20 ms·
American Data Privacy and Protection Act
- jesuspiece 4y ago
- lolinder 4y ago2 out of 3 sponsors are Republican, and not the kind that typically cross the aisle.
- weberer 4y ago>Cosponsors: >Rep. McMorris Rodgers, Cathy [R-WA-5] >Rep. Schakowsky, Janice D. [D-IL-9] >Rep. Bilirakis, Gus M. [R-FL-12]
- MerelyMortal 4y agoMaybe politics would be better if people didn't jump to stereotypes (which don't always hold true, as evidenced by your comment and the replies pointing out your error), and instead of blaming/attacking each other, we could focus more efforts on making things better.
- rabuse 4y ago"It's a big club, and you ain't in it" - George Carlin
- ck2 4y agoJust a reminder any email you have online that is over six months old can be read without a warrant.
- pacija 4y agoHm, I have 10 years worth of emails in my dovecot, on my metal, in my basement, online. Can you please describe how can it be read without a warrant by people who don't have my imap password or wheel ssh key to my server?
- criddell 4y agoDo you ever send email to other servers? If so, there are copies out there.
- ck2 4y agoWell that's the "proper" version of the clinton email server in the basement. But I meant the major services all must give access to virtually any federal government entity on request, warrantless. I think they even have portals, imagine how that is abused by anyone and everyone. Not sure how it would be enforced but I would guess if the feds wanted access to your server, even without a warrant, you'd be forced to give it to them. https://www.wired.com/2010/04/emailprivacy/ https://www.wired.com/2010/04/emailprivacy/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_Communications_Privacy_Act#Criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_Communications_Priv...
- pessimizer 4y agoCan you describe how it could be read with a warrant, or how it's relevant at all to people who have email accounts with online services?
- unionpivo 4y agoUnless you are just emailing yourself on your server, chances are that 80% of your email is searchable between Google, Microsoft or Amazon. I just checked on my mail (look at headers, for smtp hosts not just senders and receivers). For me its 76% for the past 7 years, that either originated or ended in one of the big three silos.
- youainti 4y agoAny source for this?
- yrgulation 4y agoWill you guys get to click popups on every.single.site.? If so believe it’s annoying. There must be a better way.
- chronotis 4y agoTen years or so ago, I was participating in a small business roundtable discussion with one of our state senators. At the time, I ran a consumer research agency and would often have multinational projects involving consumer data collection in both the US and EU; this is before GDPR had become ratified, but Safe Harbor was failing and there was ambiguity about what the future state would look like. Of the 15 or 20 business owners in the room, I was the only "pro privacy" voice. People were very focused on what would be the perceived additional cost of complying with any GDPR-style rules in the US, and weren't yet thinking about the negative effects of having different privacy rules in different markets. "Different markets have different rules all the time," in short. I maintain that it would be less complicated, less expensive, and more human-friendly to use data privacy rules as globally universal as can be achieved. There will always be capitalism leeches that drain money through arbitrage between the policy gaps, yes, but it would help. (Also: there is zero chance this gets through the current US Senate. Would never clear filibuster.)
- rt4mn 4y agoI would be interested to hear why you think it has no chance in Senate.
- pessimizer 4y ago> Would never clear filibuster. A filibuster by who? Neither party would support any privacy rules that placed any undue importance on privacy.
- chronotis 4y agoI'm mostly just projecting based on the current 48+2+50 state of the Senate where virtually everything gets held up. If the Democrats brought it forward, I would expect the Republicans to filibuster just on principle.
- KerrAvon 4y agoSlight historical aside here: for those too young to have been politically aware before the Obama era, the filibuster (a) is in the modern form a relatively recent invention (b) was rarely used prior to the Mitch McConnell era. McConnell and the Fox News generation of the Republican Party turned what was meant to be a tool for a last-resort veto into a sledgehammer continuously used to bludgeon the other side.
- cyral 4y agoI see they are also annoyed at cookie banners: > SEC. 210. UNIFIED OPT-OUT MECHANISMS. For the rights established under sections 204(b) and (c), and section 206(c)(3)(D) not later than 18 months after the date of enactment of this Act, the Commission shall establish one or more acceptable privacy protective, centralized mechanisms, including global privacy signals such as browser or device privacy settings, for individuals to exercise all such rights through a single interface for a covered entity to utilize to allow an individual to make such opt out designations with respect to covered data related to such individual.
