16 ms·
Cognitive ability is related to supporting freedom of speech (2020)
- aaaaaaaaaaab 4y ago
- dbxkcichhdfufu 4y ago
- OrangeMonkey 4y agoThere appears to be a recent shift on HackerNews no longer support freedom of speech. I don't know that its just HackerNews either - it seems like its 'internet residents no longer support freedom of speech.' I'm not sure how to interpret this.
- seydor 4y agoaccording to the study, a valid hypothesis is that hn became more stupid more seriously, the shift is not just HN it is everywhere. We have generations of people who have been grown up to self-censor at every step, so by natural extension freedom of speech is not a priority. Urbanization and the evergreen/growth/globalist agenda that comes with it is also in favor of restrictions that maintain the cohesion of large congregations
- nurettin 4y ago
- colordrops 4y agoYour comment may be facetious, but I believe that's the most common rationale for censorship - the public is not intelligent enough to handle the barrage of online information.
- whoooooo123 4y agoPeople who advocate censorship are usually part of "the public". "People who aren't me aren't intelligent enough to be allowed unfettered access to information. Only I am noble enough." - That's the real rationale.
- illuminerdy 4y agoSomewhere along the line, we stopped teaching children that everybody doesn't have to agree with you. And now those children have grown into adults who want only those opinions of which they approve to be heard. No free and open society can survive with that kind of thinking.
- neonsunset 4y agoThe adults are kids with elaborate excuses for their behavior.
- throwawayacc2 4y agoI don’t think it’s urbanisation. In the west, the twentieth century had urbanisation and was far more open to free speech while many parts on the world didn’t and were more censorship prone. In fact, in the middle east for example, one could argue in the middle of the twentieth century there was less urbanisation but more openness to western ideas and less religious oppression than it is now. I think the shift away from free speech we are seeing is the result of decades of indoctrination and people being goaded into emotional reactions via social media. I genuinely don’t see any functional difference between so called “social justice activists” railing people up and fanatical preachers delivering fire and brimstone sermons. It’s the same phenomenon manifested in different forms. I will also add, most censorship prone people tend to accuse their opponents of lacking “critical thinking”. While at the same time, missing the point that is precisely what opposition does. You look at the other side, you criticise it’s premises, you criticise it’s assumptions, you criticise it’s goals, you look if the stated goals align with the actual results and criticise the discrepancy. You really can’t have critical thinking if you can’t, you know, criticise. I think we had more free speech, and more critical thinking in the past because criticism was allowed. Nowadays, if you criticise anything that goes against what some would term The Cathedral, you will suffer severe consequences.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 4y agoIt is sad that people who believe in real free speech now have to clarify that they are free speech absolutists. When it comes down to it, I don’t think any of those people you are mentioning ever actually supported free speech - just the idea of it before it came to a head.
- cratermoon 4y agoHow is free speech absolutism more "real" than a more nuanced approached to speech?
- faeriechangling 4y agoAbsolute free speech is more of a thought experiment than something that's possible, so I don't really see it as sad that people are only referring to American-style free speech (No libel, fraud, fighting words, calls to imminent lawlessness) when they say "free speech", I see it as practical. Absolute free speech would imply even a lack of self-censorship. I think if you deeply analyse communication you sort of realise that it's fundamentally built on censorship. Censorship is a core communication filter function. Getting rid of censorship absolutely is actually absurd.
- Bloating 4y agoThere's a difference b/w having a filter, social consequences for lack of filter, and government restrictions
- faeriechangling 4y agoYeah but the existence of self-censorship implies a fear of social sanction, so if people are still doing it society is still being censored for fear of social sanction. Remember we're talking about absolutism here, obviously we shouldn't actually be concerned with self-censorship, but it is an obstacle to ABSOLUTE free speech.
- 8ytecoder 4y agoI think Free speech, Freedom from prosecution for speech and speech without any consequences are all confused with each other. To me, the freedoms to oppose some speech, by way of boycotting, protesting, shunning and shaming is also speech. There’s also the difference between beheading for speech and getting your Twitter account suspended. If someone says absolutely nutty stuff in a town square and the local folks drown him out or threaten to not patronize the shops in the town square for allowing the speech, is that considered suppression of speech? It seems to me that people are asking for tolerance of speech at all costs. I don’t know if Free Speech ever came with that built in.
