11 ms·
After a Legal Fight, Oberlin Says It Will Pay $36.59M to a Local Bakery
- duxup 4y ago“ The message to other colleges is to have the intestinal fortitude to be the adult in the room” That seems to be the most apt conclusion. Being an educational institution should involve more than just indulging the students. It should also challenge them and be measured in their responses to events, even if that means being unpopular with students.
- vwoolf 4y agoBeing an educational institution should involve more than just indulging the students The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) free-speech rankings seem like a good proxy for this: https://www.thefire.org/research/publications/student-surveys/2022-college-free-speech-rankings/ https://www.thefire.org/research/publications/student-survey...
- hirundo 4y agohttps://rankings.thefire.org/rank/school/oberlin-college https://rankings.thefire.org/rank/school/oberlin-college: Ranking #135, Speech Climate: Slightly Below Average So, pretty normal.
- sbuttgereit 4y agoOut of 208; Speech Code: Yellow Hmmm... pretty normal and barely passing.
- aidenn0 4y agoA few things: 1. The total ranking is wholistic, it includes pressure felt both by peers and by faculty. Given "being the adult in the room" might include reigning in peer-pressure that's probably fine. 2. FWIW, It was ranked much better on "Administrative support" 3. Tolerance for conservative speakers: #197/203 (obviously there is a lot of self-selection of liberal students going to Oberlin, so it would be very easy to be the only person with a particular conservative viewpoint, and even easier to think you are). Disclosure: My sister graduated from Oberlin 20 years ago. She was an avid line-dancer at the time and would change out of her boots before going back on campus.
- crackercrews 4y agoI can't find the link, but I read recently that FIRE came out against this verdict because they believe it infringes free speech. I agree the FIRE rankings are a good resource. But it's worth pointing out that FIRE opposes this verdict.
- pc86 4y agoWhose free speech? This verdict doesn't have anything to do with the students protesting, does it? I thought it was based [almost?] entirely on the fact that the Dean of Students was handing out these ridiculous flyers.
- sofixa 4y agoFrom TFA: > In its ruling, the Court of Appeals agreed that students had a right to protest. But the court said that the flier and a related student senate resolution — which said that the store had a history of racial profiling — were not constitutionally protected opinion. So the fliers and the student senate resolution are not free speech.
- 7402 4y agoThat doesn't sound right. It doesn't match up with what I know of FIRE. I couldn't find anything to suggest that FIRE opposed the verdict in my searches. Please try to find the link - I'd like to see it. I did find one document [0] that was a legal filing that references some FIRE documents discussing speech codes, but that was it. FIRE didn't sign it, and as far as I can tell FIRE had nothing to do with the filing supporting Oberlin. Some of the attorneys signing the filing identified themselves as "Attorneys for Amici Curiae National Coalition Against Censorship, and Defending Rights & Dissent." NCAC (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Coalition_Against_Censorship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Coalition_Against_Cen...) and DRAD (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defending_Rights_%26_Dissent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defending_Rights_%26_Dissent) are not the same thing as FIRE. [0] https://www2.oberlin.edu/appeal/documents/amicus-ncac_osc.pdf https://www2.oberlin.edu/appeal/documents/amicus-ncac_osc.pd...
- 4y ago
- dillondoyle 4y agoI just spent some time looking around that site. most of the example complaints they highlight are just students saying they don't feel comfortable speaking up or they had dorm mate issues. Does not feel like a good way to rank a school's actions to hinder speech (as an institution/administration). Does have some better real examples but large majority I read were not. Just because you don't feel comfortable doesn't mean someone is stopping you from speaking. You can't force someone to live with or listen to ones ___ whatever religion, hate speech, crazy liberal ideas etc. And yes.. Most young people are pretty open minded and fairly liberal. If you hold views outside that box you should speak them! But you can't be made if people judge you or the majority speak themselves against those beliefs. I don't see how those common complaints are a school forcing someone to be silent or punishing them for their viewpoints. Maybe I'm being too emotional given recent court rulings/direction of my country; Which is probably why I took so much time on that site and commenting. But your speech !== that I will listen, or not judge you, or allow you to be around me. A lot of the religious court rulings (PrEP most recent) feel like these complaints. Freedom to speak/express your religion does not go so far as to control my choices and my body or force me to listen to you.
