19 ms·
Who cares about diversity?
- HereIGoAgain 4y agoWell yeah, anyone with a functioning brain knew this for a long time.
- known 4y ago
- pwinnski 4y agoIt could be that the people do care about the values listed, but don't know an effective way to guarantee them, and that existing diversity statements are a stopgap measure until something better is figured out. But no, let's jump directly to "Conclusion: By and large, they don’t care about diversity. They’re just lying, in a really transparent way, because they think it gives them a patina of legal legitimacy." Or... perhaps don't ascribe to malice that which may be adequately explained by incompetence.
- hinkley 4y agoNever ascribe to incompetence that which can be adequately explained by apathy. I’ve seen it in myself and can only speculate about others, but sometimes I’ll leave a meeting completely unconvinced by an argument and come in the next day singing a different tune. People like the echo chamber because it’s comfortable. But comfortable doesn’t lead to growth.
- 300bps 4y agoThe original article went into an in-depth analysis that you label as “jump directly to…”
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- polygamous_bat 4y agoAn in depth analysis can still miss possible logical conclusions. I don't think the GP is saying they skipped possible analysis, just that they fail to consider alternatives.
- phantom_of_cato 4y ago> Or... perhaps don't ascribe to malice that which may be adequately explained by incompetence. Hanlon's razor is a heuristic which doesn't work very well in this case. Clearly, there is a lot of social pressure to at least pretend to care about diversity, so by default you'd expect at least some people to lie about it.
- duxup 4y agoI agree, the idea that they don't care and go to all this work seems absurd. Seems more likely they're just bad advocates / come up with bad policies for ideas they like. THAT does not surprise me the least. The amount of "If you get what you want here, I don't think that gets you any closer to your goal, in fact it might do the opposite." situations is pretty high out there.
- brightball 4y agoI've really wondered how much ESG scores affect how much companies "care" about this sort of thing.
- ectopod 4y agoUniversity bureaucrats have spent decades creating new kinds of work for themselves. It is an end in itself. They don't need to care.
- origin_path 4y ago[flagged]
- rootusrootus 4y ago[flagged]
- bavell 4y ago> It has been right wing dogma for quite a long time that education is bad You're confusing being educated with being elitist. Being elitist is what the right thinks is bad, not education.
- origin_path 4y agoIt's been falling steadily over time. Left wing bias in universities was far less extreme in the 60s. Given the prevalence of articles by conservatives saying they were kicked out for ideological reasons, and that this article is about the practice of forcing applicants to write a loyalty pledge to leftist dogma, it is safe to assume that this decline was largely a deliberate takeover by people who devoted themselves to excluding others over a long period of many decades.
- stuckinhell 4y agoI vouched for this because I think it's fairly reasonable. I think american and european universities were at the forefront of all the diversity and "woke", a decade earlier.
- jltsiren 4y ago
- 01D 4y ago
- kbuchanan 4y agoHe argued that if universities cared about diversity their positions on affirmative action would be more dynamic than is commonly accepted. e.g.: > Affirmative action would also apply more strongly to, say, immigrants from Iran, or Korea, or Israel, than to black people (or anyone else) from our own society. The examples he uses demonstrate that, in his mind, caring about diversity requires measuring circumstance. You might argue that universities are not so shallow as he's claiming, but I don't believe the article is mere mudslinging.
- mcphage 4y ago> their positions on affirmative action would be more dynamic than is commonly accepted People are already trying to get affirmative action programs dismantled. Making them more complicated would lead to larger surface area, and be easier to attack. > I don't believe the article is mere mudslinging. The entire argument of the article is that they don't measure diversity the same way he wants them to measure diversity, and therefore they don't care about it. It never considers that schools consider it differently, or whether his method is consistent, or whether what he proposes has been considered and dismissed.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- duxup 4y agoHow wide spread is this requirement? I've never heard about it before. >schools are requiring “Diversity Statements” as a condition for new hires Is this like when you do a self performance review and you just throw in a bunch of common phrases / text?
- guhidalg 4y agoYes. A previous boss of mine that I liked once asked me to just add some boilerplate phrases to my performance review to make sure he and I were both aligned with the corporate diversity mandates. Did I change the way I acted simply by adding this text? Nope!
- thelittlenag 4y agoMy wife just started a tenure track job in the sciences. This was the very first thing she had to provide in nearly every application.
- tokinonagare 4y agoI've seen it for a university position in Sweden. It has a self-criticism and cult like feel that I really don't like. Position in universities should be considered on scientific and educational grounds, not political.
- kyorochan 4y agoWhich university was this?
- onos 4y agoI can’t answer on stats, would also like to know. I’ve read Berkeley requires these for all faculty openings and promotions. Also below is a particularly egregious example from Canada, where it explicitly states white straight men need not apply. https://www.universityaffairs.ca/search-job/?job_id=58317 https://www.universityaffairs.ca/search-job/?job_id=58317
- whyoh 4y ago
- HideousKojima 4y agoI certainly don't, at least not in the way that modern society seems to be pushing for it. A year or two ago a high school was putting on a production of The Hunchback of Notre Dame, and there was a loud minority of students complaining because a white girl was cast as Esmeralda. In the original book, Esmeralda is ethnically French, but Gypsies steal her as an infant and replace her with Quasimodo. Many years later, Esmeralda's mother sees her and rants at her, thinking she is one of the gypsies she hates for stealing her daughter. She hates her own daughter, her own flesh and blood, because of interethnic hatred. The implication of this, and the impact of people like the students complaining because a white girl was cast in the role, are left as an exercise to the reader. Edit: News article about the high school production https://www.bet.com/article/mq8775/school-cancels-musical-after-backlash-for-lack-of-diversity https://www.bet.com/article/mq8775/school-cancels-musical-af...
- _312m 4y ago> In the original book, Esmeralda is ethnically French I mean, I just think that no one seems to be aware of this. She's not French in the movie adaptation, which is what most of those kids would be familiar with. (And the musical does heavily draw from the movie – including leaving out her meeting her mother). Without the added context of the original book's description, since it seems no one was aware of it, do you think the uproar was justified? On the other hand, there are examples of the musical performed with a caucasian lead: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a5wNynK1tHg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a5wNynK1tHg
- HideousKojima 4y ago>Without the added context of the original book's description, since it seems no one was aware of it, do you think the uproar was justified? No, I don't think willful ignorance justifies cancel culture.
- _312m 4y ago> willful ignorance I think it's just plain old fashioned ignorance, right? Dunno, to me this just looks like kids who were excited to see a musical starring someone who looked like them for once, and were understandably upset when that didn't happen. Looks like the students were targeted by alt-right publications for that, too: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/08/theater/hunchback-of-notre-dame-ithaca-high-school.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/08/theater/hunchback-of-notr...
- Negitivefrags 4y ago
- Kye 4y agoAlternate perspective: it will be flagged down because HN's community has continually proven incapable of having discussions like this without it turning into a shouting match. It's already happening.