- Bloating 4y agodon't beleive everything you read. Only the stuff you hear, on the news channels.
- kgwxd 4y agoInternet residents aren't government. They can't arrest people, lock anyone up, or sentence anyone to death for anything, let alone for saying something. There's nothing there for speech to be free from.
- OrangeMonkey 4y agoI respectfully disagree. Internet residents can, quite successfully, remove people from the internet and silence their speech on the internet. Consider Kiwifarms. I am purposefully NOT going to talk about if something is deserved or not. I am not touching that one again. I am tired of it. That said, internet outrage of a minority led to misinformation (both for and against it) and ultimately resulted in the DDOS protection vendor no longer protecting it. Once that was done, to noones surprise, someone ddos'ed it and removed the ability of others to see it. Its not that internet residents are trying to stop from hearing certain things - in some cases, they are purposefully stopping anyone else from hearing certain things also. I don't know that I believe this fully but it seems, some days, the internet itself is a country.
- seydor 4y agowhat about monetization. i.e. livelihood, the thing that keeps people from starving etc
- wpietri 4y agoThat's not new in the digital realm. Speech has always had social consequences: https://www.popehat.com/2013/09/10/speech-and-consequences/ https://www.popehat.com/2013/09/10/speech-and-consequences/
- kybernetyk 4y ago>I'm not sure how to interpret this. The normie masses joined the internet. Simple as that.
- impossiblefork 4y agoI don't think that was at all what happened. I'm a Swede, so I'm slightly disconnected from American politics-- to me the people that are shocking or must be loved or anything else in American discourse are much less shocking or to be loved, basically, everything I feel about American politics is very strongly muted; and in the past I haven't had any conflicts with the Americans I know-- they were all pro-free speech, I think. Certainly, the idea of them supporting large-scale censorship by gatekeepers controlled by powerful individuals like billionaires or the political establishment would have been unthinkable. However, in the years after the 2016 election they all flipped completely. From my point of view they became dogmatic, insane and willing to do things that I saw as long-term self harm, or at least creating a situation where they made themselves helpless to protect themselves in the long term. They also ended up very strongly anti-Assange because of a feeling that Assange had helped Trump, even though they from their previous views would have been likely to support what he did. I have a vague feeling that there's been some kind of major propaganda effort whereby only official views are to be regarded as acceptable and that's it's related to the big internet companies. There is some public information on efforts in this direction in the context of preventing spread of non-official views-- called things like efforts at 'anti-disinformation'.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hotpotamus 4y agoIf you really want to scramble your noodle, look at the recent spate of state laws placing restrictions on speech and notice the lean of the parties that control those states.
- illuminerdy 4y agoCan you give some examples? Is it actually speech that's being restricted, or actions, or access to certain types of speech/content (e.g. age restrictions)?
- hotpotamus 4y agoIt’s probably easier to assume it’s the restrictions on speech that you agree with. I usually prefer the easy way myself.
- Twistyfiasco 4y agoWell, for awhile there was lots of talk about CRT. https://www.texastribune.org/2021/12/02/texas-critical-race-theory-law/#:~:text=Republican%20bill%20that%20limits%20how,public%20policy%20or%20social%20affairs.%E2%80%9D https://www.texastribune.org/2021/12/02/texas-critical-race-...
- hotpotamus 4y agohttps://www.edweek.org/teaching-learning/lawmakers-push-to-ban-1619-project-from-schools/2021/02 https://www.edweek.org/teaching-learning/lawmakers-push-to-b... Don’t forget the 1619 Project.
- OrvalWintermute 4y agoThe 1619 project has been widely lambasted as unhistorical political educating. https://www.city-journal.org/1619-project-conspiracy-theory https://www.city-journal.org/1619-project-conspiracy-theory
- 4y ago
- ibejoeb 4y agoI don't think we know the true feelings of each individual, but certainly the major employers in the field here find it in their interests to control the information. So even if the general population wants freedom of speech, that needs to be balanced against the duties of job. If you're set up at FAANG, the risk/reward ratio might not favor one's ideals.
