26 ms·
Why no Roman industrial revolution?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lohfu 4y agoI think a more intriguing question is ”Why no Chinese industrial revolution?” Their economy was nowhere near as slavery or serfdom based, and was impressively technologically advanced
- relaxing 4y agoI’d guess the answer is similar - there was no constraint on a key resource to act as a forcing function.
- chroma 4y agoThe weirdest thing to me is that the Chinese had sky lanterns 2,300 years ago but they never scaled them up to hot air balloons. It took 2,000 years before Joseph-Michel Montgolfier saw some laundry billow as it dried above a fire, inspiring him to build a flying machine.
- zzbzq 4y agoWhat amazes me is we've had hot air balloons for 250 years and still haven't scaled them into partial vacuum space zeppelins, we're still burning rocket fuel like it's the dark ages
- danso 4y agoWith the new Game of Thrones spin-off coming out, I was just re-reading some of the author’s hilarious posts on how ridiculous and shallow the show/book were when it came to logistics [0]. Glad to see Bret Devereaux’s popularity growing; his deep dive posts feel like a welcome throwback to the golden age of blogging [0] https://acoup.blog/2019/10/04/collections-the-preposterous-logistics-of-the-loot-train-battle-game-of-thrones-s7e4/ https://acoup.blog/2019/10/04/collections-the-preposterous-l...
- driscoll42 4y agoI just started reading Bret's blog in the past couple weeks with the LOTR posts. Was quite the rabbit hole that I still haven't come out of, love the blog! Anyone with an interest in history should check his blog out.
- the_af 4y agoI like this blog, but "ridiculous" and "shallows" are not words I would use to describe escapist fantasy fiction. It simply has goals that are different from history documentaries. It thrives in fantasy stereotypes whose intersection with history is flimsy on purpose; these are stories about dragons and magic, after all. This is not Braveheart being hilariously erroneous while at the same time purporting to be about real history, only "slightly" exaggerated: Game of Thrones completely disregards the real world, and because this is on purpose, I think criticisms from "realism" are unwarranted -- unless being done just for fun, like this author seems to do [1]. Besides, it's a sliding scale: Game of Thrones, by real world standards, is probably more realistic in its unreality than, say, Lord of the Rings. Neither is wrong to be unrealistic, being more parables or entertainment than actual history. Of all the criticisms to be made of A Game of Thrones as literature, I think "being shallow" is not one of them. --- [1] https://acoup.blog/2019/05/28/new-acquisitions-not-how-it-was-game-of-thrones-and-the-middle-ages-part-i/ https://acoup.blog/2019/05/28/new-acquisitions-not-how-it-wa... > "Finally, before we dive in, two final caveats. First, this is not a criticism of George R.R. Martin’s world-building. There is, after all, no reason why his fantasy world needs to be true to the European Middle Ages (we’ll talk about known/possible historical inspirations as they come up). I do not think Martin set out to design a sneaky medieval culture lecture in fantasy novel form, so he cannot be faulted for failing to do what he never attempted."
- dtheodor 4y ago> Game of Thrones completely disregards the real world, and because this is on purpose, I think criticisms from "realism" are unwarranted This is not true, any work of fiction needs to be believable within the bounds it sets for its world. Those bounds are extended to include dragons and magic, but no more. The rest of it should be as close to the real world as possible. There's a term for this, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Verisimilitude_(fiction) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Verisimilitude_(fiction)
- politelemon 4y agoTypo in the first paragraph? The title indicates the question is why there wasn't a revolution. Opening sentence quotes “Why did the Roman Empire have an industrial revolution?”
- triceratops 4y agoHe writes fast and copiously. Typos are common on his blog. Don't care 10/10 content.
- rgrieselhuber 4y agoI’ve always heard that the prevalence and normalization of slavery eliminated incentives for technology creation and adoption.
- mmmpop 4y agoIt's an interesting thought, but I've always heard that the cotton gin was actually responsible for propping up slavery in the US south, as counter-intuitive as it that may seem?
- jhbadger 4y agoTrue, but the cotton gin only made processing cotton more efficient. It didn't help in actually growing or harvesting it. So unfortunately, more efficient processing did encourage more production by manual (slave) labor.
- thisiscorrect 4y agoThat sounds like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox, and in fact the article has this snippet: "The expansion of slavery in the United States following the invention of the cotton gin has also been cited as an example of the effect.[12]"
- praptak 4y agoThis does not counter OPs point. The invention caused the increased demand for slave labor. It wasn't slavery which caused the invention.
- notahacker 4y agoHowever, slavery didn't prevent (or even effectively compete with) the invention either, like the OP and many others have suggested about Roman slavery
- BurningFrog 4y agoOne interesting factiod¹ is that a root cause for the transatlantic slave trade was that Africans were the only plantation workers that didn't die of malaria after a few years. Both local natives, and imported Europeans kept dying off. ¹ As in, I've seen it stated as fact, but am not sure how true it is
- _9xrb 4y agoAnother take may be found on Dr. Garrett Ryan’s excellent “Told in Stone” YouTube channel: https://youtube.com/watch?v=5uqPlOAH85o https://youtube.com/watch?v=5uqPlOAH85o
- nakedrobot2 4y agoYes, this. There were no entrepreneurs, no capital, no banks, no investors. There was no incentive for someone to invent something and get rich. So, no one did.
- HarryHirsch 4y agoConsidering that ship loans were known already to the Greeks, that assertion is wrong. They were a feature of the antique world, and the fact that Mohammed declared them an abomination would indicate that they worked rather too well.
- JackFr 4y agoAnd there was a recorded instance of futures selling in olive oil in Ancient Greece. But to the GPs point, while there were contracts, there were no tradeable claims, no capital markets and no professional management separate from the ownership, all of which we associate with the early British and Dutch trading companies and eventually railroads and industrial concerns.
- Mvandenbergh 4y agoThere were all of those things in the Roman empire.
- imtringued 4y agoAnd even before the Roman empire in ancient egypt...
- tus666 4y ago> However, unlike farming which developed independently in many places at different times, the industrial revolution happened largely in one place, once and then spread out from there This. We can ask the same question about feudal Japan, Imperial China, Revolutionary France/Germany/Russia/etc. Maybe it was just a fluke after all, with the benefit of the prior scientific revolution and all that.
- triceratops 4y agoBecause having an industrial revolution implies that transportation and navigation are widespread, it's kind of a given that an industrial revolution can only happen once.