- Sir_Liigmaz 4y agoI don't think that should be as big of a deal as it is. I'm guessing it's because it's bad for publicity/ads but the whole "people are mad at each other in the comments! Shut it down!" thing that has taken over is dumb. Have you ever seen how mad people get at each other on the road? Yeah, people suck when they don't have a face in front of them to remind them its a person on the other side. It's disingenuous to pretend that side of people doesn't exist though.
- throwaway0a5e 4y agoIt's worse when you have a person to attribute it to. A bad driver could be a senile old man. A dumb comment could be from some edgy teenager or $0.50 shill. A functional adult who should know better behaving that way is hard to have sympathy for.
- phantom_of_cato 4y ago> because HN's community has continually proven incapable of having discussions like this without it turning into a shouting match Maybe, but that itself (just like downvote brigading) is a technique used to suppress discussion. Become so "outraged" when others simply state their opinion to make normal discussion impossible. That is an area in which I don't think HN moderation does a good job. They blame people who merely state a controversial opinion for "initiating a flamewar" instead of standing firm against the angry mob and putting emphasis on the importance of keeping a high standard for discussion. Simply being outraged is quite diagonal to curiosity, the core value of HN.
- qaq 4y agoGoing on a tangent I am tired of diversity theater at most companies. You know how I know you don't really care? I look at your C level (excluding Chief Diversity Officer) and you board.
- sokoloff 4y agoYears and breadth/depth of experience is far from everything, but it's also far from nothing. I'd sort of expect the CxOs at most major companies to be ~25-40 years into their career. I'd therefore expect them to look a lot like the white collar workforce new entrants looked in 1982-1997.
- qaq 4y agoAre you for real largest SV companies can't find a single "diverse" board member or C level but spend 100s of millions evangelizing how they care about diversity and on employee diversity training?
- sokoloff 4y agoIs the hiring task SELECT TOP 1 * FROM Candidates WHERE DIVERSE = 1 ORDER BY Candidate_Value_All_Things_Considered DESC or SELECT TOP 1 * FROM Candidates ORDER BY Candidate_Value_All_Things_Considered DESC There could be valid reasons to employ either strategy, but I suspect most firms are trying to apply the second and your disbelief that the first query returns zero rows is more a mismatch with the firms' hiring strategy than anything else.
- ltbarcly3 4y agoI just saw this post reach about #4 on the frontpage, get flagged, marked DEAD, then come back but no longer on the frontpage, all in about 2 minutes.
- ltbarcly3 4y agoI'm just reloading this, it was flagged then dead 2 more times since I posted the above.
- actually_a_dog 4y agoYeah, I flagged it (which killed it) in anticipation of the shit storm I expect to see in the comments an hour or 2 from now.
- shaftoe 4y ago
- actually_a_dog 4y ago
- odiroot 4y agoThe medium is the message.
- ltbarcly3 4y agoThe tribalism, it hurts. People are up-voting and down-voting this, which is just an observation about what happened when this was posted. Amazing!
- jjmorrison 4y ago
- ElCheapo 4y agoI think these institutions believe that more diversity ----> more inclusivity and less racism. How would a racist indian national deeply entrenched in caste culture help my company be less racist? How would an asian supremacist laotian increase the workplace's acceptance? If you want a place of tolerance then it should be populated by tolerant people. Throwing together males and females with a random sample of skin colors and passports is not going to make your university a more inclusive place by default.
- bheadmaster 4y ago> How would a racist indian national deeply entrenched in caste culture help my company be less racist? To be fair, there are many people from traditionally chauvinistic groups who despise the very chauvinism they live in. Many of them may be intelligent and productive people. Dismissing each and every individual because of the group is the root of discrimination. Some attempts at diversity may go too far - tolerating intolerant people just because "they grew up in different environment" - leading to the paradox of tolerance [0]. I've read news [1] about the very phenomenon. The fact is - tolerance, diversity, open-mindedness - those are all values, and they need to be enforced. In order to keep a tolerant society, you must show the door to anyone who disagrees with that philosophy. The same way you need to lock up criminals to keep an ordered society from devolving into chaos. But ultimately, in order to have a truly tolerant society, each and every member of it must be evaluated as an individual. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance [1] https://restofworld.org/2022/tech-india-caste-divides/ https://restofworld.org/2022/tech-india-caste-divides/
- AnEro 4y agoI think people are confusing corporations vs people. People want diversity and care about diversity, who optionally wants to exclude someone that has merit to participate in the work/activity. Of course bigots exist, but largely people try to respect people. Corporations, care as much as it is profitable that is the purpose of the organization is to generate wealth for stakeholders. The issue in my opinion is how subjective 'merit' is, where studies show two resumes with equal qualifications a name implying a race or gender alone is enough to change the results of which resume was chosen subconsciously. People see this problem as how do you measure someone without bias? How do you measure the cultural impact one can bring? How do you measure <something we suck a measuring currently> Corporations see this problem as, how do we stay diverse enough to not look evil? How do we make measure our diversity to prove that? THEN they approach the people's point of view on the issue, because above everything is shareholders earnings and therefore the optics. It's not even intentional to a degree, stop gap solutions to make corporation happy and people tolerant of the corporation Calling it Orwellian is crazy though, it's just capitalism and governments trying to find a way to keep it fair for non-capital owners.
- jjmorrison 4y ago
- skilled 4y ago
- 300bps 4y agoI bet there are many here on HN who would love to "go all out" on the subject. And then there are people who just downvote and flag everything they disagree with.
- skilled 4y agoI did, anyway.
- timellis-smith 4y agoNo, but by having even-handed and rational conversations we can find the best outcome and hopefully have small influence in making society incrementally better.
- skilled 4y agoSociety is responsible for itself. There are no written rules you inherit when you are a born. You only inherit whatever was passed down to you through your family lineage. And if that happens to be unsavory, then you as a person have to resolve that. I am talking high-level self-development and conscious awareness not some crap imposed onto people who think they know better.
- GrooberThiy 4y ago
- tingletech 4y agoWhen I took ecology in college, to calculate diversity of an ecosystem, we used Shannon's formula from a mathmatical theory of communications. iirc we did it with base e vs base 2 so the units for ecological diversity were in nits.
- simple-thoughts 4y agoThe purpose of universities is to support state power. A multiethnic state must keep its minorities pacified. The tragedy is international institutions copying USA policies without understanding the core reasons and thus undermining the governments they are meant to support.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Trifectaffe6 4y ago
- duxup 4y agoOf all the things to worry about I don't think "diversity" and all the song and dance is really enjoyed by the typical large corporation folks who are actually in charge enough to make this some kind of conspiracy. That's too uncharacteristic and too many steps to make sense to me. Let alone the fact that these diversity panels / oversight has caused plenty an issue at large corporations and PR messes. I don't think anyone at big corp wants any part of that just to in theory put pressure on someone else. Actual regulations and laws are plenty effective on keeping down competition in some situations. Smaller corporations rarely see any real pressure diversity wise. There might be some examples but generally smaller orgs fly under the radar of just about everything.
