6 ms·
The common presumption with free markets is that companies will grow until they consume the world. But as this article suggests, what actually happens is that c
by WalterBright 4y ago
The common presumption with free markets is that companies will grow until they consume the world. But as this article suggests, what actually happens is that companies grow until their internal bureaucracy strangles them.
Google's search business is heavily optimized towards and dependent on selling ads. Competing directly with them in search is not likely to work. But another way of doing search (I don't know what that might be) could completely undermine it.
After all, Google sank Alta Vista and Yahoo with another way of doing search.
- kashkhan 4y agocompetition (winner takes all) naturally results in oligopoly or monopoly in any market. The market is unstable. You can fight this by unending regulation/antitrust. Or by finding better ways to distribute scarce resources.
- WalterBright 4y ago> competition (winner takes all) naturally results in oligopoly or monopoly in any market. Naturally? Name one. Google/Apple/Amazon/Netflix/Tesla don't have monopolies.
- jen20 4y agoTo name two which have formed oligopolies: - cellphone carriers in the US - airlines in the US
- WalterBright 4y agoNot monopolies.
- jen20 4y agoSo? The post mentioned monopolies _AND_ oligopolies. Whether they're monopolies is thus irrelevant.
- kashkhan 4y agolook at market shares over time. initially you have innovation. then many entrants fight for it. then one wins. google is search monopoly amazon has ecommerce and AWS. netflix was innovator, middle period. apple is taking 80% of profits in mobile. middle period. tesla/electric cars is in beginning.
- WalterBright 4y agoNone of those are monopolies.
- wikfwikf 4y agoHow is Google not a monopoly? Their nearest competitor is probably 10 times smaller.
- WalterBright 4y agobing.com
- colinmhayes 4y ago2.5% market share. Not a real competitor.
- WalterBright 4y agoI use it. Maybe you can try it for a while and see if you find its results competitive.
- perryizgr8 4y agoEven if the search results are good, Google is still a monopoly.
- danaris 4y agoYou need to get the idea out of your head that "monopoly" means literally has no competitor.
- yjftsjthsd-h 4y agoDoes Google not have a monopoly on search?
- WalterBright 4y agobing.com
- hpkuarg 4y ago"In any market" is too strong a statement. In markets with high barriers to entry or other factors that make it less competitive, sure, and we call them natural monopolies. But you're claiming that every market is a natural monopoly.
- kashkhan 4y agoyes some markets take longer times and sometime tech changes so we never reach the end. but the end result is always the same as long as firms are involved. It's a feature of capitalism.
- hpkuarg 4y agoIt's not some immutable law of capitalism. There is such a thing as diseconomies of scale, where firms that are too large end up being less competitive and unable to innovate as quickly. Once they reach that size they might borrow the power of government to crush competition and retain their monopoly, but at that point we may as well it call a feature of socialism, not of capitalism. I'd be surprised if in twenty years of market forces (that is, assuming neither government antitrust action nor cronyist behavior making competitors illegal) more people were using Google for search than they are now.
- WalterBright 4y agoIf monopolies are always the end result in a free market, name one.
- elmomle 4y ago"Free market" does not mean a market without any regulatory structure. A market in which monopolies have formed is not free, as monopolies can force conditions on transactions that would not exist if multiple independent and competing parties were able to participate on the supply side.
- Proven 4y ago
- WalterBright 4y agoMonopolies only form in a free market when the government enforces them. Like the trash collection monopoly in your city.
- voisin 4y ago> Monopolies only form in a free market when the government enforces them. This is incorrect. There are many industries that lead to natural monopolies in the absence of government breaking them up. Anything with incredibly high fixed entry costs, few substitute opportunities and low variable costs tend toward monopolies (at least regionally).
- WalterBright 4y agoName one.
- voisin 4y agoThe quintessential example is railroads, but also most utility providers (electricity, water, natural gas). Toll Roads / Bridges (often the substitutes are not good alternatives). Telecoms (to a lesser degree and declining thanks to the entry of new substitutes).
- WalterBright 4y ago
- fatherzine 4y agoOn top of my head, a couple different ways of doing search I've been using lately: * Business search via maps service. * "How To" search via video service. Funny enough, best services to do so are Google Maps and YouTube.
- Aaronstotle 4y agoI think TikTok is up there and possibly surpassed YouTube for the younger generation. TikTok's user base is huge and their app makes it incredibly easy for anyone to upload and edit videos, so naturally you get lot of how to do X.
- fatherzine 4y agoYou are probably very correct! I don't use TikTok, but I noticed TikTok second-hand, via YouTube's heavily promoted Shorts.
- baja_blast 4y agodepends on the how-to, if it's how to not ruin a dress shirt in the washing machine sure. If it's a technical in depth subject Youtube is the place to be, you can't learn systems programming on your smart phone in a minute.
- rayusher 4y agoI read article about how some young people are using tiktok to search for stuff instead of google. If they want to check out a restaurant or an event they would see if someone made a tiktok of it.