- towaway15463 4y agoI thought it all happened because of coal mining. Lumber was getting scarce and expensive in Britain so people started burning coal even though they didn’t have very good coal stoves at first. Demand for coal opened more coal mines. Mines need ground water to be pumped out of them. The first steam engine was a water pump run on coal because that was the cheapest fuel source. Better pumps => more coal => cheap energy => development of better machinery to use it => better pumps… There’s your virtuous cycle.
- Robotbeat 4y agoThat is a super common explanation, but doesn’t square with the fact that steam power was a complete side note of the first half of the First Industrial Revolution, which used water power almost exclusively (wind, animal power as well).
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoWater power doesn't require advances in precision machinery.
- Robotbeat 4y ago
- actionfromafar 4y agoOne of my favourite daydreams is accidentally going back in time and having to build an internal combustion engine. I think I would go with a hot-bulb engine with cylinder walls thick cast bronze.
- dvfjsdhgfv 4y agoI often daydream similar things. And it looks like we're not alone: https://www.howtoinventeverything.com/ https://www.howtoinventeverything.com/
- triceratops 4y agoThat's pretty much the plot of A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court. Although that involved steam engines.
- WalterBright 4y agoI would have invented paper and the printing press. Gutenberg's printing press was a knee in the curve.
- DabbyDabberson 4y agoreminds me of Doc building that ice maker in Back to the Future III.
- josefresco 4y agoI'm reading a relevant book right now called "The Dawn of Everything: A New History of Humanity" While it hasn't yet touched on the Industrial Revolution, it's addressing very similar issues around farming, cities, society, technological progression (and regression) politics etc. *https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/56269264-the-dawn-of-everything https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/56269264-the-dawn-of-eve...
- timmg 4y agoHow far have you gotten into it? What's your impression? I started reading it on the subway (so, 10 minutes at a time). So far it feels overly repetitive. And the evidence feels very cherry-picked -- though I don't have the relevant expertise to know for sure.
- ch4s3 4y agoIt takes a bit of time to pick up and tie everything together. I enjoyed it a lot, but some parts didn't stand out that much.
- unmole 4y ago> And the evidence feels very cherry-picked Cherry picking and misrepresenting evidence is David Graeber's whole shtick. Full disclaimer: I didn't read Dawn of Everything and I don't intend to. My opinion is based on Debt and some of his other writings.
- timmg 4y agoOne of the reviews from GoodReads (linked above) summarizes how I've felt (so far): > but mostly, this reads like a one-sided argument that I don’t know anything about and that I didn’t know was taking place.
- josefresco 4y agoIt's not a meta analysis but rather an attempt to counter widely held but incorrect (in the eyes of the author) assumptions about human societal evolution. Much of the book was "We used to believe this, but now we have evidence that shows that to be at least partially incorrect". Many times he pauses and says "we really don't know but..." and I feel that's honest because much of it is conjecture.
- howmayiannoyyou 4y ago> not clear to me that there is a plausible and equally viable alternative path from an organic economy to an industrial one that doesn’t initially use coal and which does not gain traction by transforming textile production Here, in a nutshell, is an explanation for great power competition. Societal advancement requires step changes in productivity. Leaps in productivity require proximity to means of production. Production requires resources, and resources require access. Access is competitive. Competition breeds conflict, creates winners and losers, and fosters its own forms of advancement and innovation - often at terrible humanitarian short term costs. Nevertheless, being a winner ultimately means your society persists (Great Britain), and being a loser means your society expires (Roman Empire).
- tda 4y agoI think that the term industrial revolution is a bit misleading even, it should be named the fossil fuel revolution. Because cheap and abundant energy is what differentiates the world post industrial revolution from the world before more than anything else
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoThe industrial revolution used water power. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steam_power_during_the_Industrial_Revolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steam_power_during_the_Industr... > Improvements to the steam engine were some of the most important technologies of the Industrial Revolution, although steam did not replace water power in importance in Britain until after the Industrial Revolution
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Robotbeat 4y agoPrecisely this. Coal for powering machinery was just at the science experiment stage in the First Industrial Revolution. Water power was the workhorse. Even for iron and steel making, America (which has an abundance of trees) relied primarily on charcoal well into the mid 1800s.
- cobbzilla 4y agoI read a fun book that explored this possibility, “Kingdom of the Wicked” by Helen Dale. In the story, the Romans have somehow stumbled upon the industrial revolution at the height of the republic, the consequences are fascinating. Very good read.
- robertlagrant 4y agoI didn't know about this! I always wondered about writing a book with that change in mind. I'll read this one instead!
- dougmwne 4y agoI have a personal opinion on this, which is not scientific, but then again for such a huge question I’m not sure science can give us a very useful answer anyway. After visiting Pompeii and a number of other ruins in the area, I sense they were close. You can see it in their highly organized society, advanced construction techniques, complex economy, and vast amounts of labor at their disposal. This was an incredibly advanced society. They where clearly riding some S-curves. If the party had lasted a little while longer, a century, 3 centuries, it seems very possible they could have lit the great spark a thousand years early. We can never know, but I absolutely sense that this was an accident of history and it could have gone another way.
- mminer237 4y agoIf the Roman Empire had lasted 3 centuries longer, that would have been 55 years after Savery's steam engine.
- Robotbeat 4y agoI suspect they meant the Roman Empire at its organizational peak, ie around the 2nd Century AD.
- dougmwne 4y agoYes I was not referring to the Byzantine empire because as culturally interesting as they were, their economy was no match for the complexity of Rome.
- yywwbbn 4y agoIt’s not at all obvious to me that the economy of Rome in 1st century A.D. would have been that much more complex than that of Byzantium in 11-12th centuries. Is there any evidence showing this?
- nradov 4y agoThe vast amounts of labor (including slave labor) might have been more of a hindrance than a help. It takes a labor shortage to create an incentive for innovations that increase productivity.