- kristjank 4y agoThe original lawsuit the author cites happened more almost 50 years ago. Taking into account that similarly incompetent practices persisted for half a decade, there should now be a line where incompetence becomes malice. It's easy to hide behind apologia and recognition of past wrongdoing. The problem with the system isn't the oppressive results it might produce, the problem lies within the system itself and its innate bias to create oppression. Complacency isn't an excuse, it's an aggravating circumstance. Academia especially should try to get as close as possibe to a merit-based system, where acception and further progression are determined on past grades, not on skin color, gender, religion and economic status. Another problem that noone seems to be worried about is the mass collection of personal data and the processing thereof. How can I trust discussing my faith, ethnicity and finances with a for-profit institution, when (especially under US jurisdiction) I have little to no control of how that data gets processed, sorted and monetized?
- ryeguy_24 4y agoIsn't the real issue behind all the names (diversity, inclusion, etc) about the equalizing of opportunity or at the very least, bringing certain oppressed groups (and, if you don't think certain groups are or have been oppressed or discriminated against, educate yourself) up the opportunity curve? Do we want to live in a world where you have less opportunity because of characteristics you were born with?
- zozbot234 4y agoWell, the OP is describing a case where you might meaningfully have more or less opportunity depending on your expressed stance in matters unrelated to actual job duties - viz., your expressing support for diversity ideology, as evidenced in a "diversity impact statement". So this is basically compelled speech and/or discrimination based on ideology, which is a very real kind of oppression.
- ryeguy_24 4y agoOh, maybe I misinterpreted. I have much less interest in that argument given that there are tons of pre-existing ideologies that could be discriminated against for a job. Right? If your ideology is "I think it's important to work as little as possible to maintain a job." I'd assume many employers would discriminate against hiring someone with that ideology, no? Apologies if I'm missing the key point again.
- zozbot234 4y ago> Oh, maybe I misinterpreted. No worries. It's easy to misinterpret these things because there are facets of job performance in this area that wouldn't be out of place at all in a "diversity impact statement" (such as a proven, developed ability to teach and work with people from a high variety of backgrounds - which doesn't even correlate all that much with political stance per se). Nevertheless, the very notion of requiring that kind of statement is sure to introduce a sort of very real bias in hiring.
- actually_a_dog 4y ago
- fourstar 4y agoThe wealthy elites do. They want a race war instead of a class war.
- shishy 4y ago> Of course, none of the above predictions are borne out: the current practice of affirmative action has none of these features that you would expect if its proponents actually valued diversity. Conclusion: By and large, they don’t care about diversity. Another variation of this that I always hear is "everyone wants diversity but sucks at inclusion", which is slightly different (main article says they don't actually want diversity). Need to give this a closer re-read but my instinct is that people do actually want diversity and aren't good at making it happen; but it could be a mix of everything where they use it for the social karma and secretly don't
- stewx 4y agoFor an example of this, see this story about Canadian professor and laser scientist Patanjali Kambhampati who was denied for grants because his avowed commitment to mere non-discrimination and merit-based hiring was deemed insufficient. https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/minority-professor-denied-grants-because-he-hires-on-merit-people-are-afraid-to-think https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/minority-professor-deni...
- croes 4y agoIs that a numbers game? How many people don't get jobs because of the "wrong" skin color? They don't get famous too, that's why no news site brings an article about them. https://getd.libs.uga.edu/pdfs/harrison_matthew_s_200512_ms.pdf https://getd.libs.uga.edu/pdfs/harrison_matthew_s_200512_ms....
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- opmelogy 4y agoI don't see a problem with this, especially if part of the mission of the folks giving the grant is to create opportunities for under-represented people. "If I want to focus on merit, fairness and equality, then you get called out as racist or sexist." I'm still waiting for an example where someone can actually vet people based on merit, fairness and equality without any of their own unconscious biases being a factor. Humans are most comfortable with people that think, look, and act like them. No matter how hard they try, it skews their thinking at times.
- Test0129 4y agoWow, flagged, killed, resurrected in a VERY short amount of time. This is spicy. Diversity is a trope that I've yet to see any evidence for other than using it as a kudgel to force a single viewpoint on a bunch of people by threatening their salary. To be clear, I'm not saying we shouldn't hire other races, or prefer one race above the other. But having been both in tech and university I can tell you by and large these programs are feel good and do almost nothing to forward their goal. If the goal is to improve racial diversity, then you can do it trivially by simply selecting non-white races. This is, by definition, racist, but for some reason we've retermed this form of racism as "affirmative action". In a lot of sectors this ends up becoming a racial quota. Some tech companies even seem to gleefully promote it as such. These quotas do nothing to improve the bottom line or improve diversity. It feels more like revenge than progress and I don't think that's effective or sustainable. If the goal is to improve ideological diversity then race shouldn't be controlled for. As the author rightly points out, a white person from a poor neighborhood will have a "more diverse" viewpoint than a black person from a middle class neighborhood. However, one may wonder how increased ideological diversity would help solve a problem in software that doesn't directly lean on one of those ideologies. There has never been a point in my decades long career as a backend engineer where my political/racial/religious identity ever influenced my code. I can say this with absolute certainty. It feels like a sham to me. Suddenly in the last decade we've seen the marked rise of "diversity consultants" who by and large are simply diversity hustlers. This includes the new title "chief diversity officer" who, to this day, I am unsure what they even contribute in terms of driving profitability. Of course, these diversity hustlers will promote direct-action diversity efforts as the panacea to all of our sins because it's profitable to them. I have yet to see data that implies when controlling for education, race is a determining factor in ability. The idea itself seems false on its face but this is the exact idea they are promoting. A business seeks first to optimize profit. Meritocracy is the single best way to insure this. If you wish to reduce hiring bias develop systems for double-blind reviews of candidates and compare results. These problems can be at least partially ameliorated with statistics. But instead, it seems we choose the most inefficient and outright questionably legal method instead. Promoting these ephemeral hard to measure metrics like "X <trait> has a more diverse opinion and is therefore better than Y <trait>" is just an end-around to bigotry at the corporate and university level. We can do better to fix hiring pipeline biases, etc, but this is not the way.
- stuckinhell 4y agoI care about diversity. I've been a women in stem nearly my entire life (thanks dad!). However diversity quotas, esg scores, and all the manipulation in "diversity" and "woke" today is more about incompetent children of the rich who need fake jobs that make a lot of money. I've refused to hire an english major young woman on my development team even under extreme pressure from management because she's a women, but also because she's the CTO's wife's niece. It's just an unbelievable amount of pressure, now all resumes are pre-screened before they even get to me by a third party hiring group so corporate has plausible deniability about their schemes. It's become far more about "elite" signalling and nepotism these days.
- kadoban 4y ago> I've refused to hire an english major young woman on my development team even under extreme pressure from management because she's a women, but also because she's the CTO's wife's niece That's not "woke", that's just garden variety nepotism.
- stuckinhell 4y agoThat's the point, "woke" gives garden variety nepotism a nice shiny ESG approved cover.
- kadoban 4y agoIf we get rid of everything that some asshole can use as cover, there's not going to be a lot left.
