24 ms·
Don’t teach kids to fear the world
- boomboomsubban 4y agoThis kind if title is rich coming from the fear mongering media. Particularly as the story right above this in the most popular stories section is "America’s Fall Booster Plan Has a Fatal Paradox"
- johndhi 4y ago
- oifjsidjf 4y agoThis. The best thing to teach your kid is to clearly show them how the media and politicians lie and manipulate by showing their contradtory talking vs behaviour vs what they actually do side-by-side meme style.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- beebeepka 4y agoAgreed. However, I don't have children and I wouldn't know where to begin with my niece. Thanks for reminding me I should spend more time with her. In my experience this also works for impressionable adults but you have to keep them close
- mrguyorama 4y agoFind your local librarian or english teacher, they were the ones responsible with teaching me how to judge an article or paper or book's credibility.
- rootusrootus 4y agoI hear this all the time. The joke is that both sides of the political divide think it's the other side that credulously believes everything the media peddles to them. It smells a lot like the usual 'both sides are bad' trope.
- asdff 4y agoWell, both sides are neoliberal.
- infamouscow 4y agoInstead of dismissing the point as unoriginal, why don't you address the substance of the argument and provide evidence refuting the claim both sides are bad?
- majormajor 4y agoWhat substance? > This kind if title is rich coming from the fear mongering media. Particularly as the story right above this in the most popular stories section is "America’s Fall Booster Plan Has a Fatal Paradox" and > The best thing to teach your kid is to clearly show them how the media and politicians lie and manipulate by showing their contradtory talking vs behaviour vs what they actually do side-by-side meme style. Don't have much substance at all. One has an anecdote of the form "the same website has another article with a hyperbolic title!" (This is a classic sort of "disagreement implies deceit" argument as is always brought up when scientists disagree on things, or consensus changes.) The other has a claim of "what [the media] says and does is different" in a way that suggests this is distinctive/meaningfully different in that way than in terms of any other human's behavior without any supporting substance, you're just supposed to accept it on faith that "the media" are intentionally manipulative hypocrites. Even if this is correct, it's not actually a substantial argument as presented, it will only possibly work on the already-converted.
- Bloating 4y agoboth sides, because theres only two sides to any issue
- 4y ago
- jjulius 4y agoI would also suggest that we teach our children to read articles and understand the nuances within them, rather than assuming a worldview based on headlines alone.
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoI agree overall, but I can't pretend that every article even has nuance to look out for. Where was the nuance when almost the entire media was towing the line to cover up the Hunter Biden laptop leak articles as "Russian Disinformation"? It was a complete lie. That's not just one article, it was dozens with no nuance to be found.
- wpietri 4y agoFYI, lines get toed, not towed. Calling it a coverup is quite an accusation; do you have any evidence for that? I also remember it differently, with that being one theory expressed at the time, and it is certainly in line with what Russia has gotten up to in the past. I wondered how it turned out. From Wikipedia, on what independent analysts hired by the Washington Post found: "One of the analysts characterized the data as a 'disaster' from a forensics standpoint. The analysts found that people other than Biden had repeatedly accessed and copied data for nearly three years; they also found evidence others had written files to the drive both before and after the October 2020 New York Post reports. In September 2020, someone created six new folders on the drive, including with the names 'Biden Burisma,' 'Salacious Pics Package' and Hunter. Burisma Documents.'"
- fallingknife 4y agoIt was known from the very beginning that the laptop was legit because the Bidens never denied it. There are reasons to deny something that is real, but no reason not to deny something that is fake.
- wpietri 4y agoThat's definitely too black and white. Does it contain real data from him? Yes. Might it have been hardware he once owned? Also possible, but not proven. Was the data all his? As the text I quoted said, definitely not. Do a lot of people have an interest in making the Bidens look bad without regard to the truth? Definitely. But none of that addresses my actual question, which is asking for evidence that it's a coverup.
- jjulius 4y agoDid you read either piece to gain additional context and confirm whether or not your assumptions about them are correct, or are you commenting strictly on titles alone?
- boomboomsubban 4y agoI did read this article, but my post specifically calls out the titles.
- jjulius 4y agoTitles, inherently by their nature, are supposed to grab your attention and entice you to read. They're not there to have an answer or tell you what you need to know - their only job is to go, "Look!". I think we should all be less reactionary towards a headline and more insistent upon discussing the actual body of content.
- boomboomsubban 4y agoMany people will only ever read the title of a story, they need to entice the reader because nobody has time to read every article. They are a separate body of content, and it's fair to criticize them for being excessive fear mongering.
- zwieback 4y agoWouldn't lump The Atlantic in with general "fear mongering media", which is certainly a problem
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoYou sure? Or does The Atlantic just fit your biases?
- zwieback 4y agoSure it does, wasn't commenting on slant, just level of sensationalism
- sushisource 4y agoI find this richly ironic. One of the points of the article is that not everything is black and white, and we need to take a big picture view of things. This sentiment is... exactly the opposite. It is completely possible for there to be problems in the media, and for there also to be content it produces that is good and makes sense. Could the media be better? Sure. Does your almost comically negative comment really serve to help anyone? No.
- rhacker 4y agoWell it helped me quite a bit, I didn't have to type it myself!
