14 ms·
The Fed plans to sharply boost unemployment
- fxtentacle 4y ago"With an additional million or two people out of work, the newly unemployed and their families would sharply cut back on spending, while for most people who are still working, wage growth would flatline. When companies assume their labor costs are unlikely to rise, the theory goes, they will stop hiking prices. That, in turn, slows the growth in prices." That seems like a pretty whacky theory to me because it assumes that companies only increase prices when forced to do so, and not just because they can.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoIt also doesn’t take into account 300k Boomers retiring per month. The Fed can’t print oil or housing, but it’s going to keep raising the benchmark rate while there’s a labor supply shortage. I am skeptical they can destroy jobs faster than workers take themselves out of the labor pool (through retirement and death), although driving down artificially high asset prices is a welcome result. Look at a population pyramid for the US, it’s plain as day.
- NeverFade 4y agoIn a free market with healthy competition, a company can't just raise prices and increase its profit margins, because its competitors will keep their prices low and get all the business. Thus, indeed, companies can only afford to raise prices when all other companies in their space are forced to do the same, for instance due to rising labor costs.
- paulryanrogers 4y agoWhat portion of markets lack healthy competition?
- paulryanrogers 4y agoIf companies cannot raise prices due to higher unemployment then it may be an effective, albeit cruel, strategy.
- deeptote 4y ago> That seems like a pretty whacky theory to me because it assumes that companies only increase prices when forced to do so, and not just because they can. It comes across especially wacky to me as price hikes have outstripped wage hikes. Considering wages and purchasing power has flatlined for workers, but productivity has greatly increased, seems like there's a lot of people getting fleeced.
- refurb 4y agoTheir ability to raise prices is depending upon consumers having the money to spend.
- econ101time 4y ago>That seems like a pretty whacky theory to me because it assumes that companies only increase prices when forced to do so, and not just because they can. I see people post things like this, and I'm forced to conclude that you don't understand supply and demand. Edit: Sure, monopoly pricing is real. But blaming monopoly pricing for inflation is dubious. You'd need an account of 1) how the goods in the CPI basket are monopoly priced and 2) why all these monopolies decided to raise prices now instead of 3 or 10 years ago. The standard account is much more plausible: Supply side crunch due to covid policies and geopolitical problems and sanctions. Increased demand due to the Fed dropping money out of helicopters for over a decade + (more acutely) covid handouts.
- socialismisok 4y agoSupply and demand works on a idealized economy, but it's hardly true in the real world where there are cartels, monopolies, and other incentives to keep prices high even if there's supply.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mjhay 4y agoSupply and demand works great in Econ 101 though.
- MereInterest 4y agoCorrect, because Econ 101 is based on an idealized economy that doesn't match the real world.
- SantalBlush 4y agoThat's why you take Econ 102, which is an intro microeconomics course. It covers the different market types, like competitive, monopolistically competitive, duopolistic, and monopolistic, and it covers the concepts of positive and negative externalities, market failures, etc. A lot of people here are acting like these are foreign concepts to an econ curriculum, when they're completely rudimentary. It's just ignorance.
- koheripbal 4y agoSupply-Demand pricing is probably one of the most well studies aspects of modern economics. There is a range of prices between the underlying costs+overhead to the price point where demand drops off. In that range, several factors influence where a company sets its price. In a case where a company produces a unique product on the market, then it will price in the higher end of the range where demand drops off. On the other hand if multiple companies produce the identical product (a commodity market), then the competition all try to undercut the prices of one another and prices are more determined by the underlying input costs (such as labor and raw materials). Few companies product something COMPLETELY unique and irreplaceable for long until other companies copy them, but most try to differentiate themselves somehow to enable higher pricing without competition. They obviously also try to reduce overhead and negotiate lower input prices to gain a pricing advantage and capture more market share. Many companies exist in mature markets where commodity pricing dominates. In such cases, and in OPs case, the LACK of rising labor costs allow prices to remain low. Only on social media do people think that companies price things from a purely ethical/greed based model. Efficient pricing is just one aspect of running a successful company.
