9 ms·
KeePass is the free, open source, light-weight and easy-to-use password manager
- nix23 4y agoUse KeePassXC please.... Or pass if your only on unix'es ;) https://www.passwordstore.org/ https://www.passwordstore.org/
- viridian 4y agoKeePassXC is one of the best pieces of software out there. Does exactly what it needs to do, runs on every device I've ever owned, and has been independently audited for implementation weaknesses. It's not just great FOSS software, it's just straight up great software.
- bloaf 4y agoIt would regularly fail connect to the browser plugins when I tried it (despite successfully connecting previously), and the browser plugins failed to autofill more often than not. There were a ton of usability headaches in the core application too. The UI was quite unintuitive. It may be technically great, but that's just one dimension of greatness.
- viridian 4y agoSorry, I've never used the browser plugins. Personally, generally don't want code with squishy, hard to conceptualize access rights having more access to my web data than I intend, so I just run the desktop app or mobile app and use the copy password button to add it to the clipboard for 10 seconds.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoehhhhh lots of programs can watch your clipboard.... 10 seconds is an eternity in the lifetime of malware.
- dathinab 4y agoNever had problems with connecting to the browser (as long as frequently you update the software/browser plugin). IMHO The UI of the Linux app is ok, not grate but very usable. The Android app I think is worse though. Failing to fill auto-fill is in my experience 100% to blame on the website in question. It happens more often then with some commercial alternatives. They just don't have the same amount of resources to work around websites doing stupid quirky things with password input fields. Which websites would stop doing quirky password input field stuff.
- nix23 4y ago>and has been independently audited for implementation weaknesses. True, and also recommend by the EFF: https://ssd.eff.org/en/module/creating-strong-passwords https://ssd.eff.org/en/module/creating-strong-passwords
- liberia 4y agoI trust this over Bitwarden or Lastpass since you have to trust those services with your data (and I don't). Web-based password managers can be hacked, or have their login interface laced with third-party code that could be exfiltrating your master passphrase. My strategy is using KeePass and keeping multiple copies of the database in various cloud providers in case my local copy is lost/corrupted. It takes under a minute to sync my local copy to Dropbox, Google Drive, Box, etc
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- n4r9 4y agoFor the super paranoid, SyncThing provides a straightforward way for you to synchronise your database between various local devices without having any data in the cloud at all. [edit: Syncthing's Discovery Server probably counts as data, actually; you can work around that but then it's less "straightforward"]
- xtracto 4y agoOMG I tried to setup SyncThing a couple of months ago to sync my KeePassX (kdbx) between my PC, my MAC and my Android phone. It was hell, I had to fight SyncThing every step of the way (connecting between clients, which one is the receiver and which one is the sender and whatnot), and it just didn't sync. In addition I learned that in Android SyncThing cannot sync to an external SD card ( https://github.com/syncthing/syncthing-android/issues/1366 https://github.com/syncthing/syncthing-android/issues/1366 ) . I ended up uploading the file to Google Drive and using it's client. It works pretty flawlessly.
- n4r9 4y agoIt works just fine for my PC, laptop and Android. Shame that you had a bad experience with it although perhaps your use case is a bit unusual. Although that's surprising about Android being so difficult to work with in Go. It sounds like this is being resolved in Android 10 upwards: https://github.com/syncthing/syncthing-android/wiki/Frequently-Asked-Questions https://github.com/syncthing/syncthing-android/wiki/Frequent...
- patrulek 4y ago
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- ReptileMan 4y agoDoes anyone has a good self hosting sync scheme? Keepass is awesome... But hadn't managed the sync to work smoothly yet
- knife1nhead 4y agoI use resilio sync to sync my keepass file and it's working out pretty well. https://www.resilio.com/individuals/ https://www.resilio.com/individuals/
- xenago 4y agoI use WebDAV. Just throw up a container like dgraziotin/nginx-webdav-nononsense and connect to keepass2android and keeweb. I then use regular backup software to back up the mounted WebDAV files.
