6 ms·
> Using three separate identification strategies we show that, controlling for own-vehicle weight, being hit by a vehicle that is 1000 pounds heavier generates
by neilv 4y ago
> Using three separate identification strategies we show that, controlling for own-vehicle weight, being hit by a vehicle that is 1000 pounds heavier generates a 40–50% increase in fatality risk. [...] We consider two policies for internalizing this external cost, a weight-varying mileage tax and a gas tax, and find that they are similar for most vehicles. The findings suggest that European gas taxes may be much closer to optimal levels than the US gas tax.
In an environment of wealth inequality, this seems like another way that the wealthy can benefit: easily afford to drive heavier vehicles that increase their personal safety while increasing the lethal threats against the poor.
How about instead: if larger vehicles are more dangerous for the population overall, then they should be banned for everyone, not only effectively off-limits to the poor.
- kippster 4y agoPoor people drive pickup trucks too
- brutal_chaos_ 4y agoAnd would be eventually priced out by something like this.
- rootusrootus 4y agoThey'd drive them a lot less with European levels of gasoline tax.
- cdot2 4y agoLots of poor people actually need those vehicles. They would just suffer from having to pay the taxes.
- SECProto 4y agoI work construction. at least half of the people on the same jobs as me drive their personal trucks 80km to work, park them until the end of the day, and drive home. Not a single tool in them. The other half drive sedans.
- throwaway742 4y agoYeah my girlfriend works construction and drives a Honda Civic. It fits all her tools just fine. On the job she drives a company truck. Still 75% of her coworkers drive their own personal trucks to work. It is more of a cultural thing.
- Thlom 4y agoIn my neck of the woods the foreman/boss often drive a nice pickup, but he never has anything on the flatbed. The guys actually building drive a Hiace or Sprinter or something like that (company vehicle).
- mike_d 4y agoYou probably see a ton of trade vehicles with tools in them, you just don't associate them as personal vehicles. Or your project is only subbing out to commercial trade companies.
- SECProto 4y agoNo, it's because I work in civil construction. "Tools" are brought to site on flatbed trailers or in panel vans. Foremen drive company branded pickups, they move smaller tools around site. Most crew drive their personal vehicles to site as described above, and the only gear they have is a safety vest, boots, and their lunch.
- fmkamchatka 4y agoDo they really need a pickup truck? There are so many alternatives to carry around loads which are much lighter. What do you think construction workers and farmers use in Europe?
- atoav 4y agoMy farmer neighbour had one beatdown VW polo that he used for the field or the woods. Full motor swap for 500 €, a good car.
- Ekaros 4y agoMostly vans I believe. With roofrack or trailer if something longer is transported. Or just get it delivered by actual truck.
- jbay808 4y agoIn Japan they mostly use Kei trucks, which weigh around 700 kg (1600 lbs).
- jononomo 4y agoI can count on one hand the time I have seen someone driving a pickup truck with something actually in the back of the truck -- and it doesn't even make sense to put anything in the back of the truck unless you bring a stepladder with you as well in case you need to retrieve it.
- pandaman 4y agoNot to mention that the IRS requires a vehicle to be at least 6000 pounds in order to deprecate for business purposes. Buying anything under 6000 pounds for business means paying more taxes.
- SECProto 4y agoNote that a 6000lb minimum rules out the f150, the best selling vehicle in North America. Tax considerations can't be too top of mind.
- pandaman 4y agoNot according to a google search for "6000 pounds vehicle list".
- red369 4y agoDoesn’t look like any of the 2021 F-150s are over 6000 pounds curb weight (1). It’s not particularly close, so I would expect most of the newer model would be under 6000 pounds too (I didn’t easily find the newer brochure) (1) https://media.ford.com/content/dam/fordmedia/North%20America/US/product/2021/f150/pdfs/2021-F-150-Technical-Specs.pdf https://media.ford.com/content/dam/fordmedia/North%20America...
- argiopetech 4y agoCurb weight is an irrelevant number, interesting only to calculate payload (which many ignore, albeit at their peril). The number of interest for regulators is Gross Vehicle Weight Rating (GVWR), as that's the manufacturer's specification of the heaviest the vehicle can be in as-sold configuration and still drive down the road safely.
- SECProto 4y agoThanks for the clarification. The lowest GVWR among the f150s is about 6010 lbs which makes the IRS' apparently minimum weight make more sense. > Curb weight is an irrelevant number, interesting only to calculate payload (which many ignore, albeit at their peril). Not just their peril, also any road users or others nearby. If you've ever seen an overloaded pickup, they tend to drift around their lane as all the extra weight in the back reduces the steering authority on the front. Double so if it's pulling a badly loaded trailer that puts a lot of weight on the hitch
- badpun 4y agoLots of poor people work construction in Europe too, and they do fine without gigantic pickup trucks.
- iamacyborg 4y agoSadly, pickups are becoming more and more common from what I've seen over the last couple years in London.
- Matthias247 4y ago+1. Hardly ever have seen a pickup in germany. Most trade companies will use vans.
- noobermin 4y agoThere's a tweet I read that says something along the lines, "as long as any change, despite how beneficial for most poor people will hurt some poor people, it is the progressive position such change is bad. From that the progressive position is keep everything the same." The irony is of course that poor people disproportionately suffer from car fatalities, so "change" is already being wrought on them by the increasing size of cars and increasingly more expensive and difficult car culture. They just lack the voice (or awareness really) that middle class people who want to protect their position and privilege do, and the latter do not hesitate to use the poor as props whom they otherwise have contempt for the moment they need relief in other areas.
- mike_d 4y agoThis is overly dismissive of a legitimate concern. Laborers, tradesmen, and people who can only afford a single vehicle that must meet all their needs predominately try to get trucks and SUVs. Just because you can bike to work does not mean everyone else has the same luxury.
