18 ms·
The United States didn't do enough to help Russia transition to democracy in the 1990s. There was no "Marshall Plan" after the Cold War like there was after Wor
by lapcat 4y ago
The United States didn't do enough to help Russia transition to democracy in the 1990s. There was no "Marshall Plan" after the Cold War like there was after World War II. This was a huge mistake, and we see the consequences now, with Russia having turned back toward totalitarianism and imperialism. Sadly, it seems that Gorbachev's efforts were mostly for naught. But it was courageous at the time to open up the Soviet Union to glasnost and perestroika.
Of course Yeltsin was a big part of the problem too.
- avmich 4y agoWas the absence of Marshall plan happened because of the West or because of Russia's decision? > Sadly, it seems that Gorbachev's efforts were mostly for naught. Russia today is a faint ghost of the former USSR. The events in Eastern Europe show that to an extent.
- thriftwy 4y agoIt's smaller all right. But it is also much more robust. Late USSR was the kind of society where most everything was in short supply and which has even failed to feed itself. Yes, it had a lot of hardware and people. All of that was for no good, given the awful system in place.
- avmich 4y agoI'd point out that USSR was much more self-reliant than Russia - you couldn't really put sanctions on Eastern block of countries, they produced everything, with certain things so good they are still competitive. Yes, market economy does greatly improve Russia's agility, but special services can't stop ruin most of what they can touch, so even market economy has limited net benefits now - while at the time of USSR they had a good counterbalance in the form of the Communist Party.
- thriftwy 4y agoYou can't be self-reliant when you are bankrupt and all basic neccesities are in short supply. USSR was defunct. Its communist party was also defunct. Russia is lucky to have China which produces enormous assortment of items as well as trade surplus.
- avmich 4y agoUSSR wasn't bankrupt for many decades - until the end, of course, but it's silly to compare unstable USSR in 1991 going through destructive transformations with Russia, which still "just" losing the was against the West - so far. You should compare USSR of 1980 with Russia today (or rather before February 24 this year) - and USSR will win in capabilities, despite the lack of market economy. > USSR was defunct. Its communist party was also defunct. USSR was relatively stable for decades, with all its great shortcomings. I don't think China plays significant enough role in today's events.
- trasz 4y agoChina produced a lot of things, but Russian market is worthless. Chinese companies left the Russian market same way western ones did.
- anon_123g987 4y ago> Russia today is a faint ghost of the former USSR. Russia was only a part of the USSR. Their main problem is that they, too, believe that they are the former USSR, and try to restore the former glory. Well, the state of the war in Ukraine (another part of the former USSR) clearly shows how wrong they are.
- LudwigNagasena 4y agoThat has little to do with the USSR as those lands were conquered by the Russian Empire in 18th century from the Ottomans.
- avmich 4y ago> Well, the state of the war in Ukraine (another part of the former USSR) clearly shows how wrong they are. I assume you mean "Russia believe that they are the former USSR". It's interesting to note that Russia in 1990-s focused on economic modernization - and while it went through highly criminal years, they built a good market economy by 1999 - while Ukraine was mostly (more) doing political reform - and they had established presidential changes. Now more economically robust Russia with autocratic ruling fights with still quite corrupt, but politically much more democratic Ukraine - and shows that, yes, it's better to be a poor democracy, than a rich autocracy, because autocracy will get you in the end... or maybe it's a too hasty conclusion.
- hahaitsfunny 4y ago
- nxm 4y agoWho would pay for Marshall Plan?
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoSomebody pays eventually. We are all paying for it right now, plus interest.
- avmich 4y agoAbsolutely. And we will likely pay for similar situations with Hungary, Turkey, China...
- avmich 4y agoHow much? E.g. in early 1992 monthly stipend of a student - something which he could somehow survive for a month (not quite, too low, but somewhat close) was about 60 roubles. And the USD-RUR course was 100 roubles for a dollar. So a person was barely - very barely - surviving on 7 dollars 20 cents a year. Do you know how much Russian economy costed at the time?
- wcarron 4y agoYou can lead a horse to water; but you can't make it drink. It wasn't the US' responsibility, it was the Russian peoples'.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pessimizer 4y agoYou can't make it drink, but you can back a corrupt drunk who will shell the parliament and make sure that the Russian people know that America will never be on their side.
- wcarron 4y agoEh, let them eat Pizza hut
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoOn the contrary, the "shock therapy" approach that Russia took in the Yeltsin years was, in many ways, prescribed by the West, and ended up being a complete disaster for both your average Russian person, and for capitalism and democracy as a whole, because most people just learned to associate these things with the kleptocracy that occurred in the 90s.
- lapcat 4y ago> On the contrary I agree with everything you said, so I don't take it as contrary to what I said.
- anigbrowl 4y ago'On the contrary' can have flexible scope, in this case it seems to mean 'contrary to any idea of a Marshall plan...'
- mturmon 4y agoI think there's a lot of historical support for this view. Here's a summary from 1998: https://www.thenation.com/article/world/harvard-boys-do-russia/ https://www.thenation.com/article/world/harvard-boys-do-russ...
- sereja 4y agoInterestingly, the disdain for democracy in both Russia and China is strongly motivated by "we've already tried giving people freedom and it didn't work". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warlord_Era https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warlord_Era https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1993_Russian_constitutional_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1993_Russian_constitutional_cr...
- GekkePrutser 4y agoWarlordism has nothing to do with democracy. Each warlord was just their own little dictator fighting for expansion. The people were just cannon fodder. In fact the Chinese did manage to create a thriving democracy after the warlord era, which is still here today. But it's based in Taipei and the mainland Chinese leaders want to take it down because it undermines their narrative. And the Russians having the easiest beginnings of democracy for a few months claiming they "tried it and it didn't work"? Never heard them say it but if they did it's just dogma.
- baxtr 4y agoI once heard someone say that any country needs two attempts until democracy works out properly. Maybe it’s the same here.
- eastbound 4y agoThe upside of claiming nothing is set until the 3rd time, is that it takes 40-80 years for each try, and that gives plenty of time to be right. Democracy is fragile, chaotic and dirty. The French started democracy with beheading the people that the French would have elected (Louis XVI wasn’t killed until 1793, because he tried to organize a referendum for him, which he was sure to win, and the parliament people couldn’t let that happen). Then the French elected Napoleon, which is the opposite of democracy too in its processes. Then Napoleon was demoted and a few years went by and he came back in Juans Les Pins, and conquered Paris with huge crowds growing at each village. The whole story of democracy in each country is often a farce ending with a happy power balance, while we often turn a blind eye to blatant violations of democracy when it’s in our favour. So there’s no first or second attempt at democracy. There are errands that countries do, and sometimes they become democratic despite having a kind at the head, sometimes they look democratic and aren’t, and sometimes the negative forces win. Lest we live in the good days.
- johnchristopher 4y agoWhat would the US's second attempt be in its history ?
