12 ms·
How does the land use of different electricity sources compare?
- Grimburger 4y agoThere's a lot of R&D and experimental work being done on Agrivoltiacs, but no clear winners. Raising the panels high enough for machinery adds a lot to costs. Reduced light means only small subset of crops can be grown. For the most part it seems to do ok as is with grazing animals on land unviable for cropping but there's always tradeoffs. Surprised how high concentrated solar is though. I would have thought it is more efficient than PV, but guess not
- Melatonic 4y agoThere are actually a lot of people who think it increases overall efficiency for some farms - mainly in areas with more sun / hotter temps / less water. If you have a less dense amount of photovoltaics then you still get quite a bit of sun and they end up reducing the amount of water evaporated by quite a bit which is very important for growing crops in areas like California. We could end up with much higher overall land use efficiency.
- ncmncm 4y agoThere is no need to "raise panels high enough". Bifacial panels may be erected vertically, in fencerows running north/south, with room for farm equipment to run between. Crops and livestock both do better with shade, evaporation loss is lower, and picking up morning and afternoon sun matches the demand curve better. There is no need to pack the rows tightly, because there is way, way, way more pasture and crop land than could ever be needed for solar. All the revenue the panels provide is extra, on top of revenue from existing land use. Solar floating on reservoirs, bays, and canals also "takes up" no land area, while it reduces evaporation loss, operates more efficiently kept cool, cuts biofouling, and provides protected habitat underneath. The desert is a particularly dumb place to put solar panels: the panels get hot and dusty, cutting production, and the high temperature reduces both useful panel life and reliability. But ignorant investors love desert solar, so we are getting a great deal of desert solar. Concentrated solar thermal will always be a minor player, but the desert is a reasonable place for it. It is a better source of process heat than electricity, but we do need a great deal of industrial process heat.
- ehnto 4y ago> Bifacial panels may be erected vertically, in fencerows running north/south, with room for farm equipment to run between. For specific crops, and specific approaches to cultivation and harvesting. It's still a limiting factor.
- ncmncm 4y agoBifacial fencerow panels work with almost any crop, orchards perhaps excepted. Since there is so overwhelmingly more land available to put solar on than is needed, only the very best-suited for it need be used. Some crops do better under horizontal panels, protected by them from harsh rain- and hailstorms. Since there is no need to pack the panels as tightly as they could possibly fit, you can leave plenty of room between for farm tractors. Most stuff towed behind a farm tractor lies much lower, and has no difficulty running under panels mounted at head height. We may count on farmers to decide how best to deploy solar in their own fields, without second-guessing them.
- ehnto 4y agoI am not saying there are no applications, it's a good idea. It needs to work for the farming process though, not the crop. At a certain scale of farm, small machines are not being used. Again, it would work sure, but it would take a lot of changes for many farms to implement it.
- doitLP 4y agoCan anyone explain the assertion that “we’ll run out of land before ever can put in enough solar”. I’ve seen a lot of articles and interviews that say that, but then a whole bunch that don’t even mention the high amount of land use and seem to think that’s not a problem. Any explanation or good articles would be helpful.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 4y agoI don't have much to add here, other than a lot of land isn't suitable for solar. From not enough light to too much heat, there's less available land than you'd think.
- standardUser 4y agoThere's vastly more land than is needed for any reasonable mix of solar in a post-carbon world. There's just also lots of speculative and unreasonable scenarios one can dream up if they want to argue otherwise.
- ncmncm 4y agoAs Hamlet said, "It's as easy as lying."
- Aachen 4y agoOWID says 19–13m²/MWh depending on the panel type, no idea for which location but let's go with 15 m² for a rough idea. We need about 900 TWh of energy in the country. A calculator tells me that's $ calc 900TWh/MWh\*(15m^2) (900 \* ((terawatt \* hour) / (megawatt \* hour))) \* (15 \* (meter^2)) = 13500 km^2 The country is about 42000 km² big. We won't want to get 100% of energy from photovoltaic, but also we'll need overcapacity to compensate for losses in storage and, to a lesser extent, transmission. Presumably, the land is currently not unused. I don't know what area is currently used by roofs and parking lots, that would be interesting to put this in perspective. I was under the impression that roofs are not enough by far; perhaps it works when we add parking lots and cover all roads, or perhaps my knowledge is outdated (also because batteries have evolved since I first heard that). Either way, we'd have to cover gigantic amounts of land with electronics. Not saying it can't be done (I don't know enough about it), but not having any hydro to speak of, little space far enough from villages for wind, and no nuclear in the mix for the sake of argument... it sure seems daunting.