- Spivak 4y agohalle-fuckin-lujah please don't make it some bullshit centralized service where you have to have a specific cookie from a random website to actually use it. please just expand DNT.
- user3939382 4y agoIn the sick world we live in, ad companies would love a more granular DNT response from your browser so they can use it to fingerprint you.
- bdougherty 4y agoMore likely it will be GPC (https://globalprivacycontrol.org https://globalprivacycontrol.org).
- shishy 4y agoWas scanning for this thanks for pointing it out. Some of these banners are infuriating, and if I use firefox containers sometimes I see them over and over, especially if I'm clearing my cookies. It is insane to me that this isn't already a standard.
- shadowgovt 4y agoStandardization was attempted. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Do_Not_Track https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Do_Not_Track the tl;dr for that story is that it wasn't mandated to be honored, the industry didn't voluntarily adopt it widely, and when IE 10 tried to turn it on by default and the standard's lead supporter responded by submitting a patch to Apache web server to ignore the DNT signal coming from IE 10 because "does not protect anyone's privacy unless the recipients believe it was set by a real human being, with a real preference for privacy over personalization," that situation pretty much killed it in the crib. The problem is technologically simple to solve; all the challenges are social and legal.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hatware 4y ago
- macintux 4y agoCan you expand on what you feel is wrong with the bill?
- hatware 4y agoFeel free to read up on the last 20 years of US politics. Same shit, different day.
- macintux 4y agoThe point of HN is not to make winking, snide comments about how things are broken, but to actually discuss/document what’s good or bad. You’re not adding any value without diving into details.
- hatware 4y agoAnd you're not adding any value by staying ignorant to history. It's not my job to spoon-feed you the problems and solutions.
- dekken_ 4y agoAlways? Unlikely, can be sure, but I doubt it's always.
- lmkg 4y agoFor those following along at home: So far five states have passed local Data Privacy laws (CA, VA, UT, CT, MA). They are all different. This situation makes it much more likely that federal data privacy legislation will happen: while companies wish they could have 0 laws, they would still much rather prefer 1 law rather than 5 (trending towards 50) different laws that contradict each other. There's a whole buncha specifics about what data is covered and what companies are covered and bleh blah bluh. That's not the most important thing. There are two things which are more important than that. These two issues also happen to be the topics most hotly debated between Dems & Repubs. 1. Private Right of Action, aka "Can I, a private citizen, sue someone?" Everyone violates GDPR a dozen ways to Sunday, and nothing happens. Why? Because no one can actually enforce the law except for the local regulators who are underfunded. By contrast, the ADA lets anyone sue over violations, and as a result companies care a lot about handicap accessibility. To my understanding the current negotiations are trending towards a limited Private Right of Action. Meaning it will exist for some violations but not others. This is how CCPA works in California right now: private citizens can sue over data breaches, but any other violation can only be enforced by the Office of the Attorney General. 2. Pre-emption, aka "Does this repeal CCPA." Can states give additional protections to their residents, or is the Federal government removing the ability of states to define additional requirements for businesses. Again, the current state of negotiations seems to trend towards partial, but not total, pre-emption.
- encryptluks2 4y agoPartial preemption leads to supreme court decisions that lead to near total preemption.
- tomatotomato37 4y agoOnly if it's not a highly contentious issue. Otherwise the bigger states just go "We control X amount of the American population/economy, and thus we are going to enforce our own law anyway" Granted they would be in the wrong since this is clearly and unambiguously interstate commerce, but that hasn't stopped them before
- prego_xo 4y ago> (B) any time beyond the initial 2 times described in subparagraph (A), may allow the individual to exercise such right for a reasonable fee for each request. Paying any sum of money to receive a copy of or request to delete my private data is unreasonable in nature.
- drstewart 4y agoThis is normal: https://www.techrepublic.com/article/how-to-request-your-personal-data-under-gdpr/ https://www.techrepublic.com/article/how-to-request-your-per... >Although, the ICO also notes that a firm may charge a “reasonable fee” when “a request is manifestly unfounded or excessive, particularly if it is repetitive.” Privacy request shouldn't enable mechanisms of denial of service type attacks against companies.
