19 ms·
German digital signage ban prompts confusion
- Silverback_VII 4y agowithout a real army and without power... what did the Germans do? I would have thought that they are smart and efficient people.
- yrgulation 4y agoThe people are smart, but the country is not.
- cbxyp 4y agoThis will increase car accidents. Call it a guess.
- rcarmo 4y agoThis is going to be interesting to watch, as many low-end digital signage solutions do not have the ability to fully shut off the displays they’re attached to (and I suspect some high-end billboards will have displays fully decoupled from media players, etc.)
- raverbashing 4y agoA hardware store timer should solve that problem
- Etheryte 4y agoAt a fiver per piece, old dumb and reliable tech, and set and forget, these are by far the easiest solution.
- vladvasiliu 4y agoDon't these have some kind of basic "oh, I've had no signal for 10 minutes, guess I'll turn off"? I have two such displays in the office (Nec something) that have input sensing and a shut-down timer. They're pretty old, too (they were already there when I joined 7 years ago).
- bhaak 4y agoI don't have a problem with that because the likely workaround for those will be to not be allowed to be on at all. :-}
- the_mitsuhiko 4y agoThey will just cut the power to them.
- csmattryder 4y agoYeah, I'm trying to think how a lot of these are going to work, myself. When I built a low-cost signage platform, a lot of the devices we deployed to were Android 4.4/5.0 (yes, even in 2020+), which doesn't have auto on/off that Nougat introduced in Android 7.0. Probably some poor sap's job is to Teamviewer in and install a third-party app to control the shutdown and startup.
- TazeTSchnitzel 4y agoI wish the whole world would do this stuff. Light pollution sucks. It's understandable from street lights but other sources aren't as excusable.
- yrro 4y agoAt first I loved LED street lights because I could see so much better by them (and I presume that they have an increased deterrent effect on crime though I have not checked this). These days I think disrupting wildlife is more important than human safety and I wish we could get rid of nearly all street lighting.
- cyborgx7 4y agoI wonder if the ubiquitousness of people carrying flashlights in the form of smartphones could be leveraged into doing away with street lights as an expected practice. I don't think I would actually support that, but I think that kind of shift in culture is a possibility right now.
- megous 4y agoIt can, but one would need a bit of a ettiquette to not point it into other people's faces. Pretty sure some people would use headlamps if it was necessary for everyone to bring their light source and that is plenty annoying.
- Beltalowda 4y agoMuch of the time using a flashlight is superfluous, or even counter-productive, if it's not pitch black, unless you have very poor night vision. Your eyes will never adjust to the dark and you will end up seeing less.
- neolithicum 4y agoReally? You think protecting wildlife is more important than human life? Also, less light might increase the frequency of road kills.
- brnt 4y agoThis will chiefly affect commercial billboards and the like, which should not be even allowed to ever emit light (or exist) IMNSHO.
- sva_ 4y agoFor real, when they installed some of these ultra bright billboards by the street, I'd get blinded by them as I waited at the traffic light, especially on shorter winter days. The operator claimed they don't run them in the dark, but that was definitely a lie.
- avian 4y ago> The operator claimed they don't run them in the dark I think the following progression of events leads to many of those blindingly bright digital signs at night: Original sign conforms with regulations and comes with a light sensor to dynamically adjust brightness. It's bright during the day, dim during the night. After a few months the light sensors gets gunked up with dirt. Display now thinks its night all the time. It's way too dim to see in daylight. People running the display don't like that you can't read their ads during the day. They realize that cleaning the sensor every X days will be expensive, so they get someone to defeat the light sensor altogether and get the display to run at full brightness all the time. Result is a sign that's still making money during those valuable rush-hour traffic times, at the cost of beaming deathrays into driver's eyeballs at night.
- gog 4y agoIt's not only a gunked up light sensor, it is buggy software as well that is running those panels. At least that is what I heard from a friend working in the industry maintaining those displays.
