7 ms·
Parallel Economy: Censor-Resistant Payment Processing
- mchusma 4y agoI don't get it, seems like it is still using visa/MasterCard? Aren't they the ones at the root of most issues?
- yonaguska 4y agoIt at least bypasses Paypal and Venmo, recently in the news for banning Gays Against Groomers.
- ticviking 4y agoThere's a pretty wide range of issues that Stripe/Paypal won't take payments for but Visa/MasterCard will. It may turn out to be a marketing gimmick but it seems to me like there's a niche for a high risk payment processor that focuses on the perceived risk of being "cancelled" as the risk they help manage. How they'll deal with all the other issues a high-risk processor has to handle is something I'm curious about.
- pjkundert 4y agoGreat work! If you could implement a payment flow where payouts could be made in Crypto, that would be awesome. It is very difficult getting paid for my software, and I’m just a little software developer in Canada. I don’t understand how you manage to maintain merchant accounts with the credit card vendors. It seems likely that they’ll shut you down, as soon as someone tries to fund a peaceful protest that goes against the elite’s allowed belief matrix (like the Canadian Trucker’s Convoy)?
- Comevius 4y agoThe Canada convoy protest was peaceful, except for the bribery, threats, assault, dangerous driving and setting a building on fire. That and the $6 billion economic loss, or the fact that nobody wanted them there, or that the protesters were protesting the COVID-19 vaccination mandate. And if that's not enough the whole thing was funded from the United States by Donald Trump donors and an American billionaire called Thomas Sieber.
- gruez 4y ago>was peaceful, except for the bribery, threats, assault, dangerous driving and setting a building on fire. That and the $6 billion economic loss, or the fact that nobody wanted them there Many of these points applies to BLM protests. Should those organizers be booted from the financial system as well? >or the fact that nobody wanted them there, or that the protesters were protesting the COVID-19 vaccination mandate should this be a factor in determining the acceptability of a protest? Can you do it in a principled way that doesn't simply boil down to "if it's for a Just Cause then you can do whatever you want"? Finally, what does this mean for past movements which were also super unpopular? LGBT rights protests come to mind.
- wedn3sday 4y agoYes. However much I support the ideals behind any given movement, I strongly believe that after you cross a critical threshold, let us call it the "setting things on fire line" you should stop being able to get paid through the banking system.
- namelessoracle 4y agoI very much doubt you would support everyone participating in the BLM riots last summer be removed from having a bank account.
- bee_rider 4y agoWell, we have no way of verifying this, so I guess we'll have to make an argument based on something other than "but whatabout BLM?"
- blisterpeanuts 4y agoTwo men tried to set an apartment building on fire. They were apprehended, and were confirmed by the police as unaffiliated with the truckers convoy.
- 4y ago
- rfwhyte 4y agoThe "Freedumb" Convoy "Protest" had Nazis in it, therefore it was a Nazi "Protest." The second they didn't kick out the dudes waving Nazi flags they lost any credibility they claimed to have. And for the record the Freedumb Convoy was reviled by VAST majority of Canadians who saw it as the Nazi-enabling, grift-funded, reality-denying, anti-rational cesspool it truly was.
- hirundo 4y agoThat's a good company name. The broader the cancellations, the broader the emerging parallel economy. Every case of a corporation refusing a customer is an opportunity for another to accept. In a relatively free market you don't extinguish a sector by dividing it; that just generates targetted support. Media is dividing along partisan lines and apparently payment processing is too. What else? How broad will the parallelism will become? Companies like PayPal may incubate potential competitors in this way. PayPal is somewhat handicapping itself by accepting a smaller market, as if they had decided to cancel a particular race if that were legal.
- Comevius 4y agoThese alternatives are not very popular, and once they try to scale they face the same problems their popular brethren does. PayPal sucks, but it's also somewhat works for half a billion people.
- wedn3sday 4y agoOn the flip side, every time I hear about some right wing nut getting deplatformed by paypal, I think to myself, "hey their service isnt as bad as I thought." Virtue signaling might bring them more business then they lose by tossing out a small number of fringe wackos.
- moojd 4y agoFrom your comments throughout this thread it seems as though you are either confident that your personal convictions will remain within the overton window in perpetuity or you lack the ability to imagine that one day they may not. Not to mention some of your convictions may have been outside the overton window in recent history. In a world where cash can be refused by businesses and governments can ban physical interaction, the ability to conduct digital commerce (and speech) must not be frustrated regardless of its general unsavoriness. The fact that we as a society have allowed a small cabal of payment processors to collude on who is allowed to conduct online commerce is a tragedy.
