8 ms·
A small town that saved its only grocery store by buying it
- mxkopy 4y ago[flagged]
- walterbell 4y agoThere are more than two -isms.
- deltasevennine 4y ago
- walterbell 4y agoMunicipal-owned utilities and businesses have long existed, in many countries, of all political stripes.
- deltasevennine 4y ago[flagged]
- walterbell 4y agoIt's relevant to the thread, even if not to you.
- deltasevennine 4y agoWell you responded me and my thread. So what's the point then if it's not relevant to me? Either way I disagree. It's relevant.
- dang 4y agoWould you please not take HN threads further into flamewar and not cross into personal attack? You've done it more than once in this thread, it's completely gratuitous, and we've had to warn you about this (indeed, ban you for this, if I recall correctly) many times before. If you'd please make your substantive points without any of that, we would be grateful. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- deltasevennine 4y agoWhat? This is the first time you've mentioned anything about banning.
- dang 4y agoI don't remember what I've mentioned before; in any case, it's not the most important thing. The important thing is that we need you to follow the site guidelines from now on, and we ban accounts that won't do that.
- bobkazamakis 4y ago>I don't see any indicator that he thinks there are only two there are only about 10 other isms that would have more accurately described this, and "communism" is used in the 1995 film Hackers for a reason, but it might not be the one you're picking up on. >communism but not quite. so in other words, capitalism but not quite
- jschveibinz 4y agoIt is capitalism. The capital necessary to purchase the store, maintain cash flow, and make periodic maintenance and upgrades will come from the ownership. Profit, an important part of capitalism, may be generated by the business to the benefit of the shareholders. In this case, that profit may be cash, discounts, additional goods or services, reinvestment into the business or whatever the town owners/shareholders or their designees decide. More neighborhood co-op businesses should be formed!
- mxkopy 4y agoHave you considered that capitalism and communism are economic systems that are in a sense Turing complete, i.e. they can describe the exact same arbitrary economic phenomena And therefore what you have described is in fact communism but in a language that is subjectively more palatable ?
- jschveibinz 4y agoI have considered that co-op’s, public utilities and mutual aid societies are excellent solutions to problems such as the one presented small towns, like Erie. It is possible to utilize private capital, such as the store purchase, for public benefit (the residents of Erie) and the mechanism by which that is accomplished is secondary. The fact that the city council was involved was a matter of convenience. It could have been accomplished by any means of group cooperation. For example, only half of the town (500 people) could have been involved, rather than the whole town. Palatability is in the details.
- deltasevennine 4y ago
- mxkopy 4y agoI never said there were only two. I'm not sure what you mean?
- deltasevennine 4y agowhy is it voted down? This is technically true. People are polarized on the topic of communism vs. capitalism but the reality is these are just two different colors. Two different aspects, similar to solid or liquid. When you treat it as a sport team you become biased. If you hate capitalism you become blind to how capitalism produces powerful economies like most of the western world. If you hate communism you become blind to how stories like this can benefit a community. There are plenty of public goods that cannot thrive under pure capitalism. Grocery stores with razer thing margins are an example of this.
- AmericanChopper 4y ago> This is technically true. State owned enterprises are feature in every free market economy. The comment is not true, technically or otherwise.
- shapefrog 4y ago> in every free market economy No free market economy to ever exist has been a pure capitalism without hints, shades or straight up chunks of communism, socialism and many other flavours of -ism.
- deltasevennine 4y ago>State owned enterprises are feature in every free market economy. And that is why it is technically true. >The comment is not true, technically or otherwise. This makes zero logic, or sense. You literally just stated that every free market economy has elements of communism then denied your statement right after. I think you're caught by the connotation of the word instead of the definition. Team communism is the enemy to you.
- AmericanChopper 4y agoI think you’re projecting a lot here. It’s simply a zero-insight (and factually incorrect) comment to look at one centrally planned initiative and starting saying “communism”. The “not a real free market” and “not real communism” cohorts are equally stupid, and should be dismissed with equal passion.
- erk__ 4y agoIn Denmark we have a long history of cooperative retail stores, so a development like this is not too surprising sering as there have been quite a few examples of stores getting bought by the community here as well. I think it is a good move in general since there is not going to be the same profit over everything mentality in those stores since it is owned by people who buys stuff there.