- tpxl 4y agoFWIW, it's trivial to determine sunsets and sunrises for years in advance. If the only concern is day/night, and not also clouds/rain/whatever, then that is the cheaper, more reliable solution.
- jollybean 4y agoOther than in iconic urban spots, where it's a nice spectacle, we don't need these.
- tpmx 4y ago
- TomK32 4y agoBigger problems in Germany are the lack of big power lines between the North and South and of course the reluctance to build more wind energy. Especially Bavaria has been shooting its own feet several times, even built a gas power station a few years back and now it's in a bit of a panic...
- turing_complete 4y agoYou cannot power a country with wind power alone. Even if you want to build wind turbines, you need nuclear, gas, or coal to back them up.
- disgruntledphd2 4y agoWind, solar and pumped storage gets you a long way, to be fair. We definitely need some nuclear, but it's far too expensive to rely on.
- tjansen 4y agoGermany doesn't have much potential for pumped storage. It can work in a country like Norway, but not in Germany.
- adrianN 4y agoNo, but you can power something like 70% of a country with wind power alone. Add in some solar and a few hours worth of storage and you can go 90+%. Add a few days of storage and you reach two nines. A few weeks for more nines.
- tpmx 4y ago"Add a few days of storage" This is very non-trivial and will take decades longer than building nuclear power.
- anentropic 4y agoIf it was up to me I'd just ban outdoor advertising outright
- jansan 4y agoThis is a cult. Government is implementing micromanaging measure which may reduce energy consumtion by 1%, but on the other hand they do not want to extend the lifetime of nuclear reactors for a few years to help transition, because those 3% that they contribute are not worth it.
- yrro 4y agoThey should do both
- louwrentius 4y agoThat 1% would really matter a lot so that’s an argument in favor. All the smaller things add up too. Nuclear is back on the table in Germany afaik. Not sure if they really will backtrack, but even if they mess up the nuclear thing, this signage decision is 100% a good thing.
- martin_a 4y ago> Nuclear is back on the table in Germany afaik. Not really, no. Just some irrelevant talk, not even the power companies want to keep those things running.
- contravariant 4y agoI don't care, any time those billboards aren't flooding their immediate area with advertising and light the better.
- malermeister 4y agoDude 1% being wasted on annoying your citizenry and creating light pollution is a huge deal. How is that micromanaging?
- muhehe 4y agoLowering energy consumption is a neat goal, but most of these billboards should be outright banned for many other reasons.
- peaslock 4y agoHow much electricity can plausibly be saved this way? And how does that compare to the energy required to reprogram and possibly renew all these signs?
- martin_a 4y ago> How much electricity can plausibly be saved this way? About third of what was used before. > And how does that compare to the energy required to reprogram and possibly renew all these signs? That's cost of doing business and a one-time thing.
- peaslock 4y ago> About third of what was used before. How much is that as a fraction of the total electricity consumption?
- martin_a 4y agoAccording to the source linked in the top comment, we are looking at a total consumption of 113.000 MWh per year for those displays. One third of that is at least around 30.000 MWh of saved energy.
- peaslock 4y agoSo 0.005% at 560 TWh total consumption.
- tpmx 4y agoThe action is super visible though. Sometimes that's the most important thing. /s
- martin_a 4y agoWell, in that case we shouldn't improve anything as long as children are starving to death in this world. That should be our only and biggest "bug" to fix. Feel free to recommend another one, but we'll pause all other improvements meanwhile. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- hnbad 4y agoThe headline is a bit confusing. Looking at the article, the regulation was written in Germany but is passed by the EU (suggesting this will not only affect Germany but also other EU member countries that implement it?) and it is not just about "digital signage" but all illuminted displays in public spaces that aren't necessary for regulating traffic. So this would likely also affect neon signs and illuminated non-digital billboards. The part about there being confusion in whether this applies to shop windows likely also is more about whether this applies to LED displays and showcases in shop windows because they're technically not "in a public space" due to being in the shop but would clearly be affected if they weren't. The headline had me wonder why shops would have to turn off the e-ink displays on shelves indicating the prices of items after 10pm given that most shops that have them (e.g. supermarkets) are closed by that time anyway. The massive LED walls you see in big cities like New York are so rare in most of Germany I didn't think of them when I read "digital signage".