- stuckinhell 4y ago"Woke" is very different that other types of cover. "Woke" gets celebrated and praised, and people have to pretend that hire wasn't hired due to nepotism. As a manager whose been thru this rodeo, let me tell you what happens. 1. We have to have a mini celebration for "woke but really nepotistic" hire at big corporation. 2. We can never mention that persons skill or the "real" reason they got hired. 3. It gives the "elites" far more power to harass people via HR if they don't like the nepotism 4. The non-nepotism hires can become bitter and resentful, even more so when they have to pickup extra work for no department praise or celebrations if the "woke" hire is bad. I also have to give cover for the "woke" hire. 5. My team starts to collapse, and I have to negotiate all sorts of shit to keep my talented hires. It's just an absolute nightmare when managing a high performance results required teams.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- at_a_remove 4y agoIt's been very, uh, interesting (perhaps in the "may you live in interesting times" fashion) watching the Diversity concept leap toward an unquestioned, uncritically accepted value in and of itself. Take The Parable of the Polygons, from 2014 (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19714441 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19714441) ... it is hard to come away from this with anything other than "choice of neighborhood leads to segregation and lack of diversity, and that's bad." But what of Robert Putnam's widely critiqued 2007 study? Imagine, just for a bit, where diversity causes a loss of a sense of community, and therefore diversity would not be an uncritical good. What if humans like to be around other humans superficially like them, not unlike other social mammals? Step back and look at the various "spaces" striven for on behalf of some minorities (and women, who are not a minority but get that badge), both in Universities, in women-only workspaces featured here, and in places like Curves. Good, apparently for the goose, but not so much for that troublesome gander. These are simply non-diverse spaces when close up, pixelated. Only by putting a bunch of them together and pulling back do they look diverse. Certainly, some of the methods used to achieve diversity are questionable, and we have various people, from Elizabeth Warren to Rachel Dolezal, masquerading as minorities to acquire ... well, people seek to acquire power and status, so it is hard to argue against that people like Dolezal and Warren didn't want some additional blessing by identifying as groups they do not belong to, and also therefore hard to argue against that those group identifications aren't in some areas (especially academia) positive status and power. We've watched colleges and some corporations come under fire for enrollment and hiring practices which select strongly against (we used to call that "discrimation") certain groups, like the unruly Asians, who are square pegs, refusing to fit into the minority/poverty hole. A serious re-evaluation is due, one where people's careers aren't threatened by doing so.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cetahfh14615 4y agoPart of affirmative action (AA) involves addressing some of the issues specific to american society, I have no clue how diversity is handled outside the US but would love to hear someone else's experience To a certain degree prejudice is ingrained in the US. Not officially in laws, but in attitudes that some (not all) people hold. Not any one specific group of people either, but prejudice across different ethnic groups. AA isn't independent of this prejudice, just a more recent and politicized form of it I think the way that it has been discussed in recent years isn't going to sustain itself long term. The way that higher education discriminates against Asians is especially egregious (source: "The reason that it is harder for Asian Americans to get into Harvard is that their “personal ratings” (a subjective evaluation of personal qualities) are, on average, significantly lower than for white applicants." (https://www.forbes.com/sites/evangerstmann/2019/10/01/why-the-asian-american-students-lost-their-case-against-harvard-but-should-have-won/?sh=10627e9163c1 https://www.forbes.com/sites/evangerstmann/2019/10/01/why-th...)) The same "personal rating" bs was historically used to limit the number of Jewish applicants. At the end of the day, the Asian applicants would likely benefit from just not providing race or selecting the "other" category. The only way that the current system can sustain itself is by having people honestly self identify, yet there's no legal ramifications for not doing this. If people genuinely want to end this system, all they have to do is stop giving it real data to work with
- autokad 4y agopart of the problem with Asian Americans in the application process is that they are treated just as Asians. My Computer Science Program at University of Pennsylvania was about 74% Asian, 20% Indian, and 5% European. There was <1% you can attribute to anyone else. Problem is, the 74% Asian was almost entirely Chinese born Chinese, and I do feel it hurt the program. They did not want to join groups with non-Chinese people because they preferred speaking Chinese in group projects. They didn't want to talk to you before or after class if you were not speaking Mandarin. The chit chat and sharing of ideas is the whole point of higher education IMO. There were other problems not related to the fact they only wanted to speak Chinese their whole duration of their time in the program (such as talking during class, cheating, etc.) but I wont go into that. The point is, having nearly 70% of the program being Chinese born Chinese made the education experience worse. Unfortunately, American born Chinese (or even Korean) gets lumped into the Asian group and they have to compete against 1 billion Chinese applicants taking paper GRE tests (cheating on these paper tests is common, as you can buy the answers ahead of the test ).
- littlelamb 4y agoI am absolutely all in for equality, but definitely strongly against equity. When I get HR try to shove a resume down my throat because it ticks all of their boxes despite having none of the boxes to be succesful on the job, that is when I draw the line. I don't care if you're white, black, purple or green, and whether you fuck men, women, all of them or none of them is none of my business. At the end of the day I want the most qualified to get the position when I interview, you either know your stuff or you don't.
- wonnage 4y agoThis comment just implies that you assume any minority candidate that HR failed to screen is a diversity hire. And of course now every minority employee at your company has to excel or else they might torpedo the entire diversity hiring initiative.
- BobbyJo 4y agoI'm not getting that implication. They are saying that, on occasion, HR tries to shove a resume down his throat on the basis of race/sexuality when the applicant is lacking experience. That, in no way, leads me to extrapolate any kind of volume one way or another.
- wonnage 4y agoHR is literally not allowed, legally, to do that. Given that their entire existence is predicated on not getting the company sued I’m sure they’re well aware of that. So either OP should file a lawsuit or they’re imagining things.
- crackercrews 4y agoWhat law would HR be violating by pushing certain resumes based on favored traits? IME this pretty common at all sorts of big companies. People don't whistle-blow because its obvious you'll get buried if you do. Just ask James Damore.
- 4y ago
- tptacek 4y agoThe whole blog is like this; it's all sort of comically smug "everybody else in the entire world is wrong, and here is a 7-point axiomatic derivation proving it"†, much of it depending on specific definitions of specific words. Check-mate, atheists! There are lots of good, sharp, critical things to say about the DEI movement, most especially "institutional" DEI, but you can't meaningfully say them when you write with this tone, can you? Who's going to take you seriously? Like, at a bare minimum, you have to acknowledge (or take the trouble to refute) the concerns that animate your opposition. The author isn't a rando! This is a tenured professor of philosophy at a major university. You know, writing like a high school sophomore on a message board. † I highly recommend his carefully reasoned, inescapable argument that everyone has the right to own a gun for a perfect example of the form.
- lazyeye 4y agoThis sounds like the kind of thing you say when you are annoyed but cant find a good argument against the points being made.
- tptacek 4y agoDid this feel like a compelling argument when you wrote it? You thought to yourself, huh, maybe this person can't possibly come up with an argument for diversity that doesn't run aground of an appeal for "viewpoint diversity"?
- throwawaymaroon 4y agoThis sounds like the kind of thing you say when you are annoyed but cant find a good argument against the points being made.