- ch4s3 4y agoThere are a lot of co-ops in the US too, but that’s not quite what this is. I’m this case the town government bought and runs the store. A co-op might be better, but you may need a certain population threshold to make that work.
- erk__ 4y agoI think a populating of the around 1000 of the city and the sorrunding area is maybe enough though it is likely harder to compete in these times where everyone has cars and such. (THere is also recent examples here where it is not really a cooperative but a group of citizens getting together and raising money to buy the store and rent it out to a grocer. For example in Halvrimmen https://nordjyske.dk/nyheder/jammerbugt/borgere-koeber-koebmandsbutik-og-planlaegger-at-genaabne-1-november/3371349 https://nordjyske.dk/nyheder/jammerbugt/borgere-koeber-koebm..., where they have made a LTD that owns the store)
- MereInterest 4y agoFor sufficiently representative government, I think that government-owned and cooperatively-owned are synonymous. Especially for small towns, the overhead of having two separate organizations, each of which represents all people in the town, would be quite large.
- okaram 4y agoI think the big difference is that government is mandatory, whereas belonging to a co-op is voluntary. Both are useful and important.
- woodruffw 4y agoThe town's meeting notes are online here[1]. I think they're pretty interesting. [1]: https://erieks.com/agendas-minutes/ https://erieks.com/agendas-minutes/
- walterbell 4y agoThanks for posting, always something to be learned from governance and financial transparency.
- mleonhard 4y agoFrom the 2022-07-25 minutes, they discussed that the store is losing money. They decided to transfer money from sewer & equipment funds to it. They also decided to lower prices. https://erieks.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/JULY25MINUTES.pdf https://erieks.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/JULY25MINUTES.... I'm wondering why the city council is making such decisions. Do they have experience running grocery stores? Perhaps they cannot hire a capable manager to set prices and make the store break-even? They should consult someone with experience on the matter. The previous owners would probably be willing to give advice. From the 2022-06-27 minutes, the council approved a request to use the store's freezer for a city event. The store's manager said they needed council approval. I think the council is micro-managing the store without competence in retail management. The store manager doesn't have authority to run the store. This is probably the root cause of the store's financial troubles. https://erieks.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/JUNE27MINUTES.pdf https://erieks.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/JUNE27MINUTES....
- banannaise 4y agoHere's a better question: Should the store be break-even? If the store is "losing money" then the community's taxes are collectively paying some part of the community's food costs. That sounds like a good thing! You still have personal choice, and your money still means something, but the town is collectively paying for more equal access to food and other essential goods, in a very direct way.
- cat_plus_plus 4y agoOne thing neglected in economic discussions is economy on a small scale. In a town of 1000 people, in the middle of both natural ravages of the pandemic and artificial economic drain imposed by state and national governments through health orders, invisible hand of the market is not going to be enough. It's going to take specific individuals invested in continued existence of the town above their own personal prosperity and ease of life to make that happen. In this situation, democratic control may well be the means to select the right individuals. Just so long as we don't confuse practicality of a tiny town with global solutions for food security or climate change or mRNA vaccines...
- eterevsky 4y agoWouldn't it be cheaper for the town to just subsidize it?
- jschveibinz 4y agoThis is a good question. Patronizing the store should be sufficient to handle the economics, but I would guess the price of products is not their biggest concern or consideration. If it was my town store, I would only want to make it a co-op and become part owner if there was an issue with management and/or cost control, e.g. bad owner, staffing, salaries, inventory, profit margin, upkeep, etc.
- lozenge 4y agoHow will they know the correct subsidy amount? Excess subsidy would go to the owners.
- eterevsky 4y agoRun some kind of an auction.
- cf141q5325 4y agoAuction requires multiple people interested. Here there are none.
- theonlybutlet 4y agoThe former owners were retiring and no longer wanted to be involved. And nobody wanted to buy it.
- phire 4y agoThe problem with that plan is convincing someone to be interested enough to actually take the subsidy. In this example, the old owners were retiring, and nobody wanted to buy it. There isn't a lot of revenue for a Grocery store in a town this small. So it was easier for the town to just buy it and then operate it. Apparently the store was profitable before the sale, and the town operated store in the neighbouring town also operated at a 3% profit. But looks like this town have made the choice to keep prices lower (probably to compete with the dollar general) and operate it at a slight loss, at least for the 2021 year, which is the only year they have released the annual report for since they bought it. Maybe the 2021 year included to startup costs and it would have otherwise been profitable.