- P5fRxh5kUvp2th 4y ago
- jjulius 4y agoExcept that it does. Life is nuanced. OP is trying to make a point based on a couple of headlines, but the actual content of the articles explain things a bit more clearly and nuanced, and are a lot less "THE SKY IS FALLING!", than OP seems to be insinuating they are based on their titles alone.
- P5fRxh5kUvp2th 4y agoThis is nihilism at its finest. There are things that are knowable in this world, a website that claims A but does the opposite is one of those things. Trust means said website putting their money where their mouth is. The only defense here is that it's an opinion piece and doesn't represent the website as a whole, but the solution is to possibly trust the author but not the website. Since we're talking about nuance here, a counterexample doesn't invalidate the point being made, especially about media in general.
- majormajor 4y agoYou're performing a trick here in here of hiding the individual differences between two separate authors by referring to "a website" as a monolith. (And then you semi-walk-it-back, but treat that as somehow... a strange thing to do?) That's the sort of rhetorical subterfuge that helps promote a black-and-white us-and-them narrative. I generally don't even agree with Brooks on a lot of things, so I'd go even further and suggest that in many cases one should evaluate separate texts independently (this can lead to some problems at the extreme ends, but again, it's not a black and white rule). It's hard to see anything helpful coming from your sort of blanket dismissal response.
- alexashka 4y agoPar for the course. Sell sugar water, sell bottled water, sell cigarettes, sell quit cigarettes products. The cycle is meant to continue forever, increasing in velocity, until all the paperclips are belong to us :)
- sophacles 4y agoI get that you want to come across a wise and cynical. So why are you pretending "the media" is a single unified hive mind - that doesn't make any sense, and comes across as hyperbolic populism instead.
- asdff 4y agoIt's not a single unified hive mind, just the incentives are aligned to make the most of fear mongering and make the least of educating the populace on the real meat of the issues at hand.
- chousuke 4y agoYou're engaging in the same sort of "fearmongering" though, by lumping everything together as if they all have the same incentives and goals. Depending on which part of "the media" you look at, you'll get very different takes on various issues, some with significantly more substance behind them than others.
- TimTheTinker 4y agoUsing generalizations when characterizing a group or entity can be helpful, even if the generalization is just that (true in most cases, but not every case). In this case, I think we do all agree that "the media" very often overhypes fear -- because they have a financial incentive to do so.
- Bloating 4y agoGreedy corporations bad, except the news media ;)
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoThe Atlantic has a yearly revenue of $75m.
- dqpb 4y ago> coming from the fear mongering media I checked, and it looks like it’s coming from “Arthur C. Brooks”, a 58 year old Harvard professor from Spokane, Washington, who has a spouse and three kids. He’s a real person, with a real life.
- hulitu 4y agoThat alone does not give him any credibility.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoCheck his article history. He's been pumping out one saccharine article a week about how to be happy, how to cope with not being happy, which pet will make you happy, etc. I don't see any fear mongering though. I don't know about credibility, but he's not a fear monger.
- gipp 4y agoI think you missed his point. "The media" didn't write this article, a person did. Other people with the same job, who he doesn't know or control, wrote different opinions, so he's not allowed to have/express his without being called a hypocrite?
- boomboomsubban 4y agoThe author very likely did not come up with the title, that's often the job of an editor.
- UIUC_06 4y agoI worked at the Daily Illini for part of a semester, and my job was to write headlines. The main concern then was "does it fit in the column head?" I guess now the length constraints are less, unless there's also a print edition. But in any case, it's still probably the job of someone other than the writer.
- newaccount2021 4y ago[dead]
- Retric 4y agoThe actual article about COVID vaccination is nuanced and without scaremongering. The complaint isn’t about the vaccine, but the “deadly paradox” where vaccines become more effective the more people who take them. Further suggesting the policy to only hand it out to the fully vaccinated is a mistake.
- zwieback 4y agoDefinitely a problem. We were outliers letting our kids roam the neighborhood at age 8 or so. I wonder if some of it is because we haven't had wars, famines, etc. in the US recently so not a good reference point for what's truly life threatening.
- yboris 4y agoA great companion article from Vox: How to raise kids who give back to the world Optimism, not despair, is the way to inspire kids to help the future. https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2022/8/25/23318194/children-parenting-charity-philanthropy-climate-change https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2022/8/25/23318194/childr...
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoI chuckled for several different reasons, but it is clearly an opinion piece so some some artistic license is allowed. <<Teaching your kids that the world is dangerous can also make them less tolerant of others. Should kids be taught that the world is not dangerous to make kids less likely to be tolerant ( I attempted to retain the qualifiers )? Edit: I decided to remove the rest of the comment. The argument I presented for dangerous/safe world seemed off after I re-read it.
- Lacerda69 4y ago>Should kids be taught that the world is not dangerous to make kids less likely to be tolerant? If my kids fear that anyone who is not in their group is out to harm them,then they will become less tolerant of anyone not in their group. Dunno why you put it on the head like that?
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoBecause the question is a really simple one. Is intolerance automatically a bad thing? There is a reason stereotypes exist ( statistically, they tend to pan out ). They do not operate in a vacuum. They are effectively a useful heuristic that just happens to sometimes misfire. The issues tend to start when that heuristic is institutionalized, but as a day to day operator it tends to work. Second part is more personal, would I be willing to sacrifice my kids safety in the name of tolerance? I know how I answer that question. I am all but certain most people answer it the same way. To put it simply, as values come: kids > tolerance.