- MichaelCollins 4y agoThe Articles of Confederation were a failure, so we tried a second time, at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia in 1787, the result of which was the Constitution under which the American government has been operating since. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Articles_of_Confederation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Articles_of_Confederation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shays%27_Rebellion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shays%27_Rebellion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitutional_Convention_(United_States) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitutional_Convention_(Uni...
- thehappypm 4y agoI think the big difference is the oligarchs. The USSR had already been transitioned to a resource state, and there was no actual rebuilding that needed to happen. The Marshall plan was almost easy because you could tally up all the broken bridges and say “itll cost us $X to fix”. What’s the equivalent for post USSR? What ended up happening was oligarchs swooped in to take over from the central planners, and it’s not clear how the US could have helped steer it differently short of going to war with Russia’s upper class.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> the big difference is the oligarchs The oligarchs were minted in the late 80s and 90s. They weren’t a preëxisting power structure. Putin came to power with their and the FSB’s help. (He was also popular for not being incompetent.)
- blockwriter 4y agoWasn't the preexisting power structure the Soviet military? I thought that that Soviet generals stationed near large and valuable resources simply decided that these large and valuable resources had become their private property. Organized crimes and powerful politicians filled in the gaps.
- thriftwy 4y agoSoviet military can't do nothing. It's not Latin America or Myanmar. They will just sit there and wait for orders to come.
- vintermann 4y agoNo, none of the oligarchs were generals. They were usually entrepreneurs (Russia always had them, openly under Perestroika) who were well connected with one or more of * The state apparatus * The gray/black economy (or the criminal underworld) * Foreign interests The Soviet military was tightly politically controlled, they were well aware of the dangers of popular generals.
- 4y ago
- mytailorisrich 4y agoDemocracy does not imply friend of or aligned with the West. Russia has historically been an imperial power and seeks to further its own power and perceived interests, and they certainly refuse to be under foreign/Western/American domination. A democratic government could mean less reckless actions but it wouldn't necessarily mean friendlier actions.
- mistrial9 4y agoAmericans seem unaware of the movement of armies by Western European Imperial powers through eastern Europe, very particularly British Imperialists, in the historical shadow of the horse-lords in centuries earlier. The talk is like everyone is innocent except the current government, that the USA opposes; so far from true.
- ajross 4y ago> Democracy does not imply friend of or aligned with the West. It seems like it does, though? I mean, no, it's not like India or Brazil are subjugated client states of the US or Germany or whatever, but they know where their natural allies are and which direction the wind blows in international relationships. Market democracies are going to stick together, if for no other reason than because they'll end up poorer if they don't, and they don't like that.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoGermany is dominated by the US since WWII (having been invaded and occupied) in the same way Japan is. India is neither aligned nor allied with the US. They share interests particularly when it comes to containing China. But again India's interests on this have nothing to do with being a democracy or with China not being a democracy. The US are of course heavily involved in Brazil, including by supporting the military coup there in 1964... following which the military government was unsurprisingly completely aligned with the US. I think that there is a 'survivor' bias here because most countries are not strong enough to resist the US so either they are 'friendly' or something might happen to them... Iran did democratically elect a President once but he was not 'friendly' so was promptly replaced by a friendly dictator. To assume shared geopolitical interests only because two countries are superficially "market democracies" sounds rather naive.
- steve76 4y ago
- duxup 4y agoThe locals in power have to want to do it too. As soon as enough don’t want it, it is over. I’m skeptical of the idea that you can impose Democracy.
- hotpotamus 4y agoRepublicans have long said that the federal government is structurally incompetent and unable to effectively administer a large country. They made a convincing argument with their performance in Iraq and Afghanistan, and I doubt Russia would have been much different.
- Apocryphon 4y agoThat was a very different situation, those were states that were militarily invaded and then occupied by American forces, who were involved in reconstructing countries devastated by war.
- codyb 4y agoYea, and most young democracies are very vulnerable. You can look at the Arab Spring for examples of failed democracies, and the early United States (it took us 20 years to get off the Articles of Confederation and work on the Constitution we use today). Myanmar's another one. India's been restricting its people's rights lately. Democracy takes a while to establish as a stable system and often fails. Alexander the Great was granting (non-representative) democracies to cities in Asia Minor 2400 years ago, I wonder what he'd think of Erdogan.
- AmpsterMan 4y agoThe Thirteen Colonies had a long history of democratic self governance. The revolution was mostly an independence movement. The revolutionary part was the Republican federation. This long history of democratic rule was not present in many modern attempts to establish democracies.
- AdamJacobMuller 4y ago
- Quekid5 4y agoI think this talk shows that it's probably a bit more complicated than that: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kF9KretXqJw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kF9KretXqJw Unless you happen to understand Finnish, subtitles are mandatory (and very accurate AFAICT). There is a link to a dubbed version in the comments if that is preferred.
- cjbgkagh 4y ago
- Tarq0n 4y agoThat's a very serious claim, could you please provide some citations?
- cjbgkagh 4y agoA peer comment reminded me of the name 'shock therapy', the think tank was called 'Harvard institute for international development'. https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2022/03/22/1087654279/how-shock-therapy-created-russian-oligarchs-and-paved-the-path-for-putin https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2022/03/22/1087654279/how... https://www.thenation.com/article/world/harvard-boys-do-russia/ https://www.thenation.com/article/world/harvard-boys-do-russ... My original comment has been flagged. I'd like to know why. If I'm wrong I'd like to be corrected.
- pessimizer 4y agoIt was flagged for not sufficiently praising the awful behavior of the US during and after the fall of the USSR.
- saalweachter 4y agoIf I had to guess, it's because George Soros is often used as synecdoche for "the vast Jewish conspiracy" by anti-Semites, so your comment sounds an awful lot like "the Jews are responsible for ruining Russia". Which, uh, sounds a lot like anti-Semitic rhetoric not uncommon in, among other places, Russia.
- sereja 4y agoThe world had already A/B tested "damage the economy so that it would never be a threat again" and "help transition to democracy" with Germany. The latter worked better.
- 4y ago
- wnevets 4y ago> The United States didn't do enough to help Russia transition to democracy in the 1990s. Some how people manage to blame everything on the United States.
- markdown 4y agoThe US manages to meddle and create problems all over the world. A small part of the US footprint: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_involvement_in_regime_change https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_involvement_in_r...
- zdragnar 4y agoAh yes, the world was such a utopia before the US.
- daemoens 4y agoThat doesn't invalidate the point that the US has created incredible amounts of instability around the world.
- sgjohnson 4y agoActually the British are more to blame for that, as they are the ones who deliberately drew the borders of modern middle east with the explicit goal to cause maximum instability.
- daemoens 4y agoYes they are, but we overthrew a government from half of the Latin American countries in the same time period. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_involvement_in_regime_change_in_Latin_America https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_involvement_in_r...