- thethimble 4y agoIt’s level 3 on pg’s hierarchy of disagreement - the whole concept of which I find interesting: http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html
- 4y ago
- gnicholas 4y agoI recently watched an interesting discussion on the legality of diversity statement requirements. [1] There's a lot of nuance here, and the two speakers have different opinions on the matter. One believes that diversity statement requirements can be done properly and we shouldn't throw the baby out with the bathwater by banning diversity statement requirements. The other speaker suggests these are analogous to requirements that a candidate talk about how they support the government's ongoing war effort, and catalog all they have done in furtherance of it. 1: https://reason.com/volokh/2022/08/30/do-university-diversity-statement-requirements-violate-the-constitution/ https://reason.com/volokh/2022/08/30/do-university-diversity...
- gnicholas 4y agoI'm surprised and pleased to see that this link is the top comment. The original article was a bit dismissive/presumptive, and the submission rode the flagging/vouching rollercoaster as a result. Not a great start! But it's a testament to the HN community that the most-upvoted comment on this thread is one with a link to a video that is long form (over an hour!) and truly presents both sides. It is also legally sophisticated — not something that most HNers can digest at 3x. Yet enough folks engaged with it that this rose up slowly to be the top comment. Most communities aren't able to perform conversational alchemy — starting out with bronze and ending up with gold. HN doesn't always do this, but the fact that it can is much of the reason why I'm here.
- dbrueck 4y agoMy problem with so-called diversity efforts is that they wildly overemphasize a really superficial attribute: skin color. That is, at best, a tenuous proxy for actual diversity and goes against decades of work of the U.S. civil rights movement. There are real benefits to having a diverse group of people in just about every setting, but assessing the level of diversity by noting the range of skin tones present is ineffective (and should be deeply offensive to everyone involved). True diversity of thought, perspective, and experience - i.e. the things that make diversity desirable - come first from things like socioeconomic differences (that one alone may outweigh all others combined), your family experience growing up (including the nuclear family culture but broader culture in which you lived), etc. Any sort of correlation to skin color is not necessarily causal, especially when considering individual people, and yet using skin color as your diversity metric not-so-subtly suggests it /is/ causal, which, ironically, is on some level racist.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wnolens 4y agoIt's absolutely insane to me. It's justified racism, and poorly at that. Sometimes I feel like I am living in a dystopian novel.
- wizofaus 4y ago> they wildly overemphasize a really superficial attribute That may be true in your party of the world but at least in the IT industry in mine, diversity in skin colour (*) isn't really an issue. Diversity in sex, age and physical ability levels definitely are though, and I'd like to see a much stronger push to ensure an older disabled or blind woman is given the same consideration as a younger able-bodied/sighted man, given the there's no reason the former should be any less capable of fulfilling the job requirements, but examples of are vastly underrepresented, meaning we're almost certainly missing out on hiring the most talented engineers that we can find. (*) admittedly I'm treating skin colour as just a proxy for ethnic/racial background. There's not a marked difference in skin colour between most East Asian backgrounds for instance, but within the Indian subcontinent there's a decent range. There probably still is something of an implicit bias towards lighter skin tones even given a wide range of backgrounds, and certainly those from an indigenous background are underrepresented. But that problem starts much earlier than at the point of being hired professionally as an adult.
- fritztastic 4y agoGoing by the definition in the referenced link, “a statement of your experience with or knowledge of inclusion, diversity, equity, and belonging efforts and your plans for incorporating them into your teaching, research, mentoring, and service.” it doesn't seem outrageous- it does force the writer to think about their past experiences and observations in regards to inclusion, diversity, and equity... which makes the author of this opinion piece feel this way, and this seems the reaction has more to do with their perception and personal view of (and disagreement with) the prioritization of these concepts than it has to do with the requirement itself.
- dbrueck 4y agoThat's a good insight, and I think being asked to think deeply about these things is also good, but I'm skeptical that this activity in this specific context really leads to any sort of honest introspection. To me at least, it feels loaded with expectations that you answer a certain way. I mean, you are almost certainly going to be judged (or at least feel judged) based on what you write, so that undermines the incentive to be truly honest with yourself.
- bitmunk 4y ago>In the academy, left-wing beliefs dominate; therefore, the affirmative action supporters would be first and foremost demanding preferences for conservatives, libertarians, moderates, fascists, monarchists, and other people who do not accept the current progressive orthodoxy. This is simply being obtuse for the sake of flame-bating, caring about diversity is simply a shorthand for the inclusion of sectors that were and are (actually) prejudiced against. The actual "practical" usefulness of diversity is more "perhaps we should try this facial recognition software with black skin", not the PR-esque "being different is superpower". And no, you aren't a prejudiced because you are conservative, not even when people disagree with you on Twitter. Yes, Twitter mobs are actually a thing, yes they are dangerous, no they aren't that common. It's true that American liberals are overly interested in racial injustice to the detriment of class injustice, and affirmative action could be better based on socio-economic status.
- haunter 4y agoThe elite does. They want a race war instead of class war because they know they would lose the latter. Divide et impera has been used for more than 2000 years and it will never go away.
- gremlinsinc 4y agoTrue, but a race war is us against us, a class war is 90% vs 10%... the 10% currently in power. The southern strategy was to literally go against anything that would benefit black people, EVEN if it benefited poor white people too, because it's better to be miserable and white than to let a black person get ahead of you from government handouts. This was the entire strategy of the GOP(still is) since the 1950s. I think the centrists (which may even just be a 'role' they play) goal is to keep both parties fighting on fringe issues like abortion and guns so we don't stop to reevaluate how much we're being fleeced by the govt to create $$ for their buddies in the oil and defense industries. Their purpose is to appear w/ the others, but only slightly and to ensure that the status quo remains intact. Lee atwater said in 1981: “As to the whole Southern strategy that Harry S. Dent, Sr. and others put together in 1968, opposition to the Voting Rights Act would have been a central part of keeping the South. Y’all don’t quote me on this. You start out in 1954 by saying, ‘N*er, n*er, n*er’. By 1968 you can’t say ‘n*er’—that hurts you. Backfires. So you say stuff like forced busing, states’ rights and all that stuff. You’re getting so abstract now [that] you’re talking about cutting taxes, and all these things you’re talking about are totally economic things and a byproduct of them is [that] blacks get hurt worse than whites. And subconsciously maybe that is part of it. I’m not saying that. But I’m saying that if it is getting that abstract, and that coded, that we are doing away with the racial problem one way or the other. You follow me—because obviously sitting around saying, ‘We want to cut this’, is much more abstract than even the busing thing, and a hell of a lot more abstract than ‘N*r, n*r.’ So, any way you look at it, race is coming on the back-burner.” When I read this a few years back, it totally just clicked - that this is the entire economic platform of the right. Working class republicans support things that go against their own best interest (medicare for all for example), simply because they damn well don't want non-whites to have nice things, even if it means they don't get to either. Asinine as hell, but generations of racism and bigotry don't generally create tolerant people wanting to switch things up.
