7 ms·
Strangely enough: Windows. Yes, I fucking hate Windows 10/11 for several laundry lists' worth of reasons, but you know what? At the end of the day, Windows is
by Dalewyn 4y ago
Strangely enough: Windows.
Yes, I fucking hate Windows 10/11 for several laundry lists' worth of reasons, but you know what? At the end of the day, Windows is the only desktop OS that enables me to use my computer to do the shit I need or want to do.
So long as that fundamental principle as a tool is not violated, I will forever be thankful for Windows regardless what criticism I might have for it.
- tremon 4y agoWindows is the only desktop OS that enables me to use my computer to do the shit I need or want to do. Isn't that a very sad state of affairs? Why should such a piece of critical global infrastructure be in the hands of a single company?
- jgillich 4y agoSoftware development is a much better experience on Linux compared to Windows (unless you stay within Visual Studio). If you do tasks that are well supported by your OS, your experience will be mostly good. Don't run servers on MacOS, don't develop on Windows and don't game on Linux. Or do it anyway and deal with the unpolished aspects of it.
- guhidalg 4y agoTotally agree that development outside of Windows is better. However if a majority of your users are using Windows, shouldn't you, the developer, also use Windows? I think HN has a tired circle-jerk around hating Windows but ultimately most people use Windows for a reason, and it's not because it's a good development environment: it's because it just works and if you're a normal user you never have to open a command line.
- notatoad 4y agoif you're building desktop software for windows then yeah, you should use windows. but these days, most development isn't for windows.
- godshatter 4y ago
- deltasevennine 4y agoTrue, however user experience in windows is still superior.
- Andrex 4y agoComparing Gnome to Windows 10/11? No way.
- Dalewyn 4y agoI would pick the unholy abomination that is ExplorerMetroUWP in Windows 10/11 over GNOME any day of the week. GNOME is nigh unusable other than as an expensive piece of wall decor.
- wing-_-nuts 4y ago>GNOME is nigh unusable other than as an expensive piece of wall decor. Examples you can expand on?
- Andrex 4y agoNot the user you're replying to, but some workflows just don't work well in Gnome (yet). But the combination of key shortcuts and mouse gestures makes it feel really nice to use in practice. Workspaces work like I'd expect, as do Alt+Tab and Alt+`. The built-in apps and settings have a level of consistency the Windows team could only dream of right now. Notifications in Gnome are fantastic. I could go on.
- Dalewyn 4y agoLack of customization for one, either I do things the GNOME way or the highway. Screw that, if I wanted that I would be using MacOS and/or iOS instead since Apple does that far better. Form factor dissonance for another. GNOME clearly targets the mobile form factor, and it fails me for all the reasons Metro in Windows 8 failed me because guess what: I'm using a desktop/laptop, not a tablet/phone.
- beached_whale 4y agodocker and clion is an amazing experience. One can change their toolchain very easily without worrying about interference from all the crap on my dev machine I have installed over time, or that one needs a different config all togethor. It's similar to clion with windows/mac but the experience deteriorates, but the VM for WSL is much better on windows(no need to allocate a huge chunk of ram) than macos for docker
- yakubin 4y agoAs long as you don’t use debuggers.
- richardlblair 4y agoI kind of agree. Linux is still bit of a shit show.. my audio stack got completely fubar'd on my last linux box so back to Windows I went. WSL2 + Docker gets you really close to the development experience of Linux while maintaining your sanity.
- dan_mctree 4y agoAs a lifelong windows dev, what exactly makes linux worth moving to? I understand that coming from a linux world, doing what you like doing in linux isn't always possible on windows. But I've never really found a use for any of that console magic linux devs seem to love. Pipe this into that and through seven pieces of software that sound like glibgcd, add 8 arcane flags and in the end you have some kind of textfile that would've just as easily been made in some handmade program? What exactly is the selling point for devs?