- elevaet 4y agoThis really highlights one of the big advantages for nuclear on this crowded planet. I wonder how it would look if you factor in land that has become unusable (to humans) by disasters like Chernobyl and Fukushima, amortized appropriately of course. Perhaps this was accounted for already.
- ncmncm 4y agoIt is always easy to promote your favorite by lying. the article author's favorite is obvious. Solar, of course, does not need to take up any land at all, as it easily coexists with existing uses, whether reservoirs and canals, pasture and cropland, or industrial rooftops. Wind, similarly. And a nuke, in the US, always fills a square mile. Then there are the uranium mines and tailings beds.
- jrockway 4y agoIs the planet crowded? Whenever I go on a road trip I certainly don't get that impression. There's 20 minutes of cities, an hour of outskirts, then 4 hours of nothing. People don't want to live that far away from everyone else, in general, but wind turbines and solar panels don't get as lonely. All you really have to worry about are resistive losses when bringing the electricity to the people, and that seems very manageable. It's also a problem with nuclear because nobody really wants to live next door to a nuclear power plant. One "hold my beer!" away from being the next "Damn Interesting" article in the lost cities category.
- elevaet 4y agoI mean "crowded" is relative, but yeah I'd say we're crowding the planet. There's precious little wilderness left [1]. Livestock outweighs wild mammals by a factor of 10:1 [2]. The chicken is the most common bird, 15x the runner up [3]. Flying insects are down 75% or more since ~1990 [4]. The reefs are dying, we're dumping CO2 into the atmosphere and cooking the planet, there's plastic getting everywhere in the ocean. Maybe "crowded" is a loaded term and I can see why someone might object when they drive through the countryside and all they can see is miles of roads and fields, but we're stripping the planet of biodiversity, and gobbling all the resources we can. We're shifting the planet is shifting from a biological system to an industrial one. It's not all bad, and at heart I really do believe humans are the most precious creature here, but we're shitting the bed and spoiling our own cradle. Lately, nuclear has started looking like a necessary tool if we're going to have any chance at tackling climate change. 1. https://www.science.org/content/article/just-19-earth-s-land-still-wild-analysis-suggests https://www.science.org/content/article/just-19-earth-s-land... 2. https://ourworldindata.org/life-on-earth https://ourworldindata.org/life-on-earth 3. https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/most-populous-bird-species-in-the-world.html https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/most-populous-bird-speci... 4. https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0185809 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...
- davidkuennen 4y agoI don't get why we (Germany) don't support PV on roofs much more than we do right now.
- ncmncm 4y agoIt costs more to put them on residential roofs. It is cheap on industrial and warehouse roofs, and extends the life of the roof. But they coexist well with pasture and crop land uses, too, as well as reservoirs and canals. So space for solar is absolutely abundant everywhere.
- DoingIsLearning 4y ago> It costs more to put them on residential roofs. If you mean slanted shingle roofs the installation is still trivial. There are also plenty of flat residential roofs which are exactly the same as an 'industrial' roof.
- jasonwatkinspdx 4y agoNo, what the comment says above is correct: there's a rather dramatic difference in levelized costs between utility scale solar and rooftop residential solar. Commercial rooftop solar is only slightly better than residential. There's multiple factors that feed into this, such as how much supporting infrastructure is amortized vs scale, being able to design the array for optimal lighting vs working with an existing building, systematic regular cleaning to keep the array working near peak efficiency... lots and lots more details like that. This isn't to say residential rooftop solar is bad. However atm it's something of a vanity project for people who can afford the investment. It is most definitely not some sort of obvious solves the whole problem slam dunk idiots in government are ignoring because they're stupid. They know what they're doing and are focusing on the highest impact places to put funds, and that can scale up a lot faster than fighting NIMBYs. And yeah, I'm really disappointed in Elon's solar roof tile stunt surrounding this.
