13 ms·
Apple’s next big thing: A business model change
- theplumber 4y agoLong story short: the next big thing is milking/squeezing the existing customers through services. I guess the next next big thing would be charging customers for existing/free features(i.e pay more for privacy, no more on-device storage etc)
- skc 4y agoIs it still milking if customers are paying willingly?
- ibn_khaldun 4y agoThat depends on what you consider “willingly” to mean in this matter.
- mynameisvlad 4y agoIs Apple holding a gun to every person’s head saying “pay for Apple One or else”?
- stale2002 4y agoWhat they are doing is using anti-competitive practices, that go against the purpose of anti-trust laws and pro-competition laws.
- mynameisvlad 4y agoHow, exactly? Apple One is a subscription like any other. People can choose to get it or not.
- stale2002 4y agoThrough the process of using dominant market power, to anti-competitively harm competitors in various industries. The most common one, that is in the news, is the App Store situation, where literal laws are being passed to ban Apple's behavior. But it also applies to other parts of their business, such as ads. There could be a push to pass laws to make Apple's behavior illegal in those spaces as well.
- mynameisvlad 4y agoThis comment thread- and in fact this entire post- is about services, and milking users via services. While certainly true, I don't see how any of that is relevant in the context of this thread.
- theplumber 4y agoAre you aware of the vendor lock-in concept? Combine that with a duopoly and you get your answer about milking and Apple holding a gun to consumers heads. It's almost a "natural" path for monopolistic companies. Once it got enough market share it starts milking it. Android(google play services) and IOS lock-in is the gun you keep asking for. The whole article is about Apple switching from major hardware upgrades/innovation to charging existing customers more for services. One simple case is storage. Would would Apple provide you greater storage capacity when they can milk you more using a "cloud" subscription.
- theplumber 4y agoYea, just like Intel has been milking existing customers. For monopolistic companies milking is their main business.
- sgmoore 4y agoYes. I guess you have never been near a dairy farm at milking time and seen the cows queue up, or hear the noise they make if they are not milked.
- theplumber 4y agoThank you! You've just made my day!
- sem000 4y agoGotta love HN... always acting like Apple is holding a gun to consumers heads.
- belval 4y agoRealistically (and I am not singling out Apple here), we are more and more captive of an ecosystem. My Android phone is needed to login to most online service through 2FA, I can pay with it, have my calendar and emails on it. Losing my phone at this point is worse than losing my wallet and Apple is pushing for even tighter integrations with their customer's life which will ultimately centralize all that information.
- sem000 4y ago>Realistically (and I am not singling out Apple here), we are more and more captive of an ecosystem. Yes, we definitely are. But I am not so sure that is a bad thing? And it's nothing new... how many businesses had their entire operations tied to Blackberry, Microsoft, Lotus, etc. for so long? The market might be a little slow, but it's not stupid. I personally like Apple products and services. I like the integration. I like that I don't have to go out and find third party apps for certain things and hope for the best. > Losing my phone at this point is worse than losing my wallet and Apple is pushing for even tighter integrations with their customer's life which will ultimately centralize all that information. The great thing about this is a replacement phone can be loaded almost instantaneously with all your info again. How long would it take to have every credit card company and the DMV send you replacements?
- stale2002 4y ago> Yes, we definitely are. But I am not so sure that is a bad thing? Well, it is the basis of anti-trust law and pro-competition law, that the legal system supports competition and opposes anti-competitive effects.
- whatarethembits 4y agoIf I lost my iPhone (and the FindMy network wasn’t able to locate it), the watch can get me by just fine as if nothing even happened. Oh and this was all setup in a couple of minutes when first buying the watch, so unlikely to be in a situation where the watch can’t adequately take over phone duties because I didn’t dedicate a semester to set everything up and keep it in sync on a regular basis. It’s all automatic. Integrated devices > non-integrated devices all day long. Back to the lost phone; I would then walk into an Apple store when time permits, and get or buy a replacement (depending on Apple care coverage status) phone, enter my Apple ID on the new phone and voila its in the exact state as the old one before leaving the store. End of saga, I go meetup with mates as planned in the evening. Try to do the same with non-Apple ecosystem or with physical cards and keys. I wish there were (dependable) options, but other large organisations have proven to be utterly incompetent in this area. They have no vision and/or ability to pull off something like this. Or their own actions have made their reputation unpalatable even if they somehow offered it in the future. Also I hate having to remember to carry five different things every time I leave the house, and feel the sensation of those bulky items moving around in my pocket while walking (Europe, we walk a lot) or running. And I hate having to be limited to trousers/joggers/shorts that have deep enough pockets to fit all those items in, and them falling out while out for a run etc etc etc.