- pessimizer 4y agoWhy step into a conversation as if everybody else is arguing that there's heaven on earth? Are you going to ask people if they love Saddam next?
- LudwigNagasena 4y ago> There was no "Marshall Plan" after the Cold War like there was after World War II Well, kinda https://www.thenation.com/article/world/harvard-boys-do-russia/tnamp/ https://www.thenation.com/article/world/harvard-boys-do-russ...
- lapcat 4y agoAnd people like Larry Summers are still around giving economic "advice", failing upward.
- spaetzleesser 4y agoA "Marshall Plan" for Russia would have worked as well as the "Marshall Plan" for Afghanistan has worked over the last 20 years. You can't impose your system on people who don't want it. Do you think Russia would have handed control over to Westerners? And without control it's just an endless money sink. The oligarchs would just have become a little richer.
- avmich 4y agoJust to be certain, I'm sure the last 20 years put a long-lasting effect on Afghan people, won't be erased soon. We even see some effects in modern Iraq, where the period was shorter.
- spaetzleesser 4y agoThat effect is still in question. And the price tag was enormous.
- lapcat 4y agoI wasn't suggesting imposing a system on Russia or taking control, any more than the US imposed a system or took control of the UK after WW2. "The largest recipient of Marshall Plan money was the United Kingdom (receiving about 26% of the total). The next highest contributions went to France (18%)" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marshall_Plan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marshall_Plan Moreover, Russia clearly did want and in fact received some economic aid under Yelstin.
- jasonwatkinspdx 4y agoThe huge metal show in Moscow shows just how much optimism there was in that moment. If you've never seen this footage, definitely look: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_W7wqQwa-TU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_W7wqQwa-TU 1.6 million people in an airfield at a free concert that lasted all day. There's a documentary about it but I've not watched it. It's so disappointing the world couldn't bring that optimism to fruition, and instead kleptocrats took over.
- cronix 4y agoNot to take away from that awesome concert, but Lars has stated several times it was closer to 500k, but somehow the number keeps growing... > However, Lars explained in the conversation that he doesn’t know the exact number how many people were in the concert, but he heard at the time that there were half a million people attended the show. > “Listen, it may go up by 100,000 people each year! I heard at the time it was around half a million. Whatever it was, it was a f*ck-load of people. https://metalheadzone.com/lars-ulrich-clarifies-the-myth-that-1-6-million-people-attended-metallicas-moscow-concert-in-1991/ https://metalheadzone.com/lars-ulrich-clarifies-the-myth-tha...
- jasonwatkinspdx 4y agoI just went with the wikipedia article which has two sources, both just newspaper articles, so who knows. It's not implausible though. There've been a handful of concerts as large as 3 million apparently. That just boggles my mind. Can you imagine standing on a stage like that?
- coffee_beqn 4y agoCan you imagine having to go to the bathroom in the middle of that horde
- jasonwatkinspdx 4y agoYeah, I'm pretty sure it was just a mess. See also the reason you should never go to that stupid times square new years party.
- hourislate 4y ago
- avgcorrection 4y agoThe West was and is about capitalism, not democracy. Democracy in the Third and Second World often gets in the way for the West since it brings with itself problems like nationalization of resources (i.e. closing off resources to Western corporations). Probably other problems as well.
- mercy_dude 4y agoOr May be that was the US master plan all along. I mean when has US ever had a marshal plan? Anyone who has followed US foreign policies after war, there are multiple examples come to sight where they just straight up help the country go into deep chaos so much so that the local people hope they were better off with pre war dictatorship. Look at Iraq, Libya, Syria, Afghanistan. I don’t know why anyone would call US ally anymore or even count on them.
- eps 4y agoIt's naive to think that a Western-style democracy could've been instilled in Russia just through some extra effort. The fact that it works elsewhere doesn't mean it's a suitable model for other countries. Especially when there's a lot of prior baggage of being ruled by a single person, be it a tzar or a head of Politburo.
- theonething 4y ago> Especially when there's a lot of prior baggage of being ruled by a single person, be it a tzar or a head of Politburo. This describes Hungary, Czech Republic, Romania and Poland, all former Soviet bloc countries. They've all had varying levels of success transitioning from communism to democracy and from a planned economy to market. So it can happen. Could it have happened for Russia? Who knows? Based on the above, I lean towards yes.
- sgjohnson 4y ago> This describes Hungary, Czech Republic, Romania and Poland, all former Soviet bloc countries. They've all had varying levels of success transitioning from communism to democracy and from a planned economy to market. Yes, but neither the Baltics nor Warsaw Pact countries want anything to do with communism in the first place. It was forced onto them. So transitioning back to a democracy and market economy was far more straightforward.
- theonething 4y agoPoint taken. It's interesting to think about nations as individual people with both innate and learned characteristics. The latter can override the former in some cases, but it usually takes a lot of effort and/or extreme circumstances. A nation's innate characteristics wouldn't be gene based as would an individual though. It would stem from the circumstances of its beginning and its history that forms the ethos of a people and is passed down from generation to generation. In that way, it is gene like.
- jorblumesea 4y agoIf you study geopolitics and history, you might come to the conclusion that Russia was never going to be a democratic ally of the West regardless of how much economic aid they were given. Russia at the end of the cold war had geopolitical imperatives such as a warm water ports, buffer states and desire for Russian hegemony that would have existed regardless of their economic state. They also have a long, long history of authoritarianism.
- lapcat 4y ago> If you study geopolitics and history Please don't make assumptions about what other people have or haven't studied. > They also have a long, long history of authoritarianism. You could say the same about the Axis powers in WW2.
- hetman 4y agoThe ideologies and power structures of the axis powers ceased to exist as a result of the outcome of WW2. This was not the case when the Russian Federation took on the mantle of the inheritor of the legacy of the USSR. Therefore it does not make sense to equate the history of authoritarianism in these places.
- lapcat 4y agoIdeologies don't simply cease to exist the day the war is over.
- eej71 4y agoI'm not sure what special powers you think the United States would have that could change the course of an entire culture that still seeems drawn to the strong-man archtype. These kinds of transformations have to come from within.
- anonAndOn 4y agoMaybe it's because Russia as it currently exists is not a viable country? Moscow's delusions of adequacy really become apparent when the Russian Army is stealing washing machines en masse from its poor neighbor.
- karaterobot 4y agoYour comment makes it sounds like you believe the U.S. had the power to decide whether or not Russia would turn into a kleptocracy or not. Maybe I'm misinterpreting you, but if I'm not, I'm skeptical. Marshall plan notwithstanding, I would give credit to the people and government of Japan for their post-war success: it could easily have gone another direction, and the U.S. couldn't have stopped that from happening. Likewise, the people of Russia and their government are ultimately the ones with agency in their case. I don't think the U.S. should take on the burden of developing other countries; going down that road has been a bad idea more often than not.