- blisterpeanuts 4y agoSomething in those words reminds me of what some people were saying in early 1930s Nazi Germany: "Serves them right. Goddamn Jews." "First they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out—because I was not a socialist. Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out—because I was not a trade unionist. Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—because I was not a Jew. Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me." —Martin Niemöller https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/martin-niemoeller-first-they-came-for-the-socialists https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/martin-nie...
- shakezula 4y ago> Cancel culture will not win But what are they doing to actually prevent censorship? This feels like an excuse to capitalize on the politically charged term of “cancel culture”. My grift alert is blaring.
- canistista 4y agountil someone does a p2p btc/eth service this isn't happening.
- pessimizer 4y ago> But what are they doing to actually prevent censorship? Payment processing. edit: I have to say that I'm finding the replies unintelligible. The largest payment processors are banning organizations from receiving payments. This organization claims that they will not do that. Would that destroy censorship in the world, or keep Visa and Mastercard from banning people (or banning Parallel Economy themselves?) No. Does it stop censorship at your local high school paper? Also no.
- penultimatename 4y agoThey never explained how they'll process payments when VISA cuts them off.
- shakezula 4y agoBut… that doesn’t prevent censorship when it’s still reliant on the same core payment processors. As best as I can tell this is basically security through obscurity.
- blisterpeanuts 4y agoIsn't Parallel Economy basically positioning itself as an alternative to Paypal? Not a "full stack" solution, at least not yet, but nonetheless a workaround if Paypal locks you out.
- woodruffw 4y ago
- catapart 4y agoNice pivot. I look forward to this "economy" stabilizing in the same way that Truth Social or Parler did - at about a tenth of the scale of their competition. Happy to let the pill-sellers and woke-fearers spend their money in their own little walled garden, well away from where I every have to hear about it (or be advertised to).
- wedn3sday 4y agoYa, this is pretty much how I felt about the whole Ivermectin thing. Who am I to tell someone not to take horse de-wormer, when I also advocate for the freedom to take psychedelics? If someone _really_ wants to make sure they dont have horse heart worms, I dont see how they're hurting anyone else (besides being a disease vector, but thats not going to get worse).
- catapart 4y agoSame. It's dangerous to tell people that it does stuff that it doesn't do (more dangerous as an audience grows to the point that anecdotal data should be left out entirely, for audiences of an appropriate size), but as long as you're just doing you, have at it. But then, I'm that way about pretty much everything, including rat poison. Do what you're gonna do to yourself, just don't make it other people's problem (note that suicide is almost universally going to be someone else's problem, so that's not an endorsement of taking rat poison).
- blisterpeanuts 4y agoIn addition to veterinary applications in horses, Ivermectin is approved for human use and is a powerful anti-viral that is effective against "wide range of RNA and DNA viruses, for example, dengue, Zika, yellow fever, and others"[1]. There is, to date, no evidence that it is effective as a treatment for the Covid-19 variants. However, it's certainly harmful to post in a public forum that it's just "horse de-wormer", which could lead patients to reject approved treatment for these other diseases. 1. https://www.drugs.com/ivermectin.html https://www.drugs.com/ivermectin.html
- pessimizer 4y ago
- lottin 4y ago"Tech tyrants and authoritarians want to dictate speech — and commerce." Really?
- catapart 4y agoWhen fear-stoking is on the main page instead of technical details or documentation, it's obvious what they're selling isn't a technical service.
- pessimizer 4y agoWhat you editorialize as "fear-stoking," fearful people might characterize as "fear-recognizing."
- ameister14 4y agoI think recognizing that someone has a fear is very different from affirming that the fear is justified. They are doing the latter.
- pessimizer 4y agoThat depends on whether Paypal or other major payment processors are dropping people for their political or social opinions. If they're not, the fear of people who share those political or social opinions of having their payments cut off is not justified. If they are, the fear of people who share those political or social opinions is justified. Are they? Is it?
- catapart 4y agoMaybe, but my editorializing is not relevant to the point? Whatever you call it, they're selling THAT, rather than technical services. But, to be blunt: that site is not "recognizing" anything. As ameister14 pointed out - they are offering affirmation.
- pessimizer 4y agoSubmitted this, never heard of it before today. My big question is whether they'll accept Trans Communists With Guns Anti-TERF Squad, LLC as customers, or if it's a stunt.
- coenhyde 4y agoI don't understand what they do to prevent the things they rant about. It's like the drunk uncle payment processor. Sure there are legitimate grievances to address with the current state of freedom of speech etc, but it is clear the owners are into far right conspiracies.