- abetusk 4y agoThe basic argument is that without a clear use case to overcome the version 1.0 troubles of (steam) engines, there was no incentive to work out the kinks and pumping water out of coal mines was the big "killer application" of such motors. That is, pumping water out of coal mines was the "early adopter" market for engine technology: > As we’ll see, this was a use-case that didn’t really exist in the ancient world and indeed existed almost nowhere but Britain even in the period where it worked. I remember reading a blog post by TechnicsHistory [0] (which was on the front page of HN at one point) that makes the same argument. The acoup.blog article goes on to give a reason why coal wasn't needed earlier as the need for heating fuel became scarce when wood became scarce: > Consequently wood as a heat fuel was scarce and so beginning in the 16th century we see a marked shift over to coal as a heating fuel for things like cooking and home heating. I'm still skeptical of why it took so long. Were there no other places in Europe, Asia or the Middle East that didn't have the same deforestation issues? Was it the combination of deforestation and population density? [0] https://technicshistory.com/2021/07/13/the-triumvirate-coal-iron-and-steam/ https://technicshistory.com/2021/07/13/the-triumvirate-coal-...
- ZeroGravitas 4y ago> Consequently wood as a heat fuel was scarce and so beginning in the 16th century we see a marked shift over to coal as a heating fuel for things like cooking and home heating I believe this is a common misconception. The author seems vaguely aware of it because just before this he says that the forests were cleared in antiquity, which is the usual response to point out this as being a wrong theory that doesn't add up. They cleared most of the forests for agriculture and kept and 'farmed' the ones they coppiced for fuel for a long time after clearing the rest. When they no longer felt they needed wood as fuel, they cut down more rather than managing them as they had for hundreds of years. This is like saying people started eating beyond burgers because they ran out of cows. No, we'll stop having herds of cows because we have a replacement that makes them less necessary.
- abetusk 4y agoI see, so you're saying the author of the post got the order wrong. In other words, Britain discovered coal, to some extent, then started using it earnest and neglected the forest-as-fuel-source infrastructure that was needed to keep repopulating the forests. So you're arguing that deforestation was a consequence of using more coal, not a driver of using more coal. So the question still remains, why was coal only discovered then? What prevented people from using coal earlier?
- intrasight 4y agoMy understanding is that it's a settled question in economics that the answer is simply "risk management". This is what was "invented" at the start of the industrial revolution. Everything else already existed.
- unity1001 4y agoRome was a slave economy. When you are using millions of slaves for no-cost labor, there is little need for develop technology to improve industrial output. Being a slave society has been Rome's undoing. It started in Middle Republic period. It not only prevented industrial progress, but also killed the economy for everyone other than the richest few because those richest few were able to flood the economy with near-zero-cost produce and products, bankrupting anyone else. This caused slow concentration of entire economy, then farmland, then actual land, in the hands of the few elite and started the transition to the feudal economy.
- shadowgovt 4y agoIt's really key for people to understand this, because that economic imbalance doesn't require slaves, though slaves are a sufficient condition. It can also be done (on paper at least) with automation. The key point is "capital consolidation (which can scale) divorced from individual labor output (which does not scale)," and however you get there (slaves or robots), you can create a massive societal wealth imbalance that results in an economic arrangement utterly unlike the arrangement that spawned it. ... that reminds me, my phone pinged five minutes ago. I should go pick up that Amazon package off my porch.
- spaniard89277 4y agoBut the romans actually did innovate. Or at least put other's knowledge to massive use. The scale of planning and engineering put into their infrastructure is just awesome. It's not just roads. Their sewage systems, water treatment plants, siphons, aqueducts, pipes... IDK if any of you had a deep dive into this, but I watch some YT channels by spanish professors and this people were no joke. And they seemed to have some research on materials too.
- FollowingTheDao 4y agoNo industrial revolution? What? The Roman industry was war and empire building.
- helsinkiandrew 4y agoSurely the main point is that the Romans didn’t need an industrial revolution of the type we had later. They had no need to pump out water from deep mines, or need to reduce the cost of labour for producing cheap goods. They certainly had an architectural/construction revolution so would have likely have developed similar solutions to the same problems if they had them.
- archi42 4y agoI wonder what would have happened in the absence of coal/fossils. Obviously anything requiring higher temperatures than possible with charcoal would have been off limits for a longer period. But what would have powered an industrial revolution instead? Solar? Whale oil? Vegetable oil?
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoThe question only makes sense if you subscribe to the European centric idea that the Roman Empire fell with Rome and the medieval era was a set back. The truth is things continued to progress in the Eastern Empire, the Abassid Caliphate and in imperial China. Once you reconsider, the answer becomes obvious. The Roman Empire didn't experience the Industrial Revolution because the necessary technological advancements were yet to be invented. Humanity needed one thousand more years to reach that point and during this thousand years what was the Roman Empire morphed into something different.
- lynguist 4y agoIf you look at any global data in the scale of the past 2500 years, be it gases released to the atmosphere from human smelting, be it number of digits of pi that was known, a pattern emerges: There was an uptick during the Roman Empire, then the activity went down, and by the year 1400 the human activity was actually larger than the peak that was achieved during the Roman Empire. Something happened in the 1400s where all the human knowledge became global on a planetary scale instead of just the realm of an empire. Knowledge from the Americas and from Asia flooded into Europe and left the groundwork for more innovation. Humanity wasn’t there yet 2000 years ago, but it was there from the 1400s on. Europe, as we know it, started in the 1400s. Humanism and the printing press and global scale shipping started in the 1400s.
- WastingMyTime89 4y ago> There was an uptick during the Roman Empire, then the activity went down, and by the year 1400 the human actually was larger than the peak that was achieved during the Roman Empire. It's extremely easy to verify that this is not actually true. For your idea to hold, you have to entirely ignore how islam spread to South East Asia through the trade routes of the succeeding caliphates and the trade infrastructure put in place between the Eastern Romain Empire and China. Same for digits of pi, the approximation was improved significantly both in China and Persia during the medieval era. You can check the work of Al Khwarizmi or Zu Chongzhi. Regarding smelting, Rome did very little. Meanwhile, China had discovered cast iron in 513BC and by the fall of Rome was probably doing more metallurgy than the Roman ever did.
- speedbird 4y agoI think there’s a lot to be said for the two stage argument. First stage water mill powered factories and canals for transport. Second steam and steam railways.
- speedbird 4y agoIn a broader context of similar ideas, this is seminal: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Connections_(British_documentary) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Connections_(British_documen..., leading to the totally iconic piece of one shot perfectly timed tv: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=2WoDQBhJCVQ https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=2WoDQBhJCVQ
- wesleywt 4y agoDoes a pre-plague, slave economy need automation?