- JKCalhoun 4y ago> Is intolerance automatically a bad thing? Teaching intolerance to children? Yeah, that's a bad thing.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoIntolerance.. of what? Intolerance of their brother playing with matches under his bed? Intolerance of being bullied? Intolerance itself is amoral. Intolerance of bad things is good. Intolerance of good things is bad. Part of raising a kid is teaching them which things should be tolerated and which things not to tolerate. Absolute tolerance isn't virtuous, it makes you a wet noodle with no spine.
- nkingsy 4y agoWhy do people insist on endlessly proving that "healthy, happy people do things healthy, happy people do" and the inverse? I agree with the idea in general I guess, but there's nothing here to convince a parent. Just my data point, my kids are freaking crazy and are slowly becoming less suicidal as they hit elementary school. We try to educate them about things that are legitimately unsafe, but they would need to fear consequences to actually do what they're told, and we don't really want them acting out of fear. Who knows what the real numbers are, but I wouldn't try to claim my kids are safer.
- thenerdhead 4y agoI like Arthur Brooks. He seems to be a voice of reason in this crazy world. Having just read his recent book and both the books he mentions in the article, I actually started to understand what is being said here. On the first page of the Tao Te Ching (Stephen Mitchell translation), it talks about the true source of understanding is darkness. > Free from desire, you realize the mystery. > Caught in desire, you see only the manifestations. > Yet mystery and manifestations > arise from the same source. > This source is called darkness. > Darkness within darkness. > The gateway to all understanding. We can't teach kids nor ourselves to fear the world. We have to step into the darkness to gain clarity of who we are and what we are here to do. That's the only way to learn. This somewhat adds onto Scott Barry Kaufman's new ideas of self-actualization. Kaufman uses a sailboat as a metaphor in which the hull is security and the sail is growth. https://scottbarrykaufman.com/sailboat-metaphor/ https://scottbarrykaufman.com/sailboat-metaphor/ Which reminds me of the famous quote: > A ship in harbor is safe, but that is not what ships are built for. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/67896.Tao_Te_Ching https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/67896.Tao_Te_Ching https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/49625550-transcend https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/49625550-transcend
- hotpotamus 4y agoArthur Brooks strikes me as a genuinely nice and interesting person. But I wonder, how much did he get paid to run a billionaire funded thinktank (and that tank of thoughts seemed mostly full of "give tax cuts to billionaires")? I assume it paid pretty well. I also assume it's pretty easy to be nice and easygoing and thoughtful when you don't have to worry about where your kids next meal or health insurance payment is coming from.
- amatecha 4y agoI think knowing the darkness helps you know the "light" too. when I was a teenager I sought out the unfiltered truth of what humans were capable of, so I could properly understand what humanity "is". I found a lot of disturbing stuff (because I sought it out) and it helped me grow as a person and know how to interface with the world and get a better sense of what the full spectrum is. It didn't cause me to be fearful or anything, just aware. Anyway, maybe not 100% on-topic but what you said reminded me of that.
- lapcat 4y agoI suspect that hit TV shows like "America's Most Wanted" did a great deal of damage to the American psyche. The 1990s seemed to be when parental attitudes started to take a turn. When I grew up before then, kids were generally allowed to roam wherever they wanted unsupervised, as long as they were home in time for dinner. There are probably other factors too. I wonder if there was a kind of overcompensation from "latchkey kids" when they became parents.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoPretty much all of cable news... After cutting the cord when our first daughter was born, we were often surprised to come down from a hotel room to get breakfast in the lobby to find that some horrific things were happening, cities were burning, people being murdered, a world spinning out of control. Oh yeah, I had to remind myself, cable news was like that. So we grabbed coffee to go and headed out to the National Park to hike with the kids.
- pradn 4y agoSimilarly, it's terrible that the default thing on TV at airports and gyms is cable news. It's especially absurd at the gym - going to be healthy and feel some nice endorphins, and then you're subjected to the worst things happening in the world. Comical, really.
- mrguyorama 4y agoCable news being the choice entertainment of airports is especially funny when all the TVs are showing the plane with stuck landing gear trying to come down just outside the window. A plane with stuck gear is a minor issue that happens periodically and has very little chance of causing problems, but from the news coverage you'd think it was an unthinkable disaster.
- chrisallenlane 4y agoThis is the main reason I cancelled my gym membership. I got tired of going to the gym to clear my head, only to leave angrier than when I got there. I don't know why more gyms don't show sports on the TVs. It seems like a much more natural fit.
- ryukafalz 4y agoI broadly agree with this, but it’s going to be hard if by the time I have kids pedestrian fatalities are still on the rise. The article mentions some statistics that are dropping, but the ones I worry about more are the ones that actually are still increasing, like the chance of my kid getting hit by a car while they’re walking around the neighborhood.
- acuozzo 4y ago> but the ones I worry about more are the ones that actually are still increasing, like the chance of my kid getting hit by a car while they’re walking around the neighborhood Yes! This is my issue as well. Drivers on residential streets have gotten so much worse since I was a kid in the '80/90s.