- ortusdux 4y agoThe problem is, "reasonable" is subjective. Things like this need to be tethered to something. "The fee may not exceed 50% of the hourly federal minimum wage."
- bin_bash 4y agoThat’s just not true. “Reasonable” is a binding term used in contracts all of the time. The court system is extremely experienced in determining what is and is not reasonable.
- QuarterReptile 4y agoMuch like passing a bill to find out what's in it, going to court to discover the rules is not a healthy way for society to run.
- bin_bash 4y agoGoing to court to discover the rules is precisely how common law systems work
- encryptluks2 4y agoLol.. gotta love when they propose acts before even understanding technology. Things like this need to be collectively written by some of the best privacy advocates. Not a bunch of interns that have no clue how technology works.
- lolinder 4y agoIf there's a piece of the bill that illustrates your objection, please do share. As is this feels like a canned response based on a stereotype, not a substantial objection.
- rt4mn 4y agoAlways good to see links to direct text of bills. Reading the tea leaves a bit, Speaker Pelosi seems dead set against it and I dont think will allow it to be moved as is. she has publicly stated that "states must be allowed to address rapid changes in technology", IE, the bill preempts to many state privacy regulations, esp in California. But as a rule my default assumption for the "real reason" why Pelosi is against something is because she thinks it will harm chance of caucus holding majority in house. https://pelosi.house.gov/news/press-releases/pelosi-statement-on-federal-data-privacy-legislation https://pelosi.house.gov/news/press-releases/pelosi-statemen... Skeptical as I am of her motives / methods, I'm inclined to agree with her in this case. Act should be a floor not a ceiling.
- donjorgenson 4y agoGiggety
- gigel82 4y agoCan't read legalese much, and -judging by how these things tend to go- I bet it's butchered beyond recognition before it gets to a vote (if at all). Instead, we should consider a constitutional amendment that enshrines digital privacy as a fundamental human right.
- lolinder 4y agoWhy would a constitutional amendment be less prone to getting butchered beyond all recognition? An amendment may not have its text butchered, but there's no guarantee at all that it will be interpreted the way you hope.
- seanw444 4y agoIt probably will be interpreted in all the wrong ways you can't even anticipate. All you need for an example is 2A.
- micromacrofoot 4y agowe don't even have food and shelter as a human right
- carom 4y agoWe do have food in a sense. I began cooking for the homeless and quickly learned they all had EBT cards and didn't want my bland cooking.
- micromacrofoot 4y agothe comment I was responding to was specifically referencing rights as outlined by the constitution
- matai_kolila 4y agoFor any enterprising young legal authors, I'm sure a "rewritten for laypeople" paragraph-by-paragraph blog post would garner a large volume of views and impressions to your site...
- Kalanos 4y agoanyone know the gist of what tech companies will have to do in order to be compliant?
- xbar 4y agoLess than they do now. This washes away CCPA protections that are already nationalized-by-default.
- borbulon 4y agoIf we can let lobbyists write bills, we should be able to let privacy advocates write bills. We can do better than this.
- weberer 4y agoPrivacy advocates such as the ACLU and EFF do have lobbyists as well.
- guerrilla 4y agobut not tens of billions of dollars between them.
- jedberg 4y agoYou can help them if you want! :) https://supporters.eff.org/donate/ https://supporters.eff.org/donate/
- rt4mn 4y agoThe ACLU also does a lot of great privacy work, so donating to them is also a good idea if you care about this stuff. National ACLU does a lot of great work, but I personally suggest giving to your local affiliate https://www.aclu.org/about/affiliates https://www.aclu.org/about/affiliates, as they are often the ones who work on local issues that are likely to directly impact you. We do privacy lobbying at the municipal and state level and our local ACLU affiliate has been a huge, huge ally. There are also other great privacy orgs that are not quite as big but are also fantastic in their own ways, like Restore the Fourth (which also has local chapters like shameless plug) rt4mn) Fight for the Future, Demand Progress, Cato, and Privacy International Also, If you want to do more then just donate, you can help the EFF with its lobbying efforts by joining the Electronic Frontier Alliance https://www.eff.org/fight https://www.eff.org/fight We participate, its pretty great.