- drewcoo 4y agoRome had plagues. Plural. https://www.vita-romae.com/pandemics-in-ancient-rome.html https://www.vita-romae.com/pandemics-in-ancient-rome.html
- ramesh31 4y agoI've thought about this a lot, and it really comes down to metallurgy. The Romans just couldn't make strong enough steel. The key enabling technology of the industrial revolution was steam power, which is only possible given a theoretical understanding of thermodynamics, and the capability of creating a pressure vessel sufficiently large and strong enough to generate usable power.
- drspock11 4y agoThis blog fundamentally misunderstands the Industrial Revolution. It focuses on specific technological advancements like the steam engine as pre-requisites. The truth is that the discovery of the steam engine was inevitable. The conditions that made it possible were not. The Magna Carta, which laid the time for a democratic society, was a key precursor. Democratic societies enable the free exchange of ideas far better than other forms of government. The printing press, often considered the most important invention ever, allowed the exchange and preservation of ideas at a scale never before possible or imagined in history. Both of these led to the Scientific Revolution in England. The formalization of the scientific method, the discovery of the fundamental laws of nature- it was the Scientific Revolution which made the Industrial Revolution inevitable.
- t_mann 4y agoDon't forget double-entry bookkeeping on that list. But I think your claim to a direct link is quite strenuous. Both the printing press and the Magna Carta (as well as accounting) had been well established for centuries when the Industrial Revolution happened.
- notahacker 4y agoPerhaps more interesting than the press itself was the rapid increase in literacy believed to have occurred in the century immediately preceding the Industrial Revolution...
- boringg 4y agoThey transitioned from a democracy to an empire in which entrenched power didn't need to innovate. Additional their power structure was extraction based in terms of lands that they conquered and integrated into the empire. At a certain point in the growth of the empire I am sure that the ability to move classes was more political/militaristic than through entrepreneurial capability thus it limiting individual drive to achieve. As well I am not sure how much public funding there was available to literacy / sciences.
- photochemsyn 4y agoI wouldn't underestimate the importance of improved steel-making technology to the spread of the industrial revolution. All the machinery that made up the industrial revolution - pressurized steam engines, water turbines and pumps, etc. - relied heavily on high-quality steel that wouldn't fracture or explode under constant use. Railroads relied on steel rails, as did shipping and the spread of industrial methods of waging war.
- churchill 4y agoI remember a story (possibly anecdotal) about an inventor who shows a roman emperor a working steam engine and he basically pays him off and sends him into retirement. Another account repeated by Pliny the Elder [1] and Roman courtier Petronius [2] has the emperor Tiberius execute an inventor who created a flexible drinking glass and demonstrated it to him. After the inventor successfully tested the vessel and claimed he was the only one who could replicate it, Tiberius had him beheaded because he figured such a material would make gold and silver lose value. It's hard to sustain innovation when indie hackers are paid up to shut up or basically get beheaded for building an MVP in their dorm room. Founders use to have it rough. [1] http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus%3Atext%3A1999.02.0137%3Abook%3D36%3Achapter%3D66 http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus%3Atext%... [2] https://handwiki.org/wiki/Engineering:Flexible_glass https://handwiki.org/wiki/Engineering:Flexible_glass
- conviencefee999 4y agoInnovation never really came from MVPs like this to begin with, Bell Labs is what's considered the founding step to the modern world you'd be in delusion to think it was a bunch of young adults in their dorms, sure they're parents and friends may have given them the patents and ideas to do it but it was never them that did the hard work to begin with or really anything besides take credit.
- jotm 4y agoSure, but somewhat lesser, but still innovation, on the Internet/WWW itself was made by young adults in their dorms. Current billionaires included. I hate myself for having been born with fucking mental problems.
- narag 4y agoI remember a story (possibly anecdotal) about an inventor who shows a roman emperor a working steam engine and he basically pays him off and sends him into retirement. That's a short story by William Golding: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Envoy_Extraordinary_(novella) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Envoy_Extraordinary_(novella)
- debacle 4y agoThe answer is almost always tooling + resources. Scientific advancement outpaces tooling + resources - look at biology, physics (micro + macro), genetics, etc.
- cat_plus_plus 4y agoIn Netherlands, windmills have been used for a wide variety of applications - pumping out excess water for land reclamation, cuttings logs, making paint, pressing oil. I don't see why this couldn't have added up to an industrial revolution eventually if coal didn't take off nearby. You can use wind to pump water up and then use water for steady rotational power. Basic knowledge of electricity dates back to classical times, so you could potentially leapfrog to that eventually instead of going through an internal combustion engine. In fact, we are now trying to run our industries on wind power because coal is no longer practical for different reasons. All in all, it's always the case that what actually happened could have only happened in one place, because that place shaped all the details of what happened. Roman empire contributed hundreds of innovations without which one innovation of steam engine would not have been enough to build modern economy either.
- scythe 4y agoTo store wind energy, you either need excellent pneumatics (high-precision manufacturing) to compress air or a rectifier (semiconductors!) to charge a battery. I don't think that was in reach. Maybe you could have spun a flywheel, but you'd have a hard time making magnetic bearings without a good theory of magnetic fields and probably Earnshaw's theorem. And it's very hard to move a flywheel. Pumped hydro won't get you portable power. That's a major limitation for, e.g., vehicles. The train was invented just 66 years after the steam engine (1738-1804).
- WalterBright 4y agoI think Tesla invented an electromechanical way to convert AC to DC. Also, vacuum tubes work as rectifiers, and are much lower tech than semiconductors.
- scythe 4y agoA weak vacuum was first produced by Torricelli in the early 17th century using a long mercury-filled tube, but the manufacture of an effective vacuum tube takes you right back to the same high-performance pneumatic engineering I mentioned for compressed-air storage — the first effective model produced by JJ Thomson in the mid-19th century, thereby discovering the electron, which was a necessary step for this to be even imagined. But, to be fair, it's simpler than a semiconductor.
- scythe 4y ago>Realizing this, textile manufacturers (we’re talking about factory owners, at this point) first use watermills, but there are only so many places in Great Britain suitable for a watermill and a windmill won’t do It might be prudent to interject at this point that the windmill itself did not appear until 9th-century Iran, and the more common horizontal-axis version is first seen in the 12th century in the Low Countries. The possibility of a vacuum and thus the fact that air is a substance (rather than a quality of the world) was first conclusively shown by Torricelli in the 17th century. It's very hard to imagine not knowing things that we have taken for granted since early childhood. Even if you could make things spin by manipulating gases (which is what a steam engine does), it's very hard to improve your design if you have no idea what's going on inside it!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Cupertino95014 4y agoAny discussion of Rome quickly devolves into a discussion of how the modern world is like it. Which is the error cited at the start of that article. Let's analyze going forward from Neolithic rather than backward from now.