- ZeroGravitas 4y ago
- londons_explore 4y agoThere is a risk of policymakers reading documents like this and using it to make conclusions about which types of energy generation are 'best'. That's a bad thing to do, because no analysis like this can truly capture all the upsides and downsides of any particular plant in a specific location. You know one thing that can? It's profitability. The profits of a power plant are directly impacted by the cost of land - and a power plant competes for the same land as farms and houses. As long as our markets correctly price in externalities (for example a per-acre-per-year tax for any land not left untouched), then the market makes far better decisions about what to build where than any policymaker ever could.
- ncmncm 4y agoPolicymakers, anyway, are used to being lied to, so mostly know better than to be swayed by tendentious material like TFA. Solar and wind, uniquely, do not compete for land, as they coexist neatly with other uses. This is part of why they are the cheapest power generation that has ever been fielded.
- stormbrew 4y ago> As long as our markets correctly price in externalities This is a little like saying "if unicorns ate hay..." It sounds reasonable on the surface, but it's also never happened and probably never will.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoIt's a reasonable 'spherical cow in a vacuum' type thing to work towards and compare things with, as long as you remember that it's not the default state of the universe or that we live in the best of all possible worlds and there's no room for improvement.
- colinmhayes 4y agoRight, the definition of externality is literally a cost that isn't priced into the market.
- fsh 4y ago
- sacred_numbers 4y agoAnother thing to keep in mind with solar is that so far we have been optimizing primarily for cost, rather than land use. This means installing panels at a high angle, far apart from each other to minimize shading and maximize energy captured per panel. If land is ever the limiting factor we can tilt solar panels at a shallower angle to reduce shading problems or just accept a certain amount of shading in the morning or evening. This could reduce land use by a factor of 5 or more.
- jasonwatkinspdx 4y agoI read a really interesting article about the rise of solar powered fish farms in China some years ago. These use aquaculture techniques with ponds shaded by solar cells, with feed grasses grown as part of the same mini ecosystem. I think there's a ton of open space for exploring how we could colocate solar, wind, and other land uses in a way that's mutually beneficial to each.
- modeless 4y agoThis is counting land destroyed by mining and land with some solar panels over it as the same thing.
- hitpointdrew 4y agoHow is not the same thing? You can’t use the land for anything else. What just because you didn’t use heavy machinery to extract minerals, but instead covered the land with panels that is somehow morally superior? The land can’t be used for anything else, so it’s essentially “destroyed”.
- otherme123 4y agoYou can dismantle a solar covered land when needed, in weeks, and get back the soil almost as good as new. A mine place gets wrecked for at least a century. I present you Las Medulas, a gold mine exploited by the romans in the first century: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Las_M%C3%A9dulas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Las_M%C3%A9dulas. Even today, 2,000 years later, all you can see is the huge scar left behind the mine.
- hitpointdrew 4y agoAnd where do you think the materials to make solar panels come from? They come from mines.
- modeless 4y agoAnd how much electricity can you get per square meter of mined ground for solar vs. coal? The answer is in the linked article, though it is not obvious at first glance. And it's not clear to me how much recycling the materials in the panels is accounted for. Of course you can't recycle coal at all.