- 2Gkashmiri 4y ago>the next big thing is milking/squeezing the existing customers through services i am NOT a subscriber to netflix et al. never have been and actively avoid signing up to "trial services" because it could potentially hook me up good. maybe these people are gullible enough to be convinced enough to be parted with their money, that's fine. you see, there is "EVIDENCE" in support of cigarettes causing cancer but instead of banning the sales, governments milk it for taxes, the companies say "if someone is willing to pay, why not us" and the blame is on the user..... the same thing with alcohol and weed and stuff like that. Most of the world has grown around alcohol and even when EVERYONE knows its not healthy for the body, people still consume it, "its traditional". if people want to not own stuff, want netflix style monthly payments to have their whole life managed by apple, good for these people because then they dont have to pay individually for a bank, for a cable tv, for a cell phone company, for internet, for transport, for education, for security, for netflix, disney, hbo, prime and all that.
- theplumber 4y agoBig companies can excert influence and change behaviours. Consider this as a drug dealer who gives you a free trial.
- 2Gkashmiri 4y agoyes, that is what i am saying. there are people who avoid smoking cigarettes or take alcohol for all their lives even in the face of freebies. they aren't swayed by them but then there are people who are swayed. if cigarette makers and breweries can continue and expand their business, so can apple and it would be just the same thing imo
- Aperocky 4y ago> looked at possible candidates for Apple’s NBT (Next Big Thing), a product category that could launch an iPhone-like growth wave Is this what drove Facebook, a slowing but otherwise perfectly healthy cash cow into the disaster that is Metaverse? If Apple is going to do the same, my popcorn is ready.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoMaybe the difference was that Facebook was a one-trick pony that, unlike Apple, soiled their brand rather than bolstered it?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Aperocky 4y agohindsight is 2020. What I'm referring to is instead of coming up with something that could be a game changer organically, forcing it because "We need a big idea now". That has a much higher chance to fail.
- yurishimo 4y agoI think this is why it’s taken so long to release the VR headset. It’s obviously been functional for years at this point and there are tons of other headsets on the market proving there is at least some demand. But I think apple is taking it slow and waiting for the right opportunity rather than shoehorn it in at the last second of Q4 to bolster EOY earnings. Same with the car. I’m more skeptical of that project ever seeing the light of day, but there is no doubt that apple has the resources to bring that product to market if they wanted to, but they’re also smart enough to read the room.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoI'm not sure it's obvious there is demand. You say "tons off other headsets" but it still feels very niche to me.
- traceroute66 4y agoHonestly, for anyone who watches Apple close enough, this isn't news. Its clear Apple are heading down the disruptive disintermediation route. Look at the Air Tag. Effectively killing off competitors by making use of the global network of Apple devices. Look at their recent BNPL (buy now, pay later) announcement for example. Managing the whole caboodle, including the finance itself, entirely internally. Or look at the fact they still haven't rolled out Apple card internationally. My uninformed guess is that it is more to do with "something's brewing" rather than the US cards not working. Their recent satphone announcement. Clearly that's just the start. I think most people are guessing the endgame will be carrier disintermediation. And frankly, given how shit most cell carriers are, I can't wait for Apple to come along and give the incumbents a run for their money.
- convolvatron 4y agowhy do you call it disintermediation? apple is still the big intermediate here
- mikeyouse 4y agoIntermediate to what? They own the software, hardware, and are moving toward owning the network and billing relationship.. Intermediate between consumers and app builders maybe, but as they build more features into their own devices (e.g. Apple Maps), even those relationships are being brought into the ecosystem.
- efaref 4y agoThe real word here is "monopolisation".
- arcticbull 4y agoA monopoly would require they control the entire market for a given product or service. Apple isn't a monopoly in any area - but they are a strong competitor in many areas. They're more like a western take on a chaebol [1] in my opinion. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaebol https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaebol
- klelatti 4y agoApple has never been a 'pure' hardware builder. It's always been a systems integrator: hardware, software on your device, closely integrating open source in some cases (Unix / Webkit) then moving to link other devices (iTunes). It's just extending that integration more widely into the cloud and other services. In some ways its surprising they haven't done more of it already.
- candiddevmike 4y agoAds are the next big thing for Apple. You can see it in their job postings and their attempts at increasing ad real estate across their products.
- arkitaip 4y agoI hope they go down that route and get utterly demolished by the courts for disabling the competition in favor of their own ad network.