- nemo44x 4y agoNewtons calculus and formalization of fundamental mechanical physics was needed. The end.
- dalbasal 4y agoI feel like singling out Rome is unnecessary here. Why Rome specifically? Civilizations existed in the mediterranean (and elsewhere) for thousands of years before and alongside Rome. Why even assume that the industrial revolution had to emerge from a civilisation anyway. History suggests quite a lot of technology came from pastoralists, nomads, tribal agrarian societies, etc. Alexandrian inventors were more likely to have recorded their patents and have those survive to modernity. My guess is that a prototype steam engine, or even functionally useful devices, probably were invented many times in many places. The industrial revolution, seemingly, had a lot of chances to happen. Perhaps that's the answer. It was an unlikely occurrence, and that's why it didn't happen all those other times. Tracing back the specific path that led to steam engine prowess in England is interesting... but somewhat arbitrary... probably. For example, the flying shuttle doesn't really need a steam engine. It could be powered by a water wheel, windmill or muscle power. Power isn't really the bottleneck. I think what the flying shuttle actually needed from the steam engine was inspiration.
- Hayvok 4y agoRome is "singled out" precisely because a lot of (Western) people mistakenly assume that they were on the cusp of an industrial revolution, and just ran out of time or something before the barbarians and the Dark Ages snuffed it out. They were a powerful state, populous, technologically and politically sophisticated, and we see toy devices from time to time that _look_ like tech that helped bootstrap the Industrial Revolution. There are discussions of Chinese civilization that are equally fascinating. [1] The author's point is that an Industrial Revolution requires a very precise set of conditions to occur. Those conditions didn't exist in Rome, and they weren't far enough along the tech tree to make it happen even if they did exist. [2] He does acknowledge that we have one and only one example of an I.R. happening, and that it overspread the globe before we had a chance to observe another independent example. (This stands in contrast to agriculture, where we have several.) Perhaps you are right, and there are another set of conditions that could trigger a similar result among another civilization, or a nomadic society. (Deeply skeptical though.) [1] China is probably a good argument for why the specific conditions need to exist. They were even deeper into the tech tree than the Romans, and it still didn't trigger. Maybe they just ran out of time though; we'll never know. [2] You could do a similar study on Mesoamerican cultures and the wheel. We see toy wheels, why no "wheel revolution" there? Probably because of a very similar set of conclusions.
- baking 4y agoThis is why I tend to think that the industrial revolution and technology is "the great filter" for the Fermi Paradox. Life, intelligence, agriculture, society can all occur with relatively high probability, but each planet has, at best, one shot at a technological society and a brief window solve the problems that it creates before everything collapses. Also note that global warming is determined by the ratio of CO2 produced to the amount that was in the atmosphere before the industrial revolution. Planets with lower CO2 are actually worse off because the temperature will rise faster for the same amount of CO2. Also, Earth is helped by having a lot of oceans that absorb CO2.
- stormbrew 4y agoThis assumes a lot of things about alien physiology, structure, and tolerances are the same as humans. It's not hard to imagine the possibility of a species arising that either is less affected by a greenhouse effect or at maybe exists in an environment where it doesn't happen. That's not even getting into the possibility of different paths to energy production. This is always a problem with any Fermi paradox thought experiment. We're extrapolating so much from a sample of 1 and we understand so little about even that one case.
- lisper 4y agoThe details don't really matter. What matters is that 1) a new source of energy is discovered which 2) disrupts an existing equilibrium which in turn 3) brings about ecosystem collapse faster than even intelligence can adapt. The exact mechanism by which this series of events plays out is irrelevant.
- bamboozled 4y agoIt's such a negative thought experiment isn't it? Not saying it doesn't hold some water but man it's bleak.
- lisper 4y agoYep. I've been in a serious existential crisis over this for the last few years. It's not like disaster is inevitable. We could cut carbon emissions before they destroy technological civilization, or maybe come up with a practical way to (re-)sequester the carbon we've emitted. But right now it is not looking particularly promising to me, and time is running out fast.
- Joel_Mckay 4y agoThe western industrial revolution started by replacing both paid and slave labor with machines. Note, while Rome built many great technologies like roads, aquifers, indoor plumbing, sewers, architecture, and standardized tax law. There was no such thing as due process within their democratic process. i.e. if a dozen people from the community dropped your name on pottery shards into the anonymous legal pot, than you were banished from the city without trial. It has also been argued, that a series of incompetent leaders starting with Caligula had caused the empire to enter a downward trend. Much how Julius Caesar grew the empires influence through bloody conquest, his successors ambitions simply exceeded the civilizations limits economically. It is fascinating how a whole civilization could collapse simply by having a few greedy fools in charge. However, I am certain we are different.. ;-)
- tomrod 4y ago> It is fascinating how a whole civilization could collapse simply by having a few greedy fools in charge. However, I am certain we are different.. ;-) Marx and Hegel really were visionary.
- imbnwa 4y agoHegel wasn't a historical materialist though, the other way around no? IIRC Phenomenology of Spirit, we're about in the era of The Beautiful Souls
- Amezarak 4y agoYou’re describing the Athenian ostracon. The Romans did not have that and did in fact place a great deal emphasis on the law-as-such in a way we would consider it analogous to due process.
- Joel_Mckay 4y agoThe Roman historian Polybius described exilium, relegatio, Aquae et Ignis Interdictio, and more commonly Deportatio as being favored over other forms of punishment. Of course, my memory may be incorrect, and you should study the matter yourself.
- aurizon 4y agoIn Roman days, craftsmen had trade secrets and no patents. If you lost the trade secret for whatever = your monopoly was broken. Slaves employed in secret crafts were unable to write and well guarded.There was no IP as we know it. This carried on until widespread printing and reading permitted easy IP spreading - and letters patent = a king granted monopoly that evolved into the early patents - to-day's melange. Copyright on writing evolved to life of author - until Disney came along. Software jumped onto writing's coat tails.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe article misses a larger point. The industrial revolution followed a turn towards free markets. For example, the Chinese are the source of a lot of inventions, but they weren't exploited. The Europeans exploited them. Why? Because of the free market profit motive.