- guerby 4y agoNote that fossil fuel industry real total land use is never mentionned anywhere. Mark Z Jacobson says current fossil fuel infrastructure takes more land than needed for solar in a 100% renewable USA: https://issues.org/renewables-minerals-energy-transition-jacobson-forum/ https://issues.org/renewables-minerals-energy-transition-jac... "In “The Hard Math of Minerals” (Issues, January 27, 2022), Mark P. Mills writes that “building solar and wind systems requires roughly a tenfold increase in the total tonnage of common materials … to deliver the same quantity of energy compared to building a natural gas or other hydrocarbon-fueled power plant.” This idea is misleading, since the source cited states that it “excluded” the materials related to the fuels used in power plants. Such fuels must be mined forever. With solar and wind, fuel mining is zero, forever. One recent study that accounted for fuel mining plus infrastructure concluded that one gigawatt of wind capacity replacing coal-generated electricity on the Texas grid reduces total mining by 25 million tonnes over 20 years. In fact, in North America alone, an average of fifty thousand new oil and gas wells are drilled yearly. These are ignored by Mills. The land required for these new wells is 2,500 square kilometers per year. Once a well is depleted, it is abandoned. The United States has 1.3 million active oil and gas wells and 3.2 million abandoned ones. Worldwide, Reuters estimates that about 29 million wells are abandoned. Research I’ve conducted with colleagues estimates that fossil fuel infrastructure currently takes up about 1.3 % of US land. This is due to wells, coal mines, oil refineries, pipelines, power plants, fueling stations, and storage facilities. In comparison, transitioning the United States for all energy purposes to 100% wind, water, and solar power may take less than 1% of US land. So not only does a transition to renewables reduce material requirements, but it also reduces land use." Also see the interview here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KzU05f8lNd0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KzU05f8lNd0 The Climate Crisis with Mark Z. Jacobson | The PLUS Podcast
- EdwardDiego 4y agoIt's pretty intuitive that coal extraction in particular has an extensive land footprint if you've ever seen strip mining, mountaintop mining (especially when the waste rock is dumped into nearby valleys), or open pit mining.
- jasonwatkinspdx 4y agoUnfortunately Jacobson's numbers are not nearly as solid as he claims. I learned this digging through years ago. He depends very heavily on implied cost savings of reduced fossil fuel that are based on thin if not nonexistent modeling, just assumptions, for his breakeven calculation. It doesn't take much digging to find similar week foundations across his work in general. I was disappointed when I learned this and confirmed it with a couple people who follow this stuff a lot more closely, one of them professionally as an environmental economist.
- cycomanic 4y agoThe communications around nuclear at the moment are fascinating. I think we are really witnessing a massive PR campaign trying to take advantage of the war in Ukraine. Everyone is talking about the gas imports from Russia, while nobody talks about oil imports which are not very different (using todays prices the EU imported around 300 billion euro worth of gas and 62 billion worth of oil in 2021. They are obviously over estimates because I used last year's volumes with todays prices). On top of that many publications talk as if electricity from other sources could easily replace gas, which is also incorrect. Germany which is often criticised generates less than 10% of electricity from gas, similar to France who are the nuclear poster child (that is because gas and nuclear are used for different purposes). Most of the gas in Germany is used for heating and industrial processes. On top of that we see articles (this isn't the first) who try to reframe the question of energy consumption around land use, which is a complete red hering, designed to make nuclear look more advantageous. Finally, nobody talks how the situation at the Zaporizhzhia is an illustration of the significant security implications of nuclear. I mean Europe has not been this close to a nuclear disaster in more than 30 years and people arguing we should build more nuclear plants?
- willi59549879 4y agoAnd how about storage of radioactive garbage? That seems to be conveniently omitted too
- HyperSane 4y agoNot a problem. You reprocess the used fuel, which makes clean usable fuel and a tiny amount of nuclear waste. This is then mixed with glass and then buried deep underground.
- jimbob45 4y agoIt really helps if you post a picture. Most people unironically picture a barrel of bubbling, glowing green goo when you say “nuclear waste” like something out of The Simpsons. It helps when people don’t have to generate a picture based off of your description[0]. [0]https://www.reddit.com/r/NuclearPower/comments/b5hy9b/what_nuclear_waste_looks_like/ https://www.reddit.com/r/NuclearPower/comments/b5hy9b/what_n...
- DoingIsLearning 4y agoThis makes gas plants look good. But it is not clear from the data if it is including all the pipeline infrastructure and LNG infra in the same way that it includes all the mining for coal.
- lbriner 4y agoAs fossil plants go, gas will be the cleanest and probably cheapest overall but it is not sustainable at scale. How long until the gas has run out or we are butchering the countryside to try and find hard to reach pockets? Can we create gas from anaerobic digestion? Sure. Can we do it to have an enormous amount of electrical power generated from it? Probably not. I suspect we might end up with some green gas plants to help with the dynamic load but we haven't built enough digestors yet to feed them.