- SV_BubbleTime 4y ago
- xbar 4y ago2nd rate claptrap of a bill. Just make the CCPA national.
- criddell 4y agoI kind of wish they would just copy the EU rules. Once set of rules for the US and all of Europe would be pretty nice.
- weberer 4y agoYou can also see which companies sent lobbyists to work on this bill. https://www.opensecrets.org/federal-lobbying/bills/summary?cycle=2022&id=hr8152-117 https://www.opensecrets.org/federal-lobbying/bills/summary?c...
- guerrilla 4y agoThat is a lot worse than I imagined. So basically this would be terrible or meaningless for workers/consumers?
- noasaservice 4y agoSo basically, this is a mostly toothless law, that requires small companies to follow to the extreme detriment of the large companies... which already likely do the bare minimum. I'm not sure of the term. It's like a regulatory legal barrier that keeps new companies from entering the market.
- jedberg 4y agoRegulatory capture.
- tomatotomato37 4y agoIt's almost like blindly calling for regulation without accounting for the political/monetary influence of those being regulated is a bad idea or something
- ahtihn 4y ago> blindly calling for regulation [...] is a bad idea What do you expect people to do instead?
- water-your-self 4y agoCall for individual protections, possibly with a solvent soaked rag in a bottle, typically.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- robust-cactus 4y agoNot sure what y'all are complaining about. The amount of privacy work that happens with governments at big tech companies is substantial. The language in this doc seems like a better, less oppressive version of GDPR.
- oaiey 4y agoI find the gdpr is much easier to read than this.
- jdp23 4y agoIt's not clear that ADPPA will move forward. The current version preempts California's CCPA/CPRA legislation, and (big surprise) California doesn't like that. But, that's far from the only issue with it. Here's an update from a couple of weeks ago which discusses some of the problems, as well as potential next steps. https://thenexusofprivacy.net/adppa-new-compromise/ https://thenexusofprivacy.net/adppa-new-compromise/ And, here's EFF's position: " Americans Deserve More Than The Current American Data Privacy Protection Act" https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2022/07/americans-deserve-more-current-american-data-privacy-protection-act https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2022/07/americans-deserve-more...
- nugget 4y agoPreemption would be an enormous mistake. Federal legislation moves at a glacial pace. In a field like privacy, you may only get to pass one substantial bill every 10 or 15 years. Technology moves too quickly for lawmakers at the Federal level to keep up. States can move much faster. Justice Brandeis popularized the phrase that "[the] states are the laboratories of democracy" and digital privacy law is a text book case of an emerging field that will benefit enormously from iterative experimentation at the state level.
- yonaguska 4y agoYep, I personally only want federal pre-emption for restrictions on government. Shall not infringe type stuff.
- rt4mn 4y agoThis is exactly why Microsoft has been throwing money at lobbyists at the state level as well, pushing shitty "consumer privacy bills", both because they don't like strong legal privacy rights at the state level, but also in the hopes of forestalling and kneecapping a strong federal baseline privacy bill. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2020/03/tech-lobbyists-are-pushing-bad-privacy-bills-washington-state-can-and-must-do https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2020/03/tech-lobbyists-are-pus...
- 4y ago
- donatj 4y agoNow if we could just get a bill that actually limited the governments ability to collect data on its citizens. I'm not really worried about targeted ads, I'm worried about targeted assassinations. You talk to people and ask them why they are worried about companies collecting data, and a certain percentage will tell you they don't like that the government could get it with a court order. That'd be a HUGE improvement over the current situation where they don't have to, they just collect it directly.
- micromacrofoot 4y agoA lot of the time they just buy it from data brokers.
- Ragnarork 4y agoYou need both. Companies collecting data on you directly or indirectly is a problem, even if they don't do anything malevolent with it (and some already do). The issue is that eventually they'll be breached, and then that data can end up in the hands of malicious actors that might use it in a way that could harm you (e.g. identity theft, compromising other accounts thanks to peronal info, etc.).
- always2slow 4y agoWhy would they need a court order when they are already just buying the data with zero oversight? The panopticon works like this: fund startups that will create a data treasure trove -> legally buy / access the dataset and add it to xkeyscore.