- rightbyte 4y agoYou can have vans with a front like regular cars, too. Where I live exactly zero carpenters have pickup trucks or SUVs. There is never a need for SUVs in suburban settings. Pickup trucks atleast has some theoretical utility.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoThe problem is there are some legitimate uses for a heavy vehicle. 99% of trips can be done in a 400kg LEV or even a 30kg single occupant vehicle, but some tasks legitimately require a 3 tonne truck. Maybe add additional license classes with stricter requirements (like needing a per-trip permit for use in some areas) or move any new vehicle to existing heavy vehicle licenses?
- sidpatil 4y ago> 99% of trips can be done in a 400kg LEV or even a 30kg single occupant vehicle, but some tasks legitimately require a 3 tonne truck. If that's the case, it might be more economical to do the majority of work with a smaller vehicle, and rent the larger vehicle when necessary.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoI more meant that the need effectively allows bad faith actors who want but do not need a large vehicle to leverage that legitimate need hold people who do not need or want a large vehicle hostage by filling the streets with them and constantly yelling about how small vehicles are dangerous. The way out is difficult.
- pjerem 4y ago1% of 365 days is less than four days a year. So you say me you buy and drive an expensive, heavy and polluting vehicle that consumes a lot year long because you barely need it four days in the whole year. Vs renting a generously sized truck when you really need it ? It’s not worth it, either for you and for everyone else.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoBuddy, my primary transport is a bicycle. If I need to go further I use a train. If I need to take stuff I usually use an industrial tricycle with a 250W motor. I only use an ICE vehicle if it's unsafe to go somewhere because LEVs are illegal and there are unavoidable which roads are built to kill me if I don't get in a protective metal box. My point was the 1% of trips are used to make doing things the sane way unsafe and ban sensible vehicles from the road. Getting us out of this tarpit where you must join the murder brigade or be killed is the hard bit when you can't just ban them outright and any effective regulation would be an even worse mess of regulatory capture.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- exclipy 4y agoWhat if there was an additional tax on your income for driving a heavy vehicle? In my country (Australia), we have an additional income tax if you don't have health insurance (point is to get more people to pay for private health insurance so the government's universal health care isn't as loaded). As a result, everyone earning over $xxx,xxx buys health insurance because it's literally cheaper than not getting it. Imagine if the best income tax avoidance scheme was "don't own a big car"...
- thih9 4y agoIsn't it relatively easy to bypass? The legal owner and the person that actually uses the car might be different people. E.g. a family might swap cars to lower their taxes.
- jackvalentine 4y agoGood point. Tie it to the registration cost.
- flakeoil 4y agoThat's why it's better to tax the energy itself directly. Instead of inventing a lot of complicated tax schemes and deductions and incentives, just increase the tax on gasoline/diesel. It steers people to fuel efficient cars, which steers the manufacturers to provide those cars.
- ajmurmann 4y agoThe comment that started this thread though was about rich people being able to just pay the tax which is relatively smaller to them. Hence the idea to couple it to income.
- flakeoil 4y agoYou are right. And the simplest solution to this is to increase the cost of fuel /energy (typically by increasing taxes on it). This automatically directs us in the right direction. More fuel efficient cars. Or public transport and bicycles instead of cars. Same with electricity. It also has to cost more. Right now electric cars are not very good for the environment either. They are bigger than necessary and consume too much electricity. Unfortunately governments have never managed or dared to increase it. And unfortunately it often creates a lot of tension among the population. The population likes to complain that it is the banks which are to blame (because the invest or lend to oil companies) or that the oil companies are to blame. But it is the people using the cars (unnecessarily big cars) which are to blame. And the politicians which do not enforce a higher cost on burning energy, by not increasing taxes on energy usage. Due to the war in Ukraine we finally see some movement on this and it will become more important with energy efficiency and finally we see even governments send out flyers and inform of methods to save on energy. Why did they not do that before? There has been those COP meetings with presidents for over 20 years, but they have not been capable of doing the most basic things because they are afraid of affecting growth. Unfortunately they don't understand that a fuel efficient car can transport as much as a non-fuel efficient car.
- retcore 4y agoInstead of insurance deductibles, how about a third party accident claim payout strikeout limit? It could be quite high, say a million dollars or two, but this would still open the driver to unlimited liability for litigation in the event of reckless negligence litigation claims. I would also set a mandatory minimum compensation level to unrepresented accident victims in a similar range, possibly paid in escrow for medical expenses and family care. My thinking is partially in response to earlier comments about the wealthy just not being bothered by the cost of their own relative safety while driving the heaviest vehicles. That really ought to be tested imo.
- bluecalm 4y agoYeah but it's not as big of a problem. Sure, no one driving SUVs is a slightly better outcome than only rich people driving them but the main gain is in preventing majority from driving them. Straight up ban is just very unlikely to happen for political reasons while making it more and more expensive and inconvenient might work.
- dontlaugh 4y agoYou are correct. The same mistake is made with emissions, like London's LEZ/ULEZ. The enforcement is a fixed fee and the criteria allows large new vehicles even if their emissions per passenger are much worse than many disallowed small older vehicles. The rich get to not care.
- fennecfoxy 4y agoYup, things like 8L Lambos are ULEZ compliant! Giant Rolls SUVs, also compliant. What a fucking joke.
- P5fRxh5kUvp2th 4y agoHow about we stop attributing everything to an attack on the poor by the rich?
- lostmsu 4y agoThe paper actually does not show that larger vehicles are more dangerous for the population overall.
- davidguetta 4y agoYeah let's ban everything that's vaguely dangerous.