- thih9 4y agoThe only downside seems that it’s now more difficult for another grocery store to open and be competitive. Then again, this downside doesn’t apply here, I guess that’s the point.
- langsoul-com 4y agoIn such a place, there's only enough market for a single grocery store anyway. But they did put the store on sale for a while with no buyers.
- coffeeblack 4y agoThe town government would probably gladly sell the store to whoever wants to run it.
- Havoc 4y agoReminds me of both the DIY ISPs and to some extent the "It's Time to Build" essay. Seems that sometimes the Nike slogan is the key ingredient.
- thelittlenag 4y agoThe very small town I grew up in had to do this ten years ago. They formed a co-op and it bought the store. They split the co-op into 100 shares costing a thousand dollars each. I thought about buying one effectively as a donation, but didn’t.
- vlovich123 4y agoThis is a bit different than a coop. This is the city government owning the store.
- jrochkind1 4y ago> The cost: $300k, plus the cost of inventory (~$100k) and a 0.5% cut to the store’s previous owners for the next 10 years — in total, less than ~$500k. Who knows more about grocery retail, and can say: What makes buying an existing store like this preferable to just starting a new store, and avoiding the $300K and 0.5% cut for 10 years?
- kadoban 4y agoIt's already built, and the location is presumably decent. How much cash and time would it take to build a new one?
- rdsnsca 4y agoLikey it is the lack of retail space to build one.
- avianlyric 4y agoThink the same reason you buy any working business. The previous owner has managed to solve a great number of non-obvious operational problems. To name a few that come to mind: * Established supply chain - Working agreements with suppliers (no need to find and negotiate suppliers) - Working logistics. Scheduling of supplies is sorted, you have reliable delivery slots with all supplies * Employees. No need to find and train labour. * Working pay roll, accounting, taxes. No need to create that infrastructure from scratch. * Know good business model, with auditable accounts. You substantially de-risk the investment, because you have meaningful historical data to estimate future performance from. * Physical infrastructure already setup. No need to find a building, buy equipment (shelves, tills etc) and setup equipment. * Business generates revenue for new owner immediately after purchase. No time needed to solve all of the above problems, instead time can be used to grow or stabilise business.
- adammarples 4y agoOwning the only grocery store in town doesn't sound like a risky business model compared to the existing and apparently de-risked "only grocery store in town" business model you'd be paying for.
- fundad 4y agoNationalize all the things
- DoreenMichele 4y agoAh, this is in Kansas. Three years ago, there was a similar story in Florida. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=grocery%20store%20florida&sort=byPopularity&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- bee_rider 4y agoThey also held on to their public library. It's a rough time to be a small town, but Erie is putting up a fight at least.
- nobodyandproud 4y agoThere are parallels between low income (inner city) and rural problems. I genuinely feel modern discrimination and issues are better understood as class issues, though frequently it’s obfuscated as racial problems (etc.)
- woodruffw 4y agoObfuscated probably isn't the right word: the reality is that there are both class and racial issues. The latter feeds into the former; the former gives political cover for the latter.
- mynameishere 4y agoNot sure what you are getting at, but the problem with urban retailers is shoplifting. I doubt that is the problem at "Stub's".
- banannaise 4y agoClass issues and racial issues intersect. If you skew too far toward class issues, you wind up in class reductionism (the demonstrably false notion that creating economic equality will solve racism). If you skew too far toward race issues, you get... I'm not sure what the term for it is, but it's essentially trying to achieve racial equality by building up a class of Black entrepreneurs and ignoring everyone else. An interesting thing I've found (anecdotally) is that corporate and nonprofit efforts for "racial justice" skew very heavily toward the latter, but community aid and grassroots racial justice groups strike much more of a balance.
- swayvil 4y agoIf it's government run then it isn't profit-driven, right? That means just one brand of canned corn. The best brand. No games with 20 brands of the same stuff competing for shelf position and such. And products could be placed for ease of access. Vs maximizing your path through the store so you'll buy more. And none of that wall-of-candybars right by the cash register shenanigans. A store like that could serve the puplic with miraculous efficiency.