- deleted 4y ago
- sebastianconcpt 4y agoIn the academy, left-wing beliefs dominate; therefore, the affirmative action supporters would be first and foremost demanding preferences for conservatives, libertarians, moderates, fascists, monarchists, and other people who do not accept the current progressive orthodoxy. Everyone knows that isn’t happening. Virtually none (maybe actually zero) of the woke, social-justice-warrior people support philosophical diversity. The most “woke” people are the ones who aggressively try to silence all dissent (https://fakenous.net/?p=2932 https://fakenous.net/?p=2932) and to exclude conservatives, libertarians, etc., from the Academy. So they not only fail to value intellectual diversity; they are just about the most stridently anti-diversity people in the entire country. Correct.
- slavboj 4y ago"Diverse" doesn't mean "diverse", it just means "left constituencies". Thus certain races are "racially diverse" (blacks most, whites of course least), certain income strata are "economically diverse", etc. You really can't assume words have their conventional meaning when used in a political context.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deathanatos 4y agoI'd love to see incentives to help level the playing field for people who come from impoverished backgrounds. But instead, what we get, and what people seem to clamor most loudly for, is what a former employer of mine had: "hiring bonus if the candidate isn't white or male" (and at one point, all I could hire was non-white or non-male, and the way it was spun was "we are in a hiring freeze, except for diversity hires"). Some of us would like to solve the ills of the world without resorting to racism/sexism.
- cryptonector 4y agoIs it legal to have hiring bonuses for candidates (or for hiring them), where the bonus is based on attributes of the candidate on the basis of which it is normally not permissible to discriminate?
- nickm12 4y agoI really don't like the term "diversity hire". A candidate cannot be diverse. Diversity is a property of a population.
- psyfi 4y agoAll diversity policies and measures are leading to Cobra effects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perverse_incentive#The_original_cobra_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perverse_incentive#The_origina... The only policy that is actually right is not to discriminate against colors, ethnicities, political views, etc.. but putting pressure to try to hire african/asian/latinos/women/whatever is like putting pressure on people to buy products from someone just to proof they don't discriminate against, which is extremely absurd and against the purpose.
- revlolz 4y agoDEI measures from companies I have been with have been unironically fighting the woes of systemic racism with a new form of systemic racism. IMO it leads to resentment even from minority employees and is poison to morale in a meritocratic performance based organizations.
- registeredcorn 4y agoYep. The worries over "Am I just a diversity hire?" are a real concern. :( I really wish that applicants were required to give less information, not more. I don't want to know your name, or how old you are, or where you're from. I just want to know what your credentials are. Personally, I feel like criminal records, outside of specific work like working with weapons, children/elderly, or law enforcement, should not be asked on applications. If they served their time, let them live their lives. It's incredibly frustrating that there's all of these extraneous attributes we're supposed to hem and haw over, like we're choosing the best fruit in the market. It's human beings, and they should be treated in as fair and neutral manner as feasibly possible. Best man wins.
- revlolz 4y agoI've found that the only controllable practices are to force our hr to send anonimized resumes to my interview team and to zealously challenge bias through panel review questions to interviewers. Our reviews can't detail things like "not a culture fit" or "is unqualified." there has to be a specific quantifiable reason for decline or hire. We've never had anyone openly discriminate because I don't sincerely believe people do (intentionally) , but I'm willing to put faith into the concept of unconscious bias and take action to challenge it with methods that do not hypocritcally embrace discrimation of protected class/features/etc. However, I strongly believe dei equity creates more racism rather than remove it. All opinions here subjective, maybe I'm wrong, but I feel like it's best for both candidate and company.
- muaytimbo 4y agoThis diversity stuff comes from the very top, when I was doing my PhD the three most productive (and published) grad students and post docs were a few white and chinese guys. But every grant I proofread from my advisor extolled the "diverse" make up of the lab and the contributions from underrepresented minorities therein (women of various backgrounds) who largely did not contribute to any of the prior work on which the grant was premised. This is universities taking their cues from their funding agencies, the government, and expounding on them.
- rlewkov 4y agoAs always, follow the money.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- derrickrburns 4y agoCheck out Place Not Race by Sheryll Cashin for a more nuanced, intellectual discussion. https://www.amazon.com/Place-Not-Race-Opportunity-America/dp/0807086142/ref=sr_1_1?crid=2GSEXNWVKQ0KT&keywords=place+not+race&qid=1663008379&sprefix=place+not+rac%2Caps%2C133&sr=8-1 https://www.amazon.com/Place-Not-Race-Opportunity-America/dp...
- the__alchemist 4y agoI do. I've been in male-dominated fields my whole career, and gender imbalances create weird dynamics.
- koonsolo 4y agoCan you give an example?
- derrickrburns 4y agoCheck out Place Not Race by Sheryll Cashin for a more nuanced, intellectual discussion: https://www.amazon.com/Place-Not-Race-Opportunity-America/dp/0807086142 https://www.amazon.com/Place-Not-Race-Opportunity-America/dp...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- zwieback 4y agoSome data to back any of these feelings up would be helpful. Academics are well aware of the difficulties associated with wokeism and are actively working on finding practical solutions. This post feels very 2018.
- celeritascelery 4y ago> Academics are well aware of the difficulties associated with wokeism and are actively working on finding practical solutions That is very surprising to me. Can you share any examples of this happening?
- ALittleLight 4y agoI don't even think ideological / philosophical / political diversity is that good a thing. If you are the college admissions person, are you more likely to admit a eugenicist who thinks their ethnic group is best? I mean, that's a really unusual opinion for a prospective student to express! Wouldn't that increase diversity? You work in a media company and someone who wants to bring their niche fundamentalist religious perspective to your content - whoa, super diverse, right? Hospital hiring a witch doctor? Don't have too many of those on staff! I think for the vast majority of positions what you want is someone who can do the job well and their ability will naturally constrain their opinions and experience and, in some cases, their demographic characteristics as well. For students you want smart people who have a documented history of being able to learn. Intellectual diversity should arrive naturally from a population of smart people trying to learn. Intellectual diversity should not be a goal itself.
- ricardoplouis 4y agoGiven the stark racial inequality we have today due to compounding wealth from centuries of colonialism and slavery, it seems diversity is the bare minimum we could do to address such a burden, and it's a shame that is even considered controversial. Is there an "unoffensive" solution to address this history or should we all just get along and pretend it didn't happen?
- colpabar 4y agoNope! The bare minimum we could do is start getting mad about how rich the rich are, and stop fighting among ourselves. Diversity is a tool used by the rich to keep us from uniting against them, and sadly it is really effective.
- x86_64Ubuntu 4y agoHow come every time systemic or structural racism is brought up, the discussion instantly pivots to it being "divisive" and the real battle being class consciousness or something.
- Sir_Liigmaz 4y agoBecause race is a tool of the elites. Most structural racism is a side-effect of the rich exploiting the poor.
- ricardoplouis 4y agoThere is truth to the matter, but it's also because class conscious groups fail to recognize that they perpetuate the same racism, sexism, etc... that the elites do. Coincidentally, ignoring race as an issue is the one issue many people on both sides of the political spectrum can get down with even though economic equality does not guarantee racial equality.
- x86_64Ubuntu 4y agoNo one on the Left is about ignoring race as an issue. That's pretty much a right-wing trope 100%.