- wormer 4y agoUse syncthing on a folder with the database
- GordonS 4y agoI sync over SFTP to a VPS. Works with Keepass2Android on mobile too, I've used this for several years now.
- nicoburns 4y agoNot keepass, but you can self-host Bitwarden using `vaultwarden`, an open-source reimplementation of the server (the official server is also partially open source, but complex to install and run - this one is a simple binary you can run), which works with the official client apps.
- hartmel 4y agoA few year ago I was syncing keepass over http (it's built in keepass) with a Apache httpd and webdav module. Configuration was not really tricky and worked flawlessly. I even managed to use a yubikey on sync request.
- steventhedev 4y agoKeepassxc and syncthing. I sync two databases across Mac, linux, ipads, and android phones. One for work, one for personal.
- c-fe 4y agoI have been using KeePass with their official client on Windows and Strongbox (free tier) on both MacOS and iOS, and I synchronise via iCloud (previously via Google Drive). For me this solution has been working perfectly fine since many years now, and I am really not a technical user. I’m always surprised why not more people seem to use this solution (i.e. why password manager discussion is so common on HN)
- ZeWaka 4y agoExactly what I use (w/ GDrive and on my Android) - it really is such a clean solution, and you're in complete control of the hosting.
- slaymaker1907 4y agoYou should try out KeePassXC if you haven't already. It's cross platform and I think it's better than the official client on Windows.
- baal80spam 4y agoI also use KeePassXC for several years now and think it is better (hey, it has dark mode!) however it doesn't support plugins so it might not be a viable solution for everyone. I love KeePass for many reasons but one of the killer features for me is notes and encrypted attachments. It's also one of the reasons why I won't switch to applications like Bitwarden.
- vetinari 4y ago> but one of the killer features for me is notes and encrypted attachments. It's also one of the reasons why I won't switch to applications like Bitwarden. Bitwarden has both ;)
- runjake 4y agoPreferably use KeePassXC. Why? -> https://keepassxc.org/docs/#faq-keepassx https://keepassxc.org/docs/#faq-keepassx
- ZacharyPitts 4y agoShort answer: written in C++ instead of C# I also have used keepassxc for years now on mac/windows/linux/iphones
- barbazoo 4y ago> written in C++ instead of C# what are the advantages of that?
- ThunderSizzle 4y agoBefore .NET Core, C# can't run natively on non-Windows. That's probably the only real advantage.
- pjmlp 4y agoI guess mono never happened...
- sebazzz 4y agoIn fact, Keepass is actively supporting mono (they regularly have patches that improve mono support)
- ThunderSizzle 4y ago"natively" was the key word
- piperswe 4y agoI don't know as Mono is any less native than .NET, they both have to JIT the program's IL, and the .NET APIs don't really expose much of anything that's platform-specific so there isn't really a "native" platform.
- daveslash 4y agoI've been using Bruce Schneier's Password Safe for years - very happy with it. I was recently looking at KeePass. I've dug into the comparison a little bit, but I'd be interested to hear this community's take on KeePass vs. PasswordSafe.
- timbit42 4y agoI've used PasswordSafe for some years. My only complaint is I'd like a way to access the user, pass and notes in a view-only mode without editing so I don't accidentally trash something. I switched to KeePassXC on one of my laptops and it seems OK but requires more clicking to access and autotype a username and password. I haven't switched on any other devices. Still undecided.
- sizzzzlerz 4y agoI've been using KeePass on my windows PCs and Mac/IOS compatible versions on macs, iPads, and iPhones for years. I have my database on Dropbox so that all the Apple devices sync to the same file and a keep a local copy on my PC that is automatically updated from the Mac using WinSCP, a .bat file, and task scheduler. I have to do the copy thing because Dropbox reduced the number of devices that can access it directly to 3 several months ago for the free account. I even have it running on my work PC (sssshhhhhh!). Needless to say, I love it. It's features nicely fit my browsing style plus it's free.