- Beltalowda 4y ago> even if that means being unpopular with students. The problem is that, at the end of the day, the students are your customers for institutions like this.
- bitlax 4y agohttps://archive.ph/xOd9g https://archive.ph/xOd9g
- PaywallBuster 4y agois this considered taxable income?
- duxup 4y agoGenerally yes. Some exceptions exist but nothing like this case.
- ghufran_syed 4y agoyes, but they probably have a lot of losses from the past two years they can use to offset some of the taxes
- bruce511 4y agoThis is such a strange reply. If the business is running at a loss (including legal fees) then yes that loss can be used to reduce the tax burden this year. But since the loss burden is 100% [1],and the tax burden say 50% this is worse, not better. Sure the 5 million accumulated loss means 2.5 million less tax, but it also means 5 million gone to cover the losses.. [1] losses are funded from somewhere, and those funds typically have to be replaced sooner or later (or bankruptcy). Working capital, reserves, loans etc. Unless they're like listed on the stock exchange.
- ghufran_syed 4y agodefine “strange” - perhaps by identifying something in my statement that is factually incorrect? Or do you agree with the statement and wish the world was different somehow?
- bruce511 4y ago"strange" might be the wrong word. I mean in the sense that it feels like you're suggesting that "offsetting expenses" makes it better. When it makes it worse. [1]. So in answering the question "is this taxable income" - the answer is "yes". If you wanted to qualify it more it would be more along the lines of "not just tax, there's likely a lot of other expenses incurred as well." [1] Yes, it's better in the pure sense that there's "less tax", but overall there's more expenses than the tax that was saved.
- spamizbad 4y agoIs there more to this story? I'm honestly pretty shocked by this. The college basically got into hot water for having its Dean show up at a protest holding a flyer.
- jononomo 4y agoOberlin drove the bakery out of business while knowing full well that the bakery did nothing wrong. The kid that got caught shoplifting plead guilty and he also outright stated that racism was not involved.
- jjeaff 4y agoThis doesn't necessarily go against your point, but I have seen far too many innocent people coerced into pleading guilty to actually believe someone is guilty based on a guilty plea.
- crackercrews 4y agoSure, that happens. But it's most likely when the accused has too few resources to win at trial. Here the college was clearly in their corner. Why would they plead guilty and say racism was no part of it? Their statements seems very credible under the circumstances.
- alsaaro 4y agoThe kids accused of shoplifting were charged with felonies and eventually plead down to misdemeanors. Race is always a factor in America, especially its criminal justice system, are the students confessions genuine contrition or motivated by fear of disproportionate punishment? A question impossible to answer.
- kthejoker2 4y agoTheir guilt was definitely not in question. They were arrested by the cops in the middle of the act of assaulting the employee (kicking him while he was on the ground) and with the shoplifted property on their possession. A conviction was already assured, the guilty plea was an extremely rational move, whether out of contrition or fear.
- viggity 4y agoThis case is so egregious, in a just world there would be a criminal case too. 2 members of the bakery family have died as Oberlin has dragged this out.
- eternalban 4y agoDied of what? Emotional stress? Financial hardship? (Just asking)
- wl 4y agoAge.
- crackercrews 4y agoCancer and old age, IIRC. The author of this story implies that the drawn out saga may have contributed to the cancer death. [1] 1: https://www.commonsense.news/p/will-i-ever-see-the-36-million-oberlin https://www.commonsense.news/p/will-i-ever-see-the-36-millio...
- eternalban 4y agoThanks.
- richbell 4y agoIt's impossible to say; I have personally experienced how stress can significantly deteriorate one's health, so I believe it.
- colinmhayes 4y agoThe family members dying isn't oberlin's fault. They're allowed to appeal.
- phnofive 4y agoOut of its three comma endowment, it will pay a settlement of about six hundred student's annual tuition, which is a little less than a quarter of their undergrad population. After a six year smear campaign, sounds like money well spent!