- lapcat 4y ago> Your comment makes it sounds like you believe the U.S. had the power to decide whether or not Russia would turn into a kleptocracy or not. There's a lot of evidence that US kleptocrats collaborated to help turn Russia into a kleptocracy. Practically encouraged rather than discouraged that outcome.
- avmich 4y agoI'm sceptical that turning Russia into a kleptocracy was a plan. Usually participants just want to quickly enrich themselves. So I can agree that "let's make it good" plan didn't work well enough, but for planned degradation I'd like to see more arguments.
- koheripbal 4y agoYou cite no evidence for this conspiratorial claim.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- vladTheInhaler 4y agohttps://www.thenation.com/article/world/harvard-boys-do-russia/ https://www.thenation.com/article/world/harvard-boys-do-russ... American consultants were instrumental in organizing the massive selloff of state assets, and quite a few of them turned around and used their knowledge of the system they created to become quite rich. Andrei Shleifer said as much in an interview on the topic, though I can't find it now. edit: it seems like someone else posted the same link while I was looking for the interview.
- lucideer 4y ago> The United States didn't do enough I think if you dig into the history a bit more closely, you'll quickly find that the United States did in fact do plenty[0][1]. [0] https://www.nytimes.com/1996/03/27/world/10.2-billion-loan-to-russia-approved.html https://www.nytimes.com/1996/03/27/world/10.2-billion-loan-t... [1] https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1996-07-09-mn-22423-story.html https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1996-07-09-mn-22423-...
- lapcat 4y ago"The International Monetary Fund said today that it had approved a $10.2 billion loan for Russia. The move is expected to be helpful to President Boris N. Yeltsin in the presidential election in June. The three-year loan is the fund's second biggest, after a $17.8 billion credit granted to Mexico last year." "The United States transferred over $13 billion (equivalent of about $115 billion[A] in 2021[B]) in economic recovery programs to Western European economies after the end of World War II." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marshall_Plan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marshall_Plan
- hahaitsfunny 4y ago
- kilolima 4y agoWe did enough. See https://www.thenation.com/article/world/harvard-boys-do-russia/ https://www.thenation.com/article/world/harvard-boys-do-russ...
- abraxas 4y ago
- VictorPath 4y ago> The West has embraced Russia's democracy right after the fall of the iron curtain. Right like Clinton and the US congress cheering Yeltsin bombing Russia's elected parliament.
- lapcat 4y ago> This is subtle Russian propaganda > lie spread by the sympathizers of the current regime in Moscow Please respect the guidelines. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- CRConrad 4y agoOK, it wasn't even all that subtle. HTH!
- VictorPath 4y agoWhat do you mean, like when Clinton and the US Congress cheered Yeltsin bombing Russia's elected parliament (Duma). Then Yeltsin appointed Putin and here we are. The US has positioned Russia exactly where it wants it - it has positioned the Ukraine exactly where it wants it too.
- leosarev 4y agoNit: not Duma, but Supreme Council.
- paganel 4y ago> There was no "Marshall Plan" after the Cold War l There was such a plan, at least in the twisted minds of the people behind the Washington Consensus. They were calling it privatization or price liberalization or some other non-sense like that, thing is the common people got the very, very short stick (like my parents, who lost their jobs, their city apartment and who had to resort to literally subsistence agriculture in a matter of 4-5 years maximum; I'm not from Russia, but still from the former communist space) while some lucky ones from amongst us became entrepreneurs and business leaders. Also, most of the really juicy assets (like almost of all our banking sector, our oil resources etc) got sold to Western companies, but that was a given if we wanted to become part of the European Union and of the West more generally speaking. Yes, I've started to become more and more bitter as the years have gone by, I'm now almost the same age as my dad was in the mid-'90s, when all hell started to economically unravel. Nobody had asked my parents, or us, who were mere kids and teenagers back then, if we were agreeing to the sacrifices that they were going to impose on us.
- simonh 4y agoI thought most of the major assets got bought by connected oligarchs, sometimes by literally putting goons at the doors of the auction room to beat up anyone that tried to get in to bid against them. If the oils fields were actually owned by European companies, we’d be buying Russian oil from ourselves, not from Russia.
- ptero 4y agoThat was one way. Another was not paying salaries for months ("company has no money" was a common case) until employees sell their "vauchers" to those who wanted to buy.
- patentatt 4y agoI've heard variations of this story a lot. Common people and workers received a share of the company they work for, but times were so dire most people sold them to those with money for a pittance. So foreseeable, why was it allowed to happen?
- ozgune 4y agoI read "Gorbachev: His Life and Times" almost randomly five years ago. I'm going off of memory, but my primary takeaway from the book was your comment. Gorbachev believed in Western ideals, maybe a bit too much. The Western leaders were extremely supportive of his reforms and promised to be with him. After the Wall fell, and Russian economy nose dived, no one was there for him. People were starving on the streets, Gorbachev asked for humanitarian aid, but nothing came. https://www.nytimes.com/1991/05/23/world/gorbachev-pleads-for-100-billion-in-aid-from-west.html https://www.nytimes.com/1991/05/23/world/gorbachev-pleads-fo... I think he pleaded for $3B from Helmut Kohl in the end, but even that was too much. IIRC, the book ended with a bitter note on Western promises, what Russia could have become, along with a warning on consequences in the future.
- avmich 4y ago> People were starving on the streets, Gorbachev asked for humanitarian aid, but nothing came. Looks like some hyperbolization. There was a term "legs of Bush", referring to chicken legs from USA, sold in many places in at least some cities. There were "humanitarian" bags of rice, also available to some significant extent. This was in around 1994, so, Yeltsin times already, but before 1991 Soviet Union was somewhat more stable regarding food. Maybe the reference is regarding a short period at the end of 1991, a few months between GKChP putsch and the dissolution of the USSR? This period is mentioned in a contemporary song ("Kombinatsiya", "Two pieces of sausage"), but it was short enough so that humanitarian help couldn't get to the country.
- ozgune 4y agoYes, this could be hyperbole or my memory misleading me. I'm not Russian and it's hard to find good resources on this topic from the time. I found the following article from the Associated Press. It looks like Gorbachev said that Soviet Union didn't expect famine, but would face food shortages. It's still sad that the humanitarian aid didn't come, leading to Gorbachev's resignation. https://apnews.com/article/a9a10bdf38d213033157d6d98c29e2c1 https://apnews.com/article/a9a10bdf38d213033157d6d98c29e2c1 > In a letter last month to Jacques Delors, the EC commission president, the Soviets asked for millions of tons of food that it valued at $7.5 billion. The rest of the $14.7 billion in aid was requested from other Western nations. The Kremlin’s request included 5.5 million tons of grain, 900,000 tons of sugar, 800,000 tons of meat, 350,000 tons of butter, 300,000 tons of vegetable fat, 300,000 tons of flour, 50,000 tons of tobacco, 50,000 tons of baby food and 30,000 tons of malt.