- pksebben 4y agoI'm not sure what a handmade program on windows looks like, so I could be wrong here, but writing shell scripts to do work takes a matter of minutes and creates composable, reliable stuff that vastly reduces the time to do other work. This means that as time goes on, more of my workflow becomes scripted and I very, very rarely work on the same problem twice. Then there's the filesystem. It just works. Permissions are easy to grok and (most) error messages are clear about what's wrong. Everything being a file also means I use the same tools to: - investigate bugs in source code - check what processes are using what ports, files, sockets, etc - find files - find things in files there's very little that can't be done easily with [grep, cat, ls, mv, cd, echo, curl]. Also, manpages are incredible. All my important documentation, right there where I'm doing my work. It's really less about what's possible on windows / Linux, and more about how Linux lets me do things my way, which means I can consistently improve my methods. Also, all the good Linux stuff is free. Both kinds, so not only can I use most of it without worrying about the cost, I can fix it when it goes wrong or modify it to be more like what I want. I could go on and bore you more, but those are the key points.
- jon-wood 4y ago> writing shell scripts to do work takes a matter of minutes This is the core of it for me. Half the time I don’t even need to write a shell scrip, I just fling it straight onto the command line if I’m doing a quick one off task.
- zeppelin101 4y agoI'd also add the "Googlability" factor to this. If you want to check how to do anything in bash, you will have your answer within seconds. Not so with PowerShell. It's a much newer system that doesn't have decades of history.
- gregmac 4y agoI've done lots of dev on both linux and Windows. Neither is "better" IMHO. I started on Linux, but today my main work and personal systems are both Win10. I also have a persoanl Linux laptop I use sometimes (currently Pop_OS, because I felt like trying that). There's certain things easier on one or the other, usually caused by silly hardcoding of paths (or other OS-specific assumptions). I've run into this with python packages on Windows for sure. My Windows dev is mostly limited to .net, and I've been writing cross-platform for years (first via Mono, now .net core / .net 6). Most challenges with cross-platform .net are caused by hardcoding Windows-specific paths and backslash (vs using Environment.* and Path.Combine()), and secondarily by using win32-specific things (eg: registry). Tip for Windows dev use: install Windows Terminal [1], scoop [2], oh-my-posh [3], and busybox [4]. Makes the cli so much more usable, at least for someone like me with linux CLI muscle memory (ls, grep, etc). I've found the combo of busybox utils and PowerShell is very productive. I nearly always have at least a couple terminal tabs open, and I'm nearly 50/50 of whether I use cli or explorer to browse or operate on files. [1] https://github.com/microsoft/terminal https://github.com/microsoft/terminal [2] https://scoop.sh/ https://scoop.sh/ [3] https://ohmyposh.dev/ https://ohmyposh.dev/ [4] https://scoop.sh/#/apps?q=busybox&s=0&d=1&o=true https://scoop.sh/#/apps?q=busybox&s=0&d=1&o=true
- zeppelin101 4y agoAre you able to compare scoop to Chocolatey? I've stuck with choco for years now, because it has so many packages that I haven't wanted to try out scoop or WinGet. Regarding PowerShell, I've found that it has become incredibly customizable these days. For example, I just enabled Emacs keybindings for it a couple days ago. So it feels almost like a bash terminal.
- mrpotato 4y agoUse both! I think one of the main differences is that scoop will install for the local user. Which means you don't have to install stuff from an admin console (I think you can do that with choco but its not the default). I also just checked to see what apps I've used in scoop vs choco and the only one that choco doesn't have (that scoop does) is wsl-ssh-agent. scoop had all the apps I install through choco. I'm sure theres more differences that go a little deeper, but as a simple end user, those are the only things I've noticed
- ivank 4y agoYou can have the best of both worlds with `Visual Studio Code Remote - SSH` and a lot of mintty -> ssh user@host (to a VM, if needed).
- wizofaus 4y agoI wouldn't say the dev experience on Windows is "unpolished", but I agree it's better if you have access to linux-style command line tools (whether via WSL or even just git-bash). In principle PowerShell should be just as powerful but I don't know many devs who can throw together PS scripts the way most of us seem fine with bash etc.
- onehair 4y agoThis! I like Linux a lot, but whenever I try to build an ecosystem in it for more than few workflows I end up in deep time consuming tasks to figure out how to make things cohabit without having my services fight each other. The same open-source apps for some of the same workflows work flawlessly in few minutes without all the struggles.
- inetknght 4y ago> At the end of the day, Windows is the only desktop OS that enables me to use my computer to do the shit I need or want to do. I disagree on two fronts. First that Windows is the "only" desktop OS that enables you to use your computer to do the shit you need or want to do. macOS and Linux both do as well. Secondly that Windows is actually a very terrible OS to use your computer to do the shit you need to do unless you have zero care whatsoever for privacy.