- nojito 4y agoNot possible without being a monopoly.
- pjerem 4y agoIt never happened in a decade of App Store. Why would it happen with an ad network?
- stale2002 4y agoThe reason why it would happen is because there has been a massive legal push to sue Apple, or pass new laws that make their behavior illegal. And these laws have passed, and are going to go into effect soon, and there is little Apple can do to stop it.
- solarkraft 4y agoNever happened? Every search I can think of had an ad covering half or more of my screen (full with the keyboard still enabled). Mostly of terrible low-quality apps you'd rather expect on the Microsoft store too. There's a whole tab for "curated" content. The whole App Store is one big "ew" experience. It's what you'd expect from other companies. ... and the rest of iOS already shows similar elements. Setting up an iPhone recently I think I saw 3 full screen ads for Apple services. From what I remember it would be a lot more if I used more first-party apps. What a disappointing way to ruin an otherwise pretty nice experience!
- gfodor 4y agoApple is going to have everyone wearing a passthrough AR visor by 2025.
- Wherecombinator 4y agoI think the same. When they do AR I believe they’ll do it much better than anyone else. They’ll be some really cool feature that will make people flock to it, like apps on the iPhone.
- nottorp 4y agoI was hoping that will happen with the apple watch, but so far it just brings the notification spam to your wrist and does fitness/health monitoring if you care about that. What will the AR glasses do, bring the notifications that I have turned off anyway in my face?
- whywhywhywhy 4y agoThe notification thing really made my despise the Apple Watch, caused me way too much anxiety had to turn all those features off. I'd wear a screenless Apple band with just the health sensors but I wont wear a notification distraction on my wrist again.
- nottorp 4y ago> caused me way too much anxiety had to turn all those features off Good. You have seen the light. Now turn off those notifications on your phone too. Much improved quality of life.
- gfodor 4y agoMy personal hypothesis is they're going to lean in to perceptual enhancement. Passthrough AR will allow them to basically apply arbitrary correction and filtering to your vision, so in conjunction with their expertise on photo processing and general AR tech I think the idea will be that wearing these will make everything around you just look and feel better.
- alexb_ 4y agoThe moment that apple announced "privacy" as their focus I knew this was going to happen. They don't actually care about user privacy, but rather want exclusive rights to all of your data so that they can sell it for a markup. If you want to sell targeted ads to anyone using an Apple device, you'll have to let Apple do the targeting (and take their cut). Get customers locked into the apple ecosystem, "protect" them from non-apple marketers, and then sell access to the giant Apple userbase at a big cost. What's really worrying is that having Apple gatekeep advertisers gives them the power to dictate what platforms can get ads vs what platforms can't. Letting Apple decide what platforms/services get their potential ad revenue cut in half is not a good thing.
- throwayyy479087 4y agoI truly believe the privacy mission is personal to Tim Cook: it was a much smaller deal under Jobs, and Tim Cook was bullied for being gay in Mobile. It makes sense as a lens to view some of their other choices, too. I think that's absolutely beautiful and very human.
- rvnx 4y agoIsn't it the business model of Google that you are describing in some way instead ? "We don't sell or share your data so we can be the only ones who have access to it for advertising purposes"
- alexb_ 4y agoCorrect, and Google makes gigantic fuckloads of money doing that. It's no wonder Apple wants to do it as well. Apple having direct hardware access and aggressively locking in their customers makes this an extra degree worse for the consumer/better for Apple. At least with Google, it's easier to stop using it.
- joshmanders 4y agoWhy would Apple see what Google is doing in ads and want to do that too... Google's marketcap is half of what Apple's is... If anything Apple should keep what they're doing up, because they're clearly doing better than Google.
- intrasight 4y ago> The unacknowledged Apple Car (the “Titan” project), Augmented Reality (AR) devices, and forays into the healthcare market, none of which is a feasible candidate So wrong. PDAs were replaced by smartphones. Smartphones will be replaced by AR glasses. It is the next big thing hardware-wise. Many new services will be built upon glasses and watches, and many will be health related. You'll still buy a phone - it'll have the battery and the supercomputer powering the other two. I doubt that it will even have a display.
- raverbashing 4y agoDoubt. Strong doubt As much as people are glued to their devices, looking away is still a thing Nobody will want ads or distractions in their field of view (maaybe in very exceptional circumstances but even then) It will probably also be illegal to drive using an AR device.