- jerrya 4y agoApparently, Oberlin's President sent out the following email which states their insurance will pay > Dear Obies, > Today, Oberlin College and Conservatory initiated payment in full of the $36.59 million judgment in the Gibson’s Bakery case, an amount that represents the awarded damages and interest owed. Please see the college’s public statement below. > While this outcome is a disappointment, our financial plans for this possibility, which included insurance coverage, mean that this payment will not impact or diminish our academic or student life experience, or require us to draw down Oberlin’s endowment. > Like me, the majority of the campus was not here at the beginning of this matter in 2016. But it is also true that this case has been difficult for all of us who love this institution and its hometown. I am looking forward to all that is ahead, and remain focused on Oberlin’s core mission of providing a truly excellent liberal arts and musical education. > Carmen Twillie Ambar > President
- RhysU 4y ago> Like me, the majority of the campus was not here at the beginning of this matter in 2016. The buck stops with my predecessor. Delightful executive engineering of the slimiest sort. One gets paid to own the past at that level. Accepting the job requires due diligence on the past and being paid to own any uncertainty. That is one disgustingly cowardly sentence meriting immediate action by the board to throw this bum out. Notice, I don't care about the outcome but only the integrity that such an exec should show.
- heartbreak 4y agoCan I ask why you’re so upset about something that apparently does not involve you at all?
- crhulls 4y agoI am not all sympathetic to Oberlin, but this judgement is absurd. It is many many lifetimes of income for a small bakery. Even if they were forced into bankruptcy, this is beyond the pale. "The latest amount consists of about $5 million in compensatory damages, nearly $20 million in punitive damages, $6.5 million in attorney’s fees and almost $5 million in interest." This only contributes to our litigious society where lawyers get rich through shakedowns, and we as citizens and consumers shoulder the price either through increased overhead that is passed on to us, or ever more absurd disclaimers and risk mitigation measures to prevent from frivolous suits. So I am glad Oberlin lost overall, but the size of this judgement makes me very sad.
- dmitrygr 4y agoThat is what punitive damages are - they are not required to be connected to the size of the damage, they are meant to punish the defendant for royally (in the judge's view) fucking up, and send a message to other similar defendants to not do such things And $5M in compensatory damages seems about right for 2 years of a successful small bakery
- lajamerr 4y agoHonestly I'm not very keen on pinning blame/monetary responsibility on single individuals/companies to 'prevent/deter' unknown future crimes. We shouldn't be signaling with big punishments bigger than the crimes call for. We should carefully consider the crime based on the individual and how much punishment is appropriate for that individual to compensate the victim/deter that single individual/company from continuing that future behavior. Not to stop others. Why should I get 30 years for a crime that should be 5 years because they want to send a signal. Make it fair and make it equal. Edit: Apparently this is a unpopular opinion. All I am calling for is that punishment meets the crime. Not meets the crime and exceeds it in order to prevent unrelated parties from committing the same crime. They aren't my responsibility.
- unwise-exe 4y ago> We should carefully consider the crime based on the individual and how much punishment is appropriate for that individual to compensate the victim/deter that single individual/company from continuing that future behavior. Not to stop others. I'd think that having your standard practice be to make sure it wasn't worth it would find the same amount as the threshhold for both deterring the current perpetrator and deterring others.
- fortran77 4y ago
- paulryanrogers 4y agoI hired and worked with an Oberlin graduate. Great person. Talented engineer. What specifically puts you off their entire student body; past, present, and future?
- fortran77 4y agoWell, I just looked on Twitter and see many, many Oberlin grads lamenting the Gibson's judgement and claiming that "everyone always knew" Gibson's was "racist" without any hard facts. Just one example: https://twitter.com/ejdickson/status/1566061809500622848 https://twitter.com/ejdickson/status/1566061809500622848 She's still calling people who pled guilty to shoplifting "alleged shoplifters." That's dishonest. Let's just say I don't hold by that school's accreditation.
- krasin 4y agoIt's best to judge individual people for their indiviual deeds. Discrimination by a fact of belonging to a group is too imprecise, almost always. It's okay to be more vigilant based on it, though - statistics does work.
- remarkEon 4y agoUnrelated to your reply, but that twitter thread is truly bizarre. >The one thing about this that has always struck me as ludicrous is the argument that the student body serves as a tool of the colleges whims. Students fucking hate the administration and resist it at every turn, & always have…much like 19 yos at any liberal arts college Then why go to these schools? I don't understand why you'd pay $80k a year (just checked Oberlin's tuition for 2022) to go to a place that you hate. It makes absolutely no sense!