- kasajian 4y agoSounds pretty simple for about .000001% of users who could potentially use it. The rest would have no idea how to do any of this.
- sizzzzlerz 4y agoI didn't do this for anybody but me. As long as I know how to do it, that's all the matters. Let them spend 42 years in the computer industry to figure it out.
- hk1337 4y agoSyncthing (https://syncthing.net https://syncthing.net) is another solution for syncing between multiple devices/computers. One thing I liked about Dropbox, that wasn't necessarily available on Linux, was the ability to choose whether to sync the files locally or keep them on Dropbox. I'm pretty much Syncthing + Synology these days. The bulk of my files are on Synology and the little files like the keepass databases are passed around with Syncthing.
- schlauerfox 4y agoI keep the database in onedrive, but I keep a keyfile in addition to my password that I never put on the shared folders online.
- pbhjpbhj 4y agoHow is KeepassDX? It's on F-Droid.
- mfashby 4y agoI use it. It seems good.
- qbasic_forever 4y agoWorks great in my experience. Even supports biometric auth for unlocking your database if you'd like to use it.
- j7j7j7j7 4y agoI use KeepassXC on Linux and KeepassDX on Android... and Syncthing to keep them in sync... works great.
- dvdgsng 4y agoIt's great, but lacks yubikey support. Might arrive very soon, though, beta is already available in play store, see https://github.com/Kunzisoft/KeePassDX/issues/8 https://github.com/Kunzisoft/KeePassDX/issues/8
- janef0421 4y agoI use it on my phone and tablet. It works very well, I have no real complaints.
- kemayo 4y agoIn a way this is a nice example of why 1Password or BitWarden are doing well. This might work out okay for a technical person, but the average user isn't going to look at the KeyPass downloads page [1] and feel confident about what to download -- even assuming they're using Windows, you need a phone app and sync for meaningful password management these days... and that's very worrying in their presentation. Whereas 1Password and similar do just tell you "download this everywhere, it'll do what you need". [1]: https://keepass.info/download.html https://keepass.info/download.html
- nerdponx 4y agoKeePassXC is overall a much better experience. Even the website is significantly less intimidating-looking.
- imaltont 4y agoAt least KeePassXC has a non-cryptic website. Still not as convenient as the cloud based ones though, but it's nice if you are primarily using one device or know how to share the database between your devices.
- barbazoo 4y agoPlus I feel that once one has experienced the browser integration of 1Pass, BW, LastPass, etc it's hard to go back to manually filling credentials again. That and the seamless sync across devices. It's just too much to handle for non techie folk.
- bloaf 4y agoI'm willing to tolerate a little friction to setup syncing, but keepass has friction at almost every level. Their importer is powerful... but I had to manually configure it to import from lastpass. Just bake that in ffs. There is no "generate password" button on the main application screen despite that being the #2 use for a password manager behind autofilling. Instead the main screen has "find", "find entries" and "search" buttons which are all slightly different despite sounding completely redundant. To get a browser plugin, you have to pick from a disturbingly long list, each with pros and cons, each requiring a few config steps, and none of which work as well as the cloud competition. I had random disconnections from keepass and many autofill failures. Finally, you get to syncing, and the friction is bigger than you expect. It is not enough to set up a LAN folder; your solution needs to be able to resolve conflicts if you ever use more than one device simultaneously, otherwise you run the risk of losing changes. The most common sync solution is dropbox because that is the only mainstream cloud offering with first party support for linux, which is fine, but can still cause conflicts. The recommended way to handle this is quite convoluted[1]. Just bake that in, FFS! [1] https://keepass.info/help/kb/trigger_examples.html#dbsync https://keepass.info/help/kb/trigger_examples.html#dbsync
- ktzar 4y agohttps://keeweb.info/ https://keeweb.info/ is a website that loads a local keepass database (or from something like Google Drive). That's what I use in my Chromebook, reading the same database I keep in sync there, which I also access from Android.