- narush 4y agoStreets themselves have also gotten much worse! The vast difference in car deaths in the US and other countries is more a question of our infrastructure and what it encourages than anything else. I read a really great book about this recently -- no vested interest beyond just really liking it. Check it here [1] [1] https://www.strongtowns.org/book https://www.strongtowns.org/book
- lotsofpulp 4y agoOnce a road becomes 4+ lanes wide (32ft+), and has a speed limit of 40mph (which means people drive at 50mph), it is basically a boundary that children cannot cross. And in suburbs across the US, it is very normal to have numerous arterial roads (40mph speed limit) cut through suburbs that are 4, 6, 7, and even 8 lanes wide. How even a healthy, mobile adult is expected to cross these 60ft+ wide intersections without being scared, I do not know. There will be 3 lanes going straight through, and a right turn lane and a left turn lane. And half the people will be in SUV/pickup trucks sitting so high they will not see you in front of them, and their giant A pillar will prevent them from seeing you on the side of them.
- daltont 4y ago
- logicalmonster 4y agoI think a lot of healthy life choices stem from proper risk management and cost-benefit analysis, which humans can do on their own fairly well for normal life tasks. For instance, there's a non-zero chance you could lose your life every time you get into a car. However, almost everybody still hops into cars because the chance of a life-altering accident (if the driver not drinking and/or driving like a maniac) is relatively low and the benefits to cars in your life are high. Where I think this ability for normal people to make sensible choices gets warped is when the media's business model of driving emotional and catchy stories interferes with peoples' actual perceptions of risk. For example, there are healthy young people still utterly scared to death of Covid because their preferred media tells them to be afraid. You can apply this to almost any hot button issue that the media has adopted and find people who have had their sense of the actual risk warped.
- cyberbanjo 4y agoGetting into a car isn't the dangerous part where I live, it's being near the road. It's safer to be in a car, near the road, than on foot or on bicycle.
- munk-a 4y agoBoth actions are dangerous - and it's the presence of cars that makes it dangerous. In the US 42,915 lives were lost in automobile crashes[1] in 2021. 1. https://www.nhtsa.gov/press-releases/early-estimate-2021-traffic-fatalities https://www.nhtsa.gov/press-releases/early-estimate-2021-tra...
- logicalmonster 4y agoYou and the poster you're responding to seem to be using a different definition of the word dangerous: the one above seems to be using more of the connotation of the word (point out that there's an acceptable level of risk involved with cars) and you're using the denotation (pointing out that people do die in cars). To be clear, virtually every human activity is technically dangerous and there's a non-zero risk in almost any human activity. By the dictionary definition, owning a pool is technically dangerous because people drown and get hurt all of the time. Hell, a bucket causes a non-zero number of drowning deaths. People can die from blender accidents or shitting too hard or swallowing quarters or tripping to death on a power cord. Everything is technically dangerous.
- insane_dreamer 4y agoWe've found to be great help in this regard with our kids: no TV news, or even cable TV at all, in the house.
- Bloating 4y agoabsolutely reduces anxiety
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- teddyh 4y ago“Look for the helpers.” — Fred Rogers
- encryptluks2 4y agoBetter title... "teach your kids to be gullible consumers so that we can stay rich." Essentially, this is a new playbook by the wealthy of owning nothing, slaving away and being happy doing it.
- Bloating 4y ago[flagged]
- rcpt 4y agoCtrl+f "cars", no hits. Not reading all that.
- jpitz 4y agoDon't teach fear. How about that?
- photochemsyn 4y agoThis article seems to cherry-pick statistics in favor of its thesis. For example, here's a counter-statisic: > "In 2020, there were 618,399 victims of child abuse in the United States. This is a decrease from the previous year, when there were 656,251 victims of child abuse, and is the lowest number of victims since 2012." (Statista) Now there are an estimated 70,000,000 children (age 0-17) in the USA, but it's likely that child abuse is significantly underreported. So, do you tell kids that child abuse is insignificant, that there aren't dangerous people (actual child abusers) and that they don't need to even think about it? What should they do then, if they learn that one of their friends is a victim of child abuse? The whole article seems a bit Pollyanish. Kids can handle learning about things like wars, resource exhaustion, economic instability, etc. They can also learn that cars are dangerous and that they shouldn't run into the street without looking, all without going into a state of debilitating fearfulness. It's just a matter of balance - for example, it's a good idea to tell kids that media outlets tend to cover the worst stories, not the best, so blind faith in media - i.e. the belief that reading the newspaper or watching a news show means you have a broad picture of the world - is unwise.
- is_true 4y agoAre you sure that the 2020 number is not related with kids spending more time isolated?
- lapcat 4y agoWell, aren't the child abusers most likely to be a parent or relative rather than a stranger? You can't really give parents advice on what to teach kids if the parents themselves are the problem.
- spacechild1 4y agoMost child abuse happens within the family or situations with adult supervision, such as sport clubs, church, etc.
- viburnum 4y agoAmerica has way more deaths from guns, drugs, and cars than other rich countries. Probably should do something about that rather than lecturing parents.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- t6jvcereio 4y agoI never understood this "you don't have to be afraid" attitude. Children DO get kidnapped. Like, in really life. It's not just on TV. You can argue "but the probably is so small". Yeah sure, but I want to make sure it doesn't happen to MY children.