- wpietri 4y agoI can't speak to all of HN, but over the years I've gone from a free speech absolutist to seeing rights as balanced against one another. And also to consider what motivates me to be for free speech. For example, one reason I think free speech is vital is that I want everybody to have a say. Another is that think society works best when we hear from a wide variety of perspectives. However, there are some people who use "free speech" as a reason that they should be allowed to be abusive. Note, for example, the way that Kiwi Farms was waving the free speech banner. You'll see the same thing being done by people who advocate for exterminating Jews and returning Black people to slavery. In practice, a platform like Twitter has to choose between hosting abusive Nazis and hosting the people who the Nazis would try to drive off the platform. Personally, I am more concerned about Jews feeling safe to speak freely than I am about Nazis wanting to use their free speech to abuse them. So although my 20-year-old self might have been shocked that I am no longer a free-speech absolutist, I am fine with him being shocked, because I have come to value net, long-term practical outcomes more than the isolated ideals that I now see as valuable heuristics, not articles of faith.
- throwawayacc2 4y ago[flagged]
- wpietri 4y ago> > people who advocate for exterminating Jews and returning Black people to slavery > Literally no one does that. You are imagining things. You are obviously not a serious participant here. These people exist. They existed before the internet, and the internet has, to my great disappointment, only enabled their spread. There's a ton you could read, but maybe start with Neiwert's "God's Country" and "Alt-America", which document the pre- and post-Internet versions of America's white supremacist movement. > Abusive is a relative and in this context meaningless word. That is also embarrassingly ignorant. If you'd like to learn something, maybe try Citron's "Hate Crimes in Cyberspace", Warren's "Targeted and Trolled", Jeong's "The Internet of Garbage", and Bancroft's "Why Does He Do That".
- 4y ago
- bigbasedwolf 4y agoNot sure when you think this shift happened. HN intellectuals migrated from here almost 10 years ago. I don’t think the atmosphere has changed it’s always been a young loudmouth group. Dang is a recent entry in the compendium. HN has never really been a highly intellectual place simply because a number of key subjects, viewpoints are off limits. Inability to at will gracefully discuss sensitive subjects basically means we are all pretending to believe what we say. I don’t know what cognitive ability research says about people being able to separate their identity and worldview from what they say, but there you have it.
- OrangeMonkey 4y agoWhere did the intellectuals from 10 years ago migrate to?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bigbasedwolf 4y agoNot sure. We had a period of “goodbye HN” posts. You can hopefully find them in the search results unless they got purged somehow. Those have stopped, haven’t seen one in many years. Basically people could sense they were in an unhealthy bubble and decided to cut ties. Good for them. That fellow who would regularly post graphs of HN traffic/topic patterns at us to disprove peoples theories hasn’t posted it in many, many years. I guess he either woke up to reality or shrugged and moved on. A few old timers remain here and there. I think we just got tired and fatigued of the bullshit.
- nano9 4y agoOne interpretation I've been entertaining: In the modern world, we have recently realized that speech is more complicated than people exchanging ideas in a civil manner, and that speech has the power to influence consensus reality through second order and higher effects. (Think: phenomena such as "self-radicalization"). This leads to decisions to simply restrict speech rather than deal with the complexity. I am not entirely convinced that restricting speech is the right move. I think if anything it creates division. Either way, we'll most likely see how it works out in the next few years.
- loopdoend 4y agoIf I wanted to manipulate public opinion and had infinite resources like the Chinese government does I certainly know how I'd go about it.