- Dalewyn 4y agoKeep in mind I'm not throwing a blind eye to Windows 10/11's many problems, they are very real and I will absolutely criticize and even hate on Windows for them. But when time comes for me to do things, the only thing that matters is: Can I? At least for me (remember: everyone's needs and desires are different), Windows almost always answers with a resounding "Yes!", and for that practical fact I will always be thankful for Windows. Give credit where credit is due, as the saying goes.
- onehair 4y agoInstall SimpleWall, let it disable windows firewall, block all the things that reach to external IP addresses that you know you haven't installed yourself.
- akho 4y agoIf ‘shit you need to do’ includes office use (Excel has no competition), graphics (Adobe, others), or quite a few other equally important things, Linux will not be a good fit. I use Linux on my computers because it’s much easier to use — setup is easier and more reliable; hardware support is either available or not, without weird driver issues or clunky bespoke vendor applications; scripting is easily available; basic programming tools are much easier to set up; DEs are better than the competition and window managers exist; package management exists, … The application landscape, however, is obviously incomplete, with limited progress.
- aljgz 4y agoI use Linux as my main OS for some years now, but use Mac and Windows, mostly because I need to test my software on them, but I have to say: I totally agree. Windows is the only practical desktop OS for most people. Mac is not an OS you can use unless you buy the entire package, and then you have to live with many of its limitations. It absolutely sucks at multitasking (not that most average users care about this one, but anyone coming from windows will struggle). Linux is absolute freedom, but that comes with the cost of having to do much more than install, plug and play. You need to be a computer geek, or you need someone else to fix things for you. So as much as we are mad at Microsoft for deliberately damaging the experience of using what could be a joy to use, it's still the best at what it is.
- andrei_says_ 4y agoCould you elaborate on the difference between Windows and MacOS in the context of multitasking?
- selfhoster69 4y agoOne thing that has stood out to me is that when I have two Edge windows open, for example and I switch to the last used window from Safari, both windows overlap instead of just the one window I was working with.
- hollandheese 4y agoIf you want to just have the one window come forward use Expose to do it, rather than Cmd-Tab or the Dock.
- aljgz 4y agoUsing mouse is both slower, and needs more mental process to do the same task. Especially if you need to switch repeatedly while doing something, you come up with a short-term muscle memory: use vscode, alt-tab to the other vscode, alt-tab-tab to chrome. Now you know the first alt-tab takes you to the most recent vscode, but two alt-tabs take you to the first one. I develop a vscode extension and do this routinely. On mac I need to either use the mouse, or switch to vscode, then use CMD+backtick to switch to the other. Both are much slower and a disruption to the flow state. Apple for some reason avoids giving people too many options. Just one option: "threat windows of the same application independently" with a default of no would make everyone happy.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y agoI can't disagree, even if I would prefer something else. Easily the most compelling argument I've heard for Windows is Tom Scott's: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lIFE7h3m40U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lIFE7h3m40U.
- oska 4y agoI'm not sure why we're linking to, let alone deferring to, an entertainer like Tom Scott on HN. (Tom Scott's fine, but I would never look to him for technical advice or direction.)
- Dalewyn 4y agoIt seems I never got around to watching this particular video, thanks for linking it! I absolutely agree with Tom Scott's conclusion, Windows will absolutely enable you to do whatever it is you want, regardless how stupid, and most likely without too much low-level jank that most people can't/won't deal with.
- fsckboy 4y agoI haven't watched till the end of it, but he's on and on about bodging rather than computer science, and all I've gotta say is "sounds like he wished he knew how to use linux". Worse is better is not computer science.
- zac23or 4y agoWindows is a very good operating system. Windows haters don't hate for technical reasons, but for religious or political reasons. And I like Microsoft. Microsoft makes some products, that's it. Not experiences, or promises of freedom. They are software products, with problems, qualities, end.