- DiggyJohnson 4y agoI'm sorry to put this so bluntly, but if you are trying to get this down to "truly 0 risk of kidnapping", there is a very high chance that you are depriving your kid of developmental opportunities in the pursuit of unrealistic risk analysis.
- t6jvcereio 4y agoMy kids are amazing at risk analysis. They know exactly all the probablities, better than you with 90% probability.
- Bloating 4y ago'cause they're not allowed to do anything but math
- t6jvcereio 4y ago
- DiggyJohnson 4y agoPlease read the guidelines of this site - I’m practically begging you.
- t6jvcereio 4y agoWhich guideline does what I wrote violates?
- 4y ago
- Waterluvian 4y agoI'm struggling with this a lot right now. When we became parents my wife and I agreed that we wanted to let our kids explore the world with a similar level of freedom we had as a kids. When my 3yo was about 2, he pushed through a defective locked gate and fell down a flight of stairs, losing a tooth. Then about three weeks ago he got distracted in the bathroom and fell off a stool with a toothbrush in his mouth. I'll spare you the details. These accidents weren't directly caused by our goal of giving our kids more independence, but they had the effect of making that goal all but impossible, at least for now. I catch myself telling him he can't do things he could before, or saying "<childname> slow down!" about 100 times per day. Seeing him on a playground gives me terrible anxiety. He's fine. He's not afraid of anything. He's so bloody resilient despite all his trauma. But I'm failing him because the risks feel so real and paralyzing. To love what death can touch... One difference, I think, is that I am lucky enough to not be affected by the historical taboo of mental health. I'm seeking therapy for this, which I'm also not afraid to admit out loud. And I'm hopeful that it will help me face this.
- Ancalagon 4y agoAt least it was a baby tooth :) 3 is a little young to have much independence anyways, I would think closer to 1st grade is when kids can start having bit more
- nico 4y ago> 3 is a little young to have much independence This is very much a cultural and setting thing. In Japan there’s a tradition of having kids, at around 3 years old, go out by themselves to run errands. There’s a whole tv show about it. If you are curious about other cultures as well, there’s a pretty good documentary on Apple tv about the first 5 years of life of kids from all around the world, including kids in rural areas, big cities and even small remote tribes. Regarding the setting, there are some places (like some resorts or big estates), where young kids can be very safe and that allows them to be on their own a lot and build their independence.
- spywaregorilla 4y ago
- Claude_Shannon 4y agoMy parents never let me outside. All my youth was spend sitting in the front of the screen as I couldn't even go for a walk because they were afraid. I feel it messed me up a lot.
- duxup 4y agoWe're teaching adults to fear the world. They're going to do the same for the kids... I think we need to start with everyone.
- randcraw 4y agoThe problem of mishandling fear affects not only kids. Most adults seem to be very bad at understanding risk vs reward and responding appropriately. (To wit, how should we compare different kinds of risk/reward, like a very severe risk that's very rare (violent home invasion) as compared to a very minor risk that's an everyday booboo (misplacing your car keys). If we can't recognize where true risk lies and its true cost, and choose a sensible plan of reaction, we will misperceive and overreact to all threats.) There's no better illustration of this than the widespread confusion about vaccines, not just among "the hesitant". Responding to lopsided risk vs reward ratios, like safe vaccines for dire diseases, should be a slam dunk (polio, smallpox, typhoid). And if you're in a vulnerable subclass (old, immuno-compromised, etc) the same clarity should hold for more modest diseases because they can be mortal for you. SUCH TRADEOFFS SHOULD BE OBVIOUS. It's only the low-reward moderate-risk choices that deserve closer scrutiny (like flu vaccination for kids). Somehow we all need to learn the two essentials: 1) the basics of probability and how to properly balance risk vs reward, and 2) what are the necessary/sufficient facts -- what do we really know, and how confident should we be in using that knowledge? This really should be taught in every pubic school math class. For 90% of the population, it's much more valuable a skill than typical math courses like geometry, trig, and calculus. Properly understanding risk is also central to basic reasoning skills. Unlike what's taught in academia, the truths of the world are rarely binary/propositional. When thinking rationally, one needs to be clear in choosing the relevant value proposition (the measure of success/failure) and whether the proposed course of action will achieve it (likelihood of a plan's success/failure). That's a continuous probability, not a binary choice, and we need to develop intuition for how to weigh outcomes against our plans for achieving them. Minimizing risk should be an engineered response, where we can explain why we believe as we do. The sooner we can all be clear headed about what we know, what we want, and the real risk of success/failure, the better we will be at dealing with all probable worlds.
- Bloating 4y agoeasy... stop watching the news
- hilbert42 4y ago"...children should be at least 10 years old to play unsupervised in their own front yard, 12 years old to stay home alone for an hour, and 14 to be unsupervised at a public park." By the time I was 10 I was allowed to be unsupervised and to get on a bus to a railway station, purchase a ticket for an intercity train that took me the better part of 100 miles away to another city then alight there at a major railway junction with many platforms and from there catch a suburban train to my final destination where my grandmother lived. However, before I could get to see her I had to walk several miles to her home and this involved crossing a very busy four-lane arterial highway. I was no exception, as this was the norm for kids of my age. Moreover, such things were never a big deal for us kids, it was just the way things were back then. We gave such concerns little thought if any at all. This - unlike millions of today's kids - is why my generation were and still are a much more resilient lot and not afraid of the world than is the present younger generation. In my estimation, overprotecting kids rates on a much higher scale of child abuse than some[1] matters which are normally associated with it. If you are a modern-day parent and overprotecting your children then you need to think twice about the damage and harm that you are causing them. It is very difficult to acquire resilience if it's not acquired very early on in one's life, and those who don't are often forever handicapped. _ [1] Of course, that excludes any form of sexual abuse, it's inexcusable and unacceptable under any circumstance.