- tomasaugustus 4y agoDon't forget Putin was a darling of the US and the West for a long time. Read the praises The Economist sung of him.
- raxxorraxor 4y agoPutin even said at some point he could imagine joining NATO. I believe the last 20 years of diplomacy destroyed formerly successes in the late 20th century. It was a real slaughter.
- practice9 4y agoWhat the US (and Europe) should have done was to take away the nukes from Russia, and let Ukraine have their nukes after the fall of USSR. Russia definitely has more history of imperialism than Ukraine (which has none of that)
- trasz 4y agoWhat the US and Europe should have done was to strip Russia off all its colonies, not just some of them.
- unmole 4y ago> What the US (and Europe) should have done was to take away the nukes from Russia And how exactly would they have accomplished that? > and let Ukraine have their nukes Why would anyone in their right mind want to give nukes to a smaller, less stable country? This is just recency bias run amok.
- vt85 4y ago
- droptablemain 4y agoEveryone should read The Shock Doctrine by Naomi Klein.
- epolanski 4y agoActually US did a lot to help Yeltsin reelected, never stopped the expansion eastwards, attacked Serbia without UN approval, pushed for Kosovo referendum under Nato occupation, never stopped the military exercises and flights on russian border and tried its best to meddle in Russia's internal affairs and us economists were among those that most pushed Yeltsin for the shock transition towards a capitalist market which led to ghe 1998 default. I think US did enough divide and conquer and meddling to help bringing back an authoritarian government. Anyway, totalitarian has a specific meaning, not a random one, it's a government that holds total control on all powers in a country. Stalinist USSR and Nazi germany (modern eritrea and north korea) apply to that definition, Italian or spanish fascisms do not (in both the head of state was the king), even less Russia since it is a de jure democracy.
- avmich 4y ago> I think US did enough divide and conquer and meddling to help bringing back an authoritarian government. There is a phrase in Russia, :) "But in USA they lynch people". The idea is that in Russia it's often that discussion is interrupted by listing the ills of America, to avoid talking about Russia or for other reasons, so it's easy to justify pointing fingers to "the real evil". I think you're wrong and your arguments are misplaced. The phrase "never stopped the expansion eastwards" suggests that you don't see e.g. Slovenia as an interested party to join NATO, for whatever reason they chose, and instead see it as an evidence of guilt. > Stalinist USSR and Nazi germany ... apply to that definition... even less Russia since it is a de jure democracy. Current Russian laws mean little to define Russia de facto. Just like Hitler laws meant little at the time.
- russocan 4y agoWhat does it matter what Slovenia wants? NATO is US empire, at the end of the day it's US decision.
- leosarev 4y ago>Current Russian laws mean little to define Russia de facto. There is a huge difference between real totalitarian state and present day Russia. In present day, there are less than 100 people have been imprisoned for "political" reasons (for violating foreign agent law or for violating army fakes law). It's widely discussed and criticised in Russian national media. In 1937 alone something like 700000 people were executed by Stalin's NKVD, and millions were imprisoned. If I wrote comment like this, it surely leads to my imprisonment. That was totalitarian state, state when you are afraid to speak freely with your own family. Current Russian regime is nothing like that.
- eternalban 4y ago> There was no "Marshall Plan" after the Cold War like there was after World War II. This was a huge mistake This notion is based on ignoring historic facts. Germany (and Japan) in WWII were fully vanquished foes whose entire socio-political system was redrawn by the victors. Marshall plan executed in an environment of near total control over Germany. US simply was not in a position to do a Marshall Plan for ex-Soviet Union. > The United States didn't do enough to help Russia transition to democracy in the 1990s. This is another nice sounding but entirely wrongheaded thought. Do you really think an outside force can come and force a nation with its historic trajectory and 'make them democratic'? Democracy, or whatever goes by that name in the West today, has its roots in Magna Carta! That's 1215 [yes, I watched Better Call Saul]. Read up on history of England, and how much bloodshed it took to go from there to a parliamentary system, with (important to note) its entire elite class on board with the political arrangement -- it was after all what they wanted after having their Glorious Revolution. The idea that a bunch of Americans can waltz into Moscow and St. Petersburg and turn Russia in a "democratic nation" by some means of time compression squeezing in centuries of organic development into a couple of decades is frankly laughable.
- LtWorf 4y agoGood point. Except you're forgetting Marshal plan wasn't only for Germany and Japan.
- eternalban 4y agoNot forgetting. Wartime allies, totally vanquished foes, and newly minted countries. Russia in 1991 was neither. US did in fact do another Marshall Plan after WW2, catapulting China into 21st century. But that help came after a very deep strategic understanding between US's and China's ruling class. Again, nothing of the sort happened with Russia nor was it possible.
- lapcat 4y ago> This notion is based on ignoring historic facts. No, it's not. Please refrain from this kind of personal comment. I wasn't suggesting that the US meddle in Russia's political system. Russia was already moving to democracy by itself. The point was to provide economic aid to support that existing, fledgling, fragile democracy. What happened, unfortunately, is that many Russians suffered heavily economically during the transition, and they started to look back with some fondness to the "good old days", because they were worse off financially than before. That's where the western world could have helped.
- oytis 4y agoMarshall plan was tied to occupation though whereby U.S. could direct and correct the first steps of the young post-war German democracy. Nothing like that would be allowed by post-Soviet elites, no matter how much economic help U.S. would offer.
- andrepd 4y ago> The United States didn't do enough to help Russia transition to democracy in the 1990s. This wording implies an accident, or negligence. In fact, it was an intentional and explicit policy of "shock doctrine" economic deregulation and ultra-liberalisation that led to the absolute misery of the 1990s, and the kleptocracy that continues to this day.
- avmich 4y agoIn Poland that same "shock doctrine" led to quite good results, quite soon. Not to mention lack of evidence...
- AndyMcConachie 4y agoThe USA put Yeltsin into power with a coup. Then Yeltsin turned over the reins to Putin. To say that the USA "didn't do enough to help Russia transition to democracy in the 1990s" is incredibly ignorant. The USA had no interest in promoting democracy in 90's post-USSR. Gorbachev was a fool who believed that the USA and the west would not rape his country. We'll never know how many former citizens of the USSR died because of 90's shock therapy.
- baybal2 4y agoRussian citizen here, and one with self-honesty to talk about 199X without self-pity, unlike many of my compatriots here. > The United States didn't do enough to help Russia transition to democracy in the 1990s. There was no "Marshall Plan" after the Cold War like there was after World War II. Total bullshit. The West did put in nearly as much money as part of GDP in aid to early 199X Russia. US aid was pouring from every hole up until mid-late nineties. I would argue America went too much Marshal on Russia, and you are reaping the results of this folly now. It was a giant mistake not to finish off the beastie, and not to SCALE UP the pressure after the USSR collapse. The West is responsible for much of the CPSU comeback happening in 200X, just like USA rescued early CPSU from total collapse through food riots in early 192X out of pity. A giant mistake. US humanitarian aid was stolen many times over, sold again, stolen, and resold, giving a headstart to CPSU elements turning to banditry. It was totally unsupervised. Subsequent entries by Western multinationals funded much of 200X mess in Russia, rise, and legitimisation of early Putin's mob regime. The first Western supermarket in Russia was literally inaugurated by a mob boss of Moscow. Much of Kremlin's current denizens owe their meteoric rises to megabribes they got from Western MNCs in early 200X, which catapulted then into power.