- wbsss4412 4y agoWhile I’m sure AR glasses are coming and will be popular, the notion that they’ll be so popular that smart phones won’t even have screens is particularly bold. Smartphones didn’t replace PDAs, most people didn’t have a PDA to replace. Smart phones replaced whole categories of devices and bundled them into one: cameras, camera phones, PDAs, MP3 players, watches, timers, alarm clocks etc. People keep looking for “the next big thing” and it just isn’t coming. The smartphone was a singular event in the history of computing and it wont be replicated within our lifetimes. At most it will be unbundled again, unevenly (eg, smart watches, and glasses)
- mojuba 4y ago> People keep looking for “the next big thing” and it just isn’t coming. Or... what if the next big thing is the phone becomes the computer, i.e. there will be no laptops? Imagine a device that you can connect to some peripherals including a monitor (possibly with its own GPU), then you undock it, put it in your pocket and move on to the next place - your home or your work with peripherals ready to use. Today it seems impossible or hard to build but I think the bottleneck here is not even the hardware as much as it's software. But that's a long conversation. Just an idea (kind of an obvious one) I wanted to share.
- ibn_khaldun 4y agoThis was a nice, brief informative and insightful blog post. As a business model I understand what Apple is doing and can register the strategy as calculated. As an Apple consumer, I am not that interested. Sometime after inheriting a pair of AirPod Pros and an Apple Watch I started to feel strange. Then I booted OpenBSD on my own hardware for the first time the other day, straight into the shell and I feel changed by how brutal (as in architecture, aesthetics) the experience was. I find it distracting even to use my MacBook now. The colors, the textures, etc. I just feel different now. Apple is offering a lot of convenience, apparently. The watch is convenient. The AirPods that dig into my ear canals and make me mistake audiobooks and podcasts for my own thoughts are…disturbing…but convenient as a Bluetooth headset? As a consumer and user of these devices I just feel somewhere between recognizing these new conveniences but being disturbed by them and distracted even after some time.
- CharlesW 4y ago> The AirPods that dig into my ear canals and make me mistake audiobooks and podcasts for my own thoughts… Neat, is that an iOS 16 feature? But seriously, there are things you can do to reclaim your attention span. Here are a few: https://medium.com/make-time/six-years-with-a-distraction-free-iphone-8cf5eb4f97e3 https://medium.com/make-time/six-years-with-a-distraction-fr... https://hulry.com/ios-15-focus-mode/ https://hulry.com/ios-15-focus-mode/ https://www.wired.com/story/grayscale-ios-android-smartphone-addiction/ https://www.wired.com/story/grayscale-ios-android-smartphone...
- ibn_khaldun 4y agoI’ve actually been in the process of doing something similar to what’s described in the Medium article. I’ve tried to grayscale thing out before too but I switch back after some time. I think what I’m getting out for myself is more so a UX issue? I’m not sure. It’s not a matter of attention span with me specifically. But the look and feel of certain Apple devices as a whole makes me feel like someone who I’d hate to become. I could still see myself using an iPad or a Mac mini or something like that, because I’ve taking a liking for some of the things those devices have to offer for specific tasks. But I would love for my phone to just be a concrete brick that can spit out thermal printed slips of paper with messages on it as text messaging and emails. And if only voice calls were a distributed mesh of Solo cups and strings.
- JKCalhoun 4y ago> Nonetheless, I still want to see an Apple Car and see the company’s still working on that bet as a potential head against incrementalism. Perhaps me meant a "hedge" against incrementalism. Am I the only one that does not want to see an Apple car? We already have Tesla, I would rather see more inexpensive (electric, I assume) cars.
- Apocryphon 4y agoThey oughta work on an Apple train
- ComplexSystems 4y agoI would be much happier with something like an Apple Surface.
- jliptzin 4y agoI wish huge companies like Apple would just be happy with being #1 in their category, collecting their enormous profits and paying out dividends to shareholders, instead of feeling the need to take over the world.
- shapefrog 4y agoSo no itunes, no ipod, no iphones, no apps, no watch, no airpods, no M1 chips, nada...
- jliptzin 4y agoThose are all improvements to their main product lines. I’m talking about apple car or credit cards or whatever else they’re going to do. If people at apple want to build a car they should form a new company to do it. I don’t want my phone, computer, car, and credit card all issued by the same company.
- yunwal 4y agoThe iPod wasn't a main product when it was introduced. Honestly, if Apple wants to make a car, I'm all for it. What I don't like is that they seem to be ditching their hardware innovation in favor of SAAS like all the other tech companies. It's lazy and all with the hopes of surrounding you with marketing.
- jliptzin 4y agoThe problem for me is even if they release a car way better than anything else out there I’m not going to buy it, I don’t want to be so dependent on one company.