- kergonath 4y ago> Can we create gas from anaerobic digestion? Sure. Can we do it to have an enormous amount of electrical power generated from it? Probably not. Biogas is great if it is generated from waste. The main issue is that farmer end up growing crops purely for biogas and bioethanol production and it displaces crops we actually need to avoid starving. Same as wood pellets, which are a great way of making use of waste, but terrible if we just cut trees instead. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2022/09/07/world/europe/eu-logging-wood-pellets.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2022/09/07/world/europe/...
- pfdietz 4y agoA post-fossil economy will have a limited quantity of reduced carbon to work with. I suspect the waste stream will have many takers. Uses that can be substituted for (like fueling stationary power plants) will fall by the wayside.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoGas from waste is good because it's carbon negative (especially capturing methane that would otherwise be emitted is important). But as you say, it might be limited in scale. However, we can now economically synthesize hydrocarbons from electricity, so that's an option, though doing it (and gas-from-waste) for chemical feedstocks is probably the long term destination. Burning stuff is simply not very clean or efficient, so there's usually a better way to do whatever it is we're trying to do.
- olliej 4y agoThis misses two power sources, the first (and actually used on commercial scales) is geothermal - I can't find anything on land area usage, but I recall driving through wairakei and just seeing giant masses of pipes periodically being visible in the bush. In NZ it represents 17% (per wikipedia) of the countries power, and is the most stable source of power as it isn't dependent on rain, sun, or wind. The other more reasonably ignored option is wave based generation. In principle wave generators could generate large amounts of reliable power, but I can't recall any commercial plants in operation. There's one article I found about commercial power generation in Australia [1], but it's a single generator producing only 200kW. [1] https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-07-31/wave-power-generator-supplying-king-island-with-electricity/101282070 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-07-31/wave-power-generator-...
- lbriner 4y agoThere are groups trying to solve the problem of drilling deep enough to tap into geothermal in countries that don't have fissures useable enough for this like NZ and Iceland. At the depths we can currently get to, we are looking at heat-pump technology rather than the ability to drive steam turbines. As for wave generation, the problem afaik is simply the hostile environment of the sea and how long the equipment will last in what is basically a large electrolyte! There are a lot of experiments and some small scale production north of Scotland but after a few years, the equipment simply corrodes away. One example: https://www.offshore-mag.com/renewable-energy/article/14203296/wave-energy-prototype-arrives-at-orkney-ahead-of-trials https://www.offshore-mag.com/renewable-energy/article/142032...
- olliej 4y agoOh, I understand the why of wave energy being challenging, there's a huge amount of energy available to be harnessed, but on the other hand there's a huge amount of energy being put into any equipment, before you even have to deal with the generally hostile environment created by salt water. I was just saying I was aware that plenty of orgs are trying to develop commercially viable methods and didn't know if any had got to anything beyond small scale testing yet :D
- Gwypaas 4y agoIf land use us the metric to use when defining the viability of future energy sources then a much better target for reduction is the beef industry. https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/land-use-per-kg-poore https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/land-use-per-kg-poore
- gubby 4y agoFor an article about a specific scientific concept (the proportional land use for different types of generator), it’s surprising they actually got that concept wrong in all their examples: “These can have a small land footprint of just 8m2 per MWh” This is implies that the land is being consumed by the generator. I assume there is an implied “per year” or “per day” but it’s a little sloppy.
- DisjointedHunt 4y agoTax Incentives per EJ of Energy produced is a much better comparison: https://www.forbes.com/sites/robertbryce/2022/04/30/newsoms-about-face-on-diablo-canyon-underscores-foolishness-of-indian-point-closure-and-need-to-save-palisades/?sh=6bbb62325690 https://www.forbes.com/sites/robertbryce/2022/04/30/newsoms-... The argument i see here isn't one energy source against another, but about a SANE political weighting of subsidies and investment. WE SHOULD BE INCENTIVIZING GIGAWATT HOURS OF CLEAN ENERGY CREATION and not define subsidies targeted at any given source.