- vsareto 4y agoShrinkflation is very real and illustrates that companies still have some agency based on profit/greed in determining prices.
- econ101time 4y agoThe alternative to shrinkflation is just raising the price (or raising it more). Yes, it's toying with sticky demand psychology, such that a plain price increase would produce a less favorable equilibrium for the seller, but I'd be surprised if it was a significant driver of inflation.
- Aunche 4y agoIt sounds wacky because they're framing it in the worst possible light to generate populist outrage and get more clicks. The goal of raising interest rates is to contract the money supply because it would disincentivizing lending. Increasing unemployment is an unfortunate side effect, but clearly not their intention.
- rufus_foreman 4y agoCompanies are increasing prices now. If they could have profitably increased them before, why did they wait until now?
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoBecause genuine supply chain problem-induced price increases gave them cover to increase prices on things without supply chain problems. And also because in late 2020/early 2021, it appeared that labor was about to get a bit uppity and wee bit more powerful than it had been, so price increases were a nice preemptive move to deal with upcoming compensation issues.
- pitaj 4y ago> Because genuine supply chain problem-induced price increases gave them cover to increase prices on things without supply chain problems. Or maybe the supply chain problems bubbled out to affect more and more things? Or maybe there was an actual general devaluing of the currency? Might want to employ a razor here. > And also because in late 2020/early 2021, it appeared that labor was about to get a bit uppity and wee bit more powerful than it had been, so price increases were a nice preemptive move to deal with upcoming compensation issues. This reads as "the cabal of big capital got together and decided to raise prices across the board because they were worried about labor power". You realize this makes you sound like a conspiracy theorist right?
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoThere's never any need for conspiracies or cabals when the interests of a given group are naturally aligned, and they are not large in numbers. Corporations can behave in their "own interest" and most times, they will find themselves acting in concert, without coordination. > Or maybe the supply chain problems bubbled out to affect more and more things? Shrinkflation is not explained by supply chain problems. My razor is that corporations will generally do whatever they believe they can get away with; "supply chain problems" gave them something approaching carte blanche to reprice anything they wanted.
- petermcneeley 4y ago“Whereas my father made your yoke heavy, I will add to your yoke. Whereas my father scourged you with whips, I will scourge you with scorpions.”
- mjhay 4y agoWage growth has not been keeping up with inflation, and may even be damping it. The steady chorus of claims that wages are too high strikes me as consent-manufacturing by capital. https://www.epi.org/blog/wage-growth-has-been-dampening-inflation-all-along-and-has-slowed-even-more-recently/ https://www.epi.org/blog/wage-growth-has-been-dampening-infl... https://insurancenewsnet.com/oarticle/inflation-continues-to-outpace-wage-growth https://insurancenewsnet.com/oarticle/inflation-continues-to...
- refurb 4y agoEverybody wants to control inflation until it's time to suppress wage growth. The Bank of Canada even came right and out said that employers should definitely not raise wages quickly. https://www.theglobeandmail.com/business/article-wage-negotiations-inflation-canada/ https://www.theglobeandmail.com/business/article-wage-negoti...
- mjhay 4y agoWeird how government agencies that fall to regulatory capture all keep advocating for things beneficial to the industries they oversee. Sufficient tax increases for the well-off would have the same effect as punishing the working class, but that's never an option for some reason.
- californical 4y agoNot exactly — wealthy people don’t spend most of their money on goods & services, they leave it parked in investments. Reducing a wealthy person’s net worth don’t really affect how much they spend on consumer goods. A poor or working-class person spends (nearly) all of their money on consumer goods. Give them 10% more money and they try to buy 10% more things. Restricting money on the wealthy doesn’t reduce demand for GPUs for example, but restricting money on low-middle income people does. That lower demand for consumer goods is how you can slow inflation.
- soulofmischief 4y ago
- ajackfox 4y agoFor basically my entire adult life, at the macro level capital investments have basically been free for corporations. While I have an idea of will happen based on historical data, it will certainly be ‘interesting’ to experience it first hand. :/
- ethbr0 4y agoIt's healthy in that it causes unproductive firms to go bankrupt. It's painful in that unproductive firms are no longer handing out free money to employees and customers. Looking at the market of companies today, especially in the tech space, IMHO ten years or so of fiscal prudence would be really healthy. The only downside is that Apple, Amazon, Google, and Microsoft would weather it and come out more relatively dominant.