- yunwal 4y agoSure, but that doesn’t seem like a problem to me. In that case you just choose to not buy the car, and there is relatively little impact to you. The SAAS model thing is annoying because it seems like it’s ruining a good thing
- superdug 4y agoAm I a realist on Apple Apologist? My primary credit card is an apple card, primary dev machine is a mbp, primary work machine iPad, phone iPhone, watch Apple, and I have air tags attached to my dogs and wallet. In this ecosystem, I can reference _ANY_ of my screens for necessary and current relevant information whether it be curated or automated without breaking a glance to whatever primary device the content came from. I can air drop to my screens and other people in my family whenever I want to share anything from any of my devices. It's a walled garden sure, but the toys in here are fantastic. I also have Apple One service because of the iCloud storage alone between devices and Apple Music/News is actually a nice service. So I guess I understand the "Oh no big company taking over more of my stuff that I think I should diversify because it seems like the right thing to do", but I guess I'm just too used to things just functioning well that I get over how "limited" I am.
- joshmanders 4y agoI'm in the same boat, the walled garden is too good to ignore.
- gnicholas 4y agoI understand airtagging a dog, but how do you fit one in your wallet? Are you worried about misplacing it in your home, leaving it behind somewhere else, or theft? I like airtags and use them myself, but never considered using it with a wallet.
- superdug 4y agoIt's just a wallet with a bubble on the outside shell that holds the air-tag in it ... doesn't stick out too far and fits fine in my pocket
- CharlesW 4y agoIn my case, first I used https://www.amazon.com/TagVault-Standard-Flexible-Pending-Elevation/dp/B09GTVRVLC https://www.amazon.com/TagVault-Standard-Flexible-Pending-El..., and now I use https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0975HFFMM/ https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0975HFFMM/. It has alerted me to the wallet being left behind, and a few times I've used the AirTag to find the wallet in the house. The big downside to AirTags right now is missing family support. We hid AirTags on the kids' bikes, but only my wife can see them.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- abudabi123 4y agoThe Apple Watch and Augmented Reality facemask for extreme sports wayfinding and monitoring other complications in deep dark cave dive rescue mission are challenging usecases for marketing in the style of Rolex.
- gigel82 4y agoThe next big thing for Apple (which they've actually been working on for a while) is ads. They plan on taking down Google and Facebook in one fell swoop. They are the most heinous, disingenuous, evil empire ever. I always get downvoted when making this comment, I just hope that the "blind believers" of today will remember their mistake a few years down the line when the "privacy" house of cards comes tumbling down.
- pwinnski 4y agoYou might get downvoted because your comment is evidence-free, filled with hyperbolic value judgments, and runs counter to general observation. It is difficult to imagine what Apple could do to top Google, Facebook, or even Microsoft on a list of evil empires, ever.
- specialist 4y agoGassée (and others) misunderstands Apple's health strategy wrt wearables (watch, earbuds). Rosalind Picard's (and others) work on affective computing shows the potential. Here's her interview w/ Lex Fridman. https://lexfridman.com/rosalind-picard/ https://lexfridman.com/rosalind-picard/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affective_computing#Physiological_monitoring https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affective_computing#Physiologi... I have no idea if "quantified self" is Apple's NBT, a $1T market. I do know that affective computing will be a game changer. And currently Apple's watch is running away with that emerging market.
- anotherOneSound 4y ago> The numbers aren’t directly disclosed but reliable sources estimate tens of billions of dollars in net revenue apple is the source[1] no estimating required. all publicly traded companies, required by law. some math is required, many videos on youtube detailing the process. it can be automated, JSON is available. they are called balance sheets, M.shkreli actually has a video series going through these [1]https://sec.report/CIK/0000320193 https://sec.report/CIK/0000320193 look for 10-Q, 10-K; quarterly, annual
- 8jef 4y agoApple never invented anything. They always took something that already was nichely popular (Nokia's smartphones, Creative's MP3 players, PCs), then improved upon those things just enough to make them palatable to the masses, logo included. It's not a mystery why they've recently invested heavily in AR and electric transportation: these are two newish hardware things that still badly need to be improved upon. Unfortunately, all the money in the world cannot replace Steve Job's balls, wild flair and decisiveness. Sadly, lawyers and MBAs have taken over Apple since he departed. Other products and things newly invented are just not quite niche enough to mandate an Apple R&D budget. At any rate, Apple's still massively selling to post modern urban peasants, so fear not, they'll be around until the rise of the next great ballsy marketer.