- lapcat 4y ago> The West did put in nearly as much money as part of GDP in aid to early 199X Russia. Do you have a citation for that? "The United States transferred over $13 billion (equivalent of about $115 billion in 2021) in economic recovery programs to Western European economies after the end of World War II." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marshall_Plan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marshall_Plan
- 62951413 4y agoIn hindsight, that's directionally correct even though it was not that obvious back then. Only freaks mentioned the nukes in the 90s for example. Now it's crystal clear that their stockpile alone should have justified much higher engagement from the first world. Possibly all the way to literally buying most of it. All kinds of things were possible in the early 90s. We can definitely blame the US for forcing Ukraine to relinquish its nukes. We can blame the US for insisting for a long time on preserving the USSR (during the Gorbachev era). We can blame the US for not paying enough attention to the other two Slavic former republics early. We can blame America for not penalizing Yeltsin's regime when they started to veer off the original course. But we need to remember that it was the West in general, not just the US. The EU is equally to blame. And even though the last 20 years are a direct result of the 90s not that much was done in those 20 years either. Not in 2008, not in 2014, not even when President Trump told the Germans to cut the pipelines and spend on the military. It very well could be the case that destroying the Evil Empire was an unprecedented affair which was too hard for anybody. Where by hard I mean impossible in the Velvet Revolution style. Or at all. They had to perform multiple simultaneous transitions (Totalitarianism -> Democracy, central planning -> market economy, empire -> nation state). With a population impoverished by 70 years of Communism and three generations not knowing any other life (not the case in the Eastern Europe). It's poetically fitting that Mr Gorbachev died the same year his entire legacy was erased. He was not perfect, he was an idealist, but he gave freedom to the people. It was him who opened the border and let millions escape.
- tibbydudeza 4y agoIn hindsight it seems it would have been a futile wasted effort - there are many books that have been written about Russia and the psyche of it's people and why they would never succeed with democracy. Now we have a proto-facist regime copying some aspects the Nazi regime.
- qaq 4y agoYey it's always US fault. Russian people obviously have no agency
- lapcat 4y agoCompletely missing the point, which is that transitioning from totalitarianism/communism to democracy/capitalism is an extremely difficult task for any country, and they could use the help. Just like other countries could use the help recovering from WW2. It's indisputable that many Russian people suffered economically during the transition.
- qaq 4y agoAll former soviet republics suffered economically yet only one is acting this way.
- hparadiz 4y agoSelling off the communist factories was a huge mistake. Should have followed the Chinese model of slowly introducing capitalist things into the existing economy. Instead they laid everyone off and of course everything went to shit.
- InTheArena 4y agoThe Chinese model was to avoid what Gorbachev did, and massacre their own people at Tiananmen square.
- hetman 4y agoThat really worked out for China didn't it. Under Xi Jinping there's a resurgence of Communist ideology and not at all the gradual acclimation to Western style democracy everyone had expected.
- nickpinkston 4y agoI hope that if Putin's regime falls that the West will welcome the next Russia with open arms and such a Marshall Plan with far more commitment, scale, realism, and humility than before.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- t6jvcereio 4y agoAlso, there was no effort to dezombify the Russian population. I read recently that only in the 60s the German public opinion started moving towards "Nazis are bad", and that was because of an external effort to reeducate them (I had just assumed that after they lost the war, the population would automatically see the Nazis were bad). No such effort happened with the Russians, so they're still trying to conquer Europe, as they have been since tsarist era.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 4y agoDon't think lack of Marshall plan is to blame. Russian economy was totally dependent on oil and gas exports since 1970s. Very low oil prices in 1990s contributed to widespread poverty and allowed few oligarchs to scoop all the assets very cheaply. Putin's rise to power coincided, by chance only, with dramatic oil price recovery. So people learned to correlate good life with a strong leader, and poverty - with democracy.
- stakkur 4y agoRussia didn’t ‘transition to democracy’. This seems to be a particularly American fantasy.
- trhway 4y ago>The United States didn't do enough to help Russia transition to democracy in the 1990s. it was a tough choice. To transition to democracy it was necessary to dismantle and punish for the most egregious crimes the KGB and the likes, to actually prohibit Communist Party and to deny the people directly associated with the totalitarian regime of USSR any positions of power for at least 10 to 20 years. East Germany, Baltic and some other East Europe countries did for example various elements of such a process. Such "de-communization"/"lustration" though carried risk of instability, and instead US chose stability because of USSR/Russia nukes, and thus US actually helped KGB to survive the 1991. Splitting Russia further would have also helped to dampen the anti-democratic imperial drive in Russia, yet that was coming with the chances to increase the number of nuclear armed countries, and this is again why US didn't support the breakup of Russia into smaller pieces. I think such smaller pieces would have had higher chances for democratic transition due to most of them losing the imperial drive. Belarus has never did the "lustration", and is a lost cause for the foreseeable future. Ukraine also didn't do "lustration" back in 199x, and that resulted in the grave danger to the country in 2014 when a lot of army and government officers didn't want to defend their country. So Ukraine had to do such "lustration" in the years since 2014, and today its results are obvious in their successful fight against the invasion.
- rs_rs_rs_rs_rs 4y ago
- lapcat 4y ago> What an insane idea Please respect the HN guidelines. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html > next you're going to tell me the US is also to blame for the collapse? No, it's actually the Ronald Reagan fans who believe the US is responsible for the collapse of the USSR.
- kemiller 4y agoNot sure how a Marshall plan would have worked since, unlike Germany, we were not occupiers. Our ability to reshape their system was limited. Not that we didn’t bubble things.
- lapcat 4y ago"Somewhat more aid per capita was also directed toward the Allied nations, with less for those that had been part of the Axis or remained neutral. The largest recipient of Marshall Plan money was the United Kingdom (receiving about 26% of the total). The next highest contributions went to France" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marshall_Plan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marshall_Plan
- htowieuro234 4y agoYou realize it was the Americans under Yeltsin who basically destroyed Russian economy right ? I'm fairly sure Russian children weren't prostituting themself because the US "missed their mark" and were led astray by "corrupt Asiatics" (not being facile here; this is standard argument put out by Western "intellectuals" today - which says a lot about the deep hate for Asia.). I imagine Russians slyly and sarcastically saying, to the typically non-ironically self-righteous Westerner, "oh the Americans did plenty; plenty indeed; we really wish they didn't". Much of the global south holds much the same opinion IMO. Frankly, I'm shocked at the state of disconnect in the West. The kind of petulant idiocy displayed by the usual eminences when the majority of the world did not play along - much like they didn't play along when the US-West attacked god-knows how many countries now - was less suitable even of a pouty teenager.