- swatcoder 4y agoIt’s not 1993 any more. The arrival of a globally ubiquitous internet, and the subsequent introduction of social network feeds that insist Helen and Walter encounter five pages of engagement bait if they want to get updates on their granddaughter, have made the consequences of “free speech” less obvious to many people. Speech has qualitatively different impact than it did 50, 100, or 200 years ago. So people are stepping back and considering whether the same thinking that applied to local marches, print journalism, and cable news still makes sense in the same way for what appears to be a different landscape. Maybe you think that’s a dumb question, or maybe you already made up your mind about it, but when context seems to change dramatically, people are bound to revisit old conclusions. You can be frustrated about that, but you can’t avoid it. If your own conclusion is important to you, you’ll do the best job advocating for it by understanding why reasonable people are revisiting the matter, helping them see why free speech is still vital rather than shaming them for being reflective.
- colordrops 4y agoI don't see any judgment or shaming in the comment you replied to.
- kmeisthax 4y agoI bet you if you questioned those people on things tangentially related to free speech or with indirect questions they would still score as a supporter of it to some degree. Historically, hacker culture has couched free speech as a technical problem - i.e. the same as a network outage. This is where we get the catchy-but-wrong canard of "The Internet interprets censorship as damage and routes around it". This leads people to assume that "unrestrained publication" and "free speech" are synonyms, and that all we need are faster and better printing presses that are harder to shut down. DDoS attacks, doxing & unmasking, harassment, spam, and so on are all ways to reduce free speech online without having the technical ability to restrain publication of some content. If you take the "censorship is network damage" approach to free speech then it's hard to argue against these things that have clear censorious effects. Mocking someone on Twitter is the same as posting someone's home address under this definition. If you take free speech as a sociopolitical problem - i.e. where censorship is any kind of violence directed at someone for speaking their mind - then these things are obviously censorship, even if they are shaped like speech. The people involved in these kinds of censorship have, of course, appropriated the language of free speech. This is tragic, because it means free-speech liberals are pushed to drop that language, because it virtue-signals that you actually support censorship with extra steps. You instead talk about online harassment and marginalized groups - i.e. the people currently being censored - rather than the underlying principle of not censoring people.
- QuadmasterXLII 4y agoIt's complicated because the most serious threat to free speech in the US right now is cancel culture, but most aspects of cancel culture are explicitly protected under the first amendment: "...or abridging the freedom of speech [private corporations choosing what to host on their websites, calling someone's employer and requesting that they be fired for what they said], or of the press [this garbage https://parade.com/news/simu-liu-under-fire-joke-batgirl-cancellation]; https://parade.com/news/simu-liu-under-fire-joke-batgirl-can... or the right of the people peaceably to assemble [twitter mobs, unless you count their speech as violence in which case we are back to square one], and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances [here, demanding that a government employee be fired https://www.change.org/p/ucla-fire-ucla-professor-gordon-klein https://www.change.org/p/ucla-fire-ucla-professor-gordon-kle...].
- jen20 4y ago> the most serious threat to free speech in the US right now is cancel culture Surely you cannot be serious?
- tstrimple 4y agoI'm sure they are being completely genuine. They completely miss the irony that they are essentially saying "the most serious threat to free speech in the US right now is the free speech of people I disagree with".
- faeriechangling 4y agoMakes perfect sense to me. The free exchange of information is more appealing and less threatening when you have more information processing capability to begin with.
- sfpotter 4y agoThat is why businesses routinely encourage their workers to exchange salary information amongst themselves.
- hotpotamus 4y agoSo how would you protect those with less information processing ability from the consequences of more free exchange of information?
- rhexs 4y agoProtect them from what? I assume you're presupposing that "free speech is dangerous" here?
- hotpotamus 4y agoProtection from their perception of threat.
- harvey9 4y agoOr from exploitation by people with more nimble minds.
- faeriechangling 4y agoThe very last thread I was in somebody was expressing how unsympathetic they were to the scammed because they were stupid enough to get tricked. This wasn't a very popular notion, most people wanted to sanction scammers for their speech to protect the scammed. Quite a lot of the laws around restriction of speech are specifically designed to stop smart people from exploiting less smart people. Smart people have to be censored or they will hurt less smart people.
- tgv 4y agoIt seems to be based on data grouped on questionable labeling of dubious grouping of people, correlated with a weak proxy of cognitive ability (How many word associations do homosexuals get right; that's really one of the cells in the analysis). And it answers nothing of interest. How is this publishable?