- ilkan 4y agoSo we are the Romans of crypto, doing cool experiments? And it won't take off until the equivalent of worldwide deforestation and peasants freezing in the wintertime?
- jamiek88 4y agoNo because crypto is a useless scam on the whole. The exact opposite of an Industrial Revolution. Actually it’s more of a virus or a parasite upon our industrial society. Adds no value, consumes gigawatts.
- MilStdJunkie 4y agoMy sort-of-joking-conspiracy-theory is that "Satoshi Nakamoto" was a clandestine sentient AI who invented cryptocurrency as a way to incentivise the hairless monkeys networking together as much processing power as possible.
- ben_w 4y agoDepends. Cryptocurrencies are (or at least the famous one is) deliberately inefficient. Most of the times I've brought this up or seen someone else bring it up, a bitcoin fan insists this is a selling point. If so, it's only going to get worse unless it's banned. OTOH if you meant cryptography, then quite possibly yes.
- mpweiher 4y agoNo mention of the scientific revolution? (I did a read + a search) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_Revolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_Revolution Difficult to have the industrial revolution without first having the scientific revolution.
- irrational 4y agoAnd the scientific revolution first required the protestant reformation. The catholic church's stranghold on europe first had to be broken before the freedom that ushured in the scientific revolution could come about. And the protestant revolution probably could not have happened with Gutenberg's printing press. Gutenberg's Printing Press > Martin Luther and the Protestant Revolution > The Scientific Revolution > The Industrial Revolution > Teletubbies.
- ladyattis 4y agoAlso the Islamic Renaissance played a significant role in the evolution of the scientific method which gave European scholars a foundation to build on. Newton's quote about standing on the shoulders of giants is apt here. :)
- arrosenberg 4y ago> Newton's quote about standing on the shoulders of giants is apt here. :) Even if he was making a jab at Robert Hooke when he said it.
- olddustytrail 4y agoNot at all. The disruption and reintroduction of superstition caused by the protestant revolution (eg the burning of "witches") held back science by probably a century. And the Gutenberg press was far less important than the invention of cheap paper.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoThe catholic Counter-Reformation was equally enthusiastic about burning witches, particularly in Southern Germany.
- steve76 4y ago
- bottlepalm 4y agoGood article, a step change in energy production ushered in the industrial revolution. The next step change on the horizon would be nuclear fusion. I wonder if/when that is achieved we'll look back at today like how this article looks back at the Romans.
- Consultant32452 4y agoThe coming decades will be very interesting. We're either going to have a step change up or step change down in energy production. I hope and am optimistic nuclear (fusion or fission), solar, and wind result in a step up. Otherwise the step down will be devastating.
- OnlyMortal 4y agoSlaves. No need. When it was banned in modern era, the industrial revolution happened.
- maire 4y agoI don't think the relation between slavery and industrialization is as simple as you think. Industrial cotton mills and the invention of the cotton gin produced more slavery in the US. I am not sure about elsewhere.
- OnlyMortal 4y agoNot in the UK.
- SoftTalker 4y agoI always thought of it as the other way around. Industrial and agricultural machinery was ultimately cheaper than owning slaves to do the same work. The industrial revolution happened, and slaves were no longer economical. The same goes for draft animals, too.
- OnlyMortal 4y agoNot in the UK.
- driscoll42 4y agoThis is fantastic, though of course starting to read it I realize I should read his Decline and Fall of Rome series (https://acoup.blog/2022/01/14/collections-rome-decline-and-fall-part-i-words/ https://acoup.blog/2022/01/14/collections-rome-decline-and-f...) but then there's his "Who were the Roman's"(https://acoup.blog/category/collections/the-queens-latin/ https://acoup.blog/category/collections/the-queens-latin/) series to read before... fantastic, I love these rabbit holes.
- vgel 4y agoI haven't read his Decline series yet, but The Queen's Latin is very good, I highly recommend it.
- autokad 4y agoI think a big part of it was that coal was useless in the smelting process during roman times due to its impurities. Coke wasn't discovered until ~400 AD and it wasnt even really used until ~900 AD. Without the need for lots of coal, there was less incentive in steam engines. meanwhile Roam already good means of smelting iron (wood->charcoal). I think had Roam discovered coke, it would indeed had an industrial revolution.
- DubiousPusher 4y ago> Finley sought to demonstrate that the ancient economy was not ‘proto-capitalist’ in its orientation but rather a decidedly alien economy where economic relations were structured by status, legally enforced class and slavery more than money or profit. This is one of those things Marx really nailed with the idea that a "mode" of production wasn't just determined by labor and material but that it is also determined by the relationships between the participants in a political economy or the "relations" of production.
- jollyllama 4y agoIn summary: Surplus of slaves. Mediterranean climate. Why bother?
- Animats 4y agoThere's another route to an industrial revolution that might have happened - steel. The British industrial revolution was built from iron, not steel. Mass production of steel didn't appear until the 1880s, with the Bessemer converter. This was half a century after the deployment of successful railroads. Iron and steel was known to the Roman empire. The steel wasn't very good, even by the standards of antiquity, but it was good enough for short swords and some tools. They got as far as the "bloom" process, but no further. Despite this, there was a modest iron and steel industry. A Bessemer converter is a simple thing. It's a big iron vessel lined with brick attached to a furnace and blower. Roman ironworkers could have built one. It's the metallurgy that's hard. Bessemer built the thing, but steel quality was random at first. Robert Mushet, a metallurgist, after about 10,000 experiments, figured out how to get consistent quality from the process. The basic idea, from Wikipedia, is to apply enough heat and air to burn off almost all the carbon in iron ore, leaving pure iron. Then add 'spiegel glanz' or spiegel eisen, a "double carbonate of iron and manganese found in the Rhenish mountains" which was iron, 86…25; manganese, 8…50; and carbon, 5…25. Controlled amounts of manganese and carbon are thus put back into the molten iron, and steel comes out. A number of cultures figured out steel by accident. Thus, Japanese steel, Damascus steel, etc. Various trace additives - vanadium, molybdenum, etc. were used. The Roman empire got as far as mediocre steel. But the process was neither understood nor reproducible at scale. Mass production required enough analytical chemistry to do quality control on the ingredients. So an interesting speculation is what might have happened if an early culture had some people really into finding out what stuff is made of. That leads to analytical chemistry. Some Roman philosopher might have discovered that if you grind rocks to a powder, mix with water, and spray into a steady flame, colored light comes out. If you look at that colored light through a prism, you see sharp lines, in the same places for the same materials, which indicate the elemental composition of the material. If they'd happened to talk to someone in the Roman army responsible for a sword factory having yield problems, they might have gotten some samples of the minerals being used. That might have led to the beginnings of metallurgy quality control. As there is in a modern steel plant, there would be somebody in a little room not too far from the furnaces doing analysis on the raw materials. Steel would still be somewhat expensive, but with a repeatable production process, swords and knives would get better. Then agricultural implements and other tools. If you need to plow hard or rocky ground, a steel plow is a big help. The next big breakthrough in an an agrarian society with some steelmaking capability would be a reaper. The McCormick reaper was the first machine that really boosted agricultural production. That's what kicked the world past sustenance-level agriculture. So that's an unlikely, but not impossible, alternative path to an industrial revolution.