- jonpalmisc 4y agoKeePass is awesome. Open spec. Works offline. Plenty of good clients for every platform. Self-managed syncing via your service of choice (Dropbox, OneDrive, <other>, etc.). Can't recommend it enough.
- xenago 4y agoKeepass2android and keeweb really make for an excellent password manager system when combined. I have been using for years and love it.
- nimbius 4y agodaily reminder: the standard password manager is pass. https://www.passwordstore.org/ https://www.passwordstore.org/
- almog 4y agoI imagine it might be obvious for most users and potential users of pass, and being in line with the unix philosophy, it might be by design, but still, since I didn't see it mentioned in the documentation, it's worth mentioning: By itself, Passwordstore will not encrypt file names or directory names (which by convention represent the names of the service/site you have an account with). That might not pose a problem if no one else has access to the machine that hosts your git repo, but if that's not the case (even if it's a private repo on whatever platform), you might want to use either Tomb or git-crypt-remote to have full end-to-end encryption. There are even some tools that glue tomb and pass together (https://github.com/roddhjav/pass-tomb https://github.com/roddhjav/pass-tomb for one), though I'm not sure what's the situation is like when it comes to mobile integration with tomb/git-crypt-remote.
- aborsy 4y agoYou may not need to encrypt file names. Those are website address and perhaps with usernames, and public information. It’s like suggesting to encrypt public keys.
- almog 4y ago> It’s like suggesting to encrypt public keys. Wouldn't that same argument suggest that that encrypted DNS queries should not be something one would want to use? My point is - it's nothing like that, I'm sure that most people could think of at least one website at some point in their life where they'd want to keep the knowledge of them having an account with that website private.
- clircle 4y agoStandard? How is this a standard?
- devarifhossain 4y agoDamn! Guess you really need a few frontend contributors
- mikece 4y agoIt's been a few years but KeePassXC had far stronger memory security than KeePass. https://keepassxc.org/blog/2019-02-21-memory-security/ https://keepassxc.org/blog/2019-02-21-memory-security/
- behnamoh 4y agoHere we go again: Some company (in this case, Bitwarden) "betrayed" its customers by doing what every other firm does. And Hn goes brrr over it. I wonder, aren't the majority of HNers working at a for-profit company funded by VCs? The hypocrisy is just intolerable at this point.
- dathinab 4y agoDoesn't mean the companies the work for did so. Doesn't mean they agreed with their employers decision. Doesn't mean they don't complain about it when their company does it. Doesn't mean they don't raise complains internally with their employer. But what do you expect? They quitting their job about this, many can't afford it. They mentioning how bad their employer is too every time they complain about a different company? That would be just annoying (close to) no one wants that. Sure some people which also work for much worse companies wrt. such properties and are not currently looking for a different employer are hypocrites. But so what? Better voice your complains even if you don't act on them then to not even voice your complains and just accept bad things. (Sure acting on them would be even better, way better.)
- behnamoh 4y agoAt the end of the day, engineers/programmers are the ones who implement these changes. I find it unacceptable that lots of HNers get so high minded about these issues but then go on to contribute to the problem by working at for-profit companies. Nothing wrong with either one, just choose one.
- dathinab 4y agoBut you are also implying that all for profit companies are bad actors, which just isn't true.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoAt the end of the day engineers and programmers receive dollars for hours worked and can often be ambivalent about whether that is good or bad for customers because they no longer are valued by management as input to features and the future direction of the company.
- racl101 4y agoKeePass is really good for what it is for being free and only holding your data locally. The only thing it suffers from is that it looks too complicated for casual users. This is where 1Password or BitWarden really shine.