- sfpotter 4y agoCognitive Ability Is Related to How Seriously You Take Studies Like This
- ThrowawayTestr 4y agoTrust the science (unless it's science I disagree with)
- readthenotes1 4y agoUnless science has shown that much of the "Science" in this field of study is garbage
- Xeoncross 4y agothat's so like science isn't it?
- ptsneves 4y agoYou can trust science as in scientific method and practice and mistrust specific research or studies. All is well then.
- gruez 4y agoIf you're going through all the trouble of conducting a literature review on a given topic (ie. finding all the relevant studies and evaluating their methodology/results), then can you really call that as "scientific method and practice"? It seems much more accurate to say that you're trusting your ability to correctly evaluate studies.
- bragr 4y agoIt would be interesting to see if they could control for level of/exposure to formal education in cognitive ability (plenty of smart uneducated people, and dumb educated people). I think this would help tease of if this is a feature of cognitive ability, or if cognitive ability is just a proxy to how much civics education you've likely had.
- cratermoon 4y agoStudy 3 in the paper kind of addressed that by proxy, with Intellectual Humility. People who may not score well on cognitive ability but nevertheless recognize the limits of knowledge and intelligence.
- evancox100 4y ago“Controlling for gender, ethnicity, and education did not meaningfully alter the associations between cognitive ability and support for freedom of speech. Also controlling for participants’ ideology (separately or in addition to the demographic variables) did not meaningfully affect the associations.”
- pacbard 4y agoInteresting question. They partially address it in the paper: > Controlling for gender, ethnicity, and education did not meaningfully alter the relationships between cognitive ability and support for freedom of speech, nor the mediating role of IH. Also controlling for participants’ ideology (separately or in addition to the demographic variables) did not meaningfully alter the results, which can be found at OSF. (p. 39) I read that to suggest that, at least for study 3's results, the inclusion of education did not meaningfully change their results. If we are thinking about possible confounders, something I am wondering about the extent to which their choice to use verbal cognitive ability (i.e., "a vocabulary test (i.e., Wordsum)" for study 1 and 2, and "a (verbal) cognitive ability measure, that is, the Ammons Quick Test" for study 3) could explain participants' preference towards freedom of speech, which arguably is usually discussed as a verbal form of freedom, either spoken or printed. As they are measuring verbal capacity, I would expect people who are better with words to be more drawn to freedom of speech. Maybe people who are more "outgoing" might be drawn more towards freedom of assembly. I am also wondering how people who are drawn more towards non-written forms of communication (e.g., memes, videos, podcasts, etc.) score on their verbal cognitive test and whether they have similar/different views about freedom of speech.
- Bloating 4y agoIs it just Freedom of Speech, or Freedom in general
- AndrewKemendo 4y agoI think we can safely conclude that the more intelligent (in every dimension) the average person in a system is, the more effectively and efficiently every part of that system will run I used to think it was kind of all the same and that law of averages would generally buff out the more irrational and impulsive of us to not actually make much difference to the overall progressive trajectory. Turns out it's not the case and it only takes a minority of lower-IQ/Q/general intelligence people to really mess things up that should be very simple
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- illuminerdy 4y agoI can see how their conclusions play out in real life. One of the common threads I've noticed across many people when trying to explain why defending freedom of speech, and the free and open exchange of ideas in general, is that they're not just defending some "right-wing" person's rights, they're actually defending their own rights. Because the same tactics and rationales that are being used to suppress and silence the "right-wing" (which is comically everyone to the right of Bernie Sanders these days) will eventually be turned around and used to silence and suppress them. But so many people simple can't wrap their head around it. The notion is perfectly illustrated by Sir Thomas More in A Man for All Seasons: William Roper: “So, now you give the Devil the benefit of law!” Sir Thomas More: “Yes! What would you do? Cut a great road through the law to get after the Devil?” William Roper: “Yes, I'd cut down every law in England to do that!” Sir Thomas More: “Oh? And when the last law was down, and the Devil turned 'round on you, where would you hide, Roper, the laws all being flat? This country is planted thick with laws, from coast to coast, Man's laws, not God's! And if you cut them down, and you're just the man to do it, do you really think you could stand upright in the winds that would blow then? Yes, I'd give the Devil benefit of law, for my own safety's sake!” By protecting the rights of everyone, even people you disagree with, you are ultimately protecting your own rights. Anything else is short-sighted and dangerous.