- fallingfrog 4y agoI agree, that’s probably what will happen. It’s the natural progression of things and the boom/bust credit cycle speeds the process- a new field of technology, full of hungry competitors, eventually winnows down to a small number of large firms, who then usually proceed to fix prices to ensure permanent profits. Then you have to get government involved to make sure they don’t abuse their monopoly power, and the whole thing ends up being a government/private industry hybrid operation. At that point it’s a power struggle between popular power/democracy and private power/capital, which lately capital has been dominating, but that may reverse. Libertarian supporters of capitalism look backward to the earlier phase of a lot of competing small firms innovating rapidly, in which government is more an impediment than anything else, and while that’s a great time to be in, it’s just a phase, and eventually the board clears and you end up with a small number or just one large firm that controls a whole industry, and popular movements or government is really the only check on their power.
- ethbr0 4y agoLooking backwards (90s/early 00s), it's curious we didn't see hyperscale cloud concentration earlier. The tech was there, at least relative to state of the art of the day. I guess it was a demand problem. There needed to be one huge customer to dictate a single set of needs, and that didn't exist until Amazon bootstrapped via its own demand and internal interoperability mandates. It'll be curious if Google bows out. You'd think Android would have taught them that sometimes throwing money on a bonfire is a good investment in aggregate.
- dmm 4y agoThe fed funds rate was above 10% on avg between 1979 and 1984. If rates that high for that long were necessary to contain inflation, could we afford that at this point? Wouldn't the rates paid on the federal debt have to go way up as well?
- refurb 4y agoTreasuries have maturities up to 10 years, so some bonds that will mature in 2030 (and new bonds need to be reissues at current rates) were issued at rates from 2020. Thus, a relatively large portion of the federal debt may be isolated from a relatively short (3-5 year) jump in rates.
- vitaflo 4y agoTreasuries go up to 30 year maturities. In fact, the 30 year Treasury used to be the leading indicator for the bond market. Most use the 10 year now though.
- refurb 4y agoYou are correct, I was thinking the distinction between t-bills, treasury notes and treasury bonds, which denote different maturity length.
- hedora 4y ago> Fed Chair Jerome Powell made that amply clear this week when the central bank projected its benchmark rate hitting 4.4% ... ... In plain English, that means unemployment. The Fed forecasts the unemployment rate to rise to 4.4% next year What? The fed is setting benchmark unemployment rates now? That seems unlikely.
- gruez 4y agoSeems like a clueless reporter assuming that "benchmark rate" was referring to unemployment rather than interest. The linked article shortly after that quote confirms this, by explicitly saying that the 4.4% rate was referring to the federal funds rate.
- evancox100 4y agoActually it is just a coincidence, both numbers happen to be the same. Fed does not “set” unemployment rates but they are predicting the effect of the policy will be 4.4% unemployment by the end of 2023. Separately, the median forecast for fed funds rate by the end of 2022 is 4.4%. From Fortune: “Officials expect the benchmark rate to rise to 4.4% by year end and 4.6% during 2023, according to the median estimate in updated quarterly projections published alongside the statement. … The updated forecasts also showed unemployment rising to 4.4% by the end of next year and the same at the end of 2024 — up from 3.9% and 4.1%, respectively, in the June projections.” https://www.google.com/amp/s/fortune.com/2022/09/21/fed-raises-interest-rate-75-basis-points/amp/ https://www.google.com/amp/s/fortune.com/2022/09/21/fed-rais...
- jt2190 4y agoI think the 4.4% unemployment projection is from Table 1 of this document: “Federal Open Market Committee Summary of Economic Projections“ Sept 21, 2022 > Projections for the unemployment rate are for the average civilian unemployment rate in the fourth quarter of the year indicated. https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/files/fomcprojtabl20220921.pdf https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/files/fomcproj...