- compiler-guy 4y ago
- kevin_thibedeau 4y ago> Carmen Twillie Ambar: archaic chase-and-detain policy regarding suspected shoplifters was the catalyst for the protests. If you witness a crime you can arrest the criminal. It's basic civics. Something you might find about in an institution of higher learning. Don't know if they have one of those in Oberlin.
- scarface74 4y agoYes, what could possibly go wrong giving private citizens the right to detain other private citizens https://www.nytimes.com/article/ahmaud-arbery-shooting-georgia.html https://www.nytimes.com/article/ahmaud-arbery-shooting-georg...
- atdrummond 4y agoNot what happened here at all.
- scarface74 4y ago> If you witness a crime you can arrest the criminal He did not say “if you witness a crime you can call the police”. I don’t want a society where any random yokel thinks he can detain someone.
- krzyk 4y agoYou can't argue with the law.
- scarface74 4y agoThe old Dixiecrats said the same thing about Jim Crow laws, laws against miscegenation, etc. But that law was in fact “argued against” in the very red Georgia and it was repealed by a Republican legislation and Republican governor
- happyopossum 4y ago
- crackercrews 4y ago> The college said then that the bakery’s “archaic chase-and-detain policy regarding suspected shoplifters was the catalyst for the protests.” IIRC, the employee tried to take a photo of the shoplifter with his phone. The shoplifter took/smashed the phone or something. This makes it much more reasonable for the employee to try to stop the shoplifter from getting away. It wasn't like he tried to cuff the guy off the bat. He started with taking a photo but was thwarted.
- Lazare 4y agoYep. From wikipedia: > On Wednesday, November 9, 2016, an underage African-American Oberlin College student and Student Assistant Treasurer,[9] Jonathan Aladin (aka Elijah Aladin), attempted to purchase a bottle of wine using a fake identification card.[8] The store clerk, Allyn D. Gibson, a son and grandson of the owners,[6] rejected the fake ID. Gibson noticed that the student was concealing two other bottles of wine inside his jacket.[10][6] According to a police report, Gibson told the student he was contacting the police, and when Gibson pulled out his phone to take a photo of the student, the student slapped it away, striking Gibson's face.[11] The student ran out of the store. Gibson followed and then grabbed and held onto the shoplifter outside the store after the shoplifter had also assaulted the store owner, David Gibson.[6] Two other students, Cecelia Whettstone and Endia Lawrence, friends of the shoplifter, joined the scuffle.[6] When the police arrived, they witnessed Gibson lying on the ground with the three students punching and kicking him.[11] The police report stated that Gibson sustained a swollen lip, several cuts, and other minor injuries.[7][12] The police arrested the students, charging all three with assault and the shoplifter with robbery as well. In August 2017, the three students pleaded guilty, stating that they believed Gibson's actions were justified and were not racially motivated.[11][13][14] Their plea deals carried no jail time in exchange for restitution, the public statement, and a promise of future good behavior.[13][15] From their trial courtroom, Assistant Dean of Students Antoinette Myers sent Raimondo a text message: "I hope we rain fire and brimstone on that store."[16] That's not really an example of a "chase-and-detain policy", nor was it a "suspected shoplifter"; by the time anyone was chasing anyone else, it was a matter of assault.
- MikePlacid 4y ago
- NoblePublius 4y agoThe college still hasn’t admitted it has done anything wrong, and to my knowledge has not fired anyone for fabricating a hate crime, or doubling and tripling down on the fabrication.
- jerrya 4y agoFrom the nytimes article, the judgment will be paid by Oberlin's insurance company, it will not come out of the endowment, they have not apologized, they are not accepting they were wrong, there have been no resignations. Meredith Raimondo, the Dean of Students at the time, who was passing out flyers and far more, nine months ago to accept a position as Vice President of Student Affairs at Oglethorpe University https://oberlinreview.org/25680/news/former-dos-meredith-raimondo-leaves-oberlin/ https://oberlinreview.org/25680/news/former-dos-meredith-rai... From the NYTimes: > In a statement, Oberlin said that “this matter has been painful for everyone.” It added, “We hope that the end of the litigation will begin the healing of our entire community.” > The college acknowledged that the size of the judgment, which includes damages and interest, was “significant.” But it said that “with careful financial planning,” including insurance, it could be paid “without impacting our academic and student experience.” Oberlin has a robust endowment of nearly $1 billion. So what has Oberlin really learned?