- elihu 4y agoIt's not really an electricity source, but recently I was curious about pumped hydro storage, and how to develop any kind of intuition about the relationship between volume of water, height difference, and how much energy you can actually store that way. I used lake Mead and Hoover dam as an example. I wanted to know how much stored energy is there. Apparently the U.S. uses 3.9 trillion kwh per year. Prelude> (3.9 * 1000 * 1000 * 1000 * 1000) / 365 1.0684931506849316e10 That comes out to about 10 billion kwh per day. We'll come back to that number later. The amount of stored gravitational energy of a thing in joules is its mass in kg times height in meters times 9.8 m/s^2 (on Earth). There are 3,600,000 joules in a kilowatt hour. Lake Mead is about 29,000,000 acre feet. An acre foot weighs about 2,718,000 pounds. There's 2.2 pounds per kilogram. The "hydraulic" height of Hoover dam is 567 feet, according to wikipedia. I'm assuming that's when it's full (it isn't, but let's pretend it is). Not all the water would be at the top though. We'll say that the average water molecule is at 3/4 of the height. (It's more than half because the lake has a cross section like a martini glass). I don't know what the real number is, but 3/4 seems good enough for an estimate. We can convert feet to meters by dividing by 3.28. Prelude> (9.8 * ((5670.75)/3.28) ((29000000 * 2718000)/2.2)) / 3600000 1.2644999688192902e10 Huh, that number is pretty close to the one from earlier. If I did my math right, there's about twelve and a half billion kilowatt hours stored in a full lake Mead. So, we could, in theory, maintain a buffer capable of powering the United States for an average day with the amount of stored energy in a full lake Mead. We could also do the same thing with 1/10th the water and an altitude difference that's 10 times bigger. If one wanted to actually build something like this to buffer out day/night variations in solar power, the amount of pumps and turbines you'd need to move a lake Mead worth of water every day would be staggering. This is relevant to the question of land use, because a dedicated pumped hydro system would probably have two reservoirs, or a reservoir and a large natural body of water like the ocean, and the amount of energy you can store scales up with the water volume, which corellates with horizontal surface area. It's kind of an interesting problem to think about... where are the best pumped hydro sites?
- pfdietz 4y ago> where are the best pumped hydro sites? A GIS-driven web site for you! https://re100.eng.anu.edu.au/global/ https://re100.eng.anu.edu.au/global/
- jmcwjmcw 4y agoFounder of paces.com (YC S22) here, our software identities the best places to build their projects and so this topic is very close to my heart! Some quick thoughts: >We take an all of the above approach and support the siting of all decarbonized energy from solar to nuclear. The renewables vs nuclear arguments is something people working in the industry don't really think much about, as everyone is trying to execute and build as fast as possible across the board. >Grid capacity followed by permitting/nimbyism are way bigger limitations than land availability for decarbonizing the grid in the US for at least the next decade. >Rooftop solar and C&I battery storage are going to be a single digit but crucial part of our energy mix as they bypass issues with transmission. >Offshore wind will be bigger than many think and it bypasses the land use issue. >I grew up on a sheep farm in Ireland and am a big fan of Agrovoltaics which also help with land use issues when considering livestock.
- noneeeed 4y agoWhy do you think rooftop solar is only going to be single digit? Is it down to the cost/complexity of installation compared to greenfield solar setups? Instinctively it feels like there is a huge amount of unused roof area in the UK that could be put to good use. But I feel like it might not be as much as I think once direction is taken into account.
- legitster 4y agoI think people underrate how much square footage it is going to take to modernize a grid. In a southern enough location, a big enough house might be able to generate enough power for itself for a few months out of the year if it doesnt have an electric car to charge. But take every high rise, office, vehicle, manufacturing facility, etc in a city and single digit percentage seems pretty good.
- jmcwjmcw 4y agoAgree with this, but also want to mention something not clear in my post, that we are US focused right now, the energy mix is going to vary alot by geography. The UK does not have the land for lots of large scale solar, so their mix is going to be mostly wind, nuclear and rooftop solar might be a higher % as its a more urbanized country compared to the US. But it is unlikely it will be +10% even there.