- LUmBULtERA 4y ago
- socialismisok 4y agoReducing power of workers in favor of capital is deeply disappointing to me. The idea that we'd want to increase unemployment rather than have everyone working is frustrating. "But wages are too high!" Shouldn't the folks who believe in markets as a force for good want wages to be set by markets? The most profitable businesses can pay the wages for workers, and the least profitable ones can't hire? Why do we need someone taking away power from labor when labor starts to gain even a small amount of leverage?
- ShredKazoo 4y ago>The idea that we'd want to increase unemployment rather than have everyone working is frustrating. Keeping unemployment low is part of the Fed's mandate -- along with keeping inflation low. But sometimes you can't get everything you want.
- jibe 4y agoLabor isn’t gaining power now, or else you’d see wages gains greater than inflation. Labor is losing to inflation.
- socialismisok 4y agoIt's gained some ground with movements like the $15 now movement in Seattle. It can be the case it has gained but gained unevenly.
- jibe 4y agoIn aggregate, wage gains are behind inflation. In a country of 330 million, it will always be uneven. Everything is uneven at scale.
- Victerius 4y ago- Full employment - Low inflation - High wages Pick two.
- 4y ago
- nemo44x 4y agoThey should start by firing themselves. In a managed economy it’s the managers who are at fault for the situation we are in. But naturally it’s the common man who will suffer. They’re just a statistic after all.
- dehrmann 4y agoI don't think you realize how hard it was to get this right. Between covid, reopenings, and the war in Ukraine, there were massive supply and demand shifts in the last 3 years.
- nemo44x 4y agoMaybe everyone saying that lowering rates well over a year ago was ridiculous at the time were right? Yea it’s hard but that’s the job.
- bjourne 4y ago> In plain English, that means unemployment. The Fed forecasts the unemployment rate to rise to 4.4% next year, from 3.7% today — a number that implies an additional 1.2 million people losing their jobs. > "I wish there were a painless way to do that," Powell said. "There isn't." A reminder to us that psychopaths are running the world economy.
- propernoun 4y ago> A reminder to us that psychopaths are running the world economy. Labeling Powell/the Fed as a psychopath simply because they're turning one of the very few if not only inflation control knobs they have seems extreme. A psychopath would have done this randomly or at an illogical time (say by raising rates at the outset of the Great Recession). Just because you don't like the outcome of a decision doesn't make the decision maker a psychopath, more so when they agree that they wish there was a better way.
- bjourne 4y agoThey are psychopaths because they have no concern for the misery they cause. If it were themselves or their families who would have their lives ruined, rather than 1.2 million innocent Americans, they wouldn't be so quick to enact this policy. A policy only supported by very dubious research, mind you. They are no better than the generals that dropped the atomic bombs on Japan, Vladimir Putin, or any other psychopaths to full of shit to give a damn about the well-being of others.
- generj 4y agoThey do this knowing taking no action will be far far worse for everyone. We saw what a decade of stagflation looked like and it’s much worse than limited job losses. Even those who lose jobs will be better off with a short recession rather than costs inflating away their earnings. The actions taken in 2007 and 2008 were largely because of how terrified decision makers were of the Great Depression (Bernanke in particular was a deep student of that era and saw lots of similarities). The Fed’s mandate has always been to control inflation and promote employment. The goals sometimes oppose each other. There’s no evidence they have stepped aside from this mandate. Employment was so prioritized by the Fed for so long that their actions promoting it probably fueled some of this inflation, and led to them to not fighting the inflation sooner. Hardly the actions of Vladimir Putin.
- nathias 4y agoyea, this doesn't just affect the US, the Fed is basically a world-monarch at this point
- Kukumber 4y agoChina bad apparently
- the_optimist 4y agoBefore we do that, can we estimate the economic surplus of replacing 1) the Fed with a Brownian bridge 2) government budgeting with a formal tax limitation system
- nine_zeros 4y agoThe CPI number is high because rents are high. Every other measure of CPI has dropped. But housing prices and rents just won't budge. This is a battle between the fed and sticky rent-seeking homeowners. Everyone else is a pawn. Our healthcare, livelihoods and families are mere collateral damage.