- 2Gkashmiri 4y agotrained myself and my siblings back in 2013-15. that time was VERY difficult for them because i kept pestering them to remember every account login, every piece of important information on it to a point it became a stupid chore. years later, its wonderful. they have EVERYTHING there and on their phones. they they dont need to keep the data synced at two places since they only use their phone so they keep a live copy on it and occasionally keep one with me just in case something happens to the phone. it is a bulletproof setup that works. recently someone mistyped a password and i was like "dont you have keepass" and i was told "obvio"... that was nice.
- dathinab 4y agothe main security improvement of a password manager is to make fishing harder by only making the auto fill work iff the domain matches the secondary improvement is by making it convenient to use and in turn discourage people from putting their passwords on sticky notes
- royjacobs 4y agoI agree KeePass is free, open source and lightweight but calling it easy to use is quite a stretch, especially if you want the same kind of functionality (e.g. autofill in browsers) that other tools provide out of the box.
- dusanh 4y agoIs there something that would allow a keepass db file to be shared through a REST API? At my current work, we have a lot of credentials to test environments shared on one single keepass file and I am wondering if I could securely use it as a network accessible (VPN only) vault and ideally something I could programmatically fetch those credentials for CI.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mdaniel 4y agoThis feels like an XY problem to me. I for sure wouldn't want anyone to reinvent a security API, and that goes doubly for doing so on top of a system that is inherently single-user. As the others have pointed out, Vaultwarden exists and is GPLv3. The bitwarden CLI should work with it and is also GPLv3
- presto8 4y agoKeePass looks nice. Currently I'm using pass but I will investigate KeyPass either as a recommendation for others or possible alternative to my current solution. I set up pass (on Linux and Mac, using brew) with two GPG keypairs, a soft keypair and a YubiKey. The YubiKey goes in a physical safe along with instructions for next of kin (and as an ultimate backup for me). YubiKey is protected with PIN. For daily use, use the soft GPG key and gpg-agent to cache it. PassFF on Firefox (or see github passforios for iOS) or command-line tools (easily can build hooks with dmenu/rofi as well). pass stores the gpg-encrypted passwords in a Git repository. Set up a private remote repository and push to it for offsite backup. There is some leakage of info as the names of the sites become the filename, e.g., ycombinator.gpg. This can be mitigated with some plugins like tomb, but then PassFF and passforios won't work.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoLook at KeepassXC and vaultwarden as well before you decide on a final app.
- aborsy 4y agoIt seems to me KeepassXC is currently one of the most secure options for password management. The attack surface of offline password managers such as KeepassXC is much smaller than that of the online password managers. You may sync it with your tool of choice, eg, Dropbox. The desktop application is excellent, reliable, and with state of the art protections (Yubikey, Argon2 KDF, memory protections, etc).
- haunter 4y agoWhat's a good, trustworthy KeepassXC iOS client w/ FaceID unlock?
- lycopodiopsida 4y agoThere are two: Strongbox[1] and KeePassium[2]. [1]: https://strongboxsafe.com/ https://strongboxsafe.com/ [2]: https://keepassium.com/ https://keepassium.com/
- haunter 4y agoThanks! Do you recommend any of them?
- lycopodiopsida 4y agoI do not, although I use Strongbox - liked the UI a tick better. They are pretty similar feature-wise, KeePassium is a tick cheaper for the pro-tier, and sources are available. Strongbox is able to merge the DB in case of conflict. And in reality both apps are written by a single guy, so I would say it is a draw :)
- ixs 4y agoI previously used MiniKeepass which has been shut down. My grated to KyPass, which looks good on paper but syncing with Google Drive didn’t work in practice. Now using KeePassium Pro. Very happy. Does everything I need, uses the file API for opening files and integrates well.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoI hate KeePass so much at work. But we still have to use it because our security leadership insist on it. It's not a bad tool for a home user with one PC but it's totally inadequate for an enterprise scenario. But they keep insisting it's safe because it's been audited and the encryption is strong. Sure but what's the point of encryption if you store the password in a text file in the same folder or in some cases in the actual filename :( I've compiled a huge list of issues to convince them. Like no audit logs. No password complexity enforcement. No single password sharing with third parties (you have to give them the entire thing and password or create a new one which they can open forever). No central overview. We have no idea how many passwords are stored, how well they are secured (the master password) and who they are shared with and when. Has anyone found a good argument to convince your leadership? And what did you move to?