- junaru 4y agoWell if i understand correctly those are the people that got denied service in the first place. So since having a truly neutral payment processor is not an option having an alternative at the opposite side only brings more 'freedom' to the market.
- unmole 4y ago> drunk uncle payment processor I laughed out loud. I'm stealing this.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- woodruffw 4y agoThis sets of my grift alarms: there's no virtually no explanation of what makes it "censorship-resistant," but lots of heavy-handed references to authoritarianism, etc. There continues to be good money in playing the middleman, I suppose.
- pessimizer 4y ago> there's no virtually no explanation of what makes it "censorship-resistant," As far as I can tell, what is meant to make them censorship-resistant is that they claim they will not drop customers based on pressure from censors. They're selling that resistance to censors as "censorship-resistance."
- woodruffw 4y agoAh, the Oat Milk of censorship resistance :-)
- pessimizer 4y agoIn the way that oat milk is milk made from oats.
- woodruffw 4y agoYes, and in the way the "censorship resistance" here is predicated on only the faintest family resemblance to censorship.
- pessimizer 4y agoIf removing an organization's ability to accept and send payments due to their entirely legal messaging isn't censorship, I'd like to see what is. If this organization is on the level, it would be a godsend for Palestinian or Yemeni charity organizations, who are constantly getting their payments screwed with and their accounts closed. Palestinians are cancel culture victim #1, and the only reason anyone has ever heard of Bari Weiss is that she was a college campus cancel culture warrior.
- issa 4y agoI don't know if they are trying to grab porn money while pretending to grab right-wing money or something else is going on. But I do know that there is nothing on their site that implies they do anything NEW or DIFFERENT. So not sure how they plan to get around visa/mastercard banning them.
- zeroclip 4y agoThis sounds like a scam. If you really want censorship resistant payment processing you should not use some central custodial service extracting an obscene rent. By comparison, Ethereum is highly censorship resistant and its fees are relatively low right now, about 30¢ to transfer ETH and have it settle in ~30 seconds[1]. [1] https://etherscan.io/gastracker https://etherscan.io/gastracker
- ggambetta 4y agoIt says "15¢" first, and ".15 cents" later... lack of attention to details doesn't exactly inspire confidence :/
- the_optimist 4y agoPeople here asking for disclosure: There’s no cryptographic assurance here, and you’re asking them to publicize their threat matrix. The threat matrix to individuals in typical corporate payment processor is guerilla and political. 1) groups like “Sleeping Giants” raising an unknowable mix of outrage pitchforks and bots, corporates foreclose and deplatform, 2) rules like “Op Chokepoint” wherein payment processors cut based on regulatory suasion from behind administrative veils. This group says they’re aware of these threats and will abide by the laws while at least not admitting guerrilla attacks.
- cronix 4y agoI believe this is Dan Bongino's company (or he's heavily involved). IIRC he started it when Parler was booted off of Apple/Amazon, removing their income.
- woodruffw 4y agoThere's something particularly on the nose about a former-cop-turned-political operative handwringing about authoritarianism.
- bee_rider 4y agoWhen a company's raison d'etre is mostly political, it makes me wonder if they are substituting a political stance in the place of technical competency. Payment processing seems like a high competency requirement field, from the outside at least.
- wedn3sday 4y agoI suspect that 95% of their business will be from dodgy porn sites, or "we build the wall" type right wing scams.
- etaioinshrdlu 4y agoIn other news, I had trouble finding a crypto payments processor for my small business. Coinbase commerce and OpenNode required so much documentation that it might take me days to assemble to required documents, and BitPay has my account stuck on verification for weeks. Any recommendations? I would love to accept crypto payments but cannot believe how hard it is to onboard a processor.
- zie 4y agoYou should try getting a bank to become your credit card processor, the Crypto stuff will seem like child's play.
- imtringued 4y agoI literally don't know anything about this topic and the only reason why I know it exists is because I once looked for an example of crypto payment accepting merchants is that I went on serverhunt but, uh, have you tried Coingate?
- yodude2 4y ago[flagged]
- trinsic2 4y agoNo information on who the founders are and what their history is. I will never trust any institution that hides behind a business name when it comes to improving society. People behind the scenes need to be known and be held accountable to their creations.
- rfwhyte 4y agoThis, so very much this. I flat out refuse to do business with any company or organization who hides who is profiting from the money I spend.
- immigrantheart 4y agoTell me how you support censorship without telling me you support censorship > We facilitate voluntary exchange between consenting adults and it is that exchange which promotes peace and prosperity. who decides what peace and prosperity is?