- hetman 4y agoWhat serious intellectuals in the West are making statements about "corrupt Asiatics" today? This is clearly taken directly from some kind of propagandist talking sheet because anyone making this claim clearly understands nothing about the West of today. It's ironic that we can talk about Western petulance but ignore the petulance of the Russian Federation when their outrageous demands were not met by their neighbours.
- john_glick 4y ago
- refurb 4y agoThe United States didn't do enough to help Russia transition to democracy in the 1990s. If anyone is interested why the US get involved in other countries affairs, just look to comments like this. I'm not sure why the US has any responsibility for helping Russia transition to a democracy. And I'm not sure why, when the US does provide assistance, when the country fails to become democratic, it's because "the US didn't do enough". It's pretty clear it's a no win situation. The US gets blamed for "doing nothing, or not enough" and then when it does something it gets blamed for "interfering with another nations affairs". I'm starting to see why the founding fathers were such isolationists and the US as a whole was isolationist until WW1. There is nothing good that can come out of getting involved.
- mandevil 4y agoI've been thinking about the 'success' of the Marshall Plan relative to the massive failures of the various attempts to repeat it that spent significantly more money (off the top of my head: Vietnam, Balkans, Afghanistan, Iraq) and I've come up with a few things that seem like they were present in the Marshall Plan but not in the later, failed copies. A) Rebuilding democracy versus building it. Most obviously, it is easier to get everyone to end up in a place when they have already been there. Konrad Adenaur, for example, was first elected Mayor of Koeln under the Wilhelmine Empire, and had first won an election 40 years before becoming Chancellor (with a dozen year interregnum, spent in obscurity during the Nazi era). Similar story w.r.t Japan (Yoshida Shigeru was a diplomat rather than an elected official, but had the same sort of career, right down to the big hole where he had no official job during the war). The main Axis nations had been reasonable democracies within the past 15-20 years, whereas Afghanistan and Iraq were farther from that (and their initial leaders were refugees rather than people who had stayed, which is an enormous difference that I think US leaders missed). The USSR obviously was a lifetime since the last real, multiparty elections in 1917. B) Many nations working together. The Marshall Plan aid was distributed across most of Europe, and in a way that emphasized international cooperation (with 25% going to the UK, 18% to France, and 11% going to West Germany, it truly was split among many nations). This helped to rebuild international trade that truly cemented the nations together. This is plausible for a USSR modernization, so long as the Russians are willing to admit that the other nationalities are truly independent. (The most successful of these attempts, in the Balkans, largely did manage to tie the international knots together. The others not so much. But how much of that was that Slovenia and Croatia are great vacation trips for Europeans, in a way that going to Moscow was simply much more distance?) C) Continuing presence of US troops. Japan's economic growth really dates to the Korean War, when the US military suddenly energized and needed local production to supplement weapons and goods shipped across the Pacific. Similarly, from roughly that point to the end of the Cold War the US had a quarter-million men in Germany alone (more in the UK, Italy, etc.). Those men needed goods and services, and had dollars to spend. This is basically impossible to imagine for the fUSSR. (In Vietnam/Iraq/etc. the US military obviously had a continuing presence for a long time, but it largely provided its own food and supplies, rather than depend on the local economy. Lots of money did leak into the local economies, but not in economically beneficial ways- read much of it was captured by graft.) D) Humiliation: this is important point that is something of a combination of A and C- there was a complete and total defeat, with most of the country smashed down to rubble, which made the democratic history seem attractive, and a massive continuing US presence, which seems to have prevented Dolchstoss narratives and backsliding from taking hold. This seems incredibly unlikely for the fUSSR to me. Even at their lowest, they were an independent country with a massive nuclear arms cache and quite a bit of (well-justified) pride in, e.g. Yuri Gagarin, Sputnik, and Sergei Korolev. Basically, this isn't about money: the US spent about as much on civil reconstruction (excluding military expenses) in Afghanistan alone, as it did on the entire Marshall Plan in all of Europe adjusted for inflation (using CPI-U, the most common gauge). So there has to be more than just money, and I'm skeptical that the US had significant power to make the former USSR outcomes better. Certainly, any discussion of a successful fUSSR Marshall Plan would have to start with why the Baltics outcomes are so much better than Russia, and I don't have much of a story for that.
- jimmySixDOF 4y agoWe are also dealing today with blowback from the perceived claim that "Not One Inch" [1] of NATO expansion to the East could be expected as Western policy. The Partnership for Peace program may have started off in the right direction, but, as the military hawks took policy control like good generals the only thing they actually cared about was "securing the nukes". And expanding NATO to the East. Ps I worked with a guy who was in Russia for IBM in those days and he said they needed armed guards and dummy trucks to deliver a Mainframe. [1] https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/57615585-not-one-inch https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/57615585-not-one-inch
- hetman 4y agoAh the old "there's only two sovereign nations, USA and Russia, and everyone in between are just puppets" line of thought that seems so entrenched in the Russian Federation, presumably because the Soviets could not conceive the common people of any country wanting anything without being agitated through propaganda (after all, when you have near total control over the media, independent thought does seem like an aberration). What people who complain about NATO expansion seem to forget is that the countries being "expanded into" still have living memory, within one generation, of Soviet tanks rolling through their streets to put down any attempts at independence in governance. There was Hungary, Czechoslovakia, Poland... the US didn't coërce these countries to join NATO, these countries were practically begging to be included. Then the Russian Federation made the demand at the beginning of 2022 for NATO to remove its troops and equipment from Central/Eastern Europe as if they ruled over those nations. The gall to think to dictate the international military security policy for a population totalling twice the size of their own is astounding.
- leosarev 4y agoPlease remember that a Cuba is sovereign nation, but USA were willing to go to the nuclear war to have Soviet troops and equipment removed. But the way, USA still occupies part of Cuban soil against will of Cuban people, doesn't they?
- 4y ago
- smsm42 4y agoYou can't force democracy on people. US - as a state and as private persons (Soros in particular) invested a lot into trying to build up democratic institutions (at least as they understood them) in Russia. It didn't work, and in part it didn't work because Russians seemed not to value the same things Americans value. Now, I am talking in generic, in broad strokes - which is never 100% true for any society, it's always more complex. But you can identify the major tendencies and likelihood of certain ideas to win or wither. At least significant part of Russians seems to be ok with having no free speech, no real elections and no independent judiciary or other democratic institutions - as long as they are reasonably safe, physically and economically, and the bad things only happen to those who speak up or somehow do something "wrong" (which includes demanding to have those institutions publicly). They have been living this way for decades, and they have been living in much worse way - where bad things happened to pretty much everybody, regardless of what you do - for decades before that. Looks like they developed some habits that make their society very atomized and politically inert. Couple that with significant resentment of formerly having great empire (it was nominally "Soviet", not "Russian", but everybody knew where the capital was - in Moscow, right?!) and now being forced to play by the rules they did not write - and you get the full Weimar picture, and you know where that leads. Not to the thriving democracy. I don't think any "Marshall Plan" would have helped - and Russian wouldn't accept this magnitude of intrusion anyway.