- ErneX 4y agoExactly, in Spain the mandate for shops to turn off lights from 10pm started August 10th
- yrgulation 4y ago“suggesting this will not only affect Germany but also other EU member countries that implement it?” yes, usually germany leverages the eu into pushing other countries in doing what it wants. such is the eu.
- immibis 4y agoe-ink displays are electronically controlled passive displays that use zero power to retain an image. Refreshing them to blank every night and back to the price tag every morning would, in fact, be a waste of power. That's why these price tags are able to be powered by single coin cells.
- themoonisachees 4y ago> This means out-of-home advertising displays at bus stops, train stations and in underpasses could still be operated according to invidis managing director Florian Rotberg. “Most contracts explicitly require outdoor advertising companies to operate backlit city light posters and screens well into the night to provide passengers with more security in the waiting area. Autumn will show whether and how the exemptions will be used,” he said. Most contracts require lighting because otherwise people can't be spammed with ads without their consent at night and they're pretending it's for public safety. I hope whoever decides on this comes down hard on them for having the audacity to pretend lighting from ads is anywhere close to helping public safety. They can get bent about contracts, contracts do not supersede the law.
- Broken_Hippo 4y agoIt isn't the ads, really: They are realistically speaking of lighting in bus stops, underpasses, and train stations. Lighting in those areas, which tend to be dark or populated, helps folks feel safer. Taking away the ads makes these places darker, and I can understand not suddenly having nervous folks not take the bus or train. Though, I agree: They can get bent about the contracts. The proper response is to install proper lighting without the ads. Hopefully this is in the works.
- PurpleRamen 4y agoIt's not only for safety for the passengers. The light also helps the driver to see the bus stops and stations. Especially bus driver who often switch routes seem to have demand for this.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoStill, emitting light through a thick diffuser and a poster is not as efficient as just putting up a light.
- Broken_Hippo 4y agoAgreed completely. As I said in the last bit: The proper solution is to put up proper lighting.
- phartenfeller 4y agoHere in Germany, there was recently a leak in the news. It said that a single LED sign consumes as much energy as 10 single households[0]. Of course, the companies don't want to give any official information. That is pretty high for no real value for society in my opinion... [0] https://www.tagesschau.de/wirtschaft/technologie/led-reklametafeln-hoher-stromverbrauch-101.html https://www.tagesschau.de/wirtschaft/technologie/led-reklame...
- Beltiras 4y agoI'm quite sure brand advertisers will not concur.
- malermeister 4y agoAnd they can go fuck off if they don't. We're in a crisis and they want to waste energy we might need for heating households to manipulate people into buying shit they don't need? That's not exactly a position that'll get them a lot of sympathy.
- lm28469 4y ago> to manipulate people into buying shit they don't need? This is encouraged by our system, switching off screens at night won't change it. Attack the root cause not the very last symptom
- malermeister 4y agoAttack it on all fronts.
- freilanzer 4y agoWhy not both? Energy can be saved here that is needlessly wasted.
- lm28469 4y ago
- fzfaa 4y agoThe normalisation of poverty in Europe would much funnier so watch if I didn't live here.
- malermeister 4y agoHow is getting rid of annoying ads at night "normalizing poverty"?
- fzfaa 4y agoBecause it's done in the name of energy savings and the only reason that we all have to save energy is so the political elites of the West can play Risk against Russia.
- malermeister 4y agoWe have to save energy to soften the blow of the climate catastrophe. The Russian imperialist aggression is just an additional selling point.