- janef0421 4y agoThe kdbx format used by KeePass is an open standard, and can be used by a variety of password management applications. Perhaps another app using that format might be a better fit for you and your organisation?
- GekkePrutser 4y agoNo, our company doesn't allow any of the other apps because they have not been audited. Which also means we don't have a solution for Mac. But most of my concerns are centered around the fact that it's just files not centrally managed.
- janef0421 4y agoI don't think you're going to have much luck convincing your organisation to adopt a centralised service. Simply having files is as close to free as possible, while even a self-hosted centralised service will have a significant cost in terms of service time and administration. That's probably why they're so against change.
- benhurmarcel 4y ago
- ajdude 4y agoI love keepass, and use it with all of my systems. I have the database on my personal nextcloud instance (but you can use One Drive / Google Drive / DropBox) and encrypt it with not only a passphrase, but a keyfile. I can access the database from my phone, desktop, laptop, and other devices. Since you're also using a keyfile to encrypt it, it doesn't matter if another party gets the db file and even your passphrase, since only a device that also has the physical keyfile can decrypt it.
- mos_basik 4y agoI see nobody's mentioned TOTP support yet. My stack is KeePassXC on computers, Keepass2android on mobile and Dropbox for syncing. A few months ago I realized that both of my clients showed a TOTP option. Went digging a little and realized that there was enough support that I felt completely comfortable jumping ship away from Google Authenticator. Google Authenticator had been worryingly opaque to me until then - you scan a QR code and then somehow you get TOTP codes? - and having gone through a phone number change recently, I felt especially aware and uncomfortable about having 2FA for many important accounts tied to one fairly fragile, fairly mis-placeable electronic device (not to mention in an app controlled by Google). Figuring out how to use TOTP on KeePass was the nudge I needed to read up on how TOTP works, and of course it was quite simple. And keeping TOTP secrets in a password manager seems like a not-terrible idea (with the one caveat - and it's not a small one, I know - of busting the "second factor"ness of 2FA by making it possible to generate a TOTP code from the same device that you're using to log in with). I was especially impressed that KeePass knows about Steam's non-standard TOTP implementation and is able to generate Steam Authenticator codes. I will say that doing this requires some hairy steps! This was what put me on the right path: https://old.reddit.com/r/Bitwarden/comments/a67c1n/steam_authenticator_supported_not_sure_how_to/ https://old.reddit.com/r/Bitwarden/comments/a67c1n/steam_aut... And I put a good ~200 words of notes stored in that particular KeePass entry to remind me how I did it in the future.
- cam_l 4y agoNot only totp, but you can also get it to populate ssh-agent with a select set of keys only when kpxc is logged in. You can also have multiple files to handle different contexts, if you want some separation ie. 2FA-ness. (you might also try keepassdx on android if you want a bit more polish)
- witrak 4y ago>I see nobody's mentioned TOTP support yet. Thank you very much for your remark! I always am in trouble when I have to dig through terrible KeePass "documentation" and never found a remark about it.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoI just installed my vaultwarden as a stand alone bitwarden and imported my bitwarden data to it. It was actually pretty painless and runs in like 1/10 the space of the bitwarden (self hosted) server on a cloud instance. In the next couple days I think I'll test backup and such and if it works I'll be moving over to that from bitwarden. I have used keepass in the past but I prefer programs like lastpass and bitwarden with browser plugins.