- jedberg 4y agoSo here's where I'm stuck: On the one hand I totally understand the objections to categorizing people based on things that won't affect their job performance per se -- skin color, gender, who they are attracted to, etc. But on the other hand, those people have been systematically discriminated against, well, forever. So the question is, where should the fix be applied? If the only people who have the skills to do the job you are hiring for are straight white men, because they are the only ones who had the opportunity to get the training, should we fix that at the hiring level? The initial reaction is probably no, we should push that fix further down to make sure those people get the same chances as everyone else. But that will take decades. What do we do until then? And there is another thing too -- you can't deny that a black woman has had a vastly difference life experience than a white man, even if those two people have all the same job relevant qualifications otherwise. And frankly I'd rather have the black woman on the team to offer that perspective, especially for product decisions, because they might have interesting things to say.
- MrStonedOne 4y ago>you can't deny that a black woman has had a vastly difference life experience than a white man So, where i get stuck, is that you can't actually make this statement about any individual black woman or white man. The one common theme across all of social justice is that stereotyping is bad. Erasing individuality and forcing people to live in the shadow of their stereotypes is bad. Yet its apparently allowed here? Because it mostly benefits minorities? This is the unspoken line the separates identity politics and equality. A focus on minorities vs a focus on ending discrimination and stereotyping, which under equality would include AA. When (most) people say they are against "woke" culture or "sjws" they generally mean they are against the identity politics flavor of ""equality"". Because identity politics is just a racist sexist dog whistle for discrimination against majorities.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y ago> But on the other hand, those people have been systematically discriminated against, well, forever. The solution is not to systematically discriminate in another direction, forever. In addition, you risk political blowback. People who are discriminated against get unhappy, and you have abandoned the high moral ground that racial discrimination is always a bad thing, and you end up in a worse situation than you started.
- jscipione 4y agoDiversity and equity are Neo-Marxism.
- unknownaccount 4y agoPeople shouldnt be forced to accept diversity. It should be opt-in. Forcing anything on a person against their will does not work and leads to radicalization. The harder they push, the more radicalized people become. This is what leads to attacks like Christchurch.
- jrajav 4y agoAre you implying that people in favor of and/or implementing affirmative action members share some culpability in far-right terrorist acts? Huh. In my book, deciding to leave civil society for untargeted violence against innocent people of some other group immediately puts all the responsibility for your actions into your lap. You don't get to say it was because of some vague ideological pressure at that point.
- unknownaccount 4y agoI'm not arguing who's responsibility it is. I'm just pointing out that in practice, when you force an ideology on people + take away any outlet for them to express dissent(through deplatforming/censorship etc) then this is the kind of thing that ends up happening. That being said, whenever someone enacts a policy that affects others it is important that they consider the effects of externalities. While they may not be directly responsible for those externalities, it's irresponsible not to take them into consideration. Pointing fingers after the fact doesn't bring people back to life.
- scifibestfi 4y agoIn 2018 The Atlantic explained this phenomenon, what the utility is, and correctly posited that it would not likely go away. TLDR; Status games and intra-elite jockeying among the overproduced elite. "Think about what it takes to claw your way into America’s elite strata. Unless you were born into the upper-middle class, your surest route is to pursue an elite education. To do that, it pays to be exquisitely sensitive to the beliefs and prejudices of the people who hold the power to grant you access to the social and cultural capital you badly want. By setting the standards for what counts as praiseworthy, elite universities have a powerful effect on youthful go-getters." "As the senior assistant director of admissions at Yale recently observed, “for those students who come to Yale, we expect them to be versed in issues of social justice. We encourage them to be vocal when they see an opportunity for change in our institution and in the world.” Picture yourself as an eager high schooler reading these words, and then jotting down notes. You absorb, assuming you hadn’t already, what it takes to make your way in contemporary elite America. And as you grow older, you lean into the rhetorical gambits that served you so well in the past. You might even build a worldview out of them." https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2018/08/the-utility-of-white-bashing/566846/ https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2018/08/the-utilit...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- api 4y agoThis suggests that if we got rid of this rhetoric something else would take its place as it fills a kind of market niche. There's a limited amount of space in elite institutions and thus fierce competition over the right to obtain these degrees, which have become (in some circles) the modern equivalent of writs of noble title. This creates demand for mechanisms that can be used to signal and play status games. Also suggests why it shows up in high-status highly paid jobs like engineering, finance, executive suites, law, etc. What was it a few generations ago? Patriotism? Being the correct race or religion instead of posturing about diversity?
- origin_path 4y agoThere was no equivalent a few generations ago because hardly anyone went to university at all.
- kokizzu2 4y agomeritocracy ftw..
- RobertRoberts 4y agoTrue diversity would mean having to accept, even welcome, a MAGA wearing redneck onto the board of a black university. Therefore diversity discussions (almost always) are not about "diversity for everyone", but instead it's social cudgel for one side to use against another.
- jrajav 4y agoSorry, no it doesn't. The point under discussion is affirmative action, that is, specifically targeting and aiding underrepresented groups, so you're just misunderstanding the premise in the first place - but also, to say 'a MAGA wearing redneck' and 'black university' specifically, you clearly get that it's a racist in a race-specific context. The thing nearly everyone tries to gloss over when they pull this "Well why don't you let more conservatives in then" is that many front-and-center conservative platforms these days are explicitly intolerant. Why should you be surprised or upset when tolerant institutions seek to reject those? It's a feature of modern civil society, not a liberal conspiracy.
- RobertRoberts 4y agoThat is exactly my point, "diversity" by its very definition can't also mean exclusion. If it does, who's rules for exclusion are you using? (a diverse set of rules?) This is the problem with this discussion, I can't stand MAGA ideals, I think they are ridiculous, but you assumed I support it because I used it to point out a flaw in a popular (but flawed) idea. It's a very real example to show true diversity can't exist in our society across diverse groups.
- jiveturkey 4y ago> Most fundamentally, in this context, diversity would be variety of ideas, experiences, and attitudes, especially those relevant to the things that people are learning about in school. In the context the author wants us to assume, sure. But that is not what big-D Diversity is. "When I use a word, it means just what I choose it to mean — neither more nor less." - Humpty Dumpty In this case, of course, this is very intentional on behalf of the author, to argue a very specific agenda. Which I guess is fair enough, except that it is quite provocative in a generally bad way for society, IMHO. The author knows better and shouldn't depend on this ... diversion (heh) to promote his point.
- philwelch 4y agoI would posit that the advocates of "big-D Diversity" are the ones intentionally setting up a provocative and tendentious definition of "diversity".
- eweise 4y agoAs someone currently helping my son fill out college applications, I find this article 100% on point. For one public college, there are only two essay questions and they both deal with diversity. How does a white middle class male answer? He has an incredible fascination with weather and wants to pursue that as a major. Does he emphasize this aspect since it sets him apart from other applicants. Logically, that would be the right choice. But we know the university really is filtering out people like my son, so we will probably talk about his ancestor's immigration story and how that has affected his worldview, blah, blah blah.