- mnd999 4y agoHow do you protect the rights of those being bullied, trolled, harassed, doxxxed and revenge-porned.
- ThrowawayTestr 4y agoWith laws.
- mnd999 4y agoThat’s exactly my point. Laws restricting speech. Free speech is a utopian nonsense, there are always restrictions (just ask the SEC). It’s just a question of where a society thinks the line should be drawn.
- P0l83q4p1Hw3Ul 4y agoIs Freedom of Speech important for a democratic society to survive? Right wing extremists would say yes. In fact, this is why they believe we shouldn't allow low cognitive ability immigrants into the country or let them vote.
- User23 4y agoYou said it in a tacky way, but the evidence does suggest that the average intelligence of a population is an important limiting factor in civilizational attainment. It’s necessary, but not sufficient. Likewise, the likelihood of a startup succeeding is gated by the intelligence of its employees. Successful founders know this and hire accordingly. I’ve yet to see a sound argument for why it’s ok for a company to discriminate on intelligence, but not for a country to. And of course many countries that are seen as having admirable immigration policies, such as Canada, do exactly that through various proxy measures.
- Georgelemental 4y ago> I’ve yet to see a sound argument for why it’s ok for a company to discriminate on intelligence, but not for a country to. In the US, it's officially illegal for companies to discriminate based on intelligence, thanks to Griggs v. Duke Power. https://www.theamericanconservative.com/overturn-griggs-v-duke-power/ https://www.theamericanconservative.com/overturn-griggs-v-du...
- akomtu 4y agoThat's quite a comment. It creates a false dichotomy between freedom of speech and democratic society, and uses the word "survive" to appeal to emotions so we want to save democracy from the evil freedom. Then it attaches "right wing extremists" (the absolute evil) to the freedom of speech, suggesting that anyone who is for freedom must be an extremist. The last sentence is a blunder, though, because it suggests that voting for democrats requires low cognitive ability. One thing I'm sure about is that we don't need low-effort populists on HN.
- P0l83q4p1Hw3Ul 4y ago
- happytoexplain 4y agoIn my experience, the notion of being "for or against freedom of speech" is actually referring to something more subjective, and that phrasing is used to imply which side of the disagreement the speaker believes is correct, like referring to the debate about abortion as the debate about murdering babies. It signals a strong bias.
- OrangeMonkey 4y agoWould it be better to phrase it as "I believe that other people should be able to hear from people they want to" and "I believe that we should stop people from hearing from certain people"?
- mantas 4y agoReferring to abortion as women health issue is strong bias too. Some questions are biased on all sides.
- 1270018080 4y agoIt's a topic that is beaten to death on HN. Every few weeks a neonazi gets kicked off of a website, and it's just bad faith, poorly framed arguments, and slippery slope fallacies thrown back and forth until it falls of the front page.
- greatpostman 4y agoThe big secret: democracy requires certain cognitive abilities among the population
- P0l83q4p1Hw3Ul 4y agoHence why certain people are trying to lower the IQ as quickly as possible.
- bilsbie 4y ago"I would rather have questions that can't be answered than answers that can't be questioned" -Richard Feynman
- Dig1t 4y agoI grew up in the US being told that freedom of speech was a virtue, something that our country did very well and I always thought that it was a shared value. It's very surprising to me to see that change in such a short span, or possibly it was not as popular or widespread as I thought it was growing up and I just never noticed. Is it the internet that has caused this uptick in the number of people who think free speech is a bad idea? Or has it always been like that?
- rhexs 4y agoHow many immigrants do you think grew up the same way? Hint: almost none, as the United States is the only country that enshrines true freedom of speech as an unalienable and fundamental right. This is probably considered "hate-speech" in this day and age, but immigration, shockingly, has cons as well.