- WalterBright 4y agoCan't have an industrial revolution without a printing press. Can't have mass literacy without a printing press. Need a free market to enable people to profit from improvements.
- dredmorbius 4y agoJapan's Industrial Revolution during the Meiji era doesn't strike me as exceptionally exemplifying free market principles, but rather a strongly government-driven economic policy with market elements, more akin to the American School model described and advocated by Friedrich List. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meiji_(era) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meiji_(era) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_School_(economics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_School_(economics)
- WalterBright 4y agoCopying industry from other countries is not the same as developing one itself. Japan's military in WW2 was pretty lightly armed, and the rest of the country was not terribly prosperous. Nothing like the postwar prosperity Japan enjoyed.
- dredmorbius 4y agoWhat industrialised country invented all the innovations utilised by itself without imports from elsewhere? There are numerous market-oriented countries which failed to industrialise as rapidly as Japan did. And numerous non-market countries which industrialised quite rapidly. Your premise seems suspect.
- WalterBright 4y agoEngland and the US. Though not "all", one can always find exceptions. > There are numerous market-oriented countries which failed to industrialise as rapidly as Japan did. "Market-oriented" is a continuum, from free markets to communism. > And numerous non-market countries which industrialised quite rapidly. What, like communist countries? They remained third world countries, despite "industrializing".
- peter303 4y agoA similar argument could be made for China. They had expertise and capital, but not the incentives to jump to an industrial economy.
- dredmorbius 4y ago"The Needham Question". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Science_and_Civilisation_in_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Science_and_Civilisation_in_Ch...
- xhevahir 4y agoThe author would have done well to leave out of a lot of the engineering details, or at least give them less emphasis. That would have made it less interesting to HN, no doubt, but would have concentrated the reader's attention on his point (expressed in several bolded passages) that socioeconomic factors stood in the way of industrialization in spite of any particular technological advance. It would be interesting to compare Rome with Imperial China, where development was similarly hampered by structural factors, such as the lack of incentives for increasing agricultural output.
- namaria 4y agoThis is a nonsensical question. History is not a march towards an end goal, or an elevation from 'primitive' to 'technological'. This would be like asking 'why no lizard civilization' or 'why no Chinese monotheism'. The things that happen are a succession of complex states and they bear no analysis of sequential 'achievements'. There is no finality. Lifeforms just hunt down energy sources and reproduce, and power structures in society emerge and dissolve. There is no finality, no ascent, no goal. Edit: maybe in a couple thousand years we will have something like Mycenaean civilization but on the moon and with space elevators. Maybe a chain of volcanic eruptions will send us back to the stone age and in another dozen millennia another version of global civilization will have emerged, this time with oceanic floating cities. For all we know, given the amount of actual evidence and the margins of doubt, global civilizations might have emerged and failed 10 times before.
- jjk166 4y agoThe steam engine was not the industrial revolution. The industrial revolution was a major transformation of society which the steam engine merely was a one such development, and not even the most important. The key to the industrial revolution was that it was the first time everything was advancing steadily all at the same time. Just taking a look at the steam engine, there is an approximately 200 year long process where europe went from crude steam pumps, such as Jerónimo de Ayanz y Beaumont's steam pump from 1606, to the practical steam engines that came into use in the early 1800s. Along the way there was the discovery of the vacuum and atmospheric pressure, the development of methods to measure and alter such pressures, regenerative heating systems, the concept of the piston and cylinder, the developments of manufacturing technologies that could produce seals adequate for a steam cyclinder, improvements to metallurgy allowing for the use of high pressure steam, etc. Some people will hold up Savery's steam engine or Watt's as "the steam engine" but both these and all others represent just arbitrary points in a long line of very gradual evolution. Completely independent of the invention of steam power, you have innovations like the 4 field crop rotation, the european seed drill, the dutch plow, the mechanical thresher, new world crops, land enclosure, and scientific selective breeding which all greatly increased agricultural output, allowing a large non-agricultural population to be supported for the first time in history. Advances in manufacturing such as the development of 3 plane grinding, the metal lathe and other machine tools, and standardized threads made innovations like standardized parts, the spinning jenny, and the practical steam engine possible. A shift in the very way people thought about production lead to new manufacturing techniques for chemicals, paper, glass, iron, etc which made these goods both ammenable to the new factory system, as well as economical and high enough in quality to allow for further advancement. All of these developments were in turn part of a broader scientific and engineering revolution, which best explains why the industrial revolution did not occur in other civilizations. While invariably every society has produced curious people who have tinkered and observed the world, typically these were brief flashes in the pan. Someone like Hero of Alexandria would come along, make a bunch of cool inventions, then die and nothing would come of it. People falsely believe that civilizations like the romans were uninterested in technological progress and thus did not think to exploit inventions, but that's simply not the case. They were very good at and excited about making money with some new technology. The issue was that the utility of inventions was what they really cared about, moreso than the invention itself. The idea of developing technology for its own sake was uncommon, to the point that the very few who did see value in such projects could not effectively collaborate. In early modern Europe, you have a unique historical phenomenon where a century of so of religious upheaval and warfare suddenly mean the traditional status signalling methods of the nobility - military achievement and influence in the catholic church - fall out of vogue. People need new ways of socially one upping eachother, and by chance this takes on the form of the gentleman-scientist. Spending all your time and money doing experiments or making contraptions with little or no practical utility becomes cool. You get tons of incremental but consistent improvements which are widely disseminated and further built upon. You get people like Watt trying to make a steam engine with a double acting piston and it doesn't work because manufacturing methods are just not there yet, and then Wilkinson comes along and develops a boring machine that makes it possible. Of course all these things are rooted in deeper trends. For example the aftermath of the Black Death really kickstarts Europe's development as a labor shortage forces people to use land more efficiently to maintain agricultural output, the adoption of the printing press allows practical dissemination of ideas across a continent, and the timely discovery and exploitation of the new world lets Europe avoid what likely would have been major demographic and economic issues in the 1500s, instead allowing for a period of rapid population growth and improvement in living standards.