- yardstick 4y ago> So what has Oberlin really learned? That their insurance premium will rise only marginally next year.
- yakak 4y agoI would suspect that they learned their premium will rise substantially unless they take a few mitigating actions to not make thislevel of payment a regular reoccurrence. Insurance company as conscience seems like society reaching the anarcho-capatalist rock bottom to me, but there's the "learning".
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pc86 4y agoEven if it were to come out of the endowment, it's what, 2-3% total? I don't know how much universities typically pull out of an endowment each year but a 3% total drop can't impact yearly budgets in any meaningful way.
- spoonjim 4y agoI wonder if there’s a way to bait institutions into doing this to you so you can get a big payday
- happyopossum 4y ago> it said that “with careful financial planning,” including insurance, it could be paid “without impacting our academic and student experience.” Oberlin has a robust endowment of nearly $1 billion So insurance is gonna pony up for them, they won’t have to touch their BILLION dollars, the my don’t have to apologize, and aren’t admitting any wrongdoing. At least the Gibson family will get something out of it. Not sure it’s justice, but $36Mil would go far…
- scarab92 4y agoAt a guess, "with careful financial planning" means after negotiation our insurers, we agreed to pay increased premiums sufficient to reimburse the insurer for damages paid, allowing us to announce that the endowment is untouched and avoiding another lawsuit over whether our behaviour was covered by our insurance policy or not.
- ck2 4y agoI'm still processing the $6.5 Million the lawyers made.
- Ekaros 4y ago22% is bit much. But if I were in for 30 million payday I might be able to live with it.
- abduhl 4y agoThey probably didn't have to live with it either way. If you win then Oberlin pays, if you lose then hopefully the lawyers were on contingency and you're out nothing. Hell, the lawyers might have even funded the appeal based on winning below.
- rahimnathwani 4y agoThe hourly rate used to calculate the award for fees was under $300. This case could have gone either way. The lawyers took this case on contingency, i.e. no win no fee.
- imgabe 4y agoHopefully, it also costs them in plummeting enrollment as students realize that getting an education from an institution that willfully ignores facts might not be a great idea. One can dream, anyway.
- alsaaro 4y agoThis judgement is problematic on so many fronts, most concerning is it chills free speech, and attaches popular moral precepts to political speech. Oberlin is now responsible for the speech of its adult students and now must censor them in a Ministry of Truth like role to avoid civil liability. Must they also censor researchers debunking the efficacy of drugs in trials causing financial harm to Big Pharma? Gibson's may even be right morally, they are unfairly maligned as racists, but free speech doesn't hinge on morality, but liberty.
- googlryas 4y agoNot at all. What Oberlin isn't allowed to do is the same thing it wasn't allowed to do before - help organize a boycott of a legitimate business based on libelous accusations. The students can still do whatever they want to the extent that the institution chooses to not punish them.
- tptacek 4y agoOberlin can arrange a boycott of a business like Gibson's for being "racist" or "pro-carceral" or any of a dozen other woke reasons. What they can't do is publish false statements of actual fact, like the assertion that an employee of Gibson's assaulted a student.
- alsaaro 4y agoYou can organize a boycott for any conceivable reason, the reason doesn't have to make logical sense, be politically correct, or moral. Do you believe business are entitled to your money? And if they no longer earn your business they should be able to sue you? This perversity happened during the Civil Rights movement, white business owners sued blacks who caused them financial losses for refusing to patronize their racist establishments.
- fmajid 4y ago"Oberlin Says It Will Pay $36.59M to a Local Bakery" It's not a magnanimous concession by Oberlin, it's a court-ordered amount. If they didn't pay, the bailiffs would arrive.
- ahaferburg 4y agoThis seems like local news about an assault case. What makes this HN-note-worthy?