- throwaway9870 4y agoPlease clarify what you mean by "dropped". If you are talking over a 12 month window, that is most certainly not the case: https://www.bls.gov/cpi/ https://www.bls.gov/cpi/ Ignoring CPI, inflation is rampant in many other areas such as agriculture (basically everything is up) and manufacturing of good (again, everything seems up, metal, paint, fasteners, etc.)
- nine_zeros 4y agoIn the final CPI number, "Services less energy services" has the highest weightage. https://www.bls.gov/charts/consumer-price-index/consumer-price-index-relative-importance.htm https://www.bls.gov/charts/consumer-price-index/consumer-pri... "Services less energy services" contains Shelter, transportation and medical services, of which, shelter has the highest weightage: https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2022/01/24/as-inflation-soars-a-look-at-whats-inside-the-consumer-price-index/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2022/01/24/as-inflatio... which is still increasing month over month as much as other things but increases CPI measure disproportionately higher: https://www.bls.gov/news.release/cpi.nr0.htm https://www.bls.gov/news.release/cpi.nr0.htm
- xutopia 4y agoThis is deleterious beyond just economics. Put people out of a job and they go sick, die more frequently and have a general unpleasant time. None of these folks are willing to look at how profits are at record high... take money out of the richest hands and redistribute. The cards are stacked against the common people and asking the non-wealthy to take the brunt of the hit here is a cash grab by the elite who aren't doing their part.
- taolegal 4y ago> This is deleterious beyond just economics. Put people out of a job and they go sick, die more frequently and have a general unpleasant time. This "people are going die" justification has been behind so much catastrophically unwise policy, because there is no argument against it that matches the visceral alarms-blaring rhetoric. It's a blunt weapon and there's not a matching response, since the honest & sincere response is abstract arguments about the fallibility of human judgement & how every decision has costs and benefits, intended and unintended, associated with estimated probabilities. The problem is that this inflation is so obviously tied to the moral hazard of 2008, bailing out corporations (a result of progressive policy arguing to protect people) and then, the very much similar in spirit, policy enacted during the pandemic. Even 9/11 & the whole apparatus of the 2000s is similar in spirit. All these things were enacted under the pretense of emergency & collectivism. Totalitarian rhetoric and orwellian redefinitions of language were used to silence & stigmatize opposition. Money was printed recklessly in order to finance even more precarious and unsustainable economic dynamics & govt projects. Guess what? It's all crashing down now. This isn't austerity & libertarianism. Those people have practically no power, only a handful of politicians qualify for that label. We're ruled by big government. The New Deal won over American government, and by any reasonable analysis has reigned supreme ever since and these are the results. Constant crises spilling over into each other, eking out a couple years of relief before the dam gets ready to burst again even more spectacularly.
- polio 4y agoIt should be possible to bail out the people without bailing out the companies, and it should be doable without generic QE. What if the government builds its own farms and grocery stores and housing complexes? Would that be bad because of how much control it would give the government or would it be good because of how much control it wrests away from private industry?
- DisjointedHunt 4y agoLet's break this down. . .the most significant contributor to inflation over the past year has been fuel prices and availability. This leads to reverberations through the economy, such as: - Increased freight and transport costs, everything that moves from source to destination becomes expensive. - Most importantly, food and raw material powering all the products we buy as daily expenditures have a significant fuel cost. The Fed has only one weapon, the flow of funds into the economy. It controls this through the Fed rate as well as instruments under its gambit which give it immense power to purchase assets. In short, this is not the job of the fed. We have a molecules crisis thanks to war and supply chain issues combined with stupid energy security decisions.
- Ericson2314 4y agoHN, please take a look at where the bottlenecks are. E.g. if it's rents get involved with your local YIMBY group. If it's gasoline prices get involved with micro mobility, public transit, and other anti-car stuff. Supply bottlenecks are what technology is supposed to solve. If they impovish people every time our shoddy infrastructure isn't up to the task, what is the point of being an engineer?
- symlinkk 4y agoDemocrats are going to get annihilated in the midterms because of this.
- nilsbunger 4y agoInflation is high because demand exceeds supply. You have to reduce demand to match the available supply. Interest rates are the main tool to do that. This is true even if the ultimate cause is supply chain issues.