- candiddevmike 4y agoThis poses an interesting question: if the government mandates a company to collect data, are they exempt from this? What's stopping them from using that data for commerical purposes?
- lmkg 4y agoSection 101 part b "Permissible Purposes," defines when data is allowed to be collected. The sixth such purpose: "To comply with a legal obligation imposed by Federal, Tribal, Local, or State law..." A close reading of the wording implies this only covers requests backed by a law, i.e. it does not cover "polite requests" from a government agency. However that is a theoretic protection, practice could be different.
- greyface- 4y agoSEC. 203. INDIVIDUAL DATA OWNERSHIP AND CONTROL. (e) Verification And Exceptions.— (1) REQUIRED EXCEPTIONS.—A covered entity shall not permit an individual to exercise a right described in subsection (a), in whole or in part, if the covered entity— (C) determines that the exercise of the right would require access to or correction of another individual’s sensitive covered data; or Simple: store all your user data in an intermingled fashion, such that a read or update of any individual record necessarily involves a read or update of one or more unrelated records. Now you don't need to act on data access requests.
- tempie_deleteme 4y agobecause of the "war on drugs" was supposed to be about the health of americans, which turned out to be a lie... I think this is not about protecting the rights to data and privacy of american indivudal citizens...the other kind of american citizen, the american corporation, on the other hand, stands to gain a lot from this. > To provide consumers with foundational data privacy rights, create strong oversight mechanisms, and establish meaningful enforcement. ah, so corporations can well-foundedly and meaningfully consume the data of 'consumers' (an euphenism for fuel) in a way such that the historic shadow suckers of everything's energy (banks) can continue to partake on the sucking down of everybody's data/information (with real time measurements, which is a novelty in this ancient system build around trade, commerce, insurance, and power-authority concentration).
- jawadch93 4y ago[dead]
- justinzollars 4y agoWorst administration in History.
- rt4mn 4y agoThe Biden Administration? This is a bill introduced in an entirly different branch of government. AFAIK Bidens got squat to do with this
- macns 4y agoMaybe I'm too romantic, but I'd like to see an american GDPR (not saying that the eu name or the bill itself is better), and then an Asian and so on till we have one global GDPR protecting all consumer data. </daydream>
- ThomPete 4y agoGDPR is a horrible horrible solution and only helps the big corporations who can afford all the extra work to ensure that users who actually end up agreeing to the terms are locked in. It helps no one besides politicians who now have create more work for them selves, and is an abomination just like the cookie policy.
- belkarx 4y agoThe effort put in is commendable but this doesn't yet reach the levels of GDPR and the US market is too large for it to be likely to pass. Maybe eventually ...
- dcow 4y agoOne of the logistical issues with a law like this, and with the CCPA, is verification of the user requesting things such as account deletion. How are people supposed to do that without providing KYC-level details to every service provider?
- billiam 4y agoThe ADPPA seems like a great example of regulatory capture and gridlock of the federal government by rich corporations and individuals and how federalism (state's rights) is a crucial and increasingly fragile element in holding our economy and our society together. Privacy is a particularly fraught area. SCOTUS says it's not a constitutional right at all (unless it's your money, in which case it's speech), which means states will have to define not data privacy and the limits of the surveillance economy but abortion and marriage and contraception too.
- jjtheblunt 4y ago( typo : i think you meant "not only data privacy..." )
- say_it_as_it_is 4y agoThis is the proverbial shaking of the tree, whereby elected officials will ask (threaten) tech lobbyists for campaign contributions in exchange for their vote against the act
- pessimizer 4y agoIt's also potentially a huge score for some Democratic politicians, because for every Republican that supports the bill, they're going to need a Democrat to defect.
- kornhole 4y agoThe corporate captured government will only protect their privacy and profits. The quicker people realize this, the better.
- unknownaccount 4y agoWhy on earth would we want MORE restrictions and government interference / intrusion in our affairs? Especially in this era of worldwide creeping authoritarianism? The only way implement these sorts of mandates is stomping all over a developer's right to freedom of expression. I'm a firm believer that code is speech and that limiting what a developer can do is infringing on his own right to free speech.
- asow92 4y agoCould they have picked a better sounding acronym? Maybe APPA (American Privacy and Protection Act)?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]