- fzfaa 4y agoSaving energy means stopping growth. The West stopping growth while China, India, etc. grow uncontrollably because they don't give a crap about the stupid climate plight will be our downfall.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoIndia? Average Indian emits 1/10th of what an average american does! This is hypocracy, ignorance, and whataboutism China is on track to meet it's climate goals, 90% of electric busses in the world operate there, they have been top investor in renewables for many years. And they are still growing. Why do you never mention gulf states that emit 10 times more than an average french person does. Meanwhile UK has refused planning permissin for 24 privately funded and paid for solar farms because they look ugly, banned onshore wind because it looks ugly and getting applorval for simplest construction project takes 4 years.
- samwestdev 4y agoIt's just useless light pollution. Turn them off for good.
- defrost 4y agoSpeaking of light pollution, here's a handy map: https://www.lightpollutionmap.info/#zoom=3.78&lat=36.9075&lon=35.5169 https://www.lightpollutionmap.info/#zoom=3.78&lat=36.9075&lo... For contrast, see: https://www.lightpollutionmap.info/#zoom=6.42&lat=-26.3451&lon=119.4279 https://www.lightpollutionmap.info/#zoom=6.42&lat=-26.3451&l... Great night skies, radio silent zone (for a chunk of the Square Kilometre Array) as a bonus.
- GekkePrutser 4y ago> But the ban will not apply if the light emitted by displays is required to maintain traffic safety or ward off other hazards, and it cannot be replaced by other measures at short notice. So even the signs indicating what time the next bus comes would not be allowed?
- potamic 4y agoMy city banned billboard advertising once. All of them digital and non-digital. It was fabulous and finally felt like a place to live. Sadly it did not last long and their revival only reinforced how refreshing their absence was. I think we do not realize the value of visual space and pay a heavy price when we decide to monetize it.
- phh 4y agoWow, what city? Sounds like that would make for interesting news read
- npteljes 4y agoI think similarly, I think advertisement is mass poisoning that we happen to allow, because it makes a lot of money go around. One of the cities that did away with billboards is Sao Paulo - really interesting case. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cidade_Limpa https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cidade_Limpa
- immibis 4y agoThe city should require 98% of billboard advertising to go to a citizen's dividend - then we can see whether citizens feel it's worth it or not.
- amelius 4y agoThen I want to be paid by my Smart TV too. (Honestly, it is a bad idea, really)
- lioeters 4y agoBanksy on Advertising > People are taking the piss out of you everyday. They butt into your life, take a cheap shot at you and then disappear. They leer at you from tall buildings and make you feel small. They make flippant comments from buses that imply you’re not sexy enough and that all the fun is happening somewhere else. They are on TV making your girlfriend feel inadequate. > They have access to the most sophisticated technology the world has ever seen and they bully you with it. They are The Advertisers and they are laughing at you. You, however, are forbidden to touch them. Trademarks, intellectual property rights and copyright law mean advertisers can say what they like wherever they like with total impunity. > Fuck that. Any advert in a public space that gives you no choice whether you see it or not is yours. It’s yours to take, re-arrange and re-use. You can do whatever you like with it. Asking for permission is like asking to keep a rock someone just threw at your head. > You owe the companies nothing. Less than nothing, you especially don’t owe them any courtesy. They owe you. They have re-arranged the world to put themselves in front of you. They never asked for your permission, don’t even start asking for theirs.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoThis is an affective rationing of electricity at night when demand is lower. So this is a worrying development and feels like managed decline and a testament to the catastrophe that is the German energy policy...
- langsoul-com 4y agoI hate this trend of taking away and then labelling it as good. Covid especially, used as excuse to give less for the same or more.
- yitchelle 4y agoIt always intrigue me that eInk has not made bigger inroads into the digital signage market, especially for static images. Colour signage sell more products than Black and White? Probably.
- amelius 4y agoColor e-ink still looks like it was bleached by the Sun. Not something you would want to advertise with.
