money off AdWords You forgot "and spending it on annual chat apps"
- CydeWeys 4y ago> In my opinion, the biggest problem Sundar has is that he is too much of a chicken to shake things up, and his underlings know it. What?? Sundar is the CEO. All the buck stops with him. Why are you pretending as if he doesn't have agency? The problem here is his actions and/or lack thereof, not people under him doing stupid things and he's somehow the victim. He gets paid the big bucks to lead.
- gtowey 4y agoThis seems like a popular management style at big tech companies. I've seen exactly this kind of behavior at MS too. It's a kind of "pacifist management". Just agree with everything and everyone so you're not seen as someone who creates conflict. But then just silently ignore or drop issues you don't want to deal with. Don't take risks or take responsibility for difficult problems so your reputation is clean of any failures. Jump on board only the largest and most well supported of company initiatives so you can claim success. And the thing is, I'm not sure it's the fault of these managers that behave this way. I think it's the result of the promo system adopted by so many tech companies. As long as you have some good things to write about each promo cycle and nobody has anything bad to say about you, you can coast your way up the management chain. And with each promotion comes more money. There is no incentives to take risks as it can only hurt your promo chances and then once you're high enough up the chain, why would you risk the huge comp package? Pichai complained about engineers who "rest and vest" but only because that is exactly the behavior incentivized by the company culture and the absolutely stupid promo process and comp structure. With leadership like that, it's sure that nothing will ever change.
- Aeolun 4y agoThis starts all the way at the interview btw. If you go out of your way to do something extra, you’ll be suddenly judged on it even if it wasn’t originally in the scope of the interview, so you’re pushed to be the most average you can get.
- _cehz 4y agoWell said. I rocketed up the chain early in my career for inventing some truly innovative stuff (that's been published in top conferences). Then I fought against stupid shit. I spoke out. I had strong technical opinions. Eventually I was pushed aside and my career has tanked (but rest-and-vest baby...except I'm slowly recovering and still seen as a company intellectual resource). Meanwhile I watch all the mediocre managers keep rising who are "yes, sir" and don't make any enemies. They don't do shit except follow the status quo and build their empires.
- gscott 4y ago
- ajmurmann 4y agoMarc Andreesen recently has been talking a lot about the professional managerial class (PMC) and how it's causing the principle actor problem. Everyone is playing it safe and not risking their high pay checks for the off chance of rocking the boat and landing a moon shot. Nobody really makes any hard and decisive moves because there is much to lose and not that much more to win. This was different when we had companies owned by individuals or families.
- theGnuMe 4y agoMark @Meta seems to be making bold moves.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoDoesn't that pretty much prove the point of the comment you are replying to? > Everyone is playing it safe and not risking their high pay checks for the off chance of rocking the boat and landing a moon shot. Mark has majority of the voting shares of Meta. He could run it into the ground and still could stay in control.
- invig 4y agoYes, but the takeaway isn't that they should start making bold moves, it's that we actually want them to churn out and be surpassed over time. It's the entrenching of them through regulatory capture or predatory behaviour that's bad.
- nradov 4y agoThere are still a lot of companies owned by individuals or families. You just don't hear about them because they seldom take the big risks necessary to produce disruptive innovations.
- miohtama 4y agoThis was one of the reasons why Nokia died. When the organization grew, everything was taken over by middle management whose safest option in any scenario was “Please do not change anything.”
- User23 4y ago> His underlings know that, and they know they can do stupid shit and work against each other without accountability. This is what really sunk Eastman Kodak. The popular wisdom about them missing digital isn’t really true. Heck they owned many of the key patents. But everyone was too busy focusing on growing their little fiefdom for the company to use its assets and market position effectively. I recall one year the CEO announced he was reducing headcount by some number and the next year it had actually gone up.
- SanjayMehta 4y ago"Thoughtful" - what does he mean by that? That he's thinking about it?
- pclmulqdq 4y agoIt's kind of an internal meme: he says "we have to be thoughtful about this" or "we have to approach this thoughtfully." Almost every tough question from inside Google is met with an answer that contains the word "thoughtful." It seems to mean "there is no easy win for me in this situation, so I am passing the buck to (presumably) a committee of other people who will think about it instead, or perhaps a power-hungry VP who has a vested interest in making it happen."
- SanjayMehta 4y agoAh so. I had a colleague who would say "I suspect I shall have to think about this." In retrospect, I realise it was his code phrase for not doing anything at all.