- tmpz22 4y agoGoogle already lost the "how-to" competition. * If you "how-to" a recipe here's a 3000 word blog post with a dozen interweaved videos and a life story at the beginning. * If you want a "how-to" Youtube video here's a 10:01 video because gosh darn we need to hit that time count to maximize ad revenue, don't forget to smash the like button it really helps my channel A 12 second TikTok short or searching reddit via a third party app are both terrible alternatives that are nonetheless vastly better then Google's current offering for some meaningful searches.
- nextos 4y ago> [...] until their internal bureaucracy strangles them. I think that standard microeconomics textbooks state empirical efficiency curves tend to have an inverted U shape, so beyond certain size things get more and more inefficient. Bureaucracy, politics and communication play a significant role here. This is also what I have observed in academic and industrial labs, which scale far less than companies. Beyond certain size, quite small in fact, most managers become rent seekers and the whole thing collapses in slow motion. I think that this is a significant problem for society, as it leads to a massive waste of resources. There should be better ways to scale up organizations, or to build federated ones. Biological organisms are much better organized than us. We can do better.
- nneonneo 4y ago> Biological organisms are much better organized than us. We can do better. If you’re referring to the fact that an organism like a human body can function with trillions of individual cells, it is indeed marvelous and quite well organized. But, cells and people are different. Cells in your body are all genetically identical, and lack any form of “individuality”. Indeed, they possess genetic fetters that will cause them to commit suicide should they become too unique, and should a cell manage to throw off all of those limitations they will become cancerous and potentially kill the entire host. Regulating a large and diverse set of individuals is a much harder problem than regulating an army of clones, after all.
- dekhn 4y agoI disagree with your assertion that cells in a body are all genetically identical- in addition to any cell-specific mutations (which occur any time cells divide) and epigenetics (which provides every cell with unique modifications), at any time a particular cell's RNA complement is unique and this can be used to cluster cells in a high dimensional space. If you just mean "all cells in a body have chromosomes ultimately descended from the gamete", then yeah, sure, but that doesn't really say anything about the full state of a complex organism (which depends on the instantaneous protein concentrations, damage, etc).
- prng2021 4y ago
- nicoburns 4y agoMy pet theory is that the problems which people often associate with government have nothing to do with the difference between government and private business at all and are simply a product of organisation size. The logic that a small number of decisions makers directing a large amount of labour/capital leads to inefficiencies due to a decision-making bottleneck certainly seems to apply to both (and indeed to wealthy individuals beyond a certain level of wealth).
- midenginedcoupe 4y agoStrongly agree. Anyone who's worked in private orgs of comparable sizes can attest to their horrendous inefficiencies and waste. The idea that somehow the private sector is inherently more productive or efficient is simply not bourne out in practice. But it _sounds_ like it ought to be true so the idea won't die. And we're all worse off as a result.
- Melatonic 4y agoVery true Also you get what you pay for and governments generally are not paying at the top of the scale. Giant + middle of the road pay is going to get you the same results in a private org!
- WalterBright 4y agoIf you add in the value of benefits, government employment pays very, very well.
- WalterBright 4y agoThey are inherently more productive or efficient because: 1. they have a profit motive, and if they don't show a profit, they die 2. smaller companies continually replace large, bureaucratic organizations > simply not bourne out in practice SpaceX can launch rockets at what, 10% of the cost of NASA? > we're all worse off as a result How so?
- 4y ago
- Melatonic 4y agoGoogle did not really do anything THAT different than Alta Vista - they just did it better, cleaner, and with less junk on your screen. The results were better, they obviously had a better algo, and they didnt blast you with ads. They also (from what I remember) had some early and easy to use search modifiers for the general public (like quotes). Unfortunately now this has trended toward the opposite as they destroyed all their competition. I am hoping something like Kagi Search succeeds so we at least have more options.
- WalterBright 4y agoBeing an Alta Vista user before Google, one search with Google ended my use of Alta Vista. Yes, it was THAT different.
- lupire 4y agoTh difference was that Google didn't optimize search to sell ads, which is the opposite of your original comment.
- andsoitis 4y agoIs there a search engine today that, in your view, provides better search results than Google? It sounds like you’re implying that.
- dredmorbius 4y agoGoogle's results (in 1999) were relevant, the best results were on the first page (and very often in the first position), simple search terms worked (I'd long since mastered complex AltaVista search queries, and still had to dig through pages of results for relevant hits). Hell, I remember when AltaVista first appeared --- I was at a conference where DEC were demoing their 64-bit Ultrix at the time, which was what permitted the search index to be held in memory in the first place (AV's secret to speed). Google simply blew it out of the water. That said, that was a very long time ago, and was a very different Google.
- origin_path 4y ago
- jollybean 4y agoThis article would have nothing to do with that thesis. We're supposedly heading into a downturn, investors want to hear about 'efficiency'. Sundar is playing the game. And possibly the occasion to make a few cuts maybe he's wanted to make for a while.