- moret1979 4y agoRelated to this, deeply focused on the American experience: The Coddling of the American Mind > (...) ideas that have become increasingly woven into American childhood and education: What doesn’t kill you makes you weaker; always trust your feelings; and life is a battle between good people and evil people. These three Great Untruths contradict basic psychological principles about well-being and ancient wisdom from many cultures. Embracing these untruths—and the resulting culture of safetyism—interferes with young people’s social, emotional, and intellectual development. It makes it harder for them to become autonomous adults who are able to navigate the bumpy road of life. > Lukianoff and Haidt investigate the many social trends that have intersected to promote the spread of these untruths. They explore changes in childhood such as the rise of fearful parenting, the decline of unsupervised, child-directed play, and the new world of social media that has engulfed teenagers in the last decade. (...) https://www.amazon.com/Coddling-American-Mind-Intentions-Generation/dp/0735224897 https://www.amazon.com/Coddling-American-Mind-Intentions-Gen...
- slothtrop 4y agoOperating in the world means accepting a threshold of risk, sure. You can account for some as best you can without necessarily being overly restrictive, it's just hard to have an intuition of the odds when all you can address are black-and-white scenarios like "could someone be kidnapped right now, and how easily?". The mere cognizance is enough to make people fearful, so it requires some perspective to stay even. I'd have more fear for kids in teenage and young adult years, as either foolishness or being too trusting can lead to ostracization or even jail time.
- whiskeytuesday 4y ago
- earthboundkid 4y agoWTF is that Dao De Jing quote? Laozi did not care about love at all, whether romantic or Christian. I reskimmed https://ctext.org/dao-de-jing https://ctext.org/dao-de-jing to see if maybe I just forgot some passage, but nothing popped up. Anyone have any idea where Brooks is getting this quote from?
- 13192216873 4y agoIt looks like a loose translation of chapter 67 in the Wang Bi version that you linked. The character interpreted as love is 慈, with the quote mentioned in the article corresponding to 慈故能勇 in the original passage.
- earthboundkid 4y agoTurning 能勇 "can be brave" into "have no fear" is translator's license, but turning 慈 into "love" butchers the whole thing. :-)
- 13192216873 4y agoAgreed, and in other passages Laozi does repeatedly use 愛, which corresponds more closely to our general idea of "love" than 慈 does. So one would have to wonder how this translator would distinguish 愛 from 慈, if they insist on translating the latter as "love".
- earthboundkid 4y agoThere are a lot of things that you can chalk up to translator's license, but if the message of Laozi is to be interesting and useful, it has to be different than the Western mainstream message. Why bother reading a difficult text if it just says what non-difficult texts also say! Western thought is into "love" because of Christianity, and the meaning of "love" has different aspects at different times in Western history, like romantic love, chivalrous love, love of parents for children (in TFA), etc. Laozi absolutely does not think you should have feelings of affection towards others. He is against having strong attachments generally, and thinks we should evaluate things seen as negative more positively. So the whole thrust of the passage (you can win battles by being gentle and weak) is lost if you erase everything about Laozi and make him into a quasi-Christian nice parent. Ugh! I'm not necessarily against syncretism or reading e.g. Buddhist 慈悲 compassion as a form of love to make a Christian-Buddhist hybrid thought, but in the specific case of Laozi, I cannot believe that any of what Laozi is saying has gotten through to someone who thinks you can use "love" in this passage.
- mikotodomo 4y agoWe absolutely should fear the world. I know a friend who got COVID just because he took his mask off and someone came down the side walk and passed him. Pedos are stalking their prey with apps now. Kids are being abused by apps which they all have easy access to! There is no more important time than ever than now for parents to properly teach their kids how to be safe.
- tlear 4y agoThis is hilarious. While we lived in Japan my 7 year old was walking to school alone meeting up with friends on the way. 25mins one way. In Canada same 7 year old is not allowed to walk home 8 mins away. With friends, over 1 intersection that has a crossing guard. Wtf Half the people in the class would get in trouble with the family services(fucking joke) because we allow kids to play in park unsupervised. It is not just people’s perception it is also idiotic bureaucrats and politicians creating more regulations to grow the beast
- clintonb 4y ago99% Invisible just did an episode about this. https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/first-errand/ https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/first-errand/
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoI'm from foreign yugoslavia, then slovenia, and we did just the same as you guys did... if you had to take the bus, your parents would go with you the first few days, so you'd remember where to get off the bus, and after that, you'd be on your own. Also, it was not unusual for kids to get home at 12, and parents at 17h (5pm for americans), and we just either watched tv at home, or went out with other kids.
- vikingerik 4y agoCurious: what actually disallows the Canadian 7 year old? Is it the parents, or the school, or a government restriction, or something else?