- paganel 4y agoInteresting to see most of Western Europe go where we, Romania, were back in the 1980s under Ceausescu. Just today I was thinking about how one of my fondest memories as a kid (because it involves me, my parents and our home from back then) is of my dad teaching 5 or 6-year old me how many stairs there were in our block of apartments between two consecutive flors, so that I could use them even after the sun was down, cause said staircase wasn't lit. And then how proud I felt when I was managing to go up and down on those stairs (we were living on the last floor, the 4th) at night, only by "feeling" and counting the stairs in my head (at some point the counting became an "instinct", I was not even actively doing the counting anymore). This was all happening in the second part of the '80s. With all that said, I'm honestly not that sure that today's Western Europeans are mentally prepared to go through what we, Romanians, went through back then.
- staircasethrow 4y agoKind of an odd question, but out of curiosity, did the first set of stairs, the one on the ground floor going up, have an "even" or "odd" number of steps? Did the following sets of stairs on higher levels have the same number as the ground floor set or a different amount? Assume "odd" means that when starting on the ground floor, if you were to go up two stairs at a time, you would have to akwardly go up one stair on the final stair, whereas an even number of stairs would allow you to take 2 stair increments at a time without problem.
- paganel 4y agoThat’s a good question, because now that you asked it I remembered that there were some buildings that did indeed have that odd number of steps you mention, on the ground floor going up to the first floor, that is. I remember that I was finding that strange. Each block of apartments had 16 steps between two floors. The building we were living in had those 16 steps “split” in two, that is you were climbing 8 steps from a given floor, there was a small “platform” of 3-4 meters, and then you’d climb another 8 steps until the next floor itself, after a change of direction “architected” through that platform I mentioned. And then there were the bulldings where you’d climb 16 steps straight. I liked the 8+8 version better, imo it gave the architect the chance to add more and larger windows to the staircase, and hence more light, the 16 steps straight staircases seemed to have smaller windows, hence less light. Back to the odd number of steps on the ground floor, I think there were 15 or 17, can’t remember exactly how many. Interesting discussion, I have to admit, I sometime compare the staircases from today’s buildings to those I knew as a kid, and it seems that today they don’t care about light coming in or “ergonomy” or anything like that (there’s also the very interesting discussion of the “perfect” height for a given step).
- tauchunfall 4y ago>It said that a single LED sign consumes as much energy as 10 single households. I guess it's good to reduce energy consumption where we can. And political decisions only work in small focused steps. I wonder what happens when they find out how much energy probably is wasted for advertisements on television and the internet.
- zahma 4y agoI mean I guess this has energy-saving potential, but isn’t it just nice to have some darkness for the environment’s sake? It’s pretty awful living in such brightly lit places that have psychological effects on humans and animals alike. For example in humans light pollution alters our melatonin hormonal levels, so sleep is impacted. It can also thwart animal migration. https://education.nationalgeographic.org/resource/light-pollution https://education.nationalgeographic.org/resource/light-poll...
- Tenoke 4y agoI'd be glad to get less light pollution in Berlin (where I live) but I don't see that many signs anyway, so any benefits would be tiny. I also kind of like them at night (given that they are not ubiquitous), it makes a city feel much livelier than dark streets.
- askinforafriend 4y ago
- gareth_untether 4y agoA while ago I had an idea for a device that has a light sensor on it. The device has in/out for the data cable. It basically overlays a dark image over the feed. In dark conditions the device darkens the LED output and vice-a-versa for light conditions. Too many signs are too bright to comfortably look at night.
- cr3ative 4y agoI realise your comment isn't directly related, but the article directly states "showing a black image" is not an acceptable solution (it wouldn't save any power). I'd like to see your idea done for backlight/brightness control though!
- grnmamba 4y agoThe South Africanization of Europe is going along nicely.