- swampthing 4y agoHow do you get from your first paragraph to your second? Many immigrants I know are, if anything, more zealous about freedom of speech than other Americans. It was one of the reasons why they went through the trouble of immigrating here.
- jen20 4y agoIf you look beyond your short-sighted screed, you will typically find that most immigrants to the US value American ideals more than many Americans. In some cases that is caused by idealism, and in others it's having experienced governments which are actually oppressive.
- Georgelemental 4y ago"I know no country in which, generally speaking, there is less independence of mind and true freedom of discussion than in America." - Alexis de Tocqueville
- sejje 4y agoSaid in 1835, almost 200 years ago. I really can't think it's relevant in a thread steeped in talk about Twitter and deplatforming on social media.
- graderjs 4y ago
- oh_my_goodness 4y agoGrain of Salt Warning: Even in engineering, where the problems are much easier, most published papers are ... not valuable. "The literature" is a very mixed bag, and it takes years to learn how to find the relatively few papers that are good for anything at all. Those problems can't get easier as the subject of study becomes human beings rather than EM waves (or whatever).
- idlewords 4y agoIt's worth digging into the methodology here: the study participants were found through Mechanical Turk, and the proxy for cognitive ability is a vocabulary quiz. You can just as well use this study to show that the kind of highly educated people whose circumstances are dire enough they have to work for pennies an hour have been socialized into giving correct answers about questions pertaining to freedom of speech.
- harvey9 4y agoThanks for this. Second time in two days that a MTurk-based study has been highlighted as having questionable methodology.
- weberer 4y ago>It's worth digging into the methodology here: the study participants were found through Mechanical Turk That seems to be most studies these days. And 10 years ago it was mostly "we've recruited 200 students from [university performing the study]" and people complained about that too. And if you do a phone survey, then its "you're biasing toward the people who pick up calls from unknown numbers". There's always going to be some sort of sampling bias, and this study doesn't seem to be any sort of special outlier.
- sejje 4y ago> There's always going to be some sort of sampling bias I don't agree, I think we'll get pretty good at this. I agree there currently is pretty much always a sampling bias, though. Maybe the exception is when the study samples a particular group already, rather than the population at large.
- oh_my_goodness 4y agoI agree, but unfortunately that doesn't address the complaint. If surveys are in fact whacked out by bias (idk), then we won't get certain kinds of meaningful data from those surveys. It's tough for the surveyors, but that doesn't overcome the objection. I think in some fields this may be more obvious. If particles are too big for the LHC to find them, then we won't get meaningful data about those particles from those experiments. We can point out that we built a ridiculously, unbelievably huge collider and what do people expect? It's a valid point, but too bad for us.
- bigbasedwolf 4y agoNot surprising in the least. Anyone who has browsed 4chan instinctively senses that the pendulum swings from downright madness to sheer brilliance on a post-by-post basis, and this is something you can’t really find on other sites no matter how much you analyze the so called “signal to noise ratio.” You can’t have an open and intellectually gratifying discussion if you know there are things you cannot say. So the topics, and their themes, are stifled from the get go. Be exposed to this environment long enough and you’ll self censor.
- CharlesW 4y ago> You can’t have an open and intellectually gratifying discussion if you know there are things you cannot say. False. There are always things you cannot say if you truly want to have an open and intellectually gratifying discussion. Freedom of speech, legally and conceptually, has never meant freedom from the consequences of that speech.
- bigbasedwolf 4y agoResponses like these are why we are where we are. Enjoy the ride.
- CharlesW 4y ago[flagged]
- ThrowawayTestr 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thought-terminating_cliche https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thought-terminating_cliche
- moistly 4y agoMakes sense: people who think they are smart think everyone wants to hear what they’ve got to say, even if their babble is incorrect, hateful, or just plain stupid.
- the_cat_kittles 4y ago
- civilized 4y agoMakes sense, since intelligence correlates with openness to experience in the Big 5 model of personality. People who are open to new experiences will naturally prefer that people are allowed to express themselves so the experiences can occur. I agree with other commenters that the study seems low-quality, but the result aligns with my priors, for whatever that's worth.