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rweret4535 4y agoHumans individually and as as society don't go a lot farther than cavemans that learned to talk and have some technology available for them to use. You'll find that most of the humans in human society don't undertand at all how the heck everthing just works for them to be kept alive in a continous fashion. Neither they understand the critical importance of some practical technologies, even the simplest cultural technologies, like talking, having a written language, etc. But that doesn't go without consequences, the bulk of humans in a society just fall and follow some "meme" - or several - while they're alive. You name it, family first, friends & freedom (this a popular one nowadays), earn money & respect, save your land - conquer the weak (a famous one in the 40's), make love, not war (70s), etc. Some memes were quite useful actually, the family first thing have driven most of societies out of the woods regarding human resources for work (it carried its own problems - salary -, because the workforce wasn't anymore slaves, but family), other memes you'll find don't end too much well , like probably the "friends & freedom" which while has some perks for young adults, it is already heavily restricting societies from having a proper young productive population and at the same time enlarging it with non-productive people. Time will tell, after all some "revolutionary" memes in 70s,80s, didn't went to far after the initial years of big fuss. But, technologies, important ones, radical change technologies. Anyone with power in the society wants "to control it", hence you have - right now - very powerful, almost unbeatable adversaries to fight with, if you want to make a really new, prone to change it all, technology. Some of them are out the shadow, because of the fight between superpowers,their respective powers that be, have to make public the basic knownledge available (some stuff like fussion, artificial intelligence), because you need to win the game of numbers: as much brains capable attending the development to win the race.. and then control the technology (just the old game, a bit more public). Then you think what other technologies are out there just completely out of public sight, or even fully hidden as top secret stuff, just waiting to be strictly necessary in their societies. You know, the ARN stuff we where stuffing into us the last couple of years came just "out-of-nowhere" almost as a finished product (this is what it feels a medical technology almost completely developed: you use it in billions and just have some few millions affected with non-mortal disabilities). Now they're trying - and somehow they're succedding - in getting the genius back in the bottle, nothing has happened, you can go back to your previous technology iteration, don't ask about the other stuff ..or else
- credit_guy 4y agoGreat article. Thought provoking. Maybe an industrial revolution could not have happened in the times of the Romans, but I think maybe, just maybe, it could have happened 1000 years before them. The bronze age was followed by the iron age not because iron is a better metal (initially it was not), but because bronze requires trade routes (copper comes from some mines, tin from some other mines), and those disappeared after the Bronze Age collapse. Now, imagine that the Bronze Age had lasted a few hundred years longer. Just one hundred years before the Bronze Age collapse there was the battle of Kadesh [1], where tens of thousands of soldiers squared off. There were 5000 to 6000 chariots altogether. Which means the late Bronze Age empires needed huge quantities of weapons, therefore of bronze. Egypt does not have a lot of trees, and trees are quite scarce in other places in the Middle East. Just like Britain ran out of trees and needed to resort to coal, a few hundred years more of bronze age would have forced Egypt to look for a substitute for charcoal. It would not have been coal, because there are no easily accessible veins of coal in the Middle East. It would have been petroleum. Petroleum was known during those times [2]: More than 4000 years ago, according to Herodotus and Diodorus Siculus, asphalt was used in the construction of the walls and towers of Babylon; there were oil pits near Ardericca (near Babylon), and a pitch spring on Zacynthus. Great quantities of it were found on the banks of the river Issus, one of the tributaries of the Euphrates. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Kadesh https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Kadesh [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Petroleum#Early https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Petroleum#Early
- simonblack 4y agoI suppose it all depends on your definition of "industrial". Some Roman inventions have not been matched in the modern world. One that immediately springs to mind is 'concrete'. Roman concrete is far superior to modern concrete. Some modern concrete is only a century or so old, but is rotting away rapidly, while a lot of Roman concrete remains two thousand years later.
- webwielder2 4y agoNo rubber.
- mikewarot 4y agoThe first steam engine by Newcomen could have been built by the Romans, but it was hideously inefficient. There's one at the Henry Ford Museum in Dearborn, Michigan... it's a 2 1/2 story walking beam engine with a boiler about 8 foot in diameter, all working at NO pressure, and riveted together. Rated horsepower? 11 The steam was taken in a wide pipe and allowed to fill the cylinder (which didn't really have a great seal), and the intake was closed, then cold water sprayed into the cylinder, cooling the steam and condensing it... pulling the beam down, and thus lifting the water from the mine, in a graceful slow teeter-totter motion. The cooling of the cylinder is part of the reason the engine was so inefficient. I have no idea how much coal it took to run that, but given that if it wasn't at the head of a coal mine, all that fuel would have to be hauled by animal cart, it wasn't practical to replace 11 horses with something that used far, far more fuel than the equivalent feed for 11 horses (let's say they're in shifts, so 50 actual horses) Watt couldn't get his improved steam engine to work. The cylinders he had made had gaps of up to an INCH around the piston, and no means of packing he had could contain the steam. It was Wilkinson, who had come up with a boring machine for canon that made a cylinder that was made the gap less than 1/8 of an inch, making it possible to seal in steam, and start to use it under pressure. Once the bored cylinder from Wilkinson was available to Watt, the efficiency of steam engines tripled, and went up from there. That is how steam engines really got going.
- mikl 4y agoOne word: slavery. As long as you have cheap labor (in the form of slaves), the economic incentive to invent labor-saving devices is much smaller. It’s no accident that the industrial revolution only came after slavery (and it’s ugly cousin, serfdom) was abolished.
- jprd 4y agoSlaves
- markvdb 4y agoAn interesting precursor step to coal mining was peat mining and the transport networks that evolved around it, especially in the Netherlands. Lowtechmagazine as usual has an excellent article [0] about it. [0] https://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2011/09/peat-and-coal-fossil-fuels-in-pre-industrial-times.html https://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2011/09/peat-and-coal-fossil...