- petilon 4y ago> How does a white middle class male answer? Diversity doesn't only mean race. It can mean cultural backgrounds, experiences, values and viewpoints. It can mean creative vs. analytic thinkers, artistic vs. not, leadership, extroversion, unusual contributions to society, and so on. If you're a physics expert in a team of math experts, you add diversity.
- 3qz 4y agoThat’s true but it’s not what they actually mean when they say “diversity” so all of this should be left out of the essay.
- petilon 4y agoNot true. Take University of Washington for example. They ask for a "diversity essay". They define diversity as "diverse in cultural backgrounds, experiences, values and viewpoints." [1] [1] https://admit.washington.edu/apply/freshman/how-to-apply/writing-section/ https://admit.washington.edu/apply/freshman/how-to-apply/wri...
- eweise 4y agoYep they do. Wonder what the chances are for someone writing about their conservative viewpoint as opposed to the applicant writing about their struggles growing up in a racially segregated neighborhood?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- golemiprague 4y ago
- michaelwww 4y agoI care about diversity because different cultures bring different ideas and skills to the situation. When I get in a jam, I don't want just one idea for getting out of it, I want many.
- koonsolo 4y agoCan you give an example on how a white male software developer would develop something differently than for example an asian woman, and how the cultural difference would translate into a different approach of writing code?
- michaelwww 4y agoMan, how I wish all my problems were software problems
- koonsolo 4y agoOk, another problem a software engineer could encounter then?
- michaelwww 4y agoIf you have a point why don't you make it?
- koonsolo 4y agoYou made a generic claim that different cultures bring different ideas and skills. I have a hard time understanding what that means in practice at the workplace. That's why I'm asking for an example. I still don't see how it would work in practice, and you fail to give an example.
- DanBC 4y ago"Your name must contain..."
- 4y ago
- koonsolo 4y agoI do a lot of hiring, and co-hired a lot of my colleagues. I would never hire for diversity, and would explicitly refuse to do so. Why? Everyone in my team is hired for 1 thing: excellent developers. Nobody is questioning why they are there, and I would never put those people in a position where project managers have to question why anyone in my team is there, because of being a good developer or to fill up some statistics. Hiring for diversity has the opposite effect: it puts doubt why a person of a certain minority is there. But hey, once the world starts doing that bullshit, it's excellent for me. I'm a hetro white male, so there can be ony 1 reason why I was hired.
- crackercrews 4y ago> But hey, once the world starts doing that bullshit, it's excellent for me. I'm a hetro white male, so there can be ony 1 reason why I was hired. This logic only makes sense looking backward, assuming you got hired.
- koonsolo 4y agoDevelopers are in high demand in EU, so I wouldn't worry about that. Besides, if you don't hire for skills but for optimizing some unrelated statistics, you will need plenty of good developers to clean up the mess.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- petilon 4y ago> I would never hire for diversity, and would explicitly refuse to do so. Good. But in the end, if you end up with an all-male team then questions will be asked, and rightly so.
- rcoveson 4y agoGiven eight person teams, one in ten will have no women on it purely by chance, given that only a quarter of software engineers in the US are women. Questions may be asked, but I hope the questioners listen to reason.
- ScipioAfricanuz 4y agoHiring for social diversity (e.g race, ethnicity, gender, age) when the benefits of diversity come from cognitive diversity (micro vs macro pov, engineer working with computer scientist) is a very inefficient way of doing things. Yes it may be that someone of a different gender/race/ethnicity may have a different way of thinking, but it may also not be the case
- xtracto 4y agoAs an Hispanic Engineer I would hate to be hired to fill up a diversity quota... I am better than that. And as a Software Engineering hiring manager, when hiring I always strive to to be statistically unbiased in the diversity distribution in my team. My base distribution is the population of Software Engineering University graduates. As long as that base population has 1/10 women and 1/20 "non majority population" (in our case is average Mexican) my team should be expected to follow the same diversity distribution. The problem with a lot of "diversity" pushes is that they treat use the full country population distribution as a base, which is unreal for ALL labours, Hospitality may be skewed to females, Basketball may be skewed to Blacks, mechanics may be skewed to males, etc. Unless the distribution in the upper part of the funnels do not change, it will be unfair to attempt to force a change in the distribution in the lower stages of the funnel.
- HideousKojima 4y agoAlso for every tech company that hires more of qualified minority X than the baseline, another tech company has to hire less.
- stefantalpalaru 4y ago
- bavell 4y agoI've been watching Peter Boghossian's YT channel since I found it a few weeks ago, it has some great intellectually stimulating discussions around DEI and other hot-button topics that are extremely interesting, such as "Should the consideration of race be removed from the college admissions process?" [0]. He goes around to different colleges and asks the students on their beliefs in a reverse QA style, facilitating the conversation. The best discussions are when there are students who disagree and are on opposite ends of the spectrum on a topic. [0] https://youtu.be/a8yIFGNoFIU https://youtu.be/a8yIFGNoFIU
- azth 4y ago
- Grismar 4y agoDiversity is not important in and of itself, but it has been shown again and again that people will discriminate against it over of just selecting for quality. And it doesn't seem to be the case that having to overcome their aversion to diversity then negatively affects long term outcome. Since it is hard to measure and affect what people actually think, it's easier to measure and make policy based on outcomes, and in that sense, businesses should care about diversity as a metric. And perhaps as therapy, to cure their company culture of systemic discrimination - through exposure and by taking away the power of the drivers of discrimination to affect hiring.
- dijonman2 4y agoIt’s about time someone has the balls to tell the truth. I was paid bonuses on how many diversity candidates I hired at a prior job. Mind you I hired anyone who could do the job in previous roles, there was no discussion about any of this. People are more biased and racist than ever.
- breadbreadbread 4y agoideology is not just your political views or opinions, it is fundamentally how you interact with and view others. If your ideology is that "I am right and everyone else is wrong" or "women should be subservient to men" or "the scientific method is a tool of Satan", you are obviously a bad fit for university and a learning environment. I think it should be obvious that some ideologies are fundamentally a bad fit for a cooperative and tolerant environment. I get really frustrated with moralistic arguments that treat "ideology" as a value-neutral thing. like this: > In the academy, left-wing beliefs dominate; therefore, the affirmative action supporters would be first and foremost demanding preferences for conservatives, libertarians, moderates, fascists, monarchists, and other people who do not accept the current progressive orthodoxy. Some of those people don't want to be tolerant or cooperative. In order to have a conversation we have to want the same thing and to agree to the same rules and operate in good faith. If your opinion of "diversity" is that its pointless and hurts white men, and your peers at the university believe that cultural diversity is an important part of ideological diversity, and they AGREE that diversity statements help achieve that, then maybe you will also be a bad fit. Thats ok. Work at a different institution.
- stefantalpalaru 4y ago
- smitty1e 4y agoDiversity in all but thought.
- Juliet245 4y ago
- zephrx1111 4y agoDiversity, like wealth, is the result of a long running healthy society. Now instead, it is used as a measure, to bend the society. It is like turning the needle of a barometer by finger, and claiming the pressure is increasing.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]