- kikokikokiko 4y agoThe ads angle, in my opinion, is the least important piece of this news. What shocks me really is how Germany, one of the (if not THE) most advanced societies on Earth, came to a point where it can not produce enough energy to sustain it's needs. Western civilization has a masochistic saviour complex, and will freeze to death in winter in the name of "saving the world". I, living in a 3rd world country, can only look and fear whats coming in the future. If the germanies of the world decide to voluntarily fall, who will become the superpowers in the next decades/centuries? It's a bizarre stupidity contest.
- dontlaugh 4y agoGermany (and not only) is only wealthy by extracting vast amounts of wealth from other countries. This is done through unequal exchange, like poorly paid immigrants in Germany, ownership of factories in other countries with low wages, extracting resources at tiny prices from other countries, giving out loans at usury rates to countries who have been made to have no other choice, etc. Germany is failing to generate enough energy because the system of exploitation it is based on is beginning to fail under its own internal contradictions.
- kikokikokiko 4y agoWhat a load of BS. Of the top of my mind: -Germany pratically "invented" 100% of the chemistry we use today. Pharmaceuticals, industrial chemistry, you name it. -The fertilizer revolution that made it possible for today's 8 billion humans to exist. - Rocket science, and jet propulsion technology, that made the world the small thing it is today. - The internal combustion engine, that made it possible to cheaply deliver the food the fertilizers made cheap... Germany is rich because it's people are industrious and smart. What the hell, why does entitled 1st world millenials have become soviet lunatics?
- dontlaugh 4y agoGerman workers did all that, while they themselves are exploited by German capitalists. The same capitalists then extended their exploitation to other countries, where they could get away with even worse. I recommend you read Lenin's Imperialism. I'm from a poor country, still exploited by Germany, Austria, France, Britain, Italy, Hungary, the US, etc. My country used to have collective control over resources and industry, but that was destroyed in 89 and we were forced to privatise, deregulate and be in debt again.
- samatman 4y agoI consider the annoyance of lighted digital signage a good enough reason to turn them off, and the offense of billboards a sufficient reason to ban them as San Paolo has. I say that for context. The piecemeal approach to energy regulation is arbitrary and unfair. It introduces political friction with no evidence that it reduces emissions. Why might it not reduce emissions? Because energy which is produced is consumed. Banning a source of consumption causes marginal affordability. If the goal is to limit atmospheric carbon, which is laudable: tax carbon. Be sure to apply the proceeds generously to decarbonizing industry, because this will be expensive. If the goal is to allocate electricity which is scarce due to crisis: tax electricity use progressively. Make businesses which aren't manufacturing submit paperwork for an exemption. They'll turn the lights out at night on their own. Be sure to apply the proceeds to energy security, because no one is going to like what happens if you don't.
- m-p-3 4y agoI hope that this will lead to more eInk-based deployment for digital signage, and ultimately bring down the cost due to the economy of scale.
- swah 4y agoHere in Brazil, as everywhere, there are some ultra bright signs now - even gas prices - that are as annoying to me as hearing loud music in a otherwise calm place. Yet no one gives a f* about this. I wonder if most people don't even notice this?
- Eddy_Viscosity2 4y agoHaving lit signs turn off at certain time seems like a good idea to me. Reduce power and light pollution at the same time. What are the cons?
- iancmceachern 4y agoI want to do 2 things here where i live in San Francisco, anyone have advice for me on where to start? 1 - I want to start or join a coalition of folks looking to get this implemented in California 2 - I want to contact the city/owner of the specific digital signs right outside my window of my apartment that are on 24/7, loud, and have their glass broken monthly and then wait for the glass to be replaced for weeks. It's a public hazard.
- mitch3x3 4y agoThe term you are looking for is “sign code”, and you can find info regarding the SF laws around this here: https://sfplanning.org/general-advertising-sign-program https://sfplanning.org/general-advertising-sign-program I don’t know if you’ll have any impact at all though regarding your situation. You’re in a big city where this kind of stuff is part of life. Your best option is probably to move.