- tlear 4y agoSchool that has to obey idiotic laws. After couple grades depending on school and teacher will look the other way but grade 1-2 no. I like teachers in our school I think most know how stupid this is, but do they want to lose their job and career over it..? Of course there are also idiotic parents but they are minority. Like the ones that don’t allow their kids to use matches when they are 9.. or use sharp knife at same age poor kid had his eye pop out when he saw my younger daughter(6) cut a steak with a knife. Blows my mind.
- samstave 4y agoIf you'd like to understand how the Capitalist economy is setup around fear, this is a REALLY REALLY good watch on Lex Fridman. https://youtu.be/eF-E40pxxbI?t=4445 https://youtu.be/eF-E40pxxbI?t=4445 - Meditations on Moloch is a great write up. And if you know what the elites do at Bohemian Grove (worship an effigy of Molech) it will help you see the truth behind the bullshit system of evil we actual live under. And if youre new to this ancient concept - then please dont give me "conspiracy theory" bullshit, it will only show that you need to read up on this. Seriously, this is a fantastic summary of Molech and how it represents capitalism.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jmartrican 4y agoI think America's Most Wanted might have lead to parent's not being comfortable letting their kids to roam freely.
- swayvil 4y agoI wandered the wilds of South Dakota regularly when I was 8-11. It was pure magic. Still have all my fingers.
- jwally 4y agoBTW, another book I can't recommend enough in the same vein: https://www.amazon.com/How-Raise-Adult-Overparenting-Prepare/dp/1250093635 https://www.amazon.com/How-Raise-Adult-Overparenting-Prepare... I forget if it was this book or somewhere else I heard it, but they had a pretty pithy comment that's stuck with me since - something along the lines of "The objective of parenting isn't to raise good kids, your job as a parent is to raise good adults".
- chasd00 4y agolike others have said, my biggest fear as a parent is traffic. There's a fairly busy street at both ends of my neighborhood. We walk and cross those streets enough that i'm confident in their abilities but i have zero confidence in drivers. There's street racers and drunks constantly, a guy mowing his own yard was killed by street racers crashing into each other and then spilling over into his yard and crushing him. I routinely see people running the red lights at rush hour and the whole intersection reeks of weed between 4 and 6 PM. The list goes on. It's the traffic that scares me as a parent. /my kids are 12 and 10
- _c3ag 4y agothere this is song, from Unknown Mortal Orchestra, called Hunnybee; which the composer wrote for his daughter... btw, i wished my parents were a bit harsh when i was at my early 20s working as a bicycle courier to get money for a bicycle touring trip around South America... maybe if they told me i could got involved in an accident and get f#$%&! or dead i would have this insight 3 years sooner than by my own
- dustractor 4y agoSome people, it seems like their first instinct when faced with 'Nature', is to spray it with poison.
- perardi 4y agoI was an 80’s kid. Lots of childhood warnings about drugs or razor blades in Halloween candy. There were never any drugs in our Halloween candy. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poisoned_candy_myths https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poisoned_candy_myths
- npteljes 4y agoGood old moral panic. Wikipedia has a really nice article about them. Specifically talking about another one that's mentioned in this thread, the (perceived) increase in crime. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_panic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_panic
- neonate 4y agohttps://archive.ph/7kN9L https://archive.ph/7kN9L
- hexator 4y agoAs long as most of America remains car dependent and pedestrian-hostile, parents will be afraid of letting their kids out of the house. Unfortunately, that's rarely acknowledged as the problem (even in this article)
- esja 4y agoMeanwhile in Switzerland, 4 year olds walk to Kindergarten and back home again, twice a day, on their own. They meet friends along the way, play games, take detours, catch lizards, but also learn how to manage their time. It’s very good for them.
- pkulak 4y agoPart of the evidence this article uses is that child deaths have dropped... since we started bubble wrapping our kids. Unfortunately, I do believe that if we all kicked our kids out of the house and had them roam the neighborhoods, they'd get slaughtered. I remember playing all over my childhood neighborhood, all day, every day. I walked to elementary school. However, I also just don't remember that many cars around. I remember playing hockey in the street, and when a car showed up, it did so at a crawl, then patiently waited for us to move the goals over. Now I go back to that same neighborhood and cars are driving 40+ mph on the same road I played on. My kids bike to school today, but only on a carefully curated route in the most bike-friendly city in the country, and it still scares me a bit, honestly. If I move to Houston, they are getting loaded into the back of an SUV twice daily.
- LorenPechtel 4y agoMy parents simply taught me to be careful of cars. You look before you enter any place a car could go.
- pkulak 4y agoGreat. Like 80% of public land in cities is roads. https://i.redd.it/zbpxfwp615k81.jpg https://i.redd.it/zbpxfwp615k81.jpg
- LorenPechtel 4y agoYou have to cross roads. You do so with care. I hike--and that means at times I end up walking along roads with no sidewalk and where most drivers are not expecting pedestrians. I take the working assumption that drivers will not see me, safety only comes from getting away from the road when there's a car about.
- notch656a 4y agoI very much enjoyed the illustration, and found it to be pretty accurate. If I were to draw another illustration of eliminating vehicles without taking the appropriate long transition to moving to a new supply chain for this urban environment, it would show the valley below the cliff filled in, but with a great deal of the town dead from starvation and the stores and building dilapidated from lack of supplies.