- captainbland 4y agoI think this is sometimes true but that for developers there are very good reasons to not prefer Windows. Mostly that local software management sucks on it unless you go with WSL, which is really good but does still have some limitations (speed, GPU compatibility, etc. - in general having to manage effectively two parallel filesystems gets in the way), and is at the end of the day essentially still Linux. Sure you can use e.g. chocolatey or even cygwin but these are a bit hit and miss at the best of times. Powershell is fine but a bit verbose for day to day terminal use compared to bash or nicer variants like zsh. Also apparently I set up my last dual boot configuration in such a way that Windows 10 decided that it owned my Ubuntu partition, but only during an upgrade which happened several months after the initial installation. This ruined an actively used install. Not exactly an ideal user experience. Ok, at a stretch maybe it was a bit my fault for not learning that the Windows 10 update system was a bit more... Ambitious than previous versions of Windows, but an explicit warning prompt before it happened wouldn't have gone amiss.
- zac23or 4y agoI'm a developer. I use Windows to program in Java, Delphi with SQLServer or SQLite. Git works great on Windows. I use WSL for Ruby, Python, Go with Postgres/Mysql. I don't dual boot Linux because 100% of the time linux automatically destroys the installation. The last time this happened was because I tried a Bluetooth joystick in Kubuntu. Kubuntu freezes and won't boot again. Because this last experience, I will never use Linux again in the metal again. To develop Games, Windows. I've never used SqlServer on Linux, and when I tried to use Postgres on Windows, Postgres start using using 100% of processor, it was a total mess. Resume: My development experience is compartemized, If is possible to use Windows, Ok, if not, I use Linux(WSL or emulated). I have already programmed on Mac OS, using XCode. XCode is an aberration. One of worst software development experience in my life. Ruby or Python development experience(in terminal with vim and a package manager like HomeBrew) is good on Mac OS, after installing a good terminal.
- Bubble_Pop_22 4y agoAll Microsoft products are free of charge if you know where to look for them. Basically you have the big Fortune 500 companies subsidizing pirates who download from TPBay...and of course the pirate CD copies being sold in street markets all over Sub-Saharan Africa. Microsoft with Windows, Azure, Office, Outlook and PowerPoint is the backbone of the economy. Come noon you have already used half a dozen of different flavors of Microsoft and again if you know where to look you tasted them all for free. Analyzing things post-facto the bad reputation that Microsoft had was unwarrented given that we ended up under a much tighter stranghold of Apple in the mobile environment. At least the developing world is saving themselves using Android.
- wing-_-nuts 4y ago>All Microsoft products are free of charge if you know where to look for them. God no. I draw a hard line at pirating executable code. I forget where I read it but a not insignificant percentage of pirated software contains malware, and I don't know about you, but having my bank or brokerage account compromised would cost exponential orders of magnitude more than any software licence. Hell, I'm concerned enough about malware that even window's larger attack surface gives me pause even though I know things have gotten better since I left it. I still feel much more secure on linux.
- Dalewyn 4y ago>I forget where I read it but a not insignificant percentage of pirated software contains malware, That just means you don't know where to look. >having my bank or brokerage account compromised would cost exponential orders of magnitude more than any software licence. I agree. For anything that's important, especially if it's mission-critical or commercial in nature, go the legit way. Handing Microsoft some cash means you're buying legal assurance that something will work safely (FSVO safely) in a way where the chain of liability hopefully doesn't stop at you.
- hota_mazi 4y agoYou're missing his point. Downloading any illegal software can compromise your email and bank accounts and basically ruin your life. It only takes one.
- Arisaka1 4y ago>At the end of the day, Windows is the only desktop OS that enables me to use my computer to do the shit I need or want to do. I feel like this is the kind of dystopian thing everyone just accepted that it's normal. And by that I mean, I expected competition, options, etc. Instead I'm still forced to use Windows for my gaming, GPU's for Linux desktop is still hit or miss, and Apple decided to break up with Intel so on top of everything else I get to "enjoy" package incompatibilities for my work. And now I have to pretend that I'm enjoying that Microsoft keeps deciding to grab "a little bit more" every now and then because I really don't have any other options, besides the "stop playing video games that aren't a pain to setup or even work on Linux".
- wnolens 4y agoThe sysinternals tools make it for me. procexp and procmon are insanely powerful and you can solve really obscure issues really quickly. I'm on mac right now for my current job, and quite often a few of my cores go nuts due to a kernel_task process which I find it impossible to track down the reason why. Pretty sure I could root cause this in 10 minutes with procexp.