- lapcat 4y ago> You can't force democracy on people. The Marshall Plan was economic recovery assistance, and it went to allies as well occupied territories. "The largest recipient of Marshall Plan money was the United Kingdom (receiving about 26% of the total). The next highest contributions went to France (18%)" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marshall_Plan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marshall_Plan Russia had already implemented its own elections after the fall of the USSR. The US didn't need to force that. The point is just to support Russia in its transition, not to force it. You speak of the Weimar Republic. The lack of a "Marshall Plan" after WWI and the harsh conditions imposed by the Treaty of Versailles were a big factor in the failure of the Weimar Republic. > At least significant part of Russians seems to be ok with having no free speech, no real elections and no independent judiciary or other democratic institutions This is true also in the United States...
- bryik 4y agoTo anyone interested in this topic, I highly recommend "Collapse: The Fall of the Soviet Union" by Vladislav M. Zubok. This comment reminded me of one of my notes: Near the end of the book, George HW Bush tries to convince the US government to provide economic aid to stabilize the fledgeling Russian state but this fails. Earlier in the book there is talk of a "Grand Bargain", a theory that for $100 billion the US could convert the USSR from an enemy into a friend similar to how the Marshall Plan and Berlin Airlift converted the Germans into close US allies. Japan is another example of this. After WW2, instead of razing Japan and Germany as Rome did to Carthage, the US raised them from their knees. It helped rebuild and rehabilitate these countries. There was no Marshall Plan for Russia. Many of the Russian politicians and economists expected significant economic aid from the West. This aid did not materialize, at least not in the form and magnitude that was expected. The transition from state socialism to capitalist market economy was traumatic; during the USSR the poverty rate was 30%, after the collapse the poverty rate was 80%. The average lifespan of a Russian man was 66 during the USSR, after the collapse it was around 55. The loss of super power status, of territory, and of economic strength created significant political backlash in the years following the collapse. These conditions promoted nationalism, populism, and authoritarianism which Putin used to seize control. Russia does not have a cultural history of democracy so maybe this was inevitable, but perhaps greater Western support would have avoided it?
- hetman 4y agoI see this claim pop up pretty frequently but I think it ignores a rather important factor and that was that those countries suffered complete defeat at the hands of the US, that meant the US could impose any ideology they wished on the country. This was never the case with Russia. Now for sure, the USSR ended its life as a failed economic state, and the Russian Federation that emerged may have been willing to accept any economic ideology imposed on it... but capitalism needs more than this to work. For example it needs the firm rule of law to be established, yet it is not clear there's anything the US could have done to prevent the divvying up of state resources amongst clever individuals who appropriated vast wealth, through usually dishonest means, becoming today's oligarchs. Nor could the US do anything to eliminate the Russian pride that remained in their former empire, which placed fairly unique pressures on Russia's leaders ("we may be poor but at least everyone else is afraid of us" was not as much of a fringe attitude among the common people as one might think). So I don't think the conditions were at all similar between Germany and Japan on the one hand, and the Russian Federation on the other, and I don't think any kind of Marshal plan could have ever worked without these missing conditions. After all, for decades we thought of China that if we just made them all rich, they'd all see the benefits of Western democracy and become more like us ideologically. So the West encouraged open trade with China and... the end result was a country which now had the resources to reäffirm their state ideology. Today we see a China pushing to strengthen the Maoist values it was founded on, rather than dismantling them. Unfortunately, without utter national humiliation that completely breaks the people's belief in their former state ideology, I just don't think ideological transformation in any kind of short period of time is possible.
- edgyquant 4y agoWhile you’re not wrong they can be forgiven as they didn’t expect the nation to actually collapse.
- fithisux 4y agoYou mean Neocolonialist practices like in African or South American countries? Russia was and will always be a superpower. No need for humiliating "pats on the back" by Anglo-Saxons. They always wanted to see them fall. Tough luck though.
- jillesvangurp 4y agoI don't think it's that simple. Unlike post war Germany, the Russia that emerged from the cold war wasn't a functioning democracy but more of a kleptocracy. Yeltsin got put in power by a military that saw him as a convenient stooge. And with Yeltsin, corruption and nepotism flared up almost immediately. So any kind of Marshall plan would have deteriorated into providing billions to oligarchs. Which is of course what happened in any case. And of course eventually the KGB and Putin took over with all their institutional paranoia regarding the west. Allegedly, Putin might actually be the richest person on this planet at this point. It's hard to estimate his exact wealth but he's not a poor man, to say the least. You are also forgetting, that Russia was still a powerful nuclear capable force after the wall came down. There was no military defeat. And there were plenty of olive branches in terms of investments and collaboration. But, the Russians weren't exactly open to the US dictating them how to run their country. Germany had no choice in the matter. It was occupied by the allied forces and ruined by WW II.
- al_mandi 4y ago> to help Russia transition to democracy You mean like how they "helped" countries like Iraq and Afghanistan transition to democracy? Leaving behind millions dead and diplaced? It's astounding how some people in the West think they reached enlightenment.
- lostlogin 4y agoI think it more remarkable that The Marshall Plan happened than that other opportunities are squandered. The frequency at which such chances are missed is so high that it is very much the normal state.
- vintermann 4y agoIt's not that they did too little. On the contrary, it's that they did too much. They got everything they wanted, including "shock therapy" neoliberalism, Yeltsin as president (unhobbled by parliamentary constraints after the 1993 shelling of the Duma, which Clinton personally praised), and a continued enemy for budgetary purposes.
- nivenkos 4y agoThe US actively supported Yeltsin and paved the way for Putin. This is what they wanted. And it's working wonders now - the US will make a fortune off of LNG and arms sales, whilst completely destroying competing European industry which suffers gas shortages and uncompetitive energy prices. It's a masterful long-term play.
- rkuska 4y agoThis is how every conspiracy starts I think. Others believing that people in power have these plans laid out several decades in advance. Where in reality their plans (in democratic world) only spans several years (their active mandate). Nobody can foresee the future. US supported Yeltsin because that was something that made sense in a given time for them. They didn't do this because they expected to make ton of money in 2022 of LNG and arms sales. Now they were given opportunity to make some $ which also coincidence with their own interests. But they are not able to tell what impact will this have in another 20-30 years. They do it because it makes the most sense now. Not because they have this super masterful long term play.
- nivenkos 4y agoI more meant that they didn't want to help, because they want an enemy, not an ally. Someone to point to and keep the military and intelligence agency funding flooding in.