- fleddr 4y agoI was 6 y/o (in the 80s) when I got my first bicycle, after which I got to explore my part of the world as I see fit, unsupervised. Just be back in time for diner. My parents had no idea where I was, whom I was with and what I was doing. I learned how to use my body and its limits. I learned to make friends as well as enemies. We played creatively with whatever environment we encountered in ways positive and negative (setting small things on fire and such). Play. Experiment. Screw up. Learn. All of this in an environment far less safe than today, in a pretty dysfunctional neighborhood. One day I came home crying, as a much larger kid hit me in the face. I found little emotional support as my dad said to just hit him back. As I explained that the kid was much older and larger..."well, get a piece of wood then". Crude. Today's parents may even find it neglectful or abusive. But it wasn't. It's one of several experiences that have shaped me for the better. As I did get that piece of wood and walked towards my attacker, he could see me coming. I was scared as hell, this wood would do very little in the hands of a significantly weaker kid. Yet he made a run for it, and as word got around, nobody ever messed with me again. Because I was strong? No. Because I came back. I solved a seemingly impossible problem all by myself. It's made me a problem solver for life. I learned that negative experiences are inevitably part of life, and thus ordinary. This affords me to take a hit (physically, financially, otherwise) without getting into a state of existential panic. Nor would I waste much time complaining about it. I just calmly accept it and solve it. Another example were the few years where we were really poor. The family was under regular threat of repossession. Sometimes my dad told me to hide my toys. Half of those toys were fake. My dad's attempts to mimic A-brand toys by replicating them with cardboard and tape. Traumatic? No. I simply learned to detach myself from objects. As they're just that: objects. I still got fed, had clothes, and with an outdoor play lifestyle, I needed little else to be happy. I carry this with me to this day: I appreciate luxuries, but don't depend on them emotionally. The point of all this is that this unshielded, unmanaged childhood is life itself. By experiencing its highs and lows, you develop skills and character, useful for your entire life. Plus it's just a whole lot more fun compared to a golden prison. "A ship is most safe in the harbor, but that's not what ships are for". Oh, also...stop grinding kids by overloading them with tasks and rules. Fuck "responsibility". They're kids. They can grind for 50 years once they're adults, now is the time for irresponsibility :)
- lvl102 4y agoI generally agree with this but I have a counter argument. I grew up in the 80/90s generally unsupervised. I played outside from sunrise to sunset. Complete freedom. As a parent now, I reflect back on those days and think about the times I came really close getting badly hurt or doing something completely stupid. My conclusion is that in parenting, it’s either you supervise or you don’t. You can choose to loosen certain boundaries WHILE you’re supervising but don’t ever think allowing your kids to go completely unsupervised is good for them in any shape or form.
- spacechild1 4y ago> As a parent now, I reflect back on those days and think about the times I came really close getting badly hurt or doing something completely stupid. I am in the same situation, but I would not come to same conclusion. Although we were in very dangerous situations as kids, surprisingly little happened. None of my friends have died or been badly injured. I think you have to look at the risks and make a realistic assessment. I am horrified to imagine my own daughter in some of the situations I was facing, but still I do not want to supervise her all the time when she gets older. Actually, I have a slightly different problem: I grew up in a very small village on the country side in Austria, but now I am living in a big city (Vienna). The country side comes with its own kind of risks (free-running dogs, dangerous country roads, forests, mountains, lakes), but they are completely different than the ones you would face in a city. Since I have no experience what it's like to grow up in a city, I'm not sure how I should raise my daughter. I guess I just have to look at what my friends are doing with their kids :-)
- spoonjim 4y agoEasy to say but harder to do. A death of one's child is essentially an infinitely negative utility event, so any probability of it has an expected value of negative infinity.
- tonymet 4y agoKids learn through example. The best way to teach kids not to fear the world is to not fear the world yourself. The trouble is fear is increasing each year. We have more and more restrictions, security checks, protocols, warning signs & labels, negative news than ever. You're going to have to take some risks and go against the status quo. You may even be wrong. but it's worth the risk to raise a capable generation.
- rafaelero 4y agoConsidering how many times I was robbed walking alone in my early adulthood I must agree that my parents were correct in inciting a sense of danger in me.
- calsy 4y ago...And the entire thread devolves into old man stories, 'Kids these days. I walked 10km to school everyday barefoot on a dirt road with a racoon for a hat. Didn't hear me complaining...'
- alberth 4y agoNetflix: Old Enough For anyone who hasn’t watched Old Enough, go watch it. It’s a documentary on how in Japanese culture it common to give extremely young kids large responsibilities. A 2-year old literally walks over a mile alone across busy roads to go grocery shopping for his family. https://www.netflix.com/title/81506279 https://www.netflix.com/title/81506279
- fitblipper 4y agoIt is because CPS is an over reaching and lawless organization that can be weaponized against a neighbor that raises their kids in a way you don't agree with. If you don't want your children kidnapped legally by this entity you better raise your kids in the safest possible way or you risk giving them the line item they put in their paperwork to put your kids in foster.
- doyourbest2022 4y agoI live in New Delhi, one of the highest crimes against women here, including kids. No matter how hard I convince myself to help my daughter see the good in the world, I will still get paranoid if she went out unsupervised for a few mins. She's 5