- azeemh 4y agoFreedom of speech is the freedom to vocalize, share, and evaluate thoughts. Thought Policing is quite un-American yet it is championed by authoritarian neofascists and neoliberals alike...
- uoaei 4y agoFreedom to vocalize extends to both sides. You are free to vocalize your opinion, and dissenters are free to vocalize theirs.
- ThrowawayTestr 4y agoIs DDOSing considered speech?
- TheMightyLlama 4y agoThere’s a lot of discussion here on the topic of cancel culture, deplatforming and the responsibilities of private entities. It may be useful to clarify in our responses if we mean the above or our ability to express ourselves free from persecution by the government.
- benreesman 4y agoThe methodological flaw here is amusingly it’s own fascinating study: using some verbal sophistication proxy as a cognitive ability proxy to correlate political attitudes is arguably the key feature of modern hyper-polarized, Internet-speed news cycle politics. It’s difficult to watch a screen without hearing some version of “most people are stupid”. This is deeply wrong: most people are very smart, but this is difficult for the well-educated, because most people are inarticulate. Surviving, let alone reproducing in meaningful numbers, has almost always been a ruthless selection process on intelligence, but hyper-literacy is a path to high status that has only recently become available to people in large numbers, and even then only in some places (in the US where I live, smarty-pants hyper-literacy is dramatically higher status on the urban coasts for example). This is why so many of my fellow coastal lefties are always befuddled if not enraged that huge blocks of the rest of the country (and world) vote with their ballots or feet or both for very poorly-articulated policies and agendas: the (to borrow a dangerous phrase) “sullen, silent majority” understands why “progress” is bad for them, but doesn’t articulate it well. This leads to a combination of feeling obviously right, but getting trounced at the polls rather often.
- pstuart 4y agoI'm not sure about the policies bit. Sure, on the social front God, Guns, and Gays are powerful motivators to get those people to vote. But economic policies from the same side seem to be mainly about lowering the tax burden of the rich. What am I missing?
- WalterBright 4y agoNot sure what your point is, but wealthy people are the source of investment capital. Less capital investment means a less prosperous economy, which negatively impacts about everybody.
- pstuart 4y agoSorry, but I wasn't attacking wealthy people, nor capitalism (but would be willing to poke at 'em for fun some other time). > that huge blocks of the rest of the country (and world) vote with their ballots or feet or both for very poorly-articulated policies and agendas My point is that the policies and agendas seem to be driven more on anger than on structural policies that will enrich their lives. I'm trying desperately to not engage in any sort of partisanship here, but I'm not aware of any significant policies from the previous administration that actually made their lives better. It's been shown that fear (and anger) are powerful motivators: https://www.apa.org/news/apa/2020/fear-motivator-elections https://www.apa.org/news/apa/2020/fear-motivator-elections tl;dr -- fear+anger > economics/domestic policy
- Animats 4y agoSurvey data source: "To obtain a power of >.90 to detect effects of r = .20, 300 U.S. citizens whose native language is English were requested on Amazon Mechanical Turk." They need a better sampling method.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sebastianconcpt 4y agoIt makes total sense. The more diversity of ideas the more filtering noise and evaluating paradigms capacity you need. A simple ideology creates a prefabricated filter so people that can't or don't want to put the work can outsource filtering discernment to ideologies and save brain horse power. They also willingly brainwash themselves when they allow ideology dictate their behavior, of course. PS: Just paying behavior in exchange for convenience. World-view reason, consistency, logic and principles are totally irrelevant for ideology.
- steele 4y agoPhrenology will hit frontpage soon
- t00 4y agoThat explains why Linus Torvalds have been testing kernel developers' cognitive ability with insults. Eventually he needed to give up likely due to social justice warrior pressure. Stultus verbis non corrigitur.
- HereIGoAgain 4y agoWell yeah.. Makes sense. Even at the most basic level, smarter people tend to realize that limiting speech is not just morally and ethically wrong, but a Pandora's box.
- tsol 4y agoIt's scary how easily some people are convinced that they're scientifically superior to others. This study is weak as hell; just because a scientist came to a conclusion in a study does not mean it's correct