- alooPotato 4y agoWhy not help with supply issues too?
- slaw 4y agoAnother name for supply chain issue is China's zero Covid policy. How do you think US government can help with it?
- nilsbunger 4y agoIt’s not only china zero covid policy. For example , there’s a huge worker shortage in industries like airlines and hospitality. That’s a supply shortage too.
- nilsbunger 4y agoWe should do everything we can to fix supply issues. The sooner we do, the better. But in the meantime , demand has to adjust. Either we do it via monetary policy and any other levers, or inflation will do the job for us.
- marcosdumay 4y agoThere isn't a simple, first-order relation between the monetary and the real economies. The only thing that exists is an absurdly complex web of small second or higher order interactions.
- nilsbunger 4y agoIt’s pretty tightly linked. Lots of loans don’t happen when interest rates go up. On the consumer side , car loans, mortgages , etc. on the biz side, capital loans and lines of credit. All of this significantly reduces purchases and money in our pockets, thus putting downward pressure on gdp and demand.
- UtopiaPunk 4y agoAn economic system that demands people must work to obtain food and housing, but also demands a certain percentage of the population needs to be unemployed is barbaric.
- 50 4y agoFirst capitalism takes our brain, then the state our flesh. It is therefore no surprise just how incredibly unintelligent it makes everyone.
- yuan43 4y agoZero direct evidence for the title's claim was provided in the article. All the Fed is doing is to normalize interest rates. Deeply negative real yields (5% or more) are aberrations that history has shown to ultimately lead to catastrophe. Yet talking head and Dem Senator alike are treating rate normalization as financial Armageddon. Somebody tell me how at the very least a 0% real yield on cash is going to kill the economy. Now explain what's normal about that.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoI can’t see how killing off a bunch of zombie companies surviving on cheap debt is bad for the economy in even the medium term.
- starkd 4y agoKilling off the zombie companies will drive unemployment rate higher. Good in the longer term, but it won't come without a cost. That's the price we pay for such an extended period of cheap credit.
- slenk 4y agoZombie company to me sounds like a shell company with one or two people - that is not going to spike unemployment. Unless I don't understand what a zombie company is
- bombcar 4y agoZombie company usually means a company that should close down but continues to exist because capital is soooooo cheap. Imagine things like unprofitable companies that are riding venture capital, etc. Uber could be one, perhaps.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoThat, and unprofitable companies taking on larger and larger piles of debt to continue their operations. IIRC some 15-20% of listed companies fall in that category.
- thagerty 4y agoFat cats need more wage slaves. Period.
- twirlock 4y ago
- blockwriter 4y agoIs the term "boost" in regards to unemployment a phrase that the Fed uses, or is it editorializing?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- credit_guy 4y agoIt does not matter how we got here. Who's fault it was, or wasn't. It does not matter if the inflation is driven by supply or demand. The Fed has a job to do, by law. It has the dual mandate of keeping inflation low, and also unemployment law. Now inflation is higher than it was in 3 decades, and unemployment is record low. They are good by one measure (unemployment), but incredibly bad by another one. Their job is to take inflation down. At some point the two mandates will pull in opposite directions, but right now the inflation is high, and unemployment low. Sure, fighting inflation will increase a bit the unemployment, but few things come for free in life.
- landemva 4y agoThe mandate is for "stable prices". When a person's body weight is stable it may fluctuate a little but basically stays the same year-over-year. This says "stable prices", https://www.federalreserve.gov/aboutthefed/section2a.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/aboutthefed/section2a.htm Federal Reserve actually targets 2% per year and regularly exceeds that. Try that with your body weight and look at the scale in a decade when you can't see your toes. Nobody cares to hold Federal Reserve to the law of stable prices. Notice how they word-smith "stable prices" into "stable inflation". "... low and stable inflation at the rate of 2 percent per year ..." https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/monetary-policy-what-are-its-goals-how-does-it-work.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/monetary-polic...
- tzs 4y agoThey make it sound like 4.4% unemployment is high. For most